This is awesome! I gotta get my hands on this single. Sounds like Joy Division percussion with Siouxie and the Banshees guitar and Thom's voice, which is apparently a GREAT COMBO.
i like this version equally as the one on the album. its more raw on this one the percussion is more fun, but the vocals... just... idk.. i can't put my finger on it. love it. i know that.
well i imagine this is just thom with a sequencer, and the kind of demo to give to band members to show a new song? its hardly meant to be judge along side any album tracks. i think an all-acoustic version i'd like, much like older demos like black star.
My point is that I genuinely liked this version of the song but it was just distressing for me to read all this shit people were saying about it. Their mindset is that just because this version sounds different than the one they're used to automatically makes it inferior and intolerable. And their attitude, I don't get why they think theyre so much better than other people just because they listen to an avant garde band. Thom Yorke and the others are just as human as anyone else for fuck's sake.
@c0mLAG That's how I always type but if you need a thesaurus to understand me that's your own problem retard. Here let me dumb it down for you,
oMG U GUISE Y U SO MEEN THIS SONG SO PRETTY JUS CUZ ITS NOT ON THAT THER CD VERSHUN DONT MEEN ITS NOT GUD DONT BEE SUCH MEEN DOODOO HEADS
That's basically what I said except with a lot less conviction. It's pathetic how you're probably one of those pretentious Radiohead fans I was talking about yet you get intimidated by high school vocabulary words.
@irvingcsaltzburg ..You don't really know how a thesaurus is used, do you? And you need to pull your head out of your ass on the 'pretentious' shit. You're the arrogant prick who thinks people really give a shit. So what? Someone doesn't like this version of a song? And how fuck can you compare this to Kid A anyway? Might as well be comparing Aphex Twin and early-Smashing Pumpkins in terms of sound. Now go and spend your paycheck from the job you're underqualified for and buy a gun.
@c0mLAG I use a thesaurus all the time to look up words I don't know fuckhead, you look at the list of synonyms and it helps put the word in context, apparently you're the one who doesn't know how to use one. And I never compared this song to Kid A you fucking idiot, go back and actually read what I said because I'm getting really sick of simplifying things for you to understand. People like you are the reason why I only try to make friends with people who hate Radiohead.
@irvingcsaltzburg "I use a thesaurus all the time to look up words I don't know fuckhead" < thats a dictionary, tough guy. " - enough to accept something like Kid A but then treat the intended version of one of their best songs like it was a dirty neanderthal." < and thats you using the comparison of Kid A to There, There but then I read back and it seems you're comparing the production.
@irvingcsaltzburg "I use a thesaurus all the time to look up words I don't know fuckhead" < that's a dictionary, tough guy. "how you can be open-minded enough to accept something like Kid A but then treat the intended version of one of their best songs like it was a dirty neanderthal" < and that's your comparison to Kid A, even though it was about the production and not the sound.
@irvingcsaltzburg "I use a thesaurus all the time to look up words I don't know fuckhead" < that's a dictionary, tough guy. "how you can be open-minded enough to accept something like Kid A but then treat the intended version of one of their best songs like it was a dirty neanderthal" < and that's your comparison to Kid A, even though it was about the production and not the sound. As for the "friends with people who hate Radiohead", I'm not the one talking out of my ass, you are.
CONGRATULATIONS THIS IDIOTIC AND POINTLESS ARGUMENT HAS NOW TAKEN UP A FULL PAGE, because you can't seem to comprehend the simplest shit and I have to keep coming back here to correct you.
Notice what I said after the line you quoted me on "you look at the list of synonyms and it helps put the word in context" HMM WHAT KIND OF BOOK DOES THAT I WONDER I'll give you a hint it's not a fucking dictionary retard. Would you like to argue for another page on what a thesaurus is or are we done here?
@c0mLAG And I WAS comparing the sound of Kid A and this demo, in the sense that they both sound radically different than most everything else, what the fuck made you think I was talking about their production value? I was using Kid A as a point of reference to show these fans' hypocrisy for criticizing a song just because it sounds different. That's the only fucking reason I even mentioned Kid A, I don't know how you're pulling all these moronic assumptions out of your ass.
@irvingcsaltzburg It would be the thick headed one to call everyone down because of the "simplest shit". What the fuck is a dictionary used for then, you dumb cunt? To find definitions to what words mean? And then I was right about Kid A being compared. You're wrong. And the production as in this is a demo and that Kid A is not mainstream garbage. The sound. A different wording. Oh god. As if you're in any place to talk down to anyone. And you continued this as well, so don't be so smug.
