There's something about the way she says "I hated you, loved you too" that I just love. The look on her face, the way she sings, her eyes, the lyrics, the music, is freaking hypnotizing me!
Kate Bush is amazing! Really love this song, so I actually covered it on my latest concert. Please check it out! Love from Scandinavia <3 youtube.com/watch?v=JiDdxshjCio
How many of you also get pictures of Cathy and Heathcliff running towards each other on The Dave Allen Show? Anyhow great song. I always wanted to see Kate Bush in the role of Kathy. Then the movie could end with her singing this song outside the windows in the wind... Maybe even with Heathcliff howling like a crazy wolf towards the moon. Now that would be epic aesthetics ;)
I remeber seeing this on Top of the Pops in 1978 and thinking "what the hell is this crap???" By the time it had finished a few minutes later I thought it was fantastic. Once you know wht the song is about, it works!
florence and the machine, she sings everything as loud as possible, everything she does sounds the same, listen to the diversity of kate, every track is different as is every album,
is it just me or do I see just a tiny little connect with Florence + the Machine...ie unique voice...great music...wonderful lyrics? LOVED Kate forever...really like F + M now.
We live in a world where the word "genius" is thrown around for virtually any reason. And all the while Kate's there as the real thing. I don't know how these songs were written. They're not just good, they contain actual magic!
kate is and always has been amazing, Lady Gaga, all been done before and much better, stupid costumes, grace jones, elton john, etc, take away all the electronics and theres not much left,
@The51brian YES thankyou!!! Gaga, Beyonce, Rihhanna, Adele etc etc etc so overrated and dumb. Adele aside, all they sing about is sex, boys, partying and more sex. I'm in my 20's and i despise music of today, sometimes it makes me wish music never exsisted. Kate Bush is genius and her music will live on.
Never have I seen a woman who is so gorgeous, sexy, beautiful, scary and talented all at the same time......absolutely incredible.....those eyes!....that voice!!
Can' t help thinking she was sending herself up with the eye rolling routine etc I expect she was fed up with the piss-poor band. Still KB is more erotic sitting down than than the rest of today's pop tarts gyrating in their g-strings put together.
@bearfog07 she wasn't discovered by pink Floyd she was discovered by Andy McKay from roxy music but you are right about the talent check out an oz band called the jezabels not the same ..but similar and independent cheers
@cellulitehero From Wikipedia: "... During this time her family produced a demo tape with over 50 of her compositions, which was turned down by record labels. David Gilmour of Pink Floyd received the demo from Ricky Hopper, a mutual friend of Gilmour and the Bush family. Impressed with what he heard, Gilmour helped the sixteen-year-old Bush get a more professional-sounding demo tape recorded that would be more saleable to the record companies."
The music industry died in 1980. It is now being run totally by business people who have only one things on their mind, which is money and status. They are NOT music lovers. They could care less about quality of music, quality of voices, or even creative people. This is just watered-down entertainment for people. It is only an entertainment industry selling entertainers. Anyone who knows music really well, not commericalism, knows this. It has always been a business but this corrupt.
@MantiaRyche Is anyone else getting downright fed up with Lady bloody Gaga being mentioned in every music fans. Message to the Gaga fanboys, music existed for a long time before Gaga, and will remain when (hopefully soon) Gaga is forgotten.
Yes, I am getting sick of it. Cant even go to an Amy Grant without seeing her name somewhere. They talk about her as she re-invented pop music. Theres nothing new that Gaga does that Madonna has not done the last 20-30 years.
@MantiaRyche I remember when Madonna first started (showing my age there), and there wasnt even the same over the top stuff that the Gaga fans are doing now. Madonna had quite a it of shock, controversy and discussion, but there wasn't the slavish cultlike following like the Gaga lot.
I remember being amazed in 1978 watching this on top of the pops when I was 14, still think Kate is incredible. True ground breaker that set standards.
Kate in Babooshka sells crotch. In the video Breathing, she is wearing a see through outfit. In the Man with the Child in your Eyes, she is wearing another see through outfit, and when she is on stage in other videos she is wearing another bodysuit with her buttock hanging out.
She puts foul language in her music and seems like just another sell out pop star with water-down music. If you want to hear real artists who are not selling crotch visit my channel Thankyou.
love the way she just stares in to the camera and hardly looks down at her piano :) Kate you are such an amazing, talented, beautiful woman i love you <3 X
@fondoogle lady gaga is shit but looks wise theyre kinda on a par, I used to have the utmost dislike of gaga until I saw some youtube video showing her without the make up and stupid costumes, shes actually really quite hot, but what would you expect from someone whos italian
@fondoogle Be careful with what you are saying here. I don't want Gaga to prove you and me otherwise by molesting this song in a video with 25 one-legged transsexual vampire cannibals doing an Inca dance while she wearing a Golden Gate bridge dress with coconut sunglasses.
