@Ekorslk you can sure as hell bet Eddie feels your pain. Oftentimes the most beautiful works of art written and made with blood, sweat, tears, broken hearts and darkest hours. This song is no exception. The same anguish you feel was made to write this song.
I lost my girl... 2 months later in a Pearl Jam concert in Costa Rica, while they were playing black, y ask her: do you want to be my gf again? She said: yes!, I think that it's obvious why this is my fucking favorite song!
i dont know the actual meaning of this song but its not deep enough to make the person said cause of what they are listening to, its good material of pearl jam but i dont even know if this song is about love or some sort.
fuck!!!! I still remember Sarah, that was some years ago, but every time I listen to this song, I still ask why? why? it can't be mine, why can't she be that star in my sky
I've said it before and I'll say it again. Whoever broke Eddie Vedder's heart is surely regretting it, you can really hear the pain in his voice. I always feel like he is singing this song directly to me.
UH, the lyrics in the video are so wrong... its "SHES an empty canvas/ under sheets of clay (skin)/ her legs spread out before me/ as her body lies still..." totally totally wrong
Always find this band for teenies. Nut later I find out this is really great. Well when you are nearly 50 every day you learn more what music have to be.
@bjaekley im sorry about your mom :( my mom passed away as well & my sister, my mom & i use 2 listen 2 pearl jam all the time as well you're mom was a hard worker...jus like mine but both of our moms are in a better place RIP to both of our moms
SEARCH NIRVANA FOR XMAS NO. 1 AND SUPPORT THE CAUSE!
Come on guys, like the page and buy the single (only when we need to, or it won't count). X Factor, at the end of the day, is just a huge money machine, making money out of the naive public.
I would bet since the refraction point of pearls is 2.64 meaning that if you'd fill a jar up it would look pretty pretty nice, in fact it would be wonderful =)
killer. empty yet whole. what the fuck and I thought I was nuts. How powerful to envoke meaning less energy for all I am and all Ill be. Fucking ass. Hope the russian mob wips out philly starting with ANNE.
I could listen to this all day every day and never get tired of it. The best part is how this song can make me happy and it can make me sad. So much emotion.
I grew up on pearl jam I was in high school when I first heard this song. I have many fond memory's of a girl and this song in my life and still it can take me back to every moment that I spent with her. 1994
dont worry people just type black and press search........thumbs up unless you wanna hear new million dollar exploit young kids......just dont press it
What got me to start listening to Pearl Jam? My mom would play this song every once in awhile in memory of my father whose favorite band was Pearl Jam. My dad was killed in Iraq three months before I was born, right after the gulf war, and I've never even seen his grave.
But one day, daddy, I'll visit you, so you can see how much I've grown up.
This is truely the best song of all time. Saddest song of all time also. Such deep meaning, and description of my life. I've never had a girlfriend in my and i'm 16 just because I'm ugly. People do not accept others for who they are, they just judge them by their facial appearances and looks.This song always let's me know I'm not alone. God Bless Eddie Vedder and Pearl Jam.
@jakesisk Do not talk like that and do not think like that. I thought like you aswell, but when I encouraged myself I found a girlfriend, but I wanted her like not in very deep sense if you understand, we just hanged out because she was pretty and I was a little bit. Then she left me, and I have understood that that "love" what I had is not love (I loved her because she was pretty). I am now looking for a woman for all my life, and you know what, I do not care if she will be pretty or not.
@jakesisk The most important thing what good girls want is GOOD and INTELEGENT man who she can talk with and share things. So learn to listen people especially girls when they talk. There is a russian writer Leo Tolstoy, who at your age thought he is ugly and he will not have a girl for all life (and he was not pretty he admitted) he was very shy. But then he had some life experience and this "ugly" guy had so many girls, it was hard to believe. I encaurage you to read him. "Childhood" Anna care
@jakesisk Open your heart and love will fill that void. It has nothing to do with what you look like. Trust me on this one. There is someone for everyone if you just open your heart to people.
