I agree with the idea of dropping your right hand down an octave as well as watching your tempo as it's kind of hard to peg in to :) Otherwise pretty darn nifty
try pulling the right hand down an octive it sounded much better when i played it and i cant see but are u using A# and F for the beginning because it sounds too high...BUT AMAZING JOB!!!!
im trying to write some sheet music for this song and ive got most of it down. but what do you do with your left hand. i learned just the basic melody
the reason everybody loves this song is because it has very soothing and well-sounding chord progressions. I also like the variations you throw in you must play some jazz?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
What makes me laugh is that while everyone is busy sucking this guy's cock off, they fail to realize that in many parts, he's completely off time, and off key in several places as well.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
time has absolutely nothing to do with piano being out of tune. how the fuck does this amateur have 50,000 views. im fucking appauled. its a nice attempt, and you clearly need more lessons, but jesus.
To be perfectly honest i feel that anyone can learn to play the piano well but it takes something special to play with such emotion like you, well done, this is an amazing cover
Try playing it all an octave lower. It's supposed to be dark and pretty: that's where real emphasis with the bass should come in. Also you've kind of given it a dancebeat almost, where it's supposed to be slower..
Patterns with the left hand and major dynamic change would hurt either. As an option:for only section of the song,a higher and slightly faster melody could be very beautiful. When I did this,I found that gives it a musicbox like effect.Great job figuring it out though.You have an ear.
idk if i commented before but im just relooking this amazing job. i think i did and i can play the same thing. but yours has more notes and harmonies. its a beautiful song and its my favorite. great job!!!!
You're probably not goingto answer to this, but I'm curious if you've made the sheet music. If you have, I would be extremely greatful if you could send it to me.
Great job again. And I'm not just saying that because I want sheet msuic. I'm serious.
noob, i play guitar and piano...piano is ALOT HARDER alot, guitar tabs r easy to read...r tard... and to the video GREAT JOB i thought u cood of put more emotion into it otherwise amazing
Well on a Piano it's a lot easier than on a Guitar. A Piano has the Keys with Letters of A B C D E F G and the black ones like f flat or d flat or something. Just like write what the order is and there you go. You have Piano Tabs :P
Obviously, you don't know much about the common notation for notes on piano.
There's a lot more to it; you need to take care of measures, tone lengths, time signatures, and it's a lot of work, even with simple tools like Guitar Pro or Sibelius.
I don't think anyone asked you. Simply put, get the notes, and then play them in the way they are and anyone could just figure out how it really should be played. -.-
not that simple bud. play piano for several years and you'll find it complicated. not to say that guitar isnt complicated as well, i play both. i prefer piano, and find it more challenging. but whatever. my opinion.
It just hit me at one point during the playing and I just said "Oh Sh!t" thats all I could think of saying. Which is actually pretty sad, I should not cuss. Very good job though, I cried.
yea this version, listen 2 the non-acoustic that 1 is more exciting, this version 2 me has more of a nostalgic feel makes you think of the past and of what youve done
Only critism: Use a metronome buddy. Timing is the most important factor to music, it's WAY more important than the music itself. But really good job either way, keep it up! :)
Yeah good point, but usually when youre playing live - adrenaline usually drives the tempo - if u get what i mean. Still fair criticism, point taken :)
Yeah yeah of course, that's why I hate how they make Chad play with a click track when every breathing fan of BB knows damn well Chad can easily keep them on tempo, and still have the live feel.
Dude, if you have the piano music, can you email it to i_am_jane_doe@hotmail? Thank you thank you thank you! Oh, and by the way, you play this really well! XD
look at Alex S. cover it epic.
TWhopp721 1 year ago
The chorus sounds beautiful <3
chocolatebunny1996 1 year ago
Nice job on the chorus, sounds amazing.
itj101 2 years ago
0:42 - 1:00 beautiful!!
great job!!
stridersheikr3lo4d 2 years ago
hey
great job.....
you think you can send me the sheet music?
kishu818 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
like it
if u dont mind, i'd like you to redo it again without mistakes this time
i would really want to enjoy it
may be u can then send it to me as an
mp3 so i can put it as a rigntone in my cell :)
good job :)
nanoten 2 years ago
where goes everyone??
(so quayet)
WhiteMaster81 2 years ago
awosome!!!Whose play the pianno??
