Idina Menzel - For Good (acapella) - Atlanta

[johntboy9]

God I love her =P Shes so perfect, her voice is amazing shes so pretty and soooo nice Idina I loved being stage crew for your preformances

[SheepWearingLace]

Her voice is like honey...

[NeverAshcroft]

she ALWAYS forgets the lyrcis... XD

[Sakina1222]

If I went to her concert, I would never ask for my money back no matter how many mistakes she makes, it just makes her seem so much more real and I love it <3

[GreekGleek78]

That woman right there..is my hero. -3

[MsMusiclover024]

i don't care if you mess up just sing sin the dang phone book I'll still pay! <3

[kyloprincess]

Dang....she's amazing.

[SingingCatzzz]

yeah she always forgets theese words xD but shes soo cute! i think she does it sometimes to interact with the crowd. lol someone said she should get kristin xD idina and kristin should SO go on a tour together. that would be like, amazing. im suprized the earth hasnt split yet, having two such talented women on it at the same time :)

[MsMusiclover024]

@SingingCatzzz That would be AMAZING they would sell out in 1 sec can you say Wickedly Amazing?? CHENZELS!! <3

[SingingCatzzz]

@MsMusiclover024 haha i know! that would be WICKEDLY AMAZINGLY AWESOME! but Kristin and Idina NEED to sing this song together, its perfict for there relationship! and i wanna hear them together again :)

[MsMusiclover024]

@SingingCatzzz IK they should go on tour and they would sell oput in like 1sec!

[jheuzdumaop]

She's an actress and as I saw on her while asking "What I what for me?" she's like intended to do that...

[MsMusiclover024]

You know I'm okay if someone says I don't like Idina's voice ( a little mad but okay) But when they say she has NO TALLENT! THATS WHERE I DRAW THE LINE!!!!!!!!! -_-

[designerproductions]

she always forgets this!

[Tweet918]

Trolling the crowd!! :D <3 Idina 

[idinamenzelfanzel]

so she sings it 8 times a week for 3 years on stage and forgets the lyrics.... lol

[FlutterbaiDestiny]

@idinamenzelfanzel she did it so they would sing it with her.

[stepheyrocks]

@idinamenzelfanzel she's allowd to have brain farts every once in a while lmfao

[mochajoe2]

wow horrible... cant remember her lines????? 

[bookluvr613]

@mochajoe2 she did that on purpose. to get them to sing it also.

[fredishot4sure]

Haha get Kristin! "are you gonna ask for your money back to night I make so many mistakes... Lol

[TheNikkonish]

This would be like Michael Crawford forgetting the words to Music of the Night.

[mrsdannyjones1000]

@1romcat I don't think they wanted the literal meaning. They wanted it in context. @fraliak It means singing without a backingtrack or music, just your voice :)

[vanvanvanessaa]

 "GET KRISTIN!" YES! hahaha

[Only1Netty]

Lol she is so great!!!

[agoicoleam]

amazing. i love u idina.

[superboy7j]

forgetting the lyrics was staged. She did it in other cities too. I like Idina, but shes butchering a beautiful song

[campinloyagirl]

why does she make forggeting lyrics look so good?

love you IDINA!!:)

[rachelkillers]

A broadway star never forgets their lyrics! That was so planned, I love Idina. She's so chill

[Rosemarijn0987]

She's great!

GET KRISTIN, LOL!

[xxmoussexx]

awwww! 'ur not gonna ask for your money back, i made so many mistakes!' aww idina is still great

[flashbackmusiclexie]

im sorry is she doing this on purpose because she did this in nashville or is it just because she hasnt been in wicked for a while? haha but i still love her!

[4EverCurlz]

LOL "GET KRISTEN!" I really hope she doesn't regret this performance it's a great story to tell and she has such an amazing voice

[famosyyo]

woot woot! Go Idina xD <3333

[madmadchiken]

I love her sooooooooo much!!! She is an inspiration!

[KSP33]

She is too cute!

[Sistersliveforever]

she was pretending! she didnt actually forget!

[sophab0656]

shes an angel

[nicolelovesrice]

the forgetting lyrics part is planned...to get the audience to participate...lol

[fraliak]

Okay, this sounds really stupid but I'm going to ask anyway - What does acapella mean?

