Added: 2 months ago
From: Surelog
Views: 19,805
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (164)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • great review

  • @sirsoccer10 lmao agreed

  • First time in history where a Diablo comparison is a bad thing. Thats why I dont play MMOs (though I am going to play this)

  • Thanks for the review. You've helped me decide on whether or not to get it. I decided to :D

  • great review, i want more so i subbed.

  • Just wait for titan

  • Looks like shit

  • I could really use your advice, I really like the look of this game but I haven't really played any MMO's, does this game require some prior MMO playing or can anyone pick it up. I really like the look of the story :-)

  • It fails right out of the gate with an extremely outdated and limited character creation system coupled with an interface that looks like it was designed in the 90s and lacks any ability to customize (maybe that's changed). I also expected some kind of breakthrough combat system that was specific to using force powers, such as having to climb up a walker and use your saber to gut it. Something like God of War boss fights. Instead you wave your saber in front of the boss and damage happens.

  • yep ea and bioware just put the last nail in the coffin of mmorpgs. swtor is just boring top to bottom.

  • I agree, better than the big reviewer sites. Good job.

  • as of now it feels like i'm wasting WoW time playing SWTOR. I'm a huge star wars fan, the game was fun, but it lacks a deep game mechanic. The game's going to get better most likely, but I'm playing WoW until then.

  • Combat and PVP are cookie cutter. Not sure why you said they're both unique. Am I missing something here? Nothing was done different in combat or pvp. Only thing I find intriguing are the compaions and the nice voice acting. Other than that its a dumbed down WoW clone. Fetch quests. Repetition etc. I'll be patient because it just launched...we shall see. And yes, no auto attack is fucking dumb.

  • @CannibalCorpse909 The Combat is much more dynamic and fast paced than WoW. I hate WoW PvP coz its really unbalanced and kinda boring when you can win a PvP match with 5-6 skills. WoW depends(Some of the time) on proc chances so in a way luck in involved in it and not pure skill.. SWTOR doesnt have all that. Its fast paced and well balanced game. The BGs are very innovative and i really cant wait to see other game types.

  • @Vikramthewhite Just because you probably never got any success in WoW doesn't mean PvP is imbalanced :). You have an extremely wrong and misleading point of view about WoW.

  • Twilek are only on the republic

  • great review man :)

    information just what i wanted.

    thinking of getting it ^^

  • @darkz1820 exactly, I wish they could have made the old republic as a single player version for consoles as well. I don't see why not..

  • my only problem with the game is that you have to pay to play so i'll get it once it's free to play

  • @darkz1820 It will never be free to play, never so I wouldn't bother waiting

  • @Acphillips1995 dc universe online went freed to play so maybe, maybe not so we'll see anyways it also depends on the price

  • @darkz1820 yea im just thinking of it as a WOW type game so...

  • @darkz1820 We'll seeing as most commentators didn't do a video on DCUO then yes your right it was going to go free no one was buying it. Alot of well known commentators play this game therefore more people will buy it and pay for it. So don't expect it to go free for a long time.

  • @RznFlasHBacK i wont be getting it for awhile because if i get interested i want to keep going but i rather avoid paying for something worth the money if you pay and then don't play, because i rather play bf3 with friends more

  • twi'lek ladies=hot

  • Great review. Tops those of the big sites (IGN, GameSpot).

  • looks alot better than i expected

  • This was a great review thanks!

  • You sir just earned yourself a subscriber

    

  • every quest had voice actors in dcu online aswell and that came out a year ago

  • Can't wait for guild wars 2..

  • The sad truth of SWTOR is that they invested 300m USD into the game & it neither excells at the story or as an MMO. Had they made the successor to Starwars galaxies, with emphasis on depth & content, e.g. a vast array of planets avaliable to explore with evolving PVP & quests dependant on where you are.

    Instead EA has chosen to bridge the gap between single-player games & subscription based MMO's in order to inflate their proffit margins, by trapping unwitting players in a virtual skinner box.

  • Its pretty self evident this isn't an "unbiased" review because there is no critical analysis of the game beyond the superficial.

