All we think that the version in our language is the best. But let me say that the only judge of actors-singers' quality is the author Cocciante. And he is italo-francais, casually born in Vietnam.
boooooooooooooouuuuuuuuuhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Vous n’êtes qu'une bande de copieurs qui n'ont aucun sens d'originalité et pas de personnalité.
It's very often weird when you sing songs written for western languages in Korean or Japanese because they are often longer to convey the same meaning.
russian = VERY GOOD.. and the most beautiful esmeralda!!!!!!!!!
this one however is not to my liking ... smthings off.. maybe it IS too quiet.. although when they sing as a trio it's much better.. the solo's put me off..
@MrWorldcommunication Why do you call another versions le massacre of the original one? They are beautiful too though the French one is still the greatest.
OH MY GOD!...this is my favorite musical ever!...cocciante is a genius!...i love the italian version (i'm italian lol!)...but also the korean one is amazing!...i love korea so i must love it!^^
I've seen the Russian, English, and Italian version of this song. I have say that I think the French is way better. HOWEVER, out of the 3 versions that I mentioned, this one had the BEST harmony(if that's what you call it or whatever) when they all sing together. (NOT better than the French version though). Can't wait to see the rest!
It's beautiful ! Esmeralda fits really, I think ; and I hate every Quasimodo of the musicals except this one ! Are the korean lyrics very different from the original ones, generally ? If someone knows ?
@Hauntya no its not very different , they have simply translated the english version which is also taken from french , the meaning is almost the same in most of the parts
I love this o.o I just find it odd that not one single thing (besides the language) is different from the French version. I just know in Theatre when you adapt a play there's always room for interpretation. I'm just surprised the costumes or some of the scenery isn't different.
Honestly, I find Korean version rather quite... I find their way of saying Esméralda really cute xD. But , I could really laugh when the man that playing the role of Patrick Fiori [in French] says "Oh Fleur-de-lys!", and when the priest says "Oh Notre Dame !". This is just too adorable xD.
Finally, I am sorry, but the French version, the original is still the best...
@MiniFleurDeCerisier As a person that saw the original down in Mtl when i was a child, this......... made me laugh!! XD Dont get me wrong i found it very good!! Entertaining for sure! But i do have to agree the original with Bruno Pelletier Garou Daniel Lavoie and all the others is so much better!! Nothing good beat it!! Good try though! I enjoy it!! :)
i think its messed up how ppl are saying Korea ruined it, obviously the Korean language is different than the french so it won't sound exactly the same. Love the Korean version
These 3 have AMAZING harmonies when they sing together at the end. I could listen to it over and over again all day I think :D But they are all very good, especially Frollo! Thanks for posting this for everyone!
I think the italian version is the best, but it's amazing to listen this version, I didn't know that it exists. (Sorry about my english, I'm from spain u.u) I think Spanish version is OK too, so look for the videos of Thais (Esmeralda), She's not Lola Ponce but she sings so good too. Sorry about my english again, I'm not from england ^^U
OMG a korean version, this is amazing !!! I have absolutely no idea what the lyrics say but the result is great !! And they've got beautiful voices =)
En effet, Notre de Dame de Paris restera une œuvre française, car elle a été écrite par Victor Hugo. Cependant, si l'on parle de la comédie musicale (ce de quoi on parle) c'est bel et bien québécois. Deux des personnages principaux, Quasimodo et Frollo sont joués par des Québécois et la pièce a été réalisé par Luc Plamondon.
@trumpeted6359 how can you even say this i agree with every one claiming this got ruined just clicked to check and found out one of my favorite songs has been butchered one of the best uhm if you start from the bottom i guess. French version is the best, than english than italian,spanish and russian have a shared spot, than we have other versions that might be there and this gets ranked last
I wish I can get to meet Yun Hyungryul (Even as a Korean, his name is hard to pronounce...)... when I saw him for the first time in a game show called Challenge 1000 songs, his voice captured my heart and I was melting like crazy. To bad he lost that show though, he would of been great as a winner.
This version is incredibly good! The stage set-up is quite similar to the original, but the expressions of the actors are amazing. The tightness in Frollo's face and the despair in Quasimodo's... I applaud them for bringing so much of themselves into this production!
