Ferrari 458 Italia v Porsche 911 GT3 RS - evo Magazine

[TrippySkippy1]

Ive never lusted after a 911, never will.

[t8trg8tr]

Does Chris Harris have another job besides working for EVO? I'd be shocked if he could afford a Ferrari as a journalist.

[golferchin76]

for a moment i thought i heard "it's still got a stick between your legs"!!!

[devriln]

what does he mean by "6s" ? The f1 doesn't run a high 6 quarter mile

[Juzh123]

@devriln

he means 0-100 mph.

[TheSterlingSound]

4:52 "I suddenly remembered that I own a Ferrari 512 at the moment". LOL like you would forget!!

[eolovento]

I'm italian but ferrari haven't on me any impact. love porsche all life. classic passion for sports car. no much technologies and a design impressed in my heart

[kneelandpray1]

Ferrari 458 (Italia or Spider) is the best supercar in the world!!!

[red33m23]

I get his point...the famous Ferrari noise is not an actual engine noise but some settings on the exhaust

[fedegrass]

Ferrari 458 = the best car in the world ;-)

[XLR8Guitars]

y would they compare these cars? they r totally in different classes. you ned like the gt2 rs instead

[danpescatori]

i dont understand how is fucking possible compare a ferrari with a porsche ...i dont know...people is crazy...unbelievable....

[gastonracing17]

Manual gearbox :) Porsche forever!

[TheBakerSkater1996]

i have to correct this guy, the 458 has a 4.5L V8, thats why its called the 458 not a 4.4L

[1DUCR]

GT3 IS THE BEST DRIVER'S CAR IN THE WORLD, PERIOD. NOTHING COMES CLOSE TO THE PURE MECHANICAL EXPERIENCE OF IT. FERRARI AND LAMBO WITH ALL THEIR ELECTRONIC GIZMOS ARE FOR POSERS........................­................

[QuadraroImp]

Ferrari >>> all.

[itssimpleiwinyoulose]

Soo whey even compare a porsche to a ferrari when this guy is the biggest ferrari fanboy in the world theres no chance he will ever admit a porsche is better

[jayman81424]

@itssimpleiwinyoulose no hes not..he has a gt3 rs 4.0 himself..and have you not read his article when he completely thrashes Ferrari

[Buttnut105]

I think I'll take both and I think someone in the midst of buying a 458, if he hadn't had a Porsche already in the garage, would agree.

[NottinghamForest22]

Ferrari for me.

[danpescatori]

is more beautiful fiat Panda then porsche...absolutely...

[NickSullivan123]

Who else didnt get a 458 for christmas?

[evanpan23]

Evo is gay!

[VodafoneMcLaren92]

he said 4.4 litre...

[altimgamr]

either way u really cant lose here

[theydontwantit]

only fuckers say that porsche are common ! if they weren't stupid, they'll know that a carrera is common, but not a GT3 RS or a GT 2 ! Everybody knows the best sportive car in the world is the GT3...radical, efficeint and homogeneous

[96ToxicAvenger]

@theydontwantit I like the GT2 RS myself,but agreed! Ive personally only seen one orange and black GT 3RS ever...and that was in Columbus Ohio...

[ozekiozeki1]

Truth be told, I'm an automobile fan and when I see a GT3 next to a 458, I instantly get pulled towards the Ferrari. You can't argue the attractiveness of Ferrari. No one is doubting the greatness of Porsche, but you must know why people love Ferraris more, they are rarer, have an exotic design, whereas Porsche pretty much uses the same shape, a very good shape yes, but noobs on the street thinks your 997 Carrera is the same as a 993 Carrera. I love the 458 because it's a piece of art. Period.

[MegaVolks]

Porsche all the way

[eventlog123]

458 VS 911 ...why doesn't he drive the 911 in the clip? The quality is really bad in comparison to other EVO magazine clips.

[sackmaster]

I don't know why, but this guy ruins both cars for me.... Maybe he should stop talking like he was the better engineer for the job......

[Yeyochan]

Am i the only one getting those huge fucking ads on the left side of the screen covering almost half of the video ?

[felipe270782]

porsche!!!!!

