Closer (Live: Beside You in Time - Unedited)

[narwhalswag]

I'm glad they put this up.

Makes VEVO look like less of a group of butthurt pricks.

[doobbbb]

I think vevo was high put this up here.... no fuck!

[twitter0418]

you get me closer to god! that's my fav part!

[sickolinokio]

nothing can censor me now 

[euphamismkinky]

still kickin' ass,ever since the '90's. ;) I remember going to clubs,'an when this song would start up..girls scream.

[TheG1ng3rN1nja]

maroon five did it better is what i would say if i was a little retarded teenage girl who actually thinks maroon five is cool

[gschl1]

@TheG1ng3rN1nja Well said, my friend.

[TheJenniffervigas]

Te amooooo Giovanni Caputa... FELIZ 6 MESES DE NOVIOS!!!! Te amo (2) No apto para menores jajajaja Love you!!!!

[blokey8]

Here's hoping with the new NIN stuff coming up soon, Trent's gonna be playing live again.

[taylorgoodman93]

@blokey8 yes! where did you read that? please tell me he's touring.

[blokey8]

@taylorgoodman93 NME and a couple of other sources; Trent was saying when he's done with the new movie soundtrack NIN will be putting out new stuff, plus there's a second EP from HTDA in the pipeline :)

[savannahbr0]

2:49 - 3:09 <3

[108chusDinAZ]

What?....Oh!

[shadowkid713]

I want to fuck Trent like an animal...... :]

[TollyPepper]

More than any other I've seen, this video captures what it was like to be down there in that mosh pit 16 years ago. Like being in industrial hell, with such intense energy. I don't even remember how many times I saw them on this tour, and every one was a f**cking revelation.

[TollyPepper]

More than any other I've seen, this video captures what it was like to be down there in that mosh pit 16 years ago. Like being in industrial hell, with such intense energy. I don't even remember how many times I saw them on this tour, and every one was a fucking revelation.

[gschl1]

He clearly wrote this song about me.

[TheAndiePerson]

I think it's interesting how people say they like trent's old look better, but if you think about his style changes with his music, and the style of his older songs changes with his look. He always looks appropriate for the album he's releasing. And he always looks good.

[HeavyMetalMushrooms]

@TheAndiePerson yeah but Trent could be up there in yellow pants, a tye dye shirt, and a helicopter cap and he would still look fuckin' cool.

[micromanage5]

@HeavyMetalMushrooms Bahaha yes!

[blokey8]

They should have an audio version of this DVD; the performances of Closer and Hurt are just superb

[xplodingirl]

I <3 NIN!!

[Felpally1]

Is it odd that i think about Yuki Nagato form The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya when i hear this song?

[sm4sh3d]

@Felpally1 dun worry, we all love Nagato, she's so freakin' different and out of contest you cannot help but like her, even if she's a fictional character

[Josseppe95]

this man is a genius

[StormReverie]

Primal...

[HarveeBear]

avampireconfesses . com

[outkastdashit]

vevo...fuck you and your ADS

[mariamariaa]

I wonder how many people have fucked like animals to this song.

[vanceisvloggin]

is this from and all that could have been?

[Yogamagick]

5 nuns disliked this song because they're saving themselves for Jesus to fuck them like animals.

[kevinstroup]

@Yogamagick : I laughed till something broke inside on that one.

[Yogamagick]

@Yogamagick *bows* Thank you, thank you. 

[bilboballbagginz]

7 people...really? How, as a human being, could you not like this song...

[violentdelights1313]

Miss the hair.

[crazychainsawkid1]

@violentdelights1313 same with me :( fuck I sound so much like a fangirl.

[Nickelrea]

Im pretty sure about 100 of those views are from me :)

[brlwww]

i love this song its amazing!! :P

[Loriann288]

Fuckin amazing!! 

[stacycoop603]

i was lucky enough to see NIN once from the nose bleed section Trent is awesome

[Loriann288]

totally fukkin awesome!!!!! Trent and Josh come make a Lorri sandwhich!!!!!!! u both would luv it!

[SuperVanGogh13]

Commercials will kill youtube

[NELLA1680]

THE LIVE VERSION IS SO MUCH BETTER THAN THE STUDIO VERSION, GREAT TRENT!!!