Amazing-i get goosebumps even watching this video, and I love how though Esmeralda doesn't sing in this scene, she really embodies her character thru her every movement.
Love quasi's makeup and his husky voice even more :) and the actor is good looking too
I believe Korea is the first Asian country to do an official version ??
I don't understand one word of it but as far as voices and acting goes this Korean version is my favorite, right after the perfect original version of course.
Korean is originally the 'choppy' spoken language, so it seemed it was unavoidable that Korean version Belle damaged the original's rhyme pretty much. However as a Korean, I saw they did their best... Good job
I wonder the borders of the cultural perception face at the same rol; for exemple, in korean culture, how bad is that a priest falls in love with a woman? And the movements of the body, are they codified like, sometimes, in italian culture?
The italian version is beautifull, and it's better than this, 10 times, sorry but i disagree with you, totally.
It's more poetic and if don't understand italian sorry, but you must learn it and see the compete musical, some characters are even better than the french ones (clopin, esmeralda, frollo)
Garou power! :P mais la version Italienne est bonne aussi. Par contre Koréen :s enfin, je peux pas dire puisque c'est surement que mon oreille est pas habituée à ce type de langue :P
Fantastique!
hallospacegirl 2 weeks ago
them voices is like orginal singer :O it's great .
aprilmarby 2 weeks ago
omfg
NancyAkiraJ 2 weeks ago
陈汉典!!!
beautiful5e 3 weeks ago
bellaaaaa la parola bella è nata insieme a lei
patopathino 1 month ago
1. This version is great.
2. Maybe I'll check out the Japanese version (if it exists)
VietnameseGirl98 1 month ago
ахахахахаха
zabeg11 1 month ago
好爆笑 韓文根本不搭
cj6y7mp6 1 month ago
DPRK? :)
maxsouthpaw 1 month ago
@maxsouthpaw SOUTH Korea, thank you.
hbanana7 1 month ago
@hbanana7 Please It was a joke.
maxsouthpaw 1 month ago
JE préfère le timbre de Garou <3
WhistlerShadow 1 month ago
Lol c'est de la contrefaçon de Garou , Patrick Fiori et Daniel Lavoie !!!
maxou76700 1 month ago 2
oh? is this korean language?
wiliestman 2 months ago
right, wonderful
tthien12894 2 months ago
bọn nam Hàn nạy bệnh quá! nghệ thuật mà lại chén hàng thế này thật là đồi bại, những đứa vô liêm sỉ
artdvq 3 months ago
@artdvq là sao bạn, sao lại đồi bại, mình thấy cũng hay mà ?
kennylaw1101 2 months ago
@artdvq Nè! Sao lại nói bậy vậy?
VietnameseGirl98 1 month ago in playlist Foreign
I love this version!
Az201056 3 months ago
non ci capisco niente ma questa canzone come le altre è bellissima cantata in ogni lingua!
therebbi95 3 months ago
If Medusa and Pin head had babies, they'd have that hair of Quasimodo's. Loves it!
blatherskitenoir 3 months ago
Бурни овации!
RKlasanov 3 months ago
hermoso!!!!
nereidas68 3 months ago
I'm blown away...
...
...
...
WOW.
kthanhpn 3 months ago
All we think that the version in our language is the best. But let me say that the only judge of actors-singers' quality is the author Cocciante. And he is italo-francais, casually born in Vietnam.
MsMaric 4 months ago
wonderful...in every language!! bravo.
wildcherry73 4 months ago 12
boooooooooooooouuuuuuuuuhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Vous n’êtes qu'une bande de copieurs qui n'ont aucun sens d'originalité et pas de personnalité.
Vous faites honte à votre nation !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MyAmbrozini 4 months ago
@MyAmbrozini U_U Tu as vu les versions Espagnol, Russe ou Anglaise? XD Elle sont PAREILS que celle en français, car c'est une ADAPTATION!