[darkzeusk12]

Some of you said that ferrari is the king .... if you want ! But most of you said that Porsche is already the same since 70's. You are just jealous because Porsche make cars that everybody could buy !! Ferrari is more than 100 000 £ whereas Porsche can be average 20 000£ easy !

There are 2 exceptionnal cars, with so many difference ....

[danpescatori]

Ferrari is the King of the Kings...there is no match...no match...

[maximilianboo]

should be 458 vs. gt2 rs... now isn't that a better price range

[ladskjlasdj]

Love his reviews! !!

[sbliss554]

458 looks prettier, but I much rather have the 911. I want a drivers car.

[Thr998]

@sbliss554 the 911 is almost 60 000 punds cheaper?

[danpescatori]

porsche are al the same since 70's is like a sport VW beetle...boring boring....

[MrPatschn]

@danpescatori Wrong, to read everywhere "Porsche looks like a Beetle" that is borring. Just for you know its the concept of Porsche, and really if you compare Ferraris from the 80's to the Ferraris from today, its like the same.The front is like the same. Back to Porsche, its tradition by the Porsche company, so why should they change it?

[Thr998]

@danpescatori but cheap and fast but dosent make sense as long as the gt-r is in production.

[asd19951000]

what is he talking about??? The Ferrari's noise by far the best noise in the whole world

[miroslav1o1]

@asd19951000 I think that best sound,there are three.1 Porsche Carrera Gt,2 Maserati Gran Tourismo MC Stradale and F 430 Scuderia.....

[miroslav1o1]

@miroslav1o1 And yes,Pagani Zonda R..

[sasajungic89]

@asd19951000 What Chris means is Ferrari doesn't have much intake noise as much as Porsche

[Porschefanatic100]

@asd19951000 The best noise ever got the V10 of the Porsche Carrera GT !

[stefanpetrov8]

@Porschefanatic100

Or the lexus lfa :D

[RhythmEngineering]

@Porschefanatic100 the best noise comes from my 1968 datsun , it's so complex . You can hear noises from every part of my car

[StormedbyPizza]

@RhythmEngineering my '84 944 does the same :) Love every single sound

[123qcr]

@Porschefanatic100 of course you would say that your name is porschefanatic

[LstAlph]

@asd19951000 ...of Honda's In-Line-4 and japan motorbikes.

It's a shame when V8 sounds like a whistlin pussy.

Don't know why and who created that piece of somewhat, and what's more intresting - for what, cause we had pretty F430, very Italian and traditional (what we can't say about 458 - it's japan, french, whatever but not italian), very close to 360 Modena (that makes feel of a brand unity).

Shameful page of the Ferrary history... 458, FF

[LOVESPORTSUPERCARS]

@LstAlph You are obviously either Insane or retarded. Maybe both

[Ascendancy25]

@asd19951000 never heard of the Carrera GT, huh

[MrPeteEa]

@asd19951000 No, that would be the Carrera GT or Pagina Zonda...

[TheCaliforniaAirsoft]

@MrPeteEa tots the pagani dude

[MrPeteEa]

@TheCaliforniaAirsoft Lol yeah oops....

[scratchy996]

@asd19951000 that's just marketing , in reality Ferraris sound like crap. Carrera GT , Zonda , AMG V8 engines and the Ford GT sound a lot better.

[blahblop123]

@asd19951000 have you heard about the lexus lfa ?? noble m600 ??... maybe a pagani zonda ?? no ?

[asd19951000]

@blahblop123 yes I have heard all of them and I like them very much but I prefer this one

[blahblop123]

@asd19951000 personal preference is personal preference.. thats fair, but remember, that is synthetic noise and you might wanna give the rest another listen, just to make yourself 100% sure

[haarsje]

@asd19951000 1995. Says it all.

[veyronman]

@asd19951000 the 360CS was the pinnacle of V8 Ferrari sound IMO.

[00haze]

@veyronman 4 sure. Nothing made by anyone comes close

[DeVron001]

@asd19951000 listen to the ferrari 355 and comment again lol

[rasqo3]

@asd19951000

did you hear the gt3rs noise in real life?

And everyone got his one taste.

[asd19951000]

@rasqo3 well I love this sound and I don't care for what you say

[Ne0c225]

@asd19951000 How about the sound of pagani zonda r? do you think it's good.