Having not been in a relationship .. now turning 25 .. i truly hate myself sometimes and feel i have wasted my life ... Well this song is my only inspiration right now .. :)
The story of my fukken life!
iltfiltfiltf 1 day ago
This is one of my all-time favorite songs. Thank you for putting together a stellar journey/ I really needed this vacation. You did a phantasmic job.
starpolaris1 2 days ago
im not being sarcastic, i actually love this quality. it's like deeper somehow...
pnoplyr14 2 days ago
just black =)
Jprado31 3 days ago
236 people do not know what is music and people know what 8510 is talent
kimaloux 3 days ago
i get so da mn close to crying when i listen to this
47issues 4 days ago
This was, is and always will be their best song.
SeveralSeveredShins 5 days ago
So a girl broke my heart, and I can't Help but to cry when I listen to this. Anybody else feel my pain? Haha
Ekorslk 1 week ago
@Ekorslk you can sure as hell bet Eddie feels your pain. Oftentimes the most beautiful works of art written and made with blood, sweat, tears, broken hearts and darkest hours. This song is no exception. The same anguish you feel was made to write this song.
Viper102650 5 days ago
liza i love you. shame you hate me. I would've given you my world babe
Fknnhostile 1 week ago 2
I want this shit on FLAC !!!!
BerzurcusCircus 1 week ago in playlist Favorite videos
Song reminds me of my ex boyfriend. im n another country but am flying back for him sooo going to boom this song on the plane hehe
Kiripop88 1 week ago
I lost my girl... 2 months later in a Pearl Jam concert in Costa Rica, while they were playing black, y ask her: do you want to be my gf again? She said: yes!, I think that it's obvious why this is my fucking favorite song!
djs3794 1 week ago 2
iv lost my girl who i love and i miss her so much i just want to have her back and make a real go of things
murphy001able 1 week ago
234 people, THE HECK IS WRONG WITH YOU!?!?!?
Crixilis 1 week ago
song perfect!
PERUTECHNO 2 weeks ago
i dont know the actual meaning of this song but its not deep enough to make the person said cause of what they are listening to, its good material of pearl jam but i dont even know if this song is about love or some sort.
augie150 2 weeks ago
@augie150 Of course it's about love. How can you not know that? It's about the guy no longer having the girl in his life that he loved. Come on now.
Explorer4Truth 1 week ago
@augie150 isn´t that one of beautiful things about music and their lyrics? you decide the meaning that the song has...
hfbikes 3 days ago
I KNOW SOMEDAY YOU'LL HAVE A BEAUTIFUL LIFE
I KNOW YOU'LL BE A STAR
IN SOMEBODY ELSE'S SKY
BUT WHY? WHY?? WHY???
CAN'T IT BE
WHY CAN'T IT BE MINEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
most beautiful lyrics i've ever seen..
nickoulis 2 weeks ago 13
@nickoulis :'( So much feel.
potophan94 1 day ago
Who the fuck don't like this. Look the like bar I can't believe that there are 230 dislikes...
VanVictorious 2 weeks ago 2
the words on the video are not all correct. the right words are posted inside the cd cover jacket.
9231426 2 weeks ago
I just broke the volume knob on my speaker, from trying to turn this S#!T up TOO LOUD, BEST SONG OF ALL TIMEEE!!!
SimplyDredging 3 weeks ago
229 personas no saben nada de musica .l.
essaonda 3 weeks ago
Graaaaaaaaaande pearl jam csssm !
vickytaanicole 3 weeks ago
tema qla la zorra
jordansevenfold 3 weeks ago
amazing song, but... this copy sounds like it was recorded in a port-a-potty, there are much clearer versions out there
LtSump 3 weeks ago 3
229 people like justin bieber
sagiv01231 3 weeks ago 3
TEMASSO GRANDE PEARL JAM CTM!!
croicer 3 weeks ago
Brilliant song!
dexteri 3 weeks ago
Epiphany... Genius...Wow
creativewriter1000 3 weeks ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sucks D:
Markus019 3 weeks ago
@Markus019 ur a DICK this man can write songs so much better then u ever could
gerb10028 3 weeks ago in playlist beast
227 people got a pearl necklace instead of a Pearl Jam cd for christmas! :D
cigs1224 3 weeks ago
My life :'(
xxTR3V0RCxx 3 weeks ago
Sometimes I listen to this song over and over again all day long. "I'm spinning".
