Many of the previous youtube videos i have watched are of children at a very young age performing this piece. They play with entire concentration the vibrato and keeping in tune with notes, compared to Valarie who plays with the heart. Without expression music just plainly sounds dull.
i love these girls, and i love their talent, but I hate how people are putting them up on the pedestal for playing pieces they're not ready for. I'm sure right now Valerie has improved tremendously but please don't call it adorable when your child is playing a piece she clearly wasn't ready for. I'm glad they have the tenacity. Some people wouldn't be able to live through imperfections that happened in this performance. I admire her stride, but she deserves better.
@VladislavGomulka and what did I say that implied I am "just envious to their talents"? Did I not praise Valerie in my comment? I was just saying how BIG violin repertoire like this need to be tackled at a certain level. In this particular video, I think Valerie just rushed herself in playing this piece. Maybe another year or two would have been needed before deciding to jump in such a hard Sarasate piece. She's got talent, but she doesn't need to rush learning every major violin work as she did
@classifieds103You probably a professional musician. I am not. To me, what this young lady is doing is on the borderline of a miracle. My efforts to force my poor violin to sing were futile for many years. What I see is a miracle. This girl is great. On the other side she shows constant progress. From my experience: the best way to positively stimulate is to PRAISE. People like here are enough motivated, they are blooming on praise for the achievement and it is one. Cheers!
@VladislavGomulka Like I said, I DID praise valerie in my original comment. So you're arguing with me for no reason. In my opinion, praise alone isn't enough to help a student grow. There needs to be constructive criticism so they can learn from their mistakes and improve even more. I just provided a constructive criticism. You simply misconstrued it as an insult, which believe, I was not trying the least bit to insult or detract from Valerie's talent. It just upsets me when repertoire is rushed
@VladislavGomulka I'm going to stop replying to your comments. You're extremely defensive and angry at me for no reason despite the facts that I 1.) am not insulting or being mean to anyone 2.) never did anything to offend you. If you think constructive criticism is mean, then to each his own. But please, stop being defensive for no reason ok? It doesn't look good on anyone.
My goodness so talented and so young, I've never seen this much passion and engagment towards music in such a young people, Bravo you are both truly gifted!
even more pro...sigh as i play my violin...i'm 12 and this piece is really really difficult...she's keeps her confidence even when she gets some intonation wrong...which is good :) good luck for your future.
@ciaconne90 I know how you feel, I have this with all those other 4 - 9 yr old kids who play technically really good, but they don't with their hart and soul.
And then I bumped into these girls' vids and I just get goosebumps from them! They're both SO amazing and they play with so much feeling.
They both got talent and we'll hear of them later, I'm sure!
This is too difficult for someone so young unless they are excpetionnally musically talented. She should play easier pieces and become more naturally musical.
This looks fake because the left hand is not moving like the vibrato we are hearing. And even for a young child the intonation is unbearable. I imagine the child was play acting and that she is a very advanced player, as she is in all the correct positions.
Haaa, ela aprenderá com o tempo... quem daqui é mais novo do que ela... se ela ta com essa idade e tem essa tecnica toda pode ter certeza q com o tempo ela vai melhorar e naum piorar...concordo q seu professor a colocou pra tocar essa peça por empolgação, mas enfim... essa garotaa vai fazer muuito sucesso ainda! abraço a todos
Weird weird weird....why did their have to be so many side comments that just boasted but nothing except that......she's horrible.
I know I'm getting like -20 for this comment, but seriously.....she WAS prettttty bad......she should have done this piece later in her life and started with Rond Cappricioso by Saint Saens (which is hard too but better for growth of playing) instead.......
I know I'm going to get downgraded to hell for saying this, but I don't think she's ready for this piece. She needs to refine her technique before she can pull of the allegro, and during the lento her phrasing and intonation could use some work. Yes, she is talented, but talent can't make up for simple technique and jumping to play difficult pieces prematurely won't help - there are plenty of other pieces she could be playing well and actually perfecting.
