Added: 4 years ago
From: herebutnotremembered
Views: 47,427
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (365)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • always when i see this video i start crying... i love wincest

  • Awwww omg so sad, you pieced the clips together so wonderfully my god!

  • oh my god.....

    this is the most amazing thing ever

  • I love the video! So sad and then sweet at the end.

  • I'm a Destiel shipper, though I love this vid...what is wrong with me? o.O

  • What episode is the one where Sam hits the wall with the car?? I can't seem to recall it.

  • Fuck.. believe me... I needed tissues. By the end i was already crying and I hasd to attend the public here in the bussyness crying and with... well... that ugly things that gets outs of your nose when you cry a lot. This is awesome... I liked it really much and is the 1st winest video I`ve ever seen... and now I`m watching it again and I think i`m going to start crying again. Dean, you`re so stupid!!!!!

  • I have a puddle of salty tears on my pillow

  • Good job that was great!!

  • Oh god this totally brought a lump to my throat

  • Is this fucking real? I used to watch this show, quite a turn in a different direction...

  • what episode is from 2:19 to 2:27 pls tell me

  • This is amazing! It made me cry, this was so good!♥

  • Nice work !

  • I love everything you have ever made. But this... Amazing. I cry every time I watch this. Perfectly selected scenes, beautiful editing, ans a heartbreaking story. I'll go grab some tissues now.

  • Muito bom! Amei! Eu poderia até mesmo sentir a dor de Sammy ... Coitadinho! Final legal ... Oh, um dia eu aprender a fazer vídeos tão bom quanto o seu ...

    Very good! I love it! I could even feel the pain of Sammy ... Poor thing! Cool end ... Oh, one day I learn to make videos as good as your ...

  • wow awesome!

  • Your video is great but, OMG they're not gay! They're brothers!

  • I've seen A LOT of Wincest -- this is a masterpiece!!! Thank you;)

  • This is awesome! It's simple but oh-so-well done! By the way, has anyone played Live's "I alone" song while watching this video, both song and video synchronize perfectly!

  • Fabulous job, I love the story, you've picked perfect scenes and the music is heart wrenching! Truly excellent, Thank you for sharing! :)

  • This is beautifullly done. I'am seeing this over and over again.

  • I love this vid. I love it so much I want to show all my friends! I'm going to a fan convention in August, for people who make/watch songvids (vividcon.com). I'm putting together an hour long showing of great "story" vids from varying fandoms (Supernatural, Merlin, Dexter, etc.). I'd be honored to include "Stupid" in the playlist. I'd also like to ask if you have a higher res version available for download, or that you'd be able to upload. Your vids rock! E-mail me: lierdumoa at gmail dot com.

  • this is gold!

  • So sad...beautiful job though!

  • One word, beautiful. Just... Beautiful.

    Wonderful job.

    I love it.

    <3

  • I'm a newbie in this fandom, but daaaaamn... You picked those clips perfectly! One of my fave vids so far :D

  • Gorgeous!! you star.

  • I think this is probably one of my favourite AU wincest videos ever (and I've seen plenty). Just so well done. Fitted to the song, edited nicely, amazing.

  • What episode was the scene from 1.18 from? I don't remember ever seeing that O.O

  • @BlizzardRush I think it's from Playthings (season 2, Ep 11) when Sam gets drunk and all angsty, saying that everyone around him dies, and begging Dean to kill him like their father told him to if he'd turn evil. Dean promises just to make sam shut up. 

  • What episode was the scene from 1.18 from? I din't remember ever seeing that O.O

  • Ok, usually I'm don't read or see wincest....but this...this is amazing, really wonderful!!

    Congratulations

    (Sorry my awful english ^///^)

  • I've NEVER cried to a amv before in my entire life. D: FEEL PROUD!

  • Me gustaría poder dejar este comentario en inglés, pero de verdad que la mitad de lo que quiero decir se perdería. Adoro leer porque me hace sentir y tu video también lo hace. (se me han puesto los pelillos de punta XD)

    In my poor english: A wonderfull video. I love that it make me feel. Amazing.

  • @SimplySlash A mí tambien me encanta leer fics sobre todo los wincest. Siiiii viva el wincest.

  • beautiful, you unveil a true story, the feelings of sam are so addictive, I cried

  • Wow this is brilliant!!!!

    poor Sammy :'(, so well made!!!!!

  • SUPER CREATIVE!!!!! SO WINCESTER!!!!

    GOOD JOB!

    LOVE IT

  • mnah. mnah! MNAH!! that's all i can gather to mind right now. MNAH.

    oh my goodness. i broke a bit when dean saw the body bag, and i thought it would be left like that, but then the resurrection was done. mind blowing, just a bit. great job.~

  • OMG!

    I don't really like wincest but this as just amazing +.+

    Great job...!

