110420 [HQ] 아이유(IU) - 거위의 꿈(A Goose's Dream) Live

[SaltnSour]

Please don't compare which one is better, they all sand beautifully <3

I love how IU sang it, I love how Hyorin sang it, I love how Suzy and EunJung sang it <3

[trangxjnh919]

The only part I dislike about Hyorin's cover is that she has such a low start, but obviously you can see in the chorus HYORIN is clearly better than IU here. I'm not being offensive since I'm an IU's fan, but the song chorus by IU isn't that good as Hyorin.

[kimhaejin1]

I got goosebumps! I nearly cried!

[rosey9cheeks]

i liked hyorin's version. but she's good as well. i love both of them :) and saying that hyorin's ver. have no emotions? bias much? both have amazing voices and great emotions when singing this song, but for me hyorin's version is just pure goosebumps. :)

[Thunsit]

its like she try so hard to keep stable on high note

[xxnorcalchickxx]

In my opinion, we shouldn't compare IU with Hyorin or vice versa because both of them have different styles of singing. I think IU=soothing and beautiful while Hyorin=fierce and charismatic. Either way, love them both! :) Plus Insooni's voice is gorgeous in this song. All of them can portray emotion through this song very well.

[MrMegahermawan]

Goosebumps with the low notes at 0:33

AMAZING

Never expected that she could reach the note after hearing her high notes several times.

[MsBunny1918]

I really love this song <3

[chrislovebabyforever]

IU sing any song also nice <3

[ochrehelios]

IU has more depth on emotions - that's why it's better than other covers. Also, IU sang this on open field which is actually hard for singers. I like Hyorin's version but it was too plain and has no own trademark but still, it's good..

IU's voice is very Asian and Hyorin's is very western. They will both succeed but will never share the same stage without one having being overpowered, either intentionally or not....

[lollipop4541]

Hyorin sing this song is more powerful than IU but IU's voie is still so good

[zweiosterei]

Hyorin >>>>>>>>>>>>> IU.

[equinocs12345]

IU please sing more ballads.

[ariannekic]

Of all the ladies who sang this, Insooni's version is still my favorite. Somehow, to me, the song is so much more meanigful when Insooni sings it.

[hyd081283]

i hate it when someone saying this version is better than Hyorin's version is pretty dumb stupid.

[AjhussMD]

I like this version of A Goose's Dream but saying Hyorin sung this song with no emotion is really bias of IU :D

[ajjuma31]

she has a great voice..

[Ireallyhatethepolice]

she seems fell off

[miiiChAnn]

iu is really cute waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[dahkneee]

I mean.. I might could say IU has a bit more emotion's when singing this song.. but how can people say that Hyorin had NO emotion's when she sang this song? That's ridiculous lol.

[sofiaelfspirit]

Hyorin might have a stronger voice but she has no emotions. she just sings without actually feeling the song. (those emotional faces she so hard tries to make don't count) that is why i prefer IU. she feels the song and beautifully expresses the meaning of it. and her voice is amazing and unique too.

[akarolinada]

Hyolin, Suzy 'n Eunjung are better in this music '-' But I also like IU's voice :D

[floxsakura]

Hyorin may have a very powerful voice but when she sang this song, I couldn't feel any emotions at all, there was no feeling... I like IU's version this time. But I think that these two young singers are true amazing singers.. ^^ stop comparing please

[pandapark98]

IU is so IUloveable

[kaycee0122]

Davichi brought me here. IU is just beautiful when she sings so much emotional :)

DAVICHI & IU <3333

[oeechiza]

I love both IU and hyorin but I think hyorin kinda did better 

[honeybb1314]

the reason why iu is so famous is because her singing can touch your heart. Not that many singers can sing like this. So stop comparing her to hyroin or the A pink vocal. you cant compare with them because they have different style

[aminahmohdyusof]

in my opinion iu is a lot better than hyorin

[letgocomeon]

I can't stop hitting repeat. Damn her voice is sooooo amazing!