So sweet! And so good, too! Both girls are indeed adorable. I don't know what I admire more: Valerie's charm and expressiveness, or Dominique's great accompaniment.
@ZtiluakLibb Who are you to say she's so good as to be above criticism? No one improves by being told they're wonderful when they're really not. She might have some talent, but she's way in over her head with a piece like this and it's only going to set her back.
Those of us who are criticising her do it because we actually know something about classical music and don't just gush at the sight of little kids playing difficult pieces, regardless of how bad it is.
@firefoot77...... There's a well know saying...... 'Those that can do, and those that can't remain critics' I did try to find an example of your performances but could not find any !!!!
You may well know something about classical music but you cannot take from these girls their outstanding accomplishments...they are superb and nothing you can say can evry change that.
@marshplumuk I'm not trying to detract from her talent. My problem is with the fact that she's never going to be able to fulfill the potential her talent could allow her with people (especially her parents) ONLY going on about how wonderful she is for playing a piece that is much too difficult for her without offering any critique. It is an accomplishment to play Zigeunerweisen at age nine, but it can't even compare to being able to play it exceptionally well because she's actually ready for it.
@firefoot77 she's 9. she's just playing rep and performing it because it's good enough! brilliant because she's 9. she can play the notes... maturity will come with age.
@samloom Actually, she can hardly play the notes - she simply can't keep up with the Allegro, and I won't get into the Lento. The idea is to play repertoire that's at your proper level so you actually have room to mature and learn as you go, not to play rep that's rather painfully obviously above your level just 'cause it's impressive.
@firefoot77 : Listen to her recent video of the same piece, made 3.5 years later. THAT'S why it's not a bad thing to work on pieces that are too advanced, although I agree with you that I'm not sure it should have been performed at the stage it is in this video.
@lilly763 Her new video sounds much better, sure - but why does that have anything to do with learning difficult rep prematurely? She wasted time (and likely learned bad habits) by spending so much time on a piece she really oughtn't to have learned back then, when she could have been developing and strengthening basic techniques from 'easier' rep. This new video is fine, but given her talent, I can only wonder how much better it *could* have been.
i thought someone was shitting in my ears throughout the piece, seriosly. whats the point of playing it at 9, when u can play it at 40 or so like Pearlman and make it sound so beautiful. no expression, out of tune, jsut ruined the piece
al principio creí que era un video más de niña sobreestimada,pero veo que sí tiene la capacidad para tocar esta pieza. Las faltas que tiene son meramente interpretativas y eso se arregla con su edad.
when the violinist was pizzicato-ing I had a slight feeling that she was about to snap a string...however on the other side it's amazing to see a kid who is not is not even 10 play a piece like zigunerweisen. the pianist was great too
Her potential is good, but her emotion is unbridled, not focused. She needs more life experience, and have felt deeper emotions to convey this song to it's fullest. technique errors and intonation problems are the easy thing to fix. Experiencing love and loss is what is needed for Zigeunerweisen.
at her age, I only could play silly and easy things...so...to me is awesome how can she play the violin with only 9 years. But if we can be honest, she is not close to the perfection in this piece. I'm from Spain and well....the Gipsy air is still lose in the air xD. But she will be a very very good violinist in the future!!!
mm they are amazing but I think she didn't get even close to the feeling of it, somehow it seems too cut¡ as if there was no relation between one part and the other...
I'm very impressed that this little cute girl can play this super hard song BUT I dont like it somehow.... I guess it's true that you can tell the personality by how people play any kind of instrument.
almost perfect..the way they act while playing..living the music..even without sound you can see the talent by their moves while playing...I believe Valeri should practice more before her violin performances..she is a real talent , however it is hard to say that she plays clear and solid .. i didn't like the sounds she preduced on this performance..
