Added: 4 years ago
From: krikitdude
Views: 482,827
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (625)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • este si es un verdadero baterista no como ese mangini q no sirve pa culo

  • is the version of fatal tragedy he's playing too from a live album?

  • If Bieber would have stuck to drums only by now he would smoke this chump like a welding rod. Maybe he does anyway? Lord knows he's way more famous than this shilcok will ever dream of being..

  • 1:04 to 1:07drums or masterbating? you decide!

  • Mangina joining DT is a fatal tragedy.

  • @MlKEPORNTOY .....you are ridiculous...MP this MP that......you said on another vid that MP is the only good drummer in the world...MP is good at what he does but MM is far superior....a humble guy, w/out the drama...the new CD kicks ass.....and the drums sound even in the mix....not overdone by MR. Controlling.....and listen to more then MP...G. Bissonette, T. Sucherman, S. Phillips, R. Morgenstein, S. Smith, AVH, Peart, K. Carlock, Weckl, T. Igoe, G. Harrison...................don­t be a child

  • @mikeybbdrummin

    George Harrison's not a drummer.

  • @MlKEPORNTOY Not George Harrison, Gavin Harrison from Porcupine Tree..one of smoothest tightest drummers around...Just the fact that i had to tell you who he was tells me and it should tell you, you need to get off your MP fascination.....he's a good drummer.....but listen to some jazz, fusion, swing........there is more then Prog rock...Listen to Simon Phillips on Derek Sherinians new "fusion"......or GHS......Gambale, Hamm and S.Smith....cool fusion..S.Smith can play MP w/1 hand and 1 foot

  • @mikeybbdrummin You are seriously retarded if you think Smith can play MP with two limbs. Like...go get your head examined. Simon Phillips? LOL. What makes him better than MP? Steve Smith could never play MP's double bass parts. Smith could never play Dance of Eternity either. His hand-to-foot combinations sound like slop compared to MP. I mean he has strengths over MP but better? Not by a long shot.

  • @metalmike83 ..MP is great at what he does and Ok, two limbs....exagerated.Smith is one of the originators of the hand/foot playin.I think MP's recorded sound is better, Smith has a Bohnam sound, dont confuse it for being sloppy....If you really think MP is better overall then Smith, then your name says it all and your stuck in Metal land and have no clue about other styles of music.....MP lack the finesse and dynamics of the guysI named....And Simon is one of the most versitile drummers around.

  • @mikeybbdrummin I never said he was better than any of them just different. Smith lacks the creativity of the other drummers mentioned. His chops are very boring with way too much snare. Weckl is a much better example of a fusion drummer and he has groove and finesse leagues above MP. I will admit that. But MP has much more power and has more accuracy and dexterity around a huge kit. His agility and precision are unmatched. His metal chops are top notch.

  • @metalmike83 ....To start , better to me means, more capable I guess.......it's subjetive anyway.......also consider who you like more and who you have more recordings of as well.....take, Dont Stop Beleivin (Smith).....that is on of the most creative Difficult drum parts by anyone............but nowadays Steve plays more jazz so it involves snare a lot....and it just may not appeal to you........................I think Steve and Weckl are the smoothest best executing drummers around.

  • @mikeybbdrummin Mangini does not sound good as the other drummers we are discussion, including MP. Of course, I know that MP would have a very hard time playing Lang's impossibly difficult parts and its easier for them to cover their material. But difficulty doesn't mean better. MP is better than Lang and Virgil at creating awesome drum parts. I've always felt that Virgil lacked spontaneous creativity that MP is known for and Lang, despite his chops is just plain boring.

  • @metalmike83 Again................Thomas and Virgil hve a different bodyof work then MP and im sure you love DT so you have most of what they have done......................I think alot has do do w/their band settings as well.

  • @mikeybbdrummin Tony Royster Jr. is probably my fav drummer right up there with MP. I don't think either of these two monsters are superior to one another but they can both do things the other can't. Same goes for guys like Jojo Mayer. Mayer has unbelievable hands and chops but there are things that MP brings to the table that just aren't there with Mayer and vice versa. I appreciate all different styles but Mangini definately lacks creativity and doesn't sound top quality.