    I hope the reviewer broadens his awareness if the multifaceted aspects of what makes an MMO and not just judge it on superficial merit, aka "is this just another wow clone".

    I would strongly urge he spend 5-10 minutes reading up on behavioral psychology in games, and the lessons learned from B. F. Skinner.

    Google: A Behavioral Approach to Video Game Design

    Peace

  • @Tactums "Hey, you guys... Stop liking what I don't like."

  • @Tactums Disagree with you completely. Not sure how you can say it doesnt excel at story as an MMO. I stopped reading at that point because it was incorrect.

  • @MasonIce1999

    No my friend, you stopped reading at "the" :)

    Thus you have created yourself a red herring, form of: straw man arguement.

    If you wish to continue this cretinus behaviour, repost without reading again :)

  • Terrible game, its a single player game...Doesnt really feel like its a mmo, when the leveling feels like a boring grind in singleplayer that takes ages and then when you reach level cap its boring as shit and nothing to do. When they charge you the same amount of money per month as WoW does.......I mean look, compare what you get. I'll come back when they have some more multiplayer stuff and when the game is actually worth my time....And money.

  • @HuntsmanWTF You don't need coop or multiplayer to have a good game.

  • @GavinHatesRednecks No, but you need coop and multiplayer to have a good MMO, wich this is last time I checked :)

  • I lost respect with this review when you said "the combat is fun". I'm sorry, where do you see the fun in this? There is a 0.5 second delay and it feels unpolished. Most of the time on my BH my abilities don't work. If you noticed, damage is not real time. If you use an ability, it's actually instant for some. You'll see an animation go through but the damage is already taken from the target so you can cancel that ability. You should learn about faults of the game first before you review.

  • My wife and I have played this game since release and nooo the graphics are not the best out there (compare to Rift). $15/month for a single player like game? Never should have been released until things like guild banks, guild halls, dungeon finders... I canceled my subscription withing 2 days of play.We feel like this game should have at least offered a little more than the old standards like Wow and EQ2. If someone wants us to pay a sub then we say offer more then we will.

  • It's a buggy piece of rubbish. It's still a boring ass grind and the devs didn't bother with faction balance, must have slipped their tiny minds.

  • lol there was a world of warcraft commercial before this video started

  • FYI, Some classes can choose Twi'lek as their race

  • Good enough

  • Nianoniano1 is a idiot wow fan boy. What's wrong your computer not food enough to play anything new. Wow is done get over it.

  • Great review. Look forward to your thoughts on end game. Right now its the best mmo I've played ever. And I have played most. Even final fantasy 11 and 14. The questing in sotor is the benchmark for mmo s for next 10 years.

  • Excellent review! By the way, does anyone know how well this will run on a fully loaded imac? I can play WoW very smoothly with the graphic settings on high, but on very high it gets a bit laggy.

  • I don't mean to be a douche or anything but DCUO (DCuniverseonline) has the same fast paced combat and combat and narrative quests (also free btw). I'm not pointing fingers or anything, and I also think old republic did a good job with this, but it wasn't the first.

  • Eww this game looks horrible

  • i dunno. MMO's like this don't seem to interest me.

  • are there bothans? they're kinda humanoid but less than other races..

  • Sweet Chocolate on the left 0:59

    thats what i like, animated hotstuff.:D

  • @macf1soon that was a nasty fucking girl. did you see the hair ??!?!!? You sir have no taste in women.

  • I'm afraid bioware blew it with the voice acted missions... Don't get me wrong, it's a cool feature, and fairly enjoyable as well. But imagine when they want to patch the game, they'll have so much more to do, than any other MMO developers... 50% of the budget went to pay for the voice acting, and later on, I fear this will kill the game...

  • Awesome review! Now I'll be buying this game, looks very very fun c:

  • This sir. Is an excellent review.

  • Saying it's fun is not unbiased, anyway it would be more intelligent for you to wait for this to become free to play like every WoW-clone

  • @nianoniano1 How is it not unbiased? By that definition, "unbiased" would be "this is a game. This is what you do in the game. I'm not going to tell you if this game is fun or not, or if you should buy it." Unbiased is coming into the game without preconceptions, or fanboyism.

