JSGT - Christina Aguilera vs. Lady Gaga - Who Wins?

[atrayu90602]

Like them both..... I like Christina more

[bakatais]

Vocally, Christina Aguilera is much superior. She has a monstrous vocal range that spans 4 octaves and a semi note (C3 to C#7) and can sing every style from R&B to Pop or Rock to Jazz. Her range is second only to Mariah at her prime. She currently reigns supreme as the best vocalist since Mariah's and Whitney's voices got damaged.

Lady gaga puts on a more interesting show and relies on shock value to grab attention. She's currently at the top, but I dunno how long the gimmicks would last.

[Xtinasoul4life]

listening to the new songs that have leaked from Xtina's new album I honestly dont' see any comparisons, the only thing that people are comparing is the image, besides that..I don't think there is nothing to compare...XTINA has the vocals to back anything up...I like both artist & I think they are amazing, I think XTINA proved that she is no lady gaga when she performe YOU LOST ME, from her new album. It was just her & a mic, nothing else, no props or out of this world outfits.

[chevere200]

people dont you see the difference????...lady gaga has their way and christina has thers...but both of them have the same base...MADONNA''....MADONNA is and will be the only one....lady gaga is a just a copy in a different unverse of madonna, and christina too.....

i have a friend that she got for her b'day a jacket and after that lady gaga showed up with a very similar and every body was ahhh you look like lady gaga,,,people lady gaga is an imitation of madonna, dont forget that

[XxForeverDignityxX]

in my opinion i love GaGa i never really got into ChristinaA shes like eh for me- but LAdygaga is jsut super at what she does, and love her msuic style plus she seems more humble than Christina, like christina seems lik she walks around with big ego thinking shes the best thing ever but i dont really like her...but again thats my opinion!!!

[concert05]

they ARE BOTH Talented But at the end of the day their singers

and NO ONE can beat christian Aguilera Voice ..Point blank.. shes the only one who hasnt lost her voice unlike mariah or whitney ...i like lady gaga she cool but come on Christina has a blue eye voice which means 4 octave raNGE ..soUl