You people are all fucking crazy. I love this song but I actually prefer this demo to the album version, it feels so raw and emotional which makes the song so much more personal, to me anyway. Fucking pretentious Radiohead fans, I don't understand how you can be open-minded enough to accept something like Kid A but then treat the intended version of one of their best songs like it was a dirty neanderthal just because it wasn't yet overly produced to sound appeasing to the masses.
A really crappy version, can´t belive that they actually released it. The album version is in my ears one of their best songs ever. But fun to see/hear that even a band like Radiohead starts out with sounds like this before they decide how it SHOULD sound. But still a big mystery how they could release it...
Glad they changed it, this version is obiously worse. Still good, but not as genius as the album version.
The singing is much less confident, which really is a downer:
The narrator is supposed to be comforting, to be helping the 'you' person in the song. Being as shitty sad and cowering like the singing, kinda ruins the beauty of the song.
hmmmmm......us radiohead fans dont speak to echother that way....were kinda like a family yknow?...i guess you dont.......please take your violence to another place.thank you kindly.
I mean to ask what that lyric that sounds to my ears like "don't be shy" (barely heard here, and heard live) is? cause that doesn't seem right to me. but I can't find it or make it out
you can get a version off hail to the theif, their album. You could fish around limewire and such for this version, or have a pop at dowloading it strait from youtube and converting it to an MP3.
thanks dude let me tell you something,i like so much brithish music as radiohead,pj harvey,morrisey,beatles,travis,sorry for my bad english apreciate it
LOL at the dude who said it wasn't real. One glance at Wikipedia obviously confirms a "There There" demo was released as a B-side to "2+2=5."
Anywho, I prefer the final "Hail...Thief" version of this legendary song, but it's definitely interesting to hear this. Thom's vocals here are very nice.
i love this version. httt is the best album of all time
igorchillipeppers123 2 months ago
great diversion if you have listened to to the original version a thousand times. i even like the vocals (Y)
casual1324 3 months ago
I prefer the style of singing of Thom Yorke on this recording to hail to the thief version. And two voices and bass at the second part
bazariaraa 3 months ago
imagine the percussion from this version coupled with the solo from the final version...
JERKsaboy 4 months ago
crap, some vocal work with conviction and more pronounced everything else and this would be a top song from another rock band
WINFIELD32750 5 months ago
Comment removed
AustinBrock2 5 months ago
It's a shame Thom forgot to open his mouth when he was singing this, could have been a good version.
Longpigmss 5 months ago 4
This is awesome! I gotta get my hands on this single. Sounds like Joy Division percussion with Siouxie and the Banshees guitar and Thom's voice, which is apparently a GREAT COMBO.
thatguitarkid 7 months ago
i love this version, why do b-sides become better than a-sides?
PlanetAirsoftPlym 8 months ago
i like this version equally as the one on the album. its more raw on this one the percussion is more fun, but the vocals... just... idk.. i can't put my finger on it. love it. i know that.
iputmyhanduponmyhip 8 months ago 2
Fuck you all. Thats how i want music! Raw and natural. This is awsome!
Nirvaaanaa 9 months ago
well i imagine this is just thom with a sequencer, and the kind of demo to give to band members to show a new song? its hardly meant to be judge along side any album tracks. i think an all-acoustic version i'd like, much like older demos like black star.
jorgepeterbarton 10 months ago
This sends me into a weird trance. Thom sounds kind of embarrassed to sing in this...like he's been dared by the others to sing along.
YurzAndMyne 11 months ago
This opening drum sounds like Leaders of men by joy division
speedybill47 11 months ago
I think this one is just as good as the Album version
talkingbeatlehead 11 months ago
@talkingbeatlehead Same here, whats everyone yapping for, its fucking sweet.
oasis12334 11 months ago
@oasis12334 more like Uber i love the drum more in this one
talkingbeatlehead 11 months ago
My point is that I genuinely liked this version of the song but it was just distressing for me to read all this shit people were saying about it. Their mindset is that just because this version sounds different than the one they're used to automatically makes it inferior and intolerable. And their attitude, I don't get why they think theyre so much better than other people just because they listen to an avant garde band. Thom Yorke and the others are just as human as anyone else for fuck's sake.
irvingcsaltzburg 1 year ago
@irvingcsaltzberg you need to calm down on the thesaurus. your shitty speech seems just as over produced.
