James Hetfield (MetallicA) vs Dave Mustaine (Megadeth)

[kuba2542]

Both Bands are Thrash metal gods!

[marcosviinib]

Dave Mustaine - Best In Guitar

James Hetfield - Best In Vocal

[yahiko68]

por dios james es mejor metallica es mucho mejor ke megadeth kual megamuerte, megamierda mejor dicho, y si es ke otros dicen ke metallica es muy bendido es por ke los "los negociantes" digamos le asi buscan lo mejor y por eso es ke los escojen a ellos, megashit=shit, metallica=oro ORO ORO del puro

[GALADVIEYRA]

Si Metallica no se huviera vendido estarian parejos pero como no es asi Megadeth se la lleva con mucha ventaja .............

Kirk siendo que en su buena epoca fue un guitarro chingon jamas llego al nivel de Mustaine

menos ahora que su musica y nivel son muy decadentes

[diana200997]

MetallicA and MegadetH are great bands!!!

But the winner is MetallicA!!!

James has an amazing voice,but the guitar solos by Dave win!!!\m/

[diego27817]

Tienen que entender algo i es que mustaine tiene mejores solos pero canta mejor james

[Miguelhollow92]

Mus†aine kick ass!!

[Doneagan]

James sounds better than Mustaine ^^

I like Megadeth but i LOVE Metallica x)

[jagi503]

Mustaine!

[RICHY0354]

Megadeth win!!!!

[drakesantosjr]

Sinceramente, metallica es como un metal familiar, y megadeth es algo como mas obscuro, en sonido metallica gana, en solos mustaine, en rapidez metallica. las dos bandas son buenas tan solo vean los seguidores de ambas bandas en FB y TWT

[psycrazy100]

yo digo que 30% MTEALLICA y

70% MEGADETH

en mi humilde opinion

Respeto mucho a Metallica y me gusta tambien mucho pero

me late mas megadeth

[fca5]

enter sandman is actually kirk cration i guess

[ismaelbasi2]

prefiero al gran james y a metallica aunque megadeth es muy buena y dave tambiien

[NickHaghverdian]

metallica all the way theyve been number one and will stay number one to all the haters you wouldnt have megadeth if metallica never kicked out dave so bow down!

[Ciborock]

pffff hetfield sin duda

[pablishx]

Mustaine siguió firme a sus convicciones... Metallica se volvio asquerosamente comercial. De Mustaine tengo todas las placas, de Metallica las deje en RELOAD cuando ya estaba en una etapa muy avanzada la idea de hacer mierda para vender.

[megadethfan1983]

Mustaine better riffs

Mustaine better solos

Mustaine better lyrics

Thumps up for MegaDave!!!

[MMSUPERFUCK]

mustaine best

[dark1951]

ncncn in my opinioon dave isn't supossed too be a frontman...!!! his vocal can not compare to james...and his riffs are much laughy..!!! metallica all the way.!!!

[666TheBloodLust666]

To be honest... this is how I feel about this one... Metallica people can argue that the older stuff head to head with Megadeth was more popular music... However and I say this with sincerity the last decade or so has been owned by Megadeth.. as we know the only decent album Metallica has come up with was Death Magnetic and it still wasn't anything classic... I think Megadeth seems to be the band that although may have started off slow can atleast still create a record.

[SLOnTheRoad]

Considering Mustaine is a black belt and Hetfield a table... i wonder who win here ;)

[abigsandwich123]

Metallica is more popular but Megadeth is in the same category for me. Great bands, great music. Thanks James and Dave

[avengedthebest]

to me metallica is better !! but both bands are great so ONLY ENJOY IT MOTHERFUCKER !!

[jonaszhalo]

dave mustaine es mi padre *o*

[sid97100]

Fuck the bastard Dave Mustaine. James Hetfield will always be better. And fuck off all who disagree with the breached my opinion.

[polishguy994]

James has better riffs, Dave has better solos.

[blackCharlot11]

@polishguy994 jaaaa James better riffs jajajajaja never MUSTAINE is Best

[polishguy994]

@blackCharlot11 I'll have to disagree, James riffs on Blackened, master of puppets, Leper Messiah, and he shortest straw (just to name a few) are some of the bests riffs to have ever been written. Dave's riffs just aren't as catchy as Metallica's, but thats just my opinion.

