Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (353)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • New Christina Aguilera!!!

  • I watched every performance of season 11 and even though Janet's audition was awesome, this is by far my favorite of the entire season.

  • Comment removed

  • Performance of the season, amazing

  • She doesnt shout she just has an amzing, powerful voice and the idiots who say she shouts (yes i called gary barlow an idiot get over it) any way point is the people who say she shouts just cant handle the fact that she has a beautiful powerful voice (and is only 17) so what do they do...... they say she shouts. they are wrong.

  • he chances were practically ruined thanks to HMV.. ;/

  • Ah i love Gazzzz

  • great song havent heard it for years!

  • GOD, I'm sick of people saying she screams.. I totally agree with @lildrizzy . everyone says that because of Gary, he was more competitive than Marcus. He always had to say something about the other acts but his acts? no his were completely 'flawless'.. When I hear Amelia sing I always get shivers.. she has a very powerful voice. People are easily influenced by someone just because he's a 'judge' on a show-they're not always right you know..

  • Amelia lily is a amazing 16/17 yr old teen dat has an amazing voice. dat performance was spot on she sang it beautiful she looked beautiful nd she showed evry1 hw much she wantes 2 win x factor 2011 nd how much she wants da public votes nd ppl she needs 2 have the public votes well done amelia

  • The only reason haters are saying she "Shouts" is because of Gary Barlows comment, I didn't hear anyone else say that she "shouted her way through the competition" before he said that? Just because he's a judge people assume that he's right.

  • Louis does alot of TINKING eh?

  • @VibrGames She didn't "skip" 6 weeks and why do people judge her for that, they offered she took!! It was dumb-ass kelly's fault! I liked sophie but it was obvious that no-one was really gonna vote for her! Some people didn't deserve to be there and to practically kick off a contestant like Amelia is just absolute ridiculous! She was robbed of her place in week1 of the comp and i hope she just continues with her music and shows kelly and everyone else that doubted her how successful she can be!

  • shes a nob

  • how did she not win i will never no she has a better chance of cracking america than any of other x factor artists

  • ameila shuda won (">)

  • how come Misha B was the only one to sing a fairwell song???????

  • @margoh01 I wondered too :/ I didnt wonder Misha had one, I just thought the 3rd placed would have one too -.- I mean, we had more than enough sing-off performances by Misha and we hadnt so many performances of beautiful and talented Amelia Lily <33

  • If she had sung this in the final.. She might have won! Shame... Anyway, thought i'd revisit and have a little listen, still sounds as good as it did a few weeks back :) Might be worth putting on her album when it's released... obviously the rest of the songs should be original, but it's such a good version i'd like it

  • This was an excellent vocal and performance! :D

  • AMELIA GOT FIRST IN ALL PUBLIC VOTES ON THIS PERFORMANCE :D YAY

  • I can't believe she's gone out. Now she's not in I couldnt care less who wins

  • flawless

    

  • amelia deserve win , go amelia lily (:

  • u'r great from MALTA

  • she's sooooooooooooo goooooood............keep it up girl

  • Kelly doesnt want her to win. If she does Kelly will look like a fool for sending her home the first week

  • i think louis wants to give her one lol

  • damn this girl can hit them notes !!!

  • she is going to win, put all your money on her, and have a very merry xmas... 4/1 . £100 gives £500 return. everyone vote for her , and back her on betfair, better price, or ladbrokes on the high street. Dont say never told you all... jk

  • Thank you sooo much for everyone that voted! All your votes clearly counted :D:D! Damn kelly,she wouldn't even have an act left if frankie wasn't chucked out! Amelia Lily is in the final! THERE IS ONLY ONE WEEK LEFT SO LETS VOTE AS MUCH AS WE CAN THIS SATURDAY AND SUNDAY CROWN HER THE WINNER! Lets make this the greatest comeback on X-Factor!! This girl is just incredible and delivers every week! She is the star of the show! PLEASE KEEP UP THE SUPPORT AND VOTE ALL YOU CAN THIS SAT AND SUN!:) ty

  • yeaaah buddy she in final! plz vote for her she is amazing

  • If she wins or not she will be very successful....

