Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,626)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i love how miley goes 'MY BEST FRIEND WROTE IT' and Taylor is like :BITCH PLEASE:

  • miley was not made for this song, simple as that.

  • @shanaynay515744 Miley made it even better

  • miley and taylor vioce are different, but i think they're both amazing.that's all.

  • Miley killed it. Loved it. :D

  • Miley has an ok voice I'll admit that but she completley ruined this song :(

    Stick to your own music Miley and don't try Taylor's songs that's a whole different league for you.

  • Miley ur going TO KILL me! 1:55 to 2:00, u killed it,Taylor was trying to save it, but u just sucked!

  • Taylor Swift is pretty good, but in live performances her voice is kinda different. She still rocks!

    Miley Cyrus has no talent except for her songwriting in about two songs. She butchered this performance...

  • Miley killed it.

  • dont like either :P

  • love love love they sound good together

  • I really prefer Miley in this vid, at least she has a strong voice.But i like both :)

  • No one's better than the other. Because they both did great. Taylor's voice is so relaxing while Miley gave me goosebumps. Thumbs up for the two of you. :)

  • They both can't sing.

  • @whatupdawwg thats rude.. if u dont like it then dont...but need to leave rude comments

  • Taylor is AMAZING at singing country..

    while Miley sounds really cracky in the voice...

    I LOVE YA TAYLOR! :D

  • GOD! MILEY NEEDS 2 GET A FUC*ING LYFE! MY GOD! 

  • well, that was a shock.

  • OMG! that song was so good untill Miley started singing i think that im deaf OUCH! get better at singing Miley i mean really!

  • well.... Apparently, country music is not for Miley Cyrus... :D

  • i think miley is trying to sound like taylor (who singscounrty GOOD) and miley sounds like a hick...

  • i think miley's vibrato sounded really nice

  • miley just made it better :) i love her voice

  • Miley ruined it. case closed.

  • Tis sucks! Miley ruined the song! She was probably high! lol

  • uh come on now miley you can't sing slow songs so stop you're hurting my damn ears! go taylor you rock! miley is trying to hard to hit the note... look at taylor calm...

  • uh come on now miley you can't sing slow songs so stop you're hurting my damn ears

  • Such a true reality for young ladies... When your 15...

  • i love taylor, miley..ehh. taylor just seems really likeable. miley seems like the type in high school who everyone thinks is a stuck up biootchh. yesss?

  • at 1:47 taylor swift shakes her head like "o gosh here she goes again." lol

  • Well Thanks Miley, You ruined a GREAT song!

  • Neither one can sing live. My ears are bleeding!

  • Miley Cyrus totally butchered that song. She really can't sing.

  • MILEY IS A VIRUS SHE INFECTED THE FIFTEEN SONG>>>>>>>>>>NOW TAYLOR NEEDS AN ANTIVIRUS TO CURE IT>>>>>>

  • Taylor Swift is amazing! MILEY SUCKS TOO BAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • miley sounds just like she always does.. she CAN actually sing ... but her voice is crap

  • good old time with miley!

  • one word: awesome!

  • miley is like totally blocking out taylors voice...gross

  • is it just me, or is miley better?

  • @mimiteensy It's just you.

  • @mimiteensy i agree with U totally

  • Miley has a stronger voice then Taylor swift, but there both good.

  • they both are sooo diffrent but also young so there voices are not mature but they are awsome!!

  • Miley can sing in real live but not Taylor swift Miley didn't ruined it

    she the best in here

  • Miley Cyrus is the best in here

    she didn't ruined

    she just trying her best to be the best

    actually she very good in here but not Taylor swift she cant sing in live

    excepts for Miley, she can sing in real live

  • @MiSsMaiLiS no, Taylor sings Amazing live and miley doesn't, you can hear it when shes singing this, Taylor is WAYYY better

  • 1:55 - 2:01

    super note XD

  • no comparison taylor's voice us wayyyyyyyyy better

  • both sucks! i mean taylor mmmm fuck her! and miley...too!

  • I personally think they brought out the best in eachother :)

  • i love how miley is just swaying to the music :)

  • god sorry but why watch the video if you hate miley so much! i get that everyone has a different opinion but that doesnt mean you should shove it down the rest of our throats.

  • two ov my dearest singers are together woow

  • I love Miley but this is not her song!! Her voice isn't made for this kind of music and doesn't really match Taylor's voice.

    I LOVE TAYLOR AND MILEY :)

  • **high

  • you haters can say whatever you want...miley has an amazing voice and even with this bad quality her voice sounds awesome...just because her voice isn't as soft as taylor's and as hight as taylor's doesnt mean she didn't do a wonderful jog cause she did

  • miley is like rockin the fuck out.... its not that kinda song. compared to taylor miley looks like shes on crack.

