Tu Mane Ya Na Mane - Wadali Brothers ( Coke Studio @ MTV India )

[2849250]

Wadali Brothers are good.. even though not supported by the musicians.. they do have an enchanting voice..

[MrMahendersingh]

sir you and your sweet songs are best one for us............

[Dzongka]

MTV is the bane of South Asian society.

[Videospoint]

Replace Leslie Wid A.R Rehman

[vineetcool2407]

i love this song.. music is beyond boundaries..

[wajdanhaider]

i never thought i would say this but look at sunidhi chauhan`s performance in coke studio(chittiye).. she is indian too rite ...

[siids]

I don't know what was wrong in this? Common it just a trance. Any music as long as it has the same true soul as it had.. i dont see any probs..

[rajatdiwan07329]

very sad that ppl from either side of the border have to show their hatred by such comments. No matter who starts this foolishness. All i would say is that don't involve music into it......Being an extremely proud Indian, I have no ego issues admitting that the pakistani coke studio was better. But how on earth does it reflect on the very intrinsic nature of the people of either countries...when will guys posting such hateful remarks mature??

[varidhig1994]

what have they done to this song??..originally, its such a lovely piece of music..!

[onetaozen]

The commercial intro of the MTV breaks the continuity. For example when you are listening a play list, it disrupts the mood. This was not the case with the Pakistan edition. We know that this cultural experiment could not succeed without the commercial sponsorship but there should be a limit. Please.

[intelligenciea]

pakistan main sirf aata dal gosht main hi nahi balki music main bhi milavalt hain. bakwaas sardard nakli nonsense music. tum bas namaz padhon aur logo ko kidnap karke alla alla kar gardan katne ka kaam karo vahi tumhare liye banaya gaya hain.

[NIKEYOoOBOY]

@intelligenciea you know what thats all we should do pray to allah coz when i hang out at the paradise i see you gayhind fox burning you see me with the camera say cheezZZZzzzzZZZ dirty hoeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[887jan]

@intelligenciea: Pakistan is unique and that is pretty much depicted in it's music. It's beyond your understanding. You keep yourself to Bhajjan singing only, that suits you.

[JustAStoner]

@887jan pakistan plays india's bhajjans... ek kagna many other sufi songs are of the Hindu traditions..

[887jan]

@JustAStoner : Sufi music originated with muslims of sub-continent, everyone knows that. We took our culture with us when we separated in 1947. Pakistan listens to your music just like we listen to western music and from others parts of the world but we have our own music which is different from rest of the world, sufi music. Hindu culture is depicted in your movies, music, TV infact everything about India is Hinduish and that's your culture. Soulful sufi music is Pakistani music, our culture.

[JustAStoner]

@887jan Sufi music is an accumulation of the music of the Indus valley played by stuborn music and god lovers that are considered second grade haramis by Muslims. You took not even half your population with you in 1947, all you did is divide India meaninglessly and you have not taken India away from sufis just like Sindh will always be Hindh no matter how many genocides you'll carry. Our music, movies and culture are for everyone in the world unlike yours which is designed to match India

[887jan]

@JustAStoner: Lol. Divide India meaninglessly! There is a history to this separation nd we r proud of it. Please go and read, But alas! even your history books are distorted to suit your false notion.

You can still refer to Jaswant Singh's book about JINNAH, in which he admits that muslims of subcontinent have been living miserable lives and they were denied their political, social rights which became the reason of separation. So stop pointing fingers at our glorious history.

[JustAStoner]

@887jan If muslims were miserable it was because of the british government. All the anti-hindu masala that ur books teach u are just justifications for the blunder of partition. Indians had crowned Bahadur Shah Zafar as their King in the 1857 mutiny after which the Britishers divided the Hindus & Muslims to rule another 90 years. Pakistan is a result of the heinous divide & rule politics and the Ridiculous idea of a religious government. Reality check, visit KashifHKhan's Channel.

[887jan]

@JustAStoner: I don't need to visit any channel, Infact you need a reality check. It was your hindu leaders who were partners in crime with british. Hindu leaders of India wanted British to leave the land, leaving all the authority in the hands of Hindus. Muslims were treated like 'untouchables' by hindus. Who says muslims and hindus could live peacefully, today we witness discrimination in India on the basis of religion at it's height. How can you forget Gujrat pogroms of 2001?