[blackCharlot11]

@polishguy994 holy wars peace sells symphony of destruction trust in my darkes hour

[ImSttrykeer]

@polishguy994 que no es alrebes? La verdad Kirk tiene mejores solos talves osea metallica, pero los riffs de Megadeth son mucho mejores!

Aguante Dave!!

[matyas250395]

@polishguy994 Actually, Dave has better riffs too. what I mean is that Metallica riffs are pretty simple. So easy to play.

[polishguy994]

@matyas250395 Simplicity isn't always a bad thing. The Riff in walk by Pantera is a relatively simple riff, but its one of the best riffs in metal.

[skaterobban]

@polishguy994 Not really metallica has good riffs but megadeth riffs are much harder and interesting to listen to.. not just powerchords played through every single song.

[LeoOliveAmar]

dave plays better than james, but i preffer metallica

[lmlthrasherlml]

mustaine!!!!!!

[josuezt]

1:35 ;)



[RamosAnthony47]

AMBOS SON LOS MEJORES ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

[Sasauke12]

La verdad yo prefiero 1000 veces a Mustaine @DAMMIAN32 tiene mucha razón, siempre fue Dave solo contra Metallica, sin embargo yo sigo prefieirento 100% Megadeth. Soy muy fangirl de Mustaine. ♥

[metalheavy77alc]

@Sasauke12 muy bien,usted si sabe de musica, megadeth el mejor,supongo que lo de fangirl obio porque eres mujer?? excelente

[Juptes]

Dave is the best.

[4rk4de]

metallica solos wah wah wah wah wah wah wah

[DAMMIAN32]

Sean objetivos amigos, Megadeth es mucho mejor banda que metallica,eso lo sabe cualquier buen entendido en música y mas en el trash. Tengo todos los discos de las dos bandas y es mas que obvia la superioridad de mustaine.Mucho mejor letrista y guitarrista.recuerden que siempre fue mustaine solo contra metallica y así y todo no pueden con el colorado. Un genio!!!!

[metalheavy77alc]

@DAMMIAN32 Toda la razon dammian, hay que ser objetivo y saber de musica para saber que mustaine es mejor letrista y guitarrista, yo tambien tengo todos los discos de megadeth (los de metallica no los tengo todos, solo los primeros 4, porque la verdad no todos son buenos) solo una correcion no se escribe trash es THRASH pero en todo lo demas toda la razon. un genio el colorado!!!!!!!

[stilysilvia]

@DAMMIAN32 Totalmente de acuerdo  con ver a los dos en directo cualquiera se da cuenta.

[gofuckloser]

@DAMMIAN32 mustaine no sabe cantar

[Urielvaldez1]

@DAMMIAN32 mm tal vez tienes razon en un cierto punto mi amigo pero tambien si dices ser amante del trash tienes que saber lo que metallica ha fabricado sin mustanie :) son muchas mas cosas que sin dave de igual manera dave es un buen musico.

[blackCharlot11]

@DAMMIAN32 si amigo tienes toda la razon pero no exageres mustaine es un genio pero sin la ayuda de sus compas no podria hacer lo que hace es obvio que demuestra su grandeza por el hecho de que han cambiado muchas veces la alineacion pero demosle credito alos demas salu2

[Fabianationx123]

@DAMMIAN32 Yo también voto por MegadetH, pero.... tanto que te gustan y no sabes que thrash se escribe con "h" ?

[parlante88]

@DAMMIAN32 hetfield canta mejor, es mejor en los riffs... mustaine compone mejor, y es mejor en los solos. Los primeros trabajos de megadeth no fueron tan buenos como los siguientes, los primeros trabajos de metallica fueron los mejores, no como los siguientes. Y la cuenta sigue, las dos bandas tienen sus pro y sus contras, personalmente creo que no son comparables, ya que son muy diferentes. No porque mustaine haya sido parte de metallica, tienen que ser rivales o comparables.

[Anderson696911]

DAVE  MEGADETH!! why? ... because he was good and now he is good on guitar,sing and etc... and JAMES was good and now he is a little star and he doesn't rock more!! last album that was good was black album.. after this it's over!! dave keep thrash till today!!