  • she's amazing, really hope she wins! (or little mix) Marcus is too x factor predictable, hope he doesn't win

  • Too much make up anyone? How does she look without the pounds of make up, I wonder.

  • i loved her audition but now... not so much lol part of me wants her to do well for boro but i want marcus to win lol sorry amelia

  • fantastic. brilliant song too!

  • Amelia to win!

  • @Nailima1 get a grip! Its obviously fair because the public didnt get a chance to vote on her performances! And it cleary is fair because the public VOTED FOR HER TO GO THROUGHT TO THE SEMI-FINAL! I'd like to see how you would respond if you were allowed to re-enter the x factor...oh wait you would just reject it because its 'not fair' ! WOW she is incredible! World wide star i tell you! And louis is in love with her because he is not a tool like you!

  • @HashtagBeMusic Yeah but it's like someone skipping weeks of hard work then coming straight back into the competition. She was practically invincible for like 6 weeks.

  • @VibrGames she didn't skip 6 weeks.. it was 4 weeks and she continuously had gigs while she was out. She didn't have the chance because of Kelly..

  • Tulisa makes the best observation that Amelia is so great because she gets lost in the music, you can see Amelia wants to entertain aswell as sing the song, she has a confidence on the stage that is seductive.

    The market is pricing in Little Mix to win but I hope Amelia can steal it!

  • OMG! why is Louise in love with her?

    she's BAD

  • @Nailima1

    because as much as people laugh at louis, he is a terrific businessman and he knows that of all the contestants, amelia could make the most dollar.

  • @Nailima1 Shee ist soo mcuh betr tan yoo

  • @Nailima1 go spout your shit on a coccoza video

  • @Nailima1 you are the reason why uk music industry is degrading so fast. it used to be best in the world with beatles and queen and ledzep etc. now uk has cher lloyd, 1D seriously!!!

  • @Nailima1 *note the distinct lack of thumbs ups*

  • @Nailima1 Grow up.

  • Comment removed

  • Performance of the series! :D

  • Why the hell are we still bothering with this nonsense? I thought that all pop music production had been outsourced to South Korea…

  • bravo amelia job well done

  • shes so beautiful and talented

  • i dont like the performance only because the original by t'pau is entrenched in my mind since i was a kid. I dont think anyone can do a good rendition of it.

  • Watching this a second time and it's so much better than I thought. I love this girl, I'd buy her album, I think she's too talented for this competition though..

  • she's good but I do think she's been rigged to win it, my moneys on an emiliia and frankie cococossa duet of fairytale in new york for crimbo no 1

  • @Russwood100 LOL! XD

  • Jut watched this for the second time - Wow, what a come back, that was fantastic and would make the top ten if she recorded and released it.

  • Wow, what a come back, that was fantastic and would make the top ten if she recorded and released it.

  • Gotta say - that was one hellava knockout winning performance and has changed my mind completely about Amelia. I'm sorry Janet didn't make it through but she doesn't need X Factor, she'll be massive anyway. I think Amelia can win this now.

  • i want 80's music back,fed up of lots of pooped hip hops!!!

  • would love to hear her sing use somebody but mix it up, a little bit like pixie lotts' version :) amazing

  • HATERS ARE ON A ROLL, THIS WEEK. They are threatened and they know it. Do the right thing UK, you decide.

  • amelia doesn't deserve to win or even be in this competition. Even though she does have a great voice and can sing, she just has got a short route and hasn't even performed half of the liveshows. It's just not fair to all the other contestants who have werked every single week very hard en some of than had to leave and here amelia is, just flying through the liveshows to the semi-finals, thanks to frankie cocozza and the producers.