  • ewwww miley is SOOO BAD!!!!! EWWW I HATE HER VOICE!!!!! it sounds SOOOO BAD!!!!!! ewwww

  • Holy hell Miley sucks!!!!

    Now that is funny!!!

  • I honestly like Miley, she's not my favorite person, but she's ok... With that said, I can't stand how she sings this song... Honestly, she sucks and she makes Taylor sound bad when they sing together... Sorry Miley fans.

  • Miley the heavy dikish like voice. Crappy cunt ratt trashy lesbian whore with money!

  • Miley tried to hard to show off this song is supposed to be soft she ruined it!

  • My gosh Taylor and Miley are both amazinggg <3

  • Lets be honest here, who remembers Taylor's performance with Stevie Nicks? She fucked it up, sounded like a whiny ass cat. I don't personally like Miley, however as a performer she is good. Her voice has a great vibrato, it's full and deep- she may have been a bit off here, and it could be she's doing a duet. So what. At least her # of successful live performances totally outranks Taylor. I thınk they were both off here, and ıt's not that great of a song...or maybe ıt sounded crapp here ıdk

  • Oh, and just fyi, Taylor wouldn't have picked Miley to sing with her if she didn't believe Miley could do it. So stop pulling everyone in with your hate!

  • Miley did not ruin this song at all. I am not just saying that as a fan, she genuinely did well. I am sick and tired of Miley haters, because every single video she's in, the majority of the comments are haters and it sickens me. Miley is so inspirational, she went out and caught her dream.. I don't see any of you behind your computers doing that. I really wish people would stop focusing on the negatives about Miley and actually see that she is a great performer who is doing what she loves.

  • @Mileyobsessed1100 i really didnt care for miley in this song, but the only reason shes in music n makin money is cause of her daddy. with out him she wouldnt even have a music career cuz shes not good at all.. n the reason she has money n has sold albums is cuz of the little teens out there that dont kno wut music really is.. just saying

  • @TheJamie4realzzz Miley did not get a career because of her dad, her dad got cast in Hannah Montana after she did. He didn't pull any strings to get her the part. DISNEY PICKED HER. You want to know why Disney picked her? Because she had a good audition and could SING and DANCE. I personally believe she did this song well and I am sick and tired of people thinking she got famous because of Billy Ray because she didn't!

  • @Mileyobsessed1100 but if it wasnt for her dad havin money to get her to audition they wouldnt even give her a chance in hell. im sry but like everyone else thinks miley's dad got her to where she is today n alot of people agree witth me on that. yeah disney picked her up, shes a really good actress but as a singer no.. i do like her hannah montana show thats funny but her singing sucks... U just have to face it if it wasnt for mileys dad she wouldnt be known to anyone!!

  • @Mileyobsessed1100 but if it wasnt for her dad havin money to get her to an audition they wouldnt even given her a chance in hell. im sry but like everyone else thinks miley's dad got her to where she is today n alot of people agree witth me on that. yeah disney picked her up, shes a really good actress but as a singer no.. i do like her hannah montana show thats funny but her singing sucks... U just have to face it if it wasnt for mileys dad she wouldnt be known to anyone!!

  • @TheJamie4realzzz Sure, there are a lot of people who think that her dad helped, but they don't know Miley. If you have read her book 'Miles To Go' you would know that her dad didn't do shit to get her famous.

  • @Mileyobsessed1100 well i dont believe a word miley says. like for one wen she perform on american idol season 8 adam lambert said how beatiful she looked n they ryan asked her wut she though about wut he said n she said i dont like guys with eyeliner. ryan never asked her if she liked him. this one award show shes like heres a personal fave of mine adam lambert, he performed whataya want from me. so miley goes back on her word alot. u must be a huge miley fan well hunny ur wastein ur money!!

  • Miley sings like a goat

  • It's funny that people are arguing who sounds better when niether has any vocal talent at all. I mean really!!! they both sound atrocious!! Out of tune, pitchy and downright aweful!!!

  • you people are really jerky. miley is amazing she just sings rock& pop and taylor swift is soft and peaceful. miley was really good at 2:03

  • i had to block my ears when miley sang it was awful!!! taylor rocked though

  • miley totally ruined the song. i like her as a singer, but she doesn't have the soft voice like taylor, she has a more rock and edgy voice, and taylor has more soft pop voice. <3 love <3 both singers thoughhh :)

  • At first I was like NO MILEY, but then she sang quite well.

