You are an idiot. i phly was out first!!! By the way, you look real stupid leaning your whole body to move the heli. kinda reminds me of my nephew when hes playing video games moving the controller thinking his character will run/jump
Yeah, definitely a fake. Sure, you have Aileron, Elevator, Rudder, and Throttle, but that's 3 x servos for cyclic, 1 x gyro for rudder, and 1 x esc for throttle. 5 signals. 4 port router. 8/10 for originality, 1/10 for FAIL.
I love all the lame experts who call everything fake even though they don't really know anything about it and weren't there. Especially when they're dumb like this guy. What does router port have to do with channels? Do you know how networking works? (no)
Actually, use, I do know how networking works. He claims to be using servos with ethernet ports. Also, the beeping coming from his heli, when plugged in, is a standard RCG-35X ESC beep from a Trex450 combo kit. This ESC is not "ethernet" compatible. So how does he get his signal to his equipment from his 4 port router? There are no CHANNELS. He's not using a receiver, he's using a WIFI router. There's no AUX/ELEV/THR etc channel WITHOUT a receiver... He says he's using Wifi in the vid...
Come on - the biggest piece of over-acting iv'e seen yet! nothing the guy says is anyhting techie related to the actual workings - jsut some buzz words to throw you off..
cptsnoopy i agree with you and im not saying the guy is fake or anything. yes there is some fun in hes idea, but i would just like to see some proof in what hes done rather than just smalls shoots of one hand with phone and the other hidden thats all.
kevorkian123 give me a week and il show you a video of my TV remote working and flying my heli. now you should believe this bec its a video and its on here so it wont be fake
A mate has a Iphone and we was messing around with it and while it has one of the applications running and the light wouldnt go out while it was in use.
We left it for a couple of mins and didnt touch it and it went out and the application stopped working.
cptsnoopy i agree with and im not saying the guy is fack or anything. yes there is some fun in hes idea, but i would just like to see some proof in what hes done rather than just smalls shoots of one hand with phone and the other hidden thats all.
kevorkian123 give me a week and il show you a video of my TV remote working and flying my heli. now you should believe this bec its a video and its on here so it wont be fake
Arguing over whether or not this is real is exactly what Josh likes to see. He is a good guy and is fun to watch flying RC. This could be real, it could be a spoof. You have to admit, there is some real entertainment value to reading the comments following an announcement of this sort. It is pretty obvious though via the comments who has and has not played with RC helicopters in the last few years. :)
I am not defending the video at all .. all I am saying is that so far , every reason you have given does not prove the video is faked.
Personally I doubt he would be able to overcome the latency inherent in this design. Meaning how to get the signals to the servos at the proper time. But there is nothing preventing him from doing exactly what was shown in the video. IN FACT .. combined with helicommand or some other stabilization unit this could very well work.
Look what i put, did you see where i was asking about hes other hand?? guess not!!!
Hes being asked on other forums about this and he wont prove what hes done,
i mean how could he make the iphone basic 4 channel touch screen turn into 6 channels?
Also you see at the beginning his phone light goes off indicating his phone went into standby mode, when you are using your phone the lights stay on, the only time its off whilst in use is during a call
Actually you are wrong .. The backlight will go out after the timeout set. Its a basic power saving feature. If you want your application to override this you have to set it to do that. Also while on a call the light only goes out when the phone is up next to your ear. And its not ONLY the back light thats out .. the touch screen is disabled also.
he can send as many channels as he wants to the heli. He has complete control of what is being sent. Its just adding another packet.
you said it was fake because the iphone cant do cppm or have enough control channels THEN you say that it cant happen becuse starting in gov mode would destroy the heli ..
With so much thats wrong in the video .. why cant you tell us one that is truly wrong. The three you presented so far were explained.
Now you are trying to say its fake because other videos are fake ..
If there is so much thats not right .. tell us what they are ..
I think your just jealous that you didnt think of it first and that you do not posses the skills required to make it work.
so now your going to come back with the "person out of cam range flying it"
Shit .. I could use that for EVERY video on youtube. Even for videos of alan. Now youve been flying helis for 17 years .. I am sure you know the alan I am refering to.
The point is that the concept he presents is VALID. it is your arguments that are not.
I'd like to see some detailed hardware/software specs too but I don't see any reason why anyone would say it's impossible, it actually wouldn't be that hard to do. The people demand to see your code!
I dont think he was trying to say you had a 2(or 4 ) servo 180deg swash ..What I think He ment that its 4 directions ( forward .. back .. left .. right .. )
I doubt he really understands what he is talking about.
How about you present an argument that makes sense ??
Why would going straight to gov spint the heli to death ??
Oh you must be one of them people they never found "soft start" mode on your esc.