[AttaboyIII]

@asd19951000 Nooo..... no no no no. The best noise is the Lamborghini Gallardo's V10. No other opinions are necessary...

[asd19951000]

@AttaboyIII well it's a very good noise. Also Aventador noise is exellent

[randomdutch1]

a porsche gt3 rs vs a 458 ????????

thats like going with a knife to a gun fight

[vithaj92]

@randomdutch1 How creative of you, watched top gear lately? Haha

[randomdutch1]

@vithaj92 no why?

[vithaj92]

@randomdutch1 Thats exactly what Jeremy Clarkson said in an episode.

[randomdutch1]

@vithaj92 witch one?:D

[vithaj92]

@randomdutch1 Can't remember, search for "top gear 458, gt3 rs, mercedes sls" or something like that and you'll find it I think.

[Philipracer]

Porsche sucks!!!!!!!!!!

[limchinhuang]

@AkatsukiRei Here come 7 speed manual 991.

[vishr]

it is the best the porsche 911 gt3 rs so it is good i have it at home

[Ktmzqw]

@vishr hope to see you GT3 videos soon

[AmSat15]

Porsche 911 GT2 RS. Please.

[gogutzy]

you could have washed the cars....

[aminevich]

@gogutzy wash the car?! WHY? If you have time to wash car like this, then that's less time you have to drive it. Just saying! :-)

[veyronman]

@gogutzy I'm not sure they had a water supply to clean the cars with out there in the middle of the countryside....

[christoabbe]

Keep your hands on the wheel and look at the road. you're taking a joy ride in another mans ferrari.

[Kevin172737]

I won't get tired of that either but I will get tired of the beeping every time u do it

[haloaum]

this is probably one of the last ferrari road test chris harris has done..

Ferrari wont let his test any ferraris after he spilled the beans on ferrari..

Ferrari make journalists sign disclosure docs before testing any ferrari.. they decide what can be said and what cant be said... and also they need to know before hand which trach their cars will be tested at so they can tune the car according to the track.. they have also sent 2 cars to tests. one for track and another for drag race... dodgy !

[VanKrixsz101]

i hate Porsche!!!

[SatanicTerror]

@VanKrixsz101 why? can you give me a good reason?

[VanKrixsz101]

@SatanicTerror because of the body style.. .every time i search GTR ,458 italia.. 911 is always their !!!

[SatanicTerror]

@VanKrixsz101 but in quality and speed (in corners!) they are nearly unbreakable.......body style, ok, not everybody has to like this style :D......but I think Prosche looks very great, but thats my opinion about that^^

[mrlionkingTV]

@VanKrixsz101 fuck you

[AccanitoxVaScO4ever]

Ferrari seems to be a fighter airplane:)

[AccanitoxVaScO4ever]

Porsche always wm käfer.

[AccanitoxVaScO4ever]

FERRARI THE MONSTER. porsche the toy.

[BestCarSound]

@AccanitoxVaScO4ever Exactly opposite, Ferrari helps gadgets, Porsche - just you & car!

[AccanitoxVaScO4ever]

@BestCarSound FERRARI 430 NOVITEC, FERRARI 599 GTO, FERRARI ENZO, FERRARI F50... the is can not be compared! these are sports cars.

[JoneeB]

one of each please

[carcrazzy247]

i would like it, but the guys voice it so boring, at least be driving the car when ur saying it

[MrPorsche91730]

I know eh. I have never seen a more one sided compairson. GT3 150,000 458 280,000. Crazy stuped compairson

[TheSycaman]

Why wouldn't you put either a Turbo S or GT2 RS against that car?

[dragonman785]

which is better 2011 458 italia or 2011 enzo?

[henkie221ify]

even the gt3 RS 4.0 won't win against the 458

[tarek307]

The ferrari is nice, but come on..we all know you can't drive it every day, its a nightmare service wise, the Porsche is just more RAW..and less flashy!

[armenecaotb]

it"s like comparing mule with horse.you decide!!!

