Who Sings It Better? ALEXANDRA BURKE VS DIANA VICKERS?

[alexburkeisamazin]

diana vickers really cannot sing alex is waaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyy better 100%

[allythescally]

diana by miles she is sooooooo unique and amazing

[GilfachGuy1996]

they both sound completely different so how can u put them against each other.

i have alex's album and i love it and i am hoping 2 get dianas album 2 but singing that song it's actually hard 2 compare them

[MissC44]

@GilfachGuy1996 I put them against eachother as they are singing the same song and I wanted to see who sings it better?

[GilfachGuy1996]

@MissC44 i know its just that they sound completely different

[plasticjuicebox101]

i like diana better

[Volvican]

Let's see - either I can listen to someone who actually sounds human or someone that has the vocal quality of a singing goose.

[awkwardwonder]

alex, definitely.

[jjbop500]

diana vickers is wayy better than alex

[2010Vickerz]

Diana Vickers, No doubt!

[EmmiieKawaii]

DIANA VICKERS 10000000% :D

[LanzaloeH]

personally i rather diana.i think that alex starts to belt out the notes at the end which is gud but not for this song.this song is meant to be quiet and soft which suits diana not not alex sooooo........diana sings it better

[iwantadamnNZaccent]

i think diana >_>

it just sounds more unique, alexandra is kinda abit TOO strong.

[franbsbonebcn]

for me diana

but i like alexandra too, i love overcome album

[sandrisantander78]

Alexandra, of course!!!

[47fa4]

alexnadra by far

[leyshababe11]

ALEXANDRA BURKE

Diana sounds lyke she sayiin "HOLLER= YOOO HAR

[jessicaandkk123]

diana is better i love you hun x x x

[jessicaandkk123]

K: i like.... i dunno i like both of them, alexandra has a stronger voice but diana's version is different so i vote both lol

[jessicaandkk123]

J: i think dianas version is better i voted for you 30 times and my dad band it on the phone i love you new song hun i love you im your biggist fan i love you diana xxxxx

[PlayDrumz]

I know it's probably a different argument BUT.. I think the best female singer of this song is Sheryl Crow. I loved Dianna and Alex when they were on X factor but with hindsight neither are all that.

[jennyjenjen80]

I prefer Diana's version by far. Have you heard the full version? she sang it at Hamilton park race course. Sounded amazing. Shame she never got to sing it in the final

Why do people keep saying Alex is a copy of Leona? She sounds nothing like her

[avrilrockerstar]

diana all the way

[HappySunny13]

DIANA!!!!!!! I <3 Her Voice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[solofrutasdelbosque2]

ALEXANDRA!

[littlemark2009]

diana obviously

can't believe anybody actually likes alexandra

she didn't deserve to win

we have about 100000 singers like alexandra and 1 of diana

x factor is a complete fix

[Lovealexandraburke]

ALEXANDRA DOES IT BEST

[seanpeterhill]

too many singers like leona and alex winning , time for change , would love to see a jazz or country singer win =]

[DevilShunnieXxXx]

Diana all the wayyy DIANA IS AMAZINN XX

[warwolf193]

prefer diana because she isnt mimeing anybody and isnt boring, she actually has a personality in interviews

[Miahface]

since when did being a singer like Beyonce or Leona become a bad thing?!?!? i would love to sing as well as they can!

[xxkimmyyyyxx]

diana diana diana diana diana diana !!!!!

[glsparks001]

it is no wonder that Diana didn't win really is it - its like comparing Lilly Allen to Beyonce!

Alexandra all the way!!

[sophiewalters]

diana

[clubpenguin87622]

well i like them both

[maninthemirror45]

diana!!!!!!!

[babycakes984]

on this version, alexandra is MILES better than Diana. Diana screams and shouts.

[mad4musicgirl]

diana and omg have u seen how many people have said diana and she didn't even win\!! diana should of won she is amazing !!

[goonthings]

well i wen to the concert and she rocked i luv her so much xxxxxxx

[mishmash02]

The TV LIES!!

I saw the finalists in concert and let me tell you diana CANNOT sing!

