She is lip syncing, but thats only because this is a brittish show. Which artists usually lip sync on. On her Dignity Tour she sang every song live, beautifully.
@daviddiabetik no, she mostly lip-syncs, and on the tour most of her songs were playbacks, and when she did sing live for real it wasnt for the whole song, e.g. Fly was sung live for the verses but she lip-synced with the chorus cus shes not that strong a singer... but i still like her
yeah, she is lip-syncing...because thats what you are expected to do on british shows..it's the norm.
In America the tv people would rather the artists sang live, but in UK the producers would rather artists pre-record and the presenters can build up to the performance.
Me, myself ..I always prefer it live cos that is when talent kicks in but somre vids look good so who am i to say>
I can say that she's my fav, but I really do think she's not singing live... or maybe she is, but, whatever right? It won't change the way I feel about her.
you know even if she is lip syncing, it could just be because she had to (sure she shouldn't be afraid to sing live-she's not she's done it before) singers use this sometimes because maybe after all the singing they put themselves up to it gets too much or from sour throats, or even the mood their in, just because their all great talented singers doesn't mean their lungs and throats are invisible from not stay perfect.
is this her live? or is she supposed to be live but lip singing? if she's really singing she has an awesome voice, way better than miley shes a loser, anyway, i love hialry duffs voice! it rocks!
It doesn't matter if she's lip synching at least she a good role model. Alot of people lip synch like Lindsay lohan, Miley Cyrus, Vanessa, Ashley and alot so who cares!! No offense!! GO HILARY!!
OHH MYY JONASS. she needs to just sing. shes lyp synching in every video. when i was like 11 i was OBSESSED with her. ahha. now my new obsession is jonas brotherssss<3
I can't believe people are trying to act like she isn't lip syncing. Listen to the music video, and then listen to this song. They sound EXACTLY the same. It's not BAD that she's lip syncing, but her fans have to accept that she is in this video. Give me a thumbs down if you want, it's the truth. =/
NO. If they sound like the VIDEO then they DO lipsynch. If you can hear a natural between phrase breath and a semi- wait. Did I type gibberish or are you f**king blind? If anyone sounds exactly like the video and moves their lips slowly IT'S LIPSYNCHING. Jeez. You ARE blind. And I said I wasnt hating. Hating on a celeb is constantly leaving bad comments. Hell I LIKED Hilary then I started disliking her music. I love her studio voice from 2003-2005.
i think its pretty lame how yall focus on if it sounds the same as the cd.
and when she doesn't lip sing, yall pick on her because it doesn't sound like the cd. and when she does, you pick on her because it sounds like the cd. think about that. :)
uh, blueguitar08 i definitely agree with you she is so lip synching but have you ever heard katharine mcphee sing somewhere over the rainbow, it sounds exactly like the single she sang on american idol and her "demo" somewhere over the rainbow/my destiny-single cd
yes she wasnt singing live, im sorry but why call ur self a singer when you really dont know how? you just pretty much give poeple a rip off especially lyp synced performances.
your a bitch dont bang on Her shes a better singer then anyone!!! Why watch this if your just gonna be mean to her. Did you ever think that maybe she was forsed to lip sync or she was sick?? I have been to all her tours and she never lip synced so she has to have a reason
why she's sounds amazing
Lovelyonuoha 5 months ago
i love her. she is better than miley!
amyleebrox123456789 10 months ago
she is so gorgeous!
tcptcp123 1 year ago
Das hört sich ja mal unecht an.
Kackpratze100 1 year ago
@Kackpratze100 stimmt doch gar nicht waas laberst du
Kackpratze100 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DAMN Folks! hav u
check out Mcdonald's truth?? this will shock you... SIMPLY CLICK
ON OVER CHANNAL TO VIEW IT!
