Ammar Nakshawani - Analysis of Hadith al-Manzilah

[ZainW4]

mashallah once again, sayed ammar does a beautiful lecture.

[halakukhan]

@GentileForTruth yes he's mentioned in Bible there many verses like John16:7-15,song of solomon 5:16,John 1:25 n many more but if U ask Christines about these verses, they will tell u its holy ghost, but it wont make sense u have to be honest to ur self to see Jesus is prophesying about a person not just some ghost. there isn't any discrepancy in Quran but many can be found in Bible. n like holy prophet said he's leaving Quran n his family behind so learn Quran from ahel e beth not from xyz...

[drfreemason]

Prophet Mohammed last words before he died, "I leave behind the Quran and my family learn from them".

[85oomar]

Respond to this video... the Quaraan n my [s.a.w] Sunnah..thats was his last words

[85oomar]

@drfreemason the Quraan n my sunnah[s.a.w]..these are his [s.a.w]last WORADS..i think you have problem all with choice.or who is to b 1st..preach peace n unity ..thts what ISLAM need to b stronger....division make ISLAM weaker.......stay away from shirk n many of what the prophet s.a.w 4bid to...aslm...peace....a muslim

[rassputih]

ALLAHUMA SALI ALA MUHAMMAD, WA ALI MUHAMMAD, WA AJILL , WA FARAJAHUM, ALI MUHAMMAD..

[lesabrhodood]

Shias?

You should be wipping your back,instead of giving a lecture.

;)

[furqan1986]

@lesabrhodood you should be kissing yazeed's feet instead commenting.

[Factszz]

All hadith books were invented 200 yr aft prophet against his consent by Criminal Persian parsi Imams. THese books are full of lies. But Criminal hadith imams of shia suni wahabi etc has attched these lies to Prophet PBUH who never said these hadiths. The major reason of too many sects & troubles in Islam is due to these crap hadiths. Allah says his books is complete & fully detailed. So u do not need these crap hadith books. Proof:

w w w . smalur . com / wI

delete spaces from url

Shia Kafirs

[hezbullah786]

@Factszz you the biggest dickhead ive come across on youtube, everytime you open your mouth you shoot yourself in the foot just like your gay sunni boyfriends.

You say that all hadith books are full of lies and are fabricated, so why do you call six of your books sahih?

Why are sunni book publishers doing everything they can to publish these books in as many languages as possible?

How do you expext anyone to take you seriously when you keep contrdicting yourself?

[hezbullah786]

@Factszz you say we dont need any hadiths and the quran is all we need.

So I ask you where in the Quran does it tell us to pray 5 times a day?

Where does the Quran give detailed instructions on how to pray namaz and do wudhu?

Where in the Quran does it say that muslims should pray tarawih during ramadan?

[Factszz]

@hezbullah786

Answer of ur all 65 Questioin that usually are asked by Hadithers can be read on our this page: w w w . smalur . com / wJ

(Remove gaps from link)

[TheIslamicthought]

@Factszz - you are gravely mistaken... if there were no books of hadith, how would we know the ways of the prophet, while you find in Quran, Allah swt says that there is a good example in the prophet for the believers.

And, in my opinion, most muslims after the prophet passed away threw the prophet and his ways out the window. That's how they never reached a consensus. And today we have, as you say, "too many sects."

[ZainW4]

@Factszz well then how would you understand the verses of the quran without the hadiths you idiot. You have no right to call anyone a kafir especially the shia. You are not the same level as allah (SWT) to judge anyone so i suggest that you're more careful in the future. And to the three people who liked your comment; may allah (SWT) guide them.

[Factszz]

@ZainW4

Well u are among those millions of blindly- following jahil fanatics who are badly brainwashed by Mullahs. If so called hadith was part of Islam; prophet could had left behind manuscripts of hadith Books along with Quran but did he? NO. 250-400 yrs after Prophet, Persian Criminal Pro-shia Zoroastrian Imams fabricated ~2 millions reports & attached that crap to the name of Prophet by adding "Qala Rasool Allah'. Quran explains itself fully & it does not need help of Persian Crap

[85oomar]