PoetryPoemsPoets 3 weeks ago
My whole world is BLACK!
PoetryPoemsPoets 3 weeks ago
the desperate screams at the end mixed with all the lyrics ... really tears me inside, makes me cry
Fannakendlor188 3 weeks ago 2
Comment removed
Fannakendlor188 3 weeks ago
best song........my God who's judge? Mr.Jack Daniels?
gigimingarini 4 weeks ago
Did you upload this through a fuckin sea shell? Wtf man.
castoni2 4 weeks ago
krusko ti brusko, cerah ki numistuda pranusko!!!
moreiradeco 1 month ago
for me this will always be History class with Mr Nolan...And Amy Walker, and Ian Roullier. legends every one
solentgreenispeople 1 month ago
Why does this sound underwater though
WarGoatForestWolf666 1 month ago in playlist grunge
The best and most powerful song ever created!
Ryukotaro 1 month ago
i love grunge musiic! pearl jam rocks!
009RaulF 1 month ago
Great fucking song. Lyrical genius pearl jam is. PJ 4 life!
easyriderzombie 1 month ago
Creep from Stone Temple Pilots and Black from Pearl Jam are two of the best songs in my opinion! ^.^ <3
TheLoveNotWar1000 1 month ago
horrible quality
MrSnuggs 1 month ago
Amazing video, Love it even more knowing that these pictures are real stars and nebulae :)
cazkelly 1 month ago
fuck ;-(
SuperKare123 1 month ago
"All the love gone bad, turned my world to black..." Amazing.
AutumnNatashaCole 1 month ago
Great band,a true Rock And Roll band! A fantastic song! Wonderful video!
LuizEduardo205 1 month ago
I love the raw pain you can hear in Eddie Vedder's voice. The lyrics are amazing.
AkzulSaulie1993 1 month ago
226 personas no saven que es Musica
maurixtone 1 month ago
He's seriously an underrated writer! I mean yeah we know & hear it, but man! ... no words.... Legend!
MegaBee100 1 month ago
Why would someone ever possibly dislike this?
Brendanfranke 1 month ago
Absolutely beautiful!
peoplehatinwaitress 1 month ago
@Awezumi
Because it is the sun that brings light and warmth and all that to b.s.
mercesletifer2509 1 month ago
fuck!!!! I still remember Sarah, that was some years ago, but every time I listen to this song, I still ask why? why? it can't be mine, why can't she be that star in my sky
fuck Everything!
idthlm 1 month ago
225 people did't have there speakers on.
dexteri 1 month ago 55
@dexteri 8518 people are used to the crappy video quality most of the people upload.
swerndly 3 days ago
Toliko puno emocija...uh, naježim se. Great. Love you Eddie
vrtirepka100 1 month ago 4
This is my favorite song by Pearl Jam
drewsexxx 1 month ago
cudnt agree more on the caption
thebalaabodu 1 month ago
show
johnnys2brenno 1 month ago
gawd...........this music saved my soul when it was lost
Joz781 1 month ago
holy crap, i can still feel this song
leovieirah 1 month ago
Holy shit imagine this song written about you...
HolyAmitz 1 month ago
So much pain in this...Remembering me that I'm still alive...Without you.Am I?Ljubav je to...
TheDzeljana 1 month ago
anyone find in funny that some of these pictures kinda look like a cell in division?
layallyourloveonme1 1 month ago
She loved this so much...
SarahKerigan83 1 month ago
Mom
XTheRawOneX 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No it's STAR!!, not SUN ffs.
He says "STAR" because it has a double meaning!
I know you'll be a "STAR"; You'll be successful, and prosper
&
In somebody elses sky; In someone elses life.
Jeez, why the fuck would it be "SUN"?
