Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (678)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Yuri has a soothing husky voice...it's so nice...

    her singing is so underrated..sigh.

    I was hoping that she'll get more parts in their song Mistake cuz she wrote the lyrics

    but then again I was disappointed. You guys need watch them live.. I hope Yuri will get more parts in their songs in the future.

  • out of their visual, their voice is individually awesome. im in awe watching the star star performance. taeyeon seohyun sunny was awesome. i ddnt expect hyoyeon's able to sing her part neatly like tht. i guess i was wrong abt her, sorry :(

  • I'm a fan of taeyeon and sunny when it comes to singing, but yuri surprise me here with her beautiful voice.

  • @wildwestpoint

    Yeah, Yuri has a very sweet and smooth voice. I think she has the best voice out of SNSD's main dancers.

  • I feel bad for Yoona. I mean, why does she have to sit there and not sing. She doesn't even sang ! She just speak !!

  • poor yoona:( i luv u always<3

  • yuri's voice is so amazing

  • YURI'S VOICE ..... -dead-

  • Sunny's so good at singing high notes!

    saranghaeyo LeeSoonKyu .. SNSD JJANG !! :))

  • my friend worked as staff here and said only yuri had playback bcz she wasnt feeling good..taeyeon also had cold but didnt actually use it and sounded amazing love this song :))) snsd loove

  • Comment removed

  • it's a great song! I DO LOVE IT :D

  • I wish all nine of them are sitting on my house right now singing this song (:

  • @misstalkytalk u don't have a house lolroflmaolad

  • my favorite three are at the very top of the "roof". So angelic with beautiful looks and voices. *swoon*swoon*. Tiffany! Jessica! Taeyeon! FTW!!! That first song is beautiful.

  • wow yuri's voice is beautiful.. :))

  • if you mean at 2:36, then its Yuri. (:

  • @EmiVickyFan lol. she just sang like how she sounds in the track. look at how she breathes.

  • @LittleMissterious No No, she was using track. If you listen the studio version you can see it xd' She breaths in the studio version too e.e'

  • @EmiVickyFan hmm, u may be right. ;)

  • @EmiVickyFan She had a cold then, so I guess thats why she used the track. We all know that if she wasn't ill, she would have no problem singing live and wowing us. ^^

  • Wait, YoonA just got the intro in Star Star Star ??

  • yuri ♥

  • HAHAHHA HYOYEON'S FACE LOOKS EXACTLY LIKE JYP'S!!!! AHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAA~~!!­!!

  • @oreallyABBY yeah~ keep telling yourself that~ maybe your self-esteem will go up a notch.

  • @oreallyABBY

    Hyoyeon is beautiful.

  • @oreallyABBY That's a terrible thing to say about a girl, Hyoyeon is gorgeous.

  • Yuri, Taeyeon and Jessica~ ♥

    I love their voice!!!

  • Yuri was my favorite here, but damn! I'm so proud of my girls. ♥

  • OH ! Why Taeyeon is lipsyncing ? She don't need to ...

  • @xsundaybloodysundayx she was sick

  • @qwertydfas how did you know that ?

  • @xsundaybloodysundayx because i followed their performances when they came out with Oh!. she had a cold or flu so her throat hurted.

  • @qwertydfas Ah ok , thank you ^^ !

  • Love this song, is so beautiful!!! TwT♥

  • STOP THE ARGUMENTS !!

    enjoy watching snsd :)

  • i love sooyoung's (alwaus) and hyoyeon's voice here <3 who says they can't sing? i want them to watch this and look at themself

  • OMG 5:41

  • Sunny has such a beautiful voice <3

  • Taeyeon gives the group a POWER feel Jessica give the group a POINT feel Tiffany gives the group a SEXY and DIRTY feel Sunny gives the group a SHRIEK feel Yuri gives the group a DEEP feel Soo Young gives the group a CALM feel Hyoyeon gives the group an UNIQUE feel SeoBaby gives the group the HARMONIZATION Yoona gives the group An ART THOSE ARE WHAT THEIR VOICES WORK ON THE GROUP THUMB UP
  • @okybudisn I have to disagree on some Hyoyeon gives a strong husky voice Sunny gives a aegyo nice sweet feel Yoona gives the nice soft meaningful voice Tiffany also has a sexy husky voice but it's rarely dirty Sooyoung gives the nice long vocals Seohyun has the harmony she also has the nice voice that makes you melt Taeyeon has the strongest voice she has the most balance and can do more voices Yuri has the sexy voice she also has weaker husky voice, Jessica also has a nice soft husky cute voice

  • omg they sang so well live even, theyre great while dancing! And its so hard to sing sitting down because its so hard to control your breathing.