While there is a chance that the video is faked .. There is nothing inherent in the video or in his description of the tech used that would render this impossible.
I want tech details .. Ok .. so iphone via wifi to the router ..
I assume that you have normal servos .. whats controling them ?? Do you still use a normal RX .. perhaps bypassing the rf section.
Did you get the iphone to generate a pcm stream and just dump that into some udp packets for a demon to decode and output pcm into the RX ( aftter the RF section ) ??
Bec a basic helicopter needs 5 functions and the iphone cant give this many functions or the set up required to run a model helicopter. sorry this is fake
You are an idiot. i phly was out first!!! By the way, you look real stupid leaning your whole body to move the heli. kinda reminds me of my nephew when hes playing video games moving the controller thinking his character will run/jump
happyvapes 4 months ago
Thanks, you're awesome for taking the time to write to me! The dates actually show I was ahead of him by about a year. "Winning".
JoshZiering 4 months ago
@happyvapes Thanks, you're awesome for taking the time to write to me! The dates actually show I was ahead of him by about a year. "Winning".
JoshZiering 4 months ago
صراحه شي جميل
Sauuud20 10 months ago
Geek
colombiak 11 months ago
see - parrot drone
WolF2331 1 year ago
what a lowlife!
popstyla22 1 year ago
Air Support incoming!
Cams1197 1 year ago
so rediculously fake..
darkther4py 1 year ago
LMAO! :)
stichmyass 1 year ago
prove it, cause i think its fake
rovpilot1 1 year ago
This is totaly FAKE..... cause receiver & receiver ...... this is imposible WTF!!!
jenx1Lo 1 year ago
idiot
sqblueeyes88 1 year ago
Dude you are so full of shit. 9V castle link controller? Hahaha!
strueblood 1 year ago
Dude you are so full of shit. 9V castle link controller. Hahaha!
strueblood 1 year ago
Ya and...My name is Santa!
Gjowtheking 1 year ago
Comment removed
arikrupnik 1 year ago
Comment removed
arikrupnik 1 year ago
nice idea and nice joke.
hardabacht 1 year ago
c´mon man
tritonio 1 year ago
wats the app to do this
bmxacan11 2 years ago
Can you post a pic of your aunt?
Kidlat432 2 years ago
as soon as you landed, you tilted your body to the left but the main blades didn't tilt left...
pofrani 2 years ago 5
@pofrani yes its called BRAVO SIERRA
Macsgrafs 2 years ago
Comment removed
pofrani 2 years ago
oh lol! i get yah!!! i agree!
pofrani 2 years ago
;)))))
Macsgrafs 2 years ago
Someone get this kid a job!
DARPA would kill for skills like those.
patricktheofanis 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what a bunch of nerds. rcing for competition haha sry but...
bassthump1111 2 years ago
that is a sensitive bitch right there.
Billitteri 2 years ago
thats total shit
budgienutz 2 years ago
This is under "comedy" you know....
UnlimitedRC 2 years ago
Yeah, definitely a fake. Sure, you have Aileron, Elevator, Rudder, and Throttle, but that's 3 x servos for cyclic, 1 x gyro for rudder, and 1 x esc for throttle. 5 signals. 4 port router. 8/10 for originality, 1/10 for FAIL.
Aoxmodeus 2 years ago
I love all the lame experts who call everything fake even though they don't really know anything about it and weren't there. Especially when they're dumb like this guy. What does router port have to do with channels? Do you know how networking works? (no)
Powagoat 2 years ago
Actually, use, I do know how networking works. He claims to be using servos with ethernet ports. Also, the beeping coming from his heli, when plugged in, is a standard RCG-35X ESC beep from a Trex450 combo kit. This ESC is not "ethernet" compatible. So how does he get his signal to his equipment from his 4 port router? There are no CHANNELS. He's not using a receiver, he's using a WIFI router. There's no AUX/ELEV/THR etc channel WITHOUT a receiver... He says he's using Wifi in the vid...
Aoxmodeus 2 years ago
Bah, it's a CC35, not a RCG. Same damn difference.
Aoxmodeus 2 years ago
Josh, you always amaze me~~~
You da man~~~
nedthetoothpick 2 years ago
prendi per il culo tua sorella
scenotec 2 years ago
100% fake. if he did it 1st with a plane i might have believed it but i fly a 450se v2 and there's no way he's controlling that helicopter.
vespine 2 years ago
I love all the lame experts who call everything fake even though they don't really know anything about it and weren't there.
Why couldn't this be real?
Powagoat 2 years ago
Ok, it MIGHT not be real, but it's not unrealistic. So I don't have a hard time believing this.
Just wondering...how far away could you get before the controls cut out? I know the iPhone's wifi range isn't the greatest.
cashf10w 2 years ago
it's a fake, iPhone (with a nice MSpaint picture) in the right and controller in the other..