@Factszz just stopbla..bla..bla without knowledge,if there ere no hadiths sahih,n only QURAAN..HOW would you perform swalat[prayers]idiot it is only mentionned in sahih hadith.....not quraan..its mentionned swlat but not how to pray n how many rakaat in each..later i will give u more examples baby..u r still kids in islam ..go to madrassah[islamic skul]n leran more bros..may allah s.a.w...guide us All

[jambe1234567]

task the Sunnis why they keep denying that fact that Aisha was an Evil person when the wife of Noah and the wife of Lot, who were under righteous slaves yet betrayed them so that they (the husbands) availed them naught against Allah and it was said (unto them): Enter the Fire Quran, 66

[m000ds]

Sayed Ammar is a great speaker, and he only uses sunni hadiths, but the problem is, Sunni's don't even read their own hadith, at times i doubt they actually understand the quran.

[sangak59]

sweetsingeruk is bitten by anti-shia psychosis! all who listen to his lectures (and I am a sunni) cannot help but be impressed by his knowledge. you can wake up a sleeping sweetsingeruk, but you cannot wake up a sweetsingeruk who is pretending to be asleep

[sweetsingeruk]

sangak59, talk TO me, not ABOUT me. Unless you're worried that I, what with being a female and all, will have more sense than you, resulting in a good verbal slamming...?

And stop your fitna-mongering with your sunni-shia bullshit. It's sooooooo old.

[courseworkdue]

IRONIC!!!!!

'Talk TO me, not ABOUT me'.

The amount of Gheeba you've engaged is negates your right to say such a thing!

[sweetsingeruk]

"The amount of Gheeba you've engaged"

Oh, and of course you haven't responded, thereby incriminating yourself in this NON-EXISTENT 'gheeba'! lol you crack me up . Think before you speak, it's a sign of wisdom, otherwise you are deemed a FOOL.

[courseworkdue]

SubhanAllah I'm lost for words. Let me explain this for you slowly and simply. I am talking TO you not ABOUT you. Therefore not Gheeba. backbiting is when you speak about someone behind their back.

Now you claim Ammar can read this, well only unless he trawls through every video of his on the lookout for peoples comments, can what you say be true. And even then your premise is wrong.

As the Aimmah (as) have said:

If true its backbiting and if its false its slander.

Bring proof or ssshh...

[courseworkdue]

MashAllah with the swearing too. And also the user SANGAK isnt fitna mongering. On the contrary he is doing the opposite!

[Islamicshialectures]

Sallamun Alaykum

May Allah (AW) bless u for the video

ws wr wb

[world1world]

May Allah me pleased with Abu Bakr

May Allah me pleased with Umar

May Allah me pleased with Uthman

May Allah me pleased with Ali

[85oomar]

@world1world ameeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeen

[slicksam69]

mashaAllah great stuff, please forward and convey this message to all!!!

[albaghdady2007]

Names who transmitted this Hadith did not say it for nothing. It would better in my opinion to use Hadith from Shi'a sources with authentic transmission and then may be add the Sunni Hadiths an extra qarina.

What missing is demonstrating knowledge of Shi'a Hadiths first.

[sakzaan]

My Muslim brother, the hadith's are not Shi'a or Sunni, but these are Hadiths from Sahehh Bukhari and Muslim, for example in Muslim Vol 2 page 287 RasulAllah says, Ya Allah, my Ahlel Bayt are Ali, Fatima Hasan and Husain! In the event of Mubahila, these 5 went to represent Islam, where others who were present in the Muslim world, were not invited, then I ask u, why do u ppl not seek logic? If u cannot understand this my brother, Salama.

[albaghdady2007]

To sakzaan,

Mubahala or Kisa both means nothing towards leadership, only Ghadir speech meant the Prophet favorite was Ali as successor.

Many world political parties, their leaders only can recommend someone but does not mean a successor, its up to the election to decide.

[sakzaan]

The leaders of Islam have never been elected by the worlds election, until the time of Abu Bakr. Henceforth, Musa, elected Harun. The point in Ghadir Rasul appointed Ali. If Rasul brings Ali and not the first three into Mubahila, then i ask u, by logic, whos right shud it be then? However democracy has never been the point of Islam, until RasulAllah left, and abu bakr changed it. hope this helps you out.

[albaghdady2007]

To sakzaan,

The Prophet would not be a leader without the election of Madina leaders, you were wrong there.

The objection of Ali to Abu Bakr was nothing to do with Ghadir speech, but because Abu Bakr didnt come to power by tribe leaders election.