[NottinghamForest22]

I would take the GT3 RS. Porsche > Ferrari

[Aerosmithfan507]

@NottinghamForest22 Ferrari kicks porsche's ass. My family actually has a porsche and i would still much rather have a Ferrari 458 ANY day

[NottinghamForest22]

@Aerosmithfan507 probably got a porsche boxster lol.

[Aerosmithfan507]

@NottinghamForest22 yea, actually a boxter S but is still a porsche, were looking at getting a 911 Targa 4S

[Shoryuken4u]

Could someone please confirm who has won the most races in motorsport out of Porsche and Ferrari?!

Thanks.

[chuckaloz]

@Shoryuken4u Porsche by far.

[ferrari7060]

@Shoryuken4u ferrari all the way 16 f1 championships porsche only has like 1

[Phillythekid86]

@ferrari7060 "motorsport" and "formula 1" are NOT the same thing. Just throwing that out there.

[XxTCOBBxX720xX]

GT2 vs 599

[cokecola196]

if someone came up to you and was to give you one of these cars for free youd be crazy not to take the 458 that said sadley the porsche is probaly the the car

[austino775]

i like the porsche but the ferrari is on a whole new level. the 458 is the new benchmark in the supercar world where the porsche is just a stripped down version of the same old car,

[2dONiHAb3]

0:01



[seroyer2]

They will never, ever put real down force into a road car, the reason why is that down force kills gas mileage. In today's world if you want to build a car and sell it in the U.S. it has to even for Ferrari at least get 20mpg on the highway. This "downforce" that they talk about is really just a anti lift kit at 200mph.

[MrPorsche91730]

what a crappy video 3 felt like 3 min in the ferrari and 1 min in the porsche and they just made fun of it fuck evo fuck evo

[Morbriq]

carrera gt vs. italia. that would be fair!

[shobin05]

@Morbriq you do realize that the carrera gt is 8 years old and nearly three times the price...

[Morbriq]

@shobin05 yes but the performance is similar

[niels5087]

@Morbriq 599 gto vs carrera gt would be fair.

[KbrziHD]

@Morbriq GT2 RS is faster than the GT. Smart one

[hjdebel]

Porsche is way much cooler

[Ceetvair]

this Ferrari is one of the most ugly cars ever made 

[astoesz4]

@Ceetvair just like your girlfriend. wait, you probably dont have a girlfriend.

[MrDerprinz3]

Porsche way better ! Germans rule in automobile industry ..

[theJTW42]

zr1 is better than both just sayin

[AlumarsX]

@theJTW42 No.

[ferrari7060]

@theJTW42 the zr1 is shit i bet justin bieber has one just sayin

[platinumguitar]

@ferrari7060 Justin Bieber has a Ferrari F430!

[ferrari7060]

@platinumguitar then i guess hes not completly gay after all then

[platinumguitar]

@ferrari7060 He isn't at all :)

[The0rangePanda]

@theJTW42 No.

[derbigpr500]

@theJTW42 Gotta love stupid guys like you know absolutely nothing about cars...ill never understand how americans can possibly know so little about cars. ZR-1 is a complete piece of shit. The only reason people who are naive like you think its good is because of that lap time at nurburgring, which was btw done with road illegal semi-slick tires, special track engine mapping and specially tuned suspension for nurburgring. And it STILL is slower than 458 despite having 100 hp more.

[derbigpr500]

@theJTW42 Not to mention how more advanced Ferrari and Porsche are. ZR-1 probably feels like a beefed up 1980's car. Fast on straight, and feels like crap in corners. I'm not even gonna start about the looks and the build quality...Ferrari uses better quality plastic for their mud guards than chevrolet uses to make corvetters interior.

Sitting from 458 or 911 into ZR-1 would be like going 30 years into the past. Keep your shitty muscle cars at your american roads, we have real cars in europe.

[xXThermobaricXx]

Porche - ugly

Ferrari - Gorgeous

[maximus14433]

@xXThermobaricXx porsche is not ugly.. just isn't nearly as desirable as a ferrari.

[MrBigolnuts]

@freediver4life hear hear, he rambles on about bullshit for so long, its like hes sitting there ready the bloody owners manuals!

[freediver4life]

dude talks too much...shut up and let the cars do the talking!

[DrZsbl]

@freediver4life No.