@fondoogle are u for real?! have you seen gaga live? u realise she writes all her own material? composes.. directs her own music videos. and tony bennet has named her the most talented women he has met.. named her a musical genius.. not my words.. his! both are awesome. gaga is overlooked because her costumes when really shes a classically trained pianist.. her voice is .. quiet something. don't be ignorant and bash other artist for what?
Lady Gaga does nothing but market mini skirts for 12 year olds. Yes she writes her own music, but wheres her fucking dignity? Too busy being " weird" and "freaky" to realise that 80% of her fans are under 15's who do everything she does. Including sucking black dick every friday not and wearing as little as possible. She's a shit role model and shouldn't be market to children by her record label.
@fondoogle market mini skirts for 12 yr olds? hahahah what? my mother.. 36.. big fan.. been to two of her concerts.. more than i have. i guess people like different things and thats okay. gaga stands up for equality. she has changed a law in america, what artist that just cares about money would do that? would put there career on the line? she did. gay marriage is now legal in new york thanks to her. her song born this way has an amazing message. she actually makes me feel good about myself
@shinznay I'm sure lady gaga fans would find it an amazing achievement for humanity that gay marriage is now legal in ny, how could the world live without this? Wow! Next thing you know you will be comparing her to Jesus and Buddha or even worshiping her as God.
@sorihewi I think gay marriage is an amazing achievement. Gay people were being arbitrarily arrested forty years ago for no other reason than because they were gay. That said, I don't think she changed the law only by herself, nor do I think she is any where near as talented as Kate Bush. I think Gaga has done a lot for equality, though.
@patrickwright1 ok Patrick, fair enuf, but this is not about gays or lady gaga let's get back to the topic/purpose of this page/video. This is about one of the most beautiful pieces of art that has ever landed on this world. Watch it again. It's flawless.
As I stated, I don't care much what the public thinks. I just listened to Pat Benatar's cover on youtube, and I do not feel that she nails this song either. Its own creator ought to have done so, but blew it. I thought Kate created a more fitting ambience, but this notion that Cathy's ghost would have sounded just like Minnie Mouse, is just plain wacky. Says who? Certainly not Emily.
All this bitching! Honestly! Kate Bush is a briliant ethereal lady wtih a voice that makes me sit up and take notice and this song is sublime- Loved seeing her in all her batty wonder on MOR shows like TOTP! Go Kate!
Time for a bit of honesty hear, Kate has a squeaky voice which might improve with some training, but maybe permanently useless. The song itself but is basically ridiculous, random, barely comprehensive. This is like a scrap book of ideas for a song cut and paste together. Needs alot more work.
@brunobaritono Agree her voice is a bit off in this live version. Have you read the book though? The song really only makes sense if you're familiar with the story. In that context it is perfect.
@susanita359 her voice is a bit off lol ? not many people can sing this gud just stood there , let alone playing piano at same time plus keep track of which camera to follow lol the woman is brilliant,
@brunobaritono I totally agree that Kate needs vocal coaching--10 octaves or whatever are no use if the upper registers sound this squeaky. But to dis the song itself when you evidently have never read "Wuthering Heights", well that is somewhere it is not advisable to go. The song lyrics are unquestionably evocative of many of the things Cathy Earnshaw said in the novel, or her ghost did, when it she was urging Mr. Lockwood to "Let me in at your window." I think you meant to say:
(the song lyrics are) barely comprehensible, as "barely comprehensive" makes no sense in that sentence. But there is nothing random OR cut-and-pasted as in a scrapbook, about the ideas, they all fit that gloomy and passionate, dark novel's very essence.
@fancifulfilly Perhaps you should listen to all of the different variety of Kate songs and her singing voice on them before saying she needs vocal coaching.
@ggarlick46 I have heard her singing other songs. I had the album "The Kick Inside" on vinyl. No, Kate does not sound this way on all the tracks, but that does not make up for the fact that her voice sounds squeaky on this one. She wrote a truly inspired song, and then ruined it. Sorry, but I cannot reconcile that voice to Cathy Earnshaw's character. Nor do I like her campy, over-the-top, caricature-like antics on the video , for the same reason. The novel is gloomy, gothic.
@ggarlick46 As I was saying, the song shared many traits with the novel, but the video was campy, sharply contrasting with the mood of the song. And, I maintain, that in this song, she wrote most of it in too high a register for her to avoid sounding squeaky. This is all a matter of taste, I grant you, but it is not to mine.
