Added: 2 years ago
From: IGNentertainment
Views: 138,827
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,248)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This was guy was right poke-fanboys.I have the game but I agree with everything he says.That doesn't mean however,I did not enjoy it(I honestly haven't played a Pokemon game do three years)

  • Lies! I love this game! it is not lazy animation! You can have legendary pokemon join your team, receive wondermail from passwords found on google, and become some really awesome pokemon. If you have explorers of time/darkness though, don't buy it, because there are only a few new features.

  • Can i save a friend from Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Explorers of Sky when i have Mystery Dungeon Explorers of Darkness?

  • I see, so they get the dumb ones to review the GOOD games, and the smarter ones to review other games, NOT working in their favor, i presume?

    This game got me emotionally attached to the characters, the Dungeon layouts were either short, or very long, but gave good items to help you out

    Spinda's Cafe is an awesome place, giving new dungeons to explore, possible eggs, and Reviver Seeds through giving them Escape orbs, VERY helpful i should say

    All in all, this is a terrible review of the game.

  • @sgrantle The people, including me, disagree with the review.

  • why the video has so many dislikes the game is good the reviewer is an assmouthy

  • @MrDany000 that was a guy? I thought it was a girl with a messed up throat.

  • I lost all hope in humanity after listening to this guy, but then I read the comments and my faith was back! :)

  • The new starters are : Phanpy, Riolu, Vulpix, Shinx and Eevee. -.-

  • "A lot of them suck". There's a purely journalistic viewpoint without any form of explanation at all. Way to go.

  • He said that there are only 2 new starters, Riolu and Phanpy. There are 4 new starters -.-

    They are Riolu, Phanpy, Vulpix and Eevee

  • Does this game allow you to get all the pokemon with one cartrage or do you need 2 copies and another friend with a ds?

  • @MF0TY Also they should really stop allowing hipsters to review their games.

  • @MF0TY play one try yo get all pokemon 440 more or less and search for the codes in google for the rest of the pokemon (code exclusive and so)

  • @sgrantle Thanks.

  • this game changed my life forever!!! how is it bad?

  • The guy who did this review should be shot… several times.

  • i just got the game!!!! SHIT

  • i will never look at ign the same way again...

  • This is my favorite pokemon game! I didn't even notice the "old school graphics", but the storyline was amazing!! But he's probably right about it not being much different than the other versions, I only have Explorers of Sky.

  • @CitrusJourney333 He is right. I have all of them so I know this, All the five games, now. It's a improvent from the other versions and atleast different enough to have a differentass tittle.

  • Comment removed

  • @YoshiKecleon978 Oh cool, I was thinking of buying another one!

  • Can't spell ignorant without IGN

  • @3raserAddict The ironic thing is, you're acting ignorant, by calling them ignorant because of their own opinion.

  • your a cod fanboy

  • FUCK YOU! BURN IN HELL! I HOPE YOU DIE SLOWLY!

  • 2:37 "There's no reason why there should have been 2 versions in the first place"

    There's no reason why you shouldn't have been an abortion you little shit.

  • Hell! This review is full of more bullshit than one of Adolf Hitler's anti-semi speeches!

    Absolutely disgraceful!

  • Comment removed

  • My reaction to the verdict:

    + New dungeons (...What did you expect?)

    + Special Episodes (Could be a double + if you ask me, they were great!)

    - Lame new stuff (What the- ...screw you stupid 12 year old.)

    - Same old game (You just said there was new stuff oh and what about Yellow, Crystal, Emerald and Platinum? Idiot.)

    - Not call of Duty (Typical IGN...)

    Unsubscribe

  • wow i read the full review on ign and in closing comments this retard who didnt hit puberty yet says "the only reason nintendo made a 3rd game to this series is because they know little kids will snatch it up" im 15 you biase fuck and this games one of the best games on the DS. you know what game has the "lame new stuff"?? Call of Duty multiplayer

  • this was posted on my birthday :D

  • WOW i was gonna miss out on playing this awsome game IGN your no HELP YOUR reviews are BULLSHIT!!!!

