Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (231)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Am i the only one who thought that Snowkit was the "Forgotten Warrior"? And im glad Hollyleaf didnt come back bad,atleast thats what ive heard.^^Anyways,Even if Snowkit survived,he would probably be kinda old..

  • It's Leafpool on the cover chasing the squirrel.

  • i thought it was leafpool?

  • i want this book DX

  • i think hollyleaf might acctually be alive because she hasent been mentioned in the dark forest OR starclan.

  • @morsem2001 it was a good book

  • ... The cat on the cover is Leafpool , check the wiki

  • @CrimsonIcez In the background chasing a squirrel.

  • @foopetsgirl1 Nope! Check again Leafpool IS on the cover. The Erins said so. The cat chasing the squirrel is Hollyleaf. She looks golden reflected off the sun :)

  • @CrimsonIcez "Leafpool is the cat chasing the squirrel on the background of the cover.[5]" Please go look it up before you tell me something false.

  • @CrimsonIcez warriors.wikia.com/wiki/The_Fo­rgotten_Warrior

  • The in the prolouge is SOL!!!!!!

  • I READ IT AND IT'S SOOO GOOD! so..many....spoilers...i..want­...to...share

  • Yes, it is about frickin time! Lionblaze~ <333

  • It is confermed that hollyleaf is the forgotten warrior :/ i dont like hollyleaf

  • @eaglefeatherwarrior Btw, calling people stupid for thinking differently means you're calling me stupid. :/ I really don't get you trolls.

  • @eaglefeatherwarrior You amuse me. Everybody has their own opinions, and I'm pretty sure that the cat on the cover is Lionblaze. He's never had his own cover. Now I'd appreciate it if you'd actually show some respect and not use capitals all the time. Now, good-bye forever.

  • It's already out. I have almost read it all. If you wanna know who the forgotten warrior is ask me. I know.

  • @Kovu66 So do I

  • @foopetsgirl1 hey i dont thinkits lionblaze because hes on the third one u know im not trying to be rude but i think i might befallen because lionblaze is more orange and has longer hair u know hwat i mean?

  • @warriorscandyapple86 That was Flametail cuz Lionblaze doesn't have green eyes.

  • @LittleNinjaPuppy I don't think so, because Flametail isn't really in the book, all that is mentioned about him is that his sister Dawnpelt wants to avenge him *SPOILERS* 83

    ~Wildblaze

  • @WildFlameStudios I was talking about how Flametail was shown on the third book of the OOTS series. He's the one on the cover.

  • Respond to this video... sorry i think its fallen LEAVES sorry i speled that wrong

  • Well, I really hope it's Hollyleaf but if you think about it, no one has forgotten her. In fact, Lionblaze and Jayfeather or Cinderheart mentioned her at least once in the newest books. Though I guess that's just in one point of view of 'forgotten'

  • @LittleNinjaPuppy That IS true. I never really thought of that.

  • @foopetsgirl1 I think it is Hollyleaf because the books name is the forgotten warrior and Hollyleaf is pretty much a forgotten warrior in the clan

  • @1LPSproductions She is

  • @foopetsgirl1 is ravenpaw the forgotten warrior?

  • @SuperVancouverBC Hollyleaf is

  • Okay I believe that`s Fallen Leaves because if you read Sign of the Moon that would be the forgotten warrior

  • @nuglugs456 could be too

  • @nuglugs456 Fallen Leaves was never a warrior.

  • @foopetsgirl1 fallen leaves was a warrior in sign of the moon with half moon and that stuff

  • @foopetsgirl1 but remember he was lost in the tunnels and forgotten forever and jayfeather nearly forgotten but then he returned in sign of the moon

  • i alredy have the book yay!

  • @pokemonmaster438 How? It's not out yet.

  • @foopetsgirl1 lol! see i found this book at barns and nobel and i thought it was it but it wasn't!

  • @pokemonmaster438 lol Cx Jokes on me

  • so did hollyleaf make it through the tunnel before it collapsed? or is she in a hole?

  • If Hollyleaf is alive then what about the prophency does she have the power of the stars or does Dovewing have the power ...

  • @SwiftBlowz Dovewing. She's the real third.

  • i know Hollyleaf is alive i could tell how i know, but....

  • i was happy but sad when hollyleaf die(or not who really knows) ^_^

  • @eternitymoonlight Hollyleaf was confirmed alive.

