like @billiam4 said they were practically just kids. they were'nt music experts by a long shot. gradually they managed to communicate their meaning and understanding through music and this became more dynamic and creative than any of them could have imagined. also if you haven't already i recommend listening to the bournemouth winter gardens live version. real mindblowing.
This tracks great way better than the rather lame album version, I'm sure not many people knew Ian was such a great Guitarist, So that makes Singer, Song writer and lyricist a complete performer.
How did Iggy and Bowie influence this brilliance? You know Ian had to have been in a dark place in his head to emulate it so masterfully through this music. I wish he could have stomped some of that out so he could still be here with us.
para todos los fanaticos de esta gran banda no permitire que este album se termine con 2 canciones... el 2 de enero colgare mi primer single no me fallen acabemos con la basura comercial trivial por M M pasen la voz
everybody waiting the album complete for just 2 song wonderfull
my band is same style because i am influence about this but
need speech if you liked this band then i am sure that you will my band 2 january my first song on youtube i called trivial by M M
para todos los fanaticos de esta gran banda no permitire que este album se termine con 2 canciones... el 2 de enero colgare mi primer single no me fallen acabemos con la basura comercial trivial por M M pasen la voz
everybody waiting the album complete for just 2 song wonderfull
my band is same style because i am influence about this but
need speech if you liked this band then i am sure that you will my band 2 january my first song on youtube i called trivial by M M
i was listening to a joy playlist i made for then, then i deleted. the song i heard had a hella alot of guitar and it kept building wondering if this was the one or is there more? anymore like that i am missing? i will have to look . poor me. heh
@HazeFerRillz The studio version of this song doesn't take this much time to build up and "begin". If it was another song you're referring to, it's probably Dead Souls.
@eatshitgoogle do you know any others with alot of instrumental ? and varying repetition / eratic like . im pretty sure it wasn't t dead souls. thanx for the look out & reply.
i wouldnt want joy division to be in todays music scene. not a single band in todays mainstream music can hold a candle to joy division. jd's presence it to worthy to be in todays music scene
u mean u2 ripped off joy division, like when they wrote she's outta control, wonder where they got that title from.. shame they didn't have 1 thousandth the talent of JD. U" are a bunch of cocks... the EDGE, the edge of what??? he's the worst guitarist ever....
@mojaroar very true, sadly bland music can turn you into megastars. bono leaches onto anything that's cool - usually about 20 years after it's happened. He's done the same thing with Kraftwerk, now tries to make out they were an influence, I have no idea how
I saw them at the Rainbow Theatre April 4th in London, fascinating show. Though I perhaps did not appreciate as much then as I do now! He was dead in six weeks.
Wonderful, but frightening... I don't hear this very often... it's probably the darkes song in music history.... shows how goths and black metallers are ridiculous when compared to this...
@Billiam4 I don't think my headphones will ever be loud enough lol! It's just amazing how something so powerful was made by a group of lads in their early 20's!? They were kids! It just gives me hope that I can do something like this but take it to the next level.
Well, Ian cashed in his chips just before they were supposed to play Tuts in Chcago, and I used to regret the cancellation, but now that I've seen this video, I REALLY fucking regret it! Beyond this world ...
Joy Division, Wire and The Fall took music and destroyed it to make something completely new with what´s left. This was the greatest time of Rock&Pop. Nowaday´s not even underground can scratch on this.
jd are great at instrumental build ups. deads souls, no love lost to but name 2. the tension is palpable by the time ian curtis begins to sing. superb.
You can hear the forshadowing of so many bands that followed and flat out copied this sound. How many many come to mind!!! Incredibly talented and way ahead of their time. Muchas gracias.
WOOW como me impresiona esta Banda! demasiado adelantados para su epoca!,para mi son uno los padres del rock alternativo,apenas puedo creer que esto haya sido grabado en los 70's! descanse en paz IAN CURTIS
minha música favorita do joy division
alinesister01 1 week ago
Raw..
Demiurgi81 1 week ago
like @billiam4 said they were practically just kids. they were'nt music experts by a long shot. gradually they managed to communicate their meaning and understanding through music and this became more dynamic and creative than any of them could have imagined. also if you haven't already i recommend listening to the bournemouth winter gardens live version. real mindblowing.
ceremony1372 1 month ago
@ceremony1372 i dont no wat you think KIDS are was it a long time a go you went to churts
marchel26666 1 week ago in playlist Joy division
@marchel26666 i did'nt mean kids literally. just using it in a general way. like lads or whatever. yeah they were over 20 obviously. im just sayin
ceremony1372 1 week ago
This tracks great way better than the rather lame album version, I'm sure not many people knew Ian was such a great Guitarist, So that makes Singer, Song writer and lyricist a complete performer.
kriz716 2 months ago
@HazeFerRillz no love lost
alehander42 3 months ago
Alguien me pode decir la cancion en la que el bajo es el instrumento principal? Grax
cambiadecanal 6 months ago
@cambiadecanal
Isolation?