[blowersdaughtr]

@fraliak without background music

[TampaKurt]

@fraliak It means Google :P

[1romcat]

@fraliak actually it means "in chapel"

[SirSammichbatch]

this i not the first time she forgot the lyrics to this song during her tour haha, I guess she stopped focusing on it and starterd focusing on her album haha so the words slipped away.

still absolutely amaizing though =]

[itsmebethan]

@SirSammichbatch erm she didn't really forget... it was to get the audience to join in :) :)

[behindthegeek]

It's cute when she does that.. amazing voice, by the way

[defygravitybewicked]

hahahaa! omg theres another video where she does the same thing in nashville! some girl named charmed71 has it!

[lozwstar]

She gives me goosebumps <3

My hero.

[ilovedajman]

I WAS AT THAT CONCERT !!!

[Aleenapoo]

I like her shirt! It's cool.

[Aleenapoo]

Here echoing is like the music! she doesn't need instument! She's got a voice, that's all she really needs!!! I l♥ve Idina and ♫Wicked♫!!!

[beaniegirl23]

Gosh I wonna see her in person so bad! She's amazing and my idol!

[funnygirl4313]

I'm just soooo like...intoxicated by her voice. It's so amazing. She could sing the phonebook to me and I'd just sit there in awe.

[vbgirlpinkrox1]

@funnygirl4313 haha your totally right

[totaltyler159]

she still so amazingly gorgeous

[vegiemusiclove]

lol @ get kristin

[emilyonfirst]

haha i love her!

"aww, damn! what is it?"

haha shes funny:D

[PunkNeko19]

she misses kristin thats why she messed up hahaha

[StarlightzPlace]

Its just show :)

watch out the Other clips it´s the same "black out" again ^^ on antoher show^^

[idinaBALLET]

It's not show! She simly forgot the lyrics two nights in a row! She even says so herself...she says: "Damn, I did this last night"! And those were the only two performances she messed the lyrics to For Good up!

[tragic1Kingdom]

i could listen to her sing all day.

[bmax231]

agreed!

[madison3993]

Haha, shes not very good with old lyrics XD

But shes sooooo pretty, so it's all good

[beautifullytragic1]

Who cares if it was acted out or not?

Idina is SINGING! And it's fucking incredible as always.

[elphie4evergreen]

For Good is such a beautiful song! Love this video! And about the forgetting the lyrics being scripted i don't know, but if it was i think there are others, better ways to make the public sing with you...anyway, a beautiful performance!

[Hipmister3000]

lol, someone yelled "get kristin"

[PunkNeko19]

When?? hahaa

[Hipmister3000]

around 0:41 - 0:43

[sweetypeady]

@Hipmister3000 When? I didn't here it. :/

[aledu89]

@sweetypeady after she said: "...I made so many mistakes" (0:43) you can hear the "get Kristin"

[ani270674]

@Hipmister3000 Seriously? LOL!

[wickedautograph]

@Hipmister3000 so true. When i sung this at a talent show, i screwed up not as bad as idina, but still really bad. I got 6 from all judges. Me and my best friend took turns shouting u suck out loud at the judges all night. But they didn't know it was an idina song. if they did i wouldnt have been mad

[Sithis007]

The first time was probably for real but this time the mistakes were too obvious so it seems like she intentionally messing up just as an act

[melonflower]

poor idina . but it´s funny

[graace92]

haha "you guys can ask for your money back, i've made for too many mistakes"

hahahaha lovee her!

she still sounds amazing even tho she messes up haah

[PEACExLOVExYO]

i dont think she does. she said in the video she did this at the last one.

who cares though, shes talented.

[sweetcheerbum]

its toayly acted out duhhhh

[scoobyboi84]

this is staged, its very fun cute way for the people seeing the show to get involved.

Many singers do this

[5660201]

this is totally an act! she does this in several different performances!

[TheatreFanatic4eva]

So what!

