Added: 2 years ago
From: ferorr
Views: 93,018
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (551)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • yes, this wasn't tim's finest hour vocally but since this performance he improved drastically! he was actually pretty good by the top 7

  • Bad.... Hes not but.... A bad singer...

  • O.o

  • He's cute, but he won't ever make a good singer!

  • its to late to apologize

    for making my ears bleed

  • The worst contestant to EVER make the Top Ten. Yes, he's worse than Sanjaya. What a fuckin awful season this was.

  • Eh, it's not that bad.

    I couldn't do better, so no complaints here.

  • Will you Marry Me?

  • love him; but this is the worst performance ever

  • love the song and love him but not together...

  • Maybe this song was too high for him, but he's amazing anyway...He's got talent!

  • Hehe, oh dear.

  • no......hes so flat and just uggg nooo!

  • if hes horrible he wouldnt have made it... just a bad performance.

  • not bad imo, not great too but i dont thibk it was that bad

  • I vote Tim Urban

    Every----day!

  • I did not like Tim at all when he was on Idol.. He has gotten a lot better though. He's grown as an artist and his falsetto is much stronger! haha. Anyway, I didn't like him before but i like him a lot more now.

  • i forgot who had to be replaced ... but there had t obe lots more people t oreplace this with ?

    this is igreatious

  • wtf is this..

  • hes horrible...no offense

  • that voice is shit, damn, why is he even on the show =.="

  • WTF??!!??!!

  • its not like he had that much of a choice of what he chose to sing. He did suck this song up, but its not his style.

  • Okay, i am a super-freak OneRepublic fan, like you don't even know. this version makes me upset.:(

  • he kinda reminds me of either keegan allen or munro chambers

  • he is so cute :D

  • Press 2 repeatedly for eye twitch

  • best part of it was seeing lee's face at 1:17 :) best part <3

  • kay come on, it wasnt terrible by any means. He just doesnt have a very strong falsetto.

  • This song isn´t right for him...

  • still better than anything i could do!

  • I met Tim this week and he and i jammed together. He has gotten alot better. His falsetto is MUCH stronger, his tone is better, and he's grown into his fame. Talked to him backstage and he's a great guy!

  • my fave song

  • I give him a 3/100, and I'm not the only one

  • i can say this performance was not that good well the song doesnt fit him. but when i was at penns landing and he sang he sang really really really good i wanted him to sing more he only sang like 5 - 6 songs haha!!

  • awfulllll

  • he's cute, but he's not that good of a singer... not terrible, but not a winner either.

  • he's losing power on high notes. hahha

  • this was a very very bad performance 

  • THis is awesome! he is so hot! i love it! he shouldve won

  • best falsetto ever lol

  • omfg he killed the song! :(

  • I did not like his performance on "Apologize" and I was surprised he didn't get voted off that night let alone him making it all the way to the Top 7

  • that was horrible!

  • I LOVE YOU TIM!!!!!!

  • Butchered a good song.

  • got to meet this kid in real life today. hes a really legit dude :)

  • YOUR Amazing!!!!!!!!! I LOVE YOUR VOICE!

  • im guilty i voted for this guy ONCE cause i felt bad for him and he was cute.

  • @gothamchix same here

  • The arrangement is horrible. What the heck did they do with the song.

  • @ty2 absolutely agree

  • lmao his high notes suck but his like normal voice isnt THAT bad

  • I remember feeling really disappointed that Tyler was the one who got voted off instead of Tim in the Top 24 cause I really thought Tyler deserved being in the Top 12 more than Tim

  • While I didn't think Tim was worthy enough to stay after this performance at least he did get better as the series progressed

  • lol I love looking back at these performances. his falsetto sounded like he was having a stroke.

  • God i feel so sorry for you kids. You have nooo idea what good music and talented singers are. You actually think this guy is a great singer. What has our world of music come to?

  • He sucks! Cant believe he stayed in so long. Oh wait yeah i do, it was because all the little teen age girls had hard on's for him

  • @mattdogggg I liked him and I'm 22.

  • @mattdogggg teenage girls had hard-ons for him? okay thats disturbing - didnt expect him to have that kind of a fanbase

  • I LOVE YOU TIM <3

  • he would look good on the stage, but i still dont get why ppl thought joe munoz was worse

  • 00:51 sounds like he became aroused :)

  • ok how did he make it on to the next round and not alexxxxxxxxxxxx, hes not even cuteeeeeee

  • ok how did he make it on to the next round and not alexxxxxxxxxxxx

  • @daloooli because Tim had charm and cuteness, and I didn't see those qualities in Alex. For some reason unknown to me now, I didn't like him. I didn't like Tim at first either until he sang "Hallelujah"

  • omg i miss him. he was my fav;]

  • ok you haters try to sing infront of millions of people LIVE and then i'll post a video and say how much u suk. honestly, he's WAY better than a lot of more famous people. Justin beiber cough cough...and the majority of famous people can't sing live anyway! So lay of him..he's AWESOME!!! ;)

  • He is pretty good, he just should learn what songs fit his voice.

