HAHAHA This is great!! Especially towards the end with her little ad libs. 20 years later and she can STILL sing her earlier songs! Bravo Queen Mariah!!! Of course its in a different key but I dont think Mariah ever sang it in the original recording's key even in her prime. She really deserves a huge pat on the back. If whitney ever saw this she would be SOOOOOO PISSED and would probably smoke herself into oblivion LMAO!!
@capcomfighter13 I think that for the first year after she released 'Emotions', she sang it in B, and then for the rest of her career she's always done it in B-flat...sorry, the music dork in me is showing. The original key is C.
Estupenda canción Pero siento que aora que ya pasaron los años le cuesta mucho aser el silbido que pero como yo siempre digo los años no pasan de envalde :( no importa ella sigue igual de hermosa y talentosa!!!!!!
come on guys let´s support her this is a very hard song to sing, she has more than 20 years of hard singing over her shoulders and still sounds better than every singer we have today!
3:30 she couldn't get the notes out and then @ 3:57 she manages to get them out (quite well I might add) and gives a look of surprise and satisfaction like "damn I'm good, still got it"
OMG I wonder how she didn't fall with that tight dress lol. True, her voice has improved, she only needs to rest a lot in her room with 20 humidifiers lol I wanna sleep in a sauna as well xD
The Greatest women singer and legend that has ever lived CRT FOREVER, I Love you with all my entire heart and soul and you will always be the greatest to me.. Even past the end of time CRT FOREVER
@JuliannaMarieL No but she was on hormones which cause a woman to gain a few, well a LOT of Lbs, my mom's sister was like that when she was trying to conceived my twin baby cousins....
why do you compare them ? I love Beyoncé but I love Mariah too, and Mariah loves Beyoncé too, Beyoncé loves her too. They're both great on their own style.
I think she's improving... This may not be as good as in the 90s, but i think it's better and more powerful than in 2000, in the Rainbow Tour, the last time she performed it. I hope she rests very well so her next album will be totally huge.
People need to leave her alone, it's getting annoying now! Mariah is human & her voice very, very, very different than alot of people's. . . Most people don't sing the way she does so they don't need to rest their Voice, but she Does & all the saying she's lipping Stfu who cares she's gave us plenty of Beautiful live vocal performances & if she doesn't wanna sing live who cares! & Dont act like you know when she's lipping cause you don't, even if you do think your close to her entourage!
If you don't like her "Why Are You On A You-Tube Video Of Her!" People wonder why she say's "This Is For My Real Fans!" or when she's asked about her fans she say's the "Real Fans," it's because Fans don't turn on you because others have or because you change your Hair or wear more Make-Up than when you were young or because you Change your music style, or because you gain Weight!
As a Mariah fan i always keep in mind that Mariah doesn't have to sing she's Filthy-Rich! Mariah sings because it's what she loves to do! & Whenever i see her Live or listen to her i can tell she cares about her fans & their Opinions, but it's her life & Career! Mariah has alot more to her than just a voice until you find out your not a "REAL-FAN!"
I agree with the supporters that the recover was very nice but I'm sorry there is no denying that she didn't actually sing the whistle notes in the bridge or at the end. I love her and think she's amazing but she didnt sing those notes. sorry
She might have had a little slip up towards the end the notes didn't come out, but she killed that shit at the very end most ppl couldn't hit those notes in a million yrs. so Bam!!!
I Love you 4ever and always... #1 singer and hero... Even past the end of time CRT Forever... i love you with all my heart, Thanks for always being that One person on this entire planet that make me feel Like Im special and worth something.. just with your angel voice that no other human being can touch.. CRT forever
@FanaticoManiatico what's the point in mentioning it when she did it at the end. i was glad she messed up at 3:30 because the ad libs between the first attempt and when she aced it were amazing. you and the ignorant troll XgiugioX can have the strongest seat in the corner.
@FanaticoManiatico actually you are a joke. are you upset that you've been shut down by my response. go sit in the corner and let it marinate. no one believes you.
I Love you Mariah Carey... From the Bottom of my heart..CRT forever!!!! People for the billion gatenlith time She is a REAL 10000% singer. her voice needs lots of rest just like every other singer does, and when she does, SHE IS SO Amazing, She is A GODESS PERIDO!!! otherwise she wouldnt be where shes at now.. And I will always be her number one fan.. Forever and always CRT forever.. i dont care if anyone else on the entire Planet is! I always will.. Forever crt
I Love you from The Bottom of my heart, I know from the Bottom of my heart you are the best singer this world has and will ever know.. No other human being can touch that Phanomenal Voice.. Just keep that with you always From CRT Forever I Love you
ANY MARIAH LAMB NEEDS TO READ THIS! WHEN U LISTEN TO THIS PERFORMANCE AND THEN FAST FORWARD TO HER CONCERT IN SINGAPORE WHICH WASNT ALL THAT GOOD THEN FAST FORWARD TO HER MCIIY LP..NOW ISNT IT STRANGE THAT ON MCIIY SHE SOUNDS BETTER THAN SHE HAS ALL THIS DECADE BUT CANT PULL OFF THIS SONG WITH EASE!! THIS MAKES ME WONDER IF HER MERRY CHRISTMAS II YOU LP IS IN FACT HEAVILY DOCTORED AND INPUT WITH STUDIO TRICKERY AND ENHANCED VOCALS..AS A LAMB I WOULD TRULY PAY ATTENTION TO THIS AWARENESS!!