MarilynnReidel19883 1 year ago
even LIVE, she sounds AWSOME!!! now SHE has talent...
popthewindow 1 year ago
She is lip syncing, but thats only because this is a brittish show. Which artists usually lip sync on. On her Dignity Tour she sang every song live, beautifully.
daviddiabetik 1 year ago
@daviddiabetik no, she mostly lip-syncs, and on the tour most of her songs were playbacks, and when she did sing live for real it wasnt for the whole song, e.g. Fly was sung live for the verses but she lip-synced with the chorus cus shes not that strong a singer... but i still like her
mandyjanemore 10 months ago
it's top of the pops?
MsMileyPeace 1 year ago
playback...........
Kackpratze100 1 year ago
yeah, she is lip-syncing...because thats what you are expected to do on british shows..it's the norm.
In America the tv people would rather the artists sang live, but in UK the producers would rather artists pre-record and the presenters can build up to the performance.
Me, myself ..I always prefer it live cos that is when talent kicks in but somre vids look good so who am i to say>
wilmacpossilboyz 1 year ago
This song sounds a hell of a lot better without the backup vocals.
TheGizmo4382 1 year ago
she isn't lip synching. it's sad that most artists suck live so we have to bash those who actually have a decent voice.
eatshit2924 2 years ago
I think she's lip syncing, but she's still amazing!! I LOVE her and this song! x3
xLorreeehWHATEVERx 2 years ago
OMG HilaryMedia doesn't exist anymore!
alczem 2 years ago
wow she sounds really good! omg check out me singing this song!
horselover511 2 years ago
I can say that she's my fav, but I really do think she's not singing live... or maybe she is, but, whatever right? It won't change the way I feel about her.
lilibabalu 2 years ago
It's a compliment to her if people think she lip syns. Coz She doesnt, that must mean she sounds as good as the recrded version
cassieemaree 2 years ago
On one occasion she was accused of Lip Syncing but it turned out her microphone wasn't turned on properly.
Jamessy65 2 years ago
she is soo lipsyncing
i haf her cd
n i was listenin to it at the samee time
n it full sounds the same.
SHIZHENGGGGG 2 years ago
fake fake fake
Avril Lavigne goes to a lot of program and always sings live.
I LOVE AVRIL LAVIGNE MORE THAN EVERYTHING THIS WORLD!
Avrilackles 2 years ago
she was waaaay to skinny here
bb1816 2 years ago
she sounds EXACTLY the same in 2 different occasians. shes so lip syching. or alteast singing with a track. her band sounds exactly the same.
yoitsjoee11 2 years ago
Well guys many tv shows like this do that, but all her fans and so many people known that she really can sing :)
umbreoncero 2 years ago
Plz stop posting comments that she lip syns...
PLZZZZZZ....
She really SINGS man...
princeroyal001 2 years ago 2
It is so obvious that she is not lip syncing!
leezakayding 2 years ago
hilary i love you ...vieni in italiaaaa
AGNESUZZA 2 years ago
fake fake fake!
angelfan710 2 years ago
It was not fake
prinsses9742 2 years ago 3
totally fake, it sounds just like her recorded song. It still sounds good though, but she really is lip syncing
JustineCase1 2 years ago
i LOVE HIL ,
if she could came to argentina, it would be THE BESTTTTTTT
ivanna27 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
come visit me hilary
andoy90 2 years ago
...why do hey agents make her lip sync. she can actually sing.
they should let her prove it.
germanbaby17 2 years ago
This is totally fake. The singing and the music. They just popped in the cd and tried to make it look real.
ESP4382 2 years ago
i love this song!!!
omg you´re awesome...love ´u hilary!!!
darielduff 2 years ago 2
i love this song
RIMVYDASM69 3 years ago 13
she is sooo gorgeous
liznpollis 3 years ago 8
I could watch this video all day. I think I'll call in sick and do just that.