  • @metalmike83 ...Tony is phenomenal............I have his dvd /Chambers......to me they both just get old SOOO quick.....I get it their fast.....my favorite is Bissonette....his sense of feel, versitiliy, dynamics, knowledge of styles, hisfinese/touch make him one of the top studio drummers around........Gregg, Steve, Simon and Rod Morgenstein are among my favorites..............well rounded highly rspected drummers............thats my story and Im sticking to it!!

  • @mikeybbdrummin anyone who says Mangini is far superior is ignorant about drumming. Just listen to the way MP plays this. Mangini has nothing on record that even comes close to this. Go listen to "Mike Portnoy's killer parts" on youtube and then come back and show me one single recording of Mangini doing anything even half as impressive. You can't because all of the recordings of MM showcase him with poorly put-together drum solos and a lack of feel.

  • @mikeybbdrummin People who favor MM think drumming is all about the mechanics and not about content. They point to how MM has better four-limb coordination, raw hand speed, independence etc. There's no evidene of any of that at all. He is better at playing polyrythms I'll give him that but let's not get overly caught up with the MECHANICS of playing and thinking it's more important than the CONTENT. Sounding good is more important than playing 50 rudiments over 12 foot patterns.

  • @mikeybbdrummin You're obviously one of those deluded fruitcakes who thinks that jazz and fusion drummers are automatically better than rock drummers. Whatever. They are mostly just different but none of them are superior to to MP. I would call Weckl, Phillips, Donati etc equal to MP but not better. Just because you play in a jazz band and can play hip hop grooves in your solo doesn't qualify you supeior to a a guy who's music made Donati and Lang have problems.

  • @metalmike83 .....I love rock, I love Aldridge, AVH, Castronovo, Mcbrain, Peart, Bissonette, R.Castillo, etc....what sets jazz/fusion drummers apart from MP is he doesnt have that touch....not that make MP a bad drummer....it just makes the others "more capable".....I saw G.Bissonette two weeks ago and his latin, jazz, swing feel, finesse and touch: MP could never touch him...but I know MP has his double bass chops more together then Gregg......and if you cant admit that........you have issues.

  • @metalmike83 .....MP's solo are very audience specific...put him in a group of Drummers that like, Weckl, Smith, Colaiuta, Chambers, Carlock, or a group of non rock guy and see how bored they would be......so yes, he does impress some crowds.....but it's specific IMO...he's a music fans drummer....not a drummers drummer......we have different opinions.....ur's is one thats so up MP's ass that you cant see the value and versitility in other drummer....and mine is they exact opposite.

  • @mikeybbdrummin Let me clarfiy that last bit - when Virgil and Thomas Lang played his shit they fucked up a couple of times. MP has a unique style on the drums and plays techically as well as any drummer on the planet in his own way. I can honestly say that I've seen Chambers, Lang, Weckl etc and none of them can play a solo and rock your ass off like MP. Just remember when comparing MM to MP MM might have better mechanics (in some ways) but his content is not top notch.

  • @metalmike83 ..If you think that because Thomas and Virgil didnt memorize MP's parts correctly means that werent capable of playing those parts....you are a laughable MP brown noser...I respect MP as a player...cause he IS great, but but MP to cover Virgils parts in Planet X material...it would be more of a challenge the Virgil playing MP's parts....OK, Mp know's how to impress music fans w/a solo of hand/foot and quads....blah, blah bla...it impresses kids.....i could do it too.

  • how many times a day do you think he accidentally hits the ride instead of the 14" tom?? O.o

  • @TheRevPlaysDrums 0 TIMES!!! GET THAT THROUGH YOUR THICK SKULL!!!

  • I hate when voices are coming wrong place...

  • too many drums, too many hair highlights.....

  • They still let this pile of stink take up Youtube space?? man he is over. Gone kaput..

  • @snaredrum110 "He is over." Just like your brain activity.

  • @moviemaster8510 Go see Adrenaline Mob and tell me Portnoy isn't a wasted piece of dipshit...hahahaha

  • @snaredrum110 Mike Portnoy isn't a wasted piece of dipshit. :-)

  • @moviemaster8510 Where is that skankass at. How's Adrenaline Mob doing???hahahahahah

  • @snaredrum110 Great. Everything Mike Portnoy touches turns to gold.

  • @moviemaster8510 Adrenaline Mob is a turd band..

  • @snaredrum110 Your mom's a turd band.

  • @moviemaster8510 hahah. Mike got done fucking your face?

  • @snaredrum110 With awesomeness? Fuck yeah!