Why doesn't you show us your gauge moving? :) Where is the module BT/WIFI to Radio Frequencies?
piranhaworld 2 years ago
simply awsome dude..
never think it that way
ahmy135 2 years ago
LOL - Your a noob if you believe this. Nice idea though.
FrostbiteUK 2 years ago 6
@FrostbiteUK
Hahahahaha!!! Nice joke!!!
I've seen some other fooling people with driving a car but this is an awesome joke!!!!
Thanospappy 1 year ago
this is cool and it is real!!! i have seen people do this
fencinggearhed 2 years ago
You look like someone I once knew,
mmexico 2 years ago
Portnawak, gros fake mal fait...
Ramtalatam 2 years ago 2
thats so bad ass
rockdrummer1226 2 years ago 2
I probably will never fly a helicopter but nice work!
HamburgerJung82 2 years ago
how do u yaw n pitch???
Dimitry999 2 years ago
looked pretty real to me...
howmuchart 2 years ago
FAKE
joyx81 2 years ago 2
So fake. When he's first showing the rotors moving with the phone, look where his other arm is. He has it below the table on the real controller.
OutlawTomFantastic 2 years ago 2
Succes!
Nonsolopollo 2 years ago 2
TOTAL BS....
Come on - the biggest piece of over-acting iv'e seen yet! nothing the guy says is anyhting techie related to the actual workings - jsut some buzz words to throw you off..
freddysatellite 2 years ago
Agreed. As soon as he started talking you could tell this was just another attention seeking J who likes to go on camera and act like a hero.
OutlawTomFantastic 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
cptsnoopy i agree with you and im not saying the guy is fake or anything. yes there is some fun in hes idea, but i would just like to see some proof in what hes done rather than just smalls shoots of one hand with phone and the other hidden thats all.
kevorkian123 give me a week and il show you a video of my TV remote working and flying my heli. now you should believe this bec its a video and its on here so it wont be fake
bigcarp1976 2 years ago
A mate has a Iphone and we was messing around with it and while it has one of the applications running and the light wouldnt go out while it was in use.
We left it for a couple of mins and didnt touch it and it went out and the application stopped working.
Thats strange ant it hmmmmmm
bigcarp1976 2 years ago
cptsnoopy i agree with and im not saying the guy is fack or anything. yes there is some fun in hes idea, but i would just like to see some proof in what hes done rather than just smalls shoots of one hand with phone and the other hidden thats all.
kevorkian123 give me a week and il show you a video of my TV remote working and flying my heli. now you should believe this bec its a video and its on here so it wont be fake
bigcarp1976 2 years ago
Arguing over whether or not this is real is exactly what Josh likes to see. He is a good guy and is fun to watch flying RC. This could be real, it could be a spoof. You have to admit, there is some real entertainment value to reading the comments following an announcement of this sort. It is pretty obvious though via the comments who has and has not played with RC helicopters in the last few years. :)
Charlie
(go get'm Josh!)
cptsnoopy 2 years ago 2
I am not defending the video at all .. all I am saying is that so far , every reason you have given does not prove the video is faked.
Personally I doubt he would be able to overcome the latency inherent in this design. Meaning how to get the signals to the servos at the proper time. But there is nothing preventing him from doing exactly what was shown in the video. IN FACT .. combined with helicommand or some other stabilization unit this could very well work.
kevorkian123 2 years ago
if a version for rc cars could be released into the app store i'd but it...it would give me a reason to get back into building rc cars :)
job well done...seems like one of the more advanced apps i've seen so far
5 STARS for sure on this vid, keep up the great work man
TheFreshPrince1313 2 years ago
Comment removed
DJKskateTEAM 2 years ago
kevorkian123 again grow up!!!
Look what i put, did you see where i was asking about hes other hand?? guess not!!!
Hes being asked on other forums about this and he wont prove what hes done,
i mean how could he make the iphone basic 4 channel touch screen turn into 6 channels?
Also you see at the beginning his phone light goes off indicating his phone went into standby mode, when you are using your phone the lights stay on, the only time its off whilst in use is during a call
bigcarp1976 2 years ago
Actually you are wrong .. The backlight will go out after the timeout set. Its a basic power saving feature. If you want your application to override this you have to set it to do that. Also while on a call the light only goes out when the phone is up next to your ear. And its not ONLY the back light thats out .. the touch screen is disabled also.
he can send as many channels as he wants to the heli. He has complete control of what is being sent. Its just adding another packet.
kevorkian123 2 years ago
I never said it was impossible im just saying its fake till its proven its not and at the mo nothing is being said or shown to prove either way.
kevorkian123 grow the fuck up will you, you see a vid and wow u will believe everything you see on here wont you.
some people have put vids on here showing them controlling there heli with PS control did you believe that to be real?? most probs.
there is so much in that video thats wrong and not right but none many of you are seeing it try opening eyes.
bigcarp1976 2 years ago
Yes you did claim it was impossible.
you said it was fake because the iphone cant do cppm or have enough control channels THEN you say that it cant happen becuse starting in gov mode would destroy the heli ..