    As for it being a "WoW-clone," it's not. It's an MMORPG. There are base elements that every MMO needs. If anything, WoW is a clone of EQ and other MMOs that came before it.

  • @rpglover101 You're right, whether if it's unbiased or not doesn't matter, but, "fun" is not a valid argument when talking about the quality of a game, what I'm saying is that it can be fun to you but maybe it isn't to another person.

    Yes it is a wow clone, actually Bioware has admitted to take "inspiration" from WoW. Since this is a EA published MMO it is most likely to flop.

    WoW may be a EQ clone, but WoW was the first "quest-based" MMO to succeed, SWTOR offers nothing new.

  • I agree with everything, except for his complaints on auto attack. Also, if they don't have the swim mechanic fixed and make worlds that feel way more open, I'm going to kill Bioware.

  • i got a lot of games for xmas and not even gone on them cos of this game

  • not on laptops

  • can this game run on laptops well

  • Voice acting for all quests is not a MMO first. Dc Universe has the same thing.

  • Actually when you have a good heat gestion (=never go over 50 heat unless you got the cd ready) you only have to use your basic attack at regular intervals and not more than something like 2 times every 10 seconds, it's the same thing for every class the différence with sith and jedis as the blaster classes is that jedis/siths are forced to use their basic attack while we are not forced but end up using it as often ( except maybe for warriors/knights )

  • Such a good review!!

    

  • Fantastic review, thanks so much, it was really helpful, I was trying to decide if I want to invest my time in this game or not. It looks amazing, thanks again! :)

  • Played the Beta all the way up to 50 with Smuggler/Scoundrel and Operative/Sniper. I am a huge Star Wars fan. If you like games on rails and parting in groups of 4 buy it. If you want a sandbox feel and deep game mechanics don't. I found this games to be extremely enjoyable for 2 months and then had to force myself to play it after that.

  • @harlowsolid There are not many Betas that will give enjoyment for months. It's too bad you burned yourself out on a beta. Also it's a MMO so no it's not a sandbox game like GTA4.

  • @Surelog First off, enjoyed your video very much. However, GTA is a bad example since it is not a mmorpg. I'm not saying it has to be open choice as Galaxies or FFXI but the game is more on rails than any other mmorpg I have ever played. Game play is fun but lacks depth needed to have longevity. If they constantly update with new instances to keep game play fresh, I can see this game doing very well. I never said it was a bad game just that it is on rails and mainly focused around groups of 4.

  • Comment removed

  • @Surelog There are sandbox MMOs....

  • @Surelog Wait so you cant run where you want like wow for example?

  • @Surelog "It's an* MMO so, no it's not a sandbox game like GTA4." Well, that's like saying "He's black, so he's a criminal." There are several sandbox MMOs. EVE online and Darkfall are two examples of great sandbox MMOs.

  • @Surelog

    A lot of us submitted bug reports about the bugs you're still experiencing today.

    Months are going by fast.

  • @Surelog Funny since people who have bought the game are saying the same thing now, that it's work instead of fun, something that should never ever happen with any game much less a game you pay to play.

  • @harlowsolid I get worn out on betas faster than the real games, mostly bc i dont care about a character that wont be there a month later.

  • Thanks for the great review, gonna pick this up tonight :D

  • all these crazy mmo abbreviations that i don't understand seem great... but does the story compare with that of kotor? that is the most important thing imo, since the developers keep insisting that it is 'kotor 3,4,5...etc' (bullshit). I just don't see how they can recapture what made kotor great: feeling like your choices/actions affect the entire galaxy, when there are millions of generic jedi/sith all as powerful as eachother... in kotor it made sense because of who your character was.

  • I wont to pay sooo bad damn servers cant connect to swtor.com to active sub :(((((

  • Solid job reviewing SWTOR. Glad to see somebody give a well put together review.

  • Well it's nice to finally hear a positive user review of the game.

  • Great review. Also, thanks for not being completely monotone like some of the other reviews I've seen.

  • It sucks that I'm going to have to wait 3 months for this. I wish Bioware could have released it everywhere at the same time.