WhiteMaster81 2 years ago
sounds wrong at the begginging i could barly understand what it was
Meis4bf 2 years ago 8
esta muy bueno, te falta mejorar un poco los movimientos pero aun asi esta muy bieno. lo has trabajado mucho. sigue asi. me a gustado mucho . saludos
AdriVsl21 2 years ago
Find the down beat.
ninjabreadOman 2 years ago 3
sounds very wrong
Paulniller 2 years ago 4
I agree with the idea of dropping your right hand down an octave as well as watching your tempo as it's kind of hard to peg in to :) Otherwise pretty darn nifty
feege1113 2 years ago
I like it!!!!!
darkbloodangel342 2 years ago
can you give me a website for the piano tabs
spartan1hunter 2 years ago
yeah, try google
tehslayerkid 2 years ago
try pulling the right hand down an octive it sounded much better when i played it and i cant see but are u using A# and F for the beginning because it sounds too high...BUT AMAZING JOB!!!!
Eagleye707 2 years ago
Awesome. Wish I could play like that.
lea1028 2 years ago
idc what other people say tht was awsum
rock3rchick23 2 years ago
i don't think the piano is tuned right ..
sejmon666 2 years ago
agreed
poopedstatue 2 years ago
I DONT THINK ITS SHIT.
its better than anything i can play.
nice job!
i want to learn this but listening to that other dudes version (puckgenius) i totally decided ill never reach that level :(
crazitaco 2 years ago
nice work sounded good
94mustanggt45 2 years ago
geez people its his interperation of the song, stop knocking the guy. He has done an awesome considering that he most likely did it by ear.
tracy4jester 2 years ago 2
damn dude. did good
mindfreakett 2 years ago
Did you use music?
poosywoosycat8676 2 years ago
might not be the best dont have to say its utter shit
conscript93 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it kinda is shit... your right hand should be like 5 keys down.. for all of it.
wutsferdinner 2 years ago
Uh, this is amazing. AMAZING.
Seriously, your just jealous.
MaisieIzod 2 years ago
pretyy cool dude
matthew1820cam 2 years ago
This isnt as kickin as the song is supposed to be..
watch the one by puckgenius
[breakin benjammin - diary of jane on piano]
and tell me wat this is compared to that..
trust me..
Joshywawa2590 3 years ago
it's true... this is a shitty cover
disekrak 3 years ago
o.o
RunAway102 3 years ago
:o That's awesome! I wish I could play that good. XD
Jakgoeswee 3 years ago
listening to piano songs like this makes me think of KH. :(
werewalrusfilms3 3 years ago
The left hand is a little blocky most of the time, but u have the melody fairly spot on. keep at it.
Microrator 3 years ago
im trying to write some sheet music for this song and ive got most of it down. but what do you do with your left hand. i learned just the basic melody
sixo6oh 3 years ago
puckgenius is soooo much better.....but you did a good job kid
songwriter4life 3 years ago
Great job!
Jaaack 3 years ago
wooow !! is amazing !! xD
Slipknotnightwish 3 years ago 3
the reason everybody loves this song is because it has very soothing and well-sounding chord progressions. I also like the variations you throw in you must play some jazz?
rathrbsktn12 3 years ago 4
amazing! do you have the sheet music?
jshadows80 3 years ago
so much better than the actual song. record this with some quality equipment and you've got something.
MixtureRich 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What makes me laugh is that while everyone is busy sucking this guy's cock off, they fail to realize that in many parts, he's completely off time, and off key in several places as well.
VelvetJackson 3 years ago
yeah but he didnt fail to mention that his piano is out of tune either.
68KisstheCrook68 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
time has absolutely nothing to do with piano being out of tune. how the fuck does this amateur have 50,000 views. im fucking appauled. its a nice attempt, and you clearly need more lessons, but jesus.
TranceLQ 3 years ago
someones jelous
khalyd123 3 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I agree with TranceLQ.. they can play okay. but it's nothing that great. but still good tho. (I took piano lessons for 8 years so I should know) >->
WAY2rand0m4u 3 years ago
yeah same here...i love the song, and i think that maybe some pedal would improve this version loads, but its an good attempt
JAelsesx93 3 years ago
did you find the sheet music for that or did you learn it by ear. i am wanting to learn to play it so if you could reply that would be great!
bobyfce 3 years ago
love it!!
dragonfly1377 3 years ago
oh wow
lostidiot11 3 years ago
To be perfectly honest i feel that anyone can learn to play the piano well but it takes something special to play with such emotion like you, well done, this is an amazing cover
katharineeeee 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
bullshit
68KisstheCrook68 3 years ago
Could I have the music notes or sheet music for this song?