  • Yeash

  • Pls...go fuck yourself. This game has epic music, touching moments and it is a lot better than the two previous games. It is one of the best game ever, with it's storyline. Bias reviewers are bias. Fuck CoD. First person shooters games have no creativity. Fuck TGN, and buy this awesome game.

  • this game is amazing!

  • LISTEN YOU PEOPLE OF IGN!

    either work together as a team to review, OR! get fired, your choice

  • fuck you

    you really need to get a child to review childrens games not some brain dead american

  • "Lame new stuff". Being able to know the stories behind the guild doesn't seem lame to me.

    Graphics: Sprites! Sprites weren't supposed to be fancy, yet these still look good. And beside, this was made for the DS. Not one of your "fancy" home consoles.

    "Same old game": Let us see. CoD is all about shooting guys in the head. Now add a pathetic storyline and it's "good". Add realistic graphics and it's perfect. PMD is a simple game, with beautiful music, and touching moments. Graphics suck, "bad"

  • OOOOMMMMMGGGG I WOULD LAUGH IT I SEE ANYONE RANT OFF IGN!!!!!!!! PSSSHHHH I WILL DO THAT IN 2 WEEKS IF IGN KEEPS RANTING OFF GOOD GAMES!!!! SOO WHAT''S NEXT?? U GONNA RANT OFF SUPER MARIO?? CAUSE IF YOU DO I WILL HUNT YOU DOWN AND CARVE YOUR TUMMY LILE A JACK-O-LANTERN!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • One thing I would like to say is that this review is absolutely terrible! I loved the game. It had an amazing story and also had many dungeons that were difficult to complete such as the Zero Isles. I thought the extra side stories were very interesting and fun. Would you guys like to see a new mystery dungeon with the exact same graphics as in Explorers of sky, Blue Rescue Team, etc except with the dungeons in 3D on the 3DS? I ask because I love the way the graphics of the games already are

  • Sometimes i hate IGN and their bias reviews. It pisses me off when they diss such a fantastic game like this one for something as run of the mill as COD. You disappoint me prepubescent reviewer.

  • COD fans at work...

  • IGN can't make good review, They just look the bad stuff that can be easily ignored.

  • Im guessing THIS is why Nintendo hasn't released the Wii versions of Mystery Dungeon outside Japan. >:/

  • @gmtchilli07: this isnt a normal pokemon game its the mystery dungeons series you cant trade pokemon

  • looks like someone forgot to bring his x-ray specs to dungeons with pp zero traps

  • And on another note, it sometimes doesn't work out when Pokemon try to transition to 3D models. It just doesn't. Its better when they stick to sprite work, and the sprites are fantastic in the game. So again, aside from a few minor annoyances, this game is pretty perfect. About a 9.7, like I said before.

  • I personally found this game very satisfying, even more so since I never picked up either Time or Darkness before this came out. I really like the whole concept of "you never enter the same dungeon twice", and even though the story kinda had its ups and downs, I still enjoyed this game. I wouldn't give it a perfect 10, but I think I would settle this as about a 9.7. Only a few minor issues came up for me, and I still hate the "Ultimate Dungeon" concept they used, but it was still a great game.

  • and yeah maybe i do want to read a novel about bidoofs self asteem issues this video should be off youtube stop slagging of my faverout games IGN=FAIL

  • this is my faverout game screw you IGN worst review ever infact i might make a youtube account IGN sucks you diss nearly every game i like infact i might even make a campaign called IGN sucks IGN=FAIL

  • IGN=FAIL!!!!!!

  • ok well you did say something about the special episodes but you said its mostly cut scenes hah mostly all the last special episodes are dungeons and you say that the spinda cafe only gives you rare items ONLY these items can be really usefull to you i dont care what any of you think but im gonna spam this video with bad comments this review sucks IGN=FAIL

  • I also forgot to mention that IGN sucks and lies about everything do not listen to this game review and then you say you can make it through a dungeon on your own without help as a previous comment says try make it through zero isle without help P.S if you are not a girl then my name is IGN rules (when they suck ass)

  • worst explained review ever i mean you said there is only 2 new pokemon phampy and riolu LIES you know nothing about this game besides phampy and riolu the other new pokemon are shinx and vulpix also you did not mention aything about the new SPECIAL EPISODES in the game you are not writing anything about the good points like the story line is propably one of the best in gaming history the music is amazing same with the graphics how can you even say that it is just generally amazing DS graphics.

