There is a line that bothers me "Tell her to make me a cambric shirt/ Parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme/ without no seam or needlework" Without no seam? Would it be without a seam? without no seam means he want a seam/needlework on his shirt. I think that's not impossible to do....or am i wrong? Someone plz explain this to me!
OMG I JUST FINSIH READING IMPOSSIBLE BY NANCY WERLIN Which she wrote based on this book!!!OMG WHILE READING THAT BOOK I HAD DIS FRIGHTING FEELING THE WHOLE TIME!!!!!!
@ilSeerali It's actually not about a dying man, but it is written as a message to an ex girlfriend...the man in the song is saying that he will take her back if she performs a few impossible tasks for him, for example..."Tell her to make me a cambric shirt/ Parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme/ Without a seam or needle work......Tell her to wash it in yonder dry well/ Parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme/ Where water ne'er sprang, nor drop of rain fell"
This song does something to my soul, no matter who sings it. Its almost like watching ghosts from a very distant and sad past come to dance slowly before your eyes.
@ilSeerali Who is singing: the man or woman? Isn't SHE the one who is dying and needs a camberic shirt? Or should the song go "SHE once was a true love of mine"
@ilSeerali In one version, it is a warning, delivered to the desendents of a lass who scorned a fairy prince, and he warned that until the requirements the the song were met, all the girls of her line would be "a true love of mine". Until the the requirements were met, the girls would bear a curse-to concive a child and then die in childbirth before their 19th birthday-die, or sucumb to a drastic insanity. Personally, I like that version better, because it also tells how the last lass fixed it.
Actually this song was written to the listener. The man who wrote this song asked the listener to find his former lover (who is trying to get back with him) to do impossible tasks to win back his love such as sewing a shirt without a seam and then washing it in a dry well. and the refrain, Parsley, sage, rosemary and wine can not yet be explained but it is only seen in recent versions of this song.
@Wolfie8u yeah i read that the "parsley, sage, rosemary, and thyme" used to be "Sober and grave grows merry in time" "Every rose grows merry with time" or "There's never a rose grows fairer with time"
"The song tells the tale of a young man, who tells the listener to ask his former lover to perform for him a series of impossible tasks, such as making him a shirt without a seam and then washing it in a dry well, adding that if she completes these tasks he will take her back. Often the song is sung as a duet, with the woman then giving her lover a series of equally impossible tasks, promising to give him his seamless shirt once he has finished."
I would love for Lady Gaga to do a cover of this, then she should perform it in flamboyant Renaissance wear. This one is really good too, but I would love to see a pop version of this too.
did u know there is a book called " impossibe" wich is about this song?? I read it a while ago and just came across this song, i never knew it really existed, WOW awesome :)
did u know there is a book called " impossibe" wich is about this song?? I read it a while ago and just came across this song, i never knew it really existed, WOW awesome :)
@HeavensAngel131 I am currently reading it, i find it really interesting did you like it? Im in about the first hundred pages. The cover had the author talking about this song so i researched it and i love this song!
@idontliketotakeaname You mean in german... :D Dutch is the language which is spoken in netherlands ( I don't know the true name of that country in english :D)
If you listen to the lyrics, she wants him to do things that are impossible to do, like make a cambric shirt for her with no needle work nor seam, in order for him to be her true love.
u know, impossible is probably a good book, but the "impossible tasks" are stupid because they're not impossible. To make a shirt with no needle work or seam, tape the cloth. Cheap,, but will suffice, kinda cheating though. To plow a field with a goat horn and use only a single grain of corn to grow, just cut the corn into a million little pieces. After all they didn't say it had to grow. And the land between the sea thing, just buy an acre of land on an island. Easy as pie.
@ lalabeachbetty yeah between salt water and the sea strand? right sure your an idiot and island isn't between salt water and the sea strand. and you can easily weave the shirt, it has to be WEARABLE you know
Umm, tape the cloth? Seeing as how that would still create a seam (where the two edges are taped together), that wouldn't work, now would it? And besides, it seems to me that you're missing the heart-wrenching romance of both the book and song.
