STALKER: Call of Pripyat - DirectX 10 vs DirectX 11

[ganglandje]

there is no difference between the line!

:(

this vid suck!?

[MDFkLAKA]

it's same :D

[blindedby2monkeys]

so, dx11 has sunlight?

[tropicalrecon]

i thought this was a comparison video

[krisfather]

stalkers in pripyat lol there so is away not to fight my own when i get there but tell me is there a way not to go trought the plateua or the mercenaries>?

[erionmema1]

Stalker is not the best game to show the true power of the DX11

[Bastixxxxxxxxxxxxxxx]

I need help, when i play the game everything works fine but when i save the game go back to windows and start stalker new my savegames are gone :((((

Sorry for bad englisch

[hurnsohn100]

ich sehe da leider keinen grossen unterschied nutze aber trotzdem direct x 11 läuft damit flüssiger bei mir gruss an alle stalkier fans echt eingeiles spiel.

[MegaAibulat]

DX11 cool!

[HypnoticSuggestion]

The DX11 render is only for Tessellation of NPC's, nothing more. You will see no difference here.

[ctcon77]

i cant see the big differens

[jyeager24]

the difference is obvious from 0:01-0:05, its just science

[gungwahclorofil]

so..what's the different?

[KoSoVaAnGeL]

To me it looks the same. I can see big difference from Direct X 8 to 11 but from 10 to 11 there is nothing I can see which makes the 11 be better. The makers of these computers are sucking our blood with these tricks.

Why don't they make cards to start supporting all Direct X with just a patch? Well they will all be jobless. Then they go make cards that overheat like hell and die. Fuck that. I wish I could hang all of them.

It's really bad how they are criminals with a certificate.

[tocard3]

@KoSoVaAnGeL You can't patch hardware to support software it isn't designed to run.

[KoSoVaAnGeL]

@tocard3 This is the problem. They just don't designe them. Look at myself. I love some old games but can't play them on New OS windows 7.I feel like all they want is our money and not let us have fun.

[tocard3]

@KoSoVaAnGeL You can't design a piece of hardware to run something that doesn't exist yet. That would be like designing a vehicle that runs on gasoline as well as some future fuel. Also, you can play nearly any game on Windows 7. Today I played Beneath A Steel Sky which was released in 1994.

[Cobac]

@tocard3 the gog version was remastered , and the old version .... if you played it with scummv you kinda cheated 

[tocard3]

@Cobac Right click on the .exe and choose your compatibility mode. Profit!

[Babuu09]

the music is wonderfull, the music is direct x11 ^^

[chiffmonkey]

I fucking hate the grass popup distance in CoP

[MuslimsVsJews]

These are Basic Ugly Graphics By Todays Standard, And Yet With 500 Dollers Plus Worth Of Cards You get Sudden Popups And Cheap Polygon 4 Sheeted Trees, YUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

PC Hardware Needs To Drop In Prices Radically And Give Us PCI Express 3 Which Will Use No More Than 50 Watts To Run The Most Advance Of Graphics Cards, Today Many Cards Are reaching 450 To 500 Watts, Thats SHITTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

[2224321]

@MuslimsVsJews Learn how to type. Lol.

[wowaccpass]

No difference lol :P

[psychonaut25]

it looks like place where I live. All block houses in the former communist countries are the same :)

[MrMatyou]

absolutely no difference. moreover, i'm playing crysis 2 with directx 10 and the grafic quality is as high as with directx 11.

[Koopsas]

the only real difference i saw was better lightning in dx11

[JoshTehVideoMaker]

default stalker does not look all to great, with the absolute texture packs, smrter, and atmosfear stalker becomes beautiful :P

[johnotan74]

were is different?

[TwistXUK]

Direct-X 10 doesnt allow extra quality in their features, Dx11 uses resources better adds fuck load more detail, and in general runs far  better on Dx11 cards.

Tesselation as well, which doesnt do shit to the performance.

[gerpir]

pointels video

[FearSyndr0me]

the draw distance or 2 feet ruins it for me anyhow.

[SH1FTER92md]

@FearSyndr0me you're right, it sucks(

[pamew]

@FearSyndr0me Yeah, it sucks pretty hard, although certain mods do increase it a fair bit. The default rendering system blows pretty hard tbh, but it can look pretty good with some work.