  • Comment removed

  • @cocowrap She deserves to be there! Yes, she hasnt done as many performances as the others but she has a disadvantage because of that! She is fighting hard and i am a fan. The result last week was CORRECT!

  • @Zombi3M4n I actually hadn't think of it that it was a disadvantage for her. That's actually thrue en she deserves credit for that en working hard. Still prefer an act to win who has performed every week.

  • @cocowrap Despite wot i said, i want Little Mix to win! By far the most consistent act this year!

  • @cocowrap The truth is, people don't need to go on talent shows to get noticed. You have artists in the charts who can't keep a note and then you have people like Amelia etc. who would fight to get a record contract, but sadly they can't. Hopefully she does get something with or without the X Factor because it would be a waste of great talent :/

  • @XxLittleMonster95xX i agree. uk music industry was once strongest with acts like beatles, ledzep etc. now it is worse than S**t american industry. enuf said

  • i think she nails the high notes :/

  • /watch?v=SduhTBmCbrc

    She did this gig just before she was voted back in, and this is why I believe in her. She sounded as good as Lady Gaga singing it, and she has confidence and stage presence, without coming across as arrogant. I don't think X Factor has brought out the best in her yet. She needs the right song on Saturday to shine, but I have a feeling she is next to be thrown under the bus with shit songs to avoid the controversy of an eliminated act winning.

  • Misha B to go this week Amelia to win Marcus second place

  • She aint a patch on Carol Decker. This chick will be around 5 mins and quickly forgotten.

  • vagina in your hands? :P

  • she's the one i'm voting for :) she's a star end of.

  • I think, I think... agh

  • maybe i missing something this is not that good u guys needs to view american X factor or bgt. Misha is only one i c that real X factor

  • Louis 'TINKS' alot.!

  • no no....misha..

  • I thought she did a great performance i really enjoyed it, the sort of act you woudl pay to see. some of the others bored the pants off me to be honest.

    id be more that happy if she one i think she could go long way

    the winner!!!!!!

  • @redstaraz how will it be a disgrace if she wins? it will just prove to kelly that she got rid of the best contestant in the competition. amelia or little mix to win

  • @nikkymonoxide i would love to hear her sing that song! I think that would be perfect for her and would probably buy it aswell!

    Woohoo thanks for voting amelia lily into the semi-finals!! She soo deserves it and she will not disappoint! Lets keep it up guys and keeping voting and voting for her this weekend! We need to up our votes to get her into the final to crown her the winner! :D Thanks

  • it will be a disgrace if she wins. How can someone win who gets kicked off the competition? Also I believe no one has yet won after being in the bottom 2.

  • @redstaraz If she wins then it'll be because the public decided, so nobody can complain. It will look very bad for Kelly though, but who cares? She isn't exactly loved as it is

  • Amelia sings beautifully in the mid to the slightly higher range. However I always think she struggles with the highest notes and sound a bit shouty.  She should try and use falsetto style singing for these high notes to avoid the shouty sound. If she can do that...a deserved winner.

  • @marmeduke007 that just doesnt make sense at all. Your listening to the judges and assuming they are correct, they are not. And how in the hell is a falsetto going to help her with songs like this?

  • @marmeduke007 I would agree with you if we were talking about one of her other performances, but I thought her high notes in this song sounded natural, clear and effortless. Ever since Gary said she 'shouted her way through that performance' the previous week, everyone seems to be jumping on that bandwagon and criticising her every time she hits a big note, which is unfair, cos it sounds good and unforced as long as it isn't too high.

  • Comment removed

  • id love her to sing hurt by Christina :3

  • @nikkymonoxide Hell yeah! She'll nail it and make me cry :3

  • @nikkymonoxide Why, do u think she couldn't ?

