S Club 8 vs S Club 7

[martialartgirl23]

SCLUB7 BY FAR SO MUCH BETTER MUSIC AND SO MUCH MORE ORIGINAL!!!!!

[TheRonnie149]

Hii S Club 8 vs Club 7 Rocks!

[XCutePupa]

Sclub 8 ? WTF O.o

[martialartgirl23]

I just found out they are British. I thought they were American. oops.

[MeliKProductions]

No comparison.

A. A recording over a live voice is not comparing the two on the same format

B. 7 was more versatile. They even act as well (look for their TV series' and movies)

[ni99az123]

wtf is this s club 8 shit horrible

[animainfranta]

the winner is sclub 7! ABSOLUTELY!!!

[thunderstormabbi]

one thing sclub 7 never mimed but sclub 8 always mimed

[Domosuke]

@thunderstormabbi Yeah. Plus it should have been S club 4. Frankie, Rochelle, Calvin and Aaron were the only important ones.

[djjbcp]

no point of comparison between the two sclub7 rocks!!!

[ssshlow]

sclub created sclub juniors actually, then it somehow evolved into sclub 8

[dinotehc]

It's S Club 7 which created the group S Club 8

[melikeylove]

go s club 7 baby!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[KERRYNTYLER]

s club 777 all the way better songsss

[TheLauraShow01]

S Club 7

FTW xxxxxx

[222songwriter]

S CLUB 77777777777 777777777777777777777777777777­777777777777777777777777777777­777777777777777777777777777777­77777

[csstella]

Secondo me meglio S club 7...anche perché pure la canzone é migliore!

[onyxone144]

who signed this kid. this is the worst.

[jinnybaby]

ich finde beide bands toll.

[tht4hj]

Those girls where fourteen years old in this video, but they seem older with that clothes and that makeup.. :S

[TheKraziiGuy]

S Club 7 all the wayy!!!!! <3 :D

[14mrsblhodges]

So Sclub7! I love their music!

[LesleyLouisex]

This is horrible :|

[spj18]

fail vid

[joespice1999]

i agree, didnt know 8 existed. rachel is HOT!!!!! jos cute. the rest, whatever. but 7 rocks as a band. miss them

[B3R3N1C3A]

i like this song

[yuruirin]

it was obviously S Club 7 is far more better than S Club 8 more and more...from the singing technique and the groove...it was obvious..

[gallafey]

I Liked S Club 7 & thought S club 8 wern't too bad ether but which better, S Club 7 or S Club 8, there's only one way find out FIIIIIGHHHT!

[mspang001]

i so used to listening to s club 7

so i think s clube 7 is better

[kasgal2]

i think itz a tie b/c they r both outsatnding singerz(both groups are)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Glittergrldancer]

S Club 7 is WAAAYYY better, prolly cuz i'm so use to them, they can sing better and they look better....when did they come a long?

[zakkabil]

Bradley vs Frankie  Jo vs Stacey

[milena1434]

la verdad a mi me gustaban ambos pero es qeu s club 8 era mas funky que 7

s club is more funky than 7 but 7 is more.....happy hahah

[xxSarahxx199519]

& its jay not joe, god.

[xxSarahxx199519]

Joe is sclub 8, IS NOT chipmunk ffs .

[TVproductionsUK]

@xxSarahxx199519 you mean JAY.

[RoseT7100]

I thinkthat they are both just as good in their own way.

people should stop critising Sclub 8 if you don't them then fine but there is a load of people who do and I am not afraid to say that I am one of them.

[soccerballfreeak3]

i agree their both good

but id go with s club 7

[bikinebabe]

s club 7 much better 8 cant sing but bet you didnt know joe from s club 8 in actully chipmunk

[ripthefranks]

7 by far

[tobylane]

Well duh. One was international, mid-late twenties, experienced people who could learn, the other was formed as a gimmick as a one off who just about lasted longer than that. Both amazing for what they are.

[xLiva64x]

S Club 8 are just a bunch of kids who cant sing. S Club 7 WERE THE ORIGINAL!

[Megamunchkinn]

acttualy s club 7 MADE s club 8 so all yuh h8rz can shut ya fukin mouths theyre both as gudd as each outher and thts the way it was ment 2 b!!!

[soyvirgenyque]

que cargada eso de sclub 8 de donde salieron jaja, aguante sclub 7

[musicbabess]

we know who wins.

s club 7!