@fancifulfilly Well all I can say is you had the album "The Kick Inside" so you must have liked Kates early songs.As for ruining Wuthering Heights with her singing, you must be joking! A no 1 hit on her first ever single,and its been one of her classic songs ever since, and the one that no one else can imitate with any degree of success.
@ggarlick46 Afraid I am not...joking that is. But, before you let that get you wrapped around the axle, remember what the Romans said: "De gustibus non est disputandum." Obviously Kate has proven that she can sing, on other tracks. Obviously some people like even the squeaking. I just don't happen to be one of 'em. If she had passed on trying to sing like a coloratura, which she ain't, and stuck with her more dulcet tones, it would have been a happier outcome. In my OWN opinion.
@fancifulfilly I have to comment on your point about the video being 'campy'. Wasn't that really the case for pretty much most of videos that came out in the late 70's and well into the mid-80's? What was portrayed on MTV was generally always something conjured up in the mind of the video's producer, rather than a lock-step reflectance on the song at hand. Yes, there were exceptions, but that was the norm for videos at the time.
@ralphyboy25 Most of the videos of that era WERE rather over-the-top, but nobody forced Kate to act all "hammy", and clownish. It just does not fit with the mood of the song. Unless, of course, I just am missing the point of the song, and this song really was intended to spoof the novel, rather than capture the mood of it. Hey, I don't care if everyone and his dog went out and bought the single; plenty of people bought Tiny Tim, too. The public's taste is nothing to me.
So, you remember ol' Tiny Tim? I never forgot him, but not because I liked his silly, campy, trilling, rather because he made me laugh. Lots!! About 30 years after he was popular, the discount store Ames had these Christmas-time commercials, featuring Scrooge and Tiny Tim, where the Tiny Tim was not a frail boy, but Tiny Tim the entertainer with a ukelele, trilling "Deck the Halls". It was so silly that every time I would see it, I would near ROTFLMAO.
@ralphyboy25, I don't know why youtube did not automatically address you at the beginning of my last reply, when I clicked "reply". I had to do this one manually..weird.
@brunobaritono wat u talking about mate this song needs alot more work it was written and sung 35 years ago , and as for having a sqeaky voice kates one of the worlds greatest singer, song writers i highly doubt , infact i know she doest need voice training haha thats like saying pele cant play football or muhammad ali cant box .....
Hi, I am Marisa. I love music.I am an very artistic person who was born with some natural talent in singing and writing. Let me know what you think of my personal site. Please let me know if you thnk that she is better than I am vocally etc...Or if you think that I am superior vocally and creatively, let me know. If you think we are equals, let me know! I value your opinion. I have photos, and you can also let me know if you like my image or if you prefer famous people's images.
There's something about the way she says "I hated you, loved you too" that I just love. The look on her face, the way she sings, her eyes, the lyrics, the music, is freaking hypnotizing me!
HellHound90666 9 hours ago
she must get sick of that song
jellybean2423 3 days ago
Amazing is not the word to describe Kate Bush unique is the word thank you to this gracious lady for all she did
jppichardie 3 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Kate Bush is amazing! Really love this song, so I actually covered it on my latest concert. Please check it out! Love from Scandinavia <3 youtube.com/watch?v=JiDdxshjCio
IsabelleSjalander 4 days ago
I can't stop imagining her lips around my cock.......
staffsmole 4 days ago 2
@staffsmole me too and I don't even have one.
ohmygodfatherscat 3 days ago
@ohmygodfatherscat haha
TheRazzberet 3 days ago
does anyone else see charlotte church???
es78xx 5 days ago
@es78xx you are kidding of course
TheRazzberet 3 days ago
Reminds me O My Laurel Mac T...xoxoxoxo
2427301 6 days ago
i wanna face fuck her
hmmmmyeahbaby22 1 week ago
This girl caused her people some headaches when she wouldn't take the plane. Unique songstress though.
wombah0070 1 week ago
BIG!!! BIG KATE BUSH..
randazzovideo 1 week ago
How many of you also get pictures of Cathy and Heathcliff running towards each other on The Dave Allen Show? Anyhow great song. I always wanted to see Kate Bush in the role of Kathy. Then the movie could end with her singing this song outside the windows in the wind... Maybe even with Heathcliff howling like a crazy wolf towards the moon. Now that would be epic aesthetics ;)
edbbob 1 week ago
Beautiful genius.
curetril 1 week ago
superbement déjantée !