  • Why the hell are you guys even arguing in the first place? This is hardly the video to start an argument. It's beautiful. Could we all just sit back and enjoy the song? Jeez -.-

  • SUNNY'S VOICE IS LOVE

    SOOYOUNG'S VOICE IS REFRESHING

    TAEYEON AND SICA'S VOICE ARE AMAZING

    FANY,HYOYEON AND YURI'S VOICE ARE UNIQUE AND LOVELY

    SEOHYUN'S VOICE IS MAGNIFICENT

    YOONA'S INTRO IS PERFECT.

    IT ISNT YOONA'S FAULT SHE DOESNT HAVE MORE LINES.

  • LOVE YURI"S VOICE!! btw i wonder how they got off the house

  • LOVE YURI"S VOICE!!

  • sooyoung's line fits her voice very well, but hyoyeon should get a different line than sooyoung, sometimes her voice is just too rough & not compatible with it

  • sunny so cute

  • i love hyoyeon so much, hate what people say about her

  • Hyoyeon is gorgeous! i love her voice!

  • Yuri's voice here ! I LOVE IT

  • OMG YOONA DID ,,WHAT SHES GOOD AT..**ACT*** OMG I ALMOST CRY ..SO BEAUTIFUL <3

  • i feel sorry for yoona...she was just sitting there the whole performance! they could've at least give her that "star star star" part lol

  • @1105Pokemon i think she was filming so she didn't get any lines

  • back off w/ that voice you all freeze me...kekeke!! nice song nice voice's...

    yah snsd im here!! b-coz untill now you didn't officially back to korea,,,,,^_^

  • Lol they all sing nice u stop arguing that one of them is better they are SNSD which means they are best together without one another there would be no SNSD

  • @baraashaar2 What are you saying, BITCH ? Fuck !!!

  • This is my opinion and keep you're dirty words for yourself we don't wanna hear them .... don't think if you or snsd would like to hear and say these words that we wanna hear them .... that's so ew

    DON'T EVER REPLY MY COMMENTS ... ^.^

  • was something wrong with Taeyeon's voice? she lipsynched all her lines in 'Oh!'

  • @ranarainy when?

    

  • i love their voice, so amazing!!!

  • who sings after sunny unnie and hyo yeon unnie???

  • Sooyoung!!!! <3

  • i LOVE yuri's voice here! SNSD fighting! <3 <3 <3

  • @SkyeKEY It was because she was lipsyncing, she was sick :/

  • @kakweesiblibytwinkel still doesn't change the fact that her voice is amazing! xD

  • Please give Yoona more lines... Even though she doesnt have a good voice, she still sings from her heart.

  • which is which, besides hyo yeon soo young and sunny? i seriously cant tell the difference between tae yeon, yuri and yoona.. HELP!

  • sunny's voice in star star star shine the brightest!:D

  • TAENYSIC at the top! xD

  • Tiffany

  • Who said Yuri can't sing? She's amazing.

  • Sunny have a sweet voice <3 :)

  • @XxKpOpFoReVeRxX i <3 you

  • @MisskikiCoconuts Taeyeon.

  • the middle girl the curled brown hair on the highest part of the fake roof thingy is the best singer out of all of these girls she should lead jus sayin'

  • @MisskikiCoconuts Taeyeon is the leader and the oldest of the group, and best singer.

  • @StrickenWithFear nice shes really good

  • @MisskikiCoconuts I envy her great voice

  • the middle girl on the highest part of the fake roof thingy is the best singer out of all of these girls she should lead an i just learned about this group

  • @MisskikiCoconuts Yeah~ That's Taeyeon. She's the oldest, the leader and main vocals of the group~

  • Seobaby so cute <3 จุ๊ฟฟ ฟ

  • yuri and taeyons voice!! waaaaaaa! :) awesomme.. suits the song very well

  • idk why but iam a lil' bit happy that yoona is didnt sing at this song (no offense) but i dont like her voice for a slow-high-pitch-song like this, it didnt suits her (i love yoona!). hey sunny can sing! she's lead singers you know!

  • i think everyone all of them sung well:D

  • Why are people arguing over such stupid things? I'm not really a SNSD fan, but I like their ballads. So pssssh!!

  • @MrsKuraudoSutoraifu high five man high five. Im a sone and i respect you LOL

  • yuri!!!! and sunny did a fantastic job here!

  • they can sing very well!yul singing in mistake very well

  • FANY FANY TIFFANY!

  • now for those who say SOOYOUNG and HYOYEON can`t sing here is the proof that they CAN,so for those guys go get some life and leave our girls alone >:(

    I LOVE SNSD so much

    SNSD fighting we(sones) is always here to support you our 9 angels<3<3<3

  • And in honesty of what I'm saying, no matter what, Im sure they still sing to their best and to their fullest, even if they can't sing. Their voices are not as bad as what everyone is saying. I prefer their voices over Rebecca Black's voice.