No to the first one soak wool in some way stick it together let it sit/dry it wont be pretty but it will work. For the corn and sand find a beach at low tide and smash the corn mix it with sand and spreadin sand..is it this version or another,,,oh well in one version it says plow with a goats horn attach the horn to a wheel barrel to plow then do the corn thing.
@Lalabeachbetty I agree with you. I really like the book (sorry I keep mentioning the book!!!), but it's obvious the tasks aren't impossible because they finish them.
@ArekkusuSeketsu ya know you can audition when your 15 now oh and do you have a vid of you singing the song i would very much like to hear you sing it
Oh yeah, Impossible by Nancy Werlin? I'm only half way through it but it is such a good book! Very sad, but it really does go deep into the real meaning of the song.
@dafizz0x0x the book is awesome (ugh, the book again!!!!!!!!!!!! i'm sooooo sorry!!! you guys are probably getting tired of my comments!! sorry! I just love the song sooo much!!!)
This is one of my favorite songs. I liked the orginal singers of Celtic Woman. I miss Hayley and Meav. I still like Celtic Woman thu and I will countine to listen to their music.
I never realized how much pain the one singing this song must be in. I used to identify with the person on the "receiving" end of this song, being told that you can only go back to your love if you complete tasks that you can never complete. Now that I have been hurt by my love, I understand the desire to be with her that this song represents, but the knowledge that you would only get hurt again, hence the impossible tasks.
I'm singing this song for my solo in Honors Choir, I'm the only one who can sing this song, none of the soprano's can. XD I love this song, so simple, says a story, and a sad song in a way. Longing. . .
Merlin, this is beautiful.. makes me think of the Founders Four. Just because I'm a nerd, but this is the most beautiful song I have ever heard.
pilotmoyafan 20 hours ago
I love the instrumental in the middle it's like a beautiful dream ^.^
ThimblesAndKisses1 2 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
Comment removed
ThimblesAndKisses1 3 days ago
Comment removed
ThimblesAndKisses1 3 days ago
I love this song. Itís great
equispeque 1 week ago
i play this on piano. i sound like crap compared to her.
xXBVB99Xx 2 weeks ago
So beautiful.
UnconventionalAqua 1 month ago
There is a line that bothers me "Tell her to make me a cambric shirt/ Parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme/ without no seam or needlework" Without no seam? Would it be without a seam? without no seam means he want a seam/needlework on his shirt. I think that's not impossible to do....or am i wrong? Someone plz explain this to me!
BumbleBeeKagamine 1 month ago
Comment removed
SleepBeauty00 1 month ago
beautiful voice!!!
dgdhqgdyukqud 2 months ago
Comment removed
dgdhqgdyukqud 2 months ago
love this song, i think of zelda when i hear it.
DGK201 3 months ago
Do you not just love this song? It reminds me of the first time I picked the Fluite.
PenDragonwater 3 months ago
Comment removed
eclipse7776 4 months ago
OMG I JUST FINSIH READING IMPOSSIBLE BY NANCY WERLIN Which she wrote based on this book!!!OMG WHILE READING THAT BOOK I HAD DIS FRIGHTING FEELING THE WHOLE TIME!!!!!!
azulestars123 5 months ago
@azulestars123 I think you mean song ^^ And OMG! I've read that book too! I recommend it to all my buddies :)
ChibiPandaful 5 months ago
@azulestars123 haha i like that book its very intense and interesting
SecretsnoSurprises 4 months ago
@azulestars123 That book is what brought me here :) I barely started it, but it's pretty good so far.
Skywriter5 3 months ago
Really awesome voice for an awesome song
ZanthiaKhala 6 months ago
@ilSeerali It's actually not about a dying man, but it is written as a message to an ex girlfriend...the man in the song is saying that he will take her back if she performs a few impossible tasks for him, for example..."Tell her to make me a cambric shirt/ Parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme/ Without a seam or needle work......Tell her to wash it in yonder dry well/ Parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme/ Where water ne'er sprang, nor drop of rain fell"
tcb19881 7 months ago 10
@tcb19881 nice. really nice.
dgdhqgdyukqud 2 months ago
Oh, man. Now I need to get the image out that I pictured while listening to this
Sheashay101 7 months ago
Beautiful. I used to sing this in Olympia Youth Chorus when I was a little girl.