[JustAStoner]

@887jan Why don't you check on the 1857 mutiny urself instead of squealing like a deaf pig, u cant even verify after someone puts facts in front of u! U dont even know how Gujurat riots started. Ur using words like untouchables, shudars and brahmins bcus u wre taught to hate to justify ur separation. There are many more happier muslims in India than in Pak. u guys are unrealistic cancer like cock suckers who will keep coming to Indian videos and spewing what ur school teachers taught u

[887jan]

@JustAStoner: It's not about being happy in their personal lives. It's a collective life of muslims what pakistan was made for. There are people in your own country who agree to the fact that Hindu politicians were responsible for separation since they did not pay heed to muslim grievances. Even today, muslims in India are living miserable live, with low literacy, poverty, with hardly any representation in mainstream. Although India has more muslims than Pakistan, Afghanistan, bangladesh togetha

[887jan]

@JustAStoner : Muslims who separated in 1947, living in Bangladesh and pakistan are much better off than those who did not separate. Pakistan GDP growth was between 7-8 % in last decade, it's economy was growing faster than India.

Pakistan has to face difficulties due to these:-

a) foreign influence beyond its control b) War on terror c) threat from India , Afghanistan. c) foerign markets not opening up for trade. etc

[887jan]

@JustAStoner : Sufi music revolves around muslim philosophy of God (Allah). It's true meaning and soul is understood deeply by a muslim than anyone else.

[BABADAANG11]

@JustAStoner WTF OF YOU??????????????????????

[JustAStoner]

@BABADAANG11 Go to a chemist and get yourself a dose of 'Fukitol MG10000' you dumb piece of shit

[BABADAANG11]

@JustAStoner BIGEST" L "OF THIS CEN.....LOL

[NIKEYOoOBOY]

@intelligenciea bitch made nigga if i knew you have commented on my channel earlier i wouldve nuked your mums puccy now go down on your knees give me a blow job and then say sorry you slave i own you people you bitch nigga yoo0o0o dirty ass papa worship the ground i walk on bowwww down to me muthafucking cunt im the greatest that ever banged your mama on a street

[shamk9]

@NIKEYOoOBOY u guys r fighting over nothing =fail

[BABADAANG11]

@intelligenciea ISSSI LIAY PAKISTAN SAY ETNAY SINGERS KO BULWATAY HOOO .............LOL GO AND HAVE A LIFE HA HA HA AH

[206Eclipse]

pakistani coke studio is shit!

[Rapunzel251]

@206Eclipse Perhaps, you guys really need to educate your shit!

Guys, calm down and take a sigh and listen to Coke Studio. Only Listen to the rythems and pure voices of every singer!!

[kamalpreet369]

love d way they sing!!

u rock..

[aparichit07]

Leslie Lewis is the biggest piece of shit!!!

I dunno y Wadali Bandu agreed to perform this great song in this manner...

[ZkhanAhmed]

not as good as the pakistani one 

[mayurey]

their voice connects with the almighty but at the music front Leslie should do something good. Music is not up-to the mark.

[saeensagharsarkar]

again bakwas music

is se to acha tha k khan sahib apna gaya hoowa pehlay wala hi yahan usi music k sath ga detay

[digerpaji]

kuch jaga music ka maaza nahin aya yaar rohain hayatt would have killed it with the waddali talent

[shivek1987]

plus the original coke studio was fresh cuz they experimented with the instrumentation...i dont see any experiments with the traditional stuff here...they(coke studio) cudve brought this song alive bu instead did all the tried and tested stupid formula kinda stuff

[shivek1987]

these guys(wadali brothrs) are somewhat one of the saving graces to the pathetic indian version of coke studio... its so influenced by bollywood that it forgets to feature new talent...bloody money whores

[SUFIBEAT]

GEEWAY GREAT SUFI MUSIC OF GREATER PUNJAB.............PAKISTAN/IN­DIA

[9888083021]

god bless you all my brothers from pakistan An INDIAN

[mrafiuddin50]

looks like u people know music better than the wadali brothers and leslie lewis. go fuck urself people..listen to some dhinka chika or chammak chalo

[thesaint230]

Sorry meant Fareed Ayaz!!