Harun died before Moses.

[sakzaan]

oh my....are u telling me, that if Allah did not choose his prophet but the elections at medina did!!!!!!! OMG!!..and my brother, Harun i talk bout wen Rasul goes to Mountain. you shud read open ur books, and then talk, because if u just say, this has nothing to do with that and wtever, u will sink blind in the ocean of ignorance. May Allah guide u. Salama.

[albaghdady2007]

To sakzaan,

Are you shocked for knowing that the Prophet was elected by people like any election?

Dear sakzan; I know my books and your books inside out, but do you know enough what was written in your books?

Ocean of ignorance normally is for those do not seek knowledge.

[sakzaan]

My Muslim friend, i can post such claims as well on youtube :)...however, i am not shocked, but i am shocked at u, cuz u believe that Allah did not choose the prophet but the people did. If democracy had anything to do with it, then Ibrahim, would have been burned to death, and would not be "elected" prophet. However open Sahih Muslim Vol. 2 Page 287, Where the prophet talks about his Ahlel Bayet being Ali, Fatima Hasan Husain. Honestly, I wud like to talk to u face to face about this matter.

[albaghdady2007]

To sakzaan,

I do not need to lie to you, whether in tube or in Hawza. I say this again 'The Prophet could not be a leader of Madina without the election of people of Madina'.

The prophet hood is separate issue from leadership, leadership can only come through election.

[sakzaan]

RasulAllah is quoted in a highly placed book of the Sunni, Hadith Al Tabari Vol. 8 Page 16 That after me follow Ali, Fatima Hasan and Hussain. However, if you do believe that Allah does not choose the prophet, but the people do, then we are in a discussion which cannot resolve on this msg board. Also if democracy is the way of Islam, why were Othman and Omar not elected in such way but were elected by their predessors. I would more than willingly, meet you anywhere and have this discussion.

[albaghdady2007]

To sakz

1- The Prophet hood is not up to people, but leadership is up to people and the best leadership comes through election of the majority.

2- Non of the caliphs used the election, it was chaos when some people asked Ali to be the caliph, Ali refused it several times.

[sakzaan]

Why was this act of democracy not applied with Uthman and Omar?

Also while all these people were arguing amongst themselves over who will be the Caliph, Ali was burrying the Prophet. At the time of Abu Bakr, he was only asked by Abu Sufyan, with the intention of spreading violence in Islam. To get his approval Omar kicked the door open, killed the child inside Fatima, and dragged him from his throat with a rope!

[albaghdady2007]

Dear sakzaan,

First, have we finished from the Prophet would not be able to rule Madina without their election to him?

Then will talk about what happened after his death.

[sakzaan]

:) u donot have answers my brother, and it is futile to argue with u over youtube...i must impose meeting u, if u r as open minded as u boast u r, then i think i can convince u with reality, if not this is futile on youtube, for no matter what im saying, u are not giving me a counter. i really believe so.

[albaghdady2007]

Your logic and evidence are repeated one.

The Sunni Hadith does not say Hasan or Husein were the successors of the Prophet.

What you said in my opinion is poor, you claim using logic then you should use it and stop going around the houses.

You sound so desperate to meet?

[sakzaan]

read the versus i have quoted, then come back to me. my muslim brother, you say u seek knowledge, so that is why i wanted to meet.

but u seem very defensive, and this is futile....henceforth wasalam, May Allah Subhanahoow'atalah, show u the right path...wasalam.

[albaghdady2007]

To sakzaan,

If I have said "I seek knowledge" it does not mean I need someone to tell me ABC of Shi'i or Sunni teachings.

The logic you used was an old one and was refuted by the early Shi'i scholars. The logic you used was similar to the one of al-Khawarijj and Nasibis.

[JAFFERSH]

if the "best leadership comes thru election and the majority" then why is it that people like ex-president Bush, Hitler, and several other corrupt leaders were also once elected by the majority of the people? Ur argument is flawed. Truth lies with the minority, never with the majority...for it is far easier to do evil, then it is to do good. Look at the world today for example, is the majority of the people on the actual right path?? Even the majority of those who claim to be muslims r not.

[albaghdady2007]

To sakzaan,

The Prophet was a Prophet before the election of the Madina. Therefore leadership is something separate from the Prophet hood.