c0mLAG 1 year ago
@c0mLAG That's how I always type but if you need a thesaurus to understand me that's your own problem retard. Here let me dumb it down for you,
oMG U GUISE Y U SO MEEN THIS SONG SO PRETTY JUS CUZ ITS NOT ON THAT THER CD VERSHUN DONT MEEN ITS NOT GUD DONT BEE SUCH MEEN DOODOO HEADS
That's basically what I said except with a lot less conviction. It's pathetic how you're probably one of those pretentious Radiohead fans I was talking about yet you get intimidated by high school vocabulary words.
irvingcsaltzburg 1 year ago
@irvingcsaltzburg ..You don't really know how a thesaurus is used, do you? And you need to pull your head out of your ass on the 'pretentious' shit. You're the arrogant prick who thinks people really give a shit. So what? Someone doesn't like this version of a song? And how fuck can you compare this to Kid A anyway? Might as well be comparing Aphex Twin and early-Smashing Pumpkins in terms of sound. Now go and spend your paycheck from the job you're underqualified for and buy a gun.
c0mLAG 1 year ago
@c0mLAG I use a thesaurus all the time to look up words I don't know fuckhead, you look at the list of synonyms and it helps put the word in context, apparently you're the one who doesn't know how to use one. And I never compared this song to Kid A you fucking idiot, go back and actually read what I said because I'm getting really sick of simplifying things for you to understand. People like you are the reason why I only try to make friends with people who hate Radiohead.
irvingcsaltzburg 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@irvingcsaltzburg "I use a thesaurus all the time to look up words I don't know fuckhead" < thats a dictionary, tough guy. " - enough to accept something like Kid A but then treat the intended version of one of their best songs like it was a dirty neanderthal." < and thats you using the comparison of Kid A to There, There but then I read back and it seems you're comparing the production.
c0mLAG 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@irvingcsaltzburg "I use a thesaurus all the time to look up words I don't know fuckhead" < that's a dictionary, tough guy. "how you can be open-minded enough to accept something like Kid A but then treat the intended version of one of their best songs like it was a dirty neanderthal" < and that's your comparison to Kid A, even though it was about the production and not the sound.
c0mLAG 1 year ago
@irvingcsaltzburg "I use a thesaurus all the time to look up words I don't know fuckhead" < that's a dictionary, tough guy. "how you can be open-minded enough to accept something like Kid A but then treat the intended version of one of their best songs like it was a dirty neanderthal" < and that's your comparison to Kid A, even though it was about the production and not the sound. As for the "friends with people who hate Radiohead", I'm not the one talking out of my ass, you are.
c0mLAG 1 year ago
CONGRATULATIONS THIS IDIOTIC AND POINTLESS ARGUMENT HAS NOW TAKEN UP A FULL PAGE, because you can't seem to comprehend the simplest shit and I have to keep coming back here to correct you.
Notice what I said after the line you quoted me on "you look at the list of synonyms and it helps put the word in context" HMM WHAT KIND OF BOOK DOES THAT I WONDER I'll give you a hint it's not a fucking dictionary retard. Would you like to argue for another page on what a thesaurus is or are we done here?
irvingcsaltzburg 1 year ago
@c0mLAG And I WAS comparing the sound of Kid A and this demo, in the sense that they both sound radically different than most everything else, what the fuck made you think I was talking about their production value? I was using Kid A as a point of reference to show these fans' hypocrisy for criticizing a song just because it sounds different. That's the only fucking reason I even mentioned Kid A, I don't know how you're pulling all these moronic assumptions out of your ass.
irvingcsaltzburg 1 year ago
@irvingcsaltzburg It would be the thick headed one to call everyone down because of the "simplest shit". What the fuck is a dictionary used for then, you dumb cunt? To find definitions to what words mean? And then I was right about Kid A being compared. You're wrong. And the production as in this is a demo and that Kid A is not mainstream garbage. The sound. A different wording. Oh god. As if you're in any place to talk down to anyone. And you continued this as well, so don't be so smug.
c0mLAG 1 year ago
You people are all fucking crazy. I love this song but I actually prefer this demo to the album version, it feels so raw and emotional which makes the song so much more personal, to me anyway. Fucking pretentious Radiohead fans, I don't understand how you can be open-minded enough to accept something like Kid A but then treat the intended version of one of their best songs like it was a dirty neanderthal just because it wasn't yet overly produced to sound appeasing to the masses.
irvingcsaltzburg 1 year ago
I'm feelin' it
roblowefan1 1 year ago
I played this in my house the other day and my brother started dancing like Ian Curtis.
