Cecelia is a bit lost now....and her problems with the Coluratura start with her Mother...at the same time, the foundation her mother gave her in Legato is good...
Cecelia is a bit lost now....and her problems with the Coluratura start with her Mother...at the same time, the foundation her mother gave her in Legato is good
A mio giudizio....ci sono tante verità nel canto,cosi come in ogni cosa nella vita. L importante è non ASSOLUTIZZARE . Questo porterebbe a non vedere le cose da tutte le angolazioni possibili.
Va bene Signora, pero perche non correggi tutte le manierismi che ha la Sua figlia?? Guardi prego la sua faccia, sta facendo halluzinazioni, aprendo quel'occhi cosi grandi, facendo labbri demonali... Nel canto non c'entra sola la Gola, il piu importante e il Fiato !!! Cecilia deve cantare piu tenuta e controllata! Cosi e sempre hysterico sul palcoscenico ! -18
@jaxonbaby guarda che la tecnica di canto è la base per il cantante, luoghi comuni per tutti noi, i principi sono gli stessi per tutti... ma!!! La tecnica alla fine, una volta capita, la devi far tua, è La Bartoli, come tanti altri, forse fa dei gesti che pur non essendo neccessari, lei si trova comoda!! io sono venuto in italia proprio per imparare la tecnica della vecchia scuola italiana, e devo dire che mi trovo con quello che dice la madre, ma mettere tutto ciò in prattica, non è facile!!
CREDO KE LA VOSTRA SIA SOLO INVIDIA...CIO KE DICE LA MAMMA DI CECILIA E' GIUSTISSIMO...SOPRATTUTTO QUANDO DICE KE LA FORZA DI VOLONTA CONTA MOLTISSIMO NEL REALIZZARE I SOGNI. LA VOCE DELLA BARTOLI SI SA E' MINUSCOLA IL VOLUME E' UN DONO NATURALE SE NON C E L HAI BUONANOTTE MA CECILIA CANTA BENE LO STESSO ANKE SE LE AGILITA IN QUALUNQUE REPERTORIO SONO UGUALI MA X ME RESTA UN MOSTRO DI TECNICA|!
If all the knowledge about vocal production made its way to the stages of the world, we'd be living in a golden age. As luck would have it, we'll just have to leave vocal production and the views about it to those in the arena, namely opera singers. Excuse me; I have to get back to doing.
@skitzo429 I respect your opinion, but I wouldn't call what's down low true power. Put any voice under enough pressure with that much tension, and the sound will alter. That said, you go your way, and I'll go mine. There are plenty of singers out there for each of us to enjoy. I'll shut up now...
@ian1856 See theres the difference, its true that if you put any voice under enough tension youll get at least the illusion of power down low, but that kind of singing will destroy a voice if its not a real mezzo. Beverly Sills often commented later in her career that she had ruined her voice singing big low chesty notes in Donizetti's devereux and taken years off of her career, Bartoli has been singing professionally for over 20 years, if she wasnt a real Mezzo she wouldnt still be singing
@skitzo429 I understand your point, but I'm one of those people who feels she's actually a high soprano. And the only way a high soprano can last for so many years with that technique is to sing as a mezzo. That said, it really is nit-picking, because she's a great artist and what she's doing is obviously working for her...and a lot of other people as well! I certainly NEVER want to be one of those losers, who spends his time bashing great singers on YouTube. Do enjoy!
@ian1856 I think you missed what my point was, and your reasoning is flawed, high sopranos do not have longer careers by singing mezzo, that would ruin their voice. I know a number of sopranos who have gotten vocal nodes singing things that are too low for their voice, if anything singing mezzo roles when one is a high soprano would ruin the voice even faster. The fact that she has been singing mezzo roles for so long means she IS a mezzo. check out soprano assoluta, the concept explains her.
@bailharico I think she doesn't know herself... There are muscles that "go down", but not certainly the tongue. And just because she happens to be the mother of the most tecnicly perfect singer of ever, it doens't mean she is the greatest voice coach ever. Although, some of the things she says are true.
@Querzeo I agree, she says lots of good things but the tounge cannot be held down! Your tounge must stay up and forward if you want to activate that spot behind your nose...if you get my meaning lol
la madre della bartoli si inventa una tecnica di canto che non esiste! ecco perche cecilia è cosi stimbrata sfiatata e canta con una emissione che fa a pugni con il belcanto
@grobprandl73 non s'inventa nessuna tecnica, mi pare: ma perché non ascoltate bene? dice solo che ha un suo metodo per arrivare meglio alla tecnica. non è la stessa cosa. c'è chi apre meglio la gola sulla U, chi sulla I, ma è comunque molto difficile "aprire la gola" (che non significa ovviamente quello che un profano potrebbe intendere, sennò sarebbero buoni tutti a cantare)
@grobprandl73 INVECE MI DISPIACE X TE MA LA LARINGE SI PUO ABBASSARE DI VOLONTA'. SI ABBASSA NATURALMENTE RESPIRANDO MA LA SI PUO FAR ABBASSARE X DARE ANCORA PIU SPAZIO E TENERLA SEMPRE ABBASSATA.