[Cr1m1naLa]

pff... 8 just tries to copy 7... big deal :/

[DioRockz999]

s club is way better

[xMissLovely26x]

who the fk is s club 8 ? lol

iv'e only herd of S club 7 and s club 7 is by far the best.

[Sistadie]

S club 7 are far better than S club8!!!

♥ s club 7♥

[firewolf222]

s club 7

[sarkanyos]

S Club 7 is much better (Y)

[rodherzs]

S CLUB WINSSSS

...By the way 7 comes first!!!

[CheronaFan93]

S Club 7 wins!!

[sexygoldspink]

s club 8 is better than s club 7

[soxgirl2005]

sclub owns! but the 8...are ok ha

[e7242]

S CLUB 7 WINS!

[hotjt]

Sclub7 created Sclub8 (they was S club juniors 1st)

[FabragasFan123]

s club 7 split up so s club 8 took over the s club name

[ZaydOlivas]

(Y)

[blueaznboi03]

@ANITAKKAT s club 8 was actually s club juniors or something like that xD

[HotShotRuksy]

@ANITAKKAT  S club 8 did exist

but It was called S club juniors and they became sclub 8 after sclub 7 split

You should listen to American juniors vs sclub juniors and you will see how good they sound compared to american juniors

[missprettyyandpinkk]

@ANITAKKAT You can't really compare a kids voice with an adults.

[mollymijh]

@ANITAKKAT You have no idea what you'r talking about Stacey and Rochelle in s club 8 have amazing voices and the rest of them do to and to have a music caria at the age of 11-14 is amazing. and whats funny is that after s club 7 split non of them became succsesful with music but s club 8 did, 2 of them are in the saturdays (Frankie Sandfrd and Rochelle Wiseman).

[ANITAKKAT]

@mollymijh I don't know why people keep replying to something I wrote 2 years ago, I didn't even remember what my comment was. Anyway, I really didn't know they existed until I saw this video, where I live, S Club 8 wasn't as famous as S club 7 (I used to love 7, so I'm a little biased). And about the singing, I still think they don't sound great in here, but maybe I was too quick to judge by this video alone, I haven't heard anything else from them.

[saxoncheer09]

ok...S Club 7 all the way.....

It is like S Club 8...HELLo they basically stole the name...and I agree S Club 7 is so much better!!!

[vivaelfulham23]

S Club 7 we're like THE band for kids in the late 90s/ early 00s what were S Club 8... oh yeah crap

[kstar4eva2k8]

s club 7 girl all the way but the sclub 8's were okayyy

[nannyzceerocks]

S CLUB 7 RULES!

S CLUB 8 DROOLS! And they copied some of the music from S Club 7. Cheapos :p

[lover23231]

S club 7  all the way

[bossygirl10]

freaking s club 7 wtf is s club 8 i think theres a reason why s club 8 isnt popular i havent heard of them till now

[JoBroxx3]

s club 7 all the way :D

[robahmet1]

S Club 7

[lofiemusic]

S CLUB 7 are the original ones nd got better music

[remev4eva]

S Club 7 is the origional, and they are better. I grew up with them!

[vivaelfulham23]

I still remember everybody knowing like all the words to all their songs. It's scary I still remember them!

[Jessilo85]

i like s club 7 better sorry.

[candidita203]

s club 8 es una copia barata..... wuacala odio las copias

sclub 7 all the way

[candidita203]

sclub 7 x supuesto

[xquietthingsX]

s club 7 allll the way :D

[stephaniefewer]

both love them both!

[ellntj7]

S Club 7: PUNT UIT! ;)

sc8 is trouwens ook pure na aperij: de naam, een stukje van het liedje. SC7 was in ieder geval orgineel: daarom is het ook zo'n hit geworden

[FredrikFlintstone]

s club 7. hands down.

[NewNextXenesis]

what the holy fuck is that shit named s club 8 , god lord they sucks , i prefer 10 times more listen s club 7

[AYCYG]

es una porqueria s club 8 nada que ver con S CLUB 7 es lo mejor

[Chocorems]

Je préfère franchement S Club 7!!!

S Club 7 ou rien!!! S Club 8 est une vraie merde à côté!!!

I really prefere S Club 7!!!

It's S Club 7 or nothing!!! S Club 8 is a big shit!!!

S Club 7 is the best before, now and in the future!!!

[broncochiki889]

s club 7!!!!!!!