[mitchmoberly1]

mustaine sure likes to do that *chug chug chug chug chug CHORD! chug chug chug chug CHORD!* thing in his slower guitar riffs

[4rk4de]

@mitchmoberly1 get a life

[mitchmoberly1]

@4rk4de ok :)

[adoniszeppelin]

dave mustaine é melhor... e mais lokão!!!

[sesteam]

MEGADETH IS A WORST COPY OF METALLICA!

[skaterobban]

@sesteam how is megadeth a copy of metallica? metallica didnt even get their thrash metal sound until dave mustaine joined. they sounded like a bar rock band when they had lloyd grant on leads.

[4rk4de]

@sesteam what are you saying... shut up

[ArturScc]

5:17 he looks REALLY weird while playing the acoustic guitar

[deidarax1]

james destruye a dave

[Kevlar616]

Yes, I am "seerious". Megadeth are so much better than Metallica, I don't know why it's open for debate! And I do like Metallica too by the way, just telling it like I see it.

[Kevlar616]

look at it this way. the world would not have kill em all and ride the lightning if not for mustaine, he wrote most of both. megadeth have been consistently better than metallica on every release since 1988 (justice - so far, so good...)

[vlmmosto]

@Kevlar616 are you seerious,dave mustaine only wrote the mechanix,

and a few riffs on 3 other songs on kill em all,but 85%of the album

was lars and james,and he only wrote the main riff on the song ride

the lightning and the spider cord part,and he also wrote only 1 riff on

call of cthuluh,thats a fact,95% of ride the lighting was james and lars.

if you don't no shit,well don't say shit

[LadyJackson01]

@vlmmosto Dave´s songs "Metal Militia" Phantom Lord" "Jump in the fire" and "Mechanix" sooo...(?)

[vlmmosto]

@LadyJackson01 no dave only wrote the mecanix and jump in the fire,

the other 2 was james and lars that wrote it dave just collaborated on them,

and yes unless you have been living under a rock you should know

metallica is the biggest metal band in the world, and has been dominating the

industry for thre last 25 years,..sorry ,,sad but true

[LadyJackson01]

@vlmmosto yeah, yeah... keep dreaming

[vlmmosto]

@LadyJackson01 are you serious,your a fucking girl ,and you still

watch cartoons wtf aren't you to old to still be watching cartoons omg

and you have the nerves to talk about metal,a cartoon watching girl,wtf,

and yes metallica have been dominating the industry for the last 25 years,

anyone on the planet earth knows that,but your a girl so you don't know

shit about metal,...sorry ,sad but true.

[LadyJackson01]

@vlmmosto excuse me.... you´re saying that I´m a girl I don´t know anything about Metal? wtf! maybe you´re a nerd behind your little computer who thinks that the only band in the freakin world is "Metallica"... I mean, dude... what about "Slayer" "Antrax" and many others metal bands... you are so pathetic because you only listen to one band and your mind is closed...!!! so... SHUT UP

[vlmmosto]

@LadyJackson01 slayer and antrax don't really matter,85% of the

big4 tour audiance were there only for metallica,and metallica are

the only metal band that never whent down and never lost their fans,

metallica are the only metal band not being dominated by any pop,

or rap act,or dance act,..so yes metallica are the best

[skaterobban]

@LadyJackson01 he has no life and is writing shit on all megadeth/metallica videos

[LadyJackson01]

@skaterobban yeah. I know... that´s why I´m not answer any shit aniymore...

[vlmmosto]

the world only loves metallica

[LadyJackson01]

@vlmmosto yeah yeah yeah... keep dreaming

[vlmmosto]

who is megadeth,the world dosen't care about them

the world only want's to see metallica

[LadyJackson01]

@vlmmosto What the fuuuuck?!

you´re the fucking world or what?!

[ctrlaltsupr01]

Mustaine!!!

[pm2595]

Dave. It's so obvious that I won't even bother to explain why I think Dave's better.

[TornadoOfMegadeth]

are you joking its dave withouth doub

[alucarito]

DAVE!!!!! is better C:

[Vaekkrinhart]

sorry, but in metal it doesn't really matter who has the better voice.. James probably could sing a Pepsi commercial better, but I much prefer Mustaine. He's grittierand has more passion, and I much prefer his voice over James'.