[southertwat]

mindblowing

[MGSoldier]

They look pretty same to me. DX11 is a bit more brighter.

[sikvel]

what is the music?

[martyraz]

good music good game :))

[AndyMcNabStab]

direct x 11 is bullshit. its just microsoft again with their 'emperors new clothes' software.

[pamew]

@AndyMcNabStab DX11 is a lot better, it just wasn't really implemented that well in C.O.P. Tessellation is the only tech they really took advantage of, and you have to see NPC's and objects REALLY close up to notice the difference (plus the shitty draw distance kind of defeats the point). This is still the same basic game engine from 2004-ish, so it's not really a fair reflection. Metro 2033 gives a better picture of DX11, although it still doesn't really make full use of it.

[Chrislav7]

The dirrerence between direct x 8 and direct x 11 is AMAZING. but the difference between direct x 9 and dx 11 is marginal.

QUIT SLACKING MICROSOFT!

[yoran35]

Terrible encoding on 720p, especially for a video where you're supposed to be able to see the details.

[caskachan]

a becnhmark that does not reproduce the scenery-effects-ai-models position at the exact same time every time its run, is not a real benchmark LOL, just dissing the "benchmark" not you man thx for the vid

[USBEDR]

i like more directx 9))0

[psythrandir]

Can't see a difference. You should upload such vids in 1080p.

[USBEDR]

not so big diffrence

[snedie69er]

The goddam draw distance for grass stops me playing this game

[AlexDaUser]

720P [HD] and u'll see the difference in shadow and color ;)

[james007torres24]

went too fast, or was too far away for any detail to be visable, good job syncing though.

[zedisgreat3]

this sounds like Solar Fields soundtrack

[Saur0n100]

It's Beautiful ! music too :)

[Xpert30]

This comparison should be watched in frame by frame so that human eyes could notice the difference in graphics rendering...

[yosmer333]

Guys... we will never see a dramatic graphic improvement unless consoles like "xbox 720" or "play station 4" get released....

[Arsjonisteman]

@yosmer333

u will see massif graphic improvement march 2011

Crysis 2, full DX11 its gonna be sick :D

[GamerJulio]

@yosmer333 Correct. Consoles are holding PC devs back massively. Technology has gotten incredibly better, but almost every game has to be made to be able to down-scale it enough to run on 2005 hardware.

[jasonjapi]

hey can anyone help me with this problem? i just installed call of pripyat onto my pc, it runs fine with static lightning, but it seems like every time i switch to full dynamic lightning (dx9), the game crashes on the start, is there a reason for this? i havent try dx10 or 11 yet, does anyone what is wrong? btw my graphic card is an ATI HD 5450 512mb, please help !

[ukLeeham720]

@jasonjapi I have the same issue, I can only use Static or Enhanced DX10 mode (which runs like shit because I only have an 8800GT right now) There's no fix that I've found in all my searching.

[jasonjapi]

@ukLeeham720 *facepalm* why god...

[vipersickboy24]

it's a little brighter with dx11

[fuelofmil0]

he just drew a line and said the left was dx10 and right was dx11 :)

[Morticide83]

@fuelofmil0 No, he didn't do just that. Because there are scenes, like at the 1:50 and up mark they have people being seen, but then it passes and they're gone.

[melkegrls]

song name?

[calumhm]

How about the massively unsublte texture Level Of Detail lines in Dx10 that arean't there in 11?

>youtube kids don't know anything about graphics

[CripWking]

directx10 in green and directx 11 in red xD

[WarHawk215]

o.o no diffrence at all

[mAs7eRaZ]

Improvement?? In the end I can't see such an improvement in the fps, + the only difference I see is in the night the lighning is better on directx 11. So is it worth it going from 10 to 11 - NO, from 9 to 10,or 11 - Yes. It's always better wait a little bit more, specially if you know what are the new videocards are gonna do with newer directX ;)

[psychonaut25]

The music is nice....quite mystical...