[thesaint230]

Theghani31 ur right mate..wot a performance by Fareez Ayaz..abs blown away...

[punishbudhiraja]

So Messy mix. Wadali brothers Rocks but this one is not up to the mark.

[jubnaa]

plz watch this and you will know how much better coke studio pakistan is watch?v=gjaH2iuoYWE

[hunzukutz]

Just because you use the name "Coke Studio" doesn't actually make you a good music director. Why don't you let Wadali Brother do their stuff and I am sure that will sound thousand times better than this.

[TheGhani31]

Fuck you coke studio india....first go n listen Fareez Ayaz perfomances of coke studio pak..then u will know what is called Qawali....nd leslie go n fuck yourself....

u r not even equals to Rohail Hayat's shitt....!!!

[TheTosha08]

fuck this its really creepy the way the have cheated anyhow the music isnt even fun to watch Shafqat too got his voice ripped here :P

[TAJEEish]

Wadali bros. should go to Coke studio Pakistan

[anandrajpurohit]

this is injustice to leaving legends talent... this is far away from their original version.

[MrUmeshJain]

I think rehashing classics in shape and form which allows it access to current generations is the only way to keep them alive. Even though I have been into various semi classical and classical forms of music, but coke studio introduced me to so many old and new artists which I would have not known- Sabri bros, wadali bros, arif lohar, sanam marvi etc. And once I discovered them I am able to go back and courtesy YouTube able to listen to and appreciate originals which otherwise I would have neve

[lovepeet89]

superb .... ^_^

[inder1112]

dats wot i call peace of mind while headphones r inside my ears it cutt u out of the world awesome :) i thionk i didnt have words to describe dis song

[LiveMusicMachine]

Can everyone stop criticising?! We have amazing live music here which the world needs to hear! ... in times when music is running dry, groups like Coke Studios are keeping live music alive! in the UK we're craving this type of creativity and music scene! everyones critising and all i can hear is beautiful music and a high budget production which is rare to come across in our industry! Just enjoy... peace out

[ragas1000]

Indeed best piece of worst music direction , dam they cannot start the song together.. hope Leslie Lewis could have come out of his western music's aura and understand this is a classical sufi composition you cannot fuck with it.

[valeriesingh]

they are singing like caged birds. like nightingales singing in diamond studded cage. ...when their climes are the unfettered skies of divine love!

[1985roselyn]

save indian music stop mtv coke

[TheSaadkazmi]

@1985roselyn agreed..... ya kaya kar rahay hian itnay achay ganoon ko inhoon nay aysa kar dia hay jasay CHEMOO BANDRI PAGAL HO GAI HO.

[206Eclipse]

@1985roselyn like you knw anything abt music?

[link3240]

No need of any instruments for the livin legends

[atisir]

Tu mane ya na mane Leslie....... tune kiya coke Studio barbaad !!!

[SuperOrange1980]

i agree to some extent to imran... there is no set pattern on which a sufi should is sung.. but coke studio teams does a bit too much on mixing... tooo much mixing spoils it...

[bbcolo]

7:17 to 7:20 they cannot even sing together they must be cursing the music director in their mind at that time

[bbcolo]

No way they can match Rohal Hayat. lagta hay zabardasti gana gavaya ja raha hai. they fucked the orignal song

[cupidblues]

Thats what happens when something is copied in India..... Shame on the creaters

[ankurkohal]

Thanks Lewis for killing a great song..

[Zango664]

Crap . . . in starting RIDE of DRUM is not sink with mandolin type string instrument

. . . note is not matching . . . . . its a big mistake if you have ears pour potty in your ears . . . . .

[jagsirthind]

nice music and changes at some places there noted down some little unsynchronisation due to low tempo wat nice if u listen 3 or 4 times new composition will set in mind

[sutaksh1]

what the hell r d musicians doin here......music is just simply not goin along....instead just had allowd wadalis to use harmoniam..cud been much better...music is good but at places not in a rythm with d lyrics....kya coke studio .....beiszati karwa di hum sab ki...

[farhaanasim]

This is a very interesting version, very soothing since the tempo has been reduced and the music arrangement is amazing. Not an easy task to match the maestros, still well done.