KamikoNagisa 4 months ago
Quasimodo is fantastic!!! *____*
lizziesuperstar1 4 months ago
Asian Pheobus = WTF. It's just crazy that a show from my country originaly in my language has been translated and played in Korean.
beatboxpeej 4 months ago
Comment removed
vkvkvk1219 4 months ago
It's very often weird when you sing songs written for western languages in Korean or Japanese because they are often longer to convey the same meaning.
vkvkvk1219 4 months ago
you guys can do cars,planes,computer or any kind of electronics etc. but music is not your type of thing. im beggin you stop screwin classics.
hknboss 4 months ago
Vraiment vraiment impressionnant. Very good !
karimnovak 4 months ago
по-моему корейский квазимодо самый страшный))
TheZyuzik 4 months ago
french = BEST
russian = VERY GOOD.. and the most beautiful esmeralda!!!!!!!!!
this one however is not to my liking ... smthings off.. maybe it IS too quiet.. although when they sing as a trio it's much better.. the solo's put me off..
carolineptenchick 4 months ago
this version is...hmm..hahahahahahahaha
lordtaz222 5 months ago
its good,but i like the russian and french more. =)
Veroni4ka91 5 months ago
По моему лучше Русской версии не будет :)
VioletSakurachan 5 months ago
Мне не очень понравилось, русская и французская лучше звучат. Похоже корейский не такой мелодичный?
takeneo 5 months ago
@takeneo ну зато они старались. Вот китайцы или японцы вообще равнодушны к Гюго
TheMarat1972 5 months ago
ну ничо так, корейцы добавили свой колорит
TheMarat1972 5 months ago
Comment removed
takeneo 5 months ago
Russian version is the best forever !
MrSampledon 5 months ago
мне очень понравилось)) сильные голоса
i think thats even better than russian version =) rly beautiful
wizzard2k 5 months ago
In my opinion French version is beter then Korean... But my favorite version is Russian
Fnforcemint 5 months ago
The best one is the italian version!!!!!!!!
dottorgregorydenis 5 months ago
i think French version is best one to me
sam62345 5 months ago
once that you have seen French version no other version could pass , but this one is quite adorable too
cute!lol
wombat831964 5 months ago
Good, better than the English version, at least Korean understood that proper name SHALL NOT be translate!
8heilhitler8 5 months ago
Frollo is always best.
Blennorragie 6 months ago
It's very Beautiful !!!!
MegaVizavi 6 months ago
sarebbe bellissima anche cantata in ostrogoto
PlayerNo97 6 months ago 15
A rose by any other name would smell as sweet!
iumeomap 7 months ago
like the french,english and russian versions better than the other ones
AgathaBv 8 months ago
awesome quasimodo!!!
Harlaid89 8 months ago
wow, rly not bad, thought it will be terrible ^^
MrZimer24 8 months ago
Italian version is the best!
Absolutely!
I love it! :)
eLs97tiamo 8 months ago
Wow! I'm loving Frollo here!!
DarkAyO666 8 months ago
way better than the chinese version i think, tho they sang it in english
zakidine 9 months ago
Interesting version :) I like Esmeralda's acting in this scene too.
dzve 9 months ago
Italian version is the best !! ^^
I love it <3
nene574 9 months ago
Phoebus looks like a pedo o_O
other than that - adorable =)
SimonCleric 10 months ago
неплохо!! молодцы!!
TheAnarhist2009 10 months ago
The most charming Frollo is the Italian One XD
IreGenny 10 months ago
really beautiful but I think the french one's the best!!!
this esmeralda is really beautiful
tuenha 10 months ago
@tuenha agreed...i love the French version<3
3mobaby666 10 months ago
It's beautifull, but french version is the best.
aldon1000 10 months ago
Hmm.... J'aime bien cette Esmeralda par contre... :)
RNRwannabe 11 months ago
@MrWorldcommunication Why do you call another versions le massacre of the original one? They are beautiful too though the French one is still the greatest.
chobotarvalentina 1 year ago
Don't get me wrong I love Korean Stuff but that dude's name, Bum Suck ! That is just hilarious !!! LOL
CuteGorilla 1 year ago
@CuteGorilla Actually it should be Suk or Seok. But, yeah... I get what you mean lol
cooxia1215 1 year ago
I love Korean Esmeralda!!
nikalaj 1 year ago
i want to hear north korea version))))
pallap82 1 year ago
@pallap82 Um... I doubt one exists...
underthestarofnorth 1 year ago
@underthestarofnorth I know, just joke
pallap82 1 year ago
@underthestarofnorth Yeah, I kinda figured :D
underthestarofnorth 1 year ago
Magnifique!