  • i personally think miley sux at singing this song she ruined that whole preformance

  • Different Styles

    Miley is fabulous~

    Taylor Swift sings soft songs.

    Miley usaually sings rock songs.

    For those who don't like miley go to hell

  • On Taylors Album Fearless She Shuda Dne The Song Wiv Miley Theyre Amazing!!

  • i love taylor but miley sucks. if taylor is reading these shes gonna feel offened tht she took miley to be her partner

  • wow... thanks for ruining the song miley...

  • I dont think that Taylor sounds that good live. Miley's voice is more poppish, but it has a country twain to it so I like it better at this song, live. When Taylors voice has been tweaked, it sounds better at this song for sure. I just dont think Taylor has a very good voice when she's live.

  • maybe the reason she was trying to hard was because she knew tons of haters like y'all would comment on her performance! i think she sounds good!

  • miley should cover this song

  • Stop hateing on miley everybody i love that performance :)

  • miley sings like she's doing solo. you don't scream when you're in a duet, you LISTEN. they should just stick to soloing.

    and taylor is great with the guitar.

  • Taylor is lovely!! Miley just sucks.

  • find ich gut (: gefällt mir !

  • I totally forgot about this!!!!(:

    Haa, nicee :D

  • i think miley can't sing period.

    her voice is really raspy and ugly

    i personally think she can't sing well.

    yall should hear demi lovato now that's a singer

  • Whoever thinks that Taylor sounded better than Miley is probably RETARDED.

    Miley blew Taylor out of the water on HER OWN SONG.

    Like seriously? Taylor sounded horrible.

  • god ppl your really getting anoying with these miley thing and the pics get over it, that was 2 years ago gosh and they both were good

  • miley sings taylor guitarist........let taylor sing miley song..

  • miley sings taylor guitarist

  • miley is Horible. Cause her Music is More Pop & Taylors Is Relaxed & cihill Ish. But Taylor Souds Really Good!

  • those who r talkin bout miley (badly) obviously u do noe know miley cyrus shes more rock/pop n taylor is more country u guys r juss talkin bout her cuz other ppl r talking bout her.

  • OMG ppl just shut up miley was rlly good its just the quality so like shut up taylor and miley are amazing ppl but miley made mistakes so just shut up and deal wiht how life goes. Miley I think your gr8! you too taylor!!

  • Miley wasn't very good at all. I think Taylor was good though.

  • could Miley try any harder? Seriously...lol

  • Hate Miley, love Taylor :)

  • I think Miley was really good

  • taylor looks kinda pissed at her for singing so loud! but the song is taylors so she could of picked someone better ( for the song ).

  • Precioso Miley ♥ me gusta taylor :)

  • how many people does Miley say is her 'best friend'??

  • <3 taylor

  • miley you make me laugh, its not a rock song, you dont have to overlap taylors voice. she sounds ten times better than you anyway. MILEY CYRUS WILL NEVER BE AS GOOD AS TAYLOR SWIFT!!! And all you girls saying oh miley adds heart to the song or she souds great, YOU ARE LYING. Its just another selfish attempt for her to look better than another person. Psst Miley, yeah, hello, taylor swift is prettier than you, more loved than you and has a voice like an angel, you sound like a garbage disposal.

  • I think Miley did great!!! I was scared to watch this because of all those bad comments, but they have no sense now that I've watched it.

  • people kinda just need to stfu. i think they both sound awesome :] taylor is country & miley is pop so clearly there voices are going to sound different, and i think they sound good together :) if you dont like miley, dont comment & to be honest dont watch it ;l <3

  • i like that they are both christian, and great singers/song writers...esp. taylor :)

  • I think Miley adds heart to the song though. She gets into it.

  • A beautiful angel's playing guitar next to a witch.

  • @viethung91 That is one of the best ways that someone has put it so far. The other one was: "Miley sounds like a monkey on crack"

  • Look I'm not trying to be mean towards Miley, I don't have anything against her, I just think her voice really wasn't meant for this like 'soft' song, she's more of like a crazy loud, pop-ish song. So I agree, this wasn't Miley's best performance, and I'm a full on Taylor Swift fan, so of course I loved her here!!!!!! I mean can you imagine Taylor Swift belching her guts out to "Can't be Tamed" I don't know what I would say.

  • Why does miley make weird faces when she sings... sometimes she can sing certain songs good, but when she sings she makes faces...

  • @starlight1790 Because faces make all the more better;)

  • Comment removed

  • @TheRaChEL93 no you suck. you try singing it. i bet it worse than a parrot screeching the words.