Einvestigator96 1 month ago
@cambiadecanal La cancion From Safety to Where es bueno por tocar el bajo
360Freakoutkid 1 month ago
this is how music has to be.
ronaldvanderkleij 9 months ago
@ronaldvanderkleij amen to that
Kento617 9 months ago
wow and wow again!! love this video
weedniac 10 months ago
I remember nothing but Joy Divisions outstanding music and sweet Ians godly voice...Thanks a lot for sharing:)
TheRoseanne58 1 year ago
...
GigsixstringC 1 year ago
How did Iggy and Bowie influence this brilliance? You know Ian had to have been in a dark place in his head to emulate it so masterfully through this music. I wish he could have stomped some of that out so he could still be here with us.
dietcoke1z 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
para todos los fanaticos de esta gran banda no permitire que este album se termine con 2 canciones... el 2 de enero colgare mi primer single no me fallen acabemos con la basura comercial trivial por M M pasen la voz
everybody waiting the album complete for just 2 song wonderfull
my band is same style because i am influence about this but
need speech if you liked this band then i am sure that you will my band 2 january my first song on youtube i called trivial by M M
maverickMAQUIAVILE 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
para todos los fanaticos de esta gran banda no permitire que este album se termine con 2 canciones... el 2 de enero colgare mi primer single no me fallen acabemos con la basura comercial trivial por M M pasen la voz
everybody waiting the album complete for just 2 song wonderfull
my band is same style because i am influence about this but
need speech if you liked this band then i am sure that you will my band 2 january my first song on youtube i called trivial by M M
maverickMAQUIAVILE 1 year ago
i was listening to a joy playlist i made for then, then i deleted. the song i heard had a hella alot of guitar and it kept building wondering if this was the one or is there more? anymore like that i am missing? i will have to look . poor me. heh
HazeFerRillz 1 year ago
@HazeFerRillz The studio version of this song doesn't take this much time to build up and "begin". If it was another song you're referring to, it's probably Dead Souls.
eatshitgoogle 11 months ago
@eatshitgoogle do you know any others with alot of instrumental ? and varying repetition / eratic like . im pretty sure it wasn't t dead souls. thanx for the look out & reply.
HazeFerRillz 11 months ago
A W E S O M E ....
beforethree 1 year ago
A M A Z I N G ! How I wish I'd been there...
diskochimp 1 year ago
I wonder if U2 got their idea from these song in Bullet the Blue sky. Also check you youtube/wisprworld
wisprworld 1 year ago
@wisprworld interesting thought
wildenfree1 1 year ago
I wonder if U2 got their idea from these song in bullet the blue sky. Also check you youtube/wisprworld
wisprworld 1 year ago
A shit recording of a great performance. God dammit
Megajosh2 1 year ago
Luv jd, but this is noise
coo2kachoo 1 year ago
give me headche which makes me feel better
auchino1s 1 year ago
"Soy el unico que ha subido este video". and so what???? that doesnot mean that the vidéo belongs to you!!! YOU didn't shot this vidéo!
gillesnewwave 1 year ago
Ian Curtis is ALIVE!!!!
lanser87 1 year ago
my foundation.........
bombenfreund 1 year ago
...
TheGigsixstringAge 1 year ago
Holy shit
AndPlus 1 year ago
One one the darkest performance I have ever seen.
Just try to imagine how Joy Division could change the music if they existed since today...
gab136 1 year ago
@gab136
i wouldnt want joy division to be in todays music scene. not a single band in todays mainstream music can hold a candle to joy division. jd's presence it to worthy to be in todays music scene
guitar19904 1 year ago
joy division 4ever!!!
86devora 1 year ago
JOY DIVISION IN A LONELY PLACE 5 MINITE PLUS VERSION!!! TYPE, JOY DIVISION IN A LONELY PLACE COMPLETE VERSION, IN TO YOU TUBE SEARCH.
ds
birdandthe 1 year ago
I Remember Nothing ...
TheGigsixstringAge 1 year ago
where was this ?
birdandthe 1 year ago
beginning sounds remarkably like u2's "bullet the blue sky" (?)
dcs92567 1 year ago
u mean u2 ripped off joy division, like when they wrote she's outta control, wonder where they got that title from.. shame they didn't have 1 thousandth the talent of JD. U" are a bunch of cocks... the EDGE, the edge of what??? he's the worst guitarist ever....
mojaroar 1 year ago 5
@mojaroar ..
