Added: 4 years ago
From: ajruck
Views: 29,286
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (378)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • MAN DISNEY!!!! I DONT CARE WHAT ANY OF YOU SAY! (EVEN THOUGH SHE DOES SING HER OWN SONGS) THEY TAKE THE BEST PARTS AND EDIT IT! THATS WHY THEY HAVE MOVIE CLIPS SO REALLY! so there!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I MEAN I MAY NOT BE A FAN OF HER, BUT IM NOT GONNA SLAM HER!

  • YOU'RE SUCH A HORRIBLE PERSON! I LOOK UP TO VANESSA HUDGENS. I PLAN TO GROW UP AND TAKE NUDE PICS OF MYSELF AND DATE A TOTAL FAG.

    (If you haven't caught on to the fact that I'm not serious and Vanessa gets on my nerves, you need help.)

  • OMG nobody believes me!! Disney messed with everything....I'm going to link your video for those who don't believe me. Hope you don't mind, Ignorance is so not bliss.

  • if you didn't pay attention to the movie, "You are the music in me" was sung by the cast crew i.e Zac, Vanessa, Monique, Olesya, Kaycee, Corbin, Chris and Ryne!

    you're a lame critic.

  • lol the sky is blue

  • did u also notice when she jumped in the pool it wasnt her it was some one else

  • that's how it does... like every musical movie and music videos... yes they lipsync, but only for that... she sings live at her concerts.

  • But why would she do that? It's not like the part that was annonymous was hard or anything. & what if they edited her voice at those parts. lol

  • Oh wow..I never noticed...But I still love her! <3

  • dude u r ssooo right!!!

  • i think ur right shes lip sycning or watever most disney people do the now adays

  • omg! Who do you think you are? You have no idea how it works when they record music! They have so many takes...and take the best parts and stick it together. Ugh! You are so ridiculous and have no idea what your talking about!

    BWHAHAHAHAHA ;)

  • lol- I thought you were so serious at first...

    Ya. This video stirred quite a controversy when I first put it up, as the comments indicate, which is why I set it as private for a while to let things cool down a bit.

    I think the world is finally ready for it once again.

  • Oh Yeh Lol

  • I actually thought that when i first watched the movie. ThANKS FOR MAKING IT. I totally agree. It does sound weird.

  • hace you watch their rehearsal/recording of you are the music in me?maybe you don't,coz in that rehearsal/recording,the only 2 are singing,zac & vanessa,& no one else....

  • lair lair lair, I know she sang it all by herself, and you don't even know her number, It you do give it to me. Send me a message and I will call the number and be the judge of that. lair lair, quit hating on Vanessa!!!!!!!!!!!VANESSA HUDGENS ROXS!!!!!!!

    -xoxo-

    ~Vanessafan14

    Vanessa's BIGGEST fan ever and will always be/ obsessed with Baby V!

    p.s. she didn't call you back cuz she doesn't even know you. loser!!!!!!111

  • Let me guess... are you twelve?

  • Yay! I like it when Vanessa doesn't sing her parts! I don't like her!

  • HOw would you know her phone number. If some stranger called me at THREE IN THE MORNING i woould be scared and would not call back! And stop spreading rumors about someone who can sing!

  • That was a reference to Hillary's commercial. Maybe less Disney, more news, hmm?

  • I have noticed that the voice is different, but like Zac with Drew Seeley in the first movie, I think that Vanessa's voice was blended with another singer. At least Vanessa is still a good singer, not all good singers can reach some parts of the song with their voices.

  • actually it's the girl that plays kelsi. And while they are filming they lip sing. And then vannessa must of made a mistake of person!

    Boys sometimes have no brain...

  • ey yo,

    you missed one question mark,,

    at 1:25 it's not a long part, but i really believe she didn't sing it

  • But she doesn't sing everything in the songs with her. Same with Ashley and Zac too. When i listend to the kareoke versions with backup they are having alot of backup all the time. And the backup sings exactly like them; but just a litte better! I love Hsm, i love the cast. But that's true. Don't ask me how I know it. Have a good day everyone!

  • Um, loves you so much much right now.

  • omg u geek dont start lies and stop making fun of baby v u tech nerd

  • Seriously, she could've recorded two versions and they blended them!! Or she can just be singing lower!! Don't believe this guy!!

  • i don gett it??

  • hey ruck you are pretty cute

  • (part one) wo wo wo wo wo.....every body u have to listen close...wen she says "wen i hear my favorite song i knoe that we belong"that was the first time her actual picture was shown and wen the "fake vanessa" sings "and its brought us here because oh! u r the music in me" that was the first time the question box was shwn...