Tynorman10 3 years ago 8
shes completely beautiful
afeaugas 3 years ago 15
(wasn't try to sound like I'm having an issue with the comments; just putting across a good point) :D
elliehaydon 3 years ago 6
you know even if she is lip syncing, it could just be because she had to (sure she shouldn't be afraid to sing live-she's not she's done it before) singers use this sometimes because maybe after all the singing they put themselves up to it gets too much or from sour throats, or even the mood their in, just because their all great talented singers doesn't mean their lungs and throats are invisible from not stay perfect.
elliehaydon 3 years ago 9
WHO... HONESTLY GVES A SHIT IF SHES LIP SINCKING?!?
or HOEVER you spell it LOL
shes amazingg, beauitful, talented and such a great role model.
talinevogue 3 years ago 7
is this her live? or is she supposed to be live but lip singing? if she's really singing she has an awesome voice, way better than miley shes a loser, anyway, i love hialry duffs voice! it rocks!
girlygirl1077 3 years ago
I don't really know why she always lip synch.She a great singer so she shoundn't be afraid to sing live.
moonlite9 3 years ago 3
It doesn't matter if she's lip synching at least she a good role model. Alot of people lip synch like Lindsay lohan, Miley Cyrus, Vanessa, Ashley and alot so who cares!! No offense!! GO HILARY!!
lizzie9513 3 years ago 3
i agree with u.. lip synch doesn't means that they cant sing.. =)
o0libra0o 3 years ago 2
omg.
diana452403 3 years ago
Duh she's gana sound like the CD because she sang it ....what do u want her to throw her voice to please u loosers?
shmogen 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
OHH MYY JONASS. she needs to just sing. shes lyp synching in every video. when i was like 11 i was OBSESSED with her. ahha. now my new obsession is jonas brotherssss<3
joexjonasxfreakk 3 years ago
but she has more money than the gay brothers :D
CandyMandii 3 years ago 4
... do you not even realize how much the Jonas Brothers lip-sync and have helping background vocals from recorded audio?
TheRealThespians 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol, loser.
talinevogue 3 years ago
si en chile viene yo supe porque mi mama trabaja con la compañias de tickets!!
isaisa57 3 years ago
play-back. I havn't found a video prove she's a real artist ^^' She never sing...
elsounee 3 years ago
watch her "with love" at ellen and "good morning america" totally live. different from the cd
jhugrae 3 years ago 5
i cant beleive that she sings live
zibushka 3 years ago
si ella si viene en dentro de 3 meses
yo soy de argentina
isaisa57 3 years ago
olaaaaaaaaa
oie kmo supiste esa informacion????
porfa responde soy d Chile
=)
kianten 3 years ago
Shes so BEAUTIFULL!!! i love u Hilaryyyy !!... and well... u sing good too jjejeje :P
Alguien sabe si viene en algun momento a argentina??
magisterius2 3 years ago
i love her outfit!
she is lipsynching, but she can sing.
NEWY0RKS 3 years ago
yeah i think she always lip singing! god!
whitewingdove 3 years ago
yeah she always does that!! she can sing soo why would she do that?
eline55 3 years ago
i like the t-shirt of the giutar playerrrr
Ninaki13th 3 years ago
Nevertheless I like this song!!^^
jeanhalliwellmatthew 3 years ago
PLAYBACK GRRR because it's the same version that the cd!!
jeanhalliwellmatthew 3 years ago
most singers in europe lipsynching so does hilary duff
zonegeo 3 years ago
she lips sings all of the time..... gosh i just watch like 10 videos of her and shes not really singing in any of them....
prettywinkpink 3 years ago
probably cause there on tv. She rarely sings live on tv, but in concert she sings 100 percent live! Watch the dignity tour videos.
georgiakate10 3 years ago
shes not really singing!