[letgocomeon]

The way she sang this song,it really touched people's heart. It's a nice feeling ^_^

[xroyalfashionistax]

when compared to SISTAR hyorin , they are bout the same , but iu needs to improve on her breathing techniques especially on high notes. she shouldn breathe until it makes a "high" sound come out, unlike hyorin . u can hear the difference

[luna44866]

esta cancion es hermosa me gusta

[32mina]

내가볼땐 별로내요.. 저음부분은 확실히 못하내..지루할 정도로...부드럽게 고음 치고 올라가는 기술은 좋은데 고음내는부분도 진성이 안돼니까 가성으로 만들어 치는듯...

만들어진 목소리 ..별로임

[allkime]

HERMOSA VOZ!!!!!

[girlkidrauhl]

Such a beautiful voicee.

[amintut]

IU sings through heart. <3

[Z4Amie]

I bet if IU was in JYPE, Woohyung would be the happiest person alive. LOL

[KazuuuX3]

So beautiful... TT___TT I love this song, and this performance is so good. IU's voice is amazing, and she's so pretty... She's really the best!!! IU Jjang!!!

[KaNeaTieS]

that is perfect ~♥

[xXNatTashaXx]

This was not her best.. Her high notes were shaky. But then, overall quite nice. :)

[iloveukiss22]

Getting goosebumps watching this video

IU is really good ..

[mindszii]

handstanding...

[junjouBLlover]

1:46 till the end, never heard her sang like this before! AWESOMNESS!

[junjouBLlover]

Love the way she sings it!! :D

[mySTYLEisJ]

i don't really care about comparing IU and Hyorin. Both are great singers. full stop~ Hyorin is my idol and IU can be my role model~ :)

[Lizz1234321]

I really like IU's voice. Yes, i've watched the Hyorin version, but hey. All you people out there saying that Hyorin's version is better than IU's in my opinion, the two both have different singing styles. While IU's is mellow Hyorin's is powerful. I don't think either beat each other out because I think that both of them are awesome at their own styles.

[M4gicb00ster]

It looks like she's crying XD

[Habs4ever74]

Omfg IU unnie saranghae <3

In love with your voice

[0225benz]

I like IU than Hyorin. she's good.

[Chii471]

IN UR FACE, JYP !!! IN YOUR FACE !!!

[maosd]

this is the worst stage I've watched from her, I think she wasn't feeling well that day or something, because her other stages are great!! so guys stop bashing on her

[enriin16]

omg! i love her voice!

[jujubee061097]

I think IU should've done the sign language together with the rest. Lille how insooni does it:)

[bogey666]

very brittle voice compared to insooni's. Simon Cowell would call it something he heard at a lounge or Karaoke.

[mayenchaii47]

At first I didn't like her but after reading all the comments I guess you guys are right. :7

[anaja001]

Well, it maybe wasn't her best stage and her high notes were a little unsteady, but DAMN, how did she reached those low notes at the beginning? o.O I mean, it's really low, even Hyorin couldn't reach them...

[90829058]

@anaja001 hyorin's version was set in a different pitch. it was quite a few semi tones lower than IU's ver so hyorin's low noted are way lower than IU's. in my opinion though, both are the best singer i've seen in all these kpop :)

[anaja001]

@90829058 Oh, you're right, I didn't notice...

Well, I really respect Hyorin as a singer but I personally prefer IU's voice- it's more pleasant to hear for me. :D

[nurule713]

are they mute or something?? i mean with their hand

[WheresLiLi]

no feelings.

[TheGamer32121]

how does someone like iu have haters.. Oh well i guess haters gonna hate

[yadimaknae5]

@TheGamer32121

simple iu haters is:

1. girls who jealous because iu duet with many famaous male singer

2. fanatic fan from iu rival

any idea?

[TheGamer32121]

@yadimaknae5  didnt like iu that much but after i watched dream high shes one of my favourite idols :D.