(if you have any..)
silverbelll 3 years ago
shoot thats tight!
RichKor 3 years ago
sehr schön
AlteSchuhsohle 3 years ago 4
translated to english="Very nice"
cargodudeMT 3 years ago 2
5tars
wanaplayrough 3 years ago
Hey, do you have the sheet of music for this song if you do send me a email please :) You are good at piano!
Lovywoman3 3 years ago
DUUUDDEE!!!
That was beautiful!! Did you learn that by ear?...If you did...WOW. :D
Keep playing!!
redjumpsuit13 3 years ago
woooh! amazing...
erragonkoh 3 years ago
you give it that nice dark horror feel, its on deck. nice job
sn4pcr4ackl3p0p 3 years ago
Amazing.
drsatan22 3 years ago 2
you are AWSOME!
anajordinson 3 years ago
You're Awesome, Keep It Up!
tentin1991 3 years ago
nich schlecht, respekt 5*
schnuffelding 3 years ago
wow that is awesome playing
zeldagrl 3 years ago 2
GREAT JOB!
Howevwer, this song was supposed to be quite dark. I (personally)think that it should be played an octave lower. Still, Keep it up!
Vakama283 3 years ago
yo was it by ear or by score
i guess its by ear - if thats the case ur pro as in PRO!!!!
r u diploma??
anywayz, i only wish i can do that =S
gl with all ur other performances =P
Shadowzzz2213 3 years ago
I agree with x3AMx, it should be an octave lower. Other than that I think it's just about right.
WitchNamine 3 years ago 5
Do you have the sheet of music for this song?If you have it can you send it to me please
Lovywoman3 3 years ago
not bad ;P
p0k3Ndi3 3 years ago
Where's the sheet music for this?
Murtaghrcksmysox 3 years ago
Waaaay better than what i could do, but i think you need to go back to the drawing board...nice try though :)
malibuXoXobabe 3 years ago
you ROCK dude!!
x'D
anajordinson 3 years ago
Beautiful
I like this song hard rock, instrumental, and piano. Dude you rock!!!
5/5 and fav ^^
DifferentSoldier 3 years ago 2
DUDE U ROCK
Blackscars2007 4 years ago 3
Try playing it all an octave lower. It's supposed to be dark and pretty: that's where real emphasis with the bass should come in. Also you've kind of given it a dancebeat almost, where it's supposed to be slower..
Patterns with the left hand and major dynamic change would hurt either. As an option:for only section of the song,a higher and slightly faster melody could be very beautiful. When I did this,I found that gives it a musicbox like effect.Great job figuring it out though.You have an ear.
x3AMx 4 years ago 22
very well played!! it's really wonerfull!
xxGreatz
Biancaah36 4 years ago 2
It's played in a different pitch and it sounds kind of sad now. I like it.
ffyr 4 years ago 2
can u please make a tutorial on how to play this and send me a message when u make it??
D34D5H0T 4 years ago
thats really good
keep up the good work
cute1fairy 4 years ago 3
niceeee
TheilluSioNisT515 4 years ago 2
kool
maxhalo3 4 years ago
this is really good
susanxnguyen 4 years ago
can u show us how u to play it? :3
Anbugurl 4 years ago 2
do you know the notes for this song or somewhere i could find them? cuz i cant... lol
gni13 4 years ago
That was the best cover of Diary of Jane I've ever seen. Great job man.
MRB4DDAZZ 4 years ago
Thank you :)
jcou041 4 years ago
frickin awesome!!!!!!!
mark92atdads 4 years ago
you play very well ^^ could you make a tutorial? (please!!!)
aLiRa15 4 years ago
idk if i commented before but im just relooking this amazing job. i think i did and i can play the same thing. but yours has more notes and harmonies. its a beautiful song and its my favorite. great job!!!!
bubblytar 4 years ago
DAMN THATS FREAKING AWSOME DUDE
phatgur142 4 years ago
could u please PLEASE send me the sheet music for this???? i love this!!!
vampiregazer 4 years ago
I dont have any sheet music. If i did I would have sent it !!!
jcou041 4 years ago
5 STARS!
Great job dude.
You're probably not goingto answer to this, but I'm curious if you've made the sheet music. If you have, I would be extremely greatful if you could send it to me.
Great job again. And I'm not just saying that because I want sheet msuic. I'm serious.