TheHappyhaki 1 year ago
OH MY GOD!...this is my favorite musical ever!...cocciante is a genius!...i love the italian version (i'm italian lol!)...but also the korean one is amazing!...i love korea so i must love it!^^
SsSaBrAaA 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Awesome !!! A
And Korean Esmeralda is the most attractive =D
mystmoorth 1 year ago
Awesome !!! A
And Korean Esmeralda is the most attractive 8D
mystmoorth 1 year ago
Comment removed
mystmoorth 1 year ago
nothing matches the french (original) version
nooooot 1 year ago
viva...
10sakan 1 year ago
The French musical was amazing,I saw it the other day in highskool French class :]
amartinez6512 1 year ago
I've seen the Russian, English, and Italian version of this song. I have say that I think the French is way better. HOWEVER, out of the 3 versions that I mentioned, this one had the BEST harmony(if that's what you call it or whatever) when they all sing together. (NOT better than the French version though). Can't wait to see the rest!
Aralei13 1 year ago 14
OMG I luv this song in france and in korean *-* hehe
SvenjaChan666 1 year ago
誰でも記事を編集したり新しく作成!!!
mariopinducciu 1 year ago
It's beautiful ! Esmeralda fits really, I think ; and I hate every Quasimodo of the musicals except this one ! Are the korean lyrics very different from the original ones, generally ? If someone knows ?
Hauntya 1 year ago
@Hauntya no its not very different , they have simply translated the english version which is also taken from french , the meaning is almost the same in most of the parts
saranzm 1 year ago
I love this o.o I just find it odd that not one single thing (besides the language) is different from the French version. I just know in Theatre when you adapt a play there's always room for interpretation. I'm just surprised the costumes or some of the scenery isn't different.
KishoTenshi 1 year ago
Personnellement, je trouve ça très beau, même si je comprend pas le coréen.
heycalice 1 year ago
c plus marrant qu'autre choz
arnaudtouzeau 1 year ago
omg, this started from my hometown and now it's in korea O_O
minimouette01 1 year ago
hello mkla1000 what is the name of quasimodo.
TourDeMagie123 1 year ago
@TourDeMagie123 @TourDeMagie123 You mean, the actor? His name is Hyungryul Yoon
mkla1000 1 year ago
@mkla1000 thank you! is there any way i can see it in american?
TourDeMagie123 1 year ago
Honestly, I find Korean version rather quite... I find their way of saying Esméralda really cute xD. But , I could really laugh when the man that playing the role of Patrick Fiori [in French] says "Oh Fleur-de-lys!", and when the priest says "Oh Notre Dame !". This is just too adorable xD.
Finally, I am sorry, but the French version, the original is still the best...
MiniFleurDeCerisier 1 year ago 25
@MiniFleurDeCerisier As a person that saw the original down in Mtl when i was a child, this......... made me laugh!! XD Dont get me wrong i found it very good!! Entertaining for sure! But i do have to agree the original with Bruno Pelletier Garou Daniel Lavoie and all the others is so much better!! Nothing good beat it!! Good try though! I enjoy it!! :)
blondbabe16 6 months ago
Comment removed
MiniFleurDeCerisier 1 year ago
i think its messed up how ppl are saying Korea ruined it, obviously the Korean language is different than the french so it won't sound exactly the same. Love the Korean version
potaeto 1 year ago 3
Korean Quasi i great ,and Bell i really beauty
grendel306 1 year ago
la version Coréenne est tres jolie!! Bravo
JasminedeMassilia 1 year ago
very bad very very very bad
ilhambariton 1 year ago
These 3 have AMAZING harmonies when they sing together at the end. I could listen to it over and over again all day I think :D But they are all very good, especially Frollo! Thanks for posting this for everyone!