    And he is cute.

  • seriously like he coulda did better but like i guess he didnt! he messed this sonnng up ! (:

  • Hahaha :D so funny!! this is ridiculous, how does a guy who sings like this get to the top 7? Sorry ladies but he couldn't sing if his life depended on it.

  • man this sucks

  • Tim YOURE AMAZING(: Haahaa.

  • dude he is terrible how did he made there?!

  • AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH I CXANT STAND SEEING ALL THESE HATE COMMETS!! GO SEE OTHER SONGS HE SANG!! ULL SEE HIS VOICE IS GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Oh holy fuck what is he doing...

    Be a model or something, cause you're hot... your voice? uhh no.

  • He can definitely sing people! This was just a bad song choice but he pulled it off! Yes he's not the best singer out there but alot of people aren't! Well done Tim! :]

  • he sucks

  • shit and gay

  • ok its not his best preformance... but if u look at where he is now! like on the american idol preformance he sounded to in pitch and like an angel!!! at least the parts i heard over my screaming <3

  • honestly...yes u can't sing but still u can be a model...

  • @9009HakeeM LOL

  • "This song was a last minute decision" - Tim Urban

  • He can just smile and do those hairflips of his & melt every girl on this planet. To be honest, I love him as a person, really, but I really dislike him as a singer.

  • i feel like dieing after this... i have to shut it off! I love him so much that it hurts watching it! TIM WHY! He does better after though thank god! :)

  • not to late

  • kay guys its not as bad as you guys make it seem

  • @timurbanlover3 Yes, yes it is.

  • @timurbanlover3 "Not as bad as people make it seem" doesn't quite cut it when I want to listen to good music to be honest...

  • "He's right. It is too late to apologize. I already started the video..."

  • this is difficult to listen to...

  • the only passed him on was cause he was hot!be a model cause i will TOTALLY buy your magizine!

  • Jesus this is FUCKING HORRIBLE.

  • omg hes super hot he should just do modeling. cuz he really cannot sing and it makes me feel awkward

  • bad song for him

  • He was picked up by vote for the worst .com for this performance, thats how he made it thru the early rounds.

  • uuuuuuuummm.... tim hunny i love you and all but this was horrible i mean your not a bad singer but you were forcing it to much and the results were horendous

    :( im sorry i still love you though :D <3

  • epic fail

  • FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAIIIIIII­IIIIIILLLLLLLLLLLLLL

  • why do people watch videos if they are just gonna criticize them? i thought it was amazing

  • @aerochic4eva i understand i hate when people totally bash on things and talk about how much they hate it but its like dude then dont watch it end of story

  • its nice version for me hehe

  • this was truly awful

  • Alright, so this was not his strongest night but he DID get better. I find it amazing how so many of you come and watch his videos just to call him an awful singer. Clearly you don't like him so why do you continue to watch the videos and critique him. Do you really have nothing better to do? It's just sad. I know everyone has a right to their opinion but there are just certain things that you don't need to say. If you don't like him, don't watch him. Simple as that.

  • This might not have been a good performance but, almost none of you can sing any better than this performance. You are all pathetic for having nothing else to do but critisize other people. That is sad. Listen to Come On Get Higher and you will like it if not you hate him just to hate him.

  • Who acctually voted for him besides his family?

  • @alihzah2000 smart people did.

  • Sorry Tim, it was REALLY REALLY HORRIBLE!

  • this was actually really bad, but i'm glad he stayed because he definitely did better later on.

  • yeah not much of a singer sorry. dont know how he made it that far

  • dude! the year i stopped watchin A.I. this guy is on there?

    =|

    ...and from my childhood town too...hmph...

    lol

    =D

  • falsetto is not his strong point... 

  • apologize

    for giving this performance

  • @TheKoolcee hahahahahhah thts funny and tottaly true

  • i loved this preformance by him....i think that he was really great!! and i was like wtf when everybody said "boo" 2 him...he was awesome!!! i just like his voice

  • he may be sexy but he ruined this song!

  • guys shutup so what? it wasnt great none the less he is incredible(=

  • Comment removed

  • @TheKoolcee TO say he can't sing is exaggerating. He can sing but made horrible song choices. He wasn't as good as other people, but to say he can't sing?

  • @TheKoolcee yes he can sing he just had one bad night

  • @TheKoolcee SHUT UP!!

  • @TheKoolcee This was when he was first performing on American Idol. If you watch some of his later stuff, it's actually really good. This song was just a really horrible song choice for him.

  • To everyone who is wondering why he made it on American Idol:

    1. Someone had to leave due to legal reasons, and they brought Tim back.

    2. This is one of his earlier performances, check out his later stuff and he's better.

    3. Song choice was really sucky for Tim...horrible...

  • @TheKoolcee That made me lol. no joke.

  • @TheKoolcee And i'm sure you could do better, little fuck wit troll.