RomanceIsToxic 9 months ago
This song does something to my soul, no matter who sings it. Its almost like watching ghosts from a very distant and sad past come to dance slowly before your eyes.
TheGmgirl77 10 months ago 28
Yes, it's an old beautiful ballad, I like it so much !
prolaznica021 10 months ago
Fallen in love with this song... Almost makes me cry... <3
spartan117mastrchief 11 months ago
Fallen in love with this song... Almost makes me cry... <3
spartan117mastrchief 11 months ago
Comment removed
spartan117mastrchief 11 months ago
Comment removed
spartan117mastrchief 11 months ago
Comment removed
spartan117mastrchief 11 months ago
@ilSeerali Who is singing: the man or woman? Isn't SHE the one who is dying and needs a camberic shirt? Or should the song go "SHE once was a true love of mine"
lizclegg 1 year ago
i could like to translate this to spanish.... how i do it
or where i find it.....?
i love how she sing
wilssy001 1 year ago
Scarborough = ? in french :/
Lilinou35 1 year ago
@Lilinou35
Scarborough is a town in England :)
prolaznica021 10 months ago
@prolaznica021 Ok thank you :) Verry beautiful !! I Love England (I'm near to England --> Bretagne)
Lilinou35 10 months ago
I only need these lyrics, they're enough for me... this was completely beautiful
P4R4C0 1 year ago
I wanna try to create a faster version :) with altered lyrics :D hopefully i can pull it off
DemonWolf16 1 year ago
@ilSeerali In one version, it is a warning, delivered to the desendents of a lass who scorned a fairy prince, and he warned that until the requirements the the song were met, all the girls of her line would be "a true love of mine". Until the the requirements were met, the girls would bear a curse-to concive a child and then die in childbirth before their 19th birthday-die, or sucumb to a drastic insanity. Personally, I like that version better, because it also tells how the last lass fixed it.
starchildbladesinger 1 year ago
love this song! nya!
rubynekogirl 1 year ago
Actually this song was written to the listener. The man who wrote this song asked the listener to find his former lover (who is trying to get back with him) to do impossible tasks to win back his love such as sewing a shirt without a seam and then washing it in a dry well. and the refrain, Parsley, sage, rosemary and wine can not yet be explained but it is only seen in recent versions of this song.
Wolfie8u 1 year ago
@Wolfie8u oopsie meant Thyme not wine.
Wolfie8u 1 year ago
@Wolfie8u yeah i read that the "parsley, sage, rosemary, and thyme" used to be "Sober and grave grows merry in time" "Every rose grows merry with time" or "There's never a rose grows fairer with time"
tylove110 1 year ago
Comment removed
PeaceGirl2137 1 year ago
Thumbs up, if you get lost in this song.. cause I do.
StuartPotJR 1 year ago
Im siginging this song for a solo on November 6th 2010 and i cant wait for it to come.
TheWeirdbutawsome 1 year ago
"The song tells the tale of a young man, who tells the listener to ask his former lover to perform for him a series of impossible tasks, such as making him a shirt without a seam and then washing it in a dry well, adding that if she completes these tasks he will take her back. Often the song is sung as a duet, with the woman then giving her lover a series of equally impossible tasks, promising to give him his seamless shirt once he has finished."
as quoted from wikipedia
banrighKeltoidrui 1 year ago
actually scarborough fair is a traditional english ballad and earliest versions can be traced back over 300 years ago
banrighKeltoidrui 1 year ago
actually scarborough fair is a traditional english ballad and earliest versionc can be traced back over 300 years ago
banrighKeltoidrui 1 year ago
actually scarborough fair is a traditional english ballad and earliest versionc can be traced bak over 300 years ago
banrighKeltoidrui 1 year ago
I must have heard this sung by dozens upon dozens of people... Hayley's voice is easily the best I've ever heard singing this.
Shultzy999 1 year ago
@ilSeerali her name is hayley? thats a nice name :)
Hipboy125 1 year ago
I would love for Lady Gaga to do a cover of this, then she should perform it in flamboyant Renaissance wear. This one is really good too, but I would love to see a pop version of this too.
artsydude8900 1 year ago
This is awesome, thank you.