She sounds WAY better on the TV than in concert.

She screams and shouts, it's not singing what she does!

She is awful.

I'd like to know if anyone who also saw the tour thinks she sounds good?????

Doubt there will be anyone!!

[taliaagrace]

look at everyone, diana vickers :L

yeahh , diana , diana FTW XD xxxxx

[RUCKERS13]

Diana sings it better. defo I was really upset she didnt win!!! =(

[InvestorVoiceLtd]

I prefer Diana's version.

[FluffyDustBunni]

I like Alexandra but I prefer Diana's version.

[Katii0x]

diana, its different

[SxcSinger07]

alex so much better dianna sounds like shes gt something wrong wiv her throat

[MullyINTHEHOOD]

so dianna alex is just like everyone else

[xCaMiLlAxKaRoLiNax]

DIAAAANAAA (:

Alex has a Good Voice .. But .. She's Just another Leona Or Beyonce

Diana Is Individual.. Love Her VOICE.

[masonlebourn]

cmon does the question need to be asked. its blatantly diana vickers.

[madchic78]

i loooove alexandra waaay more than diana

but i gotta admit diana sang it better!

alex is better for the uptempo dancing songs!

[chilipeppered101]

Miss Vickers is definatley better!

no disrespect to Alexandra as she is a good singer

[dancer9l]

DIANAAAA!

[Maderzrox]

they are both amazing in their own unique way, im sure if Diana won then the same amount of people who disagreed as with Alexandra

[yelrebmiKxo]

Eugh.

Diana's voice is AWFUL!

Makes me cringe.

Alex is waayyy better than Diana

[BabiBecci12]

diiiiiana .. <3 x

[luvinMcFLY]

so diana i love her voice to me she was the best female singer and so shudda won but alexandra does hav an amazing voice

[fazzababes]

diana!!

[joshhhy111]

diana is so much better

[OhThatDannyBoy]

Diana should have won

[Milinski28]

I think Diana Vickers sings it better, she should have won :)

[shamrockdancer]

Without a doubt Diana Vickers

[catroyal]

Diana. She makes it her own, and doesn't need all the backing vocals and crap. As has been said before, this should be as simple as possible. Also Diana really manages to tell a story with the song, whereas Alex just sort of pelts it out.

[Andy081991]

I think this comparison is totally ambiguous. Alexandra and Diana are so different that its impossible to compare. You may aswell be comparing which you can clean your kitchen floor better:

chalk or cheese!

However, i do like prefer Diana version and love her to pieces. But i like Alexandra as well

P.s:

Now shout at me all you like!

[LoveYouuBitches]

Alexandra is so much better.

Diana sounds like she has a throat problem, and thats why she got it in the first place, because of her straining of her voice.

Notice Alexandra doesn't have throat problems, because she has a natural born talent to sing..

Diana is forced.

Thats my opinion. *sigh* Go ahead and criticize like they always do (:

[mailimusic]

Diana Is The Worst Singer EVVA She Lives Nerer Me Lol

[Jo0odiiee]

DIANAAAA

[DeddaBabie]

Diana makes it her own...DIANA :)

[peetah1979]

Diana Vickers is hideous.

[LittleLegs92]

what i want to know is if Diana had won, would they have still recorded it with the choir and backing singers as they did with Alexandra's?

i just think the choir ruins the song, it should just be acoustic and simple, not overblown vocals

[LittleLegs92]

prefer diana's version.. much more original

[XxdumplinsxX]

Alexandra is better than Mariah Carey... Let me think.... ERRR.... ALEX! lol :p

[chocolate90909]

Alexandra, diana sounds likes she's in pain!

[Toblarony]

Deffo Diana

[taliaagrace]

whoa you're all saying dianaa :|

like them both, but gotta say diana, it's BEAUTIFULLLLLL :D xxxx

[J3SSiixX]

Alexandra murdered this song, her voice doesnt fit the style of the song.

[emmag142]

diana sings better but alex beats her at this one.

[Makennaa]

alexandra sings it better but i like diana moree :D x

[littlenicky666]

Alexandra DICK-HEAD, DICK-HEAD, DIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIICK-H­EAD!!!!!!!!!

