How to Play the Piano : C Minor Scale for the Piano

[Silas150]

Thanks great video, i understand now

[TheEarthlyStar]

your piano is out of tune bro

[SyklSounds]

The rising inflection in his voice makes me want to strangle a baby goat.

[BonjourRich]

This is not the C harmonic minor, which is taught throughout the grades and does not contain the Bb (flat).

[Halfcan]

"E FLAT!!!!!!!!!" ill bill expert village for my new speakers after that.

[blondeeagles]

god these expert village videos are terrible...

[R3DCoke]

You know why it has a sadder kind of quality, cuz you got the scale wrong, fail.

[erniedoob]

Your subtext mistakenly says C-D-Eb-F-G-Ab-Eb-C, although I think the second Eb is really supposed to read Bb.

[R3DCoke]

@erniedoob its supposed to be a B, not even a Bb because in minor scales the 7th note is raised a semitone

[martinstatic]

@R3DCoke

In harmonic minor it's raised, natural minors it isnt. :)

[antonsdefrancua]

if i saw a finger it would be much better, but with the sound it is easy

[CellPhone79]

sup weird al

[jonnham]

Showing the fingering is a very important step and you missed it.

[Hutcarlingos]

if you watch his other lessons you won't need to see the fingers, imo

[cretin18]

omg

why are you talking to me like i'm a retard??

[Rachmanomaniac]

LOL so true!

[TyGUy2828]

virgin...

[northstar1804]

thanks for ur lessons ;0)....

[allstarplaya4000]

OMG Wierd Al Yankovic

[Triniti1101]

umm the c minor scale has E flat, A flat and a B flat but the B flat is neutralised because it doesnt sound right. your teaching the wrong stuff, it should go; c, d, e flat, f, g, a flat, b, c. the b flat isnt played! only teach it if you know it properly!

[baddiss74]

there are more than one minor scale so it depends on which one he is referring to...

[Triniti1101]

there are only 2 C minor scales, there is C minor harmonic and C minor Melodic. seeing as a melodic minor has a different pattern on the way down, and he played the same notes on the way up and the way down it suggests he is playing the harmonic minor, and he was playing it wrong...trust me i know what im on about because im grade 7 piano. and have taken grade 6 theory.(i say trying not to brag)

[bribiescaluis]

Sorry this might offend your knowledge, but there are 3 minor scales NATURAL, HARMONIC AND MELODIC and he is playin the natural c minor scale!!

[Triniti1101]

there may be but its so 'un-played' nowadays nobody plays it and nobody teaches it!!

[tegid699]

Correct! bribiescaluis (or the Aolian mode I know it as.

[shamille724]

wait i thought the melodic was like the harmonic going up and natural going down. or something. ahh i'm too confused! all i know is the one where you raise the 7th going up and then you play it normal going down. which is that?

[br00m35]

cant take this dude seriously but his piano playin is ok i guess

[shiva767]

He isnt playing it right it cannot start on any C and it is 2 octaves!

[bahanaa]

how about you are an idiot

[mymusicvideos1991]

I've seen some dumb stuff in my life, that takes the cake

[kazjooster]

this guy has such a bad technique at executing a scale you couldnt even balance a 20p on on his hand let alone a glass of water. In any piano execution especially scale passages your fingers should be the only ones doing the pyhsical work and not your hand!! or your build up tension in your upper hand. Its the only way to get a true free fast flowing execution. Plus he's missing the fundamental point of where to place your fourth fingers!! a must for beginners and good pianist.