[psychonaut25]

Now I want to play Call Of Duty 4

[halofannatic]

the only difference i see is that dx11 is slightly brighter

[9snaker]

@halofannatic

i thought dx10 is a bit brighter?! ôO

[Cyrax20000]

на этом видео ничерта не видно отличий!

[Yuanbaca]

Ok I Feel Retarded How do I get Dirtect X11?

[SufferingSarge]

@Yuanbaca if you have a video card that is directx 11 compatable and you have the drivers for it, you already have directx 11

[ZombeTheImmortal]

@Yuanbaca

For software: DirectX 11 comes with Windows 7 by default, and it is downloadable for Windows Vista, which comes with DirectX 10.1 by default, while Windows XP comes with DirectX 9.0c and doesn't support neither DirectX 11 nor 10.

For hardware: You need a GPU which supports DirectX 11. Currently only ATI released GPUs with DirectX 11 support, I would recommend you get ATI 57** HD, because the 58** series are way too expensive. nVidia hasn't made any DirectX 11 compatible cards yet.

[PsYcHiaTeRxX]

@ZombeTheImmortal thats not true.

The 400 series is DX11 compatible

[ZombeTheImmortal]

@PsYcHiaTeRxX I wasnt talking about the 400 series... X_x"

[ProjectRealityBf2]

@ZombeTheImmortal lol you make no sense, the 400 series is fully DX 11 compatible and actually performs the functions of DX 11 better then their ATi counter-part

[Alex1000pvp]

I cant find a difference.....

[SufferingSarge]

@Alex1000pvp i think the point of directx 11 is to make game less demanding meaning that it will use your gpu and cpu better

[efremch0]

The grass sure grows fast :)

[headshooter44]

dont come with texture resolution on a "720p" youtube video. youtubes hd is no real hd so you there is onely a placebo efect. if you wouldn't know wich side is dx10 and dx11 you wouldn't see a difference.

[BboyImty]

dx11 is better and it shows , the textures in dx10 is a bit foggy nd shadows are much clearer in dx11 !! overall dx11 is better..........

[thomas1984esc]

theres almost no difference between DX9 and DX10 if you are honest and not a nerd....just marketing shit

[kevingong]

I hate half & half comparison cause the two image is not the same so you got no shit to compare.

[GoldenBlackHawk]

I can't tell the difference since I'm running directX 9

[richysolo]

Finnnaalllyy, i see dx11 gets rid of those stupid shadow popups in the corners of the screen

[BDKsoft]

Stalking is fucking awesome!

[TF141Scarecrow]

i can't wait for crysis 2 in DX 12 o.O :P

[Niggix183]

@TF141Scarecrow

Crysis 2 will have dx11 :3

[TF141Scarecrow]

@Niggix183 i joke xddd

[wasitrealy]

If you look VERY closely, pause at 0:40 look at the ground in the middle and compare the color :P

[koogco]

This vid is not of a high enough quality to be able to tell much difference i am afraid, far too much compression-smudge on the screen.

[DaniEsteiro]

1:24 the kids were desintegrated when they tried to pass to dx11 lol

[GrowlingVocals]

idiot video

[DamzFR]

No difference on Youtube, but i think in native resolution there must be a small difference.

But in X10 or 11 there's always a lot of clipping with the ambrush ;)

[Ultradudeo1]

I personally do not see it, i have DX11, and to be honest, it is only noticeable in games like AVP and Crysis, which are quite heavy in graphics use, NO IDEA why AVP is good with DX11, it just is! anyone agree?

[Doofunator]

@Ultradudeo1 Well one thing is for sure, Crysis does not run in DX11, or have the ability to.

[Ultradudeo1]

@Doofunator doosent it? must be thinking of a different game :S i get some games mixed up, i do have 37 of them though :P my mistake

[mapukmapuk]

have a small diffrense with light

[hippie1335]

Isnt it a little brighter on the DirectX11 ?....

[ronspeck]

HOLY SHIT! Random magic grass! Seriously though these side by sides do DX11 no justice for the biggest changes check out some Heaven Benchmarks and picture comparisons.

[kalasnikov47]

You don't need a direct X update to have better graphics that's just Microsoft bullshit

[MrFrederiktorp]

U NEED A CLOSE UP DX11 BENCHEMARK To C the difference

[962192]

the only difference i saw is brightness + for dx11

[MrXtremie]

Well there's a difference, DirectX10 is on the left and DirectX11 on the right!