SherryLea 1 year ago
did u know there is a book called " impossibe" wich is about this song?? I read it a while ago and just came across this song, i never knew it really existed, WOW awesome :)
HeavensAngel131 1 year ago
did u know there is a book called " impossibe" wich is about this song?? I read it a while ago and just came across this song, i never knew it really existed, WOW awesome :)
HeavensAngel131 1 year ago
@HeavensAngel131 I am currently reading it, i find it really interesting did you like it? Im in about the first hundred pages. The cover had the author talking about this song so i researched it and i love this song!
janefaimeY100 1 year ago
just to get my point across people saying this is a beautiful song,, it is very VERY sad, it's about death :P
ilSeerali 1 year ago
hmm its a song BY Simon & Garfunkel that's been played by Celtic woman. but is a good version of the original song.
mptsliakos35 1 year ago
this song was written in a book that i read :)
fireloverbc13 1 year ago
Beatiful voice
Beatiful Song
jocumar117 1 year ago 2
Bellissimo! Compliments!! d.
dnadsy52 1 year ago
She has BEAUTIFUL voice. Very nice. I like your choice of font effects.
Keetluver11 1 year ago 3
*-* we used to sing this song in primary school
glad I found it again <3
O0lotta0O 1 year ago
what WC?
YuGiOhGXFanChannel31 1 year ago
do you know what you've written just?
she said CW,
and you said WC
that means toilet in Dutch
idontliketotakeaname 1 year ago
@idontliketotakeaname ok
YuGiOhGXFanChannel31 1 year ago
@idontliketotakeaname You mean in german... :D Dutch is the language which is spoken in netherlands ( I don't know the true name of that country in english :D)
Ocrana111 1 year ago
@Ocrana111
no, realy i'm dutch WC means Water Closet
and it's dutch/nederlands
idontliketotakeaname 1 year ago
@xXQuietwhispersXx ok
YuGiOhGXFanChannel31 1 year ago
ok ^^
YuGiOhGXFanChannel31 1 year ago
who's sings it, Celtic Woman or Hayley Westenra?
YuGiOhGXFanChannel31 1 year ago
hayley westenra sings it but i think the band is called celtic women
alexandralouise1 1 year ago
Hayley but this is when she was still in CW
haidiepnguyen12 1 year ago
I love this song!!!! I just finished a book called impossible that was based on this song!!!!!!!
sixstringmusic6 1 year ago
Comment removed
butterfly1289 2 years ago
If you listen to the lyrics, she wants him to do things that are impossible to do, like make a cambric shirt for her with no needle work nor seam, in order for him to be her true love.
KeiyarlaDraga 2 years ago
I know!!! It's kinda sad when she says "He once was a true love of mine"
sixstringmusic6 1 year ago
i hope u know this is not there song its just a remake its very good
fredhascome 2 years ago
The greatest love song.
composer unknown.
CaprimusicGLP 2 years ago 3
So beautiful.
RoseBurgundy 2 years ago
u know, impossible is probably a good book, but the "impossible tasks" are stupid because they're not impossible. To make a shirt with no needle work or seam, tape the cloth. Cheap,, but will suffice, kinda cheating though. To plow a field with a goat horn and use only a single grain of corn to grow, just cut the corn into a million little pieces. After all they didn't say it had to grow. And the land between the sea thing, just buy an acre of land on an island. Easy as pie.
Lalabeachbetty 2 years ago
@ lalabeachbetty yeah between salt water and the sea strand? right sure your an idiot and island isn't between salt water and the sea strand. and you can easily weave the shirt, it has to be WEARABLE you know
kitten1323 2 years ago
the wool shirt thing i told LALABEACHBETTY works is wearable if not a lil' hot though
xMonkeyClimbsx 2 years ago
Umm, tape the cloth? Seeing as how that would still create a seam (where the two edges are taped together), that wouldn't work, now would it? And besides, it seems to me that you're missing the heart-wrenching romance of both the book and song.