@MrQuadarius She had alot of vocal rest for MCIIY......I honestly think its because she had really given up her late night up days and alcohol because of her pregnancy.......
@TasteOfUrHoney SHE STARTED RECORDING MCIIY IN LATE JUNE AND FINISHED IN SEPTEMBER AND THE SINGAPORE CONCERT WAS IN MID APRIL SO MAYBE SHE DID HAVE PLENTY OF VOCAL REST..BUT MARIAH ALWAYS SAID WHEN SHE GOES ON VOCAL REST TALKING BECOMES VERY LIMITED 4 HER WHICH IS GOOD..AS A LAMB I BELIEVE IN MARIAH'S VOCALS BUT WHEN I HEAR LISTEN TO MCIIY OH SANTA AND O COME ALL YE FAITHFUL STICKS OUT TO ME AS IN BEING HEAVILY DOCTORED! ESP. THE WHISTLE RUNS IN OH SANTA AND THE FULL BELTING IN OCAYF!!
@MrQuadarius i dont think so. I also record songs and I can't sing some of my songs properly when live. Fact is, when recording, you have the luxury of re-recording a specific line of the song over and over until you nail it.
@FlashMedia1 BUT SEE AS LAMBS WE KNOW WHICH MARIAH ALBUM ERAS HAS THE WORST AND BEST LIVE VOCAL PERFORMANCES..WORST:E=MC2 ERA..BEST:DAYDREAM ERA (IN MY OPINION)! ITS VERY HARD TO DICIFER IF SHE ENHANCED HER VOCALS ON MCIIY B/C THE MEMOIRS ERA DID NOT HAVE THAT MANY GOOD PERFORMANCES..IN MY OPINION WHEN SHE PERFORMED IWTKWLI ON UK X FACTOR WAS THE BEST PERFORMANCE OF THAT ERA..INCLUDING EMOTIONS AT MADISON SQUARE GARDEN ON THE AA TOUR! I HOPE MCIIY VOCALS ARE ON THE NEXT "COMEBACK" ALBUM!!
bull shit she didn't lose her babies IDIOTS stop puting!! 2011 news in 2010s she is due to her lovely twins with nick sometime in april or june.... by the way no of yall can sing like mariah NEVER... i love u mariah... :)
seriously, she need to stops singing this tune and less more on her future tour... she already sang on daydream, butterfly and rainbow as the 1st song... i do believe people can get sick listening to this song...
@thisiswan2009 LoL I once attended her concert and I was thrilled she sang this LIVE... I think she had not sung this since "Charmbracelet" and "TAOM" tour and this song's performance shows that Mariah still has the voice =D I prefer she change "Always Be My Baby" with other B-sides option
@edwinsurijah yeah she should had change this song like maybe love takes time or anytime you need a friend or maybe close my eyes because those songs are also old schoolz what!
That old song and that voice that has always been just magical in the industry. Still can't believe she's going to be a mother, but as a singer she will always be my favourite. Go Mariah :D
stevendjie indeed...in 3:32 she forgot that the whitle is on the next chorus, lol you have a good eye. Even though she is not singing here i still love her.
@DonLouiVer Yeah, cause Madonne is making cheap clubbing-music for the gays and teenagers. Mariah has always been way more musical, so she doesnt need those huge crowds and big shows
as a matter of fact...i respect Mariah's musicality. her longevity as a singer/songwriter will be the same as Madonna. both of them are still the force to reckon with in the music industry. but when it comes to live shows...Madonna tops them all. we all know that.
3:32 ->> HAHA.... she forgot that the whistle is on the next chorus... that proves that she was lipsyncing the whistle.... also, 2:48 is fake coz she never do the beginning melismas... in 90s she always went straight to the highest note and thats it....
@stevendjie haha 3:32 may be..but you FAILED 2:48...seems like you can't notice the differences..haha..it's actually different from the CD version ..go check it out and come back and tell me the nuances at the end..don't act as if you know everything..Oops
@stevendjie3:32 doesn't prove anything, sorry! You can only say that if she's covering her ears and 'pretending' to be whistling while the track plays her singing 'you got me feeling emotions...'. 2:48 is real! Can't she change the way of singing? Your arguments are entirely flawed ;)
Voices shouldn't wear with time. She is off key and has had a lot of strain. SHe has to really push to get the notes. You can hear the breath coming through the voice as if the vocal cords can not come together.
@beavertown2006 Pathetic....But everybody know that your mother's one is good to fuck! Ask everybody and u'll see cuz everybody tried your mother! Oh please could u come to take back ur mother, I don't want her anymore cuz I spent her a lot!
i jst luv how she is so natural ahe has had no surgeries ect. she is soo pretty she is da one who inspired me to sing n she is jst a wonderful women god bless her sou;
a clear sign this is completely live singing is the changing volume of her voice as she moves around and the mic moves. It's not perfect, but yet amazing. She hits the notes she is supposed to. After singing this song for 20 years she still sounds outstanding.
WHEN MARIAH delivers a PERFECT performance including vocals, expect some stupid haters saying she lipped. haha WELL HATERS, MARIAH WILL AND ALWAYS WILL HIT THOSE HIGH NOTES SO JUST STFU, LISTEN UNTIL YOUR EARS BLEED FUCKHOLES.
@underworld91200, pay attention to what I said. I didn't say that she's whistling there; she put her fingers to her ear like she does when she does the whistle note, but it wasn't at that moment to do it. I'm not a hater nor I am stupid, especially since I can spell my words correctly.
