A year (or more) later, I still maintain that this is first-rate musically and dramatically from both singers: the controlled energy, the fine phrasing and vivid dynamics. On a par, I believe, with the incandescent L. Price-C. Valetti Salzburg Festival performance of 1960. For me, it makes the libretto believable.
Both singers magnificent! Very fine phrasing, dynamics, energy, etc. As to Stich-Randall's acting, I found it rather compelling. I think this is the view of Anna that she really loves Giovanni (who was a welcome intruder although she pretends the opposite) & cares little for Ottavio. If one subscribes to this view, then imagine her feelings at this point -- she is terribly shocked at her father's death yet also distracted, disoriented and deceitful, groping her way thru to save face!
@LobsngDmchoi This is what I have always thought. I have always believed the lady invited him in!! When he kills her father, when she believes the opposite would happen, she becomes bent on revenge. Of course the libretto puts paid to my little theory!!!!
Alva is magnificent...Stitch-Randall is stiff as a singing statue! Alva is a full fledged expressive human being! Both singers are being asked to be somewhat formal and wooden by the director! For those who think Mozart is too frufru for them, they only need listen to this intense, dark aria to be proven wrong! There is nothing trivial in the emotions expressed nor the cautionary tale that underpins the entire opera. Both singers convey the necessary sobriety! Bravo Alva!
A year (or more) later, I still maintain that this is first-rate musically and dramatically from both singers: the controlled energy, the fine phrasing and vivid dynamics. On a par, I believe, with the incandescent L. Price-C. Valetti Salzburg Festival performance of 1960. For me, it makes the libretto believable.
LobsngDmchoi 8 months ago
Quelle belle élégance !!! Deux beaux chanteurs ...
Merci pour le post .
francesca7564 9 months ago
Two splendid voices ~there is nothing as vital as a live recording ;
Mr. Alva was delightful in comic roles as well as in serious one´s (as this wonderful video proofs )
ingriddoppler 1 year ago
Both singers magnificent! Very fine phrasing, dynamics, energy, etc. As to Stich-Randall's acting, I found it rather compelling. I think this is the view of Anna that she really loves Giovanni (who was a welcome intruder although she pretends the opposite) & cares little for Ottavio. If one subscribes to this view, then imagine her feelings at this point -- she is terribly shocked at her father's death yet also distracted, disoriented and deceitful, groping her way thru to save face!
LobsngDmchoi 2 years ago
@LobsngDmchoi This is what I have always thought. I have always believed the lady invited him in!! When he kills her father, when she believes the opposite would happen, she becomes bent on revenge. Of course the libretto puts paid to my little theory!!!!
phoenix4165 9 months ago
Perfect!!!!
Thanks for sharing.
Julien
PopoliDiTessalia 2 years ago 3
@PopoliDiTessalia
N'est ce pas Julien ?
Bisous
Fan
francesca7564 9 months ago
Great as always. His voice is rich, smooth. warm, and he has a wondelful technique. A true Maestro.
blichilde 2 years ago 8
I love him as D.O. without a wig! Sounds wonderful!
schmup53 2 years ago
Bravo Maestro!!! what an excellent rendition
Torquemada0 2 years ago 2
Beautiful Expression!!! and Beautiful stage presence and style!!!
as usual touching in the your beautiful performance this is ever Surprising of the Grandmaster LUIGI ALVA!!!
BRAVISSIMO Caro e Grande Maestro!!!
Grazie Mille!!! Cara* VivaTenors*
5mila**********************
laoniricArte1 2 years ago 4
@laoniricArte1
Je dis comme toi belle amie ...
Francesca
francesca7564 9 months ago
Kievest 2 years ago 11
Bellissimo!!!...ti viene voglia di cantarlo subito. Grazie tante. Roberto
robertocasitenore 2 years ago 2
Great performance. Thank you for sharing!
fairlytaleofnewyork 2 years ago
Fantastic performance! Thanks for sharing and posting it!
angelofbebop 2 years ago 3
So it is possible to express great feelings and to sing perfectly... great !
KILLERADVICE 2 years ago 3
Great Performance!!! Thanks for the share.
Grandma mary
Fr3derick 2 years ago