@lukefromdownunder Totally agree. You really have to go for it if you want to cover NMH, and he nails it. I might like this better than the original if the mix were better.
Glen Hansard's one of the few people who have the voice and the stones to sing this song. Most excellently done and so faithful to the NMH gestalt, especially with the fusion of KoCF P2...
I find it really interesting that in the original song Jeff had a slightly "British" way of pronouncing certain words around the chorus (like hear, take, all, breaking, inside, eyes, probably a few others), while in this cover Glen's take on them sounds more "American" even though he's Irish.
This is a really talented cover, but I genuinely feel they didn't need so much noise. The original was solely acoustic guitar. Why did they need harmony, keyboard, drums, guitar, AND bass? It was too much.
If i didn't love the original so much I'd love this. But the way he screams the last verse where Jeff Magnum laments it in dark undertone kills this cover for me.
@outofstep23x i disagree. i dont think its anywhere near the original, but its not bad. and a good cover can just be a tribute... it doesnt have to be compared to the original
@juliandsouza The biggest difference between the two covers is that this dude has such a powerful voice, much like JM. The band also adds such an awesome dynamic to the song.
Amazing.. you cant seem to find any really good quality versions by Neutral or by Jeff Mangum. This has made me like Thw Swell Season even more.. Quality.
Wow....Fucking amazing!
bigblueandshiney 1 month ago 2
Great cover. Marketa's hair looks great lol
AstroMikeDexter 1 month ago
What was the song from about 5:34? Is that by The Swell Season?
popatire23 1 month ago
@popatire23 it's a part of King of carrot flowers.Part 2 i think.It's a another neutral milk hotel song
swellframe 1 week ago
@swellframe
No, the song during the credits. Where they're all writing on the wall.
popatire23 6 days ago
he gets really really really really fucking into it haha, so passionate
lukefromdownunder 2 months ago
@lukefromdownunder Totally agree. You really have to go for it if you want to cover NMH, and he nails it. I might like this better than the original if the mix were better.
drgonzo90 2 months ago
This helped me learn to play it on bass. And I fell in love with The Frames. Thanks, much.
Coraircate 2 months ago
@charlotte07071 I am in the same place as you!
brok3nboy 4 months ago
Glen Hansard's one of the few people who have the voice and the stones to sing this song. Most excellently done and so faithful to the NMH gestalt, especially with the fusion of KoCF P2...
jimnypivo 5 months ago
Fuck man, this is good. I love this.
MrLeo160 6 months ago
ew
TheTerriblyTerrific1 7 months ago
in the aeroplane over the sea cover --- lauren heenan (you tube)
martinheenan 8 months ago
glen + NMH cover = magic
martinheenan 8 months ago 3
Well if I wasn't already in love with Glen, this would surely make me fall.
SweetJaaane7 9 months ago
Nice to see a very decent band enjoying playing an excellent tune. Good work all!
Lovesupercar 10 months ago
not a huge fan of the guys voice, but these people FUCKING GET IT
RMPalm2000 10 months ago
Comment removed
Eupator5 11 months ago
I find it really interesting that in the original song Jeff had a slightly "British" way of pronouncing certain words around the chorus (like hear, take, all, breaking, inside, eyes, probably a few others), while in this cover Glen's take on them sounds more "American" even though he's Irish.
Eupator5 11 months ago 2
I LOOOOOOOOVE YOU JESUUUUUUUUUUUUS CAAAAAAHHHRIIIIIIIIIIIIIIISTTTTTTTT
Creamy360 1 year ago 10
This cover is amazing...Damn
mateodeusername 1 year ago 3
Wow, absolutely killer. They really do it justice.
speciesofpositive 1 year ago 2
This is a really talented cover, but I genuinely feel they didn't need so much noise. The original was solely acoustic guitar. Why did they need harmony, keyboard, drums, guitar, AND bass? It was too much.
Still not a bad cover though.
IxTASTExBETTER 1 year ago
Isn't he the guy from The Frames?! That's fucking awesome =D
benciano 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Fuck you Glenn. Nice faux-american accent. Neutral Milk Hotel shit on The Frames. It's a pity that guy in California missed.
barrybrien82 1 year ago
The cover and the original are amazing. Just enjoy music and pull your head out of your ass.
hungery12 1 year ago
If i didn't love the original so much I'd love this. But the way he screams the last verse where Jeff Magnum laments it in dark undertone kills this cover for me.
iImplying 1 year ago
@iImplying Exactly my thoughts; the last verse not climbing the octave when the others do makes the song for me.
ElWeasle 1 year ago
Perfection!!!
Lovesupercar 1 year ago
i'm so torn. if i'd never heard the original i'd love this. something about the way he just plows through the last verse really kills it for me.
tim4x 1 year ago
The one person who disliked this is probably some /mu/tant hispter faggot.
JacopeX 1 year ago
not a bad cover at all.
amandaurungus 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is an awful cover. If this doesn't make your skin crawl you are not a neutral milk hotel fan.
outofstep23x 1 year ago
@outofstep23x i disagree. i dont think its anywhere near the original, but its not bad. and a good cover can just be a tribute... it doesnt have to be compared to the original
plusnightlife 1 year ago
@outofstep23x
Get over yourself, you elitist
Stkieran 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@outofstep23x
Get over yourself, you elitist
Stkieran 1 year ago
Can't bate the an irish take on a classic tune :D Glen hansard rules. :)
dallan93 1 year ago
@dallan93 Yes! It's incredible, I agree.
HarveyManchesterEM 1 year ago
better than that fuckin dresden dolls cover
juliandsouza 1 year ago 3
@juliandsouza The biggest difference between the two covers is that this dude has such a powerful voice, much like JM. The band also adds such an awesome dynamic to the song.
BrettxHarvey 1 year ago 2
@BrettxHarvey agreed. also, theres none of that over the top hand movements and terrible singing either :)
juliandsouza 1 year ago
YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY KIDDING ME.
My favourite band and my favourite song. And I never even knew.
Fuck me.
charlotte07071 1 year ago 36
@charlotte07071 glenn's yell is probably the best sound in the universe. better than your new born baby.
marktrenkle 10 months ago 7
@charlotte07071 I actually looked at the title and presumed it was a different Swell Season. No way this band covered this song.
gammondorf 10 months ago
Good cover, but it's kind of missing that raw feeling that the original had.
1jon11 1 year ago
probably the best neutral milk hotel cover out there
WideAwakeCJM 1 year ago 38
Onde of the best covers I've ever listened.
higgobraga 1 year ago
Such a great cover of this tune...well done so quickly!
McNugger 1 year ago
It's hard to find a cover of this song as moving as the original. Swell Season is so Swell
JSDuncan2113 1 year ago 6
well done!! probably my favorite-of-the-moment cover ... will be sharing with as many as will listen.
Jinpagee 1 year ago
I just watched the Drive all night cover and this one.Amazing covers really.Both of them..BTW.......is that glen's guitar?
swellframe 1 year ago
@swellframe It is, but it's fixed up a bit :)
blz777 1 year ago
One of my favorite groups covering one of my favorite songs ever....thanks for uploading.
nctodc 1 year ago
eh... is that Mar????
visionz0 1 year ago
@visionz0 Yep!
Sara161616 1 year ago
Effin amazing
Sara161616 1 year ago
cute cute cute glen hansaaaaaaard
Janzah 1 year ago
Amazing.. you cant seem to find any really good quality versions by Neutral or by Jeff Mangum. This has made me like Thw Swell Season even more.. Quality.
organicate 1 year ago
Thanks for re-uploading! :-)
Stekala 1 year ago