Added: 3 years ago
From: idolmusic08
Views: 11,122
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (58)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • she shouldn't have gone for this song, it's way too over her head

  • Broke should out this round... Not her... T^T

  • did simon just say 'it was a little bit WHINY at times'? lol funny that he never noticed that 'whiny' thing from leona LOL jk

  • this is nothing like the original but she made her own version so it's still really really really good.

  • This was awesome by Kristy, I loved it. Sorry people were so unbelievably horrible to this girl, she is awesome and carried herself with grace...

  • Why does she look like LeAnn Rimes to me lol. 

  • I love the country twist on it, it's very appropriate with the melody. Very good performance!!!

  • lets face it,

    Let's say Kristy's performance was the size of a basketball.

    Mariah's version is like Mount Everest.

  • shes good, but i really like mariahs 2.

  • @zjmadman since u said that do you think kristy is better than david hernandez during top 12? i think not. she's the wordst performer during top 12. she should've gone first.

  • I am sorry but personally i think mariah was just being nice...i personally like mariah's version way better....especially she can connect to the song...because of her divorce with tommy mottola?

  • she's gotta be one of the prettiest contestants the show ever had....

  • it may be a little off-topic, but i wish mariah can perform this song again...she hasn't for 14 years. It is nice to see that at least she still kinda remembers this song haha....i hope you know what i mean...and it's nice to see mariah's reactions and stuff to hearing this song again...this is really her best song, although not well-known

  • so good !! why is she eliminated ! :o

  • i actually liked this performance....!!!!

  • No one sucked that week... ?

  • I was so pissed that she got eliminated this week!!!!! It should have been Brooke or Jason!!!! They both SUCKED!!!!! So did Carly that week.

  • umm why doesn't she have a career?????

  • @spencerruefus She does. Shes signed with Arista Records.

    Rambuli the short midget is the only one doing nothing

  • @spencerruefus She did but she got dropped. She's currently looking for a new label.

  • yeah i heard she had got dropped but she's a better vocalist then alot of the artists in country today

  • i like her...if only jason castro didnt give his best at this week

  • When I saw this originally I didn't like it, but now I liked it. She can belt a lot better than I remember.

  • So when you hugged Mariah, did you feel her "goosebumps"? Kristy can make it. Pretty to look at with slightly above average vocals. This was a good performance for her. Her best!! She could EASILY be a FAMOUS COUNTRY SINGER. I just can't imagine getting goose bumps from her singing.

  • She reminds me of another leanne rimes

  • I think this was one of the best performances that night... one of my favorites ever, she definitely gave me goosebumps all through out the song and she didn't deserve to go based on that performance... but I don't know, I'm kinda happy with how things went... back then I despised her, but now I love her... especially because of this performance. Anyway the shows done and what's important is that we support her now. Hope she releases another album soon. Her Why Wait album was amazing!!! :D

  • look... kristy is good but theres somebody in the top 8 that deserves to join the top 7. And that is michael johns. I really think that david hernandez is more deserving than her. sorry.

  • so brooke white was better than her that night? and jason? i think not

  • oh, and brooke white should have been eliminated instead of kristy too!!

  • nope, kristy lee cook shouldn't have gone home with this song! jason castro should have been eliminated!! i think the problem was, archuleta and cook was too great that week, and it hurt kristy's votes!

  • I forgot to mention from 2:17 to 2:34 ( The End of the song she sang that all without taking a breath. That was Amazing

  • Her last four performances were my favorites. She just kept getting better, so I was sad when she left

  • this actualli was a really good performance, they are so unfair most of the time...

  • i really love her performance during that time. she did really gave me goosebumps, not only MC but also the reviews coming from our nation's critics here in our country. It's not only Simon Cowell is among the few best judges... there are a LOT of good judges and critics all over the globe, i think.

  • i would like to see leanne rimes do this song she could deliver that country twang this song needs!

  • this performance was probably the best of hers, yet the feedback wasn't too good. :\ i totally disagree with randy and simon...urgh...it was SUCH a good performance.

  • I feel the same way as you, the comments from Randy and Simon were not really justified.. Kristy did a wonderful job with this song, she gave me the goosebumps for sure...

  • MC is so nice, such a great mentor to them! =D

  • a little too much flattery when Mariah said that KLC sang the song better that she did.

  • Seriously. No one can sing this song better than her.

  • She has a nice voice,but I think she does country better than she does R&B ballads.

  • WHat did Randy mutter just before Paula started speaking

  • In the performance, she sang the part "...you will always be the only ONE..." in a "yodel" way that I really did not like. I love yodeling, but it kinda killed the song... However, she sang it well with Mariah... I mean, without the yodel thing, so I was really confused.

    All in all, Kristy is a great singer.

  • OH MY GOD 2:17-2:33 she didn't breath and sang really powerfull notes...gosh to me she was very good

  • dont really like her voice

    love her hair

  • people dont like her but I do! I feel something good about her!

    She's cute, she has a good voice and she did a good job singing Mariah Carey, that's very difficult...

  • i love kristy =]

  • i cant believe she got voted off with this one! she did an excellent job! her second best performance after god bless the usa!

  • i only think she should stop crackin her voice.

  • loved loved loved loved loved this one!! i though kristy did really good on this song. i really liked it.

  • I love Kristy. She's an amazing singer and totally gorgeous. <3 I hope she makes an album.

  • She's got a single out and an album should be coming sometime in August. Can't wait!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more