Bobby Rydell hit the charts in 1959, same time as the "pretty boys" who had great looks, great hair (with "talent" being optional). So he got lumped in that catagory. Not fair. Bobby had talent. Bobby rocked and had he come out a year earlier, he would've been right there with Bobby Darin (