IBoXIDPhiL 1 week ago
She is still beautiful. Not just for her age!
mrwells111 1 week ago
Kate is and wil be the bestt singing feanle voice in the 90:thies!
agdaah01 1 week ago
this video's thumbnail is precious
dosadikejar 1 week ago
I remeber seeing this on Top of the Pops in 1978 and thinking "what the hell is this crap???" By the time it had finished a few minutes later I thought it was fantastic. Once you know wht the song is about, it works!
MrSpidron 1 week ago
@MrSpidron I agree ,the same happened to me but what a song it is.such a good singer and gorgeous.
brighton43 1 week ago
Me ziu cariu ca puompa. Come dimenticarla? :)
(PS dedicata al nurri)
moifrapax 2 weeks ago
She is sooo beautiful. And her music is timeless. Edmonton Circa1978 Roller Drome.
2427301 2 weeks ago
All Lifes Very Best All The Time...
MYENDLESSPATH 2 weeks ago
ależ ona jest paskudna... :)
irys2015 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
ianmob12 2 weeks ago
Christ alive
moofEU 2 weeks ago
The best lips in the world!
steeplepossum39 2 weeks ago
A very mysterious person who doesn't take of her clothes like others do.She's lovely!
steeplepossum39 2 weeks ago
oddly enough her voice sounds more surreal than it ever did nowadays.
dnrobs 2 weeks ago
ABSOLUTLY AMAZING WOMEN, will always love and respect this lady, her dancing, her songs, her poetic use of words are all in my heart forever.x
michelledubignon 2 weeks ago
Kate Bush doing Kate Bush like only Kate Bush can. Brilliant!
SocietyPages 2 weeks ago
Good, but what is this lady on?
Tigresswoman97 2 weeks ago
What an amazing beautiful voice.
Gammasnarf 2 weeks ago
florence and the machine, she sings everything as loud as possible, everything she does sounds the same, listen to the diversity of kate, every track is different as is every album,
The51brian 2 weeks ago
Unless you've actually read Wuthering Heights or seen the film then this song is just confusing.
RedHairedDreamer 2 weeks ago
AAAH!!! back when a song's lyrics had meaning and substance rather than thuggish rap music v injected in every other verse.
hatinae 2 weeks ago
is it just me or do I see just a tiny little connect with Florence + the Machine...ie unique voice...great music...wonderful lyrics? LOVED Kate forever...really like F + M now.
49gdawg 2 weeks ago
We live in a world where the word "genius" is thrown around for virtually any reason. And all the while Kate's there as the real thing. I don't know how these songs were written. They're not just good, they contain actual magic!
evansdm2008 3 weeks ago 6
@evansdm2008 Well said.
fabulousgerro661 5 days ago
kate is and always has been amazing, Lady Gaga, all been done before and much better, stupid costumes, grace jones, elton john, etc, take away all the electronics and theres not much left,
The51brian 3 weeks ago
@The51brian YES thankyou!!! Gaga, Beyonce, Rihhanna, Adele etc etc etc so overrated and dumb. Adele aside, all they sing about is sex, boys, partying and more sex. I'm in my 20's and i despise music of today, sometimes it makes me wish music never exsisted. Kate Bush is genius and her music will live on.
Tabitha43 2 weeks ago
She makes the best faces when she looks at the camera.
Avmasss 3 weeks ago
i miss the cartwheel
maxgrand2007 3 weeks ago
Never have I seen a woman who is so gorgeous, sexy, beautiful, scary and talented all at the same time......absolutely incredible.....those eyes!....that voice!!
Doodsydownunder 3 weeks ago
@Doodsydownunder True.
Omega7772 3 weeks ago
kate is such an amazing singer and her voice suited every song she sang like here music so long now
earleybird66 3 weeks ago
She's incredible the way she hits those notes.....love to see some of the pop tarts polluting the charts these days try and sing like this.
Doodsydownunder 3 weeks ago
man why cant we have music liek this today??? where did the real mueic artist go???
d0gm34t 3 weeks ago
@d0gm34t
I used to think like you..But there are alot of great artists out there today as well but you wont them in the charts. You need to dig deeper...
MantiaRyche 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the tia-anna parody is much better than noel fieldings, but the original is still brilliant
danmas86 3 weeks ago
She looks kinda alien
JamesT2460 3 weeks ago
Can' t help thinking she was sending herself up with the eye rolling routine etc I expect she was fed up with the piss-poor band. Still KB is more erotic sitting down than than the rest of today's pop tarts gyrating in their g-strings put together.