Awezumi 1 month ago
The emotion he puts into singing "why can't it be mine" makes my spine tingle every time I hear it, even after 17 years.
mrpotato1970 1 month ago 61
@mrpotato1970
You're f****'n right man. :-)
dreyelander1 2 weeks ago
@mrpotato1970 i agree 100%
Brad21395 2 weeks ago
best song of all time?? you have to be kidding!!
smw381st 1 month ago
@smw381st clearly you don't know what good music is. This is a great song
MikeMars23 1 month ago
Great song, but this hasn't topped Hotel California for me.
jbear1312 1 month ago
My favorite from PJ. tattooed everything!
hunter19877 1 month ago
"NICE SONG TO HEAR WHEN YOU BREAK UP,INSPIRING AND BEUTIFUL...LIVE FOREVER PEARL JAM"
adriator25 1 month ago
Vulcan Science. Now Im completly blind. I hope your happy now, thnx ryn11 !!
oldbooch 1 month ago
in the end of the song I feel the whole fuckin' universe comes down...
WertzuHun 1 month ago
such a good song. A classic.
reese8131 1 month ago
Eddie's emotions swim out through this song. His pain compliments mine. This song helps me through my struggles. Thank you, Pearl Jam.
dizzyb111 1 month ago
222 pendejos
vivapeff 2 months ago 2
i searched BLACK in the search bar and im so glad i did..... im so so so happie right now
jgourley760 2 months ago
One of my dearest song.
vrtirepka100 2 months ago 2
221 people are barbie girls who likes pink color only...
alexia191287 2 months ago
This song takes me places.
Multifire 2 months ago
this song is right next to comfortably numb and stairway to heaven.
inscrutable67 2 months ago 4
@inscrutable67 I like your analogy. This song ranks up there with the best ever.
InfamousTurley 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
Not bad... but are betters, I think
pORTUGUAYo 2 months ago
"I know someday you'll have a beautiful life
I know you'll be a star
In somebody else sky, But why? why? why?
Why can't it be, why can't it be mine"
Fucking awesome words.
MaTiXXx10 2 months ago 160
@MaTiXXx10 sun not star.. not that it really matters
BTRFitness 2 months ago
Comment removed
Awezumi 1 month ago
@MaTiXXx10 and performed with so much passion...like u can feel his pain
atmadc68 2 months ago
@MaTiXXx10 How much better can a lovesong be?
anita921970 1 month ago 2
@MaTiXXx10 , the 225 people who disliked this song are just Justin' bieber's accounts cuz hes jealous of the lyrics>olivia
oliviagnome 1 month ago
219 folks think that the best song of all time is actualy Alive :D
Deynynaay 2 months ago 2
i gonna be Astronomer Long LIFE PEARL JAM!!!!!!!! ;D
mrZackco12 2 months ago
It's over rated. Nice song but COME OFF IT! Best song of all time!?!? I could name a thousand and one better than this!
Ploppertello100 2 months ago
@Ploppertello100 Shut the fuck up, just....SHUT THE FUCK UP
Lijpekees360 2 months ago
@Lijpekees360 his saying his opinion, deal with it kid, lol
123pcp321 2 months ago
@123pcp321 Don't let me give you the same reaction as I gave @Ploppertello100...
Lijpekees360 2 months ago
It's almost impossible to find a song as beautiful and as packed full of emotion as this one.
TheCasey16 2 months ago
I've said it before and I'll say it again. Whoever broke Eddie Vedder's heart is surely regretting it, you can really hear the pain in his voice. I always feel like he is singing this song directly to me.
BTRFitness 2 months ago 2
UH, the lyrics in the video are so wrong... its "SHES an empty canvas/ under sheets of clay (skin)/ her legs spread out before me/ as her body lies still..." totally totally wrong
jrtaft3eb 2 months ago
@jrtaft3eb umm no i dont think so
epicpwnr1 2 months ago
Overrated.
snowwhitesdildo 2 months ago
@snowwhitesdildo the fuck is wrong with you?
TehFlashPwnsAll 2 months ago
@TehFlashPwnsAll I have a very small penis.
snowwhitesdildo 2 months ago
@snowwhitesdildo
Your opinion's overrated.
AlmightyScubba 2 months ago 20
This has been flagged as spam show
I know someday you´ll have a beautiful life, I know you´ll be a sun
In somebody else´s sky....but WHY?! why can´t it be mine ??? :'(
naxrose777 2 months ago
One word. Phenomenal. If this song doesn't hit you in the gut, you must be dead.
