Gemma Doyle

[VaporFlower]

what songs did you use?

[loveshakspeare]

The best video on youtube <3

[TheAraberstylerin343]

i have seen many videos from AGATB but that, and i really meen what i'm saying, is the best video from all videos i have seen....

[LenaJumped]

wow,very great! you did a very good job! i like it very much!

Og Course, Felicity is the most powerful,you're right. but she's also very beautiful and sometimes i had this feeling that she's more beautuiful than Pippa. ^^ it's only a assumtion ;)

[xmisunderstoodgirlx]

Truly amazing! It catches the books in a breathtaking manor, that makes your heart stir. I loved it. The recurrences of the eyes is extremely clever too!

[coolJessie123]

AMAZING! Thank you so much for taking time to make and share this touching video, it's great! Also thanks for writing the spoilers message because I watched the first few seconds a month ago when I was reading the second book!!

[FabiCharlie]

this is one of the most touching videos I've ever found here on youtube.

u really caught the books, i don't know how to express it.

anyone who has read the books, can see that u understand gemma's feelings and the message in the books.

I love it.

[BatlleOfTheTaco]

So simple, yet so amazing!!! The ending it my favorite.

[koreanmania111]

I so want them to make a movie of this series!

[miesermogelvogel]

WOW! Really good!!!

I think if they would film it well, the movie would be a hit! The story is absolutely exciting and wonderful! I'd just like to see a movie about it...♥

[Leeleiin]

it's really the BEST video of this category ! thank you !

[TheMartayellow]

I cried on the part of kartik T.T

[TheBookworm24]

This is by far one of the best AGATB vids EVER!! really really really good job! loved the song too

[criskris007]

this was really well done, i love this video, it definately gives u a feelin of who those girls were and the secret they share, very nice!!

[XxiwuvyouxX]

Very Beautifully written snd the music is just lovely!

[qwts]

OH!!!! What is that song?

[0MyHomeIsMyCastle0]

@qwts It´s "The mystic's dream" by Loreena McKennitt

[qwts]

@0MyHomeIsMyCastle0 thank you very much!!

[JAMdeathgod18]

why did Pippa died?

[JAMdeathgod18]

sweet video

[thecommentercritic]

i truly love this video. but i have to say, i just read the book, and ann's eyes are blue, and felicity's are gray

[Nereaundtom]

wOoow..!

i lOve it!!

[sorry for my english,but i'm spanish =)]

amazing!!

[dawlphinbri]

Wow this was amazing! Perfect job!!!!!!!! Really its wow i'm speechless I loved it! of course the ending made me sad because I hate the ending of the series i truly do but I love the video!!!!

[kissmrule]

i so vloe t hsi video it so cool and sweet

[TwilightRose07]

This was simply beautiful, stunning really. I think you captured the heart of the characters and that is what we love about the books, the characters.

[MademoiselleFleur2]

who is this actress at 4:47 ???

[themeelwoot]

The Gemma Doyle Trilogy is amazing.

Watching this made me tear up a bit. Awesome video!

But I'd like to think that Gemma would never have grandchildren... Karma lives forever.

[missleipold]

Amazing video.

Really beautiful!

[smileygirl2013]

she had it right...Felicity is charming and Ann is clever

[bakedpotat0]

amazing! absolutely PERFECT! i loved it, each person was exactly as i pictured them especially KARTIK! and i loved the spin on how she told the story to her grandchildren! That was amazing you have great talent! :) :)

[hobbedacat]

wow the music is so beautiful nice vid i love it :)

[mooneystar]

Thanks everyone! Wow over 10,000 views!

[TofifeForEvrybody]

oh wow this video is so great

you've done well

[gemmavaldez159]

That is possibly the first Gemma Doyle video I saw after finishing TSFT (my mom got me the last one first, and then after i got into the middle of it discovered that it was a trilogy, by that time it was too late) ...

...like I was saying it's the first one i saw and my favorite out of ALL of them! I LOVE IT!

[TNMEBDlove]

aww! well anyway, ann was charming, felicity was clever, btw! it was AMAZING though, i always thought felicity had blue...?

[MedievalPlease]

I agree, he is hot, but i dont really see him as Kartik at all. Hes just to modern looking. Kartik needs a more aged look, if you know what i mean, which you may not.

[kt27rule]

i lvoe thsi video itos cool and so love this book

[BelladonnaFarie]

Who did that music? It is soooo pretty and haunting and all these things mixed into one!!!! Love the vid.