[ShengGuanSG]

Amazing voice plus super cute face :D IU Fighting !! :D

[Aibok]

what's up with that caucasian at the back :D

[butterflyprincess161]

whisnisna bueatiful song!! :)

[AKATLOS]

아이유 화이팅이다

[lahmiest]

IU is talented yet overrated...

[dharmaprincessf4]

저 벽이 아니라~ 그벽아닌가?ㅋㅋㅋ 그래도 이쁘고 노래 잘한다~^_^

[keroppicake]

omg..goosebumps! i feel like crying right now! thats so beautiful!

[MrsSancis]

wow, they back talk deaf sign hands, pretty :)

[lijuree]

her voice is not professional. high notes are very band. May our poor IU was tired. oh...........

[TheJasmine1219]

너무 이쁘고 잘한다, 아이유

[darrendelong]

she should go into ballads more....dancing pop songs doesn't show her great vocals..

[MrMugetsuu]

Don't compare, IU and Hyorin have distinctly different singing styles.

Both are awesome, it's a matter of preference

[memetian1]

@MrMugetsuu no need 2 compare d..............sohyang is still the best in performing this song.............

[yadimaknae5]

i think iu more better in low tone 0:24 - 1:44

[MisoSouped]

@yadimaknae5 That's because iu sang a higher pitched version of the song -_-

[CathzPie98]

@MusicLuv80 but JYP also produced solo singers like joo or San-e not only groups

[mangoliamable1]

Awww, IU looks so damn cute here, and hell, she is so talented. I am sooooooo jealous... IU <3

[tingtingshoujo]

IU good always！

[JTam2222]

my favorate cover ^^ isooni must be proud

[LMAOoutloud]

hmm... now that i give this another listen, i realize that IU sings the verses a bit better, while hyorin is more fit for the strong chorus. their different voices suit different things.

[inazumafan95]

IU es la mejor k otras solitas

[hycho8925]

i disagree. If IU went to JYP, she would have become a LOT diffferent... less singing, SO MUCH different concept. I love her concept now.. I dont wanna see her doing goodbye baby or Tell me

[munkee312]

IU can really touch your heart not like a lot of other idols so that's why she's so good. If you listen to her ballads she expresses sadness so well while Hyorin kinda jst sings it...Hyorin IS good too though.

[MurphyMapPhi]

Well, I don't think Tae Yeon or Hyorin is as good as IU :)

[peachblossomnice]

The end part of this song, I think Taeyeon made it better than IU.

[vietaustin6]

IU is soo pretty <333

[emsterthefirst]

1:12 nearly made me tear up

[gebonizascruge]

@emsterthefirst i knoww righhtttt!! me tooo!!!!!!!

[mickey5julia]

@shootingstars357 it's a sign language it think... for deaf ppl

[shootingstars357]

this key is too low for her!! what are the stupid backstage ppl doing not matching the key to the key that IU is!!!! which is really high!!!!!!!! :(((((

[NovemberSK]

@katielfspirit i means that the song like Good day,Someday accord with her, i think she can does well the Cute style. "she is an amazing singer"...Ok i dont said she isnt amazing. But Hyorin and Taeyeon can do well everystyle, their voices make me enjoy with their performs. I love IU, too. But this is a "A Goose's Dream", a famous ballad song, her skill is OK , but emotions isnt enough :). If we love anyone, we should know and recognize their strong point and weak point.

[NovemberSK]

@katielfspirit i means that the song like Good day,Someday accord with her, i think she can does well the Cute style. "she is an amazing singer"...Ok i dont said she isnt amazing. But Hyorin and Taeyeon can do well everystyle, their voice make me enjoy with her perform. I love IU, too. But this is a "A Goose's Dream", a famous ballad song, her skill is OK , but emotions isnt enough :). If we love anyone, we should know and recognize their strong point and weak point.

[93nenita]

@NovemberSK lol at the thought of hyorin singing a cutesy song like iu's marshmellow or boo she can pull off a lot of styles but not every style and they've got different voices what use is it comparing its like comparing a dog and a cat at running...