  • (part two) but if u listen carefully real real carefully wen the real vanessa sings"wen i hear my favorite song"is the exact same voice as the "fake vanessa" voice and wen the "fake vanessa sings"here...because" is the exact same voice as the real vanessa!!so she is really singing so that proof so that white person needs to shut the eef up and stop hateing!!(comment bakk to this piz i wanna knoe ur comments about my comment)

  • what does being white have anything to do with?

  • omfg u have got to be kinding me..u haterz umm try to sing urself ur voice changes tones....and that is her!!!!so u need to shut up..like in the first high school musical movie wen vanessa was singing wen there was me and u her voice changes but thats her voice...so stop hating u retared white boy

  • @zaclover9520 SHE IS NOT THE BEST SINGER. AND ACTUALLY I CAN SING BETTER THAN SHE CAN THANK U VERY MUCH! I DONT CARE. BUT IM NOT GONNA BE MEAN ABOUT IT THO.

  • @nika4507 0.O I DUNNO WHATS WRONG WITH YALL. GET A LIFE.

  • wow u r right she diesnt sing all the song!!

  • omg i hate her now

  • she just sings a deeper bit its still her! she doesnt sing in monotone u know that would be stupid and borrringg! anyway maybe she eat some chocolate before cos it makes ur voice go funny sometimes!!!

  • she does sing her own songs but she lip-syncs

  • that was really gd mab all the other people who said that stuff are high school musical obsessionist

    gd effort

  • i heard the difference, way to listen up, haha

    but yea its not another person, its disneys editing studio, because not everyones voice is perfect, so they edited her

  • hater!!! dude it is her listin to the voice it is just she is lip singing in song cuz the music is pre recorderd you idiot!!!

  • you guys are idiots they do sing their own songs you just hate them

  • Thats a lie!! The cast in high school musical DO sing their own songs. Plus i agree with fredfredsonbaby, it is babyish and stupid for a person of your age to watch a disney film so many times!

  • Your right vanessa sings the whole song he voice never changes.

  • zac efron admitted in Rolling Stone that disney wouldnt let him actually record any of the songs he sings in the movie, they were all sung by someone else

    at least in the first one

  • "So, after watching High School Musical 2 45 times," Okay, not trying to be rude but what grown man watches a disney movie meant for children 45 times?

  • it's a joke..

  • omg you are tres tres funny i love it!! love Hattie xxxxxx

  • wow that kool

  • the voice sounds compleatly differant than vannesas and vannesa's a idiot

  • Vanessa isn't an idiot It's her voice whether ulike it or not. U may think it sounds different because u don't like her.

  • don't worry they are haters stay strong and keep beliving in Baby V

  • pshhht....it is all vanessas singing ok? gee just cuz u dont like her dont make other ppl hate her too

  • you're creepy

  • I totally agree & I noticed that before. Kinda weird. Funny video.

    =]]

    Brooke*Ashley

  • LOL!!! Really funny!And I've noticed it too! The best part of the song it isn't her!!!

  • i noticed the same thing

    but i never thought it could've sung by someone else

  • wow

    i didnt even notice that.

  • you are so good i meen that is verry good to reconise that lol

  • its a different voice. you can tell she has a tone to her voice the other one is deffenately not her. but then zac never sang the songs either.

  • Ahh true dude.

  • "and yes the sky is blue"

    lmaoooooooo.

  • haaa lmao the was soo funny the sky is blue haha

  • it is different voise and sung by some one else

  • Whoa really?I guess some people don't sing their own songs.AND THE SKY'S BLUE!wow dude!

  • actually i think he's right!

  • this is stupid! She's just singing low cuz that's how the song goes!

  • Dude, singers voices vary from time to time.

    Get over it.

  • vanessa really sings!! her normal voice just cant reach that part because its too low thats why her voice seems different.....

  • =_=, wat a stupid video...they can use other singer or ppl to record this, if is true, y not someone tell vanessa hudgens to sing in front of us...(hav a concert)

  • Ur wrong ! She sings low and the recording use technique ! Thatz all =]

  • it would be understand if you made its actual video and discussed what is wrong in the music

  • i noticed too. I was waiting for someone to post a video like this. and all of u who don't believe. face the facts.

  • You guys all believe this!

    :S I don't believe it. Vanessa sang in HSM 1 all songs. &nd now not. She's such a good singer. &nd it like she don't sing it. But's that not right!