[WeEatBrainz]

@MrXtremie Yeah the game doesnt look very good in the first place, therefore the designers did not have to make any compromises for direct x 10, games designed from the ground up for dx10 and 11 have more significant changes.

[666KOEQJE666]

@MrXtremie you can see (i didn't saw it on the first glance) that the left is slightly darker and less colourfull

[b3sTy4u]

Direct x11 have more brightness .. That's all

[MasticatedCake]

DX11 has slightly brighter colours, that's the only difference.

[Zergikun]

@MasticatedCake You have no idea. Watch the Unigine Heaven Benchmark before spreading your dumbass knowledge all over the Internet.

[MasticatedCake]

@Zergikun That wasn't really called for. A simple; "Sorry but, no, you're wrong." would of done.

I personally think that the colours are brighter.

So fuck you.

[Kaesbollle]

thats why stalker isnt programmed in D11

[will891410]

THE SAME THING

[Thaibiohazard123]

even dx10 or 11........

the grapphic still shit !!

[wukenshin4]

is that screen tearing on the DX10 side or is it just bad video quality?

[TheFatal05]

there is no DX 11 in it, i see no tessalation...

[mrjamesb56]

Any Difference in FPS?....

[KeshnerfFilms]

All I saw was a line thru the middle XD

[jimthestuntman]

Direct x 10 is abit darker?

Thats all i can see

[calumhm]

Something I see here, and didn't expect to see; is that while the Level of Detail line filling in vegetation is still obvious on both, the LOD line for the texture quality is invisible on DX11

[Cyclomega]

Anyone know the music?  Thanks.

[sheldon1423]

Trees, Shadow, and the grounds and the effects kinda obvious to me

[trabant14]

in stalker call of prypiat on Dx 10 there is a freacking shadow line that follows you I hate it ...

[charlegamer]

Id laugh if DX12 comes out in 12 months and people have to buy a new card to use it.

Pisses me off that I bought a DX10 card (8800GT) and then DX 10.1 and DX11 Come out mocking me with the features I cant have.

[charlegamer]

It takes a highly trained eye to see the difference.

DX11 does look better than 10 but only by a small margin.

The PC needs 10 more years to get it's shit together so that were all running DX11 and 4GHz six core cpus.

[grineti5]

i dont care im not going to buy a new card!!! ill just stick to my sweet directx 10 thank you very much :)

[rggfgjerjh]

directx 11 looks a tiny bit better

[Marcusleitor]

directx 11 is best

[ToxeCryz]

The main visual future with DX 11 is pretty much the tessellation and better resource management. But DX 11 will not magically make everything tessellated and pretty. Just slapping DX 11 on to a game won't make it look better.

[aslankraw]

11 has 10% better graphics only o.o and shadow quality not anything else, Lol.

[Honza549]

11 is little bit better.

[NorwegicusOnAstick]

It is a bit nicer on 11.

The game it self isn't really that terrific. :p

[richie2801]

lol, you only see the difference by full tesselation on enemies and 3d textures on walls!!

DX 11 runs faster in my case ATI 5870 you can see more details in shader 5.0 better water and smoother smoke i see this on all other games to

[AETrainingDavid97]

I notice the infamous box shadow glitch is gone in DX11.

[nazar83cm]

нет разницы

[GarrisonReevesIV]

The difference is not as much aesthetic as it is efficient. The jump from DX 9 to 10 was a large aesthetics step, in some regards, whereas DX 10 to 11 uses system resources more efficiently on DX 11 compatible cards. Games developed using DX 11 will be able to utilize new code to keep system resource usage down, allowing more visual effects to be on screen at a time. Just because it doesn't look better, doesn't mean there is not an improvement.

[Estebanfuturo]

@GarrisonReevesIV sorry man but if we are talking about a GRAPHICS CARD and i cant SEE IMPROVEMENT , it is not worth to upgrade, unless of course youre in your puberty with no girlfriend lol.