[013jared]

can they get any better they make this shit sound just like the studio version fuck yeah

[shadowofthevoid69]

I can't tell if Trent breaks into songs when he orgasms or if he has orgasms when he plays his music... I know I do :]

[Withbleedthrewteeth]

@BigLuckyDavy Aaron North

[666wintermoon]

i love 3:06... raping the piano lol :D

[DollyDoppel]

Trent gets me closer. fuckkk.

[dwdiesel3294]

Loved watchin strippers dance to this!!!

[ULibby]

Does anyone else think having a Selena Gomez commercial on a NIN song is pretty much epic fail marketing?

[KBX]

@ULibby Not quite, she'll probably do a cover pretty soon lmfao



[WTFDIARIES]

I remember when i was 7 or something and my mom blasted almost every nin song on itunes. I grew up on these songs. :D

[stever199]

My parents didn't appreciate this song, but i don't give one fuck!

[MrMetallicakid13]

I would be pissing my pants if someone used this song as their wedding song! But NIN still kicks ass, though.

[forzainter02]

@MrMetallicakid13

and what about as the bride funeral? :)

[Arthaius]

This song has always inspired me >:D

No need to go into details at to what I'm inspired to do, lol

[Spartanx57]

I Am Going To Sing This Song To My Girlfriend Goddamn It!

[BIGeSTRING]

This song is so focking amazing. Very very good live band.

[gooeish]

crying like a baby

[CoolFurby]

a vevo video that actually isnt censored yay :D

[Beautiful2219]

@harrybythessea lol how can you not with a song like this? love it!!

[celloxlove]

I keep rewinding to 0:55 - 1:00. DAMN.

[novia5211991]

Eargasm.

[mandaRebecca21]

i saw them on there last tour when they went to chicago

[jedidi]

i love artists who are live even better than on cd

[SerjRules08]

I have to see these guys live them and Tool

[adamtzsch]

Fat Elvis Period? Why not try NEW "All-Ways"...

[Spartanx57]

The way he put Emphasis On the word "Fuck" Is Awesome!

[roninfyi]

Good stuff, saw these guys live in el paso around '94. This is music that will last forever

[themahermax]

whith all rescpect that i have for ROBIN FINCK , there is no guitar player in concert charismatic like Aaron NORTH , his moves his way to play guitar and his presence in stage is so magnetic ......GOD i miss him so much !!!!

[sodadreamer21]

3:54 Justin bieber has taken the song to litteraly

[Yourfelony]

wow <3 :)

[0987ygvcxz]

2:48 makes it even more epic. Been headbanging to this song non stop.

[glomotoshiya]

Its amazing. I know this song since I was like 13 years old... I guess thats the reason why Mr.Reznor here, has always been strictly related to sex, frantic violent divine sex.

[aliensarereal666]

check my channel,nin/toronto/2009......­more!

[MrLangstar]

the 4 people are-

Lady Gaga

Bieber

Rebecca Black

and A Bee

[amyliz143ny]

I think I was in middle school when this album came out. I remember having to listen to it on headphones so my unsuspecting Christian parents couldn't hear. But screw that, because when they weren't home, I blasted the shit out of it. LOL.

[magnificentbastard27]

@amyliz143ny i feel ya there... my dad found my copies of the downward spiral and antichrist superstar and went apeshit on me. and i was in like 6th grade when this came out... i thought i was so cool for listening to it... haha

[vicchic1000]

@amyliz143ny Thats funny I did the same thing. I politely askd my parents if I could go to their concert when I was 16y; they said yes bc they never heard of them :) They got yelled at by their friends & they told my parents NOO DONT LET HER GO! To bad for them bc I was already there!! GOOD TIMES! Im 34y now and I still love them!!

[skuzy13]

best song ever

[araider18]

i like him with hair better lol

[JayTheDestroyer52]

why the fuck are there advertisements on all the good videos?

[Beautiful2219]

This song just makes me drool! and think Dirty thoughts! is that a bad thing? no..

[RenyRuIez]

Trent Reznor musical genius.

[djanzon]

Twiggy Ramirez!!!!!!!!

[trippycat123]

lmao @ the fangirls<3

[MetalGir1334]

-sigh- this song is soo sexy... i want to violently bang someone to it! damn, i think i came, im a girl... is that a problem... nah....

[SDluva29]

damn i have had some good times to this song.