[2849250]

3:30 the guy looks like NFAK..

[rippenkhosa]

No body is to be blamed but Leslie Lewis... a flop musician worked his connections to somehow get this show in india.. and you expect it to be better than that of pakistan... All here needed is a composer who is well versed with all forms of music..

[way2coolash]

Coke Studio @ MTV

What the hell is going on

your musiciam team, whats wrong with them

If they are not capable to add some value to songs please tell them not to spoil it with their crap creativity

You musicians may be best, but you are not not worth to keep up with legends

[koustubhshark]

music has a soul and must be heard without prejudice...everytime a song is sung must be heard without the shadow of your past hearings...only then the singer, the song and you will make a union at a spiritual level, and thats why there is divinity in music. so brothers dont compare it with a previous version. even if you hear the same song many times, its different. the notes will pick different vibes of your soul.

[suhailnit]

I thought Coke studio is supposed to add music to it rather than taking soul out of it.. ruined it..

[lor3691]

hail wadali brothers... !!!! and those who are comparing india and pakistan... get a life loosers..pakistan was once a part of india...

[enshl001]

@lor3691

you get some life looser, know your true self before criticizing others...

moreover, this whole world was one country for the mankind; how can you claim India to be yours...

think before speak...

.

.

.

love u Pakistan!!!

[ahsankashmiri]

great performence!!!!!!!but honestly speaking guyzzzz pakistani coke studio sets very high standards .difficult to compete that.....

[gauravdhy1]

completely messed up... original version was wayyy better...

[hikohik]

I never expected that coke studio India will not set the tone it set in Pakistan. Have been waiting eagerly to see it India, but alas till now no coke studio India song is amazing.

[jattsahib]

@hikohik i agree mate don;t know what happened india do have great singer i was hoping for a good comp but still we are no way near pak singer's i salute pak singer esp Punjabi ... yaar sun keh maza aa gaay c aik alif and Jugni dastann e ishq mate slaute to pakistan for those songs punjabi songs were the BEST .. Punjab tah punjab aa pakistan hovay jah India :):):)

[someshti]

17 pakistani hai

[NavinSatankar1]

No words...just awesome...



[sandhuizm]

i cant believe they come to coke studio

[addypro]

@bawapanesar : And wadali brothers enjoying... well that is something which depicts the true side of the story.... for every singer what matters is the lyrics... & how they feel it.. i am pretty sure they must be enjoying it but.. still the composition has not even around the benchmark that there original version set up...... No offense again... :)

[addypro]

@bawapanesar hey dude i do agree that there shouldn't be a comparison between 2 songs but do you really think the later version is justice in accord to the lyrics can you really feel the lyrics ?? does the drop down in the bottle of the heart.. does that make your heart beat a BPM faster ?? i dont believe so... & its not just me who believe so.. just check out what everyone else has got to say about it... once a zenith achieved its always treated as the benchmark dude...No offences though :)

[kmr074u]

wat the fuk is wrong with the coke studio ppl

[addypro]

Coke studio.. Killing the eternity of the original song.... this one sounds like a LORI meant to make a kid Sleep.... rather then a piece of a beauty ( i.e the original version).. which actually pulls out the soul out of your heart n make you feel each & every bit of its lyrics.... PLZ DO A FAVOUR COKE STUDIO..... IF YOU CANT PULL OUT ANYTHING BETTER ATLEST DON'T KILL THE CLASSICS

[bawapanesar]

@addypro hey bro.. this is just another creative peice from them. lets not compare it with the older one... same coin but different sides..

just listen to this song.. and when listening, forget about the old one and dont compare... u will enjoy this ...

Wadali Bros are enjoying themselves.. do u think they will sing the song if they dont enjoy... Surely NOT...

[bhattacharyyasom]

great version !!! Loved it :D

[bluerocky]

wtf.. something grossly wrong wih coke studio india!!! change the composer..... NOW!!

[SuperDesirer]

what the bloody hell...

do experiment things, but please don't kill the beauty and soul of the song..

this is what composer's and Artists of coke studio pakistan do.

Jaago Re..

[glbakshi]

pagal hogaye kya...kya dhikana aur sunana chate ho pak coke studio wakayee hum se behtar hai...hats off to suhail...

