Hi everybody, could you check out my cover of this? I really would like some feedback on it. Thank you, and thank you Billy Joel for this AMAZING song.
"...and you can have this heart to break." </3 my parents are going through a divorce, and one day, i caught my dad listening to this in his car on the driving, sobbing... i've never seen my dad cry that hard...
My husband proposed to me with this song at the conclusion of his senior piano recital. After completing the song, he stepped down from the stage he knelt by ny sude, presnted me with a pink rose, opened the ring case and placed the ring on my finger, then asked. The wedding itself was beautoful, the nothing can top the proposal.
My freshmen year..my choir teacher had ua sing this song....and I fell in love with it...It makes me cry now, becuz she lost her job....only cuz my principle is a ass...but I love this song so much.
I must admit, it is a beautifu;l song, and when you search itm, you hear all artists showing off vocals by covering. BUT the BEST cover alive with the best harmony is Marianas Trench.
This song is so deep. I never knew words could say so much until I sang this with my chorus. It more than touches me; this song tears open my soul and makes me want to cry. I am so glad I know this song.
your video best captures the raw and pure emotions described within this song. I had my heart torn out and pureed this week, and this video and song have been one of a few that have given me comfort in knowing that ultimately I'll be better off in the long run. Just the getting through the hurt and heart ache is the hardest part.
I actually sang this to a wonderful young lady who was at that point undecided as to whether or not to accept my advances. And do you know what? It worked! :D
Beautiful song. I love Billy Joel and I have neer heard this before. Does anyone know the story behind this? Like why id Billy Joel write thi. LikeGoodnight, My Angel was for his daughter. What this one for?
WOW! I have heard this song before and loved it for its beauty--but now going through a painful divorce, the song has become spiritual and has pierced me deeply.
@billyva45 how is the Marianas Trench version artificial?? It's absolutely amazing, and is pure vocals. There are no instruments and no editing. Not that they edit anyways.
no way marianas trench;s version is better, that is artificial.. there are many artist who could give it that type of over the top performance., this is a man talking to you.. that is what makes this song beautiful.. not performance art.
this is an amazing soul filled , almost sounds like someone who has come to terms with the final outcome,,knowing all the drama and pleading could not change the outcome...but just ...what else can i say baby?
What a lovely song. The words are so beautiful and so is the the melody. In high school my choir sang this song. Every time i listen to this song it brings back so many memories and it makes me want to cry.
i think what attracts people to this song, is not just the beautiful melody and harmony, but the lyrics are mesmerizing.. and if any person has had any love for a person in their lifetime-you can somewht relate to them...
when it sayd, "and you can have this heart to break" my heart jst broke </3 its insanely beautiful how realistic the words are
@MusiqueFille33 it is kinda hard to read, but IS readable. I could read it just fine. but I suggest that if you want one that you can read, you can make one yourself. It can't be too hard too do that.
@Akvamarin66 I disagree that the red was a bad choice, I think it was the only choice, red is the color of passion, and it has enough difference so it is still visible.
I love this song. It is so real. My favorite line is "I would choose to be with you, that's if the choice were mine to make. But you can make decisions too, and you can have this heart to break."
Have you ever noticed that in the movies, as soon as you tell someone how you feel about them, it magically becomes mutual and you live happily ever after. That doesn't happen in real life, I know from experience.
Thank you Billy for telling it like it is, and showing the tougher side of love.
this song just made me cry... one of my best guy friends just told me that the whole time he was with his girl friend today, he really wanted to talk to me, and couldnt get this song out of his head :' )
Just got rejected pretty hardcore... Listening to this song is what I do instead of crying.
homestarhydon 2 days ago
<3 my school chours sung this smh so beautiful =] and now i shall foreverr love this <3
MsKD09 1 week ago
My girlfriend just broke up with me, and although I am not an emotional guy, this song really touched me and was what I needed
baseballfannatic 3 weeks ago
singing this song for chorus :3
TheKissMeLexy 3 weeks ago
A very touching video to a simple but incredible song that speaks deeply. Thx. Bev
Bevisblonde58 1 month ago
I used to sing like Billy Joel, then I took an arrow in the knee
btown2345 2 months ago
@btown2345 No you didn't.
TwoDudesCooking 1 month ago
@btown2345 Seriously... shut up...