  • wow! the power and emotions behind this is amazing. you broke my heart then put it back together. seriously, this is one of the best vids I've ever seen ;)

  • °O°

    WOW!

    I mean..really, wow. I like the Story behind this Fanvid. So damn splendid ...and so sad ;_;

  • They cant see this in germany on you tube do u have a other web adress I can go to I want to share this vid with a friend in germany u see. <3 -erica

  • pretty cool, I loved the song

  • wow i´m speechless and nearly crying that was so Samazing .what else can i say you did an really great job as always.andbtw nice song choice

  • Wow this is the best video of sam and dean i have ever seen!! just

  • Wow! Excellent story line and fabulous editing.. a+ vid!

  • Though never gave any thought to Wincest,I have to admit this is so superbly done.The song,the scenes you have used and the ending is just awesome.Absolutely loved it!!Thank you so much for making this!

  • the more times i watch it the more I can see how briliant its put toghether. The feeling the show and lyrics in perfect sync. I also love it becouse its not about lust and sex its about love and how easy it is to fail and hurt someone u love.

  • great video there is no denying that but cum on man brothers dude im not dissin da vid but it doesnt make it less weird

  • So well put together.

    Beautiful.

    If wincest is wrong...I dont want to be right.

  • That was amasing, ive never seen a video flow so wonderfly!!

  • Absolutely amazing! I cannot make these vids I don't have a good enough pc . I watched twice in a row, awesome!

  • Omg I could really see and feel the storieline. Verry nicly done.

  • @The1Bigmama now this is b4 i knw about supernatural but i thought they were gay 2gether but now i know da truth

  • ty vole :D

  • is it wrong that im cursing out Dean? no? ok, ******!!! TT-TT and then poor sammy!!! this lookd so real it kinda creeped me out and i was like NOOOOOO!!!!!!! and then i remembered it wasn't an ep and i was like PHEW! this was so good and felt so real, the best wincest vid i ever seen!!! *rates 10 million stars*

  • @jasdeviel omg i totally agree!!! and sumtimes i hate having such a big imagination cause i swear it taunts me!! TT-TT *joins you in sorrow* this vid made me sad and craving some REAL clips of them and then i membered how impossible tht is and now im here sitting in misery TT-TT

  • O____O...OMG.....OO EMMMMMM GGGGG.....That was so frigging GORGEOUS!!!!! I loved it!! and the story was wonderful :)))).......................*m­ood swing*............U bastard :T_T....*sob sob*, now I've watched this vid I want to see them fucking live EVEN MORE!!!.....and youve reminded me how NOT possible that is T_T....*sob sob=full out balling*........AHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHH.... *wails of misery*

  • Oh I loved this it was heart breaking too. Awesome job with the clips they worked really well and the song choice was perfect.

  • This has to be one of the best Wincest videos I've ever seen. No, scratch that. One of the best videos I've ever seen. The story line fit so well with the songs and the clips! ><

    It was awesome <3

  • Wow.....one of the best Wincest videos I' ve ever seen....

    I ♥ it !!

  • O_O, hermosoo

  • Oh my god that was amazing to watch the story was great and I like how the scenes fit the story

  • [ Scusa, erano finiti i caratteri per i messaggi ^^ ]

    ... Anche solo per negarmi il tuo consenso.

    A proposito, come una stupida ho dimenticato di farti i miei complimenti: grande video, grande canzone, e grande accostamento! Sei davvero brava.

    Amo il Wincest e il tuo è uno dei migliori video che abbia mai trovato, e dannazione, mi ha fatto soffrire tantissimo negli ultimi secondi!

    Fortuna che c'è il lieto fine ^^

    Saluti,

    Elena ;*

  • Ciao, sono Elena, e amo il tuo video <3

    Probabilmente non conosci l'italiano e non credo che mi risponderai mai, ma provo.

    Scrivo e la storia che hai raccontato mi ha affascinato a tal punto che, da che ero nel classico 'blocco dello scrittore' , sono ritornata in pista, carica di idee.

    Ora, posso scrivere una fanfiction sul video?

    Libera di dirmi di no, ovviamente XD

    Se acconsenti metterò credits e link quando - e se - pubblicherò.

    Ti prego, se leggi questo commento, rispondimi! Anche solo

  • just amaxzin

  • Wow, that was really well done

  • nice, love it!

  • wonderful, amazing, awesome just beautiful. This story is perfect. bravo

  • You did an excellent job in storytelling I couldn't keep my eyes off of the screen.

  • Wow...the storytelling in this was excellent, it was so powerful and easy to follow. <3

  • OMG! Thank you. That was really awesome. Just what I needed to cheer me up. Cheers :)

  • omg! that was awesome!

    i luv wincest :)

  • O-o-o-o! Sank-sank-sank!

    Ah!