Yes sir right you are...I like to call them Douche2
AlDarko 1 year ago
@mojaroar very true, sadly bland music can turn you into megastars. bono leaches onto anything that's cool - usually about 20 years after it's happened. He's done the same thing with Kraftwerk, now tries to make out they were an influence, I have no idea how
chrisnoaro1 1 year ago
the sound is a bit distorted but otherwise this is better than the studio version
paolorossifan2006 2 years ago 2
i love roug recordings myself. they sound so raw and personal than studio recordings
guitar19904 2 years ago 2
esta realmente genial
darkfun2 2 years ago
brasileiro fã de Joy é Dificiu ver heim husahusahusa
adoro Joy
Ruffyhimura 1 year ago
thinking ourselves darker than ancient hells, give us a sense of peace and rest ever seen, isn't it?
TheLasal 2 years ago 2
I saw them at the Rainbow Theatre April 4th in London, fascinating show. Though I perhaps did not appreciate as much then as I do now! He was dead in six weeks.
brookesaunders 2 years ago 7
Damn u r so lucky...most of us can only dream of it...!!!
karziflora 2 years ago 2
utterly brilliant! wish I had been there!
engineroomapocalypse 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
If it wasn't for sex, i wouldn't be alive.
sleepingundrtree 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I like sex. Is nice. You can use my sister, she is good!
mrrrxxxxx 2 years ago
the perfect band for rediscovery on youtube
knownpleasures 2 years ago 3
absolute masterpiece
robert99brown 2 years ago 4
first doom song
stretchmillz101 2 years ago 7
Joy Division are the MAESTROS of intense, dark, powerful, soul piercing music!!!
Haunting & chilling as HELL!!!
karziflora 2 years ago 8
Wonderful, but frightening... I don't hear this very often... it's probably the darkes song in music history.... shows how goths and black metallers are ridiculous when compared to this...
aneworderfan 2 years ago 12
We almost see the dark souls around the band members...
prozacpeople 2 years ago 7
My particulars obsessions revisited...
Morgothfagundes 2 years ago 4
this song is so powerful and beautiful
it literally gives me chills
this is amazing live footage thanks so much!
0scaru 2 years ago 2
I wish, I had a time machine!
carlamccoy 2 years ago 51
Comment removed
feithusch 1 year ago
@carlamccoy yes...how true!
Urielthelost 1 year ago
Joy Division are one of the giants of my youth, and they will accompany me for the rest of my life for certain.
This live version is so amazing touching onto industrial, it's pure genius. I recommend to play it loud as possible.
Billiam4 2 years ago 28
@Billiam4 I don't think my headphones will ever be loud enough lol! It's just amazing how something so powerful was made by a group of lads in their early 20's!? They were kids! It just gives me hope that I can do something like this but take it to the next level.
Kento617 9 months ago
it takes some serious stones to play this song live. they succeeded brilliantly here.
mercury110 2 years ago 7
Mesmerizing!. Thanks, Alicia, just missed the breaking glass.
angulovideo 2 years ago
JD does TG?
madcapoperator 2 years ago
Muy buen video, Gracias por subirlo AliciaCurtis has de ser la esposa del Ian Curtis o su hermana?
rodmen98 2 years ago
This song sure sounds even more depressive and sinister live.
LeopBloom 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
joy division,the name says it all
josealexandro080608 2 years ago
this is so slow and full of drone is almost doom.
its fuckin genius!
postpunker 2 years ago
strong
emirss 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
thats a song?
TRBNGR666 2 years ago
You obviously don't know joy division TRBNGR666 check out some other material they were a superb band.
ittaiman 2 years ago 5
Great guitar :)
adrianmad1981 2 years ago 2
this is fuckin amazing...love the drone!
fffergieferg 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The moment(s) of following...waiting for ''Weee''...Did mens want for like Hitchock? :]
Sannjasin 3 years ago
i think it's one of the best and most intense JD songs, ever... either you get it, or you don't. they were WAY ahead of their time... wow.
gracias por subirlo!
Pacafeliz 3 years ago
"Fuckin hell,this song is shite!"
Hmm...kind of surprised you write this. For me, this was the most powerful thing that they ever did, the whole video is absolutely majestic.
This song is simply unsurpassed, nobody ever did anything as powerful as this.
Just awesome!
(btw, I didn't minus your comment, it's your opinion, that's your right!)