Such incredible passion. Moves me. -db-
Davechop54 2 months ago
Always find this band for teenies. Nut later I find out this is really great. Well when you are nearly 50 every day you learn more what music have to be.
ronaldvanderkleij 2 months ago
worst quality of al time
ZEPHprod 2 months ago
good job making sure the sound quality was utterly horrendous! PROPS!
vincntblakshadow 2 months ago
Great track
richtux1978 2 months ago
One of my favorite songs.
matrix31003 2 months ago
Great song, but prefer the live version, it´s really powerful!!
marikc84 2 months ago
I guess he bought her a lot of clothings .... Lucky Girl :-)
Great song !
Fabigothangel 2 months ago
Miss you Brittany and still love you .
malouda1989 2 months ago
gosh it has been 20 years since its release.. time flies.
deeewberry14 2 months ago
Amazing job on a great song!!!
GAEAvideo 2 months ago
240p We meet again -_-...
Enigmishh 2 months ago
214 people are deaf!
ugotube1 2 months ago 4
tu du tu du du du du, tu du tu du tu du du, tu du tu du du tu du......
reykingx 3 months ago 4
lookin at all the messages here...
Live life to the fullest ! Dont have regrets !! you only get one oppurtunity on earth, make the best of it !
bizophecles 3 months ago 3
@bjaekley im sorry about your mom :( my mom passed away as well & my sister, my mom & i use 2 listen 2 pearl jam all the time as well you're mom was a hard worker...jus like mine but both of our moms are in a better place RIP to both of our moms
yamisisasexmonster 3 months ago
qinem bii quinem bii mãããe!
321cachorro123 3 months ago
Comment removed
danamalul 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SEARCH NIRVANA FOR XMAS NO. 1 AND SUPPORT THE CAUSE!
Come on guys, like the page and buy the single (only when we need to, or it won't count). X Factor, at the end of the day, is just a huge money machine, making money out of the naive public.
Like to get this noticed!
iloveskins96 3 months ago
Allways listen to this whenever i have rough times with girls....which is allways
PachydermSouthbound 3 months ago
beautiful *-*
mjn04 3 months ago
Probably their most popular song, and it wasn't even a single
94Cioppa 3 months ago
thumbs up if you just wanna hear the best dl song with out commercials
DoubleFeo 3 months ago
@bjaekley dude, im sure your mother is in heaven and the only peace ashes geting is for the wonderfol sun she raised
OmriLeshem 3 months ago 2
How do you make jam out of pearls? is it nice?
Deanmurph20201 3 months ago
@Deanmurph20201
I would bet since the refraction point of pearls is 2.64 meaning that if you'd fill a jar up it would look pretty pretty nice, in fact it would be wonderful =)
Cokoholicar 3 months ago
killer. empty yet whole. what the fuck and I thought I was nuts. How powerful to envoke meaning less energy for all I am and all Ill be. Fucking ass. Hope the russian mob wips out philly starting with ANNE.
Resalicious13 3 months ago
we meet again 240p
c33pwnz00r 3 months ago
I could listen to this all day every day and never get tired of it. The best part is how this song can make me happy and it can make me sad. So much emotion.
l1nd5mar13 3 months ago
You have inadvertently made an awesome djent music video for an awesome 90's soft-ish rock song. You're fucking awesome. Keep that shit up.
statesolid 3 months ago
many comments here are so sad and beautiful---just like this song
blackcatclothing 3 months ago
I just farted.
xanibars 3 months ago
shit...these lyrics couldn't get any deeper...i mean these few words speak volumes...where has this music gone?!
add2t4 3 months ago
I grew up on pearl jam I was in high school when I first heard this song. I have many fond memory's of a girl and this song in my life and still it can take me back to every moment that I spent with her. 1994
crucialmatt 3 months ago
dont worry people just type black and press search........thumbs up unless you wanna hear new million dollar exploit young kids......just dont press it
DoubleFeo 3 months ago
...why can't it be mine.
ololud1993 3 months ago in playlist Ulubione filmy użytkownika ololud1993
@ololud1993 i ask my self that so much
DoubleFeo 3 months ago
What got me to start listening to Pearl Jam? My mom would play this song every once in awhile in memory of my father whose favorite band was Pearl Jam. My dad was killed in Iraq three months before I was born, right after the gulf war, and I've never even seen his grave.