Fatemi capire. all'inizio la cara Cecilia dice che bisogna cantare con libertà, e poi la madre le insegna tutto il contrario? La U è una vocale fondamentale nel canto, poiché consente il giro del suono, ma spiegata cosi' la voce si intuba...e infatti la Cecilia nostra è intubata in tutta la sua estensione.
lei all'inizio sul muretto dice delle cazzate. la madre non si sa spiegare e non usa bene la sintassi. però il loro metodo è giusto, quando sono insieme al pianoforte i vocalizzi sui picchettati sono PERFETTI, e i gesti della madre dicono molto più delle parole
All the vowels in singing must be done in the same position of the throat: some people are immediately turned the voice on U, other on I, this does not matter. But this video is a bit 'dangerous because the sound U that the mother does, is not correct: she is nice, but a bit' tricky :-)
That's ridiculous, if you only use one vowel you have no diction, if all you wanna do is sing cute vocalizes that's fine, but that doesn't work for opera. Cecilia's mother is right and the results show.
@primohomme but I have not spoken a single vocal, but only one position, which must be sung in all the different vowels. Opera singing is based on vowels, sung on the so-called "open throat" = same position of the throat, if you want an example of this, please see the explanation of Pavaraotti and Marilyn Horne here on youtube (how to sing bel canto)
@primohomme sing ee with the lips as in oo is useless, if you do not sound well supported on the breath, through the position of the throat open. The lips do not serve to make the sound round
@primohomme what she is talking is an obstacle that must be overcome to pass from uneducated sing to opera singing, ie move from the position of throat closed to open throat. It is not an easy thing, some take a long time, others never arrival this goal (was told by Bartoli's mother to a friend of mine)
What are you lot like!!! One writes crap, manrico60; one fails to open all of the Russian dolls and misses the obvious kernel,HasLev243: operamusicfan, far from living her dreams through Cecilia, her modest and gracious mother Silvana nurtured Cecilia, her sister and brother, now sadly passed, with the most precious of all things a Mothers Love.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
TERRIBLE!!! Now I understand WHY CEcilia Bartoli sings with that awful face and without voice!!!....Talis Mater talis Filia! Singing is not violence, singing is something different: like Caballé, like Berganza, like Horne, like Sutherland.AWAY!!!
Brava famiglia! La mejor profesora de Cecilia Bartoli es su Mamma!....al igual que la de Leontina Vaduva es su Mamma Maria Ciobanu. Ellas hacen grande la cultura musical de Europa. ¡Gracias!Francesc :) La Taula de Barcelona.
haha I love cecilia Bartoli, but its pretty obvious that she markets herself in the WRONG fach, she is most def. a high soprano of somesort maybe even some kind of coluratura, but for sure NOT a mezzo.
Typical sick Italian mother daughter relationship. She does everything for her . Till she depends on her . Then the mother dies , and the daughter is alone. Sula sul.
does everything? the video only shows cecilia's mother teaching her to sing. not enough to make this sweeping and unfounded generalization you have made darling.
i love how versatile she is and how adventurous. her vivaldi cd was so fantastic, just like everything she does. and she seems so genuine. besides being so gifted and humble, i think she's beautiful. and i hate the criticism too! the people who criticize her often can't do a tenth of what she can do! thank you for posting this! brava, cecilia!
You can't have any conception of the total, unreserved spiritual commitment that Cecilia has to her music. As must the whole of any musical instrument be involved in the sound composed within it so must Cecilia's "Very Being" be involved in her exquisite renditions. I do not accept your harsh and ignorant criticism of Cecilia and her Mother. Within themselves and each other they have nurtured the exquisite, unsurpassable beauty that is Cecilia, much to the unbridled pleasure of "my world".
You can't have any conception of the total, unreserved spiritual commitment that Cecilia has to her music. As must the whole of any musical instrument be involved in the sound composed within it so must Cecilia's "Very Being" be involved in her exquisite renditions. I do not accept your harsh and ignorant criticism of Cecilia and her Mother. Within themselves and each other they have nurtured the exquisite, unsurpassable beauty that is Cecilia, much to the unbridled pleasure of "my world".
es absolutamente cierto. para ser un buen cantante hay que tener talento y disciplina. y esto es en todos los cantantes de cualquier género, que parece se olvidan de esto y hacen una carrera basada en facultades naturales que con el tiempo se deterioran.