MusicalGirl4983 1 year ago
I think the italian version is the best, but it's amazing to listen this version, I didn't know that it exists. (Sorry about my english, I'm from spain u.u) I think Spanish version is OK too, so look for the videos of Thais (Esmeralda), She's not Lola Ponce but she sings so good too. Sorry about my english again, I'm not from england ^^U
Nana1990sama 1 year ago
OMG a korean version, this is amazing !!! I have absolutely no idea what the lyrics say but the result is great !! And they've got beautiful voices =)
...
But the french version remains the best ! ;D
naely93 1 year ago
Ouchie... a terrible Phoebus... And all three of them sound the same.
nodaybuttoday01 1 year ago
c'est vraiment n'importe koi en koréen...La vraie version celle québécoise c'est la meilleure...VIVIE LE QUÉBEC
desysaxoman 1 year ago
@desysaxoman Salut, juste te faire remarquer que c'est Français.. La version française... Garou est bien Québécois par contre
StuntPlaneBF 1 year ago
@StuntPlaneBF
En effet, Notre de Dame de Paris restera une œuvre française, car elle a été écrite par Victor Hugo. Cependant, si l'on parle de la comédie musicale (ce de quoi on parle) c'est bel et bien québécois. Deux des personnages principaux, Quasimodo et Frollo sont joués par des Québécois et la pièce a été réalisé par Luc Plamondon.
heycalice 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Its a Shit, Korean ruined the original Notre Dame De Paris.
XpresloX 1 year ago
One of the best versions of this. Although they all have excellent voices, Seo Bumsuck's voice really stands out.
trumpeted6359 1 year ago
@trumpeted6359 how can you even say this i agree with every one claiming this got ruined just clicked to check and found out one of my favorite songs has been butchered one of the best uhm if you start from the bottom i guess. French version is the best, than english than italian,spanish and russian have a shared spot, than we have other versions that might be there and this gets ranked last
mrssawyerford37 1 year ago
FRENCH VERSION IS THE BEST
firm71 1 year ago 11
@firm71
sorry but, the ITALIAN one is the best version
breeya1 4 months ago
아름다운 버전, 축하
fidilio89 1 year ago
@fidilio89 самая лучшая французская
Scar50x 1 year ago
WOW! best esmeralda!
dolunaydainsanolan 1 year ago
I wish I can get to meet Yun Hyungryul (Even as a Korean, his name is hard to pronounce...)... when I saw him for the first time in a game show called Challenge 1000 songs, his voice captured my heart and I was melting like crazy. To bad he lost that show though, he would of been great as a winner.
HarukoZ 1 year ago
This Quasimodo has a nice voice !
Krummablod 1 year ago
Quasimodo is ugly !! x))
chavan95 1 year ago
' Elvis Wong un chinois ' french canadian sketch lol
fremen99 1 year ago
It's official. This song transcends language barriers.
cyberdemon107 1 year ago
this is the most beautiful esmeralda i have seen
lovalova509 1 year ago 2
Wow...
This version is incredibly good! The stage set-up is quite similar to the original, but the expressions of the actors are amazing. The tightness in Frollo's face and the despair in Quasimodo's... I applaud them for bringing so much of themselves into this production!
StJohnsMount007 1 year ago
best looking esmeralda :D
qbe12 1 year ago 7
@qbe12
I Think Lola Ponce it's better...
Muartua97 1 year ago
Wow, Quasimodo was well chosen! His husky voice fits! :D
moosicalxCHOPSTICk 1 year ago 3
This is fantastic!! Very moving
homousios 2 years ago 3
oh hell oO
Quasimodo looks like Medusa XD
xXS4nnXx 2 years ago 4
hahahahahaaa!! French version stil the best
masterbabouin 2 years ago 5
good version, still I like them in this following: french, russian, itlaian, korean, english.
rusgreek 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they sound retarted!!!
HyperAuraCracK 2 years ago
Oh God I never knew there's a Korean version. Beautiful!!!!!
daonhatha 2 years ago 42
@daonhatha i never knew that there were other version
ReipubliKa 1 year ago
@daonhatha you are dumb
daunee3 6 months ago
@daunee3 Because I posted a supportive comment on a great video?
daonhatha 6 months ago
Found this today and I think it is amazing!
westernman2010 2 years ago 3
Amazing-i get goosebumps even watching this video, and I love how though Esmeralda doesn't sing in this scene, she really embodies her character thru her every movement.