[Periodistoso]

que mierda es esa de sclub 8??? ni a los talones le llegan a sclub 7

[jrtennis19]

I definately prefer S Club 7 more than S Club 8 by far

[zumajestad]

S CLUB 7 YESTERDAY, TODAY AND FOR EVER

[princesacaramelo23]

Prefiero a S Club 7

[1993ko]

I like S Club 7 than S Club 8.

[kafsmilesnwaves]

S Club 7 are WAY better!

[XxNemo121xx]

s club 7 all the way!!!!!!!!!

[230861304]

s club 7 and s club 8 !!! : )

[jake5700]

SOMETHING GOOD WILL HAPPEN TO U AT 9:10 SOMEONE WILL CALL YOU OR TALK TO YOU ONLINE AND SAY I LOVE YOU OR ASK YOU OUT BUT HERES THE CATCH Send To 3 vids

[XxIc3Bb3Xx]

that sundown song really gives me a whoossshh i dunno y lol its a good song but i prefer s-club 7 i think cuz ov the movie probably

[twilightluver91]

S CLUB 7 ALL THE WAYYY

[XxXEmotionalkoreEXxX]

sounds exactly the same for me...but honestly i would say that i prefer the s club 7

[astroid2395]

s club7 so much better stupid wannabes i hate s club 8 but s club 7 is so much cooler

[Florynbz3]

S Club 7 are the best!!!

[sarzcat]

Both amazing but S-club 7 are best :3

[Kirochi]

7 is the way. Period.

[liliazores]

S CLUB 7!!!!!!!

[darkangeldl]

S CLUB 7!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[dyyaayynii05]

i like S Club 7 BETTER.

'cause they ARE.

[oasis3505]

S Club 7

[LordAsilor]

S CLUB 7~!!!~ Way better!

[kaarliik]

s club 7 is better

[mjsld]

S CLUB 8

[irismey]

Was that Britney Spears in this video? Please, let me know. I gotta know.

[xXdramioneXx]

i agree w/ most of the comments on here

s club 8 was created for the younger fans

s club 7 was more mature and hott/sexier

S club 7 did hand pick those kids themselves.. they held auditions all around the UK . When they split up they announced that The S club juniors..now to be called S club 8 was to carry on thier legacy

but its no question.. no other pop group can live up to S club 7's name

not even thier juniors

[goaliekimmy1]

i just found out there was an s club 8, s club 7 is the ownage

[TheManiacOnWheelsUSA]

S Club 8 was originally called S Club Juniors (younger group of kids). They became S Club 8 around the time S Club (S Club 7) broke up.

I didn't know about S Club Juniors/S Club 8 until I found a video here on YouTube.

[thnikkkaman]

Theres no contest. S Club is the best!!! Those kids are wannabees

[BridgetAppleton]

s club,s club 7,s club 8 are all the same,but with different songs and people

[gordorules]

S CLUB 7!!!!!!!!

[banksiegirl]

No contest S Club 7

No other S Club is better then S Club 7

[darlinchild]

PFFT! thats not eben worth askin! s club 7!!!!

[aquanettetina]

i l love i like

[pug21306]

7. Next question

[missy4142]

THERES NOO S CLUB 8 LOL RIGHT??????

[miizshi]

S CLUB 7 da best! no doubt!

[darrenalcira]

lol i didnt even know there was an s club 8 -.-

[heyyallitsbecky]

definately sc7!!! they're more mature... that is the reason that sc8 was made... for the children...

[JessLitlemarykate]

S Club 7 are The Best 0f Bests

S Club 7 F0rever and Ever <3

J0

J0n

Tina

Paul

Rachel

Bradley

Hannah

<3 <3 <3 <3 <3

[josefinbacklund]

i think s club 7 is not for children, they are more grown up and hot. s club 8 is more fun and alive and for children. =)

[derek47]

S Club 7 has the best vocals and choreography

[lilreject88]

Hah, this is an actual question? S CLUB 7

[JoRgLuiz270]

Hannah <3

S club 7 forever and ever!!!

[OyeNacho]

Sclub 7 !!!! Yeah no more!

[Jacubbycubcub]

S S c S cl S clu S club S club 7 S club 7 R S club 7 RU S club 7 RUL S club 7 RULE S club 7 RULES

[MarshalYuen]

S Club 7 over S Club 8 any day!

[MusicSteph44]

S club 7 rules yes S S c S cl S clu S club S club 7 S club 7 R S club 7 RU S club 7 RUL S club 7 RULE S club 7 RULES Copy and paste if right!!! Thanks!!