  • I got a youtube account just to watch your vids! This is one of my favorites so far. Wonderful and your editing flows seamlessly!! Keep up the brilliant work!

  • Um, back again to show my friend and they LOVED it. He loves SPN and said it was just awesome, he believed the storyline you protrayed and your editing is just the best.(Xander) He has no youtube so I write what he said. PLEASE make more. Thanks and seriously, you should go into the media field.

  • oh wow, wow wow wow. this was incredible! you deserve some sort of award for this, it's better than most music videos. I loved the ending. fantastic job. hope you've made more like this :)

  • woooooow. :O

  • Кому нужна песенка - Sarah McLachlan - Stupid)

  • Потрясающее видео! Самое лучшее из слешных о братьях!) Автор молодец!)

  • Comment removed

  • omg

    it's wonderfoul

  • I loved your video!

    It's wonderful! The story was beautiful!

    The end ... Oh my God!

    Amazing ... Just ... Amazing!

  • wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ooooooooooooow is all i have to say. i love the ending. great stuff,.

  • awesome!

    Normally I'm for a tortured Dean, but this is class. :)

  • Nice ending!

  • what eps are 0:48 and 0:51 from?

  • OH, YOU NAILED IT! <3

    I am in totally happy Wincest land 'cause of this.  Just classic. What a vid! Wonderful job.

  • omg, i don't even like wincest, but this...this was TREMENDOUS! it broke my heart </3 very well done

  • ...the win. It's immense. :D

  • This was so amazing. I LOVE the plot, like the previous person it has really sparked my fanficcy side.

  • Oh my gosh, this was so amazingly done! The clips fit perfect! Would you mind terribly if I wrote a fanfic based around your plot?!?

  • I was THIS close to crying! :O I loved it. So beautifully made :)

  • I love how this tells a story!! AWSOME JOB!! It put tears to my eyes!

  • the car crash is a combination of "children shouldnt play with dead things" and "devils trap"

  • this is beautiful...it made me cry. I love it...but what ep. did Sam crash the car in? I am really trying to remember! i have all the SPN dvd sets, and I can't remember...

  • OHHH SOO CUTEEE :'O

    YOU MAKE ME CRY XD

  • That was absolutely amazing. I have never seen a wincest video as good as this. So beautiful...

  • omg...this is a beatiful story what I `ve ever seen before...in my fucking shit life...

    100% it is my fave!!!!!really beatiful, and cant see that they are brothers by movie, just two handsome men! thx for the sharing!!!

  • Wow... Normally, I'm not a huge fan of Wincest, but these clips were picked and placed perfectly... I love it!

  • it all fits!!!!! you made an amazing job!!! OMG! its like watching a wincesty fic!!!!!! weeee...ehem! sorry inner fangirl squeels

  • OMG!!! Truly amazing! So heart breaking. The stroytelling was awesome, everything just flowed together. Great work!

  • greatest vid so far ever!!!!!!!!!!5/5*

  • You did a fantastic job on this!  I really saw the story unfold like a real episode. Great song choice too! Oh and what season was Sam's car wreck from?

  • Comment removed

  • I love this vid!!! great work

  • Epic.

  • I Like. Beautiful. I Love Supernatural and Wincest is amazing. I'm from Brazil and I don't know write in english very well, but this video is so great, I don't resist. Anyway, Eu amei xD

  • love it, i've added to my fav's

  • Sad. But awesome.

    Love it!

    Well done. Really.

  • omg I hate wincest but this was sooo sad and well done!!!! amazing!

  • Oh my god its so sad...but it had a happy ending:)

  • Aw. That made me wanna cry.

  • amazing.. beautiful made video ...nice .. great.. SEX(y).. yeah ..

    -LovE-

  • I am ususally really against Sam/Dean stuff, but the was AMAZING! *crying*. Fantastic editing! Great storyline. i am beyond impressed :)

  • it's brilliant, it's funny, sad, i got tears in my eyes

  • wow. that's great!

  • I love the video, but the ending left it wide open, you should make another, a sequel.

  • Wonderful!

    Fantastically well done.

    Great job.

    <3

  • O

    M

    G

    LOVE IT

  • You've delivered an amazing piece of work. There's an actually story line in it, the audio and video are perfectly combined and of course the wincest ;) <3

  • Which episode is 2:21 when they're both crying?

    Also great editing! I really love this.

  • That episode is called 'Heart'

    Season Two, episode 17.

    ;)

  • so sad!!!!!... but... in a extrange way... i can stop to watch this video... i just love the song an the editing of this video!!!! ♥♥♥

    PD: Sorry my Bad English :P

  • Oo That's brilliant! The editing is just great and the plot... Oo a wonderful video, because it looks so real... and the ending... i'm crying: T___T I'm sorry for my bad english, i want to tell u more, but i can't :D good vid, really, one of my favorits...=)

  • you and Dayln3 are my favs.Your editing is ,well, just excellent.you take one canon and make us fall into the OTHER and damn, i CRIED! I love your work,LOVE it. Thanks..more please???