D4rkMotoko 4 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hi everybody, could you check out my cover of this? I really would like some feedback on it. Thank you, and thank you Billy Joel for this AMAZING song.
allbaseball77 2 months ago
Pop
TGonRS 2 months ago
"...and you can have this heart to break." </3 my parents are going through a divorce, and one day, i caught my dad listening to this in his car on the driving, sobbing... i've never seen my dad cry that hard...
iBeauty96 2 months ago 3
@iBeauty96 i've been there before, keep your head up kid.
DementedDoctor5 1 month ago
@iBeauty96 that really sucks i was almost 7 when My Parents Divorced but like that other guy said keep your head up
JoeEC420 3 weeks ago
@ cornbluff1
I whole-heartedly agree cornbluff1
2e26pst 3 months ago
i love billy joel so much i am 15 and am can not stop! i really can't stand today's music but whatever!
thanks for posting this
16coly 3 months ago 2
Babylover0990??? JJones??
jbroyles03 3 months ago
we sung this in chorus.. i feel in love with it!and i usually dont fall in love with the wack songs we sing in chorus
iRockthaMic 3 months ago 2
Everytime I hear it, it is like getting kicked in the head, but you simply must try again...Love ya All....................
Pinewhispers155 3 months ago
My husband proposed to me with this song at the conclusion of his senior piano recital. After completing the song, he stepped down from the stage he knelt by ny sude, presnted me with a pink rose, opened the ring case and placed the ring on my finger, then asked. The wedding itself was beautoful, the nothing can top the proposal.
SuperOrgandonor 3 months ago 2
Just one of those songs you cant help but love :)
melissaanntilley 4 months ago
We're singing this for choir! The alto version of it is just gorgeous too :)
sunnydale22 4 months ago in playlist Songs & Music
This song speaks to my heart in such a deep and profound way. Makes me feel a little whole again. Thank you Billy <3
malibu64 4 months ago in playlist malibu64's favorites
He wrote all of his songs, and to my knowledge never covered any.
SirSpudGun 4 months ago
And I'm not sure, but I think he wrote it, too.
msmwkc 4 months ago
I would say Billy Joel, since he "sang" the song and they "covered" it.
msmwkc 4 months ago
Just a question because im stupid :P
Who sang this song first? Marianas Trench or Billy Joel.. im guessing Billy Joel but still XD
kookykiari 5 months ago
@kookykiari Billy Joel, but I feel that Marianas Trench did an amazing job covering it
kelseydesmond 4 months ago
@kelseydesmond yeah :)
kookykiari 4 months ago
@kookykiari billy
theoffkeydiva 3 months ago
i love this song!!! we are singing it in chorus
onquingirl 5 months ago
.." but you can make decision too.. and you can have this heart to break.."
PropheticVoice7 5 months ago
My freshmen year..my choir teacher had ua sing this song....and I fell in love with it...It makes me cry now, becuz she lost her job....only cuz my principle is a ass...but I love this song so much.
PureWomanSteubenvile 6 months ago
@PureWomanSteubenvile haha this is my freshman year and we're singing this in choir. I love this song too.
StarSingShine 5 months ago
Great song and video :) peace
SGR1000 6 months ago
I must admit, it is a beautifu;l song, and when you search itm, you hear all artists showing off vocals by covering. BUT the BEST cover alive with the best harmony is Marianas Trench.
Search it.
Watch it.
Cry.
Agree with me.
Proud to be a canadian loving a Canadian band <3
horsebackgirl96 6 months ago
just dropped a load of chocolate pudding in my underpants.
zachmasterzach 6 months ago
No matter what side of a breakup you are on, this song still hits the heart so strong. This is a wonderful work of art and chokes me up every time.
Darkfixxx 6 months ago
This song always touched my heart
BERNARD0221 6 months ago
I love you David.
GothicTrioOfEdwards 7 months ago
i first heard this on boston legal but just the music
amsraiden97 7 months ago 16
@amsraiden97
Ha, me too man! I went on the net to search for it, and bam !!
This is what you call a beautiful song.
TWresterify 6 months ago
@TWresterify yeah i had to go to like 8 sites and it was well worth it
amsraiden97 6 months ago
Nice video for one of The Piano Man's most pretty & deep songs
beach1lover 7 months ago
Thumbs up for the Strangers in Paradise readers....
scrying 7 months ago
@22acacciaavenew. My thoughts exactly
4clvvess 7 months ago
Denny Crane.