  • @nikkymonoxide i think christina is just a little too obvious for amelia. there are a few too many comparisons as it is...but if she does sing a christina song then i'd prefer something a little less blatant than "hurt", something like "i turn to you" or something a little less well known, like "you lost me".

  • A rock star could be so elegant! My beautiful princess inside out!!!

    

  • her best performance on the live shows so far and one of the best of the series.

  • she seems older than 16

  • By The Power Of Grey Scull, Amelia Lily to win.

  • It just makes me wonder why no contestant had ever thought to do a T'Pau song previously on one of these shows. Their songs were always multi-layered, complex lyrics & melodies with long high notes to show off a singer's range. If you are new to T'Pau & like this song: listen to their 1991 single "Whenever You Need Me"- also found here on Youtube.

  • I never understood why stupid Kelly sent her home in Week One. I hope she wins.

    Fabulous voice.

  • amelia is stunning i would suck a fart out of her arse!

  • I would hazard a guess at 'In agreement in musical pitch or intonation, In concord or agreement, as in He was in tune with the times.' or something along those lines to be honest i'm not sure if amelia was alive in the 80's

  • OMG posted 6 days ago X Factor Live Results Show Week 7: Amelia Lily sings for survival "Please whoever made the impossible happen!!!!! for Amelia to come back - to arrange for her to be announced first safe on the next results show!!!!"

  • BEST ONE ON X FACTOR  WITHOUT DOUBT VOTE THIS GIRL No 1

  • It's a shame she's out of tune on this one nothing like the original

  • @Russellwood100 haha do u even know what is in tune meant?

  • @Russellwood100 You need a hearing aid matey cos there was nothing out of tune about this performance, it was practically note perfect! (sang differenly mind you but in tune).

  • @pacomacman She sings it well but i think frankie cococossa would have been pitch perfect

  • @Russellwood100 are you fucking joking, it doesn't get much more out of tune than the original, pretty much all the sustained notes are unbearably flat, I can hardly listen to it.

  • A-MA-ZING. This girl can really sing. I was quite moved by this song. I hope she wins it because none of the others can do that.

  • same AGAIN GUYS NEXT SAT SUN -VOTES- LETS GET HER TO THE FINAL -LOVE THIS GIRL - REAL TALENT

  • Does anyone think Amelia has any idea that this song was based on Frankenstein? Even though i am sure we all relate it to wanting something to much and becomming obsessed to the extreme (since that's the underlying theme of the story) I doubt she does (guilty pleasure hey lol)!!!

    I must have listened to this about 10 times now... I LOVE IT x

    What a..

    Great performance, great song, great singer... Hot and the complete modern star, the best the country has to offer this year - Simples :D

    xx

  • LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL! kelly gives me jokessssssssssssssssssss! I love her american ''y'all'' accent. @5:25 when she says '' first of all i have to honest i never really heard this song, but when i heard this girl sing this song and I was like oh I KNOW CHINA IN HERE NOW!'' LMFAO! THat is such a cool but funny typical american thing to say and it's hip! Well done amelia though she really is a pop star hope she goes all the way.

  • I'd kick her back door iin.

  • I luv this song snow much :-) she shuts it down even better than the t'paw version :-)

  • I don't watch this show but this girl wins for me on this performance alone. Wow.com

  • Dermott: Doesn't love clothes, loves YOU grrr lol!

  • When she started off, I thought she was really good, but then whenever she reaches the chorus she shouts it too much. I always get a headache whenever she sings a chorus, she would be so much better if she didn't shout so much :L

  • @MusicLOve995 some songs need a stamp of authority! T pau sung the original with strength, but not with a good voice, Amelia has nailed the same powerful passionate tone but with an amazing vocal!! This song was not made to be quiet. You have to be an empty soul to think it would sound good that way.

    The strength in her voice is tone perfect and ecstasy fuelled, Not just shouting. people need to recognize raw talent.

    Janet Devlin is unique, but only one dimension to her vocal. just not diggin.