@JayCroix Ok I can spell my words correctly too, it was just a mistake, and i'm french and not american or englsh so I can make some mistakes ! And i'm sorry but i think that u've said that she was whistling so i'm sorry ! But some people get on my nerves when they say that she can't sing anymore and that she made her time, it piss me off 4 real !
@shaunboi94 because they're like tongue twisters and have thousands of layered vocals...lol i exaggerate but you get the idea...the thing is her newest songs rarely have a strong lead vocal and if it does just for a while...
i thought it was a baby bump recently, but this was all the way back in January... may be just that she put on weight..? or maybe she's been trying to have a baby for a long time?....
@YUPnNOPE Well, she is pregnant now. She was suppose to be in the Tyler Perry movie (for colored girls) she was suppose to play whoopies daughter but she backed out because she is pregnant. The actress that is her fill in said so on the view.
Can't nobody do it like My mariah, I Love you so much with my heart, U have given me so much hope and even as a kid you were my hero, and you always will be Forever, CRT
this is absolutelly NOT lipped!! you can hear her breath and hear that's she's kinda tired!! trust me, I'm a singer and I know when it's lipped or not and this is NOOOOOT lipped!! plus you can hear her voice crack sometimes, but anyway I love her so much Mariah is the best!!
it was lipped!!!!! look, she's at her wost vocal moment, she didn't dare to do the ladder in 2:47 even whey she was at her best vocal moments, the notes are identicals if you hear the cd, and they are identicall with another live performances from 2010, if you hear live performances from 90's, it's not in playback.
It's well known that mariah had lipped the high chest and whistle notes in her songs since 2000,in songs like emotions,obseessed,H.A.T.E.U..and nobody can deny .
@soulandmore its not lipped she was just in good vocal condition coz i remember her saying tht she was in deep vocal training and this proves it. The ladder is her doing it coz its got a different tone to it just like the other whistle parts also u can hear her breathe wen she goes for the notes if u listen closely so shut up and be thankfull she still sings for us
@Shazni1409 Sorry, but IMO she's lipping like she do playback in Obsessed, H.A.T.E.U.
Listen:Mariah is one of my favourite singers,I will never say any lie,I feel she isn't singing the whistle,she's used to lipp the most difficuld part of her songs,from 2000.
She's in a very bad vocal moment, I hope she will improve it and her special voice will come back,but,meanwhile she will continue lipping the high chest and whistle.
You can see Obsessed @ rockefeller,she lipped the high chest during 5 secs
@soulandmore If u r a true fan of Mariah you can see that it was not lipped. It shows that u doesn't look the video by precsion. It was not lipped and Mariah can still hit those High Note even after 19 yers after ! So if u could criticize her and tell bad things about her it means that ur not a true fan as u said !
@underworld91200 Look, I'm a true fan of Mariah, but that don't mean that I'm blind and deaf, she have never done this so perfectly, she's human!!! In fact, the playback that she use is the CD track, the same, it's obvious! she used this in every concert of this tour.
@soulandmore Ok ok but this is not a playback, she's just placing her earphone ! It's seems that she's whisteling but it's not. But you know before a performance she rest her voice during 2 days and she can't speak during those 2 days, so she could hit those high notes.
@underworld91200 I know that she can still sing, she's amazing, yeah, she was singing, but the whistle is't live, believe me, she made the preparation (rest her voice during 2 days and don't speak ) when she was 20, and she have never done this as the CD version, this is the cd version, SHE LIPSYNCHED the whistle.
Mariah is amazing, her vocal range is very brilliant, but she's 40, her voice is deteriorating( naturally), please don't mystify her!! she's Human!
@soulandmore LOL I know that she's human and i don't mistify her at all. I know that her vocal range is very brilliant and everything. Ok,maybe, but i'm not sure that, she lip-synced her whistle. And I know that she can still hit high notes even her voice is deteriorating. And as a fan i have to say that she can still high note because it's true even I know that she Lyp-sync some part of her songs like every singer, isn't ? So we just have to support her as fans ! ^^
@underworld91200 I think so, U're discusing an evidence!!!She lip synch her whistles and it's not bad, it's better accept the fact and understand her side, to be blind, deaf and lie yourself
it's my last comment, i prefer enjoying Mariah's voice (live and playback ^^)
@soulandmore I love that performance but you are right, she does lipsync the whistles, she did that in all her Emotiosn 2010 performances, maybe her whistle register is finally damaged. I don't think lipsyncing is a good thing at all, a true singer should never lipsync.
damn she's been eating good
infiniteobscure 2 weeks ago
I really want her to come back wit a new album this year!
1995trg 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
itspophoe 3 weeks ago
damn she's still the best!
Novaheart1998 3 weeks ago
I really don't know but why she sounds beautifully when she sings her songs in 90s-96s.. Rather than hiphop or Rnb???
fueledbyjoshua 3 weeks ago
I believe she is pregnant here???!!!
Lioness3033 1 month ago
what did she say @3:30???? what accident????
duckableable 1 month ago
at least she didnt lipsync it
ajrhobx 1 month ago
HAHAHA This is great!! Especially towards the end with her little ad libs. 20 years later and she can STILL sing her earlier songs! Bravo Queen Mariah!!! Of course its in a different key but I dont think Mariah ever sang it in the original recording's key even in her prime. She really deserves a huge pat on the back. If whitney ever saw this she would be SOOOOOO PISSED and would probably smoke herself into oblivion LMAO!!
capcomfighter13 1 month ago
@capcomfighter13 I think that for the first year after she released 'Emotions', she sang it in B, and then for the rest of her career she's always done it in B-flat...sorry, the music dork in me is showing. The original key is C.