[NovemberSK]

@93nenita haha Hyorin can does well more style than IU, except cute (but i'm not sure, i'm not see yet), TaeYeon like that, except Rap she can does well almost stye and IU... just cute. But don't worry, IU's still famous, i just compare their true competence.

[MurphyMapPhi]

@NovemberSK IU is not just cute :) It just you haven't listened to every of her song :)

[AleiatheEnchanted]

lolz @ 1:19 she cleared her throat while the mic was near her mouth....

[NovemberSK]

I'm not bashing IU but IU never has something like Hyorin,TaeYeon's voice....Although she's 17,18 or 22 23 :( I'm not heard Hyorin sing when she's 17 but i heard TaeYeon. For me, someone like Hyorin and Taeyeon, they were borned to be a singer, their voice so touch.

IU have a beautiful voice,too. But it's so shine, so cute. Sometime she's sing a ballad or sad song, she try to sing sadly but it isn't touching although she sing well. Anyw, the songs like Goodday is for her :)

[rebornz123]

im IU's big fan but anyway Hyorin sings better :)

[kianneis13]

ippeo!

[KIKYOTHEBEST]

IU has a great voice but she is vry humble~

LIKE HER~ ^.^

[sussanaweljones]

beautiful.

[snippen1]

Every new video i watch with IU i just get amazed how beautiful she is, if i would describe the look of my dream girl she would look like this <3

[hyejinchoii]

wow just remembered that she was actually really good at singing :)

[jeopardyify]

anyone seen davichi version?



[EnigmaSoul024]

i must admit, hyorin's version of this song is more powerful but we have to realize that it had a lot to do with hyorin and iu's singing styles... i personally liked iu's version as well... it was like a more mellow rendition...

[farahpopsicle]

I really really LOVE IU!!!

[fobbiyo]

Yeah, she can get better and not everyone is perfect but I personally thought she did this song some justice. She is a really good singer and she has time to grow and get better.

[kokowillie]

AMAZING !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[happybunnyfan7]

I bet JYP was really angry and sad that he couldn't get her because of the stupid judges while watching this. I wonder what happened to the judge who turned her down.....what a sad life he is leading right now....

[mansyur1234]

@happybunnyfan7 i bet JYP would said "why when IU was auditon not gave the best performance"

[Jelliio]

@happybunnyfan7

JYP fired the person who rejected her, so he was definitely angry~ :]

IU's voice is amazing~

[Rainityy]

@Jelliio He really fired her? o_o

[Jelliio]

@Rainityy

i'm not too sure but i read somewhere that he fired that person

[smilegurl3]

@Jelliio eh? how do you know? was it in an article?

[Jelliio]

@smilegurl3

oh, the article was on allkpop and i just read it again (because i saw it last year or so)

he was just really angry about it and he did think about firing the person.

sorry for the misunderstanding ><

[smilegurl3]

@Jelliio thanks for the clarification

[MyLuckyV]

@Jelliio wait... what is this about?

[omodaebak]

@Jelliio Really? He really did that? wow He must be very furious that time ><

[MusicLuv80]

@happybunnyfan7 I am actually happy that she didn't go into JYP because they might've made her train for another 5 years and put her into a girl group....  maybe ~~~

[ngonhuuyen2812]

@happybunnyfan7 : can you tell me what happen between JYP and IU????

[joannesong]

@ngonhuuyen2812

iu auditioned for jype, but she got rejected. he wasn't there for her audition though. someone already mentioned this but, he was asked how he felt knowing he turned down such a talented singer. he jokingly said that he was going to fire the person who rejected her

[daewonchung]

@happybunnyfan7 I think although the judge didn't turn her down, JYP would reject her at the final stage. JYP is also stupid enough.

[xpurpleloveattackx]

@happybunnyfan7 hahaha actually some interviewer asked jyp that question like regarding iu auditioning and being rejected by jype

and he jokingly said something about the person who rejected iu not working with jype anymore LOL and that he wishes that he could go back and accept her or something along the lines of thattt :)

[TheGamer32121]

@happybunnyfan7 wait why couldnt jyp get iu?