  • "Make it through a dungeon on your own"? Try the Zero Isles you idiot! You would be BEGGING that the stairs are right next to you!

  • If you hate the fucking new version then you should have never gotten the same first two versions to being with. I did that and i turned out very happy

  • This end story of this game makes me want to cry , to hell with IGN's review. Get it, you'll love it! That's my review!

  • Can you trade these pokemon on to other pokemon games like B/W SS/HG?

  • He rats on the game just because of Graphics? Dude? They are sprites and very good ones too, the maps, beatiful.. If you want polygonic pokemon models in your games, look at Pokemon Rumble! Not so satifying... Still a good game though. Like muskass06 said, no mention of Music, Story. IGN, remake this review with a person who can care less about SUPAH GRAPHICS and more on gameplay and story >_>

  • Did they just take a stab at graphics?

    And base the enitr review on that stab?

    Like...seriously?

  • Hey ign tell this bitch to stop reviewing pokemon games. get someone else to do it. Not this guy

  • 434 people are obsessed with cod and will probaly never play a good game in their lives

  • @TheMudkipman Or they're glad that IGN is reviewing a pokemon game instead of CoD.

  • Haha, lol Ign! Nice one. For a second there I thought you were calling the PMD games trash. Lmfao! If you were, I'd probably dislike this video and type a sarcastic comment or something... lol. Nice sense of humor.

  • Is this a guy? 

  • This is the most RETARDED review I ever fucking seen from IGN jesus fucking christ. Don't you understand this is has great plot? Great characters? That is what makes a game. Seriously it is not ALWAYS about graphics and shit. Yea sure if it the graphics was better it would look better, but if it has lower graphics so what?! Its sprites like original games fucking retards like Mario and Zelda. IGNorant assholes.... Fuck you im going to unsucribe and go to some good reviewers like angry Joe.

  • :Singing to Guild Music:

    This is aaaa Bullllshhhitt Reeeviiiieew!

  • A 4.9 sieriusly IGN wow!

  • wtf did u do u made my brother cry wtf man well he was almost crying he loves ign and mystery dungeon and now he hates u

  • They need to fire this reviewer. He makes GOOD games look bad.

  • @palindinX i now right

  • dont be a navgtr

  • My review for this guy:This guy probaly was given this game to review against his own will.he is probaly not a fan but should be a COD player.the length of the review itself shows how much effort he placed into this.and a 4.9 is only givn to games like... uhhh........ Personally the game deserves 8 for story,music, emotion.this is guy is just uhhhh.

  • so in conclusion...can some on here who's actually played the game and says that Sky is awesome like all the other mystery dungeon games i've played please tell me if Sky is good?

  • @shadowvampwolf It's great, but if you already have Explorers of time/darkness it's not really worth it.

  • @Muckass06 so its only good if you want to find out about the other character's story's etc right?

  • @shadowvampwolf Well, it has some other shizz as well, and it's definitely better than Explorers of Time/Darkness, so if you're a die hard fan or something get it. And yeah, the other characters' stories are cool and it adds more to the story. :)

    If you haven't played Explorers of Time/Darkness yet, or simply haven't played it in a while and want to replay it and experience the awesome story and stuff again, then I'd say get it. :)

  • Awesome feeling when you come back to your comment 3 weeks later and have 13 likes. Thanks guys :D

    I could spend ages telling you about all the crap this retard spewed out in this mediocre review, but I'd be wasting my time, they won't ever learn...

  • I have got to say I disagree with you on this review. Yes explorers of sky is not perfect but it is a dang good play. The special episodes are worth replaying the game and even if they were not this game is pretty fun to play either way. Also you don't need to grind levels all that much since due to the huge story that you did not mention you can easily get to level 60 if not higher in the main story. Also the plot twist found in this game was jawdropping and of course you left that out too.