Megadeth rules.. and their new album removes all doubt about it, imo. Stellar lineup, stellar album, 13... Dave's the man.

If you disagree, you're dumb, that's all..... JK!

[VicenteNewsted]

Now James don't sing like the '8os, but Dave now sings like Donalds Duck -.-''

Sorry Dave, I love your riffs and solos... but James sings better than you

[megadethfan1983]

@VicenteNewsted dave sing awful now, before 1,5 year he sings better than hetfield and his voice will be good agaιn as before...

[MrMegariel]

dave sin dudas...

[mitchmoberly1]

mustaines voice is so snarly and anoying and i cant get into megadeth just because of his stupid voice

[megadethfan1983]

@mitchmoberly1 You probably don't have ears... Mustaine voice is very unique and good voice , Hetfield has a very usual voice... who is with me??

[151adrenaline]

@megadethfan1983 sorry man but if he had that good of a voice why wasnt he the lead singer back in metallica?not saying he sucks but hetfield was better

[megadethfan1983]

@151adrenaline because he wasn't a singer... sudenly he desided to be the singer of megadeth because he wasn't happy with the audition to find singer... It's your taste, i like more dave's voice...

[151adrenaline]

@megadethfan1983 ok i respect your opinion

[ct2pascualg]

@mitchmoberly1 hella true dude xD

[dragonfurp]

what? do u now what charts is?

[jpmage]

why can`t people just like both of them and stop trying to compare two very different bands?... -_-

[tupapasito2103]

Dave fucking mustaine!

[AIZEN1401]

Vocals: James

Guitar: Dave

[Camarooh]

METALLICA RULEZ James Alan Hetfield 100%

[popeluigi]

Think of it this way.

Singing: James>Dave

Solos: Dave>James

Rhythm: Dave=James

Smart.

[rampage222555]

@popeluigi this is so correct

[4rk4de]

@popeluigi joke?

[TiagoCavassin]

Megadeath kings

However, who is metallica?

[zatu258]

james hetfield winner

[luy2100]

HETFIELD (2)

[galponsur]

hetfield careta

[galponsur]

i love megadeth , is better than metallica , and i beleve what hammett is better than hetfield,

[TheLoquendero007]

James Hetfield el INCOMPARABLE

[alfanumrica]

@TheLoquendero007 sierto ! pero es superado por Mustaine

[TheLoquendero007]

@alfanumrica No no le llega ni a los talones

[SuperFiore12]

los dioses no se comparan

[theargentinita]

James has become a table

[pablishx]

FOOLS! METALLICA is a DAVE MUSTAINE's invention...

[sc682941]

Mustaine better gutarist but metallica better band sorry that is my opinion :)

[TheArturAfonso]

pra muita gente o james cantando é melhor, pra mim estão quase iguais (e é porque não é o principal atributo do Dave cantar e sim tocar), tocando o mustaine é melhor que o james e kirk juntos...se estes caras estivessem na mesma banda tinha pra ninguem...

[ToughestMilkman]

Mustaine is better guitarist however Hatfield is the better TABLE.

[rechrodrig0]

De longe se vê que o autor do vídeo gosta mais do James, deixou sua preferência muito na cara.

[zamtyago12]

Los 2 Pero Me Gusta Mas Mustaine!

[kokasio]

no comparen ambos son grandes o quisas lo mejor del metal y ustedes se dedican a compararlos ?? para ambos son lo mejor de lo mejor lml !!!!!

[leandroagustin98]

Cantando James, tocando Mustaine.

[megadethfan1983]

Mustaine till death!!!!!!!

[sonickofull]

James Hetfiel es el mejor..!!

[avfcmickdaly]

can we not just appreciate both bands......makes me smile to see such idiotic comments off so called adults....chill out people

[iulisoulkiller]

Hetfield - riffs and vocals

Mustaine - lyrics and solos

[megadethfan1983]

@iulisoulkiller riffs??? no. Dave -> riffs, solo, lyrics

[iulisoulkiller]

@megadethfan1983 well, I'm sorry to say to you but James' riffs are better than Dave's...