  • To sum things up: taeyeon and Yuri no doubt lipsynced, but no one needs to make a huge deal out of it. We all know that Taeyeon is the best and main vocalist in the group and Yuri is a good singer. Yoona didn't get any lines, it's sad yes. But it's okay. It's not the end of the world. Hyoyeon may not have a good singing voice, but she does have some vocals to help her singing. Sunny has more than she was credited for. Sooyoung is like Hyoyeon, but a more softer voice with some vocals.

  • Comment removed

  • @Angelover301 they arent lip-syncing. some parts maybe (such as sunny's "falsetto" notes or yuri's part) but most of this was live, and not lip-synced.

  • it's a nice song

    Hyoyeon has voice guys she can sing i hope she gets more parts

  • everyone's lip syncing. the song's playing. they don't actually need to sing. But sometimes some people sing although all they need to do is lip sync. so thats why you can hear them inhaling. but i'm very very very sure they are lip syncing

  • Comment removed

  • @Angelover301 Your face. They all lip syncing? Loll... so immature comments, try the MR Star3x there are actually members who sings live. Fail kid.

  • @Angelover301

    Why you bitching on the girls, especially Yoona? You mad cuz she's famous, unlike you who waste your time bashing on them.

  • @AJokhun an your bashing him for bashing the girls you look just as dumb

  • @TheoriginalMjj90 And here you are bashing me for bashing an unreasonable person who bashes on the girls. Now you're looking as the dumb one.

  • @AJokhun no i didnt bash u at all what you wrote was plainly ignorant to him. so now you look even dumber.

  • @TheoriginalMjj90

    What I said about the other person is true and here you are judging my statement. And what are you? Defending an anti or trying to be a troll.....

  • @AJokhun are you an idiot or something you obviously take this anti,sone shit way to seiously ppl like you are beyond irritating. its called respect learn some instead of talkin trash to someone because they dont like your favorite girl group. Not everyone likes snsd get over it.

  • @TheoriginalMjj90

    So I assume you're an anti as well. First of, If you dislike the girls, why are you watching and commenting here?

    Second, I was questioning the other person and a d-bag like you butted in. So eventually you're the dumb one. And I have no problem with people hating on the girls, I was simply questioning 'em. So get your facts straight before accusing others.

  • @AJokhun yet again your an idiot as snsd is one of my favorite groups so get your facts before you start accusing others. Saying something ignorant to ssomeone like what are you mad cuz they are more famous than you is ignorant an its morons like you that make others hate snsd, obviously you cant even comprehend what im talking about because your idiot self just claimed to be an "anti" do you know how dumb that sounds. calling people antis an see you nothing wrong with that. im done with u now.

  • @TheoriginalMjj90

    Well, you were the one who cause this situation to accumulate in the first place. We could have ended this in a more positive foot if it weren't for your insults. Have a great day sir.

  • you know why yoona didn't get to sing? because her voice can't sing ballad. It would probably ruin the whole thing. This is proof that her singing is the least in SNSD. even hyoyeon got a part

  • @Angelover301 lol. you blocked me because of my comment. is that all you've got? btw, here's my reply:

    ooooh, I'm sorry for that. I never knew you told that "scores of times" already. And I can't believe yoona's like that :( yeah, you're pretty right about the hyoyeon & taeyeon part. didn't you notice that in hoot hyo got only ONE PART. I hated SM for that :( but how did you find out about yoona complaining? did you hear it from someone who works in SM? can i have some proof PLEASE ^^ kthnx.

  • @azulaangel hyo got one part. which means although she may not be one of the good singers in snsd, atleast she can sing a little ballad. If not she would be talking with yoona.

    I can't remember where but i was once watching an article of one of the boy groups i don't remmeber which sorry. They said something about groups not getting a lot of lines because of too many members ( i think it was SuJu ) and then they said that even yoona complains that her lines are too little. And thats called ego

  • @Angelover301 lol ! where is the solid prove? get a life ! why don't make love instead of making an anti video of yoona?!

  • @Angelover301 really? WOW. I can't believe yoona said that. but i still like her. to be honest there was also a time when i was really upset because i felt bad for the other members especially hyo. from gee-hoot didn't you notice yoona's always the one in center in the first chorus? i got angry at sm because they don't even let the other members shine unlike yoona. but i still like yoona ^^ i always thought sm did that. i never knew yoona said that wow. still, i'm gonna look for proof myself..

