Added: 4 years ago
From: mrpersonanongrata
Views: 963,684
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,555)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Jesus, how shitty. Crosby and Nash just ruined my favorite song.

  • SHINE ON, Syd

  • the strat sound is unreachable

  • @Taldegardo92 No the les paul is.. there gotta be a les paul in one of the best songs ever made, you got this and MMEB "Father of day Father of Night". That Mooaaep pada di doaaeee.. o i get gooze bumps everytime i hear it, this kills the song :( on the original EP "Wish you where here" that Gibson Les paul black beauty is yes you just feel it, it's so impeccable, the strat eint even close to what the custom made black beauty from the 50-60-70 can preform.

  • @666dekadance666 I don't know if I've understood correctly... In "wish you were here" (album) Gilmour used just his Black Strat. Doesn't it?

  • @666dekadance666 there is not Les Paul on WYWH only on another brick in the wall solo from The Wall in 1979.

  • how can one comment,,when your jaw is dropped????

  • Underrated...

  • Beautiful :')

  • Gilmour is such "THE" Guitar God ...

  • ultimately is human, grew old ..... but nothing has happened to their greatness!!!

  • awesome, just awesome

  • completely flawless

  • The saxophone guy plays so good...

  • @juanixzx mel collins,im thinkin'..

  • @juanixzx check out his solo on King Crimson's 'Ladies of the Road', if you wanna really hear somthin special! :D

  • happy b-day syd

  • Stellar! To have been there.

  • wheres part 2?

  • OMG. AMAZING!!! That's what I need for my soul

  • if there is anything on the world i wish its a 1999 porsche 911 and beeing on this concert

  • how many holes did it take to fill the royal albert hall?

  • @buzzzzz69yyy ask john lennon

  • (S)hine on (y)ou crazy (d)iamond

  • Que grandes eres son a los dos que mas aprecio a David Gilmour y su guitarra

  • Syd lives.

  • EMG pickups...only for those that don't make mistakes!

  • too the person who posted the "new God in Town"!!!,well you suck ass,your music ,and if thats what you call music will never come close to Floyds music! Yeah David Gilmour is rich,so what sounds to me like you're jealous moron to me! PS why don't you go fuck yourself you peace of shit!!!

  • i again would like to thank the Universe for the random and magical events that have led me to hear and experience this...........

  • when I  listen to that song I have shivers, master forever !!

  • "O, that music were the sole language of our universe!"  - Jedediah Bartman

  • Check out the "New New God in Town" The old Floyd song, from long before you were in the group has been changed. Like your greedy ass hasn't got enough money. You were so lucky to fall into "Pink Floyd" Can you write a song relevant for today????

    I didn't think so.

  • @roballen2 have you ever listened to High Hopes? One of the most beautiful songs out there. Gilmour and his wife wrote it. Shut your fucking mouth please, we all know that Roger, Nick, Rick and David are awesome, Roger wrote the lyrics, Dave put emotion to them. He's playing Shine On because it's a song that EVERYONE who's a real Floyd fan (no, you're not) loves this song, and they WANNA LISTEN TO IT.

  • Keep playing them old "Floyd" tunes...don't you think you already got your 84 million you pais waters to hold on to the name, Pnk Floyd"

    You can't sit down and write a good song alone. PS Fuck you!

  • 8:55, superb switchover

  • The sax player goes for broke at 9:00 ---excellent!

  • Is that Bill Clinton playing the saxophone? Wow they really brought out the line-up for this concert!

  • boy oh boy,,,,i'll go second fiddle on the sax :p

  • If you love this version, then I highly recommend the incredible version from the Gdansk concert, where the intro is played on wine glasses:

    watch?v=kqugBpmmRJE

  • the people how dislike this perfect sound, please, go to listen justin baby!!! Fucking perfect, touching, and epic sound!!!

  • Insanity.

  • 36 pretentious peeps.

  • ギルモアこそ全てである。この曲のよさが判らないの人はかわいそ­う。

  • What a beautiful Hall, what a great band Pink Floyd, with Crosby and Nash singing back up, great written song.  What else could we ask for. I would have LOVED to have seen this performance.

  • The 36 people that disliked this must be confused. There is nothing like listening to musical genius. Pink Floyd creates this....

  • the true guardian of a fender stratocaster!!!

  • gilmour the best gutarist that has ever lived

  • Two of my all time top 5 favorite singers on this stage - Gilmore and Crosby - and Nash is pretty aweosme also 

  • @bigbuzman Same here! It truly is amazing that they can still sing with such a tremendous voice even at this age! The masters of harmonies and guitar both combined makes.....

  • beautiful re- eyes this two great folk sings; i love this!!!!