Amazing stuff. Maybe if the violinist stood more to her left, then the pianist would not have to turn her head so much to follow the soloist. And oh dear...that dress! (I don't normally pass comment on such things)
I feel shy and abit embarassed when playing the violin.. i just feel that i dont have the emotion or feel for the song...
*sad*
LaMarionette33 1 week ago
鳥肌がたちました。素晴らしい動画をどうもありがとう！ Wonderful！
AMviolin27 2 weeks ago
@ VladislavGomulka classified is kinda right Valerie started when she was 8
EliseNewen 2 months ago
Many of the previous youtube videos i have watched are of children at a very young age performing this piece. They play with entire concentration the vibrato and keeping in tune with notes, compared to Valarie who plays with the heart. Without expression music just plainly sounds dull.
CynthiaQANguyen 2 months ago
She's tuning in at 0:18-0:33.Prepare to meet thy doom !!
SithSereyPheap1 2 months ago
Good conbination as a grown up of morning grolia with very charastaristic on this VTR in Korean !
HighROCOCOlings 3 months ago
crazy shit =O
Homerhorst 3 months ago
Don't forget to congratulate the pianist here...doing a fantastic job in a collaborative role as a real supporting accompanist.
gwie21 3 months ago 2
ได้เห็นและได้ฟัง สองพี่น้องสองสาวน้อย Valerie Kim with Dominique Kim ไพเราะมากครับ และ มีความสุขมากๆทุกครั้งที่ได้เข้ามาชมและมาฟังครับ ขอให้ทั้งสองสาวได้เป็นนักดนตรี และ ศิลปินที่ประสบความสำเร็จในโลกนี้นะครับ ให้ได้ทั้ง ความร่ำรวย ชื่อเสียง เกียรติยศ และ การยอมรับนับถือ ด้วยนะครับ
moonfleetchiangma 6 months ago
wooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!
pazth1 7 months ago
iNCREIBLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE ,, ......................es exelenteeeee !!!!!!!!!!! mis felicitaciones toca exelentemente bien :)
Yunokikahokochan 7 months ago 2
5:23-5:33 wicked awesome piano solo
dianac3009 9 months ago
3:54 O A O ) what happen ?
nadelacchi 9 months ago
@nadelacchi Left hand pizzicato.
giorgiamiscia 8 months ago
The showmanship at such a tender age! Bravo! Music is certainly her language :) And bravo to their teachers as well. Great ensemble.
angelachanpoyiu 10 months ago
The showmanship at such a tender age! Bravo! Music is certainly her language :)
angelachanpoyiu 10 months ago
The showmanship at such a tender age! Bravo!
angelachanpoyiu 10 months ago
B R A V O..!!!!!
aqban22 10 months ago
The world will hear a lot from this incredible duo!!!
VladislavGomulka 10 months ago
Je répond à ZtiluakLibb que je suis Français
moiflute78 10 months ago
i love these girls, and i love their talent, but I hate how people are putting them up on the pedestal for playing pieces they're not ready for. I'm sure right now Valerie has improved tremendously but please don't call it adorable when your child is playing a piece she clearly wasn't ready for. I'm glad they have the tenacity. Some people wouldn't be able to live through imperfections that happened in this performance. I admire her stride, but she deserves better.
classifieds103 10 months ago
@classifieds103 You a superjerk! I do not know them, so I am objective. You are just envious to their talents!
VladislavGomulka 10 months ago
@VladislavGomulka and what did I say that implied I am "just envious to their talents"? Did I not praise Valerie in my comment? I was just saying how BIG violin repertoire like this need to be tackled at a certain level. In this particular video, I think Valerie just rushed herself in playing this piece. Maybe another year or two would have been needed before deciding to jump in such a hard Sarasate piece. She's got talent, but she doesn't need to rush learning every major violin work as she did
classifieds103 10 months ago
@classifieds103You probably a professional musician. I am not. To me, what this young lady is doing is on the borderline of a miracle. My efforts to force my poor violin to sing were futile for many years. What I see is a miracle. This girl is great. On the other side she shows constant progress. From my experience: the best way to positively stimulate is to PRAISE. People like here are enough motivated, they are blooming on praise for the achievement and it is one. Cheers!