  • @moviemaster8510 Gay boy to the max...fuck off

  • @snaredrum110 You're saying Mike Portnoy sucks and you call me gay? Hey, there's this artist named Justin Bieber, I'm sure you'd love him. You can finger your pussy to him all you want and not a single fuck will be given from me or anyone else. Toodles.

  • @moviemaster8510 Mike told me that he wants another blowjob from you. Get busy faggot

  • @snaredrum110 Look buddy go achieve what Portnoy has achieved then come back and tell me he's shit instead of sitting behind a pc screen trolling, get a job.

  • @B3NGAG3 Look what Justin Bieber has already acheived. tell Mike he ain't shit. And he can't even get a girl..hahahahaha

  • @snaredrum110 Justin Beiber? Oh! you mean the kid who supposedly impregnated one of his fans? thats right when Portnoy has been through marriages and has kids but he done that at a sensible age anyway im done argueing your worthless stop going on videos if you dont like the guy simple.

  • @B3NGAG3 Mike's married?I'm sure he's a fag. Got any pictures of his wife? Never have seen one. UGly ass hag I bet if she even exists.

  • snaredum110.......Still pretending to be a musician???? Maybe you should switch to astronaut instead. I wish I could see things from your point of view...but fortunately my head doesn't fit up my ass.

  • @snaredrum110 "I smoke portnoy and anybody you know"

    watch?v=MpKqlmAFSic

    watch?v=JGXxfYxhD6E

    Really?

  • @cliffspc I really don't think anybody cares about some 32 year ago band. WTF is the point? It's not my band.. You look plain foolish ..

  • @cliffspc Don't be putting up this Hero shit and say I did it.. Robots for Ronnie says this band recorded this in 1979!!! So what does 32 years ago mean to me?? I smoke that drummer w/ease too. You don't know a drummer that can hang with me cliffeeeboyeee....

  • @snaredrum110 Then post something, otherwise Hero will be your epitaph on YT. I will be sure everyone knows it. Deny it was you drumming and you declare yourself a complete fraud.

    Your choice...

  • @cliffspc Cause U say so??? I doubt that very very much...hahahahahaha

  • @snaredrum110 More cowbell, then...

    r.i.p. hero.

  • lol guys, there are many gods, and mike is one of them... now whether his shitty ideas ruined dream theatre or not well thats open to discussions.. but still hes one hell of a drummer.. one of the best

  • god this is boring.

  • The only guy that ever got kicked out of two bands in the same year...hahahahah

  • @snaredrum110 kicked out of two bands? hahahah you ignorant troll! He left Dream Theater by his own will, and he had only planned to play with Avenged until 2010 ended.

  • @concreteeater12 Sure kid sure.. Now he's in a going nowhere band that can't even get a record deal..

  • @snaredrum110 and is still a god

  • @ziberfantom There is only one God and it surely ain't this rotten pig fucker Mike Portnoy

  • @snaredrum110 jeez chill out dude its just an expression, i know there is only one god lol

  • @ziberfantom Admit that Mike is a scumbag piece of mediocrity and we'll be cool then. Can you be honest about it?

  • @snaredrum110 Your username is snaredrum, but looks like you dont know nothing about drums.

  • @amodelchurro I smoke portnoy and anybody you know.

  • @snaredrum110 na dude hes pretty much my drummer, but everyone is entiteled to an opinion.

  • @ziberfantom Doesn't matter to me. I smoke that mo fo like he ain't shit. cause ge ain't shit. So does Bobby jarzombek. Look at him on youtube and cry for Mike's sorry ass.

  • keep going MIke!!! any band you like! just don't stop playing!

  • Mike Portnoy endorses Promark drum sticks,

    @jadrummer endorses Depends Undergarments and PolyGrip.

    Coprophilia anyone?

    watch?v=MpKqlmAFSic

  • @cliffspc Polygrip pays way more than Promark

  • jadummer......While Portnoy plays professionally...you troll his videos on your parents computer while pretending to be a musician. Wow....... how impressive.......hahaha

  • hahaha. Both DT and Avenged got rid of Mike's skank ass. Now he stuck in the seventies with a complete waste of time Adrenanaline Mob.. hahaha Karma...