If we could all have such a mother...to instill within us, not only the wisdom oftechnique, but that firm and unbending sense of self, and the belief in that self and all the many wonders it can accomplish...It is a gift so rarely given from mother to child, in America especially. And it is this particular lack that can be found at the root of quite nearly all the struggle and pain which plagues so many of us.
tagliata così l'intervista, non si capisce assolutamente in cosa consista questo metodo, se non a fare una grottesca U in fondo alla gola; non vengono detti insomma i passi successivi che portano all'impostazione che ha la figlia, che è buona. La Bartoli canta bene, anche se il suo Bellini sembra Rossini, Rossini sembra Vivaldi and so on ... :-)
No wonder she´s one of the best. People who describes her like a "bitch" are the ones who (probably since she started singing) told her she "was not good enough" just becouse she had that extra thing called will and talent. that got a name. ENVY. Thank god she had a mother who not only knows about singing, but about life too! God bless her..
??? I think, Cecilia's mother is wonderful, she not only managed to teach Cecilia how to use her wonderful voice, but she also achieved that Cecilia could stay herself. And Cecilia's true love for her mother shows that they were and are perfect for another. As teacher and student and as mother and daughter. I really admire Silvana and appreciate her life.
Qualcuno sa se c'è un DVD di questo materiale?? sarebbe fantastico e credo che non solo per me!!
rockandbluesboy 1 month ago
How old is this video?
UncleTito72 4 months ago
@UncleTito72
1991
FadoPrimavera 1 month ago
una marea di luoghi comuni che la figlia non mette assolutamente in pratica. In Italia è un dato di fatto che la scuola di canto è scomparsa...
fra66fra 4 months ago
@fra66fra - totalmente de acuerdo !!!!
Maripudelmonaco 2 months ago in playlist Horrores
No sabia que fué su madre la que la enseñó a cacarearar.
Maripudelmonaco 4 months ago in playlist Horrores
Cecelia is a bit lost now....and her problems with the Coluratura start with her Mother...at the same time, the foundation her mother gave her in Legato is good...
all the mixed pieces of life....
bf2019 4 months ago
Cecelia is a bit lost now....and her problems with the Coluratura start with her Mother...at the same time, the foundation her mother gave her in Legato is good
all the mixed pieces of life....
bf2019 4 months ago
Did anyone understand what notes she's singing at 1:12 ? it's the HIGH F!!! of the queen of the night! she sings it 3 times here
OperaClips 5 months ago
A mio giudizio....ci sono tante verità nel canto,cosi come in ogni cosa nella vita. L importante è non ASSOLUTIZZARE . Questo porterebbe a non vedere le cose da tutte le angolazioni possibili.
vivacecilia 6 months ago
la laringe si deve muovere, non deve rimanere sempre bassa. ho capito perché la figlia canta così
ThePlutino 7 months ago
if this woman taught cecilia bartoli to sing,she needs to give lessons to everone eles
roman14032 8 months ago
What is this from? I'd love to see the whole segment.
flyinggeese426 10 months ago
@flyinggeese426 From the dvd, A portrait. It includes this documantary about Cecilia and a concert with Cecilia ;)
spenzur 9 months ago
Va bene Signora, pero perche non correggi tutte le manierismi che ha la Sua figlia?? Guardi prego la sua faccia, sta facendo halluzinazioni, aprendo quel'occhi cosi grandi, facendo labbri demonali... Nel canto non c'entra sola la Gola, il piu importante e il Fiato !!! Cecilia deve cantare piu tenuta e controllata! Cosi e sempre hysterico sul palcoscenico ! -18
jaxonbaby 10 months ago
@jaxonbaby
You actually speak a pretty good Italian but you do not understand much about music :)
jonnykam 8 months ago 2
@jaxonbaby guarda che la tecnica di canto è la base per il cantante, luoghi comuni per tutti noi, i principi sono gli stessi per tutti... ma!!! La tecnica alla fine, una volta capita, la devi far tua, è La Bartoli, come tanti altri, forse fa dei gesti che pur non essendo neccessari, lei si trova comoda!! io sono venuto in italia proprio per imparare la tecnica della vecchia scuola italiana, e devo dire che mi trovo con quello che dice la madre, ma mettere tutto ciò in prattica, non è facile!!
rockandbluesboy 1 month ago
No, not to be "the best"... wrong,
but to strive for growth, for leaning, for maturing,
for more sensibility and appreciation.