  • @APocketOfTime If you live in for example Australia just get it from amazon.

  • dude can you plzzzzz make a video guide explaining the mercenary dps rotation and healing... you are the best at breaking things down!

  • Dude when Jodie foster said "They should have sent a poet" she was talking about Surelog! Seriously well said man!

  • He speaks the truth

  • It wasn't meant to be an insult, Surelog, there was no implied elitism there. I just found you including the no auto-attack in the "negative" part to be superfluous as I believe it is one of the best inclusions in the game, especially in competitive PvP. Good luck to you.

  • I'm totally making a fat bounty hunter now! One of the things I loved about San Andreas was being obese.

  • Wow, after that review now i that i will have the game:D

  • Really enjoyed the video. Honestly best one available right now. Just wondering if you're playing at max what are the specs on your pc? I only ask because I'm in the process of buying a new one specifically for this game and I want to play on max settings as well. Thanks for the video!

  • This mmo is cool and all, but I don't get it...they took everything any other mmo has done right and put it in this. BUT! PvP is a complete boring and repetitive WoW/clones feel, Warhammer's PvP is still the best model of PvP i ever played, this game is perfect for it...but no. They make close instanced spaces and no open world PvP <= BIG MISTAKE. I hope they will put region/map dominance PvP later in game.

  • Anarchy Online > SWTOR

  • @capsule56 k have fun playing that we'll be playing SWTOR

  • @ShamefulSammy

    I wish Anarchy Online was alive again. It's a true statement though. In its prime it was way better than SWTOR as an MMO. I feel like SWTOR should have been a single player game. I'm already level 27, and I'm pretty disappointed with it thus far.

  • @capsule56 yeah i can imagine it mustve been quite a game back then but, its just that a possibly decent starwars MMO has now been released and alot of us are happy for it soooo nothing against anarchy bit this isnt the place to claim a game is better than another. although everyone is entitled to an opinion

  • @ShamefulSammy

    Dis ez true.

  • I have 1 complaint! its too popular!!!!! I bought the game (there was only 3 copies left) But the town i live in and the towns at least 30 minutes away Are all sold out of the pre paid time cards i got the game and its downloaded but i cant play. no time cards left and i don't have a credit card =(

  • I'm just playing this to get a partial KOTOR and Mass Effect fix.

  • ... and possible starving your child because you haven't paid any attention to him... Uhhhh ye.. uhhh hmmmmm yes... I mean uhh ahh CRAP...! <---- LMAO!

  • Yeah you don't get fps issues... I'm on lowest settings, shadows are fucking OFF ( sick of people asking) and am getting 1-15 fps.. I get like 4 in small caves and places like my ship, basically causing me to get killed by mobs and made me reroll. Sucks I can't afford a new computer and my old one broke. I still own pvp up though ;)

  • Will I enjoy this game if I normally don't like combat? lol. I'm more of a crafter.

  • i like star wars an all but the character design, armor, weapons and skills just dont look that cool.

  • It isn't hard to run the game on full graphics it's not that visually impressive. Nice review though.

  • The just need an Ewok!

  • so i can be a good bad guy or a bad good guy? thats kinda cool

  • Every...single...swtor...video­...I have seen....has someone making a FAT character...why?

  • @falcone4life Because...every...single...ame­rican...that...likes...star wars...is a...FAT guy

  • i played the beta as a bounty hunter and loved the combat for them, did a bit of pvp as well and had a blast. early access i made an imperial agent and i am loving the whole class questline for the class too. now im trying out a sith warrior.

  • storyline or multiplayer?

  • so is this a good competitor to wow

  • I disagree. I always found having an auto attack boring and could never play any melee attacks. Now that is different.

  • Comment removed

  • Awesome review, I love how you mentioned if you love Mass Effect you'll love SWTOR.  ME2 was probably my favourite game of all time!

  • Never played an mmo but im a huge star wars fan and this game looks epic! Probably will try it sometime soon. Only worry is im afraid my laptop may not be able to run it. Anyone play this well on an asus laptop yet?

  • dump wow for this yes?