OJDpatient3 3 years ago
I can't believe people are trying to act like she isn't lip syncing. Listen to the music video, and then listen to this song. They sound EXACTLY the same. It's not BAD that she's lip syncing, but her fans have to accept that she is in this video. Give me a thumbs down if you want, it's the truth. =/
silkscreenfantastic 3 years ago 2
She is lip syncing. A live version NEVER sounds the same as a studio version
ninjamonkey9430123 3 years ago 2
why do you all think she is lip synching. when you can prove it then i will agree.
torimonkeys 3 years ago 2
Um SHE SOUNDS LIKE THE DAMN VIDEO! That's proof enough!
xxxthoughtlessxxx 3 years ago
well maybe she can just sing!! stop hating on her, she is freaking awesome
torimonkeys 3 years ago
NO. If they sound like the VIDEO then they DO lipsynch. If you can hear a natural between phrase breath and a semi- wait. Did I type gibberish or are you f**king blind? If anyone sounds exactly like the video and moves their lips slowly IT'S LIPSYNCHING. Jeez. You ARE blind. And I said I wasnt hating. Hating on a celeb is constantly leaving bad comments. Hell I LIKED Hilary then I started disliking her music. I love her studio voice from 2003-2005.
xxxthoughtlessxxx 3 years ago
whatever. no one can actually prove that she is lip synching or singing live only hilary can... so just shut up
torimonkeys 3 years ago
STO PER VOMITARE....ho vomitato!
asdasdale 3 years ago
Hey, quit pickin.
who cares if she's lip singin?
i think its pretty lame how yall focus on if it sounds the same as the cd.
and when she doesn't lip sing, yall pick on her because it doesn't sound like the cd. and when she does, you pick on her because it sounds like the cd. think about that. :)
ChihuahuaRules123 3 years ago 9
you are not lip singing so good job
Emy1613 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
FAKE
wildgirl74 3 years ago
okay in this vid she WAS lip synching
silverleaf1108 3 years ago
shes obviosly lip shyncing u can tell it sounds EXACTLY like the cd
HorseRider678 3 years ago 4
Muy bien buen video
spartan0026 3 years ago
isnt it a playback
zodiac0987 3 years ago
The show's Top of the Pops... man i miss it :(
Amazing performance :p
papercutdreamss 3 years ago 2
love it
bigbuckhunter7001 3 years ago
it sounds like shes lipsynching at the start but for the rest of the song i dont recon she is
Jullian212 3 years ago
Wow, the person drumming in the background is doing an awful job of acting like they know what they're doing
Jezabelrox 3 years ago
she looks fuckin ugly there damm...usually shes a babbbee
buscumb07 3 years ago
shes wasnt lip syncing here its just that when you downloaded this they put a track over it idk why they do that but they do
WildfireRocks13 4 years ago
im a fan but she was slip syncing but i think it's only because the ppl a TOTP's are paranoid!
No-one sings live on their show.
ZanessaUbaFan 4 years ago
she is singing in live u guys ar just jalouse
m4h33n 4 years ago
i dont think she is lip singing i love her
showjumpersoec 4 years ago 3
im a fan of her she is lip synching on this preformace but in here concerts its live but most of the preformances on top of the pops are not live
smily558 4 years ago 4
thATS RIGHT
:)
kianten 4 years ago
yeah, i agree.
but lately she has been lip synching a lot.
but i still love her
Briannahubbard 3 years ago
uh, blueguitar08 i definitely agree with you she is so lip synching but have you ever heard katharine mcphee sing somewhere over the rainbow, it sounds exactly like the single she sang on american idol and her "demo" somewhere over the rainbow/my destiny-single cd
MelanieCBH 4 years ago
she is totally lip synching.
it sounds just like the cd.
no live performance is identical to the recorded version.
oh well, she's still a good artist i guess.
:]
blueguitar08 4 years ago
è bellissimaaaaaa
paolettomrduff 4 years ago
yes she wasnt singing live, im sorry but why call ur self a singer when you really dont know how? you just pretty much give poeple a rip off especially lyp synced performances.
meboobrat 4 years ago
your a bitch dont bang on Her shes a better singer then anyone!!! Why watch this if your just gonna be mean to her. Did you ever think that maybe she was forsed to lip sync or she was sick?? I have been to all her tours and she never lip synced so she has to have a reason
WildfireRocks13 4 years ago
im her fan,but i must say she wasnt singing live.
love4musicgirll 4 years ago 2