The being the "best" is a trap.
fabrizzzio48 11 months ago
@fabrizzzio48 So true. Self-seeking is an inauthentic motive that cannot sustain. You have to do it out of love.
AriD2385 6 months ago
CREDO KE LA VOSTRA SIA SOLO INVIDIA...CIO KE DICE LA MAMMA DI CECILIA E' GIUSTISSIMO...SOPRATTUTTO QUANDO DICE KE LA FORZA DI VOLONTA CONTA MOLTISSIMO NEL REALIZZARE I SOGNI. LA VOCE DELLA BARTOLI SI SA E' MINUSCOLA IL VOLUME E' UN DONO NATURALE SE NON C E L HAI BUONANOTTE MA CECILIA CANTA BENE LO STESSO ANKE SE LE AGILITA IN QUALUNQUE REPERTORIO SONO UGUALI MA X ME RESTA UN MOSTRO DI TECNICA|!
emilytransex 1 year ago 2
@emilytransex hai parlato per 100 anni!!! brav@!!!
rockandbluesboy 1 month ago 2
If all the knowledge about vocal production made its way to the stages of the world, we'd be living in a golden age. As luck would have it, we'll just have to leave vocal production and the views about it to those in the arena, namely opera singers. Excuse me; I have to get back to doing.
ian1856 1 year ago
...musicalità sensibilità e volere e grande disciplina interna...sapersi dominare...per raggiungere l'obiettivo prefissato...
comunicare è meraviglioso ...comunicare al prossimo attraverso la musica...è stupendo...
vero è...
bruccheri70 1 year ago
you dont see mezzos singing high Fs so often...
skitzo429 1 year ago
All wrong all wrong all wrong. She is just lucky the voice can take that kind of pressure. Not for long though.
Webarton 1 year ago
The anti-Sutherland. Mamma took a high coloratura and turned her into a pressed mezzo. Go visit Bonynge in Switzerland.
ian1856 1 year ago
@ian1856 I dont think so, the amount of power she has down low cannot be synthesized
skitzo429 1 year ago
@skitzo429 I respect your opinion, but I wouldn't call what's down low true power. Put any voice under enough pressure with that much tension, and the sound will alter. That said, you go your way, and I'll go mine. There are plenty of singers out there for each of us to enjoy. I'll shut up now...
ian1856 1 year ago
@ian1856 See theres the difference, its true that if you put any voice under enough tension youll get at least the illusion of power down low, but that kind of singing will destroy a voice if its not a real mezzo. Beverly Sills often commented later in her career that she had ruined her voice singing big low chesty notes in Donizetti's devereux and taken years off of her career, Bartoli has been singing professionally for over 20 years, if she wasnt a real Mezzo she wouldnt still be singing
skitzo429 1 year ago
@skitzo429 I understand your point, but I'm one of those people who feels she's actually a high soprano. And the only way a high soprano can last for so many years with that technique is to sing as a mezzo. That said, it really is nit-picking, because she's a great artist and what she's doing is obviously working for her...and a lot of other people as well! I certainly NEVER want to be one of those losers, who spends his time bashing great singers on YouTube. Do enjoy!
ian1856 1 year ago
@ian1856 I think you missed what my point was, and your reasoning is flawed, high sopranos do not have longer careers by singing mezzo, that would ruin their voice. I know a number of sopranos who have gotten vocal nodes singing things that are too low for their voice, if anything singing mezzo roles when one is a high soprano would ruin the voice even faster. The fact that she has been singing mezzo roles for so long means she IS a mezzo. check out soprano assoluta, the concept explains her.
skitzo429 1 year ago
@ian1856 Thank you for sharing that. Have a good evening!
ian1856 1 year ago
@ian1856
LMAO, and then she would have a hollow sound below G4...
primohomme 1 year ago
love that technique !!!! I want to know how she does that O.O!
keyphi 1 year ago
0:38 ... wow ... F#6 from a mezzo? Incredible!
rossyxan 1 year ago
@rossyxan She wasn't even straining on that F#6.I wonder how much higher she could actually go.She could try to sing more coloratura soprano roles.
FloridianWolf 1 year ago
What Cecilia mother means when she says the tongue must be down?
Cosa vuol dire la madre di Cecilia quando dice che la lingua deve essere bassa?
bailharico 1 year ago
@bailharico I think she doesn't know herself... There are muscles that "go down", but not certainly the tongue. And just because she happens to be the mother of the most tecnicly perfect singer of ever, it doens't mean she is the greatest voice coach ever. Although, some of the things she says are true.