[littlenicky666]

Alexander: Generic, polished, NO origiality, ten a penny - in America she wouldn't of even got through!!

Diana: Passionate, meaningful and NON GENERIC!! DIANA ALLLLLL THE WAY!!! Alexandra is a dick-head diva wannabe!!!

[WheresMyChain]

oh please!

your confusing plain WIERD with UNIQUE.

who the hell would enjoy listening to

haaleluaaah

she cant even speak properly

DIANNA NEEDS TO BUY A PAIR OF SHOES

[bobmarleygirl24]

Jeff Buckley

[maccee123]

diana diana diana diana diana diana

[xxEmmzyxx]

No contest...

Diana all the way! <3

[jessbxox]

DIANA!!!!!

[davis1992x]

DIANA DIANA DIANA!!

[xIyshaliciouSx]

DIANAA

[kjackey21]

Defenitely Diana!

[xoxemzypooxox]

Diana Vickers! She Is Amazing & Should Of Won X-Factor...!

[ashleesimpson001]

Diana sounds wierd in this. She is good at things like didos songs but not this. Alex is also ok but why do x factor always release a depressing song?

[branston08]

diana, the song means alot to her and she is incredible at it. Alex is good but will be compared to leona and is nowhere near that standard. Should never have won. Diana is different and unique and will be more succesful as will JLS

[irishdee18]

why wud people pose this up... its sad ... alexandra has a strong voice but diana vickers just vibs everything with her voice n calls it singin... listen 2 diana's version n u'll know wat i mean by vibs ... she does it nearly every word or two

[KATELiiSE]

Diana hands down!

Thats the only reason they chose the song as the final song anyway because she thought she was so amazing at bootcamp, and was sure she was going to win!

Why didn't she win!? I hope she releases albums of her own :-)

[docd1o1]

i love leona so much and i thought i was going to like alex but diana is so much more unique and amazing. i live in USA too. alex is almost too similar to some of the ladies we have. diana is something new.

[babii562]

they have completely different voices, you cant compare them.

i personally prefer diana as she is more original and there are so many singers with the same type of voice as alexandra :)

[AxCherryx]

i completely agree with babii562 nd SilverKismet!!!!

:)

x

[KatyWatey]

Diana is more original.

Alex doesn't have the right kinda voice for the intricate song.

[nevans09]

diana !! i agree that alex is incredible but she ruined this song. this definetly belonged to diana. she is sooo amazing at this song !!

[ejide2002]

Everyone has their own interpretation of music! Majority thoght Alex was really good and that wat put her in the running! Diane still has a chance to make music 4 those who prefer her! Stop hating on Alex plss!

[cutepearl9]

definitely Alexandra, I'm happy she won :-)

[Danashtheman1232]

I dont care what anyone thinks Alex is as good as Leona and I prefer her version!!!!

Go Alix

[leilalilly]

diana is better and hers is live....alexs is recorded

[SilverKismet]

DIANADIANADIANA!! It's HER song, she sang it first and made it her own, people are commenting saying she's 'not singing it right'... well she's actually making it her own rather than singing it like 10000 other people would sing it ;)

Hallelujah isn't a big belting ballad song which Alex has made it (of course I think she has a fantastic voice but just not right for this song)

xxx

[booshabusshums]

I hate both of them...

I wanted JLS to win :(

[18italia18]

DIANAS deffo i love her she is way betta than alexander i love her diana sud deffo be in her place i hate her for wining it sud of been diana she ay even good diana is way betta than her alex thinks she is all it !!!!

[kittiestrophe]

Diana's version far surpasses Alex's, no question. It's raw and full of feeling. Alex may have a phenomenal voice but doesn't sing it with as much passion as Diana did.

Hallelujah is awlays going to be Diana's song, her version will always be beautiful..

[cooldude2oo7]

definetely diana she made the song her own =) wiff alex its too blatently obvious its a cover

[inmemory24]

Easily Diana!!

[jobybabe]

Diana by far !!!

[015642]

just another point. halleljuah is a diffrent unique song? so it should be sung by someone with a diffrent sound going on.. diana!