  • okay people, i have good iea on who the forgotten warrior is.

    Mapleshade. OOTS is about the dark forest only the dark forest knows her. nobody cares about crookedstar so there has to be another reason why the erins made that book-mapleshade! dont ask me why but people are saying the dark forest are coming in this book so yeah... mapleshade. ^^

  • @TheFireStarFreaks Hollyleaf is the Forgotten Warrior. It was confirmed.

  • @foopetsgirl1

    uh huh? well what if they only did that so that rumors would be going about only to have it be someone different? and coleboy44thethird said it would ruin her character if she came back.

  • @TheFireStarFreaks The Erins said she would be coming back and was the forgotten warrior. I don't think the Erin's would lie to us about something like this, though it's happened before...

  • @foopetsgirl1

    see? it's mapleshade. =D

  • @TheFireStarFreaks Nope. I can send you proof of Hollyleaf being the forgotten warrior. :/

  • I love Hollyleaf, she was my favorite cat and nicely developed and the only cat who stuck to the warrior code when everybody else turned it away.

    But brining her back will only ruin her character, it always does!

  • I believe Hollyleaf is the forgotten warrior in the fifth book :3 Atleast I hope it is x3 I love Hollyleaf.

  • I knew Dovepaw's warrior name was going to be Dovewing xD

  • Who's Ginger?

  • @dpswiftstar58 I was just talking about the pelt color.

  • Yayy!! Hollyleaf :3 She has gone through so much, so I can't wait to see what happens. Also, the cat on the cover is confirmed to be Lionblaze and it is possible there is also Squirrelflight.

  • im not sure why but i love Hollyleaf, she's actually my fav character so halleluah that she's alive :3

  • @WhitemistWarriorCat Nah. I just don't want to find out it;s fake after looking for it while I could be doing something better with my life. Besides, I don't believe something unless I see it written on wands and worlds where they hold the Erin Hunter Chat. :p

  • hollyleaf is dead and has been since the 3rd series! and this book is part of the 4th series! the cat chasing the squirrel is probs lionblaze aswell or could be just a random cat :)

  • @123animalcrazy Hollyleaf was confirmed alive (much to my despair).

  • @foopetsgirl1 fair enough then well thats just crap i never liked her....oh well :)

  • @WhitemistWarriorCat Then it's probably not true,

  • @WhitemistWarriorCat What's the name of the thread?

  • @WhitemistWarriorCat I know, I'm asking you which forum it's located in. Ex: Omen of the Stars Forum, Ask Erin Forum, etc.

  • @WhitemistWarriorCat Which forum?

  • @WhitemistWarriorCat Where has this been confirmed?

  • i meant the fourth cat its pretty much hollyleaf not ivypool or anything hoolyleaf is 4th cat most likely though there can always be a twist

  • @shadowlink5556 Actually, Hollyleaf is the forgotten warrior, and Vicky said that the forgotten warrior is not the fourth

  • @foopetsgirl1 thats cool

    

  • sorry,i meant to say pretty MUCH hollyleaf

  • @shadowlink5556 I still have no idea what you mean

  • @foopetsgirl1 nevermind

    

  • what if its firestar

  • @shadowlink5556 It isn't.

  • @foopetsgirl1 so its pretty hollyleaf

    

  • if this is lionblazes cover, who is on the third books cover?

  • @WolfObsesser55 Flametail

  • @foopetsgirl1 oh thanks at first i thought it was lionblaze

  • @WolfObsesser55 He doesn't have green eyes, so...yeah...

  • @foopetsgirl1 sorry that i dont anylize covers.

  • @WolfObsesser55 I didn't mean to be rude, sorry

  • isnt ivypaw on the cover of the book 2 i meant

  • isnt ivypaw on the cover of the 2 book

  • Doesnt firestar die in this book?i think he does because hes on his last life.hollyleaf might come back also.THIS IS MAJOR SPOILERS!

  • @LpsTheFilms Maybe..............I Hope HollyLeaf comes back and has MouseWhisker's kits!!

  • it could be sol?

  • @pinkbelly7123 What could be Sol?

  • @foopetsgirl1 the cat chasing the squrrel. i got this idea because how it said "an outsider appears in ThunderClan's midst, spreading discord and turning Clanmates against one another." that sounds like sol to me. after all he let blackstar and his clan well you know...