  • this happens cuz her voice is changing a lil bit...and cuz she sings more low cuz zac have a lower voice than her... so if she sang normally we couldn't her zac's voice (cuz she sings more higher)... so in some parts seems like is a voice of an "intruder"...

  • no b/c ur wrong because she sing low

  • ur totally,100% WRONG!!!!!!!!!!

  • ur right

  • but anyway ,

    HSM 2 still rocks for me :)

  • i know that !

    don't you think that it is weird when you listen to the song ?

    it kinda two voice !!

    same case as HSM 1

    Zac case !

    i felt wierd when he sing

    TWO VOICES !

  • omg listen to the acapella of "when there was me and you" you might want to hear that

  • where is that? I want to hear it.

  • LOL! i noticed this soo long ago

  • I'm a HSM fan but i think you really may be on to something, if its true and its leaked along with those pictures....woooo her career is GONE!

  • lol....in other news the sky is blue

  • funny

  • i noticed that in the movie too

  • an by the way ajruck u r coool

  • daa anyone can change his voice to fit to the song i notised the diffrent myself too but no one can judg her well she does : ) and i didn't say that cuz i like vanessa no i just love her voice >> an thanks ^_^

  • i have noticed that...but why would she sing a song and have other parts sung by someone else?

  • really?

  • ur right. also, in other parts of the song "you are the music in me", it sounds like a different person. when she sings "gotta go my own way", her voice doesnt change, tho.

  • I agree.. she sings Go My Own Way all by herself..

  • and its weird becuz in go my own way, there r even more high parts...

    u kno wut. i hate vanessa. period. i wont go ne further.

  • Well, she does sing all of her parts. That's for sure, but dude.... You were extremely proffesional about all that, and really good @ it too. You should be a narrarator, if u ever decide to do plays or something.

  • And in the concert her voice sounds WAY lower/deeper live than when recorded for the movies!

  • It's her singing, that's for sure. It's just that they record her like a million times until it's good and then they put all the best sung lines together, so she does sound different with every line she sings.

  • yeah, that's the true! but i love this video!

  • What the heck. Most broing video i ever saw. Of course vanessa is singing her own song!!!!!!!!!!!

  • IDIOT MAN

  • You could say it was funny but come on man, GET A LIFE

    we all know she does her own singing and clearly you do too, but you're joking about it because you don't have any other way to spend your time, pathetic if you ask me.

  • o ye

  • ok.... why would she sing only certain certain parts of the song? and I can change my voice when I sing. so I am sure any one else can.

    but this was pretty funny!

  • thats rite shes a fonie

  • your how old and your obsessed with high school musical?

  • it is her and uhmmm i like the video its like NEWS FLASH you know it good but she really sings her own stuff maybe you heard somebody else in it i can be so uhhmm good luck with finding out PEACE

  • WATCH THE REHEARSALS ITS HER R U STUPID

  • Haha, I thought I was imagining it too but when you listen to the songs over and over, it actually sounds like her sometimes and sometimes someone else.

  • It sounds nothing like her.

  • they sing thier own song u loser!!!!!!!!

  • Whatever stupid!!! They do too.

  • no it is not a trick!

    gah, she sings her own stuff. and if fans know anything about the first one you would know that the only reason zac didnt sing in it was cuz his voice was too deep so they had to use drew seeley. but i think since zac sang in the second one, vanessa could sing lower to harmonize with him. thats why it doesnt sound like her at some points.

  • OMG LOLOLOLOOLOL U COULD HEAR THE CHANGE!! but there is also the chance tht he ehanched her voice....

  • omg it realli sounds like a diff person!!

  • dude, thats V but when she goes lower it sounds like its other voice...i kow it's her...i know people closed to her,.

    the only one who didnt sing in HSM ORIGINAL was Zac and v n a part of when there was me and you (that's why in the concert in one part she has a back track)...peace out (:

    everyone did their own work in hsm2 :)

  • i think its true

    when she goes "OH YEAH!" before the whole crowd sings and when she goes "you are the music in.." right after it dont sound like her

  • stop judging people!why don't you try singing,dude?FYI she sings OPERA!

  • no she doesnt.

    her voice is never gonna be opera like

  • it is v!!

  • WELL DUHH she can't freakin singggg!!!! i hate her voice what were they thinking when the gave her a lead part ughhhh,yes i need to get over it but it's just so ughhh

  • i agree with you

    she sucks

    she has a whiny voice.

  • i totally agree!