Querzeo 1 year ago
@Querzeo I agree, she says lots of good things but the tounge cannot be held down! Your tounge must stay up and forward if you want to activate that spot behind your nose...if you get my meaning lol
LaCarusiella 1 year ago
@LaCarusiella that's what I mean. Thank you. :-)
Querzeo 1 year ago
@bailharico LINGUA RILASSATA KE NON SI ALZI...
emilytransex 6 months ago
la madre della bartoli si inventa una tecnica di canto che non esiste! ecco perche cecilia è cosi stimbrata sfiatata e canta con una emissione che fa a pugni con il belcanto
grobprandl73 1 year ago
@grobprandl73 non s'inventa nessuna tecnica, mi pare: ma perché non ascoltate bene? dice solo che ha un suo metodo per arrivare meglio alla tecnica. non è la stessa cosa. c'è chi apre meglio la gola sulla U, chi sulla I, ma è comunque molto difficile "aprire la gola" (che non significa ovviamente quello che un profano potrebbe intendere, sennò sarebbero buoni tutti a cantare)
galehout 1 year ago
@grobprandl73 INVECE MI DISPIACE X TE MA LA LARINGE SI PUO ABBASSARE DI VOLONTA'. SI ABBASSA NATURALMENTE RESPIRANDO MA LA SI PUO FAR ABBASSARE X DARE ANCORA PIU SPAZIO E TENERLA SEMPRE ABBASSATA.
emilytransex 6 months ago
Her mum looks exactly like Mariella Devia :)
thomastmwc 1 year ago
@thomastmwc
Ewwww, Devia? don't insult Cecilia's mom.
primohomme 1 year ago
Does anyone else think her voice sounds a little bit like Renee Fleming's in that last part?
OperaLover84 1 year ago
i love CB!
mordoquiojunelle 1 year ago
How old is this? From the '80s, maybe?
Spoxjox 1 year ago
@Spoxjox
mid 90's.
primohomme 1 year ago
will be this video part of a documental?
jOsselinsantos 1 year ago
Mrs Bartoli, Her Majesty, looks like Meriella Devia....lol
thomastmwc 1 year ago
she looks a lot like her mum. they both have such bright eyes! like there is a fire in them!
yanpan16 1 year ago
that woman gives me the creeps. Am I the only one?
Ringrazio al padre eterno... communicare col Prossimo???
WTF???
amatorynumber 2 years ago
magnifique alala je t'aime Cecilia!
miCeciliaBartoli 2 years ago
Fatemi capire. all'inizio la cara Cecilia dice che bisogna cantare con libertà, e poi la madre le insegna tutto il contrario? La U è una vocale fondamentale nel canto, poiché consente il giro del suono, ma spiegata cosi' la voce si intuba...e infatti la Cecilia nostra è intubata in tutta la sua estensione.
Richarzh 2 years ago
@Richarzh
lei all'inizio sul muretto dice delle cazzate. la madre non si sa spiegare e non usa bene la sintassi. però il loro metodo è giusto, quando sono insieme al pianoforte i vocalizzi sui picchettati sono PERFETTI, e i gesti della madre dicono molto più delle parole
galehout 1 year ago
@galehout
Ahahah è vero....il muretto delle cazzate,ovviamente è una cosa commerciale!!Cmq grande metodo del laringe!!!
vivacecilia 1 year ago
@vivacecilia sì grande metodo, l'unico vero!
galehout 1 year ago
wish I had my mother supporting me like this
julianaperrusoo 2 years ago 2
Geez, Cecilia's so young here! It's weird to think that she's been 'on the map', so to speak, since the late '80s!
JeeRant 2 years ago
how do you use low larynx for vowels other than oo? especially ee?
StitchBeatbox 2 years ago
@StitchBeatbox
All the vowels in singing must be done in the same position of the throat: some people are immediately turned the voice on U, other on I, this does not matter. But this video is a bit 'dangerous because the sound U that the mother does, is not correct: she is nice, but a bit' tricky :-)
galehout 1 year ago
@galehout
That's ridiculous, if you only use one vowel you have no diction, if all you wanna do is sing cute vocalizes that's fine, but that doesn't work for opera. Cecilia's mother is right and the results show.
primohomme 1 year ago
@primohomme but I have not spoken a single vocal, but only one position, which must be sung in all the different vowels. Opera singing is based on vowels, sung on the so-called "open throat" = same position of the throat, if you want an example of this, please see the explanation of Pavaraotti and Marilyn Horne here on youtube (how to sing bel canto)
galehout 1 year ago
Does'nt seem too much of a problem...being she specializes in Italian rep,
idigvivaldi 1 year ago
@galehout thanks for your help galeout =)
StitchBeatbox 1 year ago
@StitchBeatbox
You don't say ee as in english but ee with the lips as in oo almost, that rounds the sound and protects it.