[JadeSteadman]

^^^There old school lol

[chuaekek]

s club 7 is the original

[PayGayMate100176]

"s club 7 is the original"

in your dreams idiot, all copies and remakes.

[Tinytimftw]

S Club 7 > My Dog bark > S club 8

[xbeenaxbbex]

S club 8 are tryin too hard and are wanna be's,

S club 7 will always be top :) x

[Andres4804]

S club 7 y 8 XD ^^

[dudob]

S CLUB 8 annoy me they are tryhard and copying S CLUB 7....

[scaryfairy1996]

they were made to be a younger version of them.

duh!

[joblo228]

S club 7are so MUCH better

[uchihachronicles]

I nvr even new that there was an s club 8...

But i like 7 better

Go S Club 7!!!

[blackpebble]

Oh please! S club 7 rules. Everybody knows!

[hazzerbbes]

Sowwi But This Is Stupid SC7 ND 8 Are lyk the sme Aka puppy love hinting at a sc7 memba so why compare them cus i love both cus sc8 are the love song ones and sc7 are the cheery songs nd i luv both types pf musiks so i say there both betta then hu made this video cus it is the worst comparison eva it just jumps nd sounds rubbish so nxt tym make it betta nd keep them at the same volume cus sc8 is way louder then sc7 nd sc7 tune is playin in bckground cus ya can hear it so:P

[helena100lol]

i don't think that you should compare them bcs actually s club 8 are the representing s club 7. s club 7 is who created them and they are just continuing the s club name. there is nothing to compare in this video. I find them both great! I love sc8 & sc7! don't take this badly but I just don't find this video interesting=/ i love them both!

[HARUNAKINGS]

obvio SCLUB 7 FUE LO MEJOR Y NADIE LO VA A SUSTITUIR Y MENOS UN GRUPO DE MORRITOS TODOS ÑANGOS , GRACIAS!!!

[xstephaniie]

S CLUB 7 FTW.

[RainbowDustFairy]

Better guys in SC8, overall probably about equal tho

[ting2xcaabay]

S CLUB 7, all the way!!!!

their songs are more catchy!

plus, the original is always more better!!

their lyrics, have more meanings, and their really better than S club 8

[BroadwayGirl76]

SC8 are soooooooooo much better because they are a little more up beat!

[kani92]

S Club 7 by far. the songs are much more catchy

[qesitoo2]

S club 7 :D!!!(L)

[sexibabiannie]

definatly s club 7 de others are crap!!

[foxybex92]

frankie and rochelle are in the satrurdays

[brits2007]

SCLUB 7 BII LOADS 1!

[timeoftea224]

s club 7

[misurzrenfree]

SC lub 8 is the juniors of S Club 7 . they were under the same company

[misurzrenfree]

S Club 8 is the juniors of s cLUB 7...They were chosen by audition which is judged by S Club 7... so, you can't really blame the S Club 8 if they're sucks can you ??

[micojoia]

Simple choice: SC7 loads of talent...SC8 who are they again?

[JessieBumxxx1992xxx]

Arent 2 of thee lasses, frankie and another from s club 8 now in the Saturdays?

x

[helena100lol]

yep!

[elbritez]

eran millones de veces mejor sclub 7

[MsEmmettCullen]

S Club 7

[soltan2008meme]

go to west go to east s club 8 is the best (*_*)

[kanaine07]

S club 7 the best <3

[DreamAznAngl]

s club 7!!!

[misurzrenfree]

Stop it you guys !!! the one who made this, just want you to arguing .... S cLUB 8 and S Club 7 is under the same company ...S club 7 pick S Club 8 through an audition...

[micojoia]

Good effort budy but the writing is on the wall. S Club 7 all the way, specialy Rachel, humm she must taste like vanila bean Haagen Dazs ice cream..

[misurzrenfree]

i love them both !!!! miss em...

[Al3xJordanSaid3]

S Club 8.

[PwincessDee33]

i think S Club 8

[underuska]

s club 7 4ever......s club 7 is best

[BANANAKAYKAYROX]

WHAT!!! s club 8 ??? they flippin' suck cheesey!! S CLUB 7 4 EVER!!!!

[misurzrenfree]

is S Club 8 is sucks, its not their fault ...S Club 7 is the one who pick them ...

[Babyloncircus87]

s club 7 the best