  • Great video. The clips meshed well, making the transition between the original story and yours easily believable and very heartrending. ^.^

  • Wow, I'm impressed, this is the first vid like this with a story behind it where I didn't have to read the summary down the side to get what was going on. Thoroughly enjoyed it :)

  • i dont like wincest coz i dont like sam the charater not jarred love him anyways this video has turned me around on the subject its beautiful really an excelent job Kudos

  • I think that I have watched this video like 47 times. It's the best one I've seen. Pleaaaaaaaaase keep up the awesome work!!! Love it!

  • i LOVED Sammy with bangs! SAM GET A CUT IN SEASON 5 PLEASE!!

  • omg i loveeee thisss its my all time favorite wincest vid ever XD amazing work. i was set 4 tears sooooo awsome keep it up x

  • omg!!!! that is the greatest vid i have ever seen!!!

    dude!! you got talent!

  • The crying i think is from Heart. I think it season two episode 17 or something like that.

  • What episode is Sam's accident from?

    Awesome video by the way! 5 stars!

  • The BEST Wincest video i've watched in a LONG time!! God you did a GREAT GREAT Job!! T_T happy sad ending *sniffle*

  • i love the last part!

  • i am now a fan ^_-

    This is BRILLANCE!!!!!! *weeps

    Its a dream come tru an Actual Wincest movie *sobs at the greatness

  • Wow.. this looks professional!

  • great!!!

  • This is just brilliant really.

  • Yeah i figured, your a sword swallower lmaoooooooo

  • Fantastic vid! Poor Sam, I was so pity for him and the end was really unexpected, but desireble. Thanks a lot!

  • Просто супер! Так жалко Сэма =(((

  • amaziiiingggg.

  • WOW that's all I can say just WOW

  • omg. I just love it. the greatest wincest vid I have ever seen

    i am your fan,

    herebutnotremembered

    *-*

  • awesome!

  • i loveeee this video =(

    soo good <3 and sadd

  • Oh, poor Sammy. ;)

  • Is there something wrong with me,am i CRAZY! coz i adore this video,and i like it very much,and i,m crying too :( Oh GOD...no,no,i can,t love wincest,i shouldn,t-or i,m in love already

  • beautifully put together :-)

  • Wonderful!

  • woah~

    This made me cry T^T

    5* + FAV

    I totally love this video

  • okay this is one of the only wincest videos that i actually liked! kudos!!

  • uncomparable!! this vid is one of the best i've ever seen....and i've seen a lot of wincest vids! (<--wincest freak)

    can you make more? XD

  • wow! the video is surprising!!

    5 stars! ..

    very good made!!

  • I love this!!!!!! Like a lot!!! Fantastic job!!!

  • Wow that was simply amazing! *favorites*

  • well, that was incredible. kudos on the editing! i'll probably watch this vid a crazy amount of times, lol...

  • Now that was wonderful. You did a fantastic job.

  • holy shit....

  • The end is... hm, i don't like it, but the rest is very nice :D

  • This was above fantastic.

    I cried!

  • your final coment has a point. mostly about the wincest you can clearly see by the faces they make at each other that there's something there. But what?? brotherly love or more?

  • LOL!!!!!!!!!! That's messed up

  • perfect! the story is amazing.

    you are an incredibly talented editor

    i wish i was half as good

  • This is really, really good. I'm going to start watching this show now, and when I'm completely obsessed, I'll have you to thank. :)

  • Oh, my god. Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful. Sad, but totally incredible. I got goosebumps at the end.

  • Wow this video is great. I bet it took a lot of time and effort to make! The story line is a cool and your transitions are perfect.

  • omg AMAZING! INCREDIBLE! BEAUTIFUL! okay im done w/ the big letters. but really this is so great. I could almost believe this to be in the show lol. I also love that you kept the whole 'sell your soul for sammy' thing, not that i liked that Dean did that, well i did because it kept the show on but whatever. Great job, love it, love you. you're awesome!

  • Dios mio, eso fue impresionante, el mejor video concatenado que haya visto de la serie. Buen Trabajo. Amazing!

  • love the vid. where on earth is 2:45 through 2:48 from?

  • I love this video!!!!!!!!

    You've made a really great job! Thanks

  • OMG that was beautiful!

    amazingly edited and perfect song choice!

    Brilliant! thank you x

  • what an amazing video. Tells a brilliant story. Loved it.

  • WOOW! This video is amazing!! thanks!

  • This video is so perfect I can't even put it into words. The editing makes it seem as though its a scene right from the show and every time I watch it I'm speechless and tearing up afterwords!

    The ending is so very powerful, and the music... amazing!!!!!