SurooshX 4 years ago
Alot less mistacks than another guy I watched. He seemed full of himself.
clarkkent163000 4 years ago
yea i just realized that. it was supposed to be a joke but i can see where you get that. i fixed it =P
rando76x 4 years ago
u roooooooock \m/
passsant 4 years ago
You're playing the acoustic version in the "Do you like that" part. Try playing the original. Dude, you rock, don't give up, make another.
ashwinrk92 4 years ago
um, maybe it is different... FUCK! i cant make up my mind... yeah, its not the same
whitnizz08 4 years ago
i totally take back everything i just said... i am retarded...
whitnizz08 4 years ago
it sounds like your playing with ben's voice, not the original piano... did you learn it by ear?
whitnizz08 4 years ago
A lot of piano songs are that way.. It's just the song. Who cares.
AnastasiaExpert 4 years ago
omg where can i get sheet music for this? this is the best
mi3pwns 4 years ago
ur really good!!
LetterBOMB611 4 years ago
Do you have an MP3 file for this? =]
NaruSaku 4 years ago
my rival... lol
rando76x 4 years ago
it's in a different key from the original, but still good. did you learn that by ear? cause it seems different to the original as well.
littleLISE89 4 years ago
AWESOMEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
shutupandsmilex 4 years ago
omfg.
0_0 i didnt even know it was possible
Diary of jane on piano...
crazy. XD
You proved me wrong.
YEah, all i gotta say is, play a lil slower and with more emotion. ^^
Piano = feelings. xD
chaosblade234 4 years ago
there is an actual acoustic version of this if you knew about it, breaking benjamin did a piano/string kinda thing.
jarrad888 4 years ago
ohhh snapp. xD thanks for the info.
chaosblade234 4 years ago
its acoustic, of course its on piano :p
blacknight089 4 years ago 2
from :53 on is my favorite part, so basically the whole vid...nice.
waffleboys 4 years ago
I want to get the sheet music for this.. anyone, do u know where to get the sheet music for breaking benjamin or evanescence? please please!!!
Aino333 4 years ago
man i have not stopped listening to this
jakealake1 4 years ago
very nice
jakealake1 4 years ago
What are tabs?
antispoilerboy 4 years ago
for some reason piano Diary of Jane sounds like beauty in the beast ...just the beginning.
Sw0rdnemesis 4 years ago
dude could you pleas gek me a sheet of this pleas pleas pleas
thnx brian
BBMM16 4 years ago
nice job
direeye 4 years ago
amazing :]
whitelightr 4 years ago
noob, i play guitar and piano...piano is ALOT HARDER alot, guitar tabs r easy to read...r tard... and to the video GREAT JOB i thought u cood of put more emotion into it otherwise amazing
thisissk8ing11 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it depends on the person playing. But as of now, the piano is still the easiest instrument to play.
evenlir 4 years ago
who has the sheet music for this song?
tdg16 4 years ago
This is probably the best that I have heard/seen out of any other video of this is on YouTube. Much appreciated if the Tabs are provided.
Eternitron 4 years ago
I dont know how to do tabs seriously if i did I wud hav put that up lol :(
jcou041 4 years ago
Well on a Piano it's a lot easier than on a Guitar. A Piano has the Keys with Letters of A B C D E F G and the black ones like f flat or d flat or something. Just like write what the order is and there you go. You have Piano Tabs :P
Eternitron 4 years ago
Obviously, you don't know much about the common notation for notes on piano.
There's a lot more to it; you need to take care of measures, tone lengths, time signatures, and it's a lot of work, even with simple tools like Guitar Pro or Sibelius.
LeMonkehUX 4 years ago
I don't think anyone asked you. Simply put, get the notes, and then play them in the way they are and anyone could just figure out how it really should be played. -.-
Eternitron 4 years ago
Aiye, but your wrong lad.
Iv been at this piano business for 11 years now maybe?
The key signatures and timing are a big part of it.
You dont wanna be playing the bass part of the verse, and the opening on your right hand do you?
Timing, is a big part of the piano, even in freestyle.
Eternitron, id have to agree that Monkeh know's his card's better then you lad.
KSakamada 4 years ago
not that simple bud. play piano for several years and you'll find it complicated. not to say that guitar isnt complicated as well, i play both. i prefer piano, and find it more challenging. but whatever. my opinion.
missxriot 4 years ago
can you send me the tabs for that?
SpiveyWhiplash 4 years ago
really awesome!
Michelwankt 4 years ago
mann! wish i could do that!! great job!!