VladislavGomulka 10 months ago
@VladislavGomulka Like I said, I DID praise valerie in my original comment. So you're arguing with me for no reason. In my opinion, praise alone isn't enough to help a student grow. There needs to be constructive criticism so they can learn from their mistakes and improve even more. I just provided a constructive criticism. You simply misconstrued it as an insult, which believe, I was not trying the least bit to insult or detract from Valerie's talent. It just upsets me when repertoire is rushed
classifieds103 10 months ago
@classifieds103 Why not to mind your own business?
VladislavGomulka 10 months ago
@VladislavGomulka I'm going to stop replying to your comments. You're extremely defensive and angry at me for no reason despite the facts that I 1.) am not insulting or being mean to anyone 2.) never did anything to offend you. If you think constructive criticism is mean, then to each his own. But please, stop being defensive for no reason ok? It doesn't look good on anyone.
classifieds103 10 months ago
@classifieds103 You, not me, mischaracterized Valerie. To present now her/himself as a victim is not decent.
VladislavGomulka 10 months ago
Yeah! Music has no age!
metteholm75 11 months ago
I think the pianist is even better than the violonist.
youprettygidiot 11 months ago
Precocious. And wonderful musicianship.
Very precocious. Thanks for sharing.
OjiiSan53 11 months ago
Those two girls can do more, than an orchestra
OFlute96O 11 months ago
O M G! ! ! ! THAT WAS JUST AMAZING! ! ! I just want to lock me in my room and practise like hell for many YEARS!!
VildeChr1 1 year ago
To me it doesn't matter if their newest video sounds better or not.
I love this one better. I didn't even notice that the reason Dominique turned the pages like she did was two were stuck together.
I just thought she needed to play a measure from the other page, then turn back to where she was.
ModelDX1 1 year ago
My goodness so talented and so young, I've never seen this much passion and engagment towards music in such a young people, Bravo you are both truly gifted!
margarcia20 1 year ago
I don't know what to say ..... these two Girls are AMAZING..... They are still so young. BRAVO .... and tenthousand Stars.
kiwistrudel 1 year ago
i thought that korean people can stand the music very well
they are great at music and everything about art
so great
vuongluu2301 1 year ago
Jesus! she can play that!
bgirlnishin23 1 year ago
I went through all 132 videos! What impresses me most is how the girls ENJOY listening to the sound they're making. Awesome.
haonhienvu 1 year ago
tu nho toi chua nghe ai choi nhac hay nhu vay
pduc12 1 year ago
OH MY GOD
kuroiyukihime 1 year ago
wow also ich spiele auch geige aber wow ich bin sprach los
Mikigirl1997 1 year ago
That was amazing.
Dharok95025 1 year ago
Maybe they can write an amazing song about all the times they spent having fun...oh wait.
prophetezekiel 1 year ago 4
@prophetezekiel AHAHAHAHAHA
naborlz 1 year ago
even more pro...sigh as i play my violin...i'm 12 and this piece is really really difficult...she's keeps her confidence even when she gets some intonation wrong...which is good :) good luck for your future.
violin4ever1 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
violin4ever1 1 year ago
I'm playing this piece now at fourteen, and its wicked hard! she may be a little out of tune and other stuff, but she is better than I am!!!
pitrimitri242 1 year ago
the fact she's playing this at this age saddens me. all my years of practice....down the drain.....to people like her :'(
(excellent though (: )
ciaconne90 1 year ago 13
@ciaconne90 I know how you feel, I have this with all those other 4 - 9 yr old kids who play technically really good, but they don't with their hart and soul.
And then I bumped into these girls' vids and I just get goosebumps from them! They're both SO amazing and they play with so much feeling.
They both got talent and we'll hear of them later, I'm sure!