[015642]

im not a big diana vickers fan but Yes Defo Diana! =]

[Lavigne182]

diana (:

[NickOLarse999]

Alex puts her voice into the song; Diana puts her voice and her heart into it.

[xMissDivax]

Alexandra is a better singer but with this song I prefer Diana's version

[Tomewatt]

Diana by a clear mile!!!. Whilst Alexandra sings the song well, .. Diana tells the story, as her voice conveys so much more raw emotion.

Alexandra never liked this song, and totally misunderstood what the song was about.

This is Diana's song, no question, .. and we can only hope that her studio version will make it's way onto YT soon. Those close to SC that have heard it all said that Diana's was their favourite version.

[Hannerr94x]

diana of course :)

[scrkinvara]

diana by FAR!

[xlilyfanx]

Alexandra 100%

[jerichok]

DIANA!!!

[AFAB93]

I agree with most of the people here - Diana !! She's got a successful carrer ahead of her ;)

[LeilahGazer]

Alexandra for sure

[avrilrockerstar]

DIANA ALL THE WAY SHE ROCKS!

[emzyb11]

DIANA! xx

[SparklyEyes121]

Alexendra for me i personally found diana's voice a bit annoying... but i still think Diana's version is really good; coz its different.. Alexandra was just better for me personally =]

[DevilShunnieXxXx]

I like alexandras version but i much prefer DIANAS version she sounds way better and is all round just better SHE SHOULD HAVE WON that song should have been hers xxxx

[Miahface]

Also, yes dianas performance of it was live but alexandra performed it live on the show and on top of the pops and in my opinion, sooooo much better than diana.

[OTHLeytonLover]

Diana.

Like some said Alex's version was also recorded in the studio, were as diana was up front, so it's not going to be perfect

[marmeduke007]

Take into consideration, Alexendra's part is the studio version while Diana is straight roughed up live.

While the debate of who is the better singer, Alexandra is very good, but too safe thus extremely boring, Diana on the other hand is by far more talented, artistic and creative.

Diana's version is much better, it should have been her song.

[eXia113]

Diana, deffo. I HATE Alexandra with a passion. She completely butchered the song, but at least Diana's has some sort of uniquness to it, instead of the shit that Simon Cowell churns out all the time (ie, Alexandra)

[cooldude2oo7]

i agree i mean dont get me wrong alexandra is a good singer and has a good version but its just going to be history repeating itself wiff leona lewis although i think leona is much better thn alexandra =] but diana was different sumfin new sumfin that isnt in the music world right that would reeli give other artists a run for their money =] i am seriously looking forward to the day diana releases her debut album =D

[hannahemm]

DIANA NO DOUBT ABOUT IT SHE IS AMAZING AND SHOULD HAVE WON THERE IS SOO MANY VOICES THE SAME AS ALEXANDRA AND IM NOT SAYING ALEXANDRA ISNT GOOD COS SHE IS GOOD ITS JUST DIANA IS AMAZING...!!! xx

[EoghanQuiggRocksx]

Diana ......=]

[Holywood4906]

diana

[clumsyflic]

Alex, no doubt- her voice is incredible, it's powerful, she projects so much emotion into the song and she has so much soul.

Diana's style is unique, but she doesn't pronounce the words quite as well. If she had a bit of coaching and her version was produced, it would be an excellent version, but, in my opinion, Alex is just in a completely different league

[zdc567890]

DIANA DIANA DIANA! her version is beautiful and i can't stop listening to it!

[arethaluv4eva]

Are u all having a laugh.....this is not even a question...Diana in her lifetime can never be a good a singer as Alex....Can you be sucessful? maybe...cos there is a ridiculous hype about her , can never be cos of her singing..

[Miahface]

I agree!!

[MichelleBowden19]

Diana is much better

[linguado4]

diana

[steveirwin4eva]

Diana

[pancakesareawsum]

Diana.

All though in this version its alex coz hers was done in a studio and stuff.. edited ?