[ballerinagirl74]

Loreena McKennit

[whooohooo1212]

whoa great job, btw i think it would have been great if Kartik was the grandfather....

[MedievalPlease]

If you've read the sweet far thing, you'll know why he couldn't be the grandfather

[bostoncremetimbit]

LOVE the Kartik part.

[GirlwithSwordandBow]

I love this! So powerful and moving. I wonder what will happen too Gemma, I guess we won't know....

[rainandthunder1991]

Wow. That was amazing! That was really quite chiling towards the end. I was getting goose bumps! I loved it!

[mooneystar]

Oh and also, Ann had brown eyes. Someone commented on that. Felicity i do believe had Grey eyes, but i always imagined them more of a sharp blue. Also I couldn't find a picture of a grey eye and I thought that the picture of the blue eye i found was more symbolic of Felicity's character, if that makes sense...

Thanks again everyone!

[mooneystar]

Okay, Wow! Thank you eso much for all of your comments! They mean so much!

I am now going to try and answer some questions. The song is called The Mystics Dream by Loreena McKennitt. I think it fits perfectly. Someone also said I should have used less pictures. I don't think i could have done that, because the photos tell the story. Somebody asked who did Gemma Marry, and I have no idea. This was just a video of what i think happened. You are free to believe what you want.

[minnie481]

Wow. Thats too good for me.

Well done.

[cemuponaitneomies]

what's the name of the song?

[heyheyitsmj]

That's fantastic. I think the part about Ann and Kartik really stick out to me. Quite good, really!

[Megslikegatorade44]

the music was GREAT!

[kt27rule]

i lvoe this video it so cool

[cagirl2010]

i really enjoyed this but could do with less photos. but the music was perfect! i hope they make a movie!

[upsidedownsheep]

really impressive, some of the images coupled with the text were really powerful.

what was the name of the song?

[TwilightSeries107]

the vid is great!!!!

i love it!

[TheWriterofFantasy]

beautiful job. i love everything about it. the song fits perfectly.

[SusieA94]

Omg the part about pippa gave me chills. although i always pictured pip as being portrayed by the chick from gilmore girls. alexis whatever

[VintageBeautyDarling]

Wow. This is the best AGATB video I have seen. I love it!

[RedHead531]

felicity had grey eyes ! not blue! I remember a part where gemma talk about her eyes cant quite remember they are grey!!

[Pathetic1994]

I thought they were green

[RedHead531]

pathetic1994: Gemma's eyes are green , felicity's are grey, ann's are brown , pippa's are violet but sometimes they turn blue :)

[winterlands654]

This is so AMAZING wow.

[bluepandababii]

This is AMAZING!

[hotbabycakes4]

OMG! i love this video so much!

i cried so many times, i cry everytime i watch it! good job making this

[soulwithaheart]

Great video!!!!!!!!!!!

[fairytalescometolife]

omg... amazing just amazing.. i was wodnering though who did she marry?? greta vid!!!

[cemuponaitneomies]

i cried so hard when kartik died

this video is great...chilling and deep...insightful =]

[meditationpriestess]

wickedly captured, original way to express it.

but idk, wasn't ann's eyes a grey color? if im wrong srry but i swore i thought they were grey...

still, LOVE UR VID!!!!!

[midnightstar345]

i LOVE you're picture of Kartik being pulled into the tree!!

where did you find such perfect pictures?

i also love the story that Gemma tells her grandchildren :)

[bluepandababii]

You did so well at using quotes and and pictures. I usually get bored when a slideshow is 7 minutes, but this one, I wish it had been longer! It was beautiful, but it was also chilling. GREAT JOB!

[artoluv]

I teared up at the end of your vid it's so sad!

[Kittalia]

Really fine work - outstanding! Thank you! :-)

[Aravis17]

Just thought you should know: I googled Gemma Doyle and this video was one of the results.

:D

[Spitfirey994]

I CAN NOT BELIEVE KARTIK IS GONE!!!!!!!!!! i think libba bray should have an alternative ending, like 1 year later where gemma and kartik are BOTH in America TOGETHER.

[crazytreekisser]

okay this video really creeps me out. i love the books but they get so deep...i hope they make a movie...I LOVE KARTIK!!!

[superawesomesekret]

Beautiful and chilling. I loved it!

[Thalia4Praise]

that video was an incrediable represnative of the book :]

[EmilyMarie556]

beautiful, outstanding video!!! it gave me goosbumps!! and im obsessed with the books!!