Hasan or Hussein could not be his successors just because they were his grandsons!

But only can happen if the people elected them.

[courseworkdue]

That's funny because I don't remember which election it was that saw omar take power, or uthman for that matter.

Oh no that's right, that's because your little coup d'etat was born in kufr and iniquity and thus the inconsistencies are glaring.

[godsent03]

Condemn Wahhabi.

[najflex]

great lecture,i have watch 2 lecture's from this brother and both very intresting,massallah his full of great knowledge,but who is he and whats his background?

[lostprophet786]

Please avoid passing off your own opinions as facts

He has his own website where you can read a brief biography on him and what he is studying. Everyone who has met him knows he is of Iraqi origin. At no time has he claimed to be a scholar, he is simply an academic researcher and lecturer.

"He talks about sex ALL the time. He has corrupted the youth."

Over 100 of his lectures can be found on Youtube

Please show me one in which he does what you accuse him of.

"He has corrupted the youth"

?

[sweetsingeruk]

"He has his own website" - LINK??

"Over 100 of his lectures can be found on Youtube"

Yes, sadly none of them are the ones I am talking about. Youtube is not a showcase for the 'lectures' of Ammar Nakshawani!

He has corrupted the youth through his 'midnight lectures', involving mixed groups of teenagers, during which he speaks openly and shamelessly about sex and the genitalia, which he seems to have an insatiable fascination with.

contd...

[sarahdeen]

Salam,

I want to share with you an Ayat from the Quran chapter 49 surah Al-Hujurat Ayat number 12. Allah says

"O you who believe! Avoid much suspicion, indeed some suspicions are sins. And spy not, neither backbite one another. Would one of you like to eat the flesh of his dead brother? You would hate it (so hate backbiting). And fear Allah verily, Allah is the one who forgives and accepts repantance, Most Merciful."

think about it....

[sweetsingeruk]

sarahdeen, many thanks for your concern, but for the record, I am not backbiting. This is an open forum, and Ammar can see these comments for himself (and probably does).

I cannot forgive the corruption of my community's children at the hands of this man. People can give me all the 'thumbs down' they want, but the truth is the truth, and I won't step back from it.

Everyone in my community is fed up of this fraud, and it's about time everyone else woke up to him.

[courseworkdue]

Are you his ex wife or something?

You sound Bitter!

He is a sayed and studied under scholars like Sayed Fadhel Milani. He is not, though, an Alim by his own admission.

So you say it happens in your mosque? Which mosque is that?

He did give lectures about sex and Islam in a university recently but im wondering about these 'midnight sessions'!

[sweetsingeruk]

courseworkdue, Mashallah! You have proven yourself to be a true follower of this deviant! Ever heard of "akhlaaq"? No? Try asking your parents to teach you what it means, and also how to talk to a woman. Practise on your mother first.

I am bitter, yes. Not because of your obscene suggestion, but because of the effects of his 'midnight sessions' on my community.

Why are you so eager to know which mosque? Do you want to attend one of his 'youth corruption and vulgarity' classes?

[courseworkdue]

Pure filth.

You have engaged in relentless backbiting and gheeba in this thread and then have the nerve to talk about akhlaq? You disgusting excuse of a human being.

I want you to say which mosque he supposedly does to know whether you're lying or not. Go on then, which mosque? If you say a mosque that he doesnt even go to then ill know you're lying and that's why you wont say!

[sweetsingeruk]

"You have engaged in relentless backbiting and gheeba in this thread"

No, actually, I haven't. Like I said before, this is a public board, which Ammar is welcome to read and respond to. Please refrain from calling me names, because if I get started on you you won't know where to hide your face.

The reason I am not saying the name of the mosque ON A PUBLIC MESSAGE BOARD is to PROTECT my community, not because a silly spotty teenager thinks I'm lying! OK..?

[courseworkdue]

Go and read into the rules concerning back biting and you will see that indeed thats what you've been doing. The fact that this is a 'public board' is the stupidest thing I have ever heard. I suppose sermon 80 is more profound that I first thought.

Regardless you still haven't said which mosque this supposedly happens in nor brought any proof. Go and record him giving these 'midnight lectures' then we can talk. Until then you're just a bitter old woman.

[sweetsingeruk]

... contd...