  • @pinkbelly7123 That actually makes sense c: Cool

  • @foopetsgirl1 why thank you :3 i never stop thinking about warrior cats. i wonder if i am right about sol. hmmmm...

  • @pinkbelly7123 Welcome, and perhaps you are c:

  • @foopetsgirl1 thank you again :3

  • @pinkbelly7123 Welcome :)

  • @foopetsgirl1 XD :D

  • who is the main cat on the cover??

  • @ArcticBang Lionblaze I believe

  • @foopetsgirl1 Then who is that cat on the cover of Night Whispers??

  • @WildFlameStudios Flametail

  • is that hollyleaf hunting the squrrel?

  • @lionblaze341 Idk

  • @lionblaze341 hollyleaf is black -_-

  • @pokemonfan200zoroark She was asking about the cat in the background...

  • @foopetsgirl1 ik that cant u c the faint outline of light brown on that cat?

  • @pokemonfan200zoroark It could just be the sun's rays lighting up the cat's fur, you know.

  • @foopetsgirl1 how can a black cat have brown highlights? -_-

  • @pokemonfan200zoroark Sun's reflection is my guess.

  • @foopetsgirl1 have it ur way im still sure that that isnt hollyleaf :Y

  • @pokemonfan200zoroark Fine then

  • @foopetsgirl1 good because now im ending this conversation XD

  • @pokemonfan200zoroark It's possible! sometimes I notice tha in the sunlight black people's hair turns slightly brown. Don't get me wrong I'm black haired.

  • @WildFlameStudios yeah i am 2 and i have proof of u watch my YOUR MOTHER IS A..... video X3

    P.S.I THOUGHT I SAID THIS DISCUATEON (omg wut is wrong with my spelling today)WUZ OVIER (OMG MY SPELLING IS BLAD)(WTF)(TODAY)

  • @pokemonfan200zoroark Calm down, there's no need for caps. Think what you want. I have my opinion, you have yours.

  • @foopetsgirl1 i thought i said this disscusion wuz over -_-"

  • @pokemonfan200zoroark You actually brought it back up by replying to WildFlame's comment :l

  • @foopetsgirl1 ok then im ending it again -_-

  • @pokemonfan200zoroark Have fun with that

  • dude, that is NOT lionblaze. Lionblaze is long haired and, is on the cover of dark river.

  • @MrEpicAaron Heathertail was on the cover of Dark River, and Lionblaze is NOT a long haired cat.

  • lionblaze kinda looks kinda FAT i always thought he was a MUSCULAR lean cat but not THAT muscular...

  • Sign of the Moon gave 2 hints that Hollyleaf is still alive- Jayfeather and Lionblaze couldn't find a body and "a dark cat" helped guild Ivypool and Blossomfall out of the caves.

  • @Kittenlover0715 We all knew that already...

  • =P if erin hadn't confirmed that hollyleaf is the forgotten warrior, i wuld have guessed squirrelflight, she's been pretty much forgotten. the cat on the covor looks ginger, like squirrelflight, and it's chasing a squirrel, which might've had a connection t squirrelflights name ^-^

  • You know, the forgotten warrior could be Ravenpaw, but Hollyleaf seems more likely

  • @SuperDucky36 Erin confirmed that Hollyleaf was the forgotten warrior.

  • hollyleaf is alive in the tunnels but later proven dead when jay and lion find a new way into the tunnels. holly,lion, and jay are running out when a huge boulder falls,crushes, and kills hollyleaf. good?

  • @rawrvampirekitty no actually shes alive comfirmed by erin hunter. look at the wiki on holly leaf she is the forgotten warrior it says as well

  • @AlisonJBranscum1231 no, the boulder crushes her, i've read the book

  • @rawrvampirekitty

    in Sign of The Moon, Jayfeather and Lionblaze go into the tunnel that collapsed on Hollyleaf they can't find her body under the rocks only a peice of her fur. So no, the boulders did not crush her.

  • @sarahm2017 NO, i've read the book in the video, lion and jay see her body being crushed

  • It was in Jayfeather's pov when Hollyleaf was crushed, and he can't see. No body really knows what happened to Hollyleaf, anyway, even Lionblaze. All Lionblaze saw was the rocks falling. What may have confused you was when Jayfeather imagined the rocks crushing Hollyleaf.

