yeah i agree with him being a good guy. he is happy to talk to anyone and even hang out with anyone after concerts. also, i dont get the damien rice comparison. i saw that people and itunes etc suggested him to me when i watched/listened to josh ritter, so i was excited to hear someone like him. i dont think he is anything like josh ritter. where is the similarity? you cant just lump non mainstream acoustic together.
you are a silly goose if you ever pass up a chance to see Josh live, you will never see a more entertaining, interactive show! I saw him on 5-13 in Atlanta and had the chance to meet him and chat with him for about 10 mins. they come no better than Josh (and Josh hugs are the best hugs on earth)....Dawn Landes, his wife, was with him and she is also a fantastic artist in her own right.
I always thought it's called 'Temptation of Adam' because of the story of Adam and Eve. He has a chance to destroy everything except for himself and the woman he loves, so he can be alone with her, like Adam and Eve. I'm not religious, I just thought that was what he was referencing.
this song is so so so so good, and he is so so so so talented. I was so happy to get to see him this summer. on my ipod where it shows how much you listen to a songs all of his are over the hundred mark, like every song, I've listened too.. hundreds of times
I think Ritter's better than Dylan. Influence aside, Ritter's lyrics are better, his voice is better, and he actually seems like he enjoys being alive and isn't conceited and grouchy.
ritter are do good but dylan are the man of s XX , you cannot say that, i think cannot compare that. This song and others are so fines but the time future will say.
Its in Standard tuning but hes tuned the whole guitar down so that the E Strings are now C#. Then the chords are C, G, B7, E minor, G, D, D/B and then C. Well thats how I do it anyway.
I didn't like josh ritter at first but then his music started to grow on me and now i find myself just sittin here listening at home outside of school even though i dont have to lol
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
cheap metaphors, so-so voice, even more over-the-top sweet than damien rice, and much more pretentious. i like guitar playing songwriters, but this guy suxxx.
I have never posted a response, but this is so far from the truth, I felt compelled. This is an example of a beautiful songwriter and his voice fits the song perfectly.
It's fine to not like someone, but to judge his song as pretentious while making a pretentious and worthless post of our own? Was that your attempt at being clever? Good job mate!
You're lame my friend. How about posting some of your writings before you start judging others.... or just jump off a cliff.
@MichaelODonoghue I dont know who i would be able to compare him to maybe neil young on his style and bob dylan on his writing ability but he is just as unique as both of those great musicians :) dont try and compare it just enjoy it :)
that is awesome. I heard he is great live I have a friend who has seen him preform twice live. He great and his talks between sets are great as well. Hope you have an awesome time
damn good...im a huge dylan fan...this music reminds of the feeling i had when dylan became a new musical obsession to me,about 15 years ago,when i discovered my fathers vinyl collection...this is very good stuff.
I've gotten into Josh after hearing the song Kathleen from Hello Starling. Since then I've followed all of his releases and THCOJR is for me the most thrilling and excitng of all of them. I adore it. This particular song is definatly one of my favorites of his.When i first heard it I was overwhelmed with emotion and still am. I allways get goosebumps when i listen to it. The melody, the voice, the lyrics are just perfect. Oh, yeah, and I got really jealous of his talent too... lol
Again, pseudo-anti-war propaganda, but propaganda seems too strong a word. It's the type of lyrical genius that makes your stomach want to fall out and your heart weep. He's amazing.
I have shared Josh's music with so many friends, and the reaction is consistent: "How have I not heard this amazing talent before!?" The world would be a better place if more people listened to Josh's music. Don't you agree? Cheers, Josh & Doug...and thanks for all that both of you do. From Doug the Santa Barbarian.
He remembers the key to great lyrics, that is honesty. Too many songwriters these days try to write beautiful lyrics but gloss of all the flaws and completely miss the point of personal songwriting
my friend had girl in the war on his myspace page and i had to look this guy up. there is something about him that just makes me smile. i love everything about this guy!
Fantastic.... never heard the name before and, bizarrely - and demonstrating the useful power of the internet - I came across it whilst researching performances of the Bach chaconne [listening to Hilary Hahn on violin] as I continue trying to unravel it's mysteries and transcribe it for 10-string guitar. Wonderfully imaginative lyrics and a haunting delivery.
I'm just hearing his stuff for the first time and it's great. Anyone think he's a little dylanesque? Similar voice I think. I'm also wondering what goes through peoples heads when they call his music out. I read a comment below calling it gay. Does this poor asshole sit around all day thinking I can't wait to bad mouth youtube videos to make myself feel better? Anyone else laugh at their posts?
I worked with him on a gig when he played here on Nantucket. Wicked cool guy. After the gig he came up to me and gave me a hug and said he looked forward to working with me again.