  • Mike got his skank ass fired from both bands.

    hahahahahaha

  • Mike left avenged sevendold because it was always be Avenged sevenfold and mike portnoy not just avenged sevenfold and mike also wanted to do solo projects

  • CAZZO è uguale a la russa

  • the sound is not in sync

    

  • @cgouais exactly, ,,,,,, my thoughts exactly,,, it's offffff!!!!!!

  • I think he was jizzin at 1:03

  • how does he manage to hit the tom underneath the ride ?

  • I find it so hilarious... ROFLMFAO that the fag band Avenged Sevenfold told his faggot ass to GTFO ....hahahahahahahahahahaha

  • @jadrummer110 LOL, Avenged didn't tell him to GTFO. He was never going to be the permanent replacement. He said he was going back to DT. Later, when he wanted to come back to Avenged, they had already hired a new drummer.

  • @Elthenar So wrong. Drink the koolaid fool. Avenged told him to GTFO. Period. So did DT. Mike's career is almost over and he is surely forgotten already... hahahahahah

  • @jadrummer110 what's the point of mocking a fallen legend? there isn't one

  • @mpawl347 Cause you say so? There's abook and over 1 billion people who disagree strongly. And if you're wrong? Big problem. If I;m wrong? I've lived a more caring better life ...either way, you come out smelling like shit..

  • @jadrummer110 Your comment doesn't really make much sense at all and it lacks enough focus and maturity for me to take it seriously. All I'm saying is, what do you have against this guy that you feel the need to drag his name and his career into the mud? This guy has inspired countless of people during his career with his talent and his kind heart. Sure, he made a lot of big mistakes but does that give you any reason to speak badly upon him? He is still an outstanding musician.

  • @mpawl347 He's not a nice a guy at all. fail.

  • @jadrummer110 excellent.

  • @mpawl347 Mike Portnoy LEFT Dream Theater after being denied a hiatus. He said he missed his family too much to be constantly touring. Avenged sevenfold didn't take him as their full time rummer because they didn't like how he responded to being denied a hiatus, to be in Avenged Sevenfold, you have to be like the rest of the band.

  • @GarrettMumford Why are you telling me this? ha. That is irrelevant to the comment conversation I was having.

  • @mpawl347 sorry meant to tag jadrummer

  • @jadrummer110 Don't believe everything you read in Tiger Beat. Everything I said is The Truth.

    Portnoy is to damn good to be forgotten and DT will be irrelevant without him.

  • @Elthenar DT is irrelevant anyway. Always was.

  • @jadrummer110 OK, you have me there. But, the only reason anyone ever talked about DT at all was Portnoy.

  • Wow....Portnoy really did inspire the Rev. There's "The Beast and the Harlot" solo right there @0:11.....

  • @saxdrummer92 Obvious troll is obvious.

  • @xZeiu Lol, I guess I can see how that is trolling. I honestly didn't mean anything by it. I was just stating an observation....Seriously was not trying to troll in any way though....my bad

  • 1:04 orgy?

  • Everyone is hating on Mike for leaving DT. Lets just enjoy what he gave us!

  • Ignore the talentless pile o shit as jadummer. Only then will this awful smell go away!!!!

  • Portnoy is a spent hack..

  • No men!!! Its crazy this men!! AWSOME!

  • I just farted, it smelled terrible.

  • @DviniciusribeiroT damn its a fatal tragedy man

  • @GdzieJestBabcia Oh yea for sure

  • @DviniciusribeiroT 1:05 = his reaction lolololol

  • Great Video

    

  • This is SPARTAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!

  • Mike Portnoy. Y U SO GOOD?!

  • Anyone know of any other videos of Mike playing Fatal Tragedy? Preferably the whole song..

  • half a video? come on, buddy.

  • hahahhaaa LOL...

    how stupid I'm in actually...

    when read this video title, I think this video's about mike portnoy when he got a fatal accident when playing a drum... LOL :D

  • @tresna2 learn english.

  • Mike Mangini is the most boring drummer ever. He has a "rinse and repeat" style of drumming. Mike Portnoy was one of the first drummers to play with the style that he plays with. People think that countless, flawless tempo changes are a simple thing. Remember, you have to make it all come together. And i am sorry to say that Mangini will only let all of you down.

  • @destroman16 amen dude, I agree with you, MP has his kinda unique signature style, MM? I have heard others playing the same style.. anyway I don't believe he fits in DT... that's just my opinion, I didn't liked the new DT single at all, there's something missing

  • There's no such thing as being better, there's only opinions... So it's a waste of time arguing about it...

