Added: 5 years ago
From: SheetMetalWorkers
Views: 1,337
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (17)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This guy is a real American hero! He is the real deal and not some phony online philosopher; he put it on the line overseas, at home, and on Capitol Hill. Three cheers for Keith!

  • Your model of the effect a union has on the economy is off. Companies such as Wal-mart mark their goods overseas. They also are the worlds biggest labor rights violator. Everyone can agree how anti-union wal-mart is. "The Democratic Staff of the Committee on Education and the Workforce estimates that one 200-person Wal-Mart store may result in a cost to federal taxpayers of $420,750 per year - about $2,103 per employee." WAL-MART Costs Taxpayers $1,557,000,000,00 to Support its Employees.

  • Is this the key to economic success? For more US companies to be like Wal-mart. America was shaped in part by unions. It is the unions that gave us the 40 hour work week, overtime, holidays, and many more things. Would you work with out a contract? Why should we?

  • So what is the solution to our economy? Ship more jobs overseas. Outsource more? I dont like paying for others mistakes anymore than the next guy. But our country needs a stimulus.  Our country needs true patriotism. We as citizens need to invest in American companies that stay in America and don't ship jobs overseas. Bottom line Americans need to buy goods produced by Americans.

  • The reason why companies leave places like Michigan and California for places like Texas is the same reason why companies leave the US. High tax rates and burdensome regulation is a deterrent. The best solution is for the government to get out of the way of businesses and for the Fed to be abolished. "Stage One" is a reference to a book by Thomas Sowell a great economist. And In regard to less wages; I pay less in taxes and it cost me less to live here, oh and more people have jobs.

  • Protectionism of an industry is bad; I think we can all agree on that that. There is a great economic equation to explain why tariffs are bad for the economy. In fact the Smooth-Hawley Tariff was a major reason that the world plunged into the great depression. Now, protectionism of a job is just as bad as industry. All a reasonable person needs to do is look around per state. High Unemployment tends to come with Unions. I'd rather get payed 5 thousand less so my neighbor can have a job.

  • Oh and there is no such thing as a "base"; our economy is cyclical. Unions come in and raise wages and benefits above market level it forces companies to increase the price of their product. The fact that their product cost more means that they are shut off from world competition because poor people around the world can't afford our products. So in order for a business to remain competitive and stay in business they must reduce their bottom line; by moving to China. Cont...

  • Cont... Because businesses are forced to leave or increase the price of their product you have more unemployed people and others who can't afford the product. Which means more taxes for welfare to pay the unemployed and checks to help the poor afford the costly products. It's called a downward spiral and Michigan is in one right now, California is on the way and America is about to follow.

  • Comment removed

  • Unions are bad for the economy. They cause continuous and progressive inflation. They force unemployment and jobs to go over seas. Don't be fooled by unions they are socialist organizations that disrupt the free-market. Unions say they will raise the standard of living, but they only raise the price of goods putting us right back at the start where everything is unaffordable.

  • As a Union Sheet Metal Worker I would have to disagree with you. In my part of the country the average wage of a non union SMW is under $15/hr. How is someone suppose to raise 2 kids on $15/hr. It is impossible. How is we force unemployment? How about this free market we have had 8 years of deregulation in the market place. Where are we now? The worst economy since the great depression. My union makes it possible for me to get treated fairly and earn a fair wage. UNION YES

  • Wages are really irreverent. In fact most companies will pay their employees above market rate in order to keep them from Unionizing. The Car companies pay more for benefits then they do steel. Look at all Union States, California, Michigan, New York, New Jersey, ect. they have the highest unemployment, highest tax burdens and lowest economic growth compared to right to work states. Social Liberalism destroyed those States and is destroying America. You need to think beyond "Stage One".

  • The notion that Neoliberal economic policies are the cause of this problem is false. The Fed artificially set interest rates below market level; Coupled with government forcing banks into accepting Zero down (ie. easy credit) policies fueled an economic boom that was unsustainable. The Republicans spent to much money and now you say that the solution is to spend more? Don't be a fool, big government either from Republicans or Democrats is the problem.

  • In response to my "stage one" thinking albeit the base of our economy the consumer. How can you say right to work is a great model? In RTW states 21% more people lack health care. 2.3% higher poverty rates. !6% higher infant mortality rates. 51% higher in regards to work related deaths. Companies my benefit from RTW but not the worker. Right to Work is Right to Work for LESS. About $5333/yr on average.

  • Please support unions. There are the only way working people will get any kind of a living wage or benefits, our government does not protect them from companies like Smithfield.

  • The people who make the laws in this country are not the people who have to live by them. Companies get legislators to pass anti-worker laws and don't even abide by the tiny protections that it gives to workers, because no legislators are representing workers. We need a worker's party.

  • It is a shame that American workers have to face intimidation, harrassment, and firing whenever they try to exercise their legal right to form a union.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more