[TheGMCBoii]

they should have the used the 911 turbo s pdk. Am i the only one who thinks the 458 is boring?

[TheGMCBoii]

they should have the used the 911 turbo s pdk.

[SaveNurburgring]

Porsche = cute . Ferrari = sinfull .

[ReaperScope13]

@SaveNurburgring PORSCHE FOR women ferrari for men

[MrPorsche91730]

@ReaperScope13 Maybe a Porsche boxter. But if you compair a Porsche of the same price like the gt2rs, or a turbo S, they handle better, brakes better and and faster, except for top speed. So you are calling the car that is faster for women, right, cause that makes sense. ferraries are for posers who want to get noticed in their bright loud gino mobile. Yea and I guess it was all women who got all those 25,0000 wins for them in racing eh lol.

[ReaperScope13]

@MrPorsche91730 if a man can afford a ferrari then he can buy hes girl a porsche

[MrPorsche91730]

@ReaperScope13 Then I guess the girl would get the faster car. Just because it is loud and flashy does not mean it is better

[ReaperScope13]

@MrPorsche91730 well you will be mostly driving a car on the real life streets so what does that mean ferrari is better

[MrPorsche91730]

@ReaperScope13 One thing I have to say is this is the most one sided compairson I have ever seen. And that says a lot when you own 300+ mags. You want attention. You are not going to take your car to the track. But I would think the turbo S would be a blast, it goes from 0-30 mph in 1 sec flat!, 0-60mph 2.5, and has better brakes. Someone said somthing I could have not said better myself, ferrari is a status car, Porsche is a race car. And a Ferrari 280,000$ uses chrysler nav system lmao

[ReaperScope13]

@MrPorsche91730 i know that ferraris a status car but thats why i love it its about being increadibly cool looking when somebody looks at it he prob thinks holy shit that guys rich and at the same time the ferraris a great supercar which doesnt let down against other cars

[MrPorsche91730]

@ReaperScope13 You have a point for sure, you will without a doubt get more attention then Porsches. The thing with Porsche though is the best part is hidden in the engine bay. You are good man for not argueing the fact that Porsches are faster, in certian aspects. All Porsche pretty much look the same though you have a point there. Unless you love Porsches like me you appriciate how the shape has evolved over the years. No offence but I dont see any old ferrari lines on any ferrari

[MrPorsche91730]

@ReaperScope13 You have a point for sure, you will without a doubt get more attention then Porsches. The thing with Porsche though is the best part is hidden in the engine bay. You are good man for not argueing the fact that Porsches are faster, in certian aspects. All Porsche pretty much look the same though you have a point there. Unless you love Porsches like me you appriciate how the shape has evolved over the years. No offence but I dont see any old ferrari lines on the 458.

[ReaperScope13]

@MrPorsche91730 yea man i agree

[chuckaloz]

@ReaperScope13 what do you drive?

[ReaperScope13]

@chuckaloz i drive the mercedes benz s 600 2010

[Aerosmithfan507]

@SaveNurburgring Porsche: simple and stupid  Ferrari: loaded and smart

[chuckaloz]

@Aerosmithfan507 stupid?

[Aerosmithfan507]

@chuckaloz No?

[Aerosmithfan507]

@Aerosmithfan507 agreed

[MichaelMellijor]

i like the ferrari better.. precision technology.

[Kamas88]

My heart is going to porsche, but brain to ferrari, what should i do ?

[mafiacool007]

@Kamas88 listen your heart first

[SnowboardA51]

u can tell he likes the Ferrari

[an50331]

i just came across this today, chris harris's thoughts on ferrari rigging test cars, its pretty interesting

m3forum.net/m3forum/archive/in­dex.php/t-354330.html

[luciferrrrr]

Porsche 911 GT cars all the way!

[3089280288]

Why doesn't Porsche have a model above the 911?

[DJVBasil]

@3089280288 THEY DONT NEED ONE.

[Chrissi525]

Ferrari is a fucking Fail

[TheRIGEL1982]

comparing these two cars is like comparing chocolate and coffee...very different and both indispensable..it's impossible to choose between them

[TheMrmurcielagolp640]

 i saw a porsche gt3 but it was blue with red vinyls and red rims it was roarin omgg