Two things I've never been able to get out of my head from this scene, ever since I first saw this movie as a kid:
1. The cop who opened fire on the wrong target on a moving carousel with lots of people on it, killing the innocent conductor, and thus directly causing a crash that caused significant property damage and possibly killed several more people, should go to prison.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Ridiculous scene. The bad acting from the main character nearly made the film unwatchable, but this scene completely killed the movie for me. The thing is not moving that fast, all of the people on it could jump off without getting hurt. It's not but about a foot off the ground.
I just saw this scene on a segment from TCM Now I want to see the whole movie. Brilliant use of a childrens ride going berserk! Hitchcock really was a movie genius In reality though a carousel has a governor on it and it couldn't speed up like that even if the operator wanted it to.
This is a great film! The band organ on the carousel, however would not speed up if the carousel revolved faster - and it definitely would not go up in PITCH. That is a blooper in this movie.
This is probably my most favorite dark movie scene of all time. I've watched this scene over and over again for the past 20 years and it gets the same emotional response from me every time. That Hitchcock throws comic relief in a few places during it so effectively is a true sign of his genius. Thanks for posting.
I always wonder starting 3:13 when is it speeded up...i wonder if that's done on purpose or technical malfunction when they record this from film to DVD. It looks more like a error than purpose tho...
This is a brilliant film, and it genuinely frightened me the first time i saw it! Robert walker was so convincing as Bruno, and Hitchcock's set pieces such as the carousel were brilliant.
I always wished the carousels that i got on as a kid went this fast. (without the carnage of course)
AngelHatchets 4 days ago
LOL, the machinery mockup even HAS a governor, you can see it not governing on the top left!
piglood 3 months ago
does anyone else think that Bruno looks like Robert Vaughn?
bugsbunnybuddy 3 months ago
Great movie hope hollywood wont remake this becoz old is gold hitchcock one of the best director for thriller movies
ResidentNotEvil5 3 months ago
Best scene in the movie.
jen8042 4 months ago
Two things I've never been able to get out of my head from this scene, ever since I first saw this movie as a kid:
1. The cop who opened fire on the wrong target on a moving carousel with lots of people on it, killing the innocent conductor, and thus directly causing a crash that caused significant property damage and possibly killed several more people, should go to prison.
2. Holy crap, that old guy is a badass.
Piecesof8 6 months ago 4
Wow!
ebonpinion 7 months ago
farley granger best actor of 50 s better then brando or dean
master82565 7 months ago
RIP Farley Granger =(
AHafan2 10 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ridiculous scene. The bad acting from the main character nearly made the film unwatchable, but this scene completely killed the movie for me. The thing is not moving that fast, all of the people on it could jump off without getting hurt. It's not but about a foot off the ground.
cbrooks83 11 months ago
@cbrooks83 hero.
jpowerlongboards 11 months ago
3:15 Aaaaww do it SLOWLY, old man!
pacoenfadonha 1 year ago
Who flagged my I can handle it! Not! as spam?
fiddlerpin 1 year ago
An awesome scene. This is one of my favourite films of all time. Great use of metaphor :D
artoftiamat 1 year ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
I can handle it! Not!
fiddlerpin 1 year ago
I just saw this scene on a segment from TCM Now I want to see the whole movie. Brilliant use of a childrens ride going berserk! Hitchcock really was a movie genius In reality though a carousel has a governor on it and it couldn't speed up like that even if the operator wanted it to.
fiddlerpin 1 year ago
@fiddlerpin even back then?
TheRealReverence 1 year ago
@TheRealReverence Yes they did have mechanical governors. Why not just kill the power?
fiddlerpin 1 year ago
@fiddlerpin because then there would be no suspeeeenseee! :D
TheRealReverence 1 year ago
@TheRealReverence Sorry I'm a mechanical contractor and just can't help thinking about this stuff. LOL
fiddlerpin 1 year ago
@fiddlerpin its all good haha
TheRealReverence 1 year ago
the subtext in this scene is pretty obvious, pistons and all that.
peplumz 1 year ago
Gotta hand it to that Old Geezer that volunteered to go under the Carousel and stop it. I wonder if he's still walking the earth today???
JarheadPatriot0311 1 year ago
One of the most intense and exhilirating climaxes of any Hitchcock film, if not of all films!
ABALLAM3 1 year ago
One of the Great ones from the 1950's
ricksay58 1 year ago
I just saw this DVD,
I'm impressed, it was good.
lawrencelugar7777 1 year ago
This is a great film! The band organ on the carousel, however would not speed up if the carousel revolved faster - and it definitely would not go up in PITCH. That is a blooper in this movie.
RKGKSC 1 year ago
@RKGKSC The speed of the song and higher pitch is to make this scene have more tension, to put the audiences on the edge of their seats!
Nbasurto17 1 year ago
Fabulous scene.
How strange that Haines still wanted to talk to Bruno after this particular episode.
perigordblues 2 years ago
This is probably my most favorite dark movie scene of all time. I've watched this scene over and over again for the past 20 years and it gets the same emotional response from me every time. That Hitchcock throws comic relief in a few places during it so effectively is a true sign of his genius. Thanks for posting.
robertfontanelli 2 years ago
Why Robert Walker didn't win an Academy
Award for his heart-stopping characterization of the homicidal maniac, Bruno Anthony, is one of the biggest injustices in movie history...
moloch49 2 years ago
I always wonder starting 3:13 when is it speeded up...i wonder if that's done on purpose or technical malfunction when they record this from film to DVD. It looks more like a error than purpose tho...
daming7562 2 years ago
@daming7562 I think it's done on purpose. It adds a bit of humor, given his very slow crawl.
Leveillee6425 1 year ago
One of my favourites!
Thank you for uploading!
bellainmyheart 2 years ago
"Hey! Be careful! Stop!"
"Well, you wanna do it yourself?"
"No, I guess he can make it alright."
Cracked me up!
Spiritgirldance 2 years ago
lol when robert walker bitchslaps the kid to the floor of the platform
creoltein 3 years ago
This is a brilliant film, and it genuinely frightened me the first time i saw it! Robert walker was so convincing as Bruno, and Hitchcock's set pieces such as the carousel were brilliant.
TheKubrickFanatic 3 years ago
great scene....I've watched it on here once before, but it doesn't seem to work now? Don't know what's gone wrong.
GentleGenius 3 years ago
YouTube is weird sometimes.
This is a wonderful film.
Nibbbling 2 years ago
Yes YouTune is decidedly weird at times. I've found out why it wouldn't work for me that night.
Great film!
GentleGenius 2 years ago
This is a classic!
aujuma 3 years ago