There aren't enough words in the dictionary to describe him. He is a great poet, a beautiful soul and a kind human being. After seeing him, I recognized him on the street in LA, and he came and joined my friend and I for a drink before his flight. He's just that kind of guy...and I love him for everything :)
Saw him for the first time last week in Asheville, NC. I've never seen a singer and band put as much emotion into an performance. Even got to spend some time with him after the show briefly. Absolutely incredible singer, writer, and person...his potential is limitless.
This is one of the best unrequited love songs I have ever heard. It totally captures that feeling of not being good enough or not the right one or what have you. Such an amazing song and some of the finest song writing I have ever heard. This is just as beautiful on a sheet of paper.
we got the same last name D:
dustin4153 3 months ago
There needs to be a "Love" button for this song.
adiamond2347 8 months ago
Every time I hear this song, I become more and more scared of the future...
Muzikman724 10 months ago
4 people slipped and hit "the button"
shroomage34 10 months ago
yeah i agree with him being a good guy. he is happy to talk to anyone and even hang out with anyone after concerts. also, i dont get the damien rice comparison. i saw that people and itunes etc suggested him to me when i watched/listened to josh ritter, so i was excited to hear someone like him. i dont think he is anything like josh ritter. where is the similarity? you cant just lump non mainstream acoustic together.
stouthunterlogan4321 1 year ago
Check my vid I posted today
thisisithahaha 1 year ago
Josh Ritter makes everything better <3
PsylightFay 1 year ago
I wish I had this version of the song in my itunes. It's so much better than the album version.
admerr 1 year ago
HOLY SHIT! this a brilliant fucking song. this is a great song. i could reference bob dylan's waliking==========shit this is just a brilliant song.
gdkeen 1 year ago 3
What a song! Just had a chill, although it's about 30 degrees Celsius in here.
ThatContainerGuy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you are a silly goose if you ever pass up a chance to see Josh live, you will never see a more entertaining, interactive show! I saw him on 5-13 in Atlanta and had the chance to meet him and chat with him for about 10 mins. they come no better than Josh (and Josh hugs are the best hugs on earth)....Dawn Landes, his wife, was with him and she is also a fantastic artist in her own right.
sugerkat 1 year ago
great job ,although musicwise ,it does remind me of a certain lincoln duncan
wassily64 1 year ago
I always thought it's called 'Temptation of Adam' because of the story of Adam and Eve. He has a chance to destroy everything except for himself and the woman he loves, so he can be alone with her, like Adam and Eve. I'm not religious, I just thought that was what he was referencing.
gerryiam 1 year ago 3
Marie, as in Marie Curie? Seems like it to me.
Beautiful beautiful song.
ethanb0nd 2 years ago
@ethanb0nd I think that he's simply referencing her name for the tone. Not actually stating it as her.
MrAdriano 1 year ago
i think he used adam in the title of the song because it sounds like atom like atomb bomb
wwwlllaasas 2 years ago 2
One of very few great artists today. Love this Guy. Also, i love ryan adams, avett brothers, the national!
Spinj33x 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
Spinj33x 2 years ago
this song is so so so so good, and he is so so so so talented. I was so happy to get to see him this summer. on my ipod where it shows how much you listen to a songs all of his are over the hundred mark, like every song, I've listened too.. hundreds of times
michelleissocool 2 years ago 4
its great
slickbnx 2 years ago
I'm crying, but I don't know if I'm happy or sad.
Genius.
Bertsnapcrackle 2 years ago 4
this is an absolutely beautiful song, probably the single best ballad I have ever heard
bullett2434 2 years ago 4
*impressed nod of approval*
my discovery of Josh Ritter occured today...
naymelessmoonlight 2 years ago 5
In that case, listen to Wings. After hearing the incredible lyrics to that song I was hooked. Happy listening!
DanRYoung 2 years ago
Pretty darn good I must say.
wrongwayup 2 years ago
Can't stop listening to this!! One of his best songs!! And i agree, better than Dylan :) Just amazing!
musicqueen05 2 years ago
I think Ritter's better than Dylan. Influence aside, Ritter's lyrics are better, his voice is better, and he actually seems like he enjoys being alive and isn't conceited and grouchy.
P.S. 1:03 and 3:27 = best
shuckslbj 2 years ago 2
ritter are do good but dylan are the man of s XX , you cannot say that, i think cannot compare that. This song and others are so fines but the time future will say.
Pamicox 2 years ago
Comment removed
ResurrectMetal 1 year ago
Comment removed
Paycheckpics 2 years ago
absolut Dylan style... this guy is a fucking genius!!