BreakinBenjaminBabe 4 years ago
cOoL yAh aWeSoMe
mHaYk001 4 years ago
whoever that was is a balla and maybe add some vocals to that dawg see what you got man great job
playafasho88 4 years ago
That's probably because this piano is out of tune.
pesavento177 4 years ago
it sounds more scarier on your piano than the original for some reason but its really cool
kkkoutofkkk 4 years ago
dude it sounds cooler the way you did it than the acual song dude this is going to my favorites man good work
Schlotty81 4 years ago
hey its shlotzerrrrrrrr
easterbunny7 4 years ago
I love thissss
ONNIHOLTTA 4 years ago
you can play piano super well!!!!! coool!!
ONNIHOLTTA 4 years ago
cool! you can do it! yyyyyou can! can! can!!! yaaaaaah yayah!
ONNIHOLTTA 4 years ago
That Was Horrible m8, just digusting! how dare you play.... nah just kidding... this was abosolutely amazing.., it really was. great job cuz.
ArrozConPollo89 4 years ago
hahaha i was about to like freak XD i love this comment so much though, makes your eyes pop until you read the rest =p
jonanaface 4 years ago
wow. brilliant
MasterofCarrots 4 years ago
That is really good!
Beetleburger 4 years ago
It just hit me at one point during the playing and I just said "Oh Sh!t" thats all I could think of saying. Which is actually pretty sad, I should not cuss. Very good job though, I cried.
rustilldown7 4 years ago
hey, it's beautiful! =)
do you have the notes?
Chelsinka 4 years ago
Absolutely lovely.
asphy20 4 years ago
thats amazing dude i've been trying to play this for a long time but no success think you could give me some music or something please?
pesavento177 4 years ago
can you give me an idea of how to play this?
llama62 4 years ago
Amazing, this is bttr than any other accoustic version I heard, except for the real one. It sounds rlly nice! and to think u did that by ear.....
Anyways 5 stars :P
venomiously 4 years ago
thank you
jcou041 4 years ago
one word... WOW
cartoonfan365 4 years ago
wow thts just genius , wish i cud do tht it well done very very yoo got a numba one fan right ere i love it its pure amazing x
myfinalwish01 4 years ago
cheers thanks
jcou041 4 years ago
Very nice, keep up the good work!
mjamesf1 4 years ago
amazing
toanss 4 years ago
sweet
darksith007 4 years ago
very impressive especially considering you did this by ear very good job i give it 5 stars
Storms15 4 years ago
Really nice played..and relaxing:))
Rokkec 4 years ago
yea this version, listen 2 the non-acoustic that 1 is more exciting, this version 2 me has more of a nostalgic feel makes you think of the past and of what youve done
Storms15 4 years ago
awesome
alexfreeman007 4 years ago
this is soo cool...i want this sheet music
BenBurneylover14 4 years ago
I dont have any sheet music for this I did it by ear
jcou041 4 years ago
u did that by ear.. thats unbelievable. 5 star
cartoonfan365 4 years ago
do you have the sheet music for this or do know where to find it? you play this song so well its fantastic.
benburnleyschick 4 years ago
awesome, do you have the sheet music?
charles4747 4 years ago
nope :(
jcou041 4 years ago
hey i know that you don't have the sheet music, but i was wondering if you could record it again from a top view of the song to help us out.
polishstud89 4 years ago
I might try doing that, just not keeping 2 well of late, will do wen im fine :)
jcou041 4 years ago
Do You Have Sheet Music For IT??...plz...
ss8421 4 years ago
no :(
jcou041 4 years ago
Only critism: Use a metronome buddy. Timing is the most important factor to music, it's WAY more important than the music itself. But really good job either way, keep it up! :)
GroundBeef14 4 years ago
Yeah good point, but usually when youre playing live - adrenaline usually drives the tempo - if u get what i mean. Still fair criticism, point taken :)
jcou041 4 years ago
Yeah yeah of course, that's why I hate how they make Chad play with a click track when every breathing fan of BB knows damn well Chad can easily keep them on tempo, and still have the live feel.
GroundBeef14 4 years ago
AWESOME!!!
xxMoonlitShadowxx 4 years ago
Dude, if you have the piano music, can you email it to i_am_jane_doe@hotmail? Thank you thank you thank you! Oh, and by the way, you play this really well! XD
WeAreJaneDoe 4 years ago
waa well done ... seriously wish i could find d sheet of music for it...waa it was gr8 keep it up
angelofmusic007 4 years ago