  • Gilmour (along with his black strat) is tattooed on my back, enough said.

  • 0:26 Gilmour can do with 1 note what other musicians can't do with 1000.

  • @RockGTA Only Gilmour can that. YEAH !

  • @RockGTA Yeah Brother...he lets it breath.......and FLY.

  • Maravilloso / Wonderful. He llorado de emoción al verlo y escucharlo. /I've cried from emotion watching and hearing it. Gracias desde España. /Thanks from Spain.

  • Is that Bill Clinton playing sax? ;) (Sarcasm)

  • Amaxing

  • Comment removed

  • How can so much talent and soul be in a single song? Pure genious.. Thank you Dave!!

  • Pure genious, like another dimesion <3

  • @brb0713 that's what she said

  • dick perry espetacular!

  • This is THE BEST version period of Shine On You Crazy Diamond!

  • STEEEEEEEEEEEVE PEEEEEEEEEEEEERRRRYYYYYYYYYYYY­YYYYY

    

  • part 8 was always my favouite part and they never played it live (after 1977) Waters did on his 2002 tours.

  • ESSA CANÇÃO É DE TIRAR O CHAPÉU ...

  • Sadness in 4 notes: Bb, F, G, E

  • Richards fingerings at the end JUST KILL ME

  • For Crosby and Nash to be onstage and sing this song with David should have them groveling on the floor begging for acceptance as they veiw themselves (We,re Not Worthy ) But David in his Musical wisdom chose the best for the job at hand

  • AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Our father who art in heaven GILMORE is his NAME !

  • @aidomcdonnell *Gilmour, which can alternatively be spelt G-O-D

  • Rock on...:) xxx

  • what happened to my top comment? i had 60 likes :'(

  • @Mwtorres24 your at the top again :D

  • 8:55: The fucking boss

  • david gilmour and richard wright, please

  • BEST SOUND, PERFECT

  • Also, goosebumps. I have them.

  • Aw my god, this was when Rick was still alive :c

    RIP Richard Wright and Syd Barrett

  • Опыт не пропьешь :)

    Experience does not spend on drink

  • playing guitar like a boss...

  • 8:57... that's talent!

  • STEVE JOBS: You reached for the secret too soon, you cried for the moon. Shine on you crazy diamond

  • and much respects to syd barret pink floyds main inspiration imo

  • jus pure magic all i can say like omg crosy n nash and david what a combo

  • I have this dvd, best purchase I made that year

  • This version is simply wonderful

  • Does someone know when was this concert?

    It's INCREDIBLE

  • @DiegoAzanza The concert was recorded in May 2006 ;-) its not too far...

  • Why are people missing Rick White??? Floyd would be nothing with out him.

    I mean they made the music they did because of the complete band.

  • @swiftie69 His Name is Mr Richard Wright and he was the Soul of the Band ,, Play music in heaven forever Rick,,,,,,,,,,,, Ill be seein ya there

  • Pure love between a man and his guitar...timeless. It makes my eyes well with tears for I've been here in awe of David all of these years...Shine on you crazy diamond!

  • Divine !

  • That is Bill Clinton on the sax. Who would have thought, what a talent.

  • @71spaceman

    Um, no, that is a session musician named Dick Parry - he played on Dark Side of the Moon - the solo stuff on Money and Us and Them - that was him - great guy.

  • Просто безумная композиция. Классика !!!

  • Music is supposed to cause you to relax, reflect, renew, and bring joy. I think this passes all the categories. What happens when we lose all these guys. I think we are seeing it as the world is really sucking right now.

  • can it any better. not likely. the best of the best

  • gawd - gilmour, crosby, and nash - something for me and hubby!!! and wus up - can there actually BE 35 people on this planet that dislike this???? funny bill clinton comment- lol! thnx for the post

  • So gooooood !!!!! Love this song ~ thank you for loading and share :)

  • Is that Bill Clinton on sax? He's good.

  • ааааааааааааааа моя любимая песня у пинк флойд!!!!!

    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah that's my favourite pink-floyd's song 

  • Every note this man has ever produced should be on the Voyager space craft , To show other civilizations what we can do in the pursuit of perfection

  • God... Forgive them... They don't know what button press....

  • I wish I had a nickle for each time I have spun one up while listening to PF.

  • who the fuck disliked this :P

  • @noldorian86 Someone born after year 2000

  • 34 persons haven't soul...

  • are the people who do'nt like this video completly deaf ?. dave gilmour and pink floyd are as close as you can can get to music being perfect , obviously they must be complete idiots and would rather listen to some teeny bopper crap thats completly meaningless.

  • Best performance of the best song of all time. My God, that brought tears to my eyes.