  • @picklemonster1001

    Also worth mentioning, she tends to have bad micoprohone technique (She admited it on xtra factor) the mics to close to her mouth when she belts loud powerful parts out (sometimes) it's ok as you said for songs like kelly clarkson that are menat to be that way for the emotions, and i tend to agree it was right for this song, but think for example (& others) it was bad technique... Something i am sure we will see her improve on (if future songs ever calls for it)

  • @picklemonster1001 Yes but she shouts. Marcus can sing without shouting, Craig sang without shouting. She would be so much better without shouting. Well it's my opinion on her, and I wouldn't say it's raw talent. At least Marcus didn't send out a sob story.

  • @MusicLOve995 Marcus and Graig havent been near, to try thoose high notes! And i dont think they should!

     Marcus, i would love too sit carmly in good compagny, and listen to him!:) Janett, if i was in a sad mood, i would listen to her. Misha, if i was to a concert, if would love to watch her on the scene, and at a party, her music would be perfect!:) Littlemix, love to go to a concert, and just party with them!:) Amelia:) I just love her voice, Fire in a lighter, and sing a long, and dance

  • @gyseleg Fair Enough :L

  • i actually liked this :D and i love her dress too, i want it man! wonder where its from. can anyone tell me

  • Love, Love Love this. i just keep coming back to it. xkx

  • If i hear "chinarr" one more time i might lose it.

  • she`s always my favourie girl, good luck amelia xx

  • She's amazing, the only really good singer/entertainer in the Xfactor atm, she really does have a rockers voice & I could see her fronting a rock band or something..

  • I want her to win.

  • that was beautiful

  • Damn she's good.

    Kinda reminds me of Kitty minus the crazy

  • little mix or amelia lily to win !!!!!!!!!

  • INCREDIBLE!!! I hope she wins!!! The best performer on X Factor. Her performance gave me goosebumps. You go Girl!!! :-)

  • @ThatMattOne I agree. But, if they not stand up, and applaus such a preformens, when will they do it. Ithink the dutch and the Australien judges are more fair, and use less taktic. If a preformens are good enough, they do it in show 3-4! I think i would buy this song as a single!

  • did louis actually shout yo ? hahahahah

  • Very captivating and a great polished vocal.

  • She's absolutely amazing!!! It moves me every time I hear her sing...

  • Gary Barlow was out of order with his comments about Carol Decker voice. T'Pau were are amazing band. Apparently Carol Decker wanted to speak to Gary Barlow on the Xtra Factor but he bottled it. Very disappointed with Gary Barlow.

  • she is winner

  • No one will ever outdo Carol Decker's version. EVER. But happy Amelia has brought this song new found attention, it's one of my all time favourites. And Gary, your comment about the original was rubbish and uncalled for. Carol for the win!

  • @djstonedog I completely agree. Carol Decker has an amazing voice, and T'Pau had some storming songs back in the day. I was really shocked at Gary s comments.

  • yeah this as very good but what ruined it for her was her next song that really was a downer

  • Better than the original. Best of the competition!

  • But is she better than Frankie Cocozza?

  • who says x factor has no talent

  • when you listen to this everyone else is average

  • One of my favourite Xfactor performances so far actually! It's such an unfamiliar song to me it almost feels like her own. And after hearing the original, her version is cracking.

  • Did anyone else realise that Louis began each of his sentences with "I think"? lol. I think, I think, I think, I think, I think, AND I think you're incredible.,,, lool.

  • @voxonmic I think you're right

  • Good song choice ! Beautiful! This song was my favorite! :)

  • Fab performance, great version of t'pau's original hit 10/10-please record it-certain no1.

  • I thought this was a marilin Marnroe *(cant spell her name, sorry) lol at first cos she really does look like her! llol <3 AMELIA TO WIN

  • AMAZING <3 !Best performance of the night xD <3 lol xxx

  • Beautiful Performance! Deserves to win