    FINALLY

    i also hate hsm

    the only reason i saw this was to see her flaws and to have even MORE reasons to hate her and make fun of her!

    hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha­hahaaaaaa

  • omg i fort it were her :O

    n i love dat smile at the end XD

    im soo subscribing

    woo haha

    x

  • You are amazing. :D

  • she sings her own song my sister has the cd she listens to it all the time

  • hahaha, that's so funny! i thought that when i watched it. there are some bits later on too and it's CLEARLY NOT KELSI.

    i'm so subscribing! :)

  • oh...well, if she has ALBUMS she MUST do all her own singing!

    hahahaha, i love you obsessive hsm fans. so very very funny.

  • lol LIES LIES LIES LIES!!! hahahaha

  • have you guys heard the FIRST PART OF WHEN THERE WAS ME AND YOU that does not sound like her

  • there were some part of you are the music in me, I was like: is it Vanessa??? so i agree

  • omg i thought that she sang that!!! omg!!!

  • I noticed that too!!! But I didn't care know it's actually true

  • omg i think ther is a diffrent voice nooooooo

  • OMG that is SO true, the voice does completely change!!

    but it probably isn't because she couldn't sing them, they probs got in a singer last minute to fill in a few words because of some recording glitches and needed them perfected if you get me lol!

  • You're funny.

    OMG i totally agree with what you're saying!

  • yeah that other voice was heard really clearly. at first i was like "erm what happened to her voice"

  • HAhHAHA~ ohmgee! i cant take it anymore.u're UBER FUNNY! love your ending with a smile.:D

  • i noticed this too on this song, but i think it is more noticeable towards the end of the song when all the screaming is going on by them..

  • ur right! they are different voices

  • HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAA omg u must be a lonley! u need a gf or bf or sumtin lol

  • you're funny!! hahaha

    get a life!!

  • you are sooo cool can i email you!!!

    xxxx misk

  • yer i know they are totaly diferent voices but she has a great voice anyway and i noticed there is quite a few songs were her voice goes like that

  • youre right, those are completely different voices

  • yea Jessisatthedisco is right.. it is kelsi in the movie cuz at parts she was singing along and then letting gabriella/vanessa sing..

  • wow ok a lot of time on your hands but when i listen to it your right it doesnt sound like her great work!

  • wow get a life!

  • It's Actually Kelsi In The Movie But I Think You Might Need A Life Dude.

  • its called editing love :)

  • Yeah, I agree with people! Before you go your little "investigation", look on a hell lot of other shows/movies from Disney and you can here that it's edited. Vanessa has her own CD where it's 110 % her own voice and she doesn't need another person to do that for her. So just drop this and get yourself a better life, cause really. You're really really REALLY.. pathetic!

  • get a life.

  • Omg, do you have a life or what? Just because she sings low doesn't mean it isn't Vanessa singing. Btw you can hear that it is Vanessa.

    And before you say anything more, everyone knows that Disney edits their songs in the movie, haha !

  • dude like just because her voice got lower doesnt meen its an imposter

  • did it seriously take you 45 times to notice this?? i'm not sure if it's someone else or just vocal editing, but it's pretty obvious.

  • GET A LIFE! its called go watch the recording/rehearsel of hsm2 on this song. SHE DOES SING!!!!!!!!1

  • yeah I agree with you.. this man should get a life!

  • i know. he needs 2 watch the behind the scenes thing

  • hmmm, very good point....i think u mite be rite...

  • HAHAHAHAHA omg you're hilarious.

    i <333 vanessa hudgens but that's ok, i think it's true. ahahahaha you're so funny

  • That sounds like a totally different person from Vanessa

  • Aunque ella cante por que si canta alguien debe de hacer coros o "background voices" o tambien se le llama "guest voices" casi siempre son hechas por alguien con la voz mas aguda,y a veces estas voces invitadas deben acompañar a las voces principales durante la cancion para llegar a cierto tono, demas puede fingir la voz para hacerla asi,lo sé por experiencia, por lo tanto vanessa SI canta

  • jep ihan selvästi Vanessa ei itse laula, mutta nothing against her! :)

  • hahahaha

  • i know what you mean..also in the song everyday..in the beggining..she sounds really..weird =S

  • they lip sing in the movie but its really them they record in studios!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • omg! peoples voices change when they sign from high to low...

  • omg ppl shut up i did start thinkin that some parts her voice sounded deeper then usual buit right before the 'so is it all a trick" THAT WAS HER!!!!!!!!! and if some parts were sung by olesya why r those parts shown by NESSA lipsyncin them?

  • omg why would kelsie be singing those parts noone sings in the same tone all the time get a life!