Love quasi's makeup and his husky voice even more :) and the actor is good looking too
I believe Korea is the first Asian country to do an official version ??
studentgirl87 2 years ago
I don't understand one word of it but as far as voices and acting goes this Korean version is my favorite, right after the perfect original version of course.
Lilacsinm 2 years ago
amazing!
Mordecaiize 2 years ago
tandetne podróby !!!
sportsnk 2 years ago
there's no point in arguing for the better version, everything is just the same as other version except the voice,
Kinda surprised though there's a korean version. lol
kirintei 2 years ago
Korean is originally the 'choppy' spoken language, so it seemed it was unavoidable that Korean version Belle damaged the original's rhyme pretty much. However as a Korean, I saw they did their best... Good job
FalconsViewpoint 2 years ago 2
liked it more that the french ver )))
TheAeroLin 2 years ago
Vauuu...
This version is very good too..
I like it..
Bravo Korea !!
egeotomasyon 2 years ago
The Korean version is really awesome.....
nethingkorean 2 years ago
I wonder the borders of the cultural perception face at the same rol; for exemple, in korean culture, how bad is that a priest falls in love with a woman? And the movements of the body, are they codified like, sometimes, in italian culture?
It is just wonderful and very intersting!!!
Thanks a lot!!!
mariepilie 2 years ago 2
wow! this is actually really good! i love both koreans singing and Belle, so this combination really surprised me)) I like it)
well, better this version than italian - the italian one made me sick=\
RossOlimO625 2 years ago
The italian version is beautifull, and it's better than this, 10 times, sorry but i disagree with you, totally.
It's more poetic and if don't understand italian sorry, but you must learn it and see the compete musical, some characters are even better than the french ones (clopin, esmeralda, frollo)
KINGoftheUNIVERSE7D 2 years ago
wow :S prever french one. but same as
CelineFascinated
laskahond 2 years ago 3
first impression - strange, but it doesn`t mean bad :)
CelineFascinated 2 years ago
Esmeralda = Bada <3
:)) Haha but i like french ver more
Belle...
InoueMichiyo 2 years ago
C'est impressionnant de réaliser à quel point cette comédie musicale a charmé le monde entier !
Fredelidou 2 years ago 6
Ca donne bien aussi en koréen ! je savais pas qu'il y avait eu autant d'adaptation.
Algonas1 2 years ago 2
korean esmeralda is much more beautiful than french one
rosaluxemburg22 2 years ago 9
She's maybe the most beautiful one
mariepilie 2 years ago
korean version is better than russian
mariobolden 2 years ago 6
....
qtzbbztq 2 years ago
the korean version is alright......and yea Quasimodo looks umm yea no comment lol
bt i like the french version better than this or russian
xxxanaxxxx 2 years ago 3
WOW. That Korean actor sounds so much like Garou.
Nebulatus 2 years ago 3
I like Korean Quasimodo. Almost like Garou. Russian Petkun is the worst Quasimodo I've ever heard
robinmatch 2 years ago
Ever notice how all the Quasimodos except the French Quasi has so much makeup on their faces it looks like their faces are sliver? Weird.
saturdaynightsunday 2 years ago 23
@saturdaynightsunday watch the dutch version, ist good but the french is still the best.
joran2april 1 year ago
i don't like how their voices harmonize
appleJUICEomg 3 years ago
il più forte rimane Giò u__u. xDxD
hermioneweasley1234 3 years ago 2
quasimodo' great!
wifeofmurtagh 3 years ago 3
Garou power! :P mais la version Italienne est bonne aussi. Par contre Koréen :s enfin, je peux pas dire puisque c'est surement que mon oreille est pas habituée à ce type de langue :P
semperimortalis 3 years ago
Complimenti anche alla versione Koreana...Very good!!!
baronerosso80 3 years ago
It means you haven't heard the Russian version yet. That is the really worst
Chocolatecreamwafer 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow that's the worst version i heard so far and Quasimodo looks like medusa.
original french version is still the best
murrkissa 3 years ago
Народ. короче, Квазимодо хорош корейский и точка:)
RaverColt 3 years ago
C'est Garou le plus fort ;)
therockeuse28 3 years ago