The Doctor and Rose--"Whistle for the Choir"

[thelymachy]

Totally adorable, in every way. :D

[genericusername337]

I usually hate fanvideos with all my heart, but this wasn't bad. Usually, they try to add their own "heartbreaking" stories with some cheesy ass song and try to make it all romantic and stuff. Kissy scenes are nice but you didn't over-do it. I also like the fact that there's no special effects. Special effects just RUIN everything.

[gamwyn]

Well, I'm glad you approve. :-)

[xxlostgurlxx]

Oh this was fantastic, so simply done. Proves you don't need all those crappy effects to get a good video. Well done my friend.

[secondstarfun]

that was sweet. well done.

[ripfudgetgp]

wow - you did a really good job!

[tamsinuk]

this is amazing

I love the use of the ninth and tenth doctors :)

5*s and fav

[someoneatMHS]

I could watch this a hundred times and it wouldn't be enough. great job gamwyn!

[gamwyn]

Aw, thank you!! :-)

[StarSlime]

Wow! gamwyn, yo are officially awesome, because this video is AMAZING!

XD

[Teaspoon985]

One of the best fan videos I've seen, and I'm not even fond of this song. I'll just go re-watch it again (again...again)

[XFACTORROX123]

Where did you get the clips from cos i tryed loads to get some i even tryed the dvd and copying it but i can't get any?

[kt27rule]

i love this video it so cool

[Celiarts]

This is so amazing because even if you didn't watch Doctor Who or know anything about it, you'd still get the feeling that Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant are kind of the same person in this!!!!!!!!!!

If you get what I mean =)

[gamwyn]

Oh cool! I'm glad it comes across that way! *hearts Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant*

[Celiarts]

lol me too =)

[khmattie]

This is so amazing. Really fantastic editing and great choice of song. :D

[gamwyn]

Thank you! And I know I've said it a zillion times, but I am SO ADDICTED to this song!! Glad you enjoyed. :-)

[ChaosxEnvy]

...I can only express undying love for this.

[gamwyn]

aw thank you! :-)

[takeabananatoaparty]

Aw. This is lovely. <3

[jaynem89]

this hasn't got half as many views as it deserves! it's fantastic one of the best nine/ten/rose videos i've seen and i love the song

[gamwyn]

Thanks very much!! I'm still addicted to this song--it's so ridiculously catchy!!

[jaynem89]

I just found it again on my itunes.brings back so many memories the whole fratellis album is fantastic.

thanks for replying!

[gamwyn]

of course! :-) Yay Fratellis!

[DarkWolf839]

Nice Video, I like it :D

[gamwyn]

Why thankee!! :-)

[showmelonely]

I've watched this video about 12 times and I'm still not sick of it

[gamwyn]

heehee yay!! Glad you like it so much. The song is so addicting!! :-)

[litlcatfeet]

As others have said, your editing is superb on this. I really like this video and the one you did with Muse's "Endlessly".

[gamwyn]

thanks! go glad you enjoyed them!!

[applegrassdude]

Stunning! Your editing is SO good...and I love the song. Perfectly fantastic :D 5*

[gamwyn]

thank you!! so glad you like it. :-)

[sorcha425]

Any possibility that you might stick in that bit of the song between the first chorus and the second verse? I think it would make this even better if you had that. There are so many good clips that could go there. :)

[gamwyn]

a-ha! Somebody called my bluff. :-) I actually DID make that part but for some reason chose not to include it. I don't remember why at the moment. Probably something to do with my loathing of Windows Movie Maker. Maybe I'll do a remake at some point...

[sorcha425]

oh, I understand--I Ioathe moviemaker, as well! I do hope you do a remake soon!

[DWhoLover]

Fabulous editing. Great job.

[gamwyn]

Thank you!!

[wolfinmytimemachine]

Really cool! Great editing and a great song! The Fratellis rock! I loved the sound clips too coz they were so random, "I want chips", lol!

[gamwyn]

haha that cracks me up as well. Glad you liked it!

[cazzykay23]

I LOVE THIS VIDEO TI SO COOL

[8m57w692]

Oh I love this one too!! This song is perfect for them! I love the part when it goes something like "I don't care if you're crazy, because you amaze me" Pretty much sums them up in my opinion!

[gamwyn]

I know, the song fits sooo well! I like that part, too. :-) Thanks for the comment!

[sorcha425]

Sorry, it's me again. I just have to say my favorite part is when #9 rolls his eyes and then bobs his head to the beat-- Eccleston could be so goofy sometimes. . .

[gamwyn]

Heehee I like that part too. Good old Nine.:-)

[sorcha425]

I love this vid! It's refreshing to see a happy DW music vid, and the tone of the song is great.

[gamwyn]

yay a comment! :-) Thanks, glad you like it!

[gamwyn]

I'm lonely for comments!! :-)