[shadowkid713]

i like that keyboardist, i had no idea a keyboard guy in a rock band could be "aggressive" XD

[Spermwhales93]

@shadowkid713 His name's Alessandro Cortini. He also filled in for Morgan Nicholls when he couldn't tour with Muse.

[djanzon]

@shadowkid713

Check out Madonna Wayne Gacy aka "Pogo" in older Marilyn Manson live-videos..

That´s an agressive Keyboardplayer for you..

[mentalitymentalist]

@djanzon POGO FTW MAN!! :)

[MrNorringtonmyiPOD]

Every time I listen to this I cannot control my urge to rock out and by the time the song is over I have to find and retrieve my glasses from my massive headbanging/air-guitaring. This song is truely one of my favourites. :D

[RenyRuIez]

I came.

[AddyVanderSlooT]

My Whole Existence Is Flawed,,,You Kept Me Kloser To Gawd...

[lizzykiss441]

this is an amazing song. omg

[TheLaluna1]

At least this version is pure!

[MrNorringtonmyiPOD]

My questions is: Are his pants made out of pleather or some similar shiny material, or are they just soaked with sweat?

[RockigualAnime]

definitely you must hear this song before you die

amazing in all senses

[bunkerpoopie]

The recording is fucking perfect, stick a head set on and pump it up, the sound engineering deserves a medal!!

[fizzle455]

@bunkerpoopie artists shouldn't put out albums unless they can preform it well, and NiN does very well doing that

[TheFrenchEngineer1]

I saw NIN with LADYTRON in Birmingham a few years ago - AWESOME!!!

[hphoofcare]

GREATEST SONG EVER WRITTEN.........EVER PERFORMED..........PERIOD.

[168lynn]

i need VIOLATED right fucking now

[rdloop]

fuck today's dance music. I say loop this from opening to closing.

[AeScarydark]

I think it's "I am the honey" bro... thumbs up for you tho.

[thedarthflagger]

he looks so good heavier and older. i would fuck him till his head exploded.

[Lisey87]

@thedarthflagger amen lol

[LupaDove]

@thedarthflagger most men look better heavier (i.e. thicker) and older. Makes me see them as a REAL MAN! *purrrr* I would drink him down into my soul and yes, fuck him until his head exploded. ;)~

[psoluri71]

@thedarthflagger lol... I wouldn't...but awesome post

[jabroni19]

@ 2:49, keyboard and drum beat from "the only time".

[MrBlorx]

Why is he holding his crotch the whole time?

[ExcisionIsDubstep]

@MrBlorx Damn skinny jeans, I feel his pain

[IZIEIDxViDz]

for some reason man people love that line i wanna fuck you like a animal

[lilredheadxx69]

loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee Nin

[punkaaron69]

wow im suprised i didnt watch this before lol

i like how they changed it up for their live set

might actually like this more than the old recorded version

[ejafjallajokul]

one of the first song I heard by nin, among with deep and just like you imagined. I love them!

[TheIvan8407]

this song is the shit everytime i hear it i want to do my girl ahahahaha

[MumboMoose]

@TheIvan8407 Yeah, i wanna do your girl whenever i hear it too

[phoen99rising]

LOL all this time I thought this was called "fxxx you like an animal" what a suprise lol! I'm into hip-hop but I LOVE this song!

[MultiKanut]

@phoen99rising If you buy the EP it has 4 different versions of this song.

[Cheshirecat55]

This song is sex to my ears

[gmilf71]

Awww they took out my favorite keyboard riff and turned it into a guitar. 

[gmilf71]

@blindfatkid23

There's a guitar riff at the bridge for him to do though.

[blindfatkid23]

@gmilf71 true, it would still be kind of awkward for the rest of the song though

[gmilf71]

@blindfatkid23

He could play keyboard. There's like 4 or 5 keyboard tracks in that song.

Like in the performance of this at woodstock 94, the guitarist was playing keyboard and then at the bridge, the guitarist got his guitar, and Trent started shredding on keyboard.

[anlegobe1]

Severo tema........lastima que no se pudo en Colombia

[kgonepostl]

Songs that much more wicked awesome when your baked

[blindfatkid23]

@kgonepostl Yes it is. Then again, isn't everything?

[slick1ru2]

Awesome concert. 