Wagnerlover777 1 month ago
@Wagnerlover777 the whistle note was really low cause she needs a long rest..... very long
chesleycareystar 1 month ago
is she pregnant there??
ajrhobx 2 months ago
@ajrhobx she's on hormones for her Pregnancy a year ago.
chesleycareystar 1 month ago
yup,,me too i believed the will never
ajrhobx 2 months ago
Wow! Great performance considering her vocal damage!
musicisunityandlove 2 months ago
lady gaga and beyonce will never hit that note.
im sure with that.
carlmatthew1970 2 months ago
Estupenda canción Pero siento que aora que ya pasaron los años le cuesta mucho aser el silbido que pero como yo siempre digo los años no pasan de envalde :( no importa ella sigue igual de hermosa y talentosa!!!!!!
MrLeslita20 2 months ago
you can actually hear mary anne use her high note at around 2:55-3:00 or so
psyunicorn 2 months ago
@psyunicorn I didn't hear it
Crzymofo69 2 months ago
4:00 aww.. she felt so genuinely pleased with her singing there.
turkeyroast100 2 months ago
Mariah was "ON" that night!!!!
Successintheprocess 3 months ago
Esssssdzzz
Love2babydoll 3 months ago
#1 Queen Forever and always.. CRT FOREVER
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 3 months ago
Her voice isn't like it was before, but she's still great
JJLopesz 4 months ago 3
2:46 - 2:53 =O nais.
JCGandMe 4 months ago
she sounds AMAZING!!! More than 20 years from the release of this song as sounds so great.
kevgonzal85 4 months ago 2
come on guys let´s support her this is a very hard song to sing, she has more than 20 years of hard singing over her shoulders and still sounds better than every singer we have today!
juan85360 4 months ago
3:30 she couldn't get the notes out and then @ 3:57 she manages to get them out (quite well I might add) and gives a look of surprise and satisfaction like "damn I'm good, still got it"
wimpytx93 4 months ago 8
@wimpytx93 Yeah i noticed tht and she finally Did the 3rd whistle Hi-Hi-HIGH in its original key she usually does it different
jameld55 3 months ago
time can't stop this woman. soooooooo greattttttttttt MC
hyca14417 6 months ago 3
OMG I wonder how she didn't fall with that tight dress lol. True, her voice has improved, she only needs to rest a lot in her room with 20 humidifiers lol I wanna sleep in a sauna as well xD
charmedone43 6 months ago
The Greatest women singer and legend that has ever lived CRT FOREVER, I Love you with all my entire heart and soul and you will always be the greatest to me.. Even past the end of time CRT FOREVER
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 6 months ago 2
seems like a motherfucker of a song to sing!!!
mrinvincible2001 6 months ago
To me these notes at the end are top 5 of the best whistle notes in all her emotions performances. They sound very dolphin-like.
beachfanatic2010 6 months ago 35
i can watch the emotions live performances all day
herladylioness 6 months ago
i can watch the emotion live performances all day
herladylioness 6 months ago
was she pregnant lol? seriously?
JuliannaMarieL 7 months ago
@JuliannaMarieL not yet, she was taking hormones that made her gain weight.
iiAmitx3 6 months ago
@iiAmitx3 thank you : ))
JuliannaMarieL 6 months ago
@JuliannaMarieL PLUS that dress was very unflattering...
iiAmitx3 6 months ago
@JuliannaMarieL No but she was on hormones which cause a woman to gain a few, well a LOT of Lbs, my mom's sister was like that when she was trying to conceived my twin baby cousins....
MariahLambie92 6 months ago
is not the best whistle note shes ever did but hey i want to see beyonce or lady gaga hit that note
itspophoe 7 months ago 25
Comment removed
SmeeeelyCat 2 months ago
@itspophoe Ya, right!!! Even Celine, Whitney and Aretha cant do them!!
TheDanradcliffe 1 month ago
@TheDanradcliffe im a big mariah fan so i know what she is capable of doing and this is not one of her best
itspophoe 1 month ago
@itspophoe
why do you compare them ? I love Beyoncé but I love Mariah too, and Mariah loves Beyoncé too, Beyoncé loves her too. They're both great on their own style.
MissSamira59 1 month ago
@MissSamira59 easily cause i can lol they are both great but mariah is the best
itspophoe 3 weeks ago
I think she's improving... This may not be as good as in the 90s, but i think it's better and more powerful than in 2000, in the Rainbow Tour, the last time she performed it. I hope she rests very well so her next album will be totally huge.
singtofeel11 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
People need to leave her alone, it's getting annoying now! Mariah is human & her voice very, very, very different than alot of people's. . . Most people don't sing the way she does so they don't need to rest their Voice, but she Does & all the saying she's lipping Stfu who cares she's gave us plenty of Beautiful live vocal performances & if she doesn't wanna sing live who cares! & Dont act like you know when she's lipping cause you don't, even if you do think your close to her entourage!
mariahpowerful 7 months ago
If you don't like her "Why Are You On A You-Tube Video Of Her!" People wonder why she say's "This Is For My Real Fans!" or when she's asked about her fans she say's the "Real Fans," it's because Fans don't turn on you because others have or because you change your Hair or wear more Make-Up than when you were young or because you Change your music style, or because you gain Weight!