ZaraGlaser 1 year ago 7
@ciaconne90 yeah if you suck...just quit
milstein91 2 months ago
Bravo!!!!!!!!
robviolin1 1 year ago 4
no manches ... pinches vagas
BeethovenOp125 1 year ago
the accompanist plays like a pro!!!! both has a musical sense and direction. very nice indeed!!! great job!!
WangYiLe1 1 year ago 4
"THEY" are simply amazing, so young... and yet they diplay and express more emotion than some professionals...!
meakiel09 1 year ago 2
so did she win the scholarship?
tenten2buns 1 year ago
shes really good
Shua26 1 year ago
OMG only pros play this song
chickadeeonfire 1 year ago
"Rough around the edges"??? Most kids that age do not even know what this type of music is. They are phenomenal!
booprunck 1 year ago
holyshiz
15minutespastmidnite 1 year ago
oh god, they are so amazing! wanna marry dominique! haha
tyuzynho 1 year ago
oh woooowwww you girls are amazing!!! your even better then most of the people at my school who play(: good job!!!
SillyDancer123 1 year ago 2
WahouUuu !!!
Sidedawn13 1 year ago 2
Woah.
ifyouarenotdead 1 year ago 2
Amazing! Wonderfully played! 5 stars!! No one should criticize these girls, they are great! How many young people do you know with this much talent?
Itneybay303 1 year ago 3
Adorable is right and not so rough, really!!
floydrharper 1 year ago 4
A blossoming virtuoso, what a gift she'll have to give our ears in years to come.
MatanuskaMafia 1 year ago 5
Ha! This is nothing for this girl! Look up her other stuff, quite a talent. Wish my memory was that good.
barquester 1 year ago 4
This is too difficult for someone so young unless they are excpetionnally musically talented. She should play easier pieces and become more naturally musical.
MrTfep 1 year ago
How many hours does she practice a day?
1discipulo 1 year ago
I like the facial expressions of Valerie. She looks like she's enjoying what she's doing very much.
ymzkjapan 1 year ago 6
jungkim2020, are you the parent of the 2 girls? They're wonderful. You must be very proud. I'm becoming their fans. How old did they start playing?
ymzkjapan 1 year ago 4
well, she could use some vibrato... I'm surprised that she can play something at this level, but can't use vibrato.
hawkfanspm 1 year ago
1:45
i thought she snapped her strings.
amazing for her age. :)
iamemod 1 year ago
This looks fake because the left hand is not moving like the vibrato we are hearing. And even for a young child the intonation is unbearable. I imagine the child was play acting and that she is a very advanced player, as she is in all the correct positions.
EJAPRIB 1 year ago 2
when i look at the score..i was like omg ...this is hard..looks back at the video..0.o..she's a genius!
Kuroakumashitsuji 1 year ago 3
Haaa, ela aprenderá com o tempo... quem daqui é mais novo do que ela... se ela ta com essa idade e tem essa tecnica toda pode ter certeza q com o tempo ela vai melhorar e naum piorar...concordo q seu professor a colocou pra tocar essa peça por empolgação, mas enfim... essa garotaa vai fazer muuito sucesso ainda! abraço a todos
jjjaaasssiiieeelll 1 year ago
Weird weird weird....why did their have to be so many side comments that just boasted but nothing except that......she's horrible.
I know I'm getting like -20 for this comment, but seriously.....she WAS prettttty bad......she should have done this piece later in her life and started with Rond Cappricioso by Saint Saens (which is hard too but better for growth of playing) instead.......
Go ahead! Give me -100....
clubpenguinmanful 1 year ago
Wow! I like both of you!