[yourikhi]

i loved this song...best so far in cokestudio mtv

[yourikhi]

u should listen songs of indian ocean band.........thats real music and sufism

[harishankarsurya]

aree yaar kyon mere desh k shandaar music ki maa bhen ek kar rhe ho......wadali brothers k chahre par is song ko gane par jo sukun dikhta hai vo kahin kho gya tha yahan par...ye cock studio walee 4 guitar 1 base guitar or drum se ......haarmoniyam ,dholak tabla....or inka jo khul kar gana h uska mukaabla kar rhe hai......ye galat hai yaar kyon nhi samjhte ho tum log abhi bachche ho in dono k saamne.........

[karanjain180]

fuvked up wid d orginalty...

[gagdeep]

original song is much much better than, i realy like this song but this coke studio ruined its legacy . i think pakistani coke studio is better then indian one.

[gagdeep]

original song is much much better than this i think pakistani coke studio is better then indian one.

[chawlasheena]

Devine is the word.They truly are the legends..

[gorlll]

divine song, divine singers what a intoxicating blend..... Words are like old wine.

[gibrantughlaq]

what has happened to originality??????

This show is again a Pakistamni Import.......

Original Coke studio is awesome tooooo

[amitthakur156]

its an awesome song...dil ko sukun milta hai ise sun k....

[mohitpanwar100]

its rocking

[rajenmak]

Finallly finally finally... A FABULOUS ONE!

You have let the legends do what they do. You have not messed with them. ANd you have created heaven in that space called 'Coke Studio'. DELIGHTFUL!

[wamsluv]

Energy nahi hay music main

[kejuldshah]

Cannot get better than this........ just awesome.......

[MrWeepraxis]

Sab se phle main Coke Studio Main dekha ta Wadali Brothers ko....

or us k Baad aap ko Net main Search kiya....and

See your this Video....Good Looking....

Dil Cheer Jati hai....

[nikpik0228]

pure song ki maa kar de salo ne itane aache song ko kharab kar diya.

[deepsang2060]

awesome

[rohitkumar5454]

abe salo song toh sun ke dekho aur use feel karo apne ap acha lage ga

[raju4302]

fucked up with originalty

[RISHU2759]

Not only has coke studio india, made the song more difficult in terms of taal , it has also managed to accomplish the tougher task of ruining the song's quality. The song never manages to reach its climax and keeps much to be desired unlike the original.What a shame ! Really what a shame !- a fellow punjabi

[skipiit]

no way ..originalis heavenly ..this music director has no sense

[ameyarockers]

Shameful!!

Can you guys stop ruining the songs.... Its' beyond tolerance.

It would be great if they just copy the original song as Wadali brothers are great. Ruined it completely!!

[goodmanthe]

its fake they are not even performing here..its recorded...its sad that MTv thinks they can fool people like this...

[arghya1988]

this is not the coke studio we used to know !!!

[gyarakol]

change the musicians... they killed the song!!!!! my god!!!!! wadalis were fantabulous... do justice to their music... i will not buy this if lewis tells me that there aren't better percussionists and guitarists in the country to match the legends.. hunt for good accompanists for gods sake.. don't murder every legendary song this way...

[hunzukutz]

Just to follow what Rohail Hayat did in Pakistan with Coke Studio doesn't mean it will be successful by using the name. You have to have some knowledge on music too. I love Wadali Brothers and yes I am a music fanatic and I don't believe in borders when it comes to music. Please don't fix it when it's not broken.

[Maddiez85]

Yaar ab main kya kahun ... Wadali brothers are Lagends plz plz plz Change ur Musicians lagends ke sath tu aisa mat kro yaar ... i am a music lover... or sufi ki tu kya he baat hai ... m sorry Wadali brothers ... i think A.R.Rehman ko coke Studio Chala Chahiye ... love from pakistan and best of Luck

[rupesshuj]

Its good. Also loved the show Coke Studio India. The only real music show. It will evolve in to finest show in coming seasons. The start is just right. Please learn to appreciate the effort

[manishmmk]

sheer waste ...those who want to listen this song in full glory... search for older videos.. coke studio has made it like a bhajan..sleeping.