  • How can you replace this!?!?

  • @destroman16 You get a better drumer named Mangini. Simple

  • @rrdrums1952 or u can get a sucky drummer like... idk.... YOU

  • @stcynsn1 truthfully mangini is better than portnoy, but they are both definitely better than him .

  • @rrdrums1952 he won because he could imitate what MP did. He will never be able to replace him.

  • @destroman16 Who cares? They have a better than Mike Portnoy drummer now. Isn't that what matters to DT? Quit living in the past. Portnoy is junk old technology..

  • It's easy to see why both DT and AX& fired this skankass drummer.

  • @rrdrums1952 a7x?

  • @rrdrums1952 they didnt fire him dumb ass he quit and at7 didnt fire him either he knew it was only to record and finish the tour

  • @Dakota9851 They both tol skankass Mike to hit the bricks boy..hahaha. Cause he's a pile of poop in his own pants stink..

  • @rrdrums1952 i can't believe you're still wasting your life trolling on Portnoy videos... how many years as it been ? i wish you find a mate, shut down your computer and start to live.

  • @Zoury I have a fine wife and I am life.. Next??

  • @rrdrums1952 yea i bet ur wife is some low profile murderer that pays u to say lies. u r life? life is a giant wannabe troll?

  • Yeah Peart. Go Peart. Shampoo that is...

  • L-O-V-E

  • Stop at 1:04 ... EARGASMM!!

  • Mike Portnoy looks like King Leonitus.

  • THIS IS SPARTAAA!

  • 1:01 - 1:08

  • I love A7x and all, but, mike you should have stayed.

  • @UberGrimm what does a7x have to with it, he already said they had no factor in his decision to leave dream theater, which was proven when him and a7x parted ways over 6 months ago

  • lol @ him getting in the camera's face

  • How the fuck does he get out of there?

  • @rockbandftmfw9 He doesn't. He practices 24/7

  • @amdestuiani lol

  • THIS IS SPARTA!!!

  • the 1 . NO MORE.

  • Met this guy a while ago... great guy, really nice, and he signed my first top of the line cymbal :D AAXplosion 16" Crash.

  • WOW AMAZING.. EXTREMELY BOMB...

  • The Oldskool shit... this is in my opinion the best portnoy's kit totally great and full acoustic sounding 

  • 0:13 lol

  • This looks like it's from the early 90s

  • @JimiPain This is from early 00s, Scenes From A Memory came out in 1999.

  • @Gasb92 No shit? Tell me something new >.>

  • @JimiPain Ok. Mike Mangini is the new drummer of Dream Theater.

  • @Gasb92 Not really something new

  • @JimiPain Just kidding ;D

  • The 'purple monster' is one of the best kits out there

  • @percdann i think the pussy monster might be slightly better

  • Tama Starclassic's baby

  • hes not that good at drumming like shit

  • heee! pone el video completo cheee!

    put the full video!! >.<!!

  • I died in the snare drum part ._.

  • Mike kit's is so awesome!!

  • no i thought it was a good spot to end it

  • haha awesome drumming spartan

  • imagine trying to find the right cymbal in that forest!

  • Mike Leaving Dream Theatr was a fatal tragedy.

  • @Xx25BeasT96xX Dream Soap Opera..Nah but mangini was better to me..I dunno why people´s so tough on him..hes really good and...gulp...better than mike portnoy but he was humble and he respected the things he did...hes a better drummer and a better person...and he proved it...it was more than words...(get it???, he played on extreme)

  • @Xx25BeasT96xX HAHA

    fucking good one

  • @Xx25BeasT96xX omg so right

  • Your mother is a fatal tragedy=))

  • jesus that set looks terrifying to be sat behind.

  • @EmperorBubba its beautiful

  • @xXRASHEEDXx

    oh I agree, it's wicked, but daaamn, i'd shit myself behind it.

  • haha i'm suprised he could even get into the drum set.

  • What are those things beneath the Octobans at 0:50? The assortment of little things?

  • @Peartnoy518 I believe it's a set of small cymbals called crotales. They're tuned chromatically (A, A#, B, etc..) and produce a very high ringing tone when hit.

  • oh fatal tragedy is a song i thought he had heart attack or something lol

  • terrible sound lag

  • THIS IS DREAM THEATER! 0:15

  • He looks like a midget in this vid