You are very talent ^-^
MaMiMoMu09 1 year ago 7
I agree with firefoot
Spambinator 1 year ago
I know I'm going to get downgraded to hell for saying this, but I don't think she's ready for this piece. She needs to refine her technique before she can pull of the allegro, and during the lento her phrasing and intonation could use some work. Yes, she is talented, but talent can't make up for simple technique and jumping to play difficult pieces prematurely won't help - there are plenty of other pieces she could be playing well and actually perfecting.
firefoot77 1 year ago 5
this is crazy...
yenhoho 1 year ago 3
How talented this child prodigy is!
benfrankz94 1 year ago 6
IMPRESSIONNANT ET EMOUVANT !
PACTproduction 1 year ago 7
I simply love this. She reminds me of me!
zeagle79 2 years ago 3
omg they are so good!
twilightlover814 2 years ago 9
i think shes really good expressing what she thinks but she is kinda off key in many places......
elbo1015 2 years ago 5
So sweet! And so good, too! Both girls are indeed adorable. I don't know what I admire more: Valerie's charm and expressiveness, or Dominique's great accompaniment.
bartmeijer1954 2 years ago 41
@bartmeijer1954 probably both of their beauty
Belchmaster41 10 months ago
OMG! 9 years old!!!
caelimck 2 years ago 7
These girls need no one telling them what to do better here. Just enjoy while watching their amazing talent, who are you to tell them how to play.
ZtiluakLibb 2 years ago 60
@ZtiluakLibb
yeah you're right..... they're exceptional
hikaritina 1 year ago 2
@ZtiluakLibb Who are you to say she's so good as to be above criticism? No one improves by being told they're wonderful when they're really not. She might have some talent, but she's way in over her head with a piece like this and it's only going to set her back.
Those of us who are criticising her do it because we actually know something about classical music and don't just gush at the sight of little kids playing difficult pieces, regardless of how bad it is.
firefoot77 1 year ago
@firefoot77...... There's a well know saying...... 'Those that can do, and those that can't remain critics' I did try to find an example of your performances but could not find any !!!!
You may well know something about classical music but you cannot take from these girls their outstanding accomplishments...they are superb and nothing you can say can evry change that.
marshplumuk 1 year ago 3
@marshplumuk I'm not trying to detract from her talent. My problem is with the fact that she's never going to be able to fulfill the potential her talent could allow her with people (especially her parents) ONLY going on about how wonderful she is for playing a piece that is much too difficult for her without offering any critique. It is an accomplishment to play Zigeunerweisen at age nine, but it can't even compare to being able to play it exceptionally well because she's actually ready for it.
firefoot77 1 year ago
@firefoot77 she's 9. she's just playing rep and performing it because it's good enough! brilliant because she's 9. she can play the notes... maturity will come with age.
samloom 1 year ago 2
@samloom Actually, she can hardly play the notes - she simply can't keep up with the Allegro, and I won't get into the Lento. The idea is to play repertoire that's at your proper level so you actually have room to mature and learn as you go, not to play rep that's rather painfully obviously above your level just 'cause it's impressive.
firefoot77 1 year ago
@firefoot77 : Listen to her recent video of the same piece, made 3.5 years later. THAT'S why it's not a bad thing to work on pieces that are too advanced, although I agree with you that I'm not sure it should have been performed at the stage it is in this video.
lilly763 1 year ago
@lilly763 Her new video sounds much better, sure - but why does that have anything to do with learning difficult rep prematurely? She wasted time (and likely learned bad habits) by spending so much time on a piece she really oughtn't to have learned back then, when she could have been developing and strengthening basic techniques from 'easier' rep. This new video is fine, but given her talent, I can only wonder how much better it *could* have been.
firefoot77 1 year ago 3
@firefoot77 haters gunn hate!
violaplyr 1 year ago
@ZtiluakLibb I agree 100% these two girls haven't charged a single person here on Y/T one cent to watch them play.
No one has the right to complain unless they paid for a ticket to watch. And didn't get their money's worth.
ModelDX1 1 year ago
@ZtiluakLibb
Quelle incroyable maturité musicale, si jeune!!! bluffé.
moiflute78 11 months ago
@moiflute78 English, Swedish, español or Deutsch please :)
ZtiluakLibb 10 months ago
@ZtiluakLibb Je suis Français
moiflute78 10 months ago
perfecto
perfecto
perfecto
perfecto
perfecto
perfecto
...