22acaciaavenew 8 months ago
Thank you for this...
mirandawrights 8 months ago
Thank you for posting this most beautiful song
Abkeda 8 months ago
awesome song! Very deep and touching
babylover0990 10 months ago
I cry like every time I listen to this :(
Backstrom1991 10 months ago
This song really makes me want to cry :'( It sounds just like what happened to me and the guy I love.... I mean every word this song says...
</3
Mabiline1 10 months ago
I LOVE this song! in choir I am singing this!
omiredrose 10 months ago
@omiredrose Me too! omg! lol
Mabiline1 10 months ago
I LOVE this song, and I love this video! Very well done! =D This song is so deep and meaningful.... You can't beat the oldies =)
xAngelx086 11 months ago
Uptown girl, she's been living in her uptown world :-)))))))))) one of the best musicians to ever wonder this earth. And that's the TRUTH.
cornbluff1 11 months ago 9
@cornbluff1 Couldn't have said it better myself! <3
sunnydale22 3 months ago in playlist Songs & Music
This has been flagged as spam show
Notice how theres onlt ONE dislike? That's saying something <3
Wowimawesome13 11 months ago
Notice how theres onlt ONE dislike? That's sayign something <3
Wowimawesome13 11 months ago
This song is so deep. I never knew words could say so much until I sang this with my chorus. It more than touches me; this song tears open my soul and makes me want to cry. I am so glad I know this song.
irateyourvids101 11 months ago
for some reason I feel like 1:04 is an allusion to the hedgehog's dilemma. Is that what it's there for, or is it just cause it's adorable as hell?
ZCodeProductions 11 months ago 2
your video best captures the raw and pure emotions described within this song. I had my heart torn out and pureed this week, and this video and song have been one of a few that have given me comfort in knowing that ultimately I'll be better off in the long run. Just the getting through the hurt and heart ache is the hardest part.
mcmjr405 11 months ago
i love singing this Beautiful song! xo
1baratone 11 months ago
I actually sang this to a wonderful young lady who was at that point undecided as to whether or not to accept my advances. And do you know what? It worked! :D
lordrosemount 1 year ago
Beautiful song. I love Billy Joel and I have neer heard this before. Does anyone know the story behind this? Like why id Billy Joel write thi. LikeGoodnight, My Angel was for his daughter. What this one for?
1puppetmaster1 1 year ago
@1puppetmaster1 The relationship he had with Elle MacPherson not Christie Brinkley
mactheartofwarfare 1 year ago
@mactheartofwarfare Thank you. It has been driving me mad that I couldnt find the story
1puppetmaster1 1 year ago
Funny how this video was uploaded the day after I had my heart broken.
NYerintransit 1 year ago
The lyrics.. <3
mina8596 1 year ago
So I would choose to be with you
That's if the choice were mine to make
But you can make decisions too
And you can have this heart to break
best part.
JeessiieeeLovesYou 1 year ago
@JeessiieeeLovesYou You are very right. Extremely eloquent, meaningful lyrics. They make me feel something indescribable.
danbcarson 1 year ago
WOW! I have heard this song before and loved it for its beauty--but now going through a painful divorce, the song has become spiritual and has pierced me deeply.
Transterra55 1 year ago 2
This is one song right here that makes me cry. It's so beautiful!
ChemicalDestroy 1 year ago
1:08 OMFG CUTENESS ATTACK.
bananaduckproduction 1 year ago
Comment removed
Cubano507 1 year ago
Comment removed
Cubano507 1 year ago
Comment removed
Cubano507 1 year ago
listen to the king's singers doing this beauty of a song - perfection <3
rockyourboatx 1 year ago
The piano in this song is haunting. I need to find more songs with this sort of piano in them. This is heartwrenchingly beautiful.
MWCR 1 year ago
im so excited i get to sing this in choir and i may get a solo
MrOddVlogs 1 year ago
@billyva45 how is the Marianas Trench version artificial?? It's absolutely amazing, and is pure vocals. There are no instruments and no editing. Not that they edit anyways.
RamsayDearest 1 year ago 2
no way marianas trench;s version is better, that is artificial.. there are many artist who could give it that type of over the top performance., this is a man talking to you.. that is what makes this song beautiful.. not performance art.
billyva45 1 year ago
Sang This For Choir♥ We Did So Good Our Choir Teacher Almost Cried(: Beautiful Song...
MzHeRsHiI 1 year ago
i think marianas trench's version is better :/ but he wrote the lyrics right. so i have to give credit for that. the lyrics are amazing. <3
blissblueblew 1 year ago
I feel like crying everytime I hear this song. It is exactly how I am feeling at this time of my life
grillows19 1 year ago
this is an amazing soul filled , almost sounds like someone who has come to terms with the final outcome,,knowing all the drama and pleading could not change the outcome...but just ...what else can i say baby?
billyva45 1 year ago
What a lovely song. The words are so beautiful and so is the the melody. In high school my choir sang this song. Every time i listen to this song it brings back so many memories and it makes me want to cry.
1992brb 1 year ago
i think what attracts people to this song, is not just the beautiful melody and harmony, but the lyrics are mesmerizing.. and if any person has had any love for a person in their lifetime-you can somewht relate to them...
when it sayd, "and you can have this heart to break" my heart jst broke </3 its insanely beautiful how realistic the words are
taytayy0821 1 year ago
the music is me...the lyrics is me...thank you, Billy Joel....a great artist.
Petiszived 1 year ago
Hi all! Thanks for your comments... And yes, I know the red color was a bad choice ;o)) Only thing... I tried different colors. None good at all. LOL
Akvamarin66 1 year ago 20
@Akvamarin66 Do you know how many comments,witch were very meaningful for all of us, does your video has in one of the FB page?
Be happy, please.You do it best! Thank you!
irencas 1 year ago
@Akvamarin66
I would have tried a white glow, if it's possible, or a white drop shadow, or some other effect to set it off.
rimedragona 1 year ago
@Akvamarin66
Such a beautiful song
TheSweetp1974 11 months ago
@Akvamarin66 that's okay! It is still good!! Thank you for trying!
bjfv567 11 months ago
@Akvamarin66 Get a different background then. Because I swear, this is the only And so It goes with lyrics on youtube.
MusiqueFille33 10 months ago
@MusiqueFille33 it is kinda hard to read, but IS readable. I could read it just fine. but I suggest that if you want one that you can read, you can make one yourself. It can't be too hard too do that.
babylover0990 10 months ago
@Akvamarin66 I disagree that the red was a bad choice, I think it was the only choice, red is the color of passion, and it has enough difference so it is still visible.
mcmjr405 7 months ago
I love this song. It is so real. My favorite line is "I would choose to be with you, that's if the choice were mine to make. But you can make decisions too, and you can have this heart to break."
Have you ever noticed that in the movies, as soon as you tell someone how you feel about them, it magically becomes mutual and you live happily ever after. That doesn't happen in real life, I know from experience.
Thank you Billy for telling it like it is, and showing the tougher side of love.
nonnenja2281 1 year ago 10
@nonnenja2281 Yes indeed...
WhiteWolf1088 1 year ago
@nonnenja2281 ... :( and now i know it too :(
BravoRed691 5 months ago
@nonnenja2281 ... :( and now i know it too :(
BravoRed691 5 months ago
i love this song x3
shyandquietluvsu 1 year ago
What is the second picture in this video? of the angel and the pensive looking man? Whats the name of the painting?
Gm030192 1 year ago
this song just made me cry... one of my best guy friends just told me that the whole time he was with his girl friend today, he really wanted to talk to me, and couldnt get this song out of his head :' )
keehret 1 year ago
this lyrics for this song is so deep. "so i will share this room with you, and you can have this heart to break" :'(
jiniton 1 year ago 45
The lyrics to this song are very powerful and moving.
danceteacher74 1 year ago
beautiful song. Alot of Billy Joel's songs are very deep. I love his songs.
howlcall 1 year ago
I had never heard this until I watched Boston Legal the other night, have just looked it up, listened, love it! Beautifull.
rafhenlow 1 year ago 2
Red Text not a good thing,, but a beautiful song
CloggieIllinois 1 year ago 21
cool i love it, but for your next video consider the color of the text and the bakcground
AlexPalacios97 2 years ago
how does that person hold the hedgehog?
bubbyboy1000 2 years ago
Good job. one critique is I wish u used black not red for the letters. it's hard to see them. thanks for making it, its one of my favorites.
sweettrt 2 years ago
This song is so breath-taking I love it, especially when David Archuleta sings it
Juarez1692 2 years ago
When I listen this song it make s me think thay are the words to Neda "From Iran" from her family and her fiance.
Elaheh1naz 2 years ago
Waw
Elaheh1naz 2 years ago