With so much thats wrong in the video .. why cant you tell us one that is truly wrong. The three you presented so far were explained.
Now you are trying to say its fake because other videos are fake ..
If there is so much thats not right .. tell us what they are ..
kevorkian123 2 years ago
why would anyone fake this idea.... wow
cyclone12 2 years ago
I think your just jealous that you didnt think of it first and that you do not posses the skills required to make it work.
so now your going to come back with the "person out of cam range flying it"
Shit .. I could use that for EVERY video on youtube. Even for videos of alan. Now youve been flying helis for 17 years .. I am sure you know the alan I am refering to.
The point is that the concept he presents is VALID. it is your arguments that are not.
kevorkian123 2 years ago
I'd like to see some detailed hardware/software specs too but I don't see any reason why anyone would say it's impossible, it actually wouldn't be that hard to do. The people demand to see your code!
danwagoner 2 years ago
right you will need controls to do
4 point cyclic control
tail
pitch
throttle
gyro
--------
then you would need to be able to set up the pitch curve, gyro %. throttlr curve
Sorry i will stick with my claim this is fake
bigcarp1976 2 years ago
And which part of that do you think the iphone cant handle ??
4 point cyclic control .. thats the 4 axis tilt control ..
Tail .. a slider control just like the way you unlock the phone ..
Pitch and throttle .. another slider .. same as on a real tx..
Shit if he wanted .. I bet you could use a simple touch pad type control where you place two thumbs on the iphone and just control it that way.
Gyro does NOT need to be controlled by the tx .. just set it and forget it ..
kevorkian123 2 years ago
Who uses 4 point cyclic control? Thats silly. I use 120 ccpm.
So that said:
Tail.
Roll
Elevator
Pitch (Collective)
JoshZiering 2 years ago
I dont think he was trying to say you had a 2(or 4 ) servo 180deg swash ..What I think He ment that its 4 directions ( forward .. back .. left .. right .. )
I doubt he really understands what he is talking about.
kevorkian123 2 years ago
This is not a fake!! Amazing app by the way Josh.
thinklikeansob 2 years ago
Oh btw .. if you pay for bandwith on "myauntishot" you will be getting a very big bill this month ..
As you may be aware .. you made slashdot .. So yea .. your webserver is hurting ..
kevorkian123 2 years ago
Stunt 1. Using governor, so I dont need throttle and pitch. Just pitch
JoshZiering 2 years ago
how did u set up the gov?? how did you do the spool up?? you cant just go straight to gov it will spin its self to death
bigcarp1976 2 years ago
You are really set on trying to call this fake ..
How about you present an argument that makes sense ??
Why would going straight to gov spint the heli to death ??
Oh you must be one of them people they never found "soft start" mode on your esc.
While there is a chance that the video is faked .. There is nothing inherent in the video or in his description of the tech used that would render this impossible.
kevorkian123 2 years ago
I want tech details .. Ok .. so iphone via wifi to the router ..
I assume that you have normal servos .. whats controling them ?? Do you still use a normal RX .. perhaps bypassing the rf section.
Did you get the iphone to generate a pcm stream and just dump that into some udp packets for a demon to decode and output pcm into the RX ( aftter the RF section ) ??
kevorkian123 2 years ago
Bec a basic helicopter needs 5 functions and the iphone cant give this many functions or the set up required to run a model helicopter. sorry this is fake
bigcarp1976 2 years ago
While it still could be faked .. why do you make assumptions about what the phone can control ??
even off the top of my head I could see this working
the "tilt" being the right stick .. and then two thumb sliders for throttle and rudder on each edge of the phone.
You think that an iphone cant be programed to handle cppm while china pumps out 24.95 tx/rx combos that can handle it ??
what exactly do you think the iphone couldnt do ??
kevorkian123 2 years ago
Excellent work. Now if you just get a camera on board and can feed the video to the iPhone...
-jcr
NSResponder 2 years ago
shame its fake, many reasons why it would never work
bigcarp1976 2 years ago
Please give us one.
Danielg42 2 years ago
Speaking as an ex-Apple engineer, I see no reason to think this is fake.
-jcr
NSResponder 2 years ago
Top notch hack. Can't wait to see more test flights!
jkcason 2 years ago
stop talking and show more helicopter shots!
davidfromnl 2 years ago 2