  • [Trade]: WTB=Auto Attack!

  • Good to see someone reviewing a game that isn't paid by EA..

  • dude nice video, one question, are you powertech with bounty hunter with all that flamethrowers and stuff...?

  • I agree with you. I played most of the beta and the pre release for peeps who preordered and I can not seem to stop playing! Skyrim I love to death took a backseat for awhile. And as far as many races, I hope and will assume expansion pack will add more playable races.

  • 12/20/2011 - SWTOR CSR: Greetings,

    I am Protocol Droid M0-T0 And i have received your transmission,

    We would like to thank you for the report you have submitted to us, We have passed this information onto one of our Specialized Teams who will investigate.

    We thank you for the Valuable information you have provided.

    Galactic Support is our specialty...

    Sincerely,

    Protocol Droid M0-T0

    Star Wars: The Old Republic Customer Service.

    (anyone else get this same message? me and my bro got it.)

  • I agree with everything u said, Only problem i have with the game imho is the customer support. I made 2 tickets and got the same stupid response for both. from the same GM. i will post it in my next comment.

  • hey surelog do u know if its pay per month? cant find info on it on their site

  • @fireglowrofl nvm i found it and it is, so fuck this game -_-

  • Unless you really like Star Wars and absolutely have to add this game to your collection, keep your money. I've been playing this off and on since beta and today may be the last time I play it. It's just boring.

  • this review was great, funny and efficient. ill be watching more of youre videos as of now

  • seriously, one of the best reviews i have ever seen. IGN desperately needs someone like you, Awesome job

  • Too late my kid already died cause this game jk jk jk

  • i dont know if they changed it but not every race can play every class like that race of humans that are born without eyes on the republic side i think they cant be a trooper and i think one other class

  • I love this video, it feels very well put together, and I really needed a good review especially from a cool, reliable youtuber like Surelog! THANKS! :)

  • @xijnnijx wana suck his dick anymore?

  • @Ownography no but you obviously suck you own hahahah. Why in in such a bad mood that you gotta make comments like that. just don't watch his vids if you're not a fan.

  • @xijnnijx the only difference is that Star Wars the old republic is good...

  • Hey surelog. There is deep water on Tython :)

  • wow sucks stop riping everquest and ultima online off dum wow fans

  • @tylerrules738 *ripping, Blizzard being a butt-hurt bitch has nothing to do with the fans.

  • btw you shuld do more reviews

  • what is the level cap

  • Great review

  • Best review

  • Does this game have a monthly fee or anything like that

  • @BeefSupreme101 i think so sadly

  • I have been playing since the first were allowed and it is very well put together. Great effects and story line activity. But...in the end you all shall bow before me and call me the Jen'ari...down with the rebel scum.

  • Hey, the website is down for maintenance, so does anyone know what the base cost and the monthly costs will be?

  • @habboaddict2 Oh, and can you create more than 1 character per account?

  • That comment you made about it being so involving you can't get away to eat? Right there with ya!

  • seems like a fair review of course you review it in MMO standards where you could also review it in RPG standards. as for late game pvp is how it stands every flash point in the game has a hard mode that should keep the small groups busy. bigger raids people have been hit or miss on them pretty sure swtor has no huge 24 man or bigger groups is why. i dont see the why people love the big groups but people do.

  • I LOVE this game only a few things i want added, and i think Cyborgs should of been a human choice to have or not and have another race...

  • I havent played this game but from the amount of videos i have seen then the combat looks badass. Makes you feel like a boss

  • not a fan of the subscription model.

  • i would have to say that the best graphics in mmo goes to Age of Conan, and probably the best combat mechanics...

  • I was going to allow Arrow/knee comments, but then I hit the remove button.

  • @Surelog then u got an arrow to the knee

  • There are some races that only exist for certain classes

  • @toadster84 Thank you. I didn't realize this. I'm responding to this so people will see this.

  • you can be a twi'lek,,,,,,

  • @TheD3fu53r yeah I heard that as I was listening to the video but forgot to add that. Regardless the twi'lek was an awful example anyway as they're just another humanized character. 

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more