But one day, daddy, I'll visit you, so you can see how much I've grown up.
fillayesheeoh 3 months ago 214
@fillayesheeoh Make sure you do that. May your daddy rest in peace forever.
bigbaldbull82 2 months ago 2
@fillayesheeoh ur post expresses ur true feeling brother, i m sure he already watching u grow up and proud of u :-)
pallijohnriar 2 months ago 4
@fillayesheeoh
word.
APittsburghOriginal 2 months ago
@fillayesheeoh He is most certainly a star in your sky. And you in his.
chadem311 2 months ago 2
@fillayesheeoh talk more bullshit u bitch
glenn5185 2 months ago
@fillayesheeoh Be proud, and may you have the gratitude of the free :)
dobbylikesmusic 2 months ago
NIRVANAS BETTER :3 giggity.....
XxSpeCHaLBoYXx 3 months ago
@XxSpeCHaLBoYXx <3
Nirvanafanforlife17 3 months ago
We,we belong together, toghether
FckYoCouch97 3 months ago
I normaly listen black and death metal but this isn't very bad
k03n0p3 4 months ago
this song makes any mood shift into mellowness
MannyO1995 4 months ago 34
This has been flagged as spam show
anyone else hope that this fad nowadays called ''hip-hop'' can just go away and this stuff can come back? or is it just me?
poundld01 4 months ago
anyone else hope that this fad nowadays called ''hip-hop'' can just go away and this stuff can come back? or is it just me?
poundld01 4 months ago
A melhor musica deles cara! O show vai ser zica!
klebinho7777 4 months ago
:)
blaztix 4 months ago
This is truely the best song of all time. Saddest song of all time also. Such deep meaning, and description of my life. I've never had a girlfriend in my and i'm 16 just because I'm ugly. People do not accept others for who they are, they just judge them by their facial appearances and looks.This song always let's me know I'm not alone. God Bless Eddie Vedder and Pearl Jam.
jakesisk 4 months ago 3
@jakesisk Do not talk like that and do not think like that. I thought like you aswell, but when I encouraged myself I found a girlfriend, but I wanted her like not in very deep sense if you understand, we just hanged out because she was pretty and I was a little bit. Then she left me, and I have understood that that "love" what I had is not love (I loved her because she was pretty). I am now looking for a woman for all my life, and you know what, I do not care if she will be pretty or not.
Brodjaga211 4 months ago
@jakesisk The most important thing what good girls want is GOOD and INTELEGENT man who she can talk with and share things. So learn to listen people especially girls when they talk. There is a russian writer Leo Tolstoy, who at your age thought he is ugly and he will not have a girl for all life (and he was not pretty he admitted) he was very shy. But then he had some life experience and this "ugly" guy had so many girls, it was hard to believe. I encaurage you to read him. "Childhood" Anna care
Brodjaga211 4 months ago
@Brodjaga211
Thx i'll try to do that.
jakesisk 4 months ago
@jakesisk Open your heart and love will fill that void. It has nothing to do with what you look like. Trust me on this one. There is someone for everyone if you just open your heart to people.
331paradiddle 3 months ago
@jakesisk
I bet you're not even ugly. And I can tell you are intelligent. Plus you have great taste in music. There's a girl out there for you, I promise.
l1nd5mar13 3 months ago
This is truely the best song of all time. Saddest song of all time also.
jakesisk 4 months ago
@TheSuperDingus and @RafitoOoO .... thanks a lot guys .. u have totally made my day .. :)
monenigma 4 months ago
Having not been in a relationship .. now turning 25 .. i truly hate myself sometimes and feel i have wasted my life ... Well this song is my only inspiration right now .. :)
monenigma 4 months ago
@monenigma I think you're being a little rough on yourself, you'll meet someone :)
TheSuperDingus 4 months ago
@monenigma I know someday you'll have a beautiful life, I know you'll be a star :)
RafitoOoO 4 months ago
@monenigma 26.. same here.
rokzroom 3 months ago