  • this game is one of the best nintendo games i have ever played

  • You can go to options so you can make ur walk speed faster

  • WHO CARES ABOUT THE STUPID DIFFERENCES BETWEEN POKEMON TIME/DARKNESS AND SKY?!?!?!?! THE STORYLINE IS THE MOST IMPORTANT!! AND THE GRAPHICS ARE FINE!!

  • IGN's review of this game:

    Hi, I'm a gay ass 12 year old who wants to review a 13 hour game in 3 minutes. I only got up to Apple Woods, but I just want to assume that all dungeons are just like the first four. I haven't even played the game far enough to notice the significant changes that Sky offers from Darkness and Time. Now that I'm done with my half-ass review, I'm gonna go jack-off to COD just like all my other 11 year old friends.

    Verdict: 4.9 for no good reasons at all :D

  • @YoshiDude27 lol so true XD

  • @YoshiDude27 Can you just calm your balls down, wow. It's his own opinion on the fucking game. In my opinion PMD ExoTaD should of got a 9.0 I loved it. But you don't see me acting like an idiot on the internet, and thinking I'm smart with "good insults".

  • @iXavierTV

    You calm down bro, it was a joke. I know it was an opinion, but his opinion was based on the first couple of hours of the game and he failed to notice the difference between Explorers of Sky from Darkness.

    If you make a review or opinion, you need to get your facts straight. And you're the only one who didn't take this as a joke and instead thought that I was being serious, I think that you need to calm yourself and stop making yourself look like an idot on the internet XD

  • @YoshiDude27 I fucking hate sarcasm -_-

  • Okay, I heard the guide nook for this game is like 700 pages long so I went here to see what kind of game this is.

    Result: I learned nothing about this game.

    WTF? All this review did is crying like a baby how this version has no major improvements over the two old versions.

    Now I know why people hate IGN reviews.

  • are you kidding pmd was great! the plot was fantastic and it deserves a ten!

  • Ok someone grab me a nuke please. these amatures probly go by this

    "IF IT AINT COD OR HALO RELATED IT GETS A 5 ER LESS FER DA SCORE HERPA DER" no mention of the awsome storyline no mention of the amazeing soundtrack,no mention ANY of the awsome stuff that makes this game great.

  • @piplup10036 Agree.

  • I do not agree with this review at all. I've played this game for many hours now and i love it, the music and the plot are awesome. Even the graphic is ok. To rate this game a 4.9 must mean you either skip the story, haven't finished the game or just think about the graphics.

  • This fucking lady is a retard and sounds like a man

  • Wow, this is the worst review I've ever seen of this game. NO mention of the beautiful, and often touching music, NO mention of the incredible story that I'm not ashamed to admit made me cry the odd manly tear at times, NO.

    Instead, all they talk about are the graphics, saying they're lazy, they're NOT; they're SPRITES dumbass. What happens when Pokemon tries to use polygons? Crap, exactly. Also, these sprites are pretty beautiful and surprisingly detailed.

    Unsubscribed.

  • @Muckass06 you are awesome

  • @Muckass06 Yeah, but everyone gave it bad reviews..

  • @gayterdzsuck Who is everyone? Also, I'm fine with people disliking the game as long as they actually play it all the way through, mention the story, and don't claim the graphics are lazy for being sprites even though everyone knows that Pokemon + polygons nearly always equals trash.

  • @Muckass06 Why do you think that they play COD? to understand the story? no. They play it and review it well just so they can get all the cod fans to subscribe and keep them going, if they didnt upload their COD reviews IGN would be dead, which would be a good thing. Considering they rate the good games bad and the bad games good

  • @blarghblargh5 Good summary.

  • @Muckass06 The music is amazing! Plot :fun! IGNenterainment, go fuck youself!

  • @Muckass06  no its not whatch there reviw of micheal jakson the expirence

  • @Muckass06 i agree all of the games in this series have made me shed tears even though i know whats going to happen

  • want to know whats lazy for 3 minutes complaining when ign sould be praiseing. jerks :(

  • What the hell...