  • @ashleykicklighter te sei scema bimba

  • yes they both have the accent, but i don't rly hear the harmony :-/

  • If the Key, Instruments, Rhythm, And Tempo of this song was changed, Miley could produce an amazing pop cover of this song.

  • they are both so stupid they dont have soul at all

  • mileys voice doesnt fit with the rythm of he song.its suppost to be soft and relaxing but shes just pushing it and sounds stressed.taylors voice is flowing perfectly with the song.mileys making the rythm sound horrible,and differently then the sing goes

  • not saying that either one did badly, but their voices really contrast

  • I think they're both great and if you dont like em hwy do you guys even listen to it?!

  • I like Mileys voice here :)

  • who's the man in the background ??

  • miley sucks at this song and she can sing softer so i think shes trying to over power taylor to bad she will never be as good as taylor

  • OMGoodness, Miley ruined this song. Crazy. I think she needs to sing the way she does because she really can't sing.

  • I love taylor swift, but Miley is trying way to hard to compete with taylor!! she just cant, so miley, just, just NO dont sing please!! Taylor doesnt have to try when she sings, its natural!! you can see mileys vainy things popping out of her neck on high notes!! and taylors are safe3 in her neck!! sorry!1

  • me and my sis think miley was trying to out power taylors voice it would have sounded better if miley calmed down a little

  • @natloverforever OMG I totally agree, taylor is natrual and doesnt have to try, miley struggles to sing!!

  • miley destroyed this song. stop screaming and over powering taylor. cuz taylor is much better than u.

  • Mileys rockin out like its something hardcore.

  • this is absolute  RUBBISH. nuf sed

  • lmfao taylor was trying to hint out to tell miley to lower her voice. i love miley and taylor

  • i heard this duet is part of little feud Taylor had with Joe whats-his-face cause miley also dated a jonas bro

  • I LOVE YOU TAYLOOOR!!!!

  • only if this version was downloadable

  • i think this is great but why does Miley have to try and "belt" everything out

    I dont hate her im a fan of both of them before anyone decides to tell me im hating on cyrus

  • i like taylor, dont get me wrong! but i think miley can out sing her in a contest cuz she has more vibrato in her voice

  • Taylor Swift looks mad because Miley is trying to over due it and making it her own when they are singing a duet.

  • 1.47 ITS SO GOOD

  • Taylor is waaaay better than miley, but it still sounds pretty good

  • wow taylor and miley sound TERRIBLE together.... miley should just sing normally, she sounds a heck of a lot different bc shes just going for volume. MILEY, YOU HAVE A MIKE FOR A REASON. USE IT!

  • Wow, Niley hints much???

  • Tay and Miley are amazing :i

    I think their voices together is epic.

  • they're AWESOME ! (:

  • Miley can sing, but she needs to relax!

  • Wow, thats the most clothes ive seen miley in since... ever?

  • @BridgetLovesYerFace lol so true

  • whatever. i think there both great! and i think its really cute they did a duet. so stop hating miley.

  • this is amazing. i love both of them. :)

  • Guys, this is taylors song , so mileys not gonna be that goood!

  • Taylor sounds great, this is her song after all. Miley's trying waayyy too hard. She's trying to be country, but isn't doing a vert good job.

    My grades

    Taylor: A-

    Miley: C

  • Okay. Everyone stop arguing over who was worse and accept that in this performance they both had major flaws, Taylor is singing flat for the whole song, and Miley's voice is definitely not right for this song. Separate, they are both amazing young women, but they absolutely do NOT sound good together.

  • I don't like Miley, but she sounds way better than Taylor live. Taylor CANNOT sing good live. I like Taylor, but you gotta admit that she sounds bad. At times Taylor sounds good, but overall it's not good.

  • I think Miley just sounds really bad because Taylor Swifts songs are more for relaxed, soft voices. & miley cyrus has a pop kind of voice.

  • @Christinababyguh

    They're both fake

  • @Christinababyguh yea i think ur sorta rite its sorta like american idol great voice but rong song choice

  • @Christinababyguh yea i think ur sorta rite its sorta like american idol great voice but rong song choice i still love miley though

  • Comment removed

  • @Christinababyguh

    A good singer can sing ANYTHING. Miley Cyrus is a one trick pony.

  • what i like about miley is her STRONG voice.love them both but taylor s voice is not as strong as miley s ...love miley s vocals...mabe fou some of u guys i dont sounds good but it s just because they are not voice-compatible...

  • She has a loud voice. She can help that guys.

  • miley butchered the song wth i thought it would be gud but i waz WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY wrong >.<

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed