Added: 2 years ago
From: gamespot
Views: 107,182
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (566)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i need some one to play with on xbox 360 i will join a crew if you have one my xbox live gamer tag is smellyshroom just send me a msg

  • Comment removed

  • i love this game

  • BRING IT TO PS3 GODDAMIT

  • @Cbob972 yea no shit

  • Best world war 2 strategy game ever, except for company of heroes

  • @MrJimEvil What about R.U.S.E ? My favorite RTS of all time!

  • @Muticole Ruse is a great game an all but its just so satisfying to drop a bomb on enemy ship yourself.

  • is it 2 player local and can you pick what you want to do like to do like drive a plane or drive a sub

  • @kaza12345678 in signle player, you can sqitch between what you are given, example, (in thinking of the first one i havnt played this one) lets say near the end of the game, on a level, they give you 2 subs, a battle ship, 3 destroyers, and an air craft carrier , you can freely switch to whatever you want, also make planes and fly them off the carrier, when you stop controlling one and go to the other, the computer takes over for you

  • Does anybody know if there is a game like this that incorporates both the Atlantic and Pacific theaters of the war?

  • fuck u, youtube, i gotta study

  • @3Slim3Shady3

    Damn dude,that kinda talk requires determination.

  • @3Slim3Shady3 Love this comment

  • wich platforms are the game for?

  • @MrDeano324 You forget Starcraft :D

  • does anybody know if people still play ths game online?

  • @RandomBEARWITHaHAT Dudeeeee people still play midway the older version, im sure theres a ton of people who play this

  • @RandomBEARWITHaHAT i do on xbox

  • The USS Iowa class battleships and the IJN Yamoto class battleships were the most fearsome, biggest, bad-ass, of World war 2

  • Wait... The submarines missions are the most boring ones? Am I the only one who disagrees with him?

  • does this game have any offline replay value

  • @475kennedy yes it does

  • @hefletpakard Have you played Halo Wars, because i want another game like that because I am an offline gamer and I like RTS games

  • @475kennedy sorry never played halo wars

  • @hefletpakard O you select units but dont control them, just tell them where to go. But it hav the best campaign

  • @475kennedy

    I would highly recomend the Total War series on PC if you have a graphics card. They are the ultimate in War RTS games.

  • @MrDeano324 I cant play PC games. My internet, computer and everything else about it sucks

  • @475kennedy

    Ah what a shame mate. I think you would have enjoyed them. On Xbox there is the Command and Conquer series. But RTS's are not native to console gaming, therefore many devs chose the PC platform. But there are some on the market.

  • @MrDeano324 Ya it is. Its hard to find good RTS games for console

  • @MrDeano324 ya but boring after some time...I need a Total War game thats like...WW2. Like order of war but with medieval campaign control. That'd be awesome if done right

  • Mix this game with IL-2 Sturmovik 1946 and with Battlefield 1942= WIN

  • awesome game i hope they will make battlestations atlantic

  • Whats the plane at 5:29? it looks awesome!

  • @DoomWanderer it is a b-17 with a kamakasiee rocket they were only avalible at the far end of the war but they are still cool

  • Comment removed

  • @DoomWanderer I think it is a Mitsubishi G4M ''Betty'' carrying a Yokusuka MXY7 Ohka.

  • They should make a Battlestaions Gundam! That would be awesome!

  • Is this game worth it?

  • This was the biggest let down ever.. <.<

  • @sneakyrogues ok? how long did you play it..? 5 min or?

  • @kubel83 I tried playing it for 6 hours, never could get the controls down good, the missions were a drag, and the gameplay is much different than midway, and not even as realistic as midway.

  • "You must face the proper direction so there's also an important tactical element"

    Yeah that about sums up the amount of dumbing-down in Pacific.

  • Does anyone even play this online anymore?

  • Probably the most criminally underated game this generation.

    RIP Eidos Hungary.

    I traded mine for a new game soon after - a fucking fool I am.

  • can i get this on ps2 or computer and if so will it slow down my computer

  • @metalrulesforrever they don't make it for ps2 but they do have it for pc, its about 2 years old now so check your specs to see if your computer can handle it.

  • wooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!! Nakajima Floatplane!

    can they go in water and fly?

  • @jsplicer9 yes, they can, as well as the PBY Catalina, King Fisher, and 2 or 3 other seaplanes

  • A modern one would be cool

  • Haha, the japan voice actor did a great job!

  • Submarine missions are boring eh? Well, that's that realism u reviewers always bitch about, but when u get it, u bitch some more. Exactly why video games weren't made to be realistic, but if they are, cool.

  • Would be amazing if you could jump into any unit in a RTS game and controle it like this :D

    Would be a mix of Battlefield, Battlestations and World of tanks, and then just being an RTS you can play it as if it was any regular RTS, just the units you controlled in the moment would for example aim better or shoot faster..

  • Comment removed

  • Thats to bad the company went out of buisseness i really wanted a 3rd Battlestations!! Best game i have ever played!!!

  • I want to see The Kriegsmarine, Bismark and U-Boats FTW!

  • great game...would be prefect if you could play as infantry ;p

  • EPIC MISS AT 2:38

  • @stoogeofstooges1 EPIC fail @2:26 - that was torpedo!

  • go to 0:00 to skip ads

  • battle stations Atlantic would be awesome.

  • they need to make battlestations atlantic

  • @angel85555 dude that would suck so hard. you would get hit by a missle from a ship you couldnt even see or a stealth aircraft. None of that kick ass big artillery cannons stuff would be a match for anything. modern day naval warfare sucks ass.

  • @liamdudeeee uh FYI we refer to the present day as Modern...not the 1900s

  • @mothrabattra wtf are you on about? i said that this game but with modern ships would suck because its mostly all cruise missles and all that and none of that awesome artillary like in this game would be a match for missles. please point out where i said that the 1900s is modern.

  • @liamdudeeee You say artillery cannons wouldn't be a match for anything yet modern day warfare sucks...which one is it? how can how can you imply 1900s ships are weak but still better than modern ships? FYI, you need to fix your horrible grammar.

  • @mothrabattra once again, wtf are you on about? lets break this down so you can hopefully understand, although i have no idea why you don't understand in the first place. Someone said that modern naval warfare would make a good game like this one. So i said that it wouldn't because guided missiles shot from many many miles away would just suck and be boring as hell for a game compared to the kick ass artillery cannons that 1940s ships had. omg is it so hard to understand.

  • @liamdudeeee now you make sense, you should work on your grammar cause even one word can mess a whole sentence up.

  • this game begged to be PC only so it could fully make use of features like skirmish mode. just pick a map, pick your fleet and begin. kinda sucks that the campaign is the only way to have fun on it.

  • did the person playing this game at gamespot have downs or something?

  • how funny when the fat gamer sais battlefield hungary it sounds as if he sais battlefield hungry =3

  • dont forget about bismarcks sister ship Tirpitz.

  • Is this on ps3 if not its kinda stupid and its losing out on a lot of money

  • also they need to add in ground troops such as infantry and tanks to expand from the sea and skys as the land battles were still an important role in the pacicfic

  • Do you have to start and land on the carriers or is it just acton game that starts in the air ?

  • does anyone even play this anymore???

  • The US voice sounds almost British.

  • Why did they Dive Bomb with a torpedo?

  • this game is so awesome it laggs a bit of my laptop but it is okay nice game! :)

  • A bit slowly....? They're ships... Not bloody jet planes.

  • i havent got to play the new game i played the first battlestation game and that was bad ass

  • @kawasakikx250ff in battle stations midway i would often use the SDB as a fighter because i found it morre manuverable than the f4f haha

  • How about u all stop fighting and shutup canada is obviously best

  • @LeStereotype i think he means battles that took place on the pacific

  • the graphics are amazing. You can actually bomb the crew off the ships and see bodies flying

  • Does this game have a long campaign?

  • @UG0TP0WND yes and it is really fun, i recomend getting it, used copy at Eb games is only 27 bucks

  • @1234canadian1234

    Or spend 2hrs downloading it for free on BTtorrent

  • @bshaun2 ha it would be like 3 weeks and 1 broken computer with my computer

  • great review man. covered pretty much everything i was looking for A+

  • Squre enix has shut down the developer so more games are unlikely unless another developer or publisher buys the rights to battlestations. A battlestations Europe would be awesom though

  • Battlestations needs a game in the European theatre. The Rotal Navy was the best navy of the era and it's barley represented. Also the German navy was very strong with ships such as the Bismark and Graff spee. And the prospect of re enacting the battle between Hood and Bismark would be awsome.

  • @MrDeano324 The US pacific fleet was the largest and most effect fleet in the world at the end of the world, bub. No offense. Dozens of aircraft carriers made up the core. Somewhere close to 50 attacked Okinawa.

  • @pizzamovies hestalking about between 1939-1943 the RN was much more superior to the USN, after the war many carriers in the USN were sold or scrapped, not the super carriers tho

  • @1234canadian1234

    Thanks for putting another overley patriotic and non factual american straight.

  • @MrDeano324 the taranto harbor attack would be fun to play, the Brits got the idea from the pearl harbour attack, also providing support for commandos raiding the norweigen coast, convoys, and being the first sub to hit another sub with a torpedo. they could also have allied bombing campaigns and battle of britian, and i think they should have an alternate German campaign where Nazi Germany defeats Britian (Hittler could conquer then North Africa) and Russia and later conquers China with Japan.