primohomme 1 year ago
@primohomme sing ee with the lips as in oo is useless, if you do not sound well supported on the breath, through the position of the throat open. The lips do not serve to make the sound round
galehout 1 year ago
@primohomme what she is talking is an obstacle that must be overcome to pass from uneducated sing to opera singing, ie move from the position of throat closed to open throat. It is not an easy thing, some take a long time, others never arrival this goal (was told by Bartoli's mother to a friend of mine)
galehout 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@StitchBeatbox
You don't say ee as in english but ee with the lips as in oo almost, that rounds the sound and protects it.
primohomme 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@StitchBeatbox
You don't say ee as in english but ee with the lips as in oo almost, that rounds the sound and protects it.
primohomme 1 year ago
This is very interesting!
leoperarm 2 years ago 6
What are you lot like!!! One writes crap, manrico60; one fails to open all of the Russian dolls and misses the obvious kernel,HasLev243: operamusicfan, far from living her dreams through Cecilia, her modest and gracious mother Silvana nurtured Cecilia, her sister and brother, now sadly passed, with the most precious of all things a Mothers Love.
Get a grip!!!
bill7671 2 years ago 13
This has been flagged as spam show
You can tell she's living her dreams through her daughter.
operamusicfan 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
guys I watched this vid and see the same method they taught us in russia)))))Everywhere s the same if u wanna sing belcanto
HasLev2483 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What a lot of crap!!
Her mother has no idea what voice productiobn is all about, so much so that she tried evrything and ended up in a chorus in rome.
bartoli is all nature and good luck,nothing else.
manrico60 2 years ago
You chase Bartoli as I chase you chasing her...
You just don't like her...
sagarzon 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Su estupidez no merece una respuesta sensata
A comer frijoles y cruzao,de musica no sabe nada.
manrico60 2 years ago
Resentido.
sagarzon 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
maricon
manrico60 2 years ago
jejejeje
qué es cruzao?
sagarzon 2 years ago
oh shut up!
ceciliafan1 2 years ago
biffy... shut the fuck up!
firelvr07 2 years ago
obviously he's way in over his head...
Sabiano 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
TERRIBLE!!! Now I understand WHY CEcilia Bartoli sings with that awful face and without voice!!!....Talis Mater talis Filia! Singing is not violence, singing is something different: like Caballé, like Berganza, like Horne, like Sutherland.AWAY!!!
arturogelli 2 years ago
the method is the same, like Caballé etc. She simply refer to open throat ("un po' violento" in her italian expression = volontary)
galehout 2 years ago
I find it funny when she says - you need quite a lot of things to be a good singer, I mean her daughter is a magnificent singer!
Stupendo
MissLimLam 2 years ago
Bravo Cecilia!!!
cecilala85 2 years ago
Brava famiglia! La mejor profesora de Cecilia Bartoli es su Mamma!....al igual que la de Leontina Vaduva es su Mamma Maria Ciobanu. Ellas hacen grande la cultura musical de Europa. ¡Gracias!Francesc :) La Taula de Barcelona.
LaTaula 3 years ago
that was inspiring!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
merycruze 3 years ago
I see she's as hyper at home as she is on stage :P
ShawDAMAN 3 years ago
haha I love cecilia Bartoli, but its pretty obvious that she markets herself in the WRONG fach, she is most def. a high soprano of somesort maybe even some kind of coluratura, but for sure NOT a mezzo.
Biffy2008 3 years ago 2
Actually. She is a mezzo. A coloratura mezzo soprano.
Spiceofmadrid 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Typical sick Italian mother daughter relationship. She does everything for her . Till she depends on her . Then the mother dies , and the daughter is alone. Sula sul.
tenorismo 3 years ago
How do you know that? Do you live with then? lol
staydatip xD
TheEmperorsNewClothe 3 years ago 2
How do you know it's typical? Do you live in italy? no? I didn't think so.
elisaballerina456 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Che schifo...sembra la mamma di Psycho...vai a cagare
dotorbartolo 3 years ago
does everything? the video only shows cecilia's mother teaching her to sing. not enough to make this sweeping and unfounded generalization you have made darling.
anohbey 3 years ago
But its fact that Cecilia Bartoli is the best of the best!!