[megadethfan1983]

@iulisoulkiller probably you know nothing about megadeth (music) , Dave is genius, go to listen some megadeth songs and then you see the truth. Mustaine -> riffs, end of story.

[gunskitallica]

@iulisoulkiller BEING a great metallica fan i say that dave riffs are better than of james.SAD BUT TRUE

[dragonfurp]

@gunskitallica lol! James is a riff lord! dave may be better at solos, but not riffs

[gunskitallica]

@dragonfurp i think u never did any megadeth song yet? :D

[SpaceDyeDream]

@iulisoulkiller

Hah.

[jador2219]

musteine es el mejor ....james es un hp vendido solo buska el kapital y lo mejor para su carrera

[marcuskonstantin]

james hetfield!!!!!

[nez349]

James Hetfield no questions

[VenlaSajama]

Mustaine is so much better singer than Hetfield.

And Megadeth is so much better band than Metallica.

And Megadeth do have much better songs than Metallica.

And otherwise ways Megadeth is better !

I was Metallica fan when i was 9/10 years old.

Then I heared some Megadeth!

I walked to Megadeth, never even didn't even watch behind to Metallica. :)

...Know what i'm saying?

[dragonfurp]

@VenlaSajama i still like metallica`s music way better! but my opinion dosent matter? most of the people i know like metallica more, i remember in 9th grade everybody liked megadeth, but the previous years everybody liked metallica! most got bored with megadeth after a couple of months, and jumped back to metallica! question: do u really think that mustaine is a better singer? sadly u must be deaf, because dave sounds like a rat! sorry to say it, but he really does !

[mikeammot]

@dragonfurp

what do you mean couple of moths??

i've been a Metallica fan before for two years

but when i hear Megadeth's songs., it totally shakes me up

and up to now I am Megadeth's fan for 5 years and never thought of being a Metallica fan again,,, i dont care if Dave was kicked out,, who cares?? Dave was violent back then that is why he was kicked out but still I prefer Megadeth's music compare to any band.... 

[mikeammot]

@dragonfurp

if someone says that Dave was a better singer compare to James, it doesn't mean that he/she is deaf...

it is his own opinion....

obviously it is awful to hear James' voice in Tornado of Souls

and Dave's voice in Nothing Else Matter

and will some of you quit comparing those bands... if you prefer Metallica, ok no big deal, it's just you....

Stop posting some bad comments about the other singer,,, even James has no right to say something bad to Dave and so are you...

[dragonfurp]

@mikeammot the fact is that dave sucks at singing! what ur saying is just like saying that dave would suck at playing nothing else matters and james would suck at playing tornado of souls on guitar! It does not change the fact that dave cant sing

[mikeammot]

@dragonfurp

if Dave can't sing, who is the one who does the singing in Megadeth for thirteen albums???

the fact is that Dave can sing but you just don't like it...

and James would sing Tornado of Souls??? trust??? it might be a total disaster... anyone can sing dude... even you and me...

[dragonfurp]

@mikeammot omg! typical dave fan! u cant even see his faults! he does not have many, but he truly suck ass at singing

[mikeammot]

@dragonfurp

hahaha... I am not Dave's fan but Megadeth's fan... unlike you, you are so obssesed with James... are you going to marry him..??? ohohoho...

i like both of bands of course... but i think Megadeth is better...haha... that is why Megadeth's Trust and Countdown to Extinction topped the billboard chart...

how about James' writiings??? only Enter Sandman??? okok.. i accept it... James standard is too high to be in the billboard... hahaha

happy??? marry him instead.. ohohohoho

[dragonfurp]

@mikeammot lol! metallica`s songs are WAY higher on the charts than megadeth! what are u talking about?

[mikeammot]

@dragonfurp

i'm talking in USA not in Norway dude... i felt sorry for whatever standard you have.. hahaha

[dragonfurp]

@mikeammot im talking about their carrer u dumbass! not right now ! "facepalm"

[mikeammot]

@dragonfurp

metallica's career is deteriorating after the black album... everyone knows it... and what do you mean now??? i know they are now lagging behind MEGADETH nowadays... i know youre a big fan but you must accept the truth...

fuckin' faggot dumbass idiot!!!!