  • @1234canadian1234

    Exactly my point. This game needs to be taken to the european theartre to expand the franchise. The only problem with your idea of an alternate nazi campaign is that eventually it would have to take you to the pacific because Hitler wanted to take over the world. And if he had already Taken G.B, China, USSR and N.Africa as you say..why would he stop there insted of invading the U.S and Canada. Hence the crossing of european and pacific theatres.

  • @MrDeano324 it would stretch supply lines really far and the americans and us canadians would build subs just like they did, and its strange how close hitler was to winning the war, he was bombinb britains airfeilds and factorys and they were so close to losing but then they bombed berlin and hitler started bombing london,dumb nazi he was so close

  • @1234canadian1234 well hitler started bombing british cities after 6 months of permanent british bomb raids on german civillian cities, churchill wanted to make the british hate the germans so he could continue war even though germany had offered many times a peace offer.

    when the uk declared war on germany they were the biggest empire in the world, when ww2 was over the uk was bancrupt and ended as a tiny little country with almost no influence, the usa und soviets got superpowers.

  • @MrDeano324 the reason they dont feature the royal navy its because it did not evolve strongly into carrier warfare wich was the future of naval warfare

  • @MrDeano324 battlestations atlantic

  • @MrDeano324 soviet navy could be interesting too

  • @MrDeano324 Sadly the studio that made this game was shut down

  • @griz312 And the DLC is still expensive! Should be free since the devs won't get a cut. MS and Sony probably get all of the profits from the DLC.

  • @bandofbrothersmovie I did not know that, I dont have a microsoft account but i dont think sony has any rights to this game but yeah that is pretty dumb.

  • @MrDeano324

    lol so British campaign: your ship insta-dies. The rest of the game you get to fly a biplane that goes 80 mph.

    German campaign: you insta-win vs Hood, then for the rest of the campaign get chased by airplanes and then you push the button that sinks your own ship.

    German campaign bonus mission: Tirpitz. you spend all game sitting in port and watch while the British try to bomb/ sabotage/ sink your ship.

  • @MrDeano324

    oh forgot. the tutorial for the german campaign is the graff spee, where you learn how to use the scuttle button you later need for the Bismark level

  • @MrDeano324 we dont know.. maybe theyre still working on it .. hoping ..

  • @MrDeano324 you do know the Bismark was pretty much handicapped by a torpedo then the hood just destroyed like a fat kid destroys cake.

  • @hihi1043

    Hood was sunk by Bismark in the Battle of the Denmark Strait. HMS Hood was long gone by the time Bismark was sunk by British sword fish bi-planes off the coast of France. Your comment is a little historically inaccurate.

  • @MrDeano324 most have my ships mix up or something I know it was handicapped by a torpedo but what did the final blow?

  • @hihi1043

    Yeah your a little confused it would appear. British ww1 era swordfish bi-planes started the final attack on Bismark. One of the Swordfish's torpedo's hit Bismarks rudder and she was unnable to turn. German Admiral Lütjens sent a message to Berlin stating "Ship unmaneuverable. We will fight to the last shell, Long live the Fuhrer." As this happened, HMS's King George IV, Rodney, Norfolk and Dorsetshire closed on the crippled Bismarck and delivered the killing blow.

  • @MrDeano324 the swordfish was not from ww1 it first flew in 1934, lots of people assume all biplanes were made in WW1 this is wrong

  • @hihi1043

    Hey mate, just found this. Thought you might be interested. Just type this in YT and it should be the first vid down....

    Dogfights: "Sink the Bismarck" 1 of 5

  • Guys can anyone help me please i have a problem when trying to access multiplayer. There are no servers available. I tried to do so many different things but nothing seemed to give me any servers. It's hard to believe that no one would be playing this game. what am I doing wrong?? thanks in advance

  • @daliborplecas idk what your doing wrong when ever i enter the games theres like 20 servers

  • @daliborplecas mate i have the exact same problem i honestly dont no

  • @daliborplecas usually when that happens it's a firewall issue. make sure that the channel that the game is going through is not blocked :)

  • guys do i need live to launch the game? because i launch the game, press home, and the thing pops up, i sign in, but how do i actually PLAY the game? (ATI Radeon 9800 PRO, and 1GB of RAM :\) but im getting more RAM and a new video card sometime this week i think, but yea how do i actually play the game

  • At 1:43 why does that carrier have no control tower?

  • @251rocker Its an escort carrier. Most escort carriers or light carriers in World War II have no control towers :)

  • @Jackie68450 Oh Than how was it controlled?