[PiaffeQueen]

Worshipped the books, adored you're movie. Great Job!

[animegreengirl]

I loved this! it is so great

[EmilyMarie556]

oh man this video is wonderful! i loved it! i loved the books with a PASSION and cant wait for the movie! the last parts gave me goosebumps and i about cried. of course i cried my eyes out when i read the last book. great job!

[horsewhisperer990]

Wow, this was an amazing trailer! I gobbled up the books like crazy, and I can't wait for the movie. This was a lovely video.

[AddieRocks94]

i LOVED this video i read all the books religiously and cried alot. i thin this vide is wonderful!!!

[nicolearielle]

i really liked the video, and how much thought you put into it, but i don't believe gemma would of been with another man, let alone marry and have children with. i know i wouldn't. xD but great work, i really enjoyed watching it.

[Madlen1304]

Hi there! I love those novels. OMG they are perfect! Love Loreena McKennit- she is just one lovely angel. Are they making a movie of Gemma Doyle Trilogy? Please if someone knows post the answer in a comment. Thank you!

[tsftfan]

There is a movie being made, but it is still in the early stages of prodction. You can probably get more information from sources such as IMDb--I hope that helps. :)

[Madlen1304]

Thank you tsftfan for your latter and comment. That was lovely of you!!! And it helps :))))))

[xniconx77]

this reminds me of Twilight. her perfect boy is stuck at the age 19 forever and when she dies and goes to the realms she'll be old but Kartik will be forever 19. like how in New Moon when Bella sees herself as her Grandma and Edward is still 17

[Raindrop37]

I forgot if I commented on this before, but I will anyway just in case I haven't, this is a great video! I put it on my favorites. I love ths music and the pictures. Great job.

[1valkyrie2]

oh my god.. that was amazing!! i loved it...

[mooneystar]

Thanks everyone!! I am glad you liked it.. for the most part. Sorry it was too long for ya RachelReed. Great Stories need a long time to tell.

[Annamieuk]

Slightly confused here, not having heard of these books, are they made into films and available on video/dvd? I loved what you have done here, and would like to see the films and read the books. Your SpPOILER didn't ruin anything for me as I didn't have any preconceptions to be spoilt!

[tsftfan]

There's a movie coming out, probably next year, of the first book-A Great and Terrible Beauty. No one's been cast yet, and you can check IMDb for more information. :)

[LarissaAshlee]

Hello fellow imdb member.

This was really lovely. I loved how you showed pictures for Gemma's part.

Katrik <3

[Froggykick]

this was an awesome video i really loved the first pictures of pippa anf fee

[cemuponaitneomies]

wow.

enough said.

[szaba2]

Unbelievable clip. Amazing pictures, great music and choice of quotes. You captured the whole story beautifully.

[tsftfan]

Lovely video. The pictures are beautiful.

[1988rachelreed]

I know that a lot of work was put into the making of this video, and it took a long time.... but it takes a long time to WATCH, too! TOO long, I must say. I started skipping ahead at about 2 minutes. I honestly commend your efforts here, but for me, unfortunately, it was rather boring, and in truth, I stopped watching all together after i had skipped ahead like 3 times, and still had 3 minutes left to watch! So, I just stopped. That's a shame, really, cuz it had great potential.

[BeautyVintageRoses]

=/ =[

[lesleymanhin]

wat is IMDb?

[NIKEsweet476]

Internet Movie Database. It's a movie site.

Good job, though, amazing vid. Nicely put ending too ;)

[girlgooru28]

hey i love this video!!! it was so good i felt teary at the kartik part... lol im excited for the movies!! (yes there are miovies to come) anyways ur vid is great!!

[sexypenguin4]

that was amazing!!11 out of 10!!

[jdeppfan0730]

Wow..... that was incredible.

[fresha95]

That was very good. I love the music. The Kartik part made me tear up a bit. lol

that part is so sad. I hope they make a movie.

[TheSistersReverie]

I finished TSFT and was thrilled to finally watch this.

I'm not lying when I say it gave me chills and brought tears to my eye. Especially about Kartik... =,,,( I don't think I'll ever get over this book.

[mooneystar]

hey everyone! Thank you so much!! I am glad all of you like it! I am working a new one right now. But my computer acts up, so it may take years and years before i complete it!!! P.S. The song is The Mystics Dream by Loreena McKennitt for those who asked.

[orlisgirlzyx92887]

You have done the best out of all the vidoes of the Gemma Doyle series i have scene. I really get into the clip every time i watch it. I really feel like i am reading the book again and again. nice job!