CelloVoice 3 years ago
Excuse me, but are you jealous of such relationships?
nichtsleezy 3 years ago
Why would you even say something like that?
chubaboo 3 years ago
<3!!
cecilia ...awesome :)
jopagazza 3 years ago
Thank you so much for posting this!
barabysik 3 years ago
kmeee....I want her to teach me...
namaria6666 3 years ago
I think she is her mum, because they look similar. Her mum says very crucial things!!
madziua90 3 years ago 2
Is that really her mother? If so, she is very lucky to have a mother like that. Hopefully, Cecilia feels the same way.
cyliu0413 3 years ago 27
@cyliu0413 cecilia's parents are bother lyrical singer. in italy people like we call people like cecilia "figli d'arte"
mat558513 4 months ago
Wow. Cecilia is absolutely beautiful in both body and voice!
AdIgnorantiam 3 years ago 4
i love how versatile she is and how adventurous. her vivaldi cd was so fantastic, just like everything she does. and she seems so genuine. besides being so gifted and humble, i think she's beautiful. and i hate the criticism too! the people who criticize her often can't do a tenth of what she can do! thank you for posting this! brava, cecilia!
oleander1684 3 years ago 3
Amen!!!
CubbyNH 2 years ago
cecilia bartoli is too amazing for words to fully describe. her voice is beautiful and her control over it is amazing.
XXMaliceCreatorXX 3 years ago 6
When I see her performing live I really feel like jumping into the stage and giving her a big hug
abdc1122 3 years ago 5
does anyone know what this clip is from?
gibraltarrr 3 years ago
It's on the DVD "Cecilia Bartoli - A Portrait". Beautiful DVD for Cecilia fans....
isimice 3 years ago
sono convinto che Cecilia non faccia quello che dice la madre in fatto di tecnica...non canterebbe come canta..
belcantomania 3 years ago
She's got AMAZING EYES
and truly AMAZING VOICE=)
NaiRaPriNCeSS 3 years ago
How hih does she go?
AlexiouValenti 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I don't like this permanent hiccups at all.
scarpia1965 4 years ago
pardon? what do you mean?
jarheadshort 3 years ago
I think Cecilia's facial expressions are wonderful and part of her charm.
buelligan123 4 years ago 20
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sometimes I wonder if she's singing or having an allergic reaction.
djs259 4 years ago
Your Lobotomy went well then??
bill7671 4 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
It's just a permanent hiccups!
scarpia1965 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Too bad her mother didn't teacher her to supress those obnoxious tics and grimaces while singing.
djs259 4 years ago
You can't have any conception of the total, unreserved spiritual commitment that Cecilia has to her music. As must the whole of any musical instrument be involved in the sound composed within it so must Cecilia's "Very Being" be involved in her exquisite renditions. I do not accept your harsh and ignorant criticism of Cecilia and her Mother. Within themselves and each other they have nurtured the exquisite, unsurpassable beauty that is Cecilia, much to the unbridled pleasure of "my world".
bill7671 4 years ago 5
You can't have any conception of the total, unreserved spiritual commitment that Cecilia has to her music. As must the whole of any musical instrument be involved in the sound composed within it so must Cecilia's "Very Being" be involved in her exquisite renditions. I do not accept your harsh and ignorant criticism of Cecilia and her Mother. Within themselves and each other they have nurtured the exquisite, unsurpassable beauty that is Cecilia, much to the unbridled pleasure of "my world".
bill7671 4 years ago
Wow, well and beautifully put!!!
I love Cecilia too and I hate the criticism she recieves!!! I love this video and I love what you wrote!!!
Thank you.
Macoperaking 3 years ago 5
Thank you for your kind comments: this world is immeasurably richer graced as it is with Cecilia's exquisite presence.
bill7671 3 years ago 5
la lingua deve essere bassa ecco jajajjajaj
overlin2 4 years ago
es absolutamente cierto. para ser un buen cantante hay que tener talento y disciplina. y esto es en todos los cantantes de cualquier género, que parece se olvidan de esto y hacen una carrera basada en facultades naturales que con el tiempo se deterioran.
salvadorangelmejia 4 years ago
thanks for posting this :)
hallohooo 4 years ago
I WANT TO BE THE BEST!!!
stuart1desert1pea 4 years ago
If that's a real real wish, deam right you're gonna be the piu best!!! at list, that's what cecilia's mom would say to you if she were your mom...
141407078989 4 years ago
gracias por tu comentario!
stuart1desert1pea 4 years ago
If we could all have such a mother...to instill within us, not only the wisdom oftechnique, but that firm and unbending sense of self, and the belief in that self and all the many wonders it can accomplish...It is a gift so rarely given from mother to child, in America especially. And it is this particular lack that can be found at the root of quite nearly all the struggle and pain which plagues so many of us.