  • @Angelover301 lol if they were lipsynching it would sound exactly like the studio version which it doesnt use a little common sense

  • hyo yeon can sing ! and it wouldnt matter if she couldnt, cuz shes a beast dancer, which is why sm chose her <3

  • the maknaes are away from the unies :DD

  • im sry not to hate but hyeyeon cant sing.

  • @heartbreakdrakemusic get your own life and dont bash anyone!!!

  • poor yoona she didnt get to sing

  • I really think Taeyeon and Yuri were lipsyncing in Star3x, because Taeyeon were sick that time and Yuri had a very heavy schedule...I'm not saying they can't sing though, it's understandable :)

  • was yoona crying?

  • yoona only talked in star star star....

  • Star Star Star is probably my favorite song on this CD! Sunny sounds so amazing! I didn't know she could sing that high pitch for real!

  • Sooyoung and Hyoyeon can sing very well, just tat Sm Ent doesn't give th 2 of thm chance.. It really irritated me when I knew they only managed to sing 1 line in Dear Mom ..

  • love taeyeon

  • O_O.... i love yuri's voice.... <3

  • @minyulshidae19 so did i until i found out she was lipsyncing :(

  • @minyulshidae19 Which one is Yuri? I always get her mixed up with Yoona and Seohyun lol

  • @babydancer07

    the one singin at 2:38 :)

  • taeyeon's voice can really melt my heart and bring out all the emotions that have been bottled up.

  • sunny pwned this performance :DD

  • Ugh. Some Sones are so hypocritical. This song still needs more Hyoyeon. Other songs need more HYOYEON.

  • Taeny >//<

  • guys can u all please shut up ESPECIALLY TO THOSE ANTIS!

    sooyoung and yoona can sing but not as good like taeyeon,jess,seo,tiff and sunny.and hyoyeon can sing but not as ballad or something same as sooyoung. they can sing very well,like in RDR hyoyeon and sooyoung,yoona standout in that song because their voice really fit to those kind of song...! so please just shut up if u dnt know everything.

    SNSD jjang.to my 9 angels dnt mind those anti we r here(sones) to protect yo. WE LOVE YOU girls ! <3

  • @jam03100 Yeah, but Yoona got only 2 lines while Hyo got 4 lines..........but HYO GOGOGO!! same with Yoona

  • Sunny sings REALLY well when she doesn't try to sound cute.

  • TaeYeon<3 Sunny<3 HyoYeon<3 Jessica<3 Tiffany<3 SeoYeon<3 SooYoung <3 Yuri<3 YooNa<3

    SNSD FIGHTING!~ <3

  • 1:56 Why... YoonA looks so happy.

  • how can i watch an energetic song after a sad one?

  • This is the best song on this album and I am really impressed about how they sang this. Especially Sunny, who I admit I thought could not sing. But she definitely steals the show in this song. Even Yuri sounds great! I love SNSD even more now... if that's possible. I do still think it's weird that Yoona got like no lines though.

  • your right sunny does sound great i also thought she could not sing but she did really good on this song poor yoona has no lines

  • I like the sound of Yuri's voice!

  • Star,,Tell me,whaT CaN I dO??

  • i think sunny really sang well here..

  • @COJYkpop yeah, but jessica sounded kinda bad :(

  • To all anti- fans, you can see how Hyo Yeon unnie, Sunny unnie, Yuri unnie, Soo Young unnie can SING!!! <3

  • @hninaung and Tae yeon unnie!!! :)

  • @hninaung sorrrryy i'm a sone too (: but in this they were lip syncing.

  • @sorrybutiloveyouu yeah... I am not saying they aren't. As I know, Taeyeon unnie and Yur unnie are lip syncing. :)

  • @sorrybutiloveyouu no, they're not, listen carefully

  • @dudephilippe9 dude...i'm a sone don't rage at me for saying something that is different. i forgot what i said, but i knew taeyeon didn't meant to lip-sync but she was sick and needed to because sick voice and singing aren't exactly the best combination. i never doubted either taeyeon or yuri's talent as a performer. you're just insecure about people's opinion of your idols.

    don't fucking rage at me because you can't understand what i commented. because you just sound stupid and ignorant

  • @MelGemma i think they have an reasonable reason thats why they didnt give yoona any singing part ,.. we dont know whats goin on their minds so lets just understand ..

  • For all the anti`s please think twice, These Girls WORK HARD for this sucess!! and after that you`ll just hate them??? What kind of Human are you??? God given you mind to use it well TNX and I LOVE SNSD SUPPORT THEM FOREVER SONES!!!!!

  • Hyoyeon :)) her voice is really nice :) and sica and fany did good here :)

  • SUPER ADDICTED TO THIS SONG :D !

    SNSD IS THE BEST (Y)