[matj2310]

different! i like diana she is hotter

[10jvincent]

Dianaaa Diana Diana!!!!!!!!

i love her voice its amazing, i have all her performances on my ipod i love them all :D

[Lewizee]

DiANA DiANA DiANA !!

[JellyBeansxx4evaxx]

I dont think diana was as good at this song, but OMG she is so much better at singing than alexandra.. just my opinion though!

[TashaaLovesLeahh]

i think diana is a better singer and i love her and wanted her to win but i think alex is a bit better at this song

but i love dianas magic mirror and i loved her singing man in a mirror white flag call me -- most of her songs really but i didnt like yellow :\:\ I LOVE DIANA

[welshgazza1992]

Diana Of Course :D

She should have won! :D :D

[SingingSiz]

Alexandra Burke is much better!

[couroweney]

I think alexandrea was better at this song but OMG diana would soo kick her arse doing man in the mirror x

[KayleyLovesPaul]

diana !!

[J0RD2K7]

diana vickers !!!

she shud have won !! :(((((

[DevilGurl1x]

There bothh good at different parts of the song x

[aprilbabygyal]

DIANA!

[Miahface]

are you people deaf?! diana can't even sing!!

[TashaaLovesLeahh]

yeah she can your obviously the death 1

[Miahface]

oh i'm death now am i?! i didn't realise i died...hmmm...

i don't understand how people find that irritating little yelp she does at the end of each word to actually sound good and even be in tune. but that's just my opinion :)

[LuFf33U]

Can i just say, LOADS of singers do that 'yelp'. Listen to Beyonce, even she does it.

[Miahface]

Well i already have been on it. So good luck with that.

And if so many other singers yelp like diana then they must hide it very well by staying in tune.

[LuFf33U]

What did the judges say? She does stay in tune, but adds her own edge to the song. You dont have to like it. But please, don't blatantly insult me and the majority of the people here.

[Miahface]

I didn't see them [you'll understand when you audition.

I didn't mean to insult you on purpose, i just feel very strongly about my views.

when is your audition?

[LuFf33U]

well, boo you.

[fatpaul57]

Diana by miles!!!!!!!

[singing1sensation]

hmm for hallelujah is say diana..... but alexandra is one of my fave singers so it was really hard for me to say that! i was sad when diana went from xfactor :(

[mizzrock13]

Diana Vickers!!!!!!!

[RachelFrancessx]

DIANNA .....she has a much more different voice and it mkes it sound better

[DamoRicho09]

both can sing really good but i havent heared dianas real version of the whole song so i wouldnt know

[xSparklezZx]

DIANNAAA. alex's version is so common and her voice sounds like any other singer.

diana is a beautiful soulful singer.

[laraliadakara]

Alexandra Burke. I really hate Diana's voice!

[Miahface]

Well i won't be buying any of diana's songs if she actually makes any. If i wanted to listen to a whining baby, i would.

[LuFf33U]

Well, obviously you dont have ANY taste. And she most certainly DOESN'T sound like a whining baby... And if this is what a whining baby sounds like, then I'm gonna listen to one every bloody day.

[Miahface]

Obviously a stalker in the making...

Like i said, this is MY opinion and i honestly couldn't care less if some random crazy stalker disagrees with it.

[LuFf33U]

And what I said was MY opinion. I really son't see how disagreeing to comment on youtube makes me a stalker. And although Alexandra is a good singer, there's nothing original about her; she's just another singer that. On the contrary, Diana is unique and quirky.

[Miahface]

No actually because you were attacking me saying i have no taste when you obviously know me sooo well?! where as i was just stating my opinion about THE QUESTION. And i don't think Diana is unique and 'quirky' because i've actually heard a ton of singers that sing the way she does but miles better [not that hard] they just arent as well know as they didnt go on x factor! Plus Alexandra can actually sing in tune.

[LuFf33U]

I don't need to know you well to think that you have bad taste in music. I just took my knowledge of your taste in music and commented on that. And I don't think you can talk, you've been condradicting the majority of the people that have commented by making blatantly insulting remarks about Diana Vickers' singing. Diana is quirky, you have to give her that. It's isn't just the way she sings, her personality, looks and even her accent make her the way that she is.