StoatOnToast 4 weeks ago 13
@bearfog07 she wasn't discovered by pink Floyd she was discovered by Andy McKay from roxy music but you are right about the talent check out an oz band called the jezabels not the same ..but similar and independent cheers
cellulitehero 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
guitarandgraves 3 weeks ago
@cellulitehero From Wikipedia: "... During this time her family produced a demo tape with over 50 of her compositions, which was turned down by record labels. David Gilmour of Pink Floyd received the demo from Ricky Hopper, a mutual friend of Gilmour and the Bush family. Impressed with what he heard, Gilmour helped the sixteen-year-old Bush get a more professional-sounding demo tape recorded that would be more saleable to the record companies."
guitarandgraves 3 weeks ago
I totally love this song.... What a voice, great artist!:-))
I realise suddenly that my make-up is still very 1978... :-))
Blessed Be;
Althea )0(
AltheaHekate 4 weeks ago
Gotta love those eyes!!
tayarinecr 1 month ago
I was 8 but who cares, Kate Bush presented a song that remains in my memory from my time in Scotland , one year exodus.
ikkiso 1 month ago
aleister crowley would've loved her....
moonboots69 1 month ago
still like this song
grijzecanta 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The music industry died in 1980. It is now being run totally by business people who have only one things on their mind, which is money and status. They are NOT music lovers. They could care less about quality of music, quality of voices, or even creative people. This is just watered-down entertainment for people. It is only an entertainment industry selling entertainers. Anyone who knows music really well, not commericalism, knows this. It has always been a business but this corrupt.
peoniesfleur 1 month ago
Comment removed
sorihewi 1 month ago
Simply beautiful and she sings like an angel
TheSteviet123 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
BokKejte..
pishmolj 1 month ago
BokKejte..
pishmolj 1 month ago
What a song, and such a beautiful voice! It's a shame now music is dead
baldenscare 1 month ago
What a talent and she was discovered by Pink Floyd, a legendary band
bearfog07 1 month ago
I think this is the most gorgeous thing I've seen in this life...
sorihewi 1 month ago 20
@sorihewi Can't disagree with that, she's just so beautiful.
kwackaboy 3 weeks ago
@sorihewi me too
HYPERJOHNBASS 2 weeks ago
Our Lay Gaga of the 70tees,
Kashmir1907 1 month ago
@Kashmir1907 Sorry but Lady Gaga doesn't get even close to her...
sorihewi 1 month ago
@Kashmir1907
Lady Gaga could never touch Kate.
Besides Kate Bush had real originality, Gaga on the other is basically just a Madonna clone.
MantiaRyche 1 month ago
@MantiaRyche Is anyone else getting downright fed up with Lady bloody Gaga being mentioned in every music fans. Message to the Gaga fanboys, music existed for a long time before Gaga, and will remain when (hopefully soon) Gaga is forgotten.
jadefalconmk1 3 weeks ago
@jadefalconmk1
Yes, I am getting sick of it. Cant even go to an Amy Grant without seeing her name somewhere. They talk about her as she re-invented pop music. Theres nothing new that Gaga does that Madonna has not done the last 20-30 years.
MantiaRyche 3 weeks ago
@MantiaRyche
*video
MantiaRyche 3 weeks ago
@MantiaRyche I remember when Madonna first started (showing my age there), and there wasnt even the same over the top stuff that the Gaga fans are doing now. Madonna had quite a it of shock, controversy and discussion, but there wasn't the slavish cultlike following like the Gaga lot.
jadefalconmk1 3 weeks ago
I remember being amazed in 1978 watching this on top of the pops when I was 14, still think Kate is incredible. True ground breaker that set standards.
0963tinkerbell 1 month ago 2
4th play in a row and I'm still buzzing.
matrags 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Kate in Babooshka sells crotch. In the video Breathing, she is wearing a see through outfit. In the Man with the Child in your Eyes, she is wearing another see through outfit, and when she is on stage in other videos she is wearing another bodysuit with her buttock hanging out.
She puts foul language in her music and seems like just another sell out pop star with water-down music. If you want to hear real artists who are not selling crotch visit my channel Thankyou.
peoniesfleur 1 month ago
@fritz51304! Danke fuer den Text !
gilamonster001 1 month ago
Her lips! Holy shit!
heartsthatbleed87 1 month ago
Pure genius and complete class. 1978? Beats the poop out of anything from 2012.
MrJML72 1 month ago
1:10 pahahahahaha :) she crazy.
Otterley07 1 month ago
play it again, play it again!
ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh where did music go X-/
cagonzl 1 month ago 2
Kate is hot here
lombard605 1 month ago
fuck lady gaga...viva kate
iatlos 1 month ago
oh ! those lips.. She's FAB
brattslapper 1 month ago 2
love the way she just stares in to the camera and hardly looks down at her piano :) Kate you are such an amazing, talented, beautiful woman i love you <3 X
hannahhazlehurst 1 month ago 2
Dear God, thanks for Kate's voice!
omertahistoriamafii 1 month ago 2
back when pop music reached it's peak in creativity
1manfactory 1 month ago 2
if im not mistaken no one even can sing in eight octaves, let alone ten.
EveryLosersDream 1 month ago
@EveryLosersDream She sings over 9000 octivz!
Khyrid 1 month ago
Kippevel,...te gek!
depasafe 1 month ago in playlist Meer video's van fritz51304
was she a jew??
kosak0 1 month ago in playlist MUZYKA
She is one of the best songbirds I've ever heard!
noranekoolga 1 month ago 2
i didnt know kate bush can play a piano lol ha cool
jamie12345950 1 month ago
i don't understand , when i was a child i hear this song,and his voice is not like that !!
MsChamallow 1 month ago
lindooooooooooooooooo
milton49santista 1 month ago
WOW live gesungen..super
10ramses8 1 month ago
great song - still today!
mctomaz 1 month ago
Instant boner
yeclix 1 month ago
makes you realise how shit lady gaga is.
fondoogle 1 month ago 72
@fondoogle
Absolutely!
GamesFrontiers 1 month ago
@fondoogle THE BEST COMMENT EVER, THANK U
dio666able 1 month ago
@fondoogle Yeeah! Hahaha! Best comment ever :-)
Lampodikt 1 month ago
@fondoogle lady gaga is shit but looks wise theyre kinda on a par, I used to have the utmost dislike of gaga until I saw some youtube video showing her without the make up and stupid costumes, shes actually really quite hot, but what would you expect from someone whos italian
PhrozenPhlanges 1 month ago
@fondoogle Be careful with what you are saying here. I don't want Gaga to prove you and me otherwise by molesting this song in a video with 25 one-legged transsexual vampire cannibals doing an Inca dance while she wearing a Golden Gate bridge dress with coconut sunglasses.
Mrpretpakket 1 month ago 26
@Mrpretpakket pffffft now i want to see that with my buddies while drunk. We're gonna have a hell of a laugh.
s4pil4ut 1 month ago
@Mrpretpakket
Ahahaha
strauss12345 1 month ago
@Mrpretpakket lol..you forgot the triple camel toe...lol
luc649 2 weeks ago
@fondoogle are u for real?! have you seen gaga live? u realise she writes all her own material? composes.. directs her own music videos. and tony bennet has named her the most talented women he has met.. named her a musical genius.. not my words.. his! both are awesome. gaga is overlooked because her costumes when really shes a classically trained pianist.. her voice is .. quiet something. don't be ignorant and bash other artist for what?
shinznay 1 month ago
@shinznay
Lady Gaga does nothing but market mini skirts for 12 year olds. Yes she writes her own music, but wheres her fucking dignity? Too busy being " weird" and "freaky" to realise that 80% of her fans are under 15's who do everything she does. Including sucking black dick every friday not and wearing as little as possible. She's a shit role model and shouldn't be market to children by her record label.
Alas, anything for a quick dollar these days.
Fucking disgrace.
fondoogle 1 month ago
@fondoogle market mini skirts for 12 yr olds? hahahah what? my mother.. 36.. big fan.. been to two of her concerts.. more than i have. i guess people like different things and thats okay. gaga stands up for equality. she has changed a law in america, what artist that just cares about money would do that? would put there career on the line? she did. gay marriage is now legal in new york thanks to her. her song born this way has an amazing message. she actually makes me feel good about myself
shinznay 1 month ago
@shinznay I'm sure lady gaga fans would find it an amazing achievement for humanity that gay marriage is now legal in ny, how could the world live without this? Wow! Next thing you know you will be comparing her to Jesus and Buddha or even worshiping her as God.
sorihewi 1 month ago
@sorihewi I think gay marriage is an amazing achievement. Gay people were being arbitrarily arrested forty years ago for no other reason than because they were gay. That said, I don't think she changed the law only by herself, nor do I think she is any where near as talented as Kate Bush. I think Gaga has done a lot for equality, though.
patrickwright1 1 month ago 2
Comment removed
sorihewi 1 month ago
Comment removed
sorihewi 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@patrickwright1 ok Patrick, fair enuf, but this is not about gays or lady gaga let's get back to the topic/purpose of this page/video. This is about one of the most beautiful pieces of art that has ever landed on this world. Watch it again. It's flawless.
