Coco Ma (10) Beethoven concerto No 3 in C Minor, 1 mvt

[RichardPianist]

Hi Coco, great performance! Richard will take CMC age 10 class in 2012 too.

[asorescu]

Such a good performance, and so unfortunate they did not let her finish it!! I hope Coco had the chance to see at least one of Lang Lang's recent performances of the five Beethoven concertos in Toronto... that was quite an event for all young pianists, who connect well with him on a musical energy level.

[punkviolin1]

You're really amazing! Beautiful playing!

[pianist626262]

Really wonderful performance like always!!!

[Chopin1986]

Such a big talent!!!!! Your performance is really amazing!!

[jjrcz021]

Congratulations on winning the 3rd prize!! This is a beautiful concerto and you played so well!! You are only 10, but have such strong hands already!! A question: In Canada, do they allow recording at the competitions? Just wondering. Best wishes.

[tarinou49]

What a pity for the end ! At last I read in the comments that you had obtained a 3ème price ! Well done Coco it's superb ! Play this difficult concerto at ten years it's phenomenal. I wish you a great carreer of pianist. And especially to play this marvellous concerto with orchestra !

[Katherine223411]

Wow your playing is amazing !! Keep up the great work :)

Katherine

[chobeethaninov]

Bravo Coco! You truly are a genius!!! I hope you can upload a video of the rest of it. :)

[alpenmumie]

awesome performance - really talented - greetings from germany

[unpodimusica1]

My favorite Beethoven concerto, you play it sooo beautifully. So full of passion and elan - I had to keep reminding myself you're 10 years old. Amazing!!!

[jennypianohall]

Coco, that was amazing.It's very sad that didn't play the ending. But it still was a great performance. I like your channel's videos. Keep up the great work!!!!

[helladm1]

BRAVO!!!! a wonderful performance, very virtuos and expressive... greetings Hella

[pianist626262]

Wonderful performance!

[TheMuusika]

Everytime I'm listening to it I find it so powerful and it is a huge remarkable work for only a 10 years old girl having a lot ambitions to play that great Concerto of Beethoven. Coco, you a superbly talented!!! And, oh my... that Grand Cadenza is outstanding. Couldn't imagine of your achievement so far!

Love,

Christina.

[ERIMISAYA]

Hi CoCo,

This is really wonderful DUO PIANO.

Sounds of two piano are mixed elegantly.

[abhikmazumder]

This is very well played Coco. You brought out Beethoven's spirit perfectly in your interpretation. Hope you get a chance to perform this with an orchestra. It will be great.

[Lalitamusic]

Excellent duo Coco. Your progress is quite astonishing and this piece certainly was created to challenge that. It truly is a shame that you ran out of time and that might account for the judges not placing you at the top of the list, but just the same you performed like a veteran. Congratulations.

Lots of love

Lalita

[pianolover1004]

Hi, Coco!

You played so wonderfully. I really like it. Bravo!

[kevingao2000]

The cadenza was outstanding, and what a pity that we couldn't see the ending. Nontheless, it is still very good performance overall !! Thumbs up !!!

[littleaiinpst]

Bravo!

[cristeny]

Dear Coco, thank you for the fantastic performance. And I am so so so sad the judges didn't allow US to hear the wonderful ending! Absolutely passionate and spirited playing with astonishing tehnique and great Beethoven's sonority. Maybe you will able to make a recording of the whole Concerto, or at lest the 1st movement. We would be very happy!!! And lots of congrats for your 3rd Prize, obviously the judges weren't very smart as we all know that this performance deserve the 1st Prize!

[2308Amari]

Wow Coco, that was absolutely fantastic. I wonder how the competition went for you? I'm sure you won first prize :)

[samuelngkee]

Hi! Coco, it's fantastic job!!!!

[MaxGavOhio]

Once again, beautiful playing!!

[qingpiano]

indeed very passionate playing! many congratulations. can't believe Coco is already 10! how she progressed!

[mimifeng2004]

Bravo! Very well done! Look forward to your performance with an orchestra someday. 

[tsunyituan]

Coco, I really hope to hear you play this piece with orchistra soon. With this quality of work that will be awesome. Thanks for sharing.

[tanadihensen73]

I have no idea whether the tempos are right, for if we play in orchestra, with violin, we should play the tempos in the final tones longer, my dear Coco. You play the middle and final part very blend and fluid and with right intonation. Very strong music memory, too !

[lepaintre123]

Well, despite some confusion between the piano and orchestral solo piano tone, I am confident that with a real orchestra, you could sublimate this performance beyond your expectations. Coco expensive then continues the good work, I'd be happy to hear you play this marvelous concerto assisted by an orchestra ...

Jacques in Paris

[mbpiano5]

Brava Coco!

[Amnas2011]

Fantastic performance!

[Zanpra]

I waaaaant the ending ! ^^ It's really fantastic !

[pianogirl4ever]

Congratulations Coco!! Such a brilliant performance! (*^^*)

[pianofreak1993]

Awesome!

[ExcelLied]

Magnificent, it must be so hard to be a judge in this competitions, you certainly are a first prize player. Congratulations on this excellent performance :)

[OldRabit]

Many congratulations, dear Coco - what an achievement!!! So proud of you!!! Totally agree with thepianist1995.

[ThePianist1995]

COCO You'll always be first in my eyes (y). Great Job :)

~yiwei