  • The world misses you Mr. Wright

  • 34 persons do not shine.

  • @inforafaelmontero ...and probably never will.

  • 7:14 fuckin goosebumps

  • Amazing love this version!

    David Gilmour = god :)

  • at 8:12 I thought this guy was super small.

  • @darthsadic lol thats a bigass sax

  • @bojanks15 Thats a Baritone Sax. Sweetest sound ever!

  • @bojanks15 That is a Baritone Sax. Sweetest sound ever.

  • @bojanks15 Ever seen a contrabass before?

  • É Explêndido,úma versão diferente porém tão boa quanto a épica original confira parabéns pela postagem Rio de Janeiro Brasil. It is splendid, but a different version of the epic as good as the original check congratulations on posting Rio de Janeiro Brazil

  • sit back and relax. peace

  • this is not fair God, I asked you to be David Gilmour before he did.

  • dang idk how many times i replayed this. super great stuff!!!!!!!!

  • Roger Water must have made 33 YouTube accounts to dislike this.. how else could you dislike such a thing, its simply brilliant

  • Rick Wright on keyboards! RIP my man!

  • Why do these notes hurting me so much ??? Straight in the heart my friend !!!

  • dioses de la MUSICA

    

  • damn right i wish i was there

  • fantastic. thats all there is to say

  • David Gimour is probably one of the only musician that sounds alike in studio as in live....some hate it but i love it :D

  • Crosby and Nash, nice touch...

  • Roger the main writer...David the main singer...

  • 33 persons never shine ):

  • Any version of that wonderful song played by Gilmour are the best.

    Any.

  • Bill Clinton will never know how to play this.

  • This is incredible, im 18 and yet i can appreciate music that was golden from its time and progressed into something beautiful through time, wonderful music!

  • Voice, Guitars, Bass, Keyboards, Saxophone: in this song there is the best of all the modern music

  • y que decir de esta, es fantastica, no hay palabras para describirla

  • Dear God, this is perfect!!!!!!!

  • Syd...

  • I love it !!!!

  • 3333 likes

    vs

    33 dislikes

  • There's at least 33 deaf and tasteless youtube users

  • WoW this is music.......perfect 10!

  • I love every note..

  • Perfection!!!!!

  • stunningly beautiful.

  • Crosby and Nash make pretty good backup singers....harmonius and pure are their tones. This whole series is great...gave me a new-found respect for Pink FLoyd aoart from the quaalude induced impressions from the early 70's that I had. Wonderfully produced.

  • is a fucking orgasm =)

  • This me possibly be the best version of that song ... You gotta love the boys from CSN :-)

  • @Kafrifelle I got a better version, pm me if you want it, cause youtube took it off.

  • The BEST "string bender" guitarist ever ... EPIC Song ...

  • i really cant get over that incredible sax switch....

    

  • 33 Tone Deaf People.....

  • Beautiful!!! Love it. Thanks for sharing:)

    GRandma Mary

  • MERCI / RICHARD,WRIGHT/ R ,I ,P,/

  • 8:54 Epic change never i saw

  • Their best performance of all time.

  • Why did CSN come on? Were they jobless then?

  • Dick Parry is a saxophone badass.

  • best 10 minutes and 13 seconds on youtube. truly epic.

  • el saxo es Tom Scott?

  • how can there be a dislike button

  • how can there be a dislike button

  • why is there even a dislike button???

  • got to get in on the comments. Cobain didn't hold a candle to Gilmore. David should be in the top 10 best guitarist of all time. pretty simple technique but amazing display of how you should be able to use a pedal board. Matter of fact i dont thanks Cobain ever did any guitar solo that stood out in my mind. can you thanks of one that even compares to shine on you crazy diamond. much love to all the floyd fans. 

  • @thebluesman1979 Y is Cobain's name even brought up on this COMMENT page ?

    Cobain is a 1% Gilmour !

  • @motokev hahaha, does cobain have 1% of daves talent, wouldnt think so, would be like 0.0000000001 times -1000000 or something

  • 25 and quite screwed, Pink kept me together somehow...

  • Hey you..............;))))

  • why is David on 82 place out of 100 on Rolling Stones best guitarist of all time ? And Curt Cobain on 12 ?

    I really dont understand ?! Can someone explaine ? I studied guitar at the accademy ...and I still dont understand the chart

  • @peltanr ah ah Curt Cobain was the 12th guitarist ? RIP, he was playing guitar IMHO

  • @peltanr Because Rolling Stones magazine is piece of sh*t who needs to sell his toilet paper to the kids who don't have the ears to understand what Gilmour has to give to the world, and that Cobain's had the guitar skills of most of these kids... Imo. No offence of course.