sorihewi 1 month ago
Comment removed
sorihewi 1 month ago
Comment removed
patrickwright1 1 month ago
@fondoogle mmm, I'd prefer kids of mine to listen to her music and learn from her message of acceptance than be influenced by a racist like you.
patrickwright1 1 month ago
@fondoogle Gaga is a bratty Italian egotistical b*tch just like Madonna
mkerna 1 month ago 2
@fondoogle Agreed
computersolutions164 3 weeks ago
This song gives me the chills but in a good kind of way. I can't stop listening to it and I don't even like the story of Wuthering Heights that much.
kaceyrain1 1 month ago
Simon Lane sent me
icecreamcancer 1 month ago 16
@icecreamcancer whos simon lane?
LAhannah1 1 month ago
Amazing voice - great song!
TheJuergen62 1 month ago
shut up guys. 10 octaves comment is just hyperbole i'm sure -___-
TSAsian10 1 month ago
this octave crap interests me, how many octaves does mariah carey reach in her prime?
leNOIRfae 1 month ago
As I stated, I don't care much what the public thinks. I just listened to Pat Benatar's cover on youtube, and I do not feel that she nails this song either. Its own creator ought to have done so, but blew it. I thought Kate created a more fitting ambience, but this notion that Cathy's ghost would have sounded just like Minnie Mouse, is just plain wacky. Says who? Certainly not Emily.
fancifulfilly 2 months ago
All this bitching! Honestly! Kate Bush is a briliant ethereal lady wtih a voice that makes me sit up and take notice and this song is sublime- Loved seeing her in all her batty wonder on MOR shows like TOTP! Go Kate!
MulBerrie 2 months ago
Lovely to hear an un-autotuned voice.
Welencier05 2 months ago
SHE'S INDEED A MULTITALENT ,ALSO A BEAUTIFULL WOMAN , I LOVE HER !
winchestermentolatt 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Kate Bush is so Amazing :D
if you love this music, probably'll like the Angra's version :)
To me, each one has its particularity
One complete the another :D
Version : /watch?v=TmDjtm4FFcY :)
megatons 2 months ago
Comment removed
megatons 2 months ago
Time for a bit of honesty hear, Kate has a squeaky voice which might improve with some training, but maybe permanently useless. The song itself but is basically ridiculous, random, barely comprehensive. This is like a scrap book of ideas for a song cut and paste together. Needs alot more work.
brunobaritono 2 months ago
@brunobaritono Agree her voice is a bit off in this live version. Have you read the book though? The song really only makes sense if you're familiar with the story. In that context it is perfect.
susanita359 2 months ago
@susanita359 her voice is a bit off lol ? not many people can sing this gud just stood there , let alone playing piano at same time plus keep track of which camera to follow lol the woman is brilliant,
tex58434 2 months ago
@brunobaritono I totally agree that Kate needs vocal coaching--10 octaves or whatever are no use if the upper registers sound this squeaky. But to dis the song itself when you evidently have never read "Wuthering Heights", well that is somewhere it is not advisable to go. The song lyrics are unquestionably evocative of many of the things Cathy Earnshaw said in the novel, or her ghost did, when it she was urging Mr. Lockwood to "Let me in at your window." I think you meant to say:
fancifulfilly 2 months ago
(the song lyrics are) barely comprehensible, as "barely comprehensive" makes no sense in that sentence. But there is nothing random OR cut-and-pasted as in a scrapbook, about the ideas, they all fit that gloomy and passionate, dark novel's very essence.
fancifulfilly 2 months ago
@fancifulfilly Perhaps you should listen to all of the different variety of Kate songs and her singing voice on them before saying she needs vocal coaching.
ggarlick46 2 months ago
@ggarlick46 I have heard her singing other songs. I had the album "The Kick Inside" on vinyl. No, Kate does not sound this way on all the tracks, but that does not make up for the fact that her voice sounds squeaky on this one. She wrote a truly inspired song, and then ruined it. Sorry, but I cannot reconcile that voice to Cathy Earnshaw's character. Nor do I like her campy, over-the-top, caricature-like antics on the video , for the same reason. The novel is gloomy, gothic.
fancifulfilly 2 months ago
@ggarlick46 As I was saying, the song shared many traits with the novel, but the video was campy, sharply contrasting with the mood of the song. And, I maintain, that in this song, she wrote most of it in too high a register for her to avoid sounding squeaky. This is all a matter of taste, I grant you, but it is not to mine.
fancifulfilly 2 months ago
@fancifulfilly Well all I can say is you had the album "The Kick Inside" so you must have liked Kates early songs.As for ruining Wuthering Heights with her singing, you must be joking! A no 1 hit on her first ever single,and its been one of her classic songs ever since, and the one that no one else can imitate with any degree of success.