PunkFictionProdction 1 year ago
JOY DIVISION!
pstrokeslibsarctic 1 year ago 3
The Phil snareroll is deeply missed here.
popoyt 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
IT REMINDS ME TO JOY DIVISION
fernandofrias1 1 year ago
IT REMINDS ME TO JOY DIVISION
fernandofrias1 1 year ago
Well I, for one, thought it was cute.
banans21 1 year ago
well...i think i love it just the same...even more...kill me or something
so soft the voices...prefer this version for the listening, the official for the concerts
tartufo7y7 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
A really crappy version, can´t belive that they actually released it. The album version is in my ears one of their best songs ever. But fun to see/hear that even a band like Radiohead starts out with sounds like this before they decide how it SHOULD sound. But still a big mystery how they could release it...
FatherFakkers 1 year ago
@FatherFakkers Well, that's why b-sides exist, and usually fans look for them.
inferneko 1 year ago 24
@inferneko word, I agree. I also enjoy different versions - but this was a really an expetion from other b-sides.
FatherFakkers 1 year ago
@FatherFakkers
ya man. i just see this as an alternate version. and personaly, i really like it! (nothing compares to the original of course
stickman225 1 year ago
Krautrock FTW XD
araglar101 1 year ago
Glad they fixed it for the studio version.
UnitedStatesOfPariah 1 year ago
Glad they changed it, this version is obiously worse. Still good, but not as genius as the album version.
The singing is much less confident, which really is a downer:
The narrator is supposed to be comforting, to be helping the 'you' person in the song. Being as shitty sad and cowering like the singing, kinda ruins the beauty of the song.
ewfq2 1 year ago
@ewfq2 whatever dude...
yousuperpussy 1 year ago
Muse stole the drum beat from this but i cant remember the name of the song, it's identical.
jirdimaster 1 year ago
@jirdimaster supermassive blackhole perhaps?
MicahBuzan 1 year ago
@MicahBuzan It was exo-politics i think
jirdimaster 1 year ago
@jirdimaster You sure that's not Air Traffic you're thinking of? 'No More Running Away' is what comes to my mind.
skullface89 1 year ago
i love it! so raw and abrasive
johnc310 2 years ago 2
RADIOHEAD¡¡¡
EDguitar65 2 years ago
"we are accidents waiting to happen. "
radiohead aint no accident.
seapockets 2 years ago 5
Thank you for posting it!
Mey405 2 years ago
a link to download this one would be appreciated
Charlieepy 2 years ago
The structure of the song is less padded, bonier, and probably better to learn if you want to play this song.
aphor 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is definitely not radiohead - whoever posted this used a program. please do not think this is radiohead. lol
Walloflce 2 years ago
unfortunately, IT IS :(
although this song ain't THAT BAD
ILovToilet 2 years ago
it is radiohead they even have video of this jam
ItsWhatever24 2 years ago 3
your an idiot
Recovrd1 2 years ago
i like this version, it feels like they are on a empty stage just the echoes makes you drawn to it even more.
flaperise 2 years ago 3
Heaven sent you to me...love Ed's backing vocals, well clear...me likey this...
slumpytube 2 years ago
Actually, that's Phil.
bigclownshoes 2 years ago
The only thing I miss is the awesome guitar during all of the "We are accidents" part.
dandelionhero 2 years ago 11
Me too, I love that part, good they imroved this demo version to make the actual album version ;)
inferneko 2 years ago 2
@dandelionhero I miss the bassline
rippersk8er 7 months ago
You almost can't hear Thom's voice in this version of the song.
MSepol 2 years ago
True, but I think his voice is better in this version.
coffmantra18 2 years ago
hahahaha yeah! sound like basketball!!
55charlietoy 2 years ago 9
Thom sings like he doesn't want to wake up the neighbors .... thank you for the upload(s)
hilomona 2 years ago 16
the drums at the start sound like basketballs
1foofighter606 2 years ago 50
thoms voice doesnt sound as good hear but the guitar is better i think
pooop64 2 years ago
i like the drums better in this. ferocious lo-fi goodness.
beeflog1 2 years ago 4
This song has the same ''I mighty be wrong'' vibe ... great Demo .. but I still preffer the album version
Greetings!
taniatikaram 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
the only thing that might be wrong is you u fat slob.
i would murder u if i had the chance
damndirtyRob 2 years ago
Someone has probably had a bad day...