Buen trabajo, sois las mejores, llegaréis muy lejos
SofiaNDL 2 years ago 6
Beautiful
rise3370 2 years ago 9
WOW
buleiqi 2 years ago 8
why those kid can play so well!! it's erally cool
unajou0525 2 years ago 7
i love her
1asdfsdfg 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yeah, have to admit it's a bit out of tunes (especially the presto), but it was a great effort anyway.
Zhyhm 2 years ago
wow.
Twilight2451 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
i thought someone was shitting in my ears throughout the piece, seriosly. whats the point of playing it at 9, when u can play it at 40 or so like Pearlman and make it sound so beautiful. no expression, out of tune, jsut ruined the piece
Tsingtao4 2 years ago
WOW!!! Dang I wish I was like them, I play good and all, but not that good. lol : )
BehindThesePianoKeys 2 years ago
what did she do at 1:44?
bellekd1413 2 years ago
i think she played four strings at once: a "quadruple stop" but she did it rly hard and aggressive
BassClr13 2 years ago
pizzicato
tedgoh 2 years ago 5
cUtE!
crackerberries 2 years ago 2
Amazing! Intonation is a bit iffy, but the piece overall is hard to get all notes right, especially for this age. Great job!
violymnast 2 years ago 3
beautiful =o i wish to hear more...
TheChinkninja 2 years ago 4
al principio creí que era un video más de niña sobreestimada,pero veo que sí tiene la capacidad para tocar esta pieza. Las faltas que tiene son meramente interpretativas y eso se arregla con su edad.
Bravísimo.
kof00j 2 years ago
wow!!! Zigeunerweisen!!! I only know 1 person who has played this and he did when he was 13.
1a2b3c4d5e6ff 2 years ago 3
I love the dress!
SophiaVonHelgastein 2 years ago
nine.... NINE?!?!
leahgranniee 2 years ago 2
what the.... Am I watching a dream. Incredible, incredibler than susan boyle
stradivarius001 2 years ago 5
¡¡que bello!.. maravilloso!! desde argentina un abrazo!
TheCane2 2 years ago 5
As a 9 year old violinist, she shows some unbelievable concentration for a long period time!
sigpaik5 2 years ago 7
The only people that would rate this less than 5 stars are just jealous of their talent.
SuprSokrSuicide 2 years ago 7
just... amazing.
xXkaddiiiXx 2 years ago 5
Both incredible musicians!
gypcnme 2 years ago 8
how old she is, increditable.....emotion can be expressed by music..... now u
must agree, hahahaha : )
billy672828 2 years ago 2
when the violinist was pizzicato-ing I had a slight feeling that she was about to snap a string...however on the other side it's amazing to see a kid who is not is not even 10 play a piece like zigunerweisen. the pianist was great too
randomstuff314 2 years ago 4
WOW O.O
zce813 2 years ago 4
It could be , " Rap ". I loved it.
thewelford 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Go home to shaolin temple
Heifetzfanatic 2 years ago
can they both enjoy at least ten years of childhood before becoming amazingly talented?
FLTiNGReeN91 2 years ago
Her potential is good, but her emotion is unbridled, not focused. She needs more life experience, and have felt deeper emotions to convey this song to it's fullest. technique errors and intonation problems are the easy thing to fix. Experiencing love and loss is what is needed for Zigeunerweisen.
Stainlessfights4u 2 years ago
wow...
finland 2 years ago
ヴァイオリンの子うますぎ！！！
歌うとこなんか大人顔負けだね。
伴奏の子にミスが多くて残念だけど、
非常に才能があると思います。
gremlins878 2 years ago
Jesus.. talk about kids that have been whipped in to shape by less talented parents
borjeman 2 years ago
seriously...guys most kids nowadays start at nine...and im 14 and still learning this piece
nimkus1995 2 years ago
Cut her some slack -__-::
Could any of YOU play like this when you were 9 in front of an audience to boot?