mariahpowerful 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
As a Mariah fan i always keep in mind that Mariah doesn't have to sing she's Filthy-Rich! Mariah sings because it's what she loves to do! & Whenever i see her Live or listen to her i can tell she cares about her fans & their Opinions, but it's her life & Career! Mariah has alot more to her than just a voice until you find out your not a "REAL-FAN!"
mariahpowerful 7 months ago
I agree with the supporters that the recover was very nice but I'm sorry there is no denying that she didn't actually sing the whistle notes in the bridge or at the end. I love her and think she's amazing but she didnt sing those notes. sorry
Imabetch1 7 months ago
@Imabetch1 Yes she did. Why would she TRY to sing the last few whistle notes and fail if she wasn't going to sing them?
Raimundo91 5 months ago
She might have had a little slip up towards the end the notes didn't come out, but she killed that shit at the very end most ppl couldn't hit those notes in a million yrs. so Bam!!!
MrChalaki 7 months ago
U betta hit dat not work it girl,, and ppl still underestimate her to this day stupidity is all that is if u doubt her with all she as accomplished
MrChalaki 7 months ago
she made it happen at the end. i love her.
thedynamicd85 7 months ago
I Love you 4ever and always... #1 singer and hero... Even past the end of time CRT Forever... i love you with all my heart, Thanks for always being that One person on this entire planet that make me feel Like Im special and worth something.. just with your angel voice that no other human being can touch.. CRT forever
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 7 months ago
3:30 #FAIL lol
FanaticoManiatico 7 months ago
@FanaticoManiatico what's the point in mentioning it when she did it at the end. i was glad she messed up at 3:30 because the ad libs between the first attempt and when she aced it were amazing. you and the ignorant troll XgiugioX can have the strongest seat in the corner.
thedynamicd85 7 months ago
@thedynamicd85 actually i'm a lambie you idiot....
FanaticoManiatico 7 months ago
@FanaticoManiatico actually you are a joke. are you upset that you've been shut down by my response. go sit in the corner and let it marinate. no one believes you.
thedynamicd85 7 months ago
PLAYBACK FAIL AT THE END
XgiugioX1 7 months ago
I like the transformation of her voice, from voice to whistle! 2:47
AkiMC2u 7 months ago
@3:32 is that a mistake? hope it's not...
seductivelydangerous 7 months ago
I Love you forever and ever, The best singer on the entire Planet.. and my hero and #1 in my heart even past the end of time CRT forever
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 8 months ago
This is Dolce&Gabbana Dress i love
Apisitique 8 months ago
I Love you Mariah Carey... From the Bottom of my heart..CRT forever!!!! People for the billion gatenlith time She is a REAL 10000% singer. her voice needs lots of rest just like every other singer does, and when she does, SHE IS SO Amazing, She is A GODESS PERIDO!!! otherwise she wouldnt be where shes at now.. And I will always be her number one fan.. Forever and always CRT forever.. i dont care if anyone else on the entire Planet is! I always will.. Forever crt
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 8 months ago
that thing on 2:47 seems on plyaback
MrMarshV 8 months ago
ILove you From The Bottom of my Heart, Always and Forever CRT my hero forever and always CRT forever
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 9 months ago
Yeahhhhh Emotions!!!!! :D
hernan24mba 9 months ago
I Love you from The Bottom of my heart, I know from the Bottom of my heart you are the best singer this world has and will ever know.. No other human being can touch that Phanomenal Voice.. Just keep that with you always From CRT Forever I Love you
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 9 months ago
ANY MARIAH LAMB NEEDS TO READ THIS! WHEN U LISTEN TO THIS PERFORMANCE AND THEN FAST FORWARD TO HER CONCERT IN SINGAPORE WHICH WASNT ALL THAT GOOD THEN FAST FORWARD TO HER MCIIY LP..NOW ISNT IT STRANGE THAT ON MCIIY SHE SOUNDS BETTER THAN SHE HAS ALL THIS DECADE BUT CANT PULL OFF THIS SONG WITH EASE!! THIS MAKES ME WONDER IF HER MERRY CHRISTMAS II YOU LP IS IN FACT HEAVILY DOCTORED AND INPUT WITH STUDIO TRICKERY AND ENHANCED VOCALS..AS A LAMB I WOULD TRULY PAY ATTENTION TO THIS AWARENESS!!
MrQuadarius 10 months ago
@MrQuadarius She had alot of vocal rest for MCIIY......I honestly think its because she had really given up her late night up days and alcohol because of her pregnancy.......
TasteOfUrHoney 10 months ago
@TasteOfUrHoney SHE STARTED RECORDING MCIIY IN LATE JUNE AND FINISHED IN SEPTEMBER AND THE SINGAPORE CONCERT WAS IN MID APRIL SO MAYBE SHE DID HAVE PLENTY OF VOCAL REST..BUT MARIAH ALWAYS SAID WHEN SHE GOES ON VOCAL REST TALKING BECOMES VERY LIMITED 4 HER WHICH IS GOOD..AS A LAMB I BELIEVE IN MARIAH'S VOCALS BUT WHEN I HEAR LISTEN TO MCIIY OH SANTA AND O COME ALL YE FAITHFUL STICKS OUT TO ME AS IN BEING HEAVILY DOCTORED! ESP. THE WHISTLE RUNS IN OH SANTA AND THE FULL BELTING IN OCAYF!!