[sharaycutie]

It gets me so pissed off that he stole this song from blood on the dance floor because blood on the dance floor makes this band look like shit on a garbage plate

[scoobyfckndoo]

@sharaycutie you sir are wrong

[TrafficRiot911]

@sharaycutie your kidding right

[biggersoadfan]

‎" I wanna fuck you like an animal, I wanna feel you from the inside (...) I drink the honey inside your hive, you're the reason I stay alive. "

This song is SO amazing, thanks Trent !

[chuckxmulholland]

@biggersoadfan "i am the honey inside your hive" not drink the honey.

[Oi325]

he was kool in 2wo

[THmusic8]

i'm watching this because of JARED LETO..

u like it or not..never heard of this band..n' its pretty good i can say.

[Bunnyxdsingh]

@THmusic8 where the fuck you live on mars

[THmusic8]

@Bunnyxdsingh Exactly...especially 30 seconds to Mars..

[Bunnyxdsingh]

@THmusic8 errrr. i mean there is no Jared Leto in this

[slippery7936]

the trick is to click to tubifier [dot] com to download the high quality mp3 for this song.

[razza858]

this has to be one of ma favourite sexy songss its soooooo crude!!!!!

[wildbloodydragon]

Holy shit Trent, when did you get so buffed up? 

[05hipkinja]

something about this song just hits the spot of that caveman instinct for danger and sex. best NIN song.

[TheLipgloss02]

i'm lovin this!!! he gots da hottest voice eva :)

[DuneBuggy00]

if i was there i wouldve been on so many drugs and dancing the shit out of myself

[nae4sound]

Trent is HOT!!!

[ShadowTearsXIII]

nine inch nails has been my number one band since the fifth grade. im going to be in 10'th. I would give anything to see them live(:

[validcode]

They sound awesome live

[3third3eye3]

I mean...trent is simply amaziing!!! I love this song, is just, perfect!

[ThePiranhaman]

This is the best song ever written, lyrics, music, everything. I saw them in 94 at Maple leaf Gradens in Toronto, Canada. Closer was the encore, beat playing in darkness for minutes.....Manson and Jim's sideshow circus opened. Best concert I have ever seen..PERIOD!!!

[kayman1st]

@ThePiranhaman Best song ever written, please....learn about music before making an inane statement like that

[conortuff]

the crowds reaction to when they hear the drum beat is amazing!

[TIKOREX]

This is sex !!!

[nasdaqjc]

Pretty Hate Machine was the first CD I bought

[LLawlietFTW]

Heh...ending lyrics:

Through every forest, through the trees

Within my stomach, scraped off my f*cking knees

I drink the honey, inside your hive.

You are the reason, i stay alive.

[Shishiwakarashi]

Briliant and sexy....

[stephybehbeh]

wow this song is so sexy!

[JustaWyomingGirl]

OH Trent, anytime.... anywhere!! I may be married but you're number 1 on my five!!!

[Tulllip27]

I think that this is pretty much the sexiest song ever written !!! And i love how Alessandro attacks the keyboard at the middle part there woohooo !!!

[1RamenGuy]

im so glad vevo didn't censor this ;D

[ixxCxxUxx]

ummm.......yea....;D

[JuanY29]

EPIC

[Charity563]

This is one of the best songs, by NIN

I just love this <3

[midnalover99]

This song live looks so awesome! I also like the lights in the sky version as well.

I don't know any other song so awesome with light effects like this.

[aShotOfDaniels]

@2:48 The drummer does that nice spin with his drum stick.

[RosesBelikov]

This is one of the funkiest beats, but it makes you wanna move. :)

[olddavid4]

Is that Reznor singing? It looks like Scott Stapp? Please correct me. Something feels off in this performance.

[RetartedWaffles]

@olddavid4 I don't know who Scott Stapp is I googled it (found out he was from Creed, not a fan but oh well) and he looks nothing like Scott Stapp, and this is in fact Trent Reznor, Trent got a haircut (which kinda sucks I liked his long hair better D:)

[veilofviolet]

i'm pretty sure about 2,000 babies were conceived because of this performance......freaking hot!

[0uterHeaven0]

widespread orgy?

[NHLman27]

wow that crowd is pretty serene- in a good way, just jamming and enjoying the music

[koolgerms]

NIN is awesome! I love their performances, they REALLY like strobe lights... I would be afraid if I was epileptic... but probably still take the risk!

[TIKOREX]

Best closer performance ever !

[TheWuzzyLine]

I think jizz just came out my heart and out my ears. <3333