IvyLupusXKariCatta 2 years ago
Soak wool and kinda stick it together its not pretty but it works.
xMonkeyClimbsx 2 years ago
No to the first one soak wool in some way stick it together let it sit/dry it wont be pretty but it will work. For the corn and sand find a beach at low tide and smash the corn mix it with sand and spreadin sand..is it this version or another,,,oh well in one version it says plow with a goats horn attach the horn to a wheel barrel to plow then do the corn thing.
xMonkeyClimbsx 2 years ago
@Lalabeachbetty I agree with you. I really like the book (sorry I keep mentioning the book!!!), but it's obvious the tasks aren't impossible because they finish them.
sixstringmusic6 1 year ago
When I go to try out for American Idol when I'm eighteen, This is so the song I'm going to sing -w-
I've been practiceing everyday
ArekkusuSeketsu 2 years ago 27
Good luck!
rvgmuhs07 2 years ago
@ArekkusuSeketsu good luck!!
sixstringmusic6 1 year ago
@ArekkusuSeketsu Good luck!
rvgmuhs07 1 year ago
@ArekkusuSeketsu good luck :)
DemonWolf16 1 year ago
@ArekkusuSeketsu ya know you can audition when your 15 now oh and do you have a vid of you singing the song i would very much like to hear you sing it
WORMIE4456W 11 months ago
theres a book based off this song, its really good!
dafizz0x0x 2 years ago 4
Oh yeah, Impossible by Nancy Werlin? I'm only half way through it but it is such a good book! Very sad, but it really does go deep into the real meaning of the song.
music4me2Iwant 2 years ago 3
@dafizz0x0x The book is amazing! Everybody should read it!
HeAvEn17100 2 years ago 2
yeah I read it in like 2 days, amazing book
kitten1323 2 years ago 3
@dafizz0x0x yeah IMPOSSIBLE!!!! I <3 that book
xMonkeyClimbsx 2 years ago
@xMonkeyClimbsx I love that book too!!!!! I just read it (as says my other comment!!!)
sixstringmusic6 1 year ago
@dafizz0x0x the book is awesome (ugh, the book again!!!!!!!!!!!! i'm sooooo sorry!!! you guys are probably getting tired of my comments!! sorry! I just love the song sooo much!!!)
sixstringmusic6 1 year ago
This is one of my favorite songs. I liked the orginal singers of Celtic Woman. I miss Hayley and Meav. I still like Celtic Woman thu and I will countine to listen to their music.
Elizabeth52101 2 years ago 2
it sounds sad to me, its deep.... though it is beautiful :]
<3 Amynn
Amynn1993 2 years ago 2
...0:00 To 3:14 More Than Beautiful...
MiguelAngelValenciaG 2 years ago 3
hayley is an angel, or at least she has the voice of one :D
ethalinia 2 years ago 39
I never realized how much pain the one singing this song must be in. I used to identify with the person on the "receiving" end of this song, being told that you can only go back to your love if you complete tasks that you can never complete. Now that I have been hurt by my love, I understand the desire to be with her that this song represents, but the knowledge that you would only get hurt again, hence the impossible tasks.
rvgmuhs07 2 years ago 4
I get what ur getting at but the tasks actually arent that hard
xMonkeyClimbsx 2 years ago
I'm singing this song for my solo in Honors Choir, I'm the only one who can sing this song, none of the soprano's can. XD I love this song, so simple, says a story, and a sad song in a way. Longing. . .
19652703 2 years ago
I'm learning this song in orchestra, I'm the only person that can sing to it. I love this song :) Sad but Heavenly :)
smm2cool1 2 years ago
the music is soo beutiful heavenly and sad.:(
TheMythsrock 2 years ago
Am I the only person who thinks that this is a sad song?
mrsellemby 2 years ago
Sooo lovely! Great job on this!
meadowlarkkids 2 years ago 2
It´s wonderful! The rose is really beautiful!!!!
HollywoodGirl095 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
queensryche does it much better
zsefvb9 2 years ago
i love this song, it's simple and relaxing.
hayley is awesome
for one of your first video it's great!!!
kitsunefernandez 2 years ago 3
i love hayley <3
penguinfox529 2 years ago 2
Enjoy!!
MichelleXxLoveXx 2 years ago 4