MrQuadarius 10 months ago
@MrQuadarius i dont think so. I also record songs and I can't sing some of my songs properly when live. Fact is, when recording, you have the luxury of re-recording a specific line of the song over and over until you nail it.
FlashMedia1 10 months ago
@FlashMedia1 BUT SEE AS LAMBS WE KNOW WHICH MARIAH ALBUM ERAS HAS THE WORST AND BEST LIVE VOCAL PERFORMANCES..WORST:E=MC2 ERA..BEST:DAYDREAM ERA (IN MY OPINION)! ITS VERY HARD TO DICIFER IF SHE ENHANCED HER VOCALS ON MCIIY B/C THE MEMOIRS ERA DID NOT HAVE THAT MANY GOOD PERFORMANCES..IN MY OPINION WHEN SHE PERFORMED IWTKWLI ON UK X FACTOR WAS THE BEST PERFORMANCE OF THAT ERA..INCLUDING EMOTIONS AT MADISON SQUARE GARDEN ON THE AA TOUR! I HOPE MCIIY VOCALS ARE ON THE NEXT "COMEBACK" ALBUM!!
MrQuadarius 10 months ago
@MrQuadarius IS YOUR CAPS LOCK BUTTON BROKEN?
MCisthebestbyfar 9 months ago
bull shit she didn't lose her babies IDIOTS stop puting!! 2011 news in 2010s she is due to her lovely twins with nick sometime in april or june.... by the way no of yall can sing like mariah NEVER... i love u mariah... :)
vybzmafia16 10 months ago
Kill it Baby Forever and EVER CRT
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 10 months ago
fat fat fat
love MC
KIKEMONDACA 10 months ago
she was like a month pregnant here?
aquamarine11500 11 months ago
@aquamarine11500 no this was in january 2010 she would have her babies now if she was pregnant here.
BlanketGirly11 10 months ago
@BlanketGirly11 Yes she was pregnant..But lost her baby..
SHe kept it secret for months...
darwin1902 10 months ago
@darwin1902 She did lose her baby but that was in 2008.
BlanketGirly11 10 months ago
I Love You soo Much From The Bottom of my heart, Always and Forever!!!! Happy Birthday!!!
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 11 months ago
seriously, she need to stops singing this tune and less more on her future tour... she already sang on daydream, butterfly and rainbow as the 1st song... i do believe people can get sick listening to this song...
thisiswan2009 11 months ago
@thisiswan2009 LoL I once attended her concert and I was thrilled she sang this LIVE... I think she had not sung this since "Charmbracelet" and "TAOM" tour and this song's performance shows that Mariah still has the voice =D I prefer she change "Always Be My Baby" with other B-sides option
edwinsurijah 11 months ago
@edwinsurijah yeah she should had change this song like maybe love takes time or anytime you need a friend or maybe close my eyes because those songs are also old schoolz what!
thisiswan2009 11 months ago
@thisiswan2009 she hasn't sung this song in probably ten years...
jakey1126 7 months ago
That old song and that voice that has always been just magical in the industry. Still can't believe she's going to be a mother, but as a singer she will always be my favourite. Go Mariah :D
Tacheles0 11 months ago
great quality (:
iiAmitx3 11 months ago
the last whistle arnt live...
Richiethorpe 1 year ago
stevendjie indeed...in 3:32 she forgot that the whitle is on the next chorus, lol you have a good eye. Even though she is not singing here i still love her.
beachfanatic2010 1 year ago
@beachfanatic2010 True!
Crzymofo69 2 months ago
just like Whitney...this concert is a lop...
only Madonna can bring in the cash and large crowds concert-wise
DonLouiVer 1 year ago
@DonLouiVer Yeah, cause Madonne is making cheap clubbing-music for the gays and teenagers. Mariah has always been way more musical, so she doesnt need those huge crowds and big shows
Tacheles0 11 months ago
@Tacheles0
as a matter of fact...i respect Mariah's musicality. her longevity as a singer/songwriter will be the same as Madonna. both of them are still the force to reckon with in the music industry. but when it comes to live shows...Madonna tops them all. we all know that.
DonLouiVer 11 months ago
3:32 ->> HAHA.... she forgot that the whistle is on the next chorus... that proves that she was lipsyncing the whistle.... also, 2:48 is fake coz she never do the beginning melismas... in 90s she always went straight to the highest note and thats it....
stevendjie 1 year ago
@stevendjie haha 3:32 may be..but you FAILED 2:48...seems like you can't notice the differences..haha..it's actually different from the CD version ..go check it out and come back and tell me the nuances at the end..don't act as if you know everything..Oops
kelvinpyaeko 1 year ago
@stevendjie 3:32 doesn't prove anything, sorry! You can only say that if she's covering her ears and 'pretending' to be whistling while the track plays her singing 'you got me feeling emotions...'. 2:48 is real! Can't she change the way of singing? Your arguments are entirely flawed ;)
Cyberdrill 1 year ago
i love how she chuckles before easily singing in the whistle register...while walking across the stage...YEEEESSSS MARIAH!!!
abx9 1 year ago
Voices shouldn't wear with time. She is off key and has had a lot of strain. SHe has to really push to get the notes. You can hear the breath coming through the voice as if the vocal cords can not come together.
