Added: 3 years ago
From: RandomDCE
Views: 4,701
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (59)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the dark night is good but overated

  • this should have won the oscar

  • Damn right!

  • I thought the ending was VERY empty. Not even an ending really. But it was good.

  • @Tronman73 yeah^^ i must say i enjoyed the novel more than the movie^^

  • Your 2 Slow DCE LOL!

  • I had to read that story Last year

  • I really wanna see this after watching this review.

  • Well yeah, it looks very deep and emotional... This isn't an action movie.

  • Anybody knows if the book version is as good?

  • Yes, it's very good.

    We just finished reading it in our Modern Lit class.

  • Actually i just finished reading it yesterday :D

    I think the first 3rd was brilliant.Her point of view on the world was funny and small things how she compared God to Marx.The second 3rd was interesting aspeccialy the new characters and had a lot less imagination like the first 3rd and slightly boring but around the time she was homeless the novel was incredibly dull and not entertaining.

  • I never saw it as a very exciting book. I think it served its purpose for a different reason. But I can see what you mean.

  • PUNK IS NOT DED! MUTHAFUKKA!!!!!!!

  • I saw the movie one year ago, and I must say your comparaison with the Dark Knight is quite relevant.

    They should definitely do more traditional and original animation movies like this one, especially nowadays,almost everything is pre-packed and CGI.

  • I thought of ordering it on Pay-Per-View, but the commercials made it seem that it would be something that'll offend me..

  • hmm.. this movie looks good. If the DCE says it's good than it must be.

  • Watching this just made me think of the american and US releases of the Sly series, all the cutscenes were comic book style.

  • But, how do you feel about it not winning the oscar for animated feature?

    I do agree, I hadn't seen anything like it. But it took me multiple viewings to really understand it, and once I did I enjoyed it more than the initial viewing.

  • I think my college has this in the library. I'll make a note to check it out sometime in the week, maybe tomorrow even.

  • I saw the poster for this at a bookstore once, and it intrigued me...

    Well, I better go watch it then, huh?

  • You know what I think they need to make?

    A Batman: The Long Halloween animated movie.......animated in the EXACT SAME STYLE AS THE BOOK IS DRAWN. But then again, This is DC we are talking about. They get movies out as fast as a parylyzed turtle, huping a duck, that has no legs.

    DCE: WTF?

  • even so, they are still completely different, and you shouldn't compare them just because they are based on comics. road to perdition and tank girl are both based on comics, and you wouldn't compare them to eachother.

    i'm not particularly having a go at you or DCE, it's just a pet peeve of mine that i want to get off my cheast. and you should seriously go read maus, DCE. when you're done with watchmen.

  • I had no idea that this film was a comic book movie. Now that I heard have this is more emotionally driven than the Dark Knight, this movie is deffinitley on my Must See Movie List. Thanks 4 the review.

  • Hmm, I should check this out. This seems Interesting.

  • hey random, thanks for this video! as an iranian, this was awesome for someone to talk about my culture. hey i saw this at its opening in san francisco and guess who i saw there? robert redford. i know... i know... oh but i watched it in french.

  • i remember this from his ben 10 review

  • The first thing I thought after watching this, while I was leaving the theater, was "and we want to bomb that country..."

    I had a friend who watched it with me who knew nothing of Iranian politics and it really moved her.

    I told her that, had America not supported a dictator there in the 1950's, Iran might not be as messed up as it is now.

  • 4 Down

    3 To Go

    You convinced me to possibly watch this.

  • your outros are getting old you should put new ones like m.bison saying "OF COURSE!" XD

  • I know. I need some new ones.

  • please don't compare persepolis to the dark knight. they are both incredible films, but they are no meant to be stood up back to back with eachother.

    and if you like this DCE, you should read Maus

  • I'll go see it.

  • What do you mean by "Punk is not ded?"

  • LEARN YOUR HISTORY BOY!

  • I love how you can acctually leave this movie like you've been changed, almost educated in a way.

  • god I've been wanting to see this movie since i saw the trailer! I'm gonna have to go rent it tonight

  • I've never heard of it nor have I seen it, but it sounds great and I really want to watch it now!

  • I have wanted wanted to see this movie, and now I have to see this movie. Thanks mate!

  • I'll be sure to rent this movie the next time I go to blockbuster ;)

  • It is a very good movie! I went to the cinema to watch the premier in german dub and have also senn the original version subbed!

    I give it a 5 out of 5 ;)

  • Wow, you rareley ever give an A out, I might have to see this.

  • I never really seen it. Damn... why the hell is good things coming past in thin air?

  • I've seen this movie and liked it. it was the art design and the plot that got me interested.

  • Never heard of it. But now I crave to watch it!

  • Awesome review but why didn't you say that this movie is based in iran?....I think!

  • I remember reading the controversy about that segment of the film. I felt it was best to ignore it (Just this one time)

  • @RandomDCE This movie has become a lot more culturally relevant due to the recent events in Iran. Well, last year's protests to be exact. Thanks for the review! :D

  • This is a good movie, but IMO it cannot touch The Dark Knight

  • I didn't say It's better than TDK (Hell, what movie is?) But I feel it's more emotionaly driven that TDK.

  • well, it's your opinion anyway, was just saying is all

  • Thanks a bunch Random!!! I just finshed this movie a couople hours ago & I was amazed on how beatuiful yet how seious this movie is(unlike most Hollywood movies). Besides marjane, her grandmother was my favorite character. This film will defintely stand the test of time like "Graveyard of Fireflies."

  • i cannot think of a decent comment.

    so here is a half-ass comment.

  • Nice review. Even though I am not into either movies or graphic novels of that type, you did a great review.

  • More emotional than the Dark knight, eh? Hmm......

    Good review.

  • Nice review, I never heard of it before.

  • =O really better then The Dark Knight

    I have to see this movie

  • Good review dude you made good points

  • I happen to know David Gasman, one of the voice actors.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more