Pamicox 2 years ago 2
is he in standard tuning? i dont think so. im trying to figure this song out.
meatwadXcore 2 years ago
Its in Standard tuning but hes tuned the whole guitar down so that the E Strings are now C#. Then the chords are C, G, B7, E minor, G, D, D/B and then C. Well thats how I do it anyway.
klausbarbie123 2 years ago
I didn't like josh ritter at first but then his music started to grow on me and now i find myself just sittin here listening at home outside of school even though i dont have to lol
revan100290 2 years ago 4
you had to listen to him at school?
EvolFighter 2 years ago
Yeah his music are his poems, and our english teacher is having us do peom analysis on either his songs "Girl in the war" or "Thin blue flame"
revan100290 2 years ago
what do you live in his hometown or something?
manofrandomnumbers 2 years ago
You lucky duck.
nellowys 2 years ago
You must have a bad ass teacher.
ethanb0nd 2 years ago 3
Whats this song about?
bootyourface 2 years ago
Two soldiers who work in a nuclear missile silo falling in love with one another.
Hubris73 2 years ago
WWIII. learning to love the bomb
and if I can't have her, then no one can
EvolFighter 2 years ago 2
In a nut shell :P
123ElijahGoesPee 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
cheap metaphors, so-so voice, even more over-the-top sweet than damien rice, and much more pretentious. i like guitar playing songwriters, but this guy suxxx.
Massacrus 2 years ago
have you heard any of his other songs? this is one of his poorer songs granted, but its not that bad
fireflybuzzbuzz 2 years ago
You really think so? This is one of my favorites of his...
ThePOWERtoRULE 2 years ago 3
Hey do you mean cheap as in easily affordable by anyone unlike the expensive ones only talentless critics can afford?
Yamahman 2 years ago 4
You're my hero Yamahman.
mearegenius 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
rhanley01 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I have never posted a response, but this is so far from the truth, I felt compelled. This is an example of a beautiful songwriter and his voice fits the song perfectly.
It's fine to not like someone, but to judge his song as pretentious while making a pretentious and worthless post of our own? Was that your attempt at being clever? Good job mate!
You're lame my friend. How about posting some of your writings before you start judging others.... or just jump off a cliff.
rhanley01 2 years ago 2
More pretentious that Damien Rice? I doubt it. I have met this man and he is genuinely a gent.
Listen to thin blue flame and you will realise how wrong you are.
MichaelODonoghue 2 years ago 15
@MichaelODonoghue I dont know who i would be able to compare him to maybe neil young on his style and bob dylan on his writing ability but he is just as unique as both of those great musicians :) dont try and compare it just enjoy it :)
Vincentmc01 8 months ago
i am in love with this man...
he is genius
funny
brilliant
i know genius and brilliant are like the same...but he is my all time favorite artist...i can listen to him non stop
i wlll die happy if i can see him preform live
Justmyfish24 3 years ago
Genius and brilliant aren't the same!!!
Also, I am seeing him on July 4th this year!!! can't wait!!!!!
minidazzler 2 years ago
Hahaha I guess you are right.
that is awesome. I heard he is great live I have a friend who has seen him preform twice live. He great and his talks between sets are great as well. Hope you have an awesome time
Justmyfish24 2 years ago
JOSH RITTER HAS MY VOTE!!!!
fergiemcgee24 3 years ago
"You said fusion was the broken heart that's lonely's only thought" is lyrical genious. lonely has a thought?
mjbarry03 3 years ago 3
damn good...im a huge dylan fan...this music reminds of the feeling i had when dylan became a new musical obsession to me,about 15 years ago,when i discovered my fathers vinyl collection...this is very good stuff.
jaypriceman 3 years ago
i paid 50 bucks just to see him open. only played i think 5 songs.
worth it
cmcomins 3 years ago
I've gotten into Josh after hearing the song Kathleen from Hello Starling. Since then I've followed all of his releases and THCOJR is for me the most thrilling and excitng of all of them. I adore it. This particular song is definatly one of my favorites of his.When i first heard it I was overwhelmed with emotion and still am. I allways get goosebumps when i listen to it. The melody, the voice, the lyrics are just perfect. Oh, yeah, and I got really jealous of his talent too... lol
stereosanctity1 3 years ago
Again, pseudo-anti-war propaganda, but propaganda seems too strong a word. It's the type of lyrical genius that makes your stomach want to fall out and your heart weep. He's amazing.
amordevida1027 3 years ago 3
i'm in love wwiiith this man's music
jroytoy 3 years ago
hmm....did yopu wo the "wwiii" on purpose?
TheMeager123 3 years ago
Comment removed
jroytoy 3 years ago
ive listened to this song 115 times (: i love it so much
annah126 3 years ago
chills every time I hear this song... it is so well written and I can listen to it over and over.