  • @251rocker well, I guess it must have a bridge somewhere...... ;)

  • 5:45 YES! Planes to have explosives! lol

  • omg if have to see another one of these "buttershoes" commercials, I am gonna go apeshit

  • Does the aircraft carrier at 1:59 have artillery? If it is It would be nice to use against the pesky little destroyers if they broke threw defenses like in BS Midway MP.

  • who cares about history i just want to mount a yamato ship and search and destroy.....

  • @12ock i read somewhere u can download a super yamato with like 22-24 inch guns instead of 18 inch

  • This game is one of the best games I've played on the 360. It's mighty.

  • if this game was on ps3 i would get it

  • This or Naval assault ? hmmm

  • @JoEjOhSoN2fAn get bs pacific it is terrific unlike that stupis naval assault game

  • @TheShadowbanisher ok, thanks for that 

  • xr(DOT)com/pgkl

  • Agree with the voice acting comment. I mean, they're not really bad. The game talking is okay but the story mode voices (characters linked to story) are just retarded.

  • hello.....I have a Question...How to save game and anyone have the product key for windows live

  • what net for the battlestations franchise????

  • @vegitibles Something like Battlestations Europe would be nice. Midway and Pacific both cover the Pacific theater & have similar aircraft associated with them. There are other WWII combat sims out, but they're either soldier FPS or fighter planes (which I have no problem with fighter plane part), but the opportunity to multi-platformed in the European theater would be nice...especially if it added some ground warfare with tank play. Not to mention sub warfare possibilities. Would be nice.

  • This seems like a great game, to bad online play won't work anymore since Edios Hungary is being shutdown. I woulda loved to spam destroyers and torpedoes.

  • looks pretty cool. i was thinking bout buying this game. now i think i will =]

  • im getting this soon, and aside from the terrible voicing, it looks like its everything i hope it will be

  • 2 questions

    Is this game good for people who like strategy games? (Like me)

    Can you play multiplayer like fighting AI's when your not online?

    Thanks

  • @spartan5536 yeah its a good strategy game and you can play without being online.

    Only thing that is a problem is that the online wont work but outside that its still a great game to play :)

  • @AlexSaysHi2013

    The company, Edios Hungary, which makes this series, was shut down a few months back. There parent company said they couldn't win in the RTS genre, so no more battlestations games ever again :( very sad.

  • @thejoshknight theyre working on kane&lynch right now

  • awesome review i can't wait for the next game from this series and this developer!

  • the only thing i dont like on dis game is that the pple walking around the ship arnt running around or dying lol

  • Hell yea i remember year ago i was playing midway demo now im looking for that ;d i hope it will works and it will be gr8 game like previous

  • is this game on PC or just xbox?

  • @Simmo8536 Both

  • Man, I thought this game was like one of those "game-board" conversions. I'll be on the lookout for this one . I like the multi action concept.

  • if you like a game where you can control units and armies download toy soldiers for xbox 360 (1200 microsoft points)

  • do you think this game is worth $30?

  • @SteelBeWithYou i myself would like better a battlestation eastern front :D

  • Gspot rules!!!!! XD(not that gspot )

  • 2:26 WTF is that! Ha haha

  • haha nice

  • good game..at first i had no clue what to do.

  • The voice - over ain't too bad, but I completed the U.S. and Japanese campaign in about 6 Hours, so more missions needed. I'm already finding myself bored with the units, more units, more maps and more missions. Over - all brilliant game, good job!

  • is there anyway to download the mustang pack without xbox 360?  really could use some help.

  • I know that this doesn't have much to do with this video, but I need help with saving the game. Whenever I complete a mission and I have to go, I just hit quit mission and then exit from the main screen. The problem that I am having is that when I open battlestations pacific again, all my progress is lost! How do I keep my progress saved when I exit the game? PLEASE HELP!

  • Eidos Hungary is being closed:(. R.I.P Battlestations

  • @davidkaaa Nooooooooooo they can not end BattleStations R.I.P

  • this game was ok but i prefer Heroes of the pacific I found more enjoyable. I hate how the plane for no reason keeps stalling on me making it frustrating. Unless I'm doing barrol rolls or climbing strait up, I should have to deal with a stalling engine. The online was pretty fun tho but I only found one person to verse. this game could use some improvement but other wise good.

  • @Lightingbolt008 were you using spitfire? if so that is why the engine stalls. The spitfire had a carb and that was its biggest flaw

  • a game with awsome AI? i must be dreaming

  • No. It sucks compared to Midway.

  • bull midway was complete shit even the creators say that

  • @ssgkillsuall Yeah, okay, whatever, I bet they did.

    Midway was great.

  • Yes buy the unit and the two map packs it's worth the money all you need is a 1600 point card ($20) and you will still have left ofer points

  • I own this on xbox 360 and I was wondering shoud I download the carriers battle map pack?