[milafanway1]

I'M ONLY SAY I LOVE IU!! SOMEONE MORE?¿ THUMBS UP IF YOU LOVE HER MORE AND MORE EVERYDAY!!

[Nasyiq91]

@95mk1 i agree.she's undeniably talented,with her vocal range etc,but she lacks something to be in a powerhouse line-up.

stil,i like her voice in bubbly songs.personally,dat suits her most.

[heyyitsmimihsu]

i just remembered that someone was singing this in the korean concert in ny :O forgot who...

[MaJoGuMiHo]

sentí su voz apretada...sentí la emoción en su canto :D y aún así, mantuvo su preciosa voz ^^

[samsungisahottie]

@musicallheart2 There's nothing wrong with trying too hard though...

[Phinaellia]

I like's IU's singing, but she can't beat Hyorin from Sistar.

[valentina1227]

check out davichi's version..its really good. iu is soo cute and talented

[devilmyday]

omg it made me cry at 1:11.. to think that an man like him so supportive in a song like this.. making those hand movements with the other ppl on stage.. it jus made me cry.. *sniff sniff*

[fxSHINee]

so young, and yet so unbelievably talented.

she also looks extra pretty in this video.

i also think her voice sounds more mature with this song.

[KoshiroEmika]

she strived hard and she got there <3

she can put her emotions into this song and make it sound so much better than anyone else <3

[yulsic91]

GooseBumps !!

[mariasukuiyf]

I like this. Wish i can sing

[Vamwolfang]

shes so beautiful talented.. she my dream girl :) but as everyone knows shell never be with me :'(

[musicluva42500]

she looks really mature in this vid ;D

[KiMO3z]

Ahe has an angelic voice! i love her 

[melodyberry12]

<3 just beautiful

[Hm0ngYexus]

She has a pretty face.

But that is it.

I prefer the original.

[LoveMJforever11]

I am a goose and I dream of this everyday

[psychedelicacynical]

from her very first line there were tears in my eyes

[suin2002]

@rzy1193 wait a sec... Who said that the original is by insooni? It's by carnival! Lee jeok and kim dong ryul!

[erasers9876]

this is a really beautiful song and if just any idol sang this, it could've ruined it. but wowww. this is very nice. :D

[autumnfri]

IU looks so cute!

[PlzCallMeAnything]

In my opinion, scientists should design create invent a device that can sent music to the brain of those who are unfortunate enough not to be able to go to the paradise of music. However Somehow they are trying to design create invent iphone 3-iphone4-iphone 5-ipad 1-ipad2. p.s. deaf people cant use them either... Dont get me wrong as im not bashing the scientists. just my opinion ONLY.

[zer0cooL7]

she is completely captivating and just utterly beautiful. undeniable.

[s70406]

So touchable.

[SolaceSunset]

For me Music is a way to release my stress and forget about all my mistakes and be in my little peaceful world with nobody to nag me and such. So when I think about all the Deaf people, who can't hear music I feel so sad because they would never be able to feel like that with Music. But In this performance at least the deaf people can have a little glimpse of Music

[rzy1193]

i like this version....but nothing beats the original by insooni!!

[mslemoneda]

music is the best thing in the world and it's so sad to think there are pple who can't hear it

[ancilalibra]

Like IU with her humble...

[GeuryeoyoPue]

IU IU IU IU ♥♥ U ARE MY FAVORITE EVAAA !!

[yumiireyna00]

This really warms my heart<3

IU's singing, the signers at the back, and the audience

[NgoNicole]

How can a person have such a beautiful and perfect voice? And she's pretty too. So lucky. Totally envious of IU. Hwaiting IU!!

[wlgPRkRnd]

Youtube really should put auto replay button..

[xNekomimi93x]

@wlgPRkRnd I agree !

[NicoleLovesSHINee]

That was wonderful, I'm getting chills on my back.

[whtjgud0410]

i get goosbumps everytime her note goes high ._.