This type of mixed gathering is stricly FORBIDDEN in Islam. Boys and girls should not be together in the same room when these things are talked about, but should be taught separately, by scholars of their own gender!

Oh, and btw "his own website" doesn't actually count. He is telling us what his background is, this doesn't mean it's true. That's what fraud is all about. Lies. lies and more lies.

Accept what you conscience is screaming at you!

[lostprophet786]

Regarding the mixed gatherings, I agree, such explicit topics should not be spoken about in such manner, and what you are saying is quite alarming. However I would still have to verify such gatherings occur for myself before making a judgement, with all due respect I can't take your word for it.

"He is telling us what his background is, this doesn't mean it's true"

So what exactly makes it 'true' and what in it did you find a lie? His studies?

[sweetsingeruk]

Certainly, it is your perogative to find out for yourself. I know it happens because it happens in my mosque!

"So what exactly makes it 'true' and what in it did you find a lie? His studies? "

The fact that there is no information anywhere else about his 'background' other than his own website does lead one to wonder, you must admit, what the truth is..?

[Lebanese28]

Allahoma Sali 3ala Mohamadon Wa2ali Mohamad

[Zulfiqarr]

Good lecture, and no sunnis and shias should dislike of the hadith al-Manzilah.

[shuayb2]

this brother talks of Umar, narrators of hadeeth bukhari and Muslim, but does he agree that bukhari and Muslim is authentic???

since normally shias don't mention these hadeth and reject them, or is he just using sections which he wants for his gains>>???

[lostprophet786]

"or is he just using sections which he wants for his gains>>???"

He is using Hadiths deemed 'authentic' by Sunnis to prove his point, not for 'his gains'.

It is what you do in a intellectual discussions, use narrations deemed authentic by the other party so that they have no grounds in which they can disagree.

[jambe1234567]

@lostprophet786 Not all Sunni Narrations are concocted. some are true

most are not

[HasanAbulFez]

You must understand the rules of debate. I ask you brother. If a Shia came to you with this hadiith from a book like Al Kafi or Nahj al Balagha, you would imediately throw it out and say this is a Shia book, or something along those lines. We must prove to you through your books, like we must prove things to christians through the bible. If a Christian tried to tell you Jesus was God (astaghfur Allah) with the bible, you would laugh. Same scenario here.

[lebmo]

The real story is brother that not all the sunni hadiths are considerd false or fabricated just like we dont consider the current bible to be completely fabricated, the bigger picture is that ammar is pointing out that the issues he is dealing with are not even contradicted in sunni hadith. The shia do not consider all our chains of hadith are correct infact we disregard anything that condradicts the teaching of our INFALIBLE prophet and his pure progeny whom are a reflection of his teachings

[furqan1986]

@shuayb2 it is not called gaining, we call it mutifiqa raye. it means that you are deviating from your book,, it never means we reject so we will not read it to support our cause which is right.

[85oomar]

@shuayb2 u r rite..may ALlah s.w.a guide them,n 2ndly he is saying prophets name as if he is talking to a friend.[muhammad].without saying s.a.w..did he know the hadith n saying of nabi s.a.w...when saying ameen 3 times when approaching the nimbar,[its was when gibrael a.s said curse to the 1 who does not send salams when mentionning ur name[muhammad s.a.w]in sahih hadith LOL.then continue ur imaginative lucture,n don't compare the situation of musa..a.s n harun to Ali r.a.read sahih hadith lol

[MuzzyPursuit]

Mashallah bro..

Beautiful lecture..

Forwarded to all my friends..

Thankyou and Salam to all..

[12imams]

love it! and love teh way he breaks things down! it shouldnt leave people with doubt! but it does!... he does dramatise some ashura lectures, but it needs passion.. i still love him :-)

anyways, any brothers and sister from the sunni school who have any questions on shia ways, please feel free to ask and i will reference and reply.

salams..

[jimbowzee24]

Sallam,

When was this video taken?

Great Video lostprophet786, many thanks!

Ali

[Hazzybollah]

our camera in hyderi really isn't clear at all lol

[sweetsingeruk]

neither is the man it's pointing at, Hazzybollah. lol

[Pinkflowers326]

al salamo 3alaykom....

jus wonderin-

when did this lecture take place?

..i'm guessing quite recently...?

thnx

[lostprophet786]

This lecture was given last year on Eid-e-Ghadir.

Alaykum Salaam.