IamScarface 3 years ago 5
Well, Ian cashed in his chips just before they were supposed to play Tuts in Chcago, and I used to regret the cancellation, but now that I've seen this video, I REALLY fucking regret it! Beyond this world ...
lezzenzero 3 years ago
I love the drone. I love the drone.
NinetiesYouth 3 years ago 6
Thanks for digging up a video of this... strange stuff, not any less masterful
walonsubi 3 years ago
i love this song.
asche1987 3 years ago 2
niesamowita piosenka i kurwa on ma zajebisty głos idealnie pasuje do muzyki
ejzojeden 3 years ago
Joy Division, Wire and The Fall took music and destroyed it to make something completely new with what´s left. This was the greatest time of Rock&Pop. Nowaday´s not even underground can scratch on this.
allmaecht 3 years ago 6
sweet jesus
Giovannisenzaterra 3 years ago
rare video, thanks for upload it!
AngelMiami 3 years ago
ke rolooooonaa!
migueltavera 3 years ago
Their very best song.
SigneRobertson 3 years ago
Łał, daje poi berecie.
I mean, good.
Velianna 3 years ago
this just doesnt make sense who are these people where am i ooooo
cajohn54 3 years ago
Thank you.
marsfieldmusic 3 years ago
la unica o el unico???
cezarix 3 years ago
So good live.
xyling 3 years ago
best song
afroboy94 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
that gave me major headache
redflagal08 3 years ago
stop listening to great music then
you may be allergic
paulclargo 3 years ago 6
there is nothing more you can remember
...there is nothing more you can feel
...what you are is nothing
...what you dream of is ilussion
zielony9999 3 years ago
-- speachless
Pigsywigsy 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
du kralio porra...
philokiko 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
du kralio porra...
philokiko 3 years ago
So I now have the Here Are The Young Men VHS and can see where most of the rare live clips come from now.
donnybrooklads 3 years ago
Joy divisions most haunting song?
RebeccaChambersBF 4 years ago
As cliche as it is, i'd still say Love Will Tear Us Apart is the most haunting. Gives me a shiver everytime i hear it.
PUMF 4 years ago
defo
and new dawn fades
joydivision19842 4 years ago 5
i agree, also most underrated
Soniclife91 3 years ago 2
so true
guitarmastaasd 3 years ago
another stunning joy division video
joydivision19842 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
whatever happened to this pop banned.
TehHoldSteady 4 years ago
er, well, the lead singer hanging himself sort of threw a spanner in the works really...
AnyNameNotUsedYet 4 years ago
it did kinda did nt it whatever happened to this band indeed
dermot51 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i thought he overdosed on barbiturates??
feron9 3 years ago
*Post punk
RebeccaChambersBF 3 years ago
This is probably Eindhoven 1980 or possibly it is Leuven.
4N3Y 4 years ago
@4N3Y No this was from The Apollo.
RiotNrrrdUTube 1 year ago
@RiotNrrrdUTube
Was this ever released on anything besides the video tape "Here Are The Young men"?
monkeytek 1 year ago
@monkeytek unknown pleasures album
birdandthe 1 year ago
@birdandthe
Thanks, I meant this version!
monkeytek 1 year ago
@monkeytek No, just on HATYM.
RiotNrrrdUTube 1 year ago
If it wasn't for Martin Hannett's mastery in electronic sound effects Barney wouldn't know what to do at that time with that sound board!
donnybrooklads 4 years ago
And you think he would now :)
TehHoldSteady 3 years ago
Comment removed
holllly0 2 years ago
jd are great at instrumental build ups. deads souls, no love lost to but name 2. the tension is palpable by the time ian curtis begins to sing. superb.
CloudesleyShovel 4 years ago 4
great footage
makky123 4 years ago
date please?
pathoplastic 4 years ago
79 supporting the Buzzcocks
tosh2804 4 years ago
Really underrated song, never forget first seeing this video, mindblowing!!
IamScarface 4 years ago 2
great footage.
thank you for the video.
gangofanthony 4 years ago
un gran coñazo, pero porlomenos a alguien les gusta.
MarinaUtena 4 years ago
Hail to the Ian!
Just great.
BioCurtis 4 years ago
You can hear the forshadowing of so many bands that followed and flat out copied this sound. How many many come to mind!!! Incredibly talented and way ahead of their time. Muchas gracias.
joyxdivision 4 years ago
This is really ominous and creepy!
ferry64 4 years ago
WOOW como me impresiona esta Banda! demasiado adelantados para su epoca!,para mi son uno los padres del rock alternativo,apenas puedo creer que esto haya sido grabado en los 70's! descanse en paz IAN CURTIS
tarkiss 5 years ago