[Melock16]

love the video! whats the name of the song?

[aqua2angel]

love  vid!!!!!!!!

well done!*claps*d pics were brilliant

it was well put 2gether

[karategrl824]

that was great! you totally caught the characters. i wish they would make a movie out of these books. That was so freaking awesome!!!!!

[lovewarpeace]

haha, they are making a film =) the script is being finished off now

check out the IMDb board for AGATB, we're all super nice there =)

again, BRILLIANT

this is new, fantastic and INSPIRED!

=) (this is bryy, from the IMDb boards btw =])

[ItsJamhoney]

i really like this video

i find i keep watching it over and over!

good work, i love the way you captured gemma.

[faaestaaburrida]

WOW! I absolutely love this video, it's something new and it's very well done.

Its going to my favorites :)

Oh, and I'm from the Imdb boards (fabiola_mef), I'll prpobably vote for you... I haven't seen all the videos yet but this one is definetly on my top. nice job!

[TheSistersReverie]

Gah!

I started watching this and I didn't see the SPOILER thing.

Luckily, I didn't watch too far into it.

Because I still have not finished TSFT.

I feel like an idiot.

I've already ruined so many things by reading the imdbpro boards. lol. But yet, the book is still exciting.

From what I saw, it was AWESOME!!

It was very... fresh. lol.

Nice Job.

[xSweeneyxToddx]

oh my g[emma], amazing! love the end. what's the music?

[stan3211]

kartick dies so i guess they are never really together for long! by the way great video except i didn't really see ann

[BeautyVintageRoses]

This is like a breath of fresh air awesome job!

[mooneystar]

thanks everyone! I appreciate it so much! I am glad everyone likes it (for the most part!) and i love your comments! Thanks!

And for you lichigo911, its is near to impossible to find pictures of Victorian young ladies. Also its up to each individual person as to what you think they look like. So you cant say they dont look like the people, because none of us know exactly how they look. Thats why i didnt use actors. And also its Gemma talking, so she may see them differently! Thanks though!!

[Beatlesaholic]

finally a goodlooking kartik!!!!!

[xoxogossipgirlxoxo1]

the best video ever!

[Iichigo911]

That was A great video but know girl would wear that kind of thing in the victorean ages. They were not aloud to show there wrist or ankels so you might want to fix that. But other than that Bravo! you should make more. Also mabie find different photos because none of those looked like the people!

[minnie481]

WHAT! was that

[tinkerbells101]

oh my goodness it immediatly captures my heart do another pls i beg you!!! you were great THAT was great!!

[ItsJamhoney]

wow that was really amazing!

i could hear Gemma talking in my head as i read the story.

it was perfect!

[Annka110]

Why? Why was Kartik dying ? It´s unfair !

He was the one I liked the most...

ugh this is.....Sad

But great vid

[Annka110]

one question i wanna know...

At the end...ehm... Is she not with Kartik at the end of the book? Please tell me..pls pls pls

[iceprincess55]

Great Great video. One of the best I've seen about the series!

[Aravis17]

WOW - the best slideshow for the Gemma Doyle Trilogy I've ever seen - including my own. Unique, creative, and no one can complain about casting, because you cleverly didn't use real actresses - LOVE IT!!!

[mooneystar]

thank you so much everyone! I am so glad people are enjoying it! Thanks for taking the time to watch it and comment! It means a lot! Thanks Again!

[pinayflava90]

this is the most beautiful amazing awesome great video i have ever seen about gemma! i love it!!!!

i seriously felt like crying towards the end. it was awesome!!

[darkXchii]

Omgggg.

I want to see it!

I saw you post it on IMDB.

I'm on page 321 on TSFT.

I don't want to wait!

Maybe, just watch the first half, erm?

[lovewarpeace]

that was just stupidly good! so well told, and in such a different way

lovely pictures, and such a cute ending!

I miss Kartik =( He has to come back

[readingandwrititng]

Okay, I joined YouTube just so I could comment on this.

I LOVED it. The way you told the story is so haunting and original. And I totally agree with DreamFateHope. I felt like crying at the end too.

[xxcliquemoviexx]

wow! Beautiful pictures

[megdondero]

Beautiful! Wonderful job.

[DreamFateHope]

i LOVED it!!! FANTASTIC!! you talked about the girls wonderfully, explained them fantastically. the music was perfect and the ending...

about Kartik...

I felt like I was about to cry. ),:

Beautifully done!! I LOVE it!!!