SOTSV 1 year ago
Wasn't she pregnant
jayoncestan12 1 year ago
amazing in the end of the song just great
Lugaoexpress 1 year ago
So fat as a pig.
beavertown2006 1 year ago
@beavertown2006 take he to the gym so u all can lose the weight tgther asshole
kugi123 1 year ago
@beavertown2006 Yeah, gaining weight when ur pregnant, that happens sometimes. -_-
BlanketGirly11 1 year ago
@beavertown2006 hahhhhaa, thats funny lol.
lemvin04 1 year ago
@beavertown2006 DIE
Crzymofo69 1 year ago
@beavertown2006 And you are so stupid as a monkey ;)
underworld91200 9 months ago
@underworld91200 Back to your mother.
beavertown2006 9 months ago
@beavertown2006 Oh I can't cuz I'm with yours!
underworld91200 9 months ago
@underworld91200 LOL, your mother's dry cunt no one fucks.
beavertown2006 9 months ago
@beavertown2006 Pathetic....But everybody know that your mother's one is good to fuck! Ask everybody and u'll see cuz everybody tried your mother! Oh please could u come to take back ur mother, I don't want her anymore cuz I spent her a lot!
underworld91200 9 months ago
@underworld91200 You wish. LOL.
beavertown2006 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@beavertown2006 Not at all because it's the truth and u can't accept it, ur mother is a bitch hihi!
underworld91200 9 months ago
i jst luv how she is so natural ahe has had no surgeries ect. she is soo pretty she is da one who inspired me to sing n she is jst a wonderful women god bless her sou;
itzmebarbiebitch12 1 year ago
Love U Mariah! ^^
soulandmore 1 year ago 7
she is singing it! totally live, it is obvious. She is still able to sing it in the original key after 20 years! she is amazing
lemonchel0 1 year ago
a clear sign this is completely live singing is the changing volume of her voice as she moves around and the mic moves. It's not perfect, but yet amazing. She hits the notes she is supposed to. After singing this song for 20 years she still sounds outstanding.
dkutsc1 1 year ago
ah just looove those high notes
they keep on crushing them haters to death!!!
bet the whales were disturbed at some point..=)
pathetiquebeachloser 1 year ago
@ :15 she said "I can barely hear it turn it up please"
deshawnhawkins2 1 year ago
i love you mariah, Crt forever
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 1 year ago
good but not as good as she used to be!!
she's losing it :/
</3
MrLiamantonyhoughton 1 year ago
WHEN MARIAH delivers a PERFECT performance including vocals, expect some stupid haters saying she lipped. haha WELL HATERS, MARIAH WILL AND ALWAYS WILL HIT THOSE HIGH NOTES SO JUST STFU, LISTEN UNTIL YOUR EARS BLEED FUCKHOLES.
malandiaq 1 year ago
I Love you Forever and ever charles Ryan Thornton....
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 1 year ago
I love you so much Forever and ever the best singer on the Planet
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 1 year ago
Oh my god haters, i love you From the bottom of my heart always and Forever CRT
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 1 year ago
@ 3:02 - "That's your note baby, I can't hit that." PRICELESS!!!!
@ 3:31, did she forget that the whistle is not right then? Hmmm..
All in all, good performance.
JayCroix 1 year ago
@JayCroix Did u thing that it's funny ! She's not whisteling at 3:31 ! So u can keep ur ironie for u and other stupid people who r haters like u !
underworld91200 1 year ago
@underworld91200, pay attention to what I said. I didn't say that she's whistling there; she put her fingers to her ear like she does when she does the whistle note, but it wasn't at that moment to do it. I'm not a hater nor I am stupid, especially since I can spell my words correctly.
JayCroix 1 year ago
@JayCroix Ok I can spell my words correctly too, it was just a mistake, and i'm french and not american or englsh so I can make some mistakes ! And i'm sorry but i think that u've said that she was whistling so i'm sorry ! But some people get on my nerves when they say that she can't sing anymore and that she made her time, it piss me off 4 real !
underworld91200 1 year ago
@JayCroix Lol, I love 3:02!
Crzymofo69 2 months ago
when she sings live all her old songs she sings amazing but its her new songs that she sings not aswel live
shaunboi94 1 year ago
@shaunboi94 because they're like tongue twisters and have thousands of layered vocals...lol i exaggerate but you get the idea...the thing is her newest songs rarely have a strong lead vocal and if it does just for a while...
JPhillippeMusic 1 year ago
@shaunboi94 - yes that is so true. I wonder why.
calleridcallerid 1 year ago
Oh shes preggy...and still doing shows....wow
hasher22 1 year ago
The Note Is F6-F6-Bb6-Eb7
jhaypee100 1 year ago
I was there! It was all live and she hit every note!!!!! 2nd row! She was amazing.
greeneyedboriqua 1 year ago
i thought it was a baby bump recently, but this was all the way back in January... may be just that she put on weight..? or maybe she's been trying to have a baby for a long time?....
YUPnNOPE 1 year ago
@YUPnNOPE Well, she is pregnant now. She was suppose to be in the Tyler Perry movie (for colored girls) she was suppose to play whoopies daughter but she backed out because she is pregnant. The actress that is her fill in said so on the view.
greeneyedboriqua 1 year ago
@YUPnNOPE she took progesterone
JPhillippeMusic 1 year ago
she sings well., maybe good hormones? bec shes pregnannt?
kyupid15mikey 1 year ago
i saw her in detroit and was soooo excited she did this one
McPheever1144 1 year ago
GOD BLESS MARIAH SHE IS A TRUE ANGEL
victormanuel1976 1 year ago
of course she can still hit those notes! she's the best!