Kewkyness 2 years ago 4
hmmmmm......us radiohead fans dont speak to echother that way....were kinda like a family yknow?...i guess you dont.......please take your violence to another place.thank you kindly.
servo1056 2 years ago
il murder u also
damndirtyRob 2 years ago
so sad.....just so very sad......you choose your own path my friend.
servo1056 2 years ago
Condescending makes you no better, buddy.
remember132 2 years ago
and it what way was i condenscending again?
servo1056 2 years ago
Easily the biggest overreaction to someone's different opinion that I've ever seen.
eyepatchplease 2 years ago
wtf
1foofighter606 2 years ago
thanks for posting this!!!
love it!!!!
zerochance01 2 years ago
i must admit that this version is good, however i love the way that the album version just breaks down at the end
louiscoop1192 2 years ago
i didn't know phil beat boxed!!
Vader12Tater12 3 years ago 5
There There is one of my all time favorite Radiohead song. Can't believe this version, while different, is just as good. Thanks!
LiviaIndica 3 years ago 2
it's much less fierce than the final recording. I like it
itfeelslikenever 3 years ago
thoms voice here....wow, its amazing! So soft, its like having your ears wrapped up in silk...
MLAshadow 3 years ago 4
fucking nice!
Scott17quebec 3 years ago 7
omg awesome awesome awesome
QuietschiiFan 3 years ago 3
thanks for uploading this song.
modernlifechews 3 years ago
ah the last bit of my comment didn't work
I mean to ask what that lyric that sounds to my ears like "don't be shy" (barely heard here, and heard live) is? cause that doesn't seem right to me. but I can't find it or make it out
oh wait
it's "don't reach out," isn't it?
mktrees 3 years ago 2
yes its don't reach out
imdanumber1 3 years ago 2
haha i thought it was 'Only child an only child'
what a tool
KarmaPolice90 3 years ago
I could listen to this all day!
don't be shy, don't be shy
mktrees 3 years ago
i need this song, somebody know where can i get it
rafamexrocker 3 years ago
you can get a version off hail to the theif, their album. You could fish around limewire and such for this version, or have a pop at dowloading it strait from youtube and converting it to an MP3.
MLAshadow 3 years ago
thanks dude let me tell you something,i like so much brithish music as radiohead,pj harvey,morrisey,beatles,travis,sorry for my bad english apreciate it
rafamexrocker 3 years ago
suena good +depresion!!!!!!!!!
Headtizado 3 years ago
this version sounds a bit joy division like!
virusinsideus 3 years ago 45
im glad someone picked up on that...it really was worth saying.
negativecreep90 3 years ago
@virusinsideus hell yes!
TheWhiteNoiseNation 1 year ago
@virusinsideus Sad to imagine what Joy Division might have produced if they had more time. Still my favourite band of all time ahead of Radiohead.
pablooooo77 4 months ago
it would be cool if they had the jam outro on httt
jimisevertoolhed 3 years ago 2
LOL at the dude who said it wasn't real. One glance at Wikipedia obviously confirms a "There There" demo was released as a B-side to "2+2=5."
Anywho, I prefer the final "Hail...Thief" version of this legendary song, but it's definitely interesting to hear this. Thom's vocals here are very nice.
GunslingerXYZ 3 years ago 3
wow, his voice is so soft in this. can you upload this?
srmtpp 3 years ago 2
i am a massive radiohead fan. masssssive. never ever heard this version there's so much on your channel i can feast my eyes on!! : )
johngalantini 3 years ago 2
I really dig this version, thanks for posting it :)
saltythebear 3 years ago
i particularly dig the drum sounds
kalsikum 3 years ago 3
I don't think theirs much radiohead can do wrong,both versions are equal in greatness I excepected this much they shit genius
dead1eyes1crow 3 years ago
wow just great
kalsikum 3 years ago
i got the same one on the 2+2=5 ep. its really good, especially disk 2
TToxicunderground 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fake rh, good for your hobbie practice guys...
visores 3 years ago
Not really, it IS straight out from a Radiohead single, but oh well, belibe what you want :]
inferneko 3 years ago
the drums are very joy division
gregkestenbaum 3 years ago 7
You mean like Atrocity Exhibition? I agree
ZeSephian 3 years ago
Sounds more like someone else's vocals and a remixed sound
Riqtam 3 years ago
Yeah, it could be, but it's not, it's straight out from a Radiohead single ;3
inferneko 3 years ago
@Riqtam you sound more like someones else's vocals and a remixed sound
dust2sday 1 year ago
Awesome tune from the Head
iRECKONER 3 years ago
AMAZING
SnowiQ 3 years ago
Atmospheric, inspiring and beautiful. Music from a different dimension.
Thank You x
LoFizz 3 years ago 4