MelancholyBaby21 4 years ago 2
WOW!!! Congratulations !!!
giulsy35 4 years ago
meravigliose ;)
MrDamon84 4 years ago
tagliata così l'intervista, non si capisce assolutamente in cosa consista questo metodo, se non a fare una grottesca U in fondo alla gola; non vengono detti insomma i passi successivi che portano all'impostazione che ha la figlia, che è buona. La Bartoli canta bene, anche se il suo Bellini sembra Rossini, Rossini sembra Vivaldi and so on ... :-)
akenato62 4 years ago
geloso?
luisluis84 4 years ago
sì!
akenato62 4 years ago 2
I need a bartoli's mom in my house!!! I love her!!! wonderful!!
liricobarroco 4 years ago
mi consola vedere che anche cecilia bartoli a volte fa i vocalizzi poco precisi e la maestra la riprende! ;)
canterina1977 4 years ago
Brava Silvana Vazzoni , tuve la suerte de conocerla en Roma y dar lecciones con ella. una gran maestra.
AndresVera24 4 years ago
LOVE IT.........
JessiCott 4 years ago
i want a mama like this one please adopt me beatiful love it
Toastyummy 4 years ago
La madre necessita di qualche lezione di grammatica, Cecilia invece è meravigliosa!!!!
persepolis69 4 years ago
I wish my mom was a singing teacher!
lamezzoenfrancais 4 years ago
That was really cool! Thank you for this!
operagirl81 4 years ago
do you have any vidoee were your teaching more voice lessons?
idelacerda 4 years ago
tanto una con le doti della Bartoli avrebbe cantato anche se le avesse insegnato una verduraia e a testa in giù!! ;-)
giorgio973 4 years ago
un generale del terzo REICH
lyside1 4 years ago 2
@lyside1 Ahahahah commento stuoendo!!
vivacecilia 6 months ago
questa è un MACELLAIO..non un'insegnante di canto
lyside1 4 years ago
XD XD perchè un macellaio?
lampora 4 years ago
Comment removed
galehout 4 years ago
Please please please mother, do you want to be my mother??? Please!...
encoberta 4 years ago
SABIAS PALABRAS!!!
mariafsilva 4 years ago
Nice Video! Download and save this youtube video to your harddrive with _youtubex.com_
jennifer4091 4 years ago
Her enormous talent makes a lot more sense when you hear her mother...
adcian 4 years ago
What DVD is this???
CHerbek 4 years ago
Amazing mother!! no wonder she's one of the best!!
Mafecr 4 years ago
la adoro, y canta de maravilla
Venusgye 4 years ago
Her voice is bewitching!! and I really wish I could have a teacher like that,someone who cares,,,hard to find these days!
AMMARsedghi 4 years ago
No wonder she´s one of the best. People who describes her like a "bitch" are the ones who (probably since she started singing) told her she "was not good enough" just becouse she had that extra thing called will and talent. that got a name. ENVY. Thank god she had a mother who not only knows about singing, but about life too! God bless her..
simadrid2000 5 years ago
Gosh, but that woman glances like a mad person, just look at her when she says "You have to be the best"... Poor Cecilia !
temictocles88 5 years ago
omg ...no wonder she's such a bitch.
ciociosan 5 years ago
Cecilia? I bet you never met her, or you wouldn´t think (and unfortunately say) that. Go and inform yourself before you judge.
Saliaah 4 years ago
Do you refer to my posting? Do _you_ know Cecilia?
isimice 4 years ago
Agreed... I'd rather not have a mom like that:). I bet I wouldn't love music today if I'd had one of those.
urgrad03 4 years ago
??? I think, Cecilia's mother is wonderful, she not only managed to teach Cecilia how to use her wonderful voice, but she also achieved that Cecilia could stay herself. And Cecilia's true love for her mother shows that they were and are perfect for another. As teacher and student and as mother and daughter. I really admire Silvana and appreciate her life.
isimice 4 years ago 6
Que bonita es Cecilia, por supuesto canta como los dioses!
Ah, gracias suegra!!!
drjotais 5 years ago
Just purchase this DVD, if you're a singer or interested in classical singing- it's MUST!
LaBartoli 5 years ago
From what DVD was this video taken?
antoniomb87 5 years ago
This video was taken from the DVD "Cecilia Bartoli- A Portrait", and I highly recommend to buy it!
LaBartoli 5 years ago
oooh awsome :D thats so sweet seeing Cecilia being coached by her mother :D
Thanks!
LeRoiSoleilInt 5 years ago
WOW, Cecilia actually hits F6 in here
princesuperstar 5 years ago
thos were some high notes she reached they are my highest notes well a little lower than my highest
nicki121 5 years ago