    This game is amazing... The storyline is fantastic, the gameplay is awesome, and the graphics aren't bad at all. Also, the special episode things are awesome.

  • I agree with other reviews but not this one.

  • I don't understand why people dislike IGN's reviews so much. They're trying to be honest. But I guess that's "ignorant" in your opinion.

  • @Shizakura34 Greetings sir! IGN is A FUCKING DOUCHEBAG right now. They are being lazy and not playing the whole game. They are just talking about the damned graphics and not concentrating the gameplay. I believe that this game is extremely addicting and I'm sticking with it right now. Playing in my 3DS and enjoying the emotional cutscenes that make me cry.

  • oh come on this game is awesome you can't dislike a game just because of its basically explorers of darkness with improvements and the music is awesome

    and wtf is wrong with the gameplay

  • "same old game" gee why don't they complain about cod then THEY HAVE BEEN GIVING US THE SAME SHIT FOR 4 YEARS well, you can't spell ignorant without IGN

  • Um, guys? PMD is my favorite part of the Pokemon franchise simply because of the story, but everything this guy said in the video is pretty true. The only to buy this game if you already have Time or Darkness is for the special episodes, which are pretty cool.

  • This is completely biased and what they're basing their final score on is just pathetic. "Same old game," you say? This wasn't used against the more recent review of Ocarina of Time 3D. "Lame new stuff" is also a very pitiful, childish thing to say, considering the "new stuff" included in other games they've favored was not even mentioned. Really, if you aren't going to say something worth listening to, rather than your biased hatred of Pokemon games, don't even review the game.

  • @Pippland Oops, I meant hypocritical. Still, the point is there.

  • Level grinding?You can go through the game normally and beat it T.T Not saying this is a bad game since i love it,but there is no level grinding like this guy said.

  • this game is the best pokemon game cause it actually has a good story. wtf 4.9? IGN is so bias about nintendo games like sonic and pokemon. so get off blackops and actually play games that are actually good.

  • @AvengedGames dude i couldnt agree with you more its like your in my mind, this gmes story is possibly one of my favirtes ever, i even cried at the end of the main game its that good, honestly play the game for what it is and dont just go on about flamin graphics all the time yeeesh

  • i like pokemon very much but these games look like crap.

  • @leafeondude Just try them out first.You will love them.

  • how old are you?

  • 4.9? You're kidding, right?! I understand that people can have their own opinions, but...

  • the only problem with explorers of the sky is the damned grudge traps. .__. especially if activated by a random trap which is worse.

  • the mystery dungeon series has the best storys of any pokemon game WTF really graphics give this game a 4.9

  • This guy is retarded

  • You sound like Ash.

  • What pisses me off is that people are going to see this review, and actually not buy a very good game! You clearly don't know what your talking about. Do you think it's a coincidence that you have more dislikes than likes?

  • i love how for the fps games it sounds like adults are reviewing. And for this game, it kind of sounds like a kid just starting his puberty is reviewing. I don't see how this game got such a low ranking -.- i bet this teen wanted to review COD but he was told to rev this instead :3

  • Description: "Put your money away."

    No thanks, this game already has my money.

  • how dare u say 4.9 out of ten even bidoof's novel of self esteem issues is better than listening to u

  • You rate this game as if it were an FPS game, are you that stupid? Take the 360 controller out of your ass and quit being a biased moron.

  • ME:hey mewtwo watch this

    MEWTWO:GIVE ME MY GUN

  • WHAT I LOVE THESE POKEMON SERIS HOW DARE U INSULT IT

  • There is no way im subscribing now that i heard that load of shit D: 4.9 rate oout of 10 my ass

  • two words FUCK YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • IGN you suck you don't know a thing about gaming and you are a retard to say that explorers of sky is bad

  • Comment removed

  • @ActionStar00 dude! chill out! its just an opinion! i think the game is cool too but is that any reason to flip out on him?

  • ... This guy likes dick -_-

  • Go to fucking hell you, pompous, self center, ass numbing, monkey jerking, uncaring, pokemon hating prick!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!

  • Unless you never got the games before psh... IGN logic only xbox and ps3

  • I loved this game! Great story! AND VERY ADDICTIVE!