[9snaker]

@GarrisonReevesIV

i don't see a difference, well maybe in directly comparable

but then: why does dircetX 10 looks better than 11

and why does 9 looks better than 10?

i mean what the hell is that shit?

look here for more stupidness!

youtube.com/watch?v=2WJG14uLA3­k

[DimDima]

The difference I noticed was that directx 11 was a bit brighter.

[TheCellCH]

Well but you do know that stalker just uses dx 11 for the shadows of the trees?

Seriously dx 11 got some kickass things like the tessellation

even Blizzard takes the new Order independet Transparency technology from dx 11 (for the coming games maybe)

What I want to say is, that dx 11 is just released and the first games who fully support dx 11 are not out yet

[PsyHeart]

the only difference that i can see is that the dx11 version is jsut a bit more clearer. oh and the trees in the dc11 version are a bit better rendered., but thats it really

[gabba1gabba1hey]

11 does look a bit smoother, less grainy. but thats just the game, stalker is infamous for fuzzy and grainy.

[satan163]

i hate grass draw distance in all games

[KMRecords1]

all i see on the left it look alittle shaded

[wan2do]

maybe just more reflections in 11 but that seems about it

[Alucardthedeadone]

Most people say they see the diff yet to get

[Alucardthedeadone]

@Alucardthedeadone (keyboard FU) Most people say they can't see the diff yet to get a good look at it you really need to playing a game on DX10 and DX11 for ur self a video only running 1200kps is not really going show you DX10 VS DX11

[TheArea510]

same

[dzonikg]

if there was no line in the midle i would not see any diference

[pabloenis]

I really don't care about graphics anymore... Nowadays looks almost every game nice, no matter if the shadows are round or a little bit rounder than round.... I want fun gameplay! :)

[0dani0valencia]

Es lo mismo...No?, yo creo que lo unico que cambia es el precio de la targeta

[SunLenZ]

you dont really see it in the benchmark, but you see it in game like wen its raining or your very close to a surface or object. the details with dx11 are a bit sarper and you have a nice deth feeling ^^

anyway this benchmark dont show the full potential of Call of Prypiat

[thefuckindarkside]

lol I don't give a fuck about DirectX... it's S.T.A.L.K.E.R. mixed with some super chilled Drum and Bass-ish track... see the beauty ppl...don't crack up ur butts screwing about the fuckin' DirectX...lol

[bladefinor]

They should have mirrored DirectX 11's screen from 10's. This way we MIGHT have seen a difference.

[Snake1337h4x0r]

i see no difference..

[o0CSS0o]

Make it high detail and there will be a noticeable difference

[StJohn0007]

Отличий ноль

[hedarfoota]

Dx11 has just started..give it time to grow...remember call of juarez?one of the oldest dx 10 games...even in dx10 it didn't look look as good as other dx 8 and 9 games...

[jesus160607]

I couldn't see any difference I guess the only one is in the performance. I don't know.

[gameplaya117]

There ere more vibrant colors on 11

[0nomercy0]

what about FPS? DX11 should be better...

[Jahofnietdan2]

I LOVE STALKER!!!

[knowledgethief]

what is the point of these comparison if both sides arent mirroring each other...?

[Mandragara]

DX9 FTW

[Georg5555]

lol where is the difference ?

[TF141Scarecrow]

@Georg5555 textures and shadows

[ClassicDragRace]

Seems that this game doesnt support DX11...

[zumm1212]

the shadows on the dx10 had a bug or glitch,whatever,but the dx11 had a pure realistlic mode

[thevandit]

I see no difference

[behemuth]

@thevandit ya gotta be close to see it, im guessing you know what tesslation in dx 11 does (pretty much what dx 11 is all about nowadays) basically, y'know how circular objects look like hexacons or octacons? tesslation increases te number of "edges" making the object appear more rounded. it has many applications but stalker have few objects in need of it.

also the shadows diminish in intensity the further away from the source they are,

[HuangQiaoqiao]

@behemuth Um, the tesslation in dx11 is the AA in dx 10. u can achive everything in dx 11 by using dx9, its just the way of how to write the scrip, whitch is alot harder for developer. And for hardwear company, its just another way to make money, since i see no significant improvment over manufacture tecnology and performence increasement.