  • @rawrvampirekitty

    that was in sunrise. in sign of the moon the went and checked underneath the rockpile but couldnt find her

  • @foopetsgirl1 yeah, I kinda just got really happy so I didn't think.

  • @foopetsgirl1 oh it's fine! I love the vid

  • @100rainfur Thank you for understanding, and thanks again!

  • @100rainfur I already have a video about the last book. I'm removing this due to spoilers. Sorry for the inconvenience.

  • @isabe11ehan she's in most of the 4th series.

  • And remember when his name was rusty :,)

  • Firestar can't die!!!!!!!! We have all followed his life!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Don't u remember when he became an apprentice, when he first fell in love, and now he's the leader And doesn't that make u wanna cry??!!!!!!

  • I want dovexbumble! I lov that couple or maybe even dovexfox. Like those two r so nice to her. I hope ivy gets some one to.

  • @100rainfur Ivypool will probably get a mate, and it's most likely going Bumblestripe. No offence, I respect your opinion, but I despise both DovexBumble and DovexFox *Waves IvyxBumble, DovexToad, IcexLion, WillowxJay, and CinderxMouse flags.*

  • @foopetsgirl1

    No, I mean they come back in the end to help fight.

  • Hey mapleshade is my fav bad guy!!!!! Shes crazy!

  • @100rainfur The only place I've seen Mapleshade is in Crookedstar's Promise.

  • I bet it's more than 1 forgotten warrior. Like all the warriors who were forgotten in starclan come back. And the forth cat is ivypool OR Hollyleaf comes back and it is her. I also bet Hollyleaf found the yarrow and the squirrel was her's. Hollyleaf was also the second cat down in the tunnels when ivypool and Blossomfall were lost (first one most likely was fallen leaves.) and the paw prints are her's. I'm guessing a lot of u guessed that stuff too or some thing like that.

  • @100rainfur If it's more than one forgotten warrior, than why isn't the book called "The Forgotten Warriors"?

  • @100rainfur I guessed that xD

  • I DON'T WANT FIRESTAR TO DIE

    He is my favorite and i swear im going to CRY :(

  • Firestar is gonna die in this series? :'(

  • @warriorfan1940 I'm going to delete your comment due to spoilers. Sorry for the inconvenience.

  • OMG firestar is going to DIE at the end of this series!

    He was so awsome in the first series!

    :(

  • oh god i want the book to come but i don't want Firestar to go...

    

  • Yeah, I mean why would any mother be mean to their child? Mapleshade is a demon from the Dark forest, btw

  • @Warriorcatslover01 Yes, I know, but please refrain from commenting about spoilers.

  • @foopetsgirl1  WHYYYYYY????????????/

  • I wish that never happened with Biarlight.

  • I hate to think how Millie will behave on this book. It's her fault that Blossomfall's training with the Dark Forest now. That's the only reason why I don't like her anymore.

  • @goldblaze93 I hate her too, but think about this: It's actually Blossomfall's fault she's deciding not to deal with it reasonably. She just decides not to be mature at all and join the Dark Forest instead of talking to somebody about it and be mature about the situation. That's why I hate Millie, Graystripe, Blossomfall, and Briarlight at the moment, but I hate Briarlight the most out of them all, please don't ask why, though. ^^

  • @foopetsgirl1 I won't ask why, but I'd give Briarlight a chance. She lost the use for her back legs, that's all.

  • @goldblaze93 Yeah, but Honeyfern died saving a kit that turns out wasn't going to be useless in the future, and thanks to her, HoneyxBerry is ruined, and Millie denies Blossomfall and Bumblestripe exist. Well, at least Millie is more realistic than Rainflower.

  • @foopetsgirl1 Yeah. I got Crookedstar's Promise a few days ago and I couldn't believe how Rainflower was acting. And Mapleshade, too! When I saw her manga form, she looked like a demon!

  • @goldblaze93 I meant useful, defiantly not useless.

  • @foopetsgirl1 I hear ya.

  • i think that hollyleaf is alive because think of the title, the forgotten warrior? i believe shes alive, but i could be wrong...

  • i think the cat on the cover is just there to be there (the one hunting)

  • BREAKING NEWS!!! I saw people saying that the Erins confirmed that LEAFPOOL (hates) is on the cover! This is ridiculous. She already had her own cover! I hope it's just a fake! :'(