[pinkeyscareymya]

omg...she is AMAZING!!!! and hysterical too. she forgot one of the RENT lyrics at the show in albany the other night and ppl,started laughing and she was like " Don't laugh at my ignorance!" haha at least she makes fun of herself in those situations cuz I would do the same. i was so happy i got to see her. we were in the first row and she ket looking right at me!!!! hahahaha

[RavenPallas]

I thought she said, "Don't applaud my ignorance," and then she started over again.

[LucyXenaCL]

she was amazing that night in albany! omg I loved it!

[cheekymonkey3np]

She forgot the lyrics the night before too!

[fawn512]

of course this is scripted, trying to get the fans to sing with her :) LOL She's funny :)

[likextotallyxlol]

why did you get a thumbs down for this comment?? lol wow :)

actually i dont think it was scripted because she did it the night before also, and she mentioned it here.

but who knows, it could be :)

[fawn512]

oops, my bad, i must've clicked somthing. how do i edit it? :)

[likextotallyxlol]

no it was nothing you did. someone rated your comment a thumbs down because you said the messup was scripted, which it probably was lol

:)

[fawn512]

I see LOL, i never did learn how to use most of the features here at youtube :)

[cwag123]

sorry i have to agree with you cause i went to one of her concerts and she did the same thing and on another vid

[horsegal1234]

i don't think so because she Cursed herself at Nashville Show

[XxAikaChan]

she is amazing, i loveee her personality!

[MvyMkr]

BLESS

HER

[dreamstar0108]

I dont think we should get down about her frogeting the lyrics. Theres no Kristin(this was a big son for them) and lol it looks like its been a long night for her. Se did her best. I LOVE YA Dee!

Peace and Dee Love

[idinawanabe]

Dont forget Helen Dallimore!!

[dreamstar0108]

haha of course her!!! Their both AMAZING!! KRISTIN AND HELEN!!!! IDINA TOO!!! :D

[imsocool43210]

she needs kristin!!!!! but she still sounds the same!!

[wickedmenzel]

she amazes me every time

[tatyrules12]

lol i love her i guess this is why she had us sing it with her in orlando so she wouldnt look silly but shes ahmahzing anyway even if i didnt get to meet her

[GabbyDee32]

god that was beautiful! she looks so beaitiful o! i love when she sings acapella! who cares she forgot shes still gorgeous and i love her!

[jumperhunter101]

She sounds a lot better live! c=

[ejaynes]

Poor thing, the night before in Nashville she forgot the lyrics too. I was there! But she is still amazing :D

[MvyMkr]

This made me go AAAAAAAAAW rather than eeew

[SillyCruz]

lmao! she is hilarious!

I LOVE IDINA!!!!

:)

thanks for posting!

[TurpentineValentine]

And I thought this song couldn't get any better, but it just did.

Beautiful video!

Thanks for posting.

[c0ll3g3g1rl1o1]

THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR POSTING THIS!!! I was there!!! So worth the drive (from MS) and everything! Now I can always remember (and replay) that night! ^_^

[xObroadwaybabyyOx]

ahh idina we love you!!

Peace and Dee Love

[dioxie]

Aw, poor Idina, she forgot the lyrics again! She's still amazing and I still love her. :D

[Fabala13]

i love how she curses in the middle of the song

[ewstumblebutt]

Poor Idina! She probably psyched herself out because of what happened in Nashville.

[DragonHeart06]

What happened?

[PinkJewell]

She forgot the lyrics in Nashville the night before. You know, I assume people are gonna think that she does it on purpose, but honestly, I think she psyched herself out like ewstumblebutt said. Because she totally screwed up in Nashville. And if she was doing in on purpose everywhere then she would've screwed up really bad again. So that's what I think. But it was still really sweet and wonderful. And she's still our girl. :)

[holly1fan]

oh! i heard someone say "get kristin" lol. i can't believe she forgot again! oh well. she's still amazing.

[PinkIcing7]

Whoever said that WINS.

[holly1fan]

yep.

[DragonHeart06]

I was there!! Wow she's amazing. But it's funny how she forgot the lyrics, and everyone sang them to her!

[Elphiethegood]

NO WAY! Wow I wish i would've been there. oh gosh thats funny!!

[unabletosoldier]

lol i love her!

she's so forgetful!

[adameyelashlover]

Again?!?! Classic!