  • @TheKoolcee : Fuck That Noise! You Can't sing! at LEAST hE WENT OUT AND TRIED! What are you doing? sitting at home on your computer facebooking to yourself criticizing people when you do nothing, so Fuck You and Get a Life xD Team Urban 4Ever!!!

  • He Wasn't As Bad As I Remembered It....Just No Falestto Tim :)

  • Ha this is ridiculous! This guy ruined this song! He sounds awful when he wants to do falsetto! Hahaha listen especially at 0:30 0:38 1:01. In those spots, his falsetto sounds weak, doesn't sound uniform, and gets pitchy... plus other errors on other places... Result: dreadful disaster!!!! Another plastic singer... blah

  • Not his best he could of done better but he should of made it fourther

    ANYWHO

    I am grateful Lee won because I predicted Casey or Lee

  • he sounds amazing but his high notes make me wanna crack up he should loxer them!^-^ he should have won i would rather buy a cd of him then lee

  • he sounds better with his guitar :)

  • I know some of you are fans, but listen this song is just too much for him it wasn't good at all.

    Even fans should admit when someones at fault and definitely didn't do this song no justice.

  • anny body who says he sucks obviously doesnt know music for theyre life . kbye.

  • Not bad ! At least, he tried his best ! He's lovely !

  • I love this song and did a cover of this, but it's no way near as good as him or OneRepublic.

  • People he is extremely talented and has a great personality!  BTW THIS WAS A VERY GOOD PERFORMANCE

  • he sucks

  • he normally sings better with his guitar...that's what ive noticed and he has terrible moments and great moments...but I love him...

  • This performance was great! No, wait, ALL OF HIS PERFORMANCES WERE and ARE GREAT!

  • Todrick Hall should have made it through. Not Tim. Todrick's "Somebody To Love" was the best moment this season, I thought.

  • Tim has a great voice. He has a great personality too. He was my FAVORITE on american idol.

  • this performance definitely sucked. lmfao

  • Wow I haven't watched this in a while...he STILL SUCKS!

  • im the to be mrs. urban he's so cute but he cant sing the only reason people vote for him is beacase his smile is awesome and he's cute

  • @coccoabunny2345 I look like him :) haha

  • @coccoabunny2345 exactly

  • dude everyone just needs to stop hating. he's not that bad. i want to see ya'll get that far on american idol and have the balls to actually even attempt singing such a difficult song. dont hate on people who actually follow their dreams. how would you like to have everyone smash you down when you're trying to do something you love? grow up and get over it

  • THIS IS THE SHITTIEST THING I HAVE EVER HEARD IN MY ENTIRE LIFE.

  • i dont think hes that bad stop hating guyss

  • OMG THIS IS MY FAVE SONG IN THE WORLD BUH THIS STUPID FUCK "TIM URBAN" RUINED IT WHAT THE HELL WERE THEY THINKING.......TODRICK HALL WAS WAYYYYYYY BETTER THAN THIS POSER

  • he sucks

  • sorry tim, but you suck at singing

  • If you like this, you're either deaf, retarded, or gay. I feel like I want to shoot myself in the face after hearing this.

  • he sucks

  • ridiculous song choice

  • Hes soooooo finne!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =O

  • it was good until 0:27 lmao then it got funny and really sucked lol

  • this is way better than the original :)

  • funny

  • He started pretty good but then he stuffed it on the high notes :P And now he sounds really good after only one week ! =D

    He's hot too ! ;) LOL .

  • SEXY

  • he can't hit those high notes it sounds like his voice is fading away when hes singing at parts of the song he shud've picked another song that fits his voice better cuz if he did he might've made it farther cuz he is HOT!

  • Singing is not for him. Hes well.. hes horrible. Go be like Zac and be queer with yet another High School Musical. And lets be honest. He only made it as far as he did because of 13 year old girls and depressed soccor moms who miss their teen years. Terrible.

  • Ugggh...

  • he is sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ooooooooooooooooooooooooo HOT

  • wow hes sucks lol i think it funny when he trys to sing high pitch. he may be hot no for singing.

  • OOOOOOW--stinko

  • He's so hott!! I love his voice. Too bad he didn't win. Lee is good, but chances are, he won't get as many contracts and the other chick who was runner up. Lee won tonight.

  • i love him but this isnt his song

  • WOW. When I first watched this, I was in SHOCK. Most horrible thing I've heard on American Idol (besides some auditions) ever. There were some okay parts, but holy crap! WHAT was he doing?!

  • @rachelrandom6 he's not that bad, of course he had a few bad moments but what he did with the song was smart, if you notice in the real song, those notes go a lot higher but he changed them up so that he can sing it, also the judges ALWAYS say do something special, do something that you usually wouldn't do, and he goes and does it, and then they tear him down. Yes it was not amazing but it was still a good try and not THAT bad, cut the kid some slack.

  • @xoparadisecityox I think it was mostly nerves getting the best of him, because he had a few in there that were pretty good. But you gotta admit, he only made it as far as he did because he has a gorgeous smile. Haha! =)

  • not a good song 4 him but i love him