  • Hey guess what IGN: FUCK YOU!!!

    this game is wayy better than your shitty fucking reiview says it is!!!

  • IGNORANT GAMING NOOBS!

  • there just pissed that this game has better graphics than cod.

  • U FUCKING ASSHOLE POKEMON MYSTERY DUNGEON EXPLORERS OF

    SKY IS EXTREMELY ADDICTING DONT GIVE A SHIT ABOUT GRAPHICS!!!!!! Why

    am I talking in caps? CAUSE I'M D***GA.

  • Just because it's a rehash doesn't make it a bad game, IMO. Super Mario Galaxy 2 was a rehash of 1, yet I still loved that game.

  • I own Explorers of Time, and I think it's an okay game. Is this better or worse?

  • So...should I buy this game before I go on my summer vacation? I dobt really like IGN reviews due to their reviews having like 22% of the review being good. So should I get this? (don't ask why I watch their reviews even if I don't like them, I just want to know their opinions.

  • wow all of you guys who are always cussing out IGN are real fucking idiots you know that? I actually loved explorers of darkness, I don't have explorers of sky but if I did I'd probably like it too. as much as I like explorers of darkness though I see why other people wouldn't like it so I don't cuss out the reviers of IGN just for giving their opinion about the freaking game. and besides, IT'S JUST A FUCKING GAME!!!! God damn I'm 16 years old and I'm more mature than you idiots

  • @AnimeFreak6781 Most of these "idiots" you mention are probably only about 12 years old, so I would cut them a little slack. :)

  • Well, I absolutely adore the game, I think they may be a tad overanalytical.

  • I know these guys are professionals, but explorers of sky is a really great game in my opinion; and there are a lot of new features that have been really helpful. but the one thing is that this game does talk ALOT.

  • i actually played this game to get through the story line

    this story was one of the best ones i ever faced

    suspence

    twist

    excitement

    sadness

    n many other feelings to keep u comn

    i dont think alot of games hav tht

  • damn i rely love this game

    but i can see why alot of people wouldnt like it

  • Whatever you sucker ... I love Mystery Dungeon games!!!

  • I think the reviews this sucks....fuck you IGN!!!YOU SUCK A DICK...

  • F**K YOU IGN!!!!! Pokemon Mystery Dungeon had one of THE BEST STORYLINES!!!!! I CRIED MY EYES out and you guy call this game a waste of money?!?! I love this game!! and charmander (my partner) (charmander.. (sob..)

  • shut up DURRR DURR CANT SPELL IGNORANT WITHOUT IGN

    ITS A COPY GAME IT DESERVES WHAT IT GOT BUT THIS GAME IS FUN.

  • Reveiws are not for everyone, it is just one persons thoughts. Sometimes, that one person was obviouly dropped on their head as a baby!

  • if this is so official then how come Pokémon is spelled Pokemon

  • The featured video is 9001 times better than this

  • IGN do you know how to do reviews? Where did you get this guy he doesn't know shit!

  • this sucks, IGN !!!!

  • you suck,asswipe

  • If you saw the full review, he says that the MUSIC sucks. Seriously, I laughed my ass off when I saw that.

  • OMG a 4.9?! IGNorant!!! IGNORANT I TELL YA!! THIS IS THE MOST POPULAR POKEMON GAME AT THE TIME!!! NOOBS!!! *******!!!! YOU ARE THE BIGGEST ****** MORON EVER!!! YOU SUCK!!! lemmie tell ya their initials decoded

    Ignorant

    Gaming

    Noobs

    See? remember this voice for the reveiw, if u hear this voice, ITS A BAD RATING!!

  • FAGGOT GET A NEW JOB YOU DON"T KNOW THE AWESOMENESS OF POKEMON!

  • Lol IGN failing at reviewing games.

    they score this badly yet they give the worst mario game in history a 10.

  • this review is bullshit

  • shut up............

  • Hey IGN get new reviewers

  • dude this reviewers nuts. this game is so great. for a cute pokemon game the story is amazing and in my opinion , very moving.