Teuthodoll 2 years ago 4
Can somebody tell me the home and e-mail adress of these geniuses? I have something for them
musicingredient 2 years ago
stalker.
iwasadeum 2 years ago
Can somebody tell me the home and e-mail address of these kids ?
musicingredient 2 years ago
wow stalker...
InfernoNova4 2 years ago 2
at her age, I only could play silly and easy things...so...to me is awesome how can she play the violin with only 9 years. But if we can be honest, she is not close to the perfection in this piece. I'm from Spain and well....the Gipsy air is still lose in the air xD. But she will be a very very good violinist in the future!!!
AntiguoShergot 2 years ago 5
and after minute 7 it's kinda scrued up ^^
pollakmatias 2 years ago
mm they are amazing but I think she didn't get even close to the feeling of it, somehow it seems too cut¡ as if there was no relation between one part and the other...
pollakmatias 2 years ago 2
It's great for her age, but she is still young to play it right.
NightwishLady92 2 years ago
she's not at the level to play this peice. the details are far from there.
DannyViolinMan 2 years ago
piece*
DannyViolinMan 2 years ago
yeah i think you're right, at this age i don't think she can too, but now she can, she got a lot better.
kuvhlubkojibleegxwbo 2 years ago
Thought I do believe the child is too young to know how to feel the music, it is a very diffcult piece, so I can see why.
No hard feelings here. =D
It was a nice preformance.
Skull12Candy 2 years ago
I'm very impressed that this little cute girl can play this super hard song BUT I dont like it somehow.... I guess it's true that you can tell the personality by how people play any kind of instrument.
stradivarius001 2 years ago
Bravíssimo, maravilhosas!!!
Grazzife 2 years ago 2
r they korean????????
dnrhdql 2 years ago 2
wow.............................
god bless u
dnrhdql 2 years ago 3
holy ..... this took my breath away. They are quite astounding. Bonte'! only 9 and 11? Bravo! wonderful performance by both!
mickie825 2 years ago 3
the two together are amazing!...shes better thaN me and she younger..lol...GOOD JOB!!!!!!!!
xxchiefaustinxx 2 years ago
G-O-D...!
schostaievski 2 years ago 2
so im guesing they r sisters?
their family must b so proud , im so proud n im not even related!!!!
judith1twilighter 2 years ago 2
almost perfect..the way they act while playing..living the music..even without sound you can see the talent by their moves while playing...I believe Valeri should practice more before her violin performances..she is a real talent , however it is hard to say that she plays clear and solid .. i didn't like the sounds she preduced on this performance..
dongolo 2 years ago
what's wrong with the screen?????
jennyjeon214 2 years ago 2
I think the camera's quality is not good enough.
lokwokyan 2 years ago
Amazing stuff. Maybe if the violinist stood more to her left, then the pianist would not have to turn her head so much to follow the soloist. And oh dear...that dress! (I don't normally pass comment on such things)
whigwood 2 years ago 2
Bravo
100violins 2 years ago
genius = =''
gh8nxn 2 years ago 2
He says great! This children is really a genious! ^^
gh8nxn 2 years ago
太棒了 真是天才
tasiwenlong 2 years ago
Translation please?
jungkim2020 2 years ago
(That's awesome! What a genius)
chewhwe 2 years ago 2
@jungkim2020
This is so wonderful! You're such a talent
destinybone 1 year ago 3
@jungkim2020
Translate from Chinese: Great performance. You are really talented.
I also think the same way. Are you a parent of them?
VietFiddle 1 year ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
@jungkim2020
太棒了 真是天才 Great days
LandTeen 1 year ago
@jungkim2020 I think he or she wanted to say truly, thay have talent ;)
stife93 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
@jungkim2020 I think he or she wanted to say they have talent ;)
stife93 1 year ago