ggarlick46 2 months ago
@ggarlick46 Afraid I am not...joking that is. But, before you let that get you wrapped around the axle, remember what the Romans said: "De gustibus non est disputandum." Obviously Kate has proven that she can sing, on other tracks. Obviously some people like even the squeaking. I just don't happen to be one of 'em. If she had passed on trying to sing like a coloratura, which she ain't, and stuck with her more dulcet tones, it would have been a happier outcome. In my OWN opinion.
fancifulfilly 2 months ago
@fancifulfilly Obviously you would be better with off with some dumb pat benatar version of it as well mate.
ggarlick46 2 months ago
@ggarlick46 Obviously.
fancifulfilly 2 months ago
@fancifulfilly Thought so.
ggarlick46 2 months ago
@fancifulfilly I have to comment on your point about the video being 'campy'. Wasn't that really the case for pretty much most of videos that came out in the late 70's and well into the mid-80's? What was portrayed on MTV was generally always something conjured up in the mind of the video's producer, rather than a lock-step reflectance on the song at hand. Yes, there were exceptions, but that was the norm for videos at the time.
ralphyboy25 2 months ago
@ralphyboy25 Most of the videos of that era WERE rather over-the-top, but nobody forced Kate to act all "hammy", and clownish. It just does not fit with the mood of the song. Unless, of course, I just am missing the point of the song, and this song really was intended to spoof the novel, rather than capture the mood of it. Hey, I don't care if everyone and his dog went out and bought the single; plenty of people bought Tiny Tim, too. The public's taste is nothing to me.
fancifulfilly 2 months ago
@fancifulfilly Ok.... now you having me laughing, thinking back to the ridiculousness of Tiny Tim. True camp for the time.
Peace.
ralphyboy25 2 months ago
So, you remember ol' Tiny Tim? I never forgot him, but not because I liked his silly, campy, trilling, rather because he made me laugh. Lots!! About 30 years after he was popular, the discount store Ames had these Christmas-time commercials, featuring Scrooge and Tiny Tim, where the Tiny Tim was not a frail boy, but Tiny Tim the entertainer with a ukelele, trilling "Deck the Halls". It was so silly that every time I would see it, I would near ROTFLMAO.
fancifulfilly 2 months ago
@ralphyboy25, I don't know why youtube did not automatically address you at the beginning of my last reply, when I clicked "reply". I had to do this one manually..weird.
fancifulfilly 2 months ago
@fancifulfilly Yes who could forget Tiny Tim and Miss Vicki. I remember him as a regular on Rowan and Martin's Laugh-In.
ralphyboy25 2 months ago
@ggarlick46 Exactly my opinion. Her voice is unique and extraordinary. Full stop.
TheAkelei 1 month ago 2
@TheAkelei Agreed!
ggarlick46 1 month ago
@brunobaritono wat u talking about mate this song needs alot more work it was written and sung 35 years ago , and as for having a sqeaky voice kates one of the worlds greatest singer, song writers i highly doubt , infact i know she doest need voice training haha thats like saying pele cant play football or muhammad ali cant box .....
tex58434 2 months ago
Comment removed
sorihewi 1 month ago
Can't get enough of this...
partyinamsterdam 2 months ago
i understand her better then i understood hayley westenra
xasuchan 2 months ago
I had this 45 rpm at one time in my life. It was a radio promo that the radio station was just giving away. Love this song so much.
yogertlvr 2 months ago
crazy old bint
Moonshinedistiller 2 months ago
zajebisty kawalekl
adaskasia 2 months ago
is an angel!
alfista88 2 months ago
With all due respect, but rather the voice of Andre Matos ....
icarotkd 2 months ago
@icarotkd Pffft... hahahahaha.
Zeanu 2 months ago
la maman de toutes les autres .
titoux1260 2 months ago
@titoux1260 moi qui pensait que la nouvelle big mama soul etait Adele...
BohemianConspiracy 2 months ago
In that time they did not have auto-tune, artists had to have real talent. Nowadays everyone can be a Kate Bush...
gorgolaka 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hi, I am Marisa. I love music.I am an very artistic person who was born with some natural talent in singing and writing. Let me know what you think of my personal site. Please let me know if you thnk that she is better than I am vocally etc...Or if you think that I am superior vocally and creatively, let me know. If you think we are equals, let me know! I value your opinion. I have photos, and you can also let me know if you like my image or if you prefer famous people's images.
peoniesfleur 2 months ago