Most people can only dream of having this calibre of songwriting ability.
darreneedens 3 years ago 26
josh. doug. i love you both.
jenevie2000 3 years ago
I have shared Josh's music with so many friends, and the reaction is consistent: "How have I not heard this amazing talent before!?" The world would be a better place if more people listened to Josh's music. Don't you agree? Cheers, Josh & Doug...and thanks for all that both of you do. From Doug the Santa Barbarian.
kayakrazy2 3 years ago
He remembers the key to great lyrics, that is honesty. Too many songwriters these days try to write beautiful lyrics but gloss of all the flaws and completely miss the point of personal songwriting
tolchock1984 3 years ago 3
Ritter is so amazing with lyrics. So pure. So Honest. So creative.
Changeis9 3 years ago
my friend had girl in the war on his myspace page and i had to look this guy up. there is something about him that just makes me smile. i love everything about this guy!
:)
baileyboo2011 3 years ago
ahh he's an angell
mrschrisdaughtry 3 years ago
Fantastic.... never heard the name before and, bizarrely - and demonstrating the useful power of the internet - I came across it whilst researching performances of the Bach chaconne [listening to Hilary Hahn on violin] as I continue trying to unravel it's mysteries and transcribe it for 10-string guitar. Wonderfully imaginative lyrics and a haunting delivery.
paulcroft1944 3 years ago
OMG!!!!!!!!!!
SisterMayhem 3 years ago
the lyrics in this song are amazing and as always beautifully song! wat an artist, poet watever u wanna call him! 5/5 easy!
bowzyjnr 3 years ago 3
Petite David Anyone?
shaunathon6 3 years ago
hell yeah
lonewolf499 3 years ago
He did it better.
antichris777 3 years ago
he did and has a better voice
lonewolf499 3 years ago
Gawd bless im.
antichris777 3 years ago
Petit David yah! ELC for life!
xXoMaryoXx 3 years ago
great lyrics, nice singing, finger-picking guitar...
nebulagirl007 3 years ago 2
josh ritter is an amazing musician and poet, one of the best of our time.
areksia 3 years ago 4
been compared to dylan and springsteen,
a waste of words in my opinion,
well, compared to the way he uses them.
globeofamerica 3 years ago
I'm just hearing his stuff for the first time and it's great. Anyone think he's a little dylanesque? Similar voice I think. I'm also wondering what goes through peoples heads when they call his music out. I read a comment below calling it gay. Does this poor asshole sit around all day thinking I can't wait to bad mouth youtube videos to make myself feel better? Anyone else laugh at their posts?
und215 3 years ago 2
I worked with him on a gig when he played here on Nantucket. Wicked cool guy. After the gig he came up to me and gave me a hug and said he looked forward to working with me again.
smthill 3 years ago
There aren't enough words in the dictionary to describe him. He is a great poet, a beautiful soul and a kind human being. After seeing him, I recognized him on the street in LA, and he came and joined my friend and I for a drink before his flight. He's just that kind of guy...and I love him for everything :)
karmakelly 3 years ago
Saw him for the first time last week in Asheville, NC. I've never seen a singer and band put as much emotion into an performance. Even got to spend some time with him after the show briefly. Absolutely incredible singer, writer, and person...his potential is limitless.
jdubsnc3 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sucked. really gay
bucschm 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fuckwit
yellowmoonmusic 3 years ago
Definitely my favourite of his.
establecido 3 years ago
This song gives me chills! Josh Ritter is amazing :)
jmwinter01 3 years ago
He never ceases to amaze me.
angelopeb 3 years ago
This is one of the best unrequited love songs I have ever heard. It totally captures that feeling of not being good enough or not the right one or what have you. Such an amazing song and some of the finest song writing I have ever heard. This is just as beautiful on a sheet of paper.
pavement27 3 years ago 2
Josh is gonna be a legend... From Riaan is South Africa.
riaandirect 3 years ago
so amazing
flipside10189 3 years ago
Anyone need a ticket to see him in Brooklyn on the 28th? I need to sell my ticket :(
indiequeen182 3 years ago
I love this man.
PaleIryss 3 years ago 2
Hehe. Me too
GoldenAgeOfRadio 3 years ago 2
these lyrics...so great. rock on, josh!
colormekoye 3 years ago
Seeing him tomorrow night!
This songs awesome :), I love it.
WindsweptAngel 3 years ago
would say, I like those sad songs by hin...not the happy ONES...cheers
macstasy 3 years ago
I love those songs from josh...I don`t like those new happy once...but I´m glad he is :-)
macstasy 3 years ago 2
^_^
I love this song. Saw him preform it live in 2007 at a EMI fringe.
geeksquad4ever 3 years ago
I just LOVE this version. Is this the same one that was up on Amazon? I think so, but I haven't seen in for a while...
spaceelevators 3 years ago
so beautiful.
melanie0523 3 years ago
Josh!!! You are the greatest, but you seriously need to come back to Chicago.
mrfacques 3 years ago