MsDolo08 1 year ago
Forever and Ever The best singer on The planet..., And My hero for all Time, CRT
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 1 year ago
I Toatally agree and she is The best singer on The Planet, i love you Forever and Always CRT
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 1 year ago
She totally NAILED IT! Love u Mariah xx
ticklemecrazy 1 year ago 6
THANKS FOR POSTNG
ticklemecrazy 1 year ago
Can't nobody do it like My mariah, I Love you so much with my heart, U have given me so much hope and even as a kid you were my hero, and you always will be Forever, CRT
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 1 year ago
OMG look at her belly giggles
clawsonangel1990 1 year ago
Let's hope U never ge one then! ... giggles! We all do! Its called Growing older!! Unless U have a LIPOSUCTION machine!!
ticklemecrazy 1 year ago
The whistles arn't good but they are real! Got it Mimi is back!
296218047 1 year ago
I'm shocked O.O That was NOOOOT LIPPED! MOTHERF***ER!
loveavril92ki 1 year ago
this is absolutelly NOT lipped!! you can hear her breath and hear that's she's kinda tired!! trust me, I'm a singer and I know when it's lipped or not and this is NOOOOOT lipped!! plus you can hear her voice crack sometimes, but anyway I love her so much Mariah is the best!!
MRTromp1 1 year ago
A singer is a singer, not a model ... pfff
Mariah is the best singer ever !
Eyenem 1 year ago
You guys make it sound like putting on weight is a crime!
PinkBabey 1 year ago
it was lipped!!!!! look, she's at her wost vocal moment, she didn't dare to do the ladder in 2:47 even whey she was at her best vocal moments, the notes are identicals if you hear the cd, and they are identicall with another live performances from 2010, if you hear live performances from 90's, it's not in playback.
It's well known that mariah had lipped the high chest and whistle notes in her songs since 2000,in songs like emotions,obseessed,H.A.T.E.U..and nobody can deny .
just another playback
soulandmore 1 year ago
@soulandmore its not lipped she was just in good vocal condition coz i remember her saying tht she was in deep vocal training and this proves it. The ladder is her doing it coz its got a different tone to it just like the other whistle parts also u can hear her breathe wen she goes for the notes if u listen closely so shut up and be thankfull she still sings for us
Shazni1409 1 year ago
@Shazni1409 Sorry, but IMO she's lipping like she do playback in Obsessed, H.A.T.E.U.
Listen:Mariah is one of my favourite singers,I will never say any lie,I feel she isn't singing the whistle,she's used to lipp the most difficuld part of her songs,from 2000.
She's in a very bad vocal moment, I hope she will improve it and her special voice will come back,but,meanwhile she will continue lipping the high chest and whistle.
You can see Obsessed @ rockefeller,she lipped the high chest during 5 secs
soulandmore 1 year ago
Comment removed
underworld91200 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@soulandmore If u r a true fan of Mariah you can see that it was not lipped. It shows that u doesn't look the video by precsion. It was not lipped and Mariah can still hit those High Note even after 19 yers after ! So if u could criticize her and tell bad things about her it means that ur not a true fan as u said !
underworld91200 1 year ago
@underworld91200 Look, I'm a true fan of Mariah, but that don't mean that I'm blind and deaf, she have never done this so perfectly, she's human!!! In fact, the playback that she use is the CD track, the same, it's obvious! she used this in every concert of this tour.
I also insist I'm fan, not deaf and blind
soulandmore 1 year ago
@soulandmore Ok ok but this is not a playback, she's just placing her earphone ! It's seems that she's whisteling but it's not. But you know before a performance she rest her voice during 2 days and she can't speak during those 2 days, so she could hit those high notes.
underworld91200 1 year ago
@underworld91200 I know that she can still sing, she's amazing, yeah, she was singing, but the whistle is't live, believe me, she made the preparation (rest her voice during 2 days and don't speak ) when she was 20, and she have never done this as the CD version, this is the cd version, SHE LIPSYNCHED the whistle.
Mariah is amazing, her vocal range is very brilliant, but she's 40, her voice is deteriorating( naturally), please don't mystify her!! she's Human!
soulandmore 1 year ago
@soulandmore LOL I know that she's human and i don't mistify her at all. I know that her vocal range is very brilliant and everything. Ok,maybe, but i'm not sure that, she lip-synced her whistle. And I know that she can still hit high notes even her voice is deteriorating. And as a fan i have to say that she can still high note because it's true even I know that she Lyp-sync some part of her songs like every singer, isn't ? So we just have to support her as fans ! ^^
underworld91200 1 year ago
@underworld91200 And what do you think that I'm doing? I'm supporting her!!! it's normal that she lip synch the whistle notes!!!
Don't missunderstand me!
soulandmore 1 year ago
@soulandmore I don't missunderstand you...I'm not stupid, what do you think ?!
underworld91200 1 year ago
@underworld91200 I think so, U're discusing an evidence!!!She lip synch her whistles and it's not bad, it's better accept the fact and understand her side, to be blind, deaf and lie yourself
it's my last comment, i prefer enjoying Mariah's voice (live and playback ^^)
soulandmore 1 year ago
@soulandmore I love that performance but you are right, she does lipsync the whistles, she did that in all her Emotiosn 2010 performances, maybe her whistle register is finally damaged. I don't think lipsyncing is a good thing at all, a true singer should never lipsync.
theoneandonly2503 1 year ago