[Amanbindra87]

I think LEWIS should do some work as to da expectations of da audions if dis song was made bit fast as of ATIF LOHAR "jugni" from pakistani coke studio it would be gr8

No regrets from WADALI BROTHERS

LEGEND REMAIN LEGEND

[Guribhathal]

coke studio is not matching the expectations of there fans.............musicians and composers are need to work hard.............otherwise no need to carry this show, we are happy with coke studio of pakistan, wadali bros are awesome as they are allways

[aivdeep]

it seems dat wadali brothers singing while sleeping..........no dout they are arguably gr8 singers but i think its coke studio`s influence. Original song is so beautifull.

[ldhbramp]

coke studio seriously need some high quality musicians and the arrangers .. wadali brothers are legends ..

[mythicmarty]

No Creativity in the Music, the coke studio dint made it up to the Expectations of their Fans and Especially when the Legends are performing they would have made it much much Creative and Musical. Thumbs up to d Wadali Bros. Thumbs down to the Music Creation or the Music Director of Cke Stdio. :)

[sunejaaman]

Spoiled the Original Song.......& Coke Studio Music......arghhhhhhhhhhhh

[sabeeh20]

have they changed the raag r what they did???

[ajayrajpoot1]

Koi bol rha hai purana song batter hai. koi bol rha slow hai .koi bol rha enargy nai thi.i cant unnderstand dis yr .ye beta live gaya gya tha or live me to sur bhi kisi k baap ka nai hota aapne aap ka hota hai.wadali brothers is best.

[ani9pur]

SUPERB...



[raajtalk]

i think older is better than the new ones.....

[MrKaran0143]

This is superb performance by wadali Brothers.... i Love it..... I am listening this song from past few years... this one is my favr8... but this slow version is ultimate heart touching... i have no words to comment about this.... speechless....... A quality Performance...very few people can understand this quality..hats off..........

[rockeychumber]

i Dont know why Mtv got ready to telecast dis pthetic show music is not matching to the voice its seeming dat music done just to pass the time..its a disrespect to such a high class singers i am not talkin about singing i am not talkin about singers i am talkin about creativity in music its pathetic pakistani version is much much better ...........

[TheRabia14]

i lovd it its peacefull even i loved orignal one

[krishanartist]

original song is much batter.......ohh..coke studio....wt u did

[dvaibhav]

Ah i miss the energy in this performance. Coke Studio didn't do justice to Wadaali Brothers ! 

[bhadwal]

What the Fu... Man.....they actually spoiled Wadhalis.....Screwed up music.....no sync with the voices...way to go if they actually want to beat pakistani compositions.....Get up guys....Pakistanis are presenting indian classical like anything...gear up with some good compositions!!!

[sunnysunny2380]

Voice Of Wadalis is inner voice of there heart and soul,its original nt impcted by anyhing

[weka1717]

With all due respects to Wadali Brothers, the Coke Studio has, "FIZZED OUT" the fizz

[nitishnet]

I love this some that much , I cannt dislike :( wadali Brother. What this Coke studio is doing they should stop it right now if they are not able to give respect to such talented singers, they can create magic on stage but simply seems put extra restriction to him for shake of so called Fusion creation and making it different ,... BOSS kuch cheez original hi acchi lagti hai dont over experiment..... Once again Very disappointed by Coke Studio India ... Chala Dane pe Dana sunne ......

[pankaj4443]

i love da way dey present deir songs.....wat a chemistry between dese brothers.love deir voices

[khush5ab]

indeed frenz , the original was so much btr , da coke studio cudnt cope up with legends...!!!

they have decreased the tempo of the song to more than enough extent , ruined it , odrwise wadalis r gr8 wen dey sing under no restrictions

[TapanRaval]

@khush5ab you are right... original one is far far better and the gold one



[malharmvyas]

@khush5ab very true bro....

[gurbhej4u]

What a garbage music director. Fuking asshole should be kicked out. I wana piss on music director.

[msggarcha]

original is best... leslie has to learn a lot about Sufi....

[imrannagesh]

coke studio ruined the real quality of this song original song is awesome

[pinakpuki]

great song, nd thanks to mtv......to host a show like that........

[dev123enator]

The best live performers!!