[dragonfurp]

@mikeammot My point is that thru their carrer they have owned megadeth on al charts...

[mikeammot]

@dragonfurp

WHAT??? what year are you born??? 2011??

Metallica debuted on charts during the black album on the song Enter Sandman and nothing follows...

while Megadeth topped it trice... TRUST, COUNTDOWN TO EXTINCTION, ENDGAME...

but still it's even for me because Metallica won the Grammy awards and Megadeth is a nominee...

[vlmmosto]

@mikeammot are you serious, you say megadeth have more chart hits than metallica

are you kidding me.metallica sold 110 million albums with 9studio albums ,and megadeth sold 25 million albums with 13 studio albums,so how can you say they have more chart hits than metallica

are you gay,wtf.and metallica didn't lose any fans what are you talking about,they are the only metal band

who can play any stadium in the world,and megadeth are struggling to sell tickets nowadays

you just make up shit

[mikeammot]

@vlmmosto

yeah you are right... but it's 30 million not 25....

Metallica sold 110 million, 59 million on us only and Megadeth sold 30 million all over the world...

that makes a very bg difference...

[vlmmosto]

@mikeammot thanks for admiting i am right ,,that was big of you

[mikeammot]

@vlmmosto

i wish someday Metallica would be able to meet the achievements of Beatles, though it's quiet impossible.

[XxMETALLICAFAN9xX]

@VenlaSajama your retarded and ignorant

[MsGustavoFontes]

Dave Mustaine é beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeem melhor!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Dave é mais rápido e melhor, tem uma banda melhor, músicas bem melhores

Dave Mustaine é fodão

Dave Mustaine : 10/10

James Hetfield : 0/10

[MultiHulkbuster]

@MsGustavoFontes metallica é melhor

[dijang3113]

@VenlaSajama si estoy comprendiendo que eres un posser!!!

[TurnOffYourMind1]

@VenlaSajama no your sadly retarded

[mikeammot]

@TurnOffYourMind1

he's a good listener in any ways... we like Thrash Metal that is why we like Dave more then James which plays Heavy Metal...

[Metadeth1997]

@VenlaSajama lol you can go fuck yourselves, everything you wrote here is so wrong. James is a hell of a lot better singer than dave ever was, and Metallica have alot better songs than Megadeth.

[SIRupKyTcK]

Hetfield 1982 - 1993

Mustaine 1982 - now

[DeathMagneticReece]

HETFIELD FTW!!!!!!! MUSTAIN IS CATAPILLA

[TheFred157]

hetfield 10000000

mustaine 1

[472bloodman]

But metallica FADE TO BLACK over megadeath SYMPHONY OF DESTRUCTION but megadeath HOLY WARS over metallica BATTERY

[472bloodman]

hetfield for his epic vocals but mustane cause he has a cool guitar sound and same as me ( Dean Explorer)

[steffelaar]

can you guys even compare these two? they so different... megadeth is trash at it's finest , while metallica is mainstream metal. yes you heard it mainstream metal.. you can't compare them too each other , it's like comparing justin bieber to lord worm

[011sazzad]

mustaine is bullshit

[CeNNteR]

James is definetly a better rhytm guitarist and definetly a better vocalist but Dave has more shredding abilities. END OF STORY!!!! ENOUGH (sorry for my bad english)

[alexaandraw]

Guitar: Mustaine. Voice: Hetfield. Just my opinion.

[SmackdownVsRawcmpunk]

broderick beats kirk, james beats mustaine guitar wise and vocal wise, but both bands still kick ass

[Kaz10005]

Dave hands down. Dave wrote alot of Metallica's first album...Dave invented the spider cord..Dave ALL THE WAY....Metallica sucked UNTIL they came out with the black album, which got me real bored after a whole. Megadeath album up to this day NEVER get me tired...

[BoozeNMetaL]

Mustaine Rules.

Old School James Kicks ass (untill Black Album).

New/actual James Sucks Dick.

Simple as that

[Monoxyde1994]

Dave mustain is gay

[luc00leh]

Both rule!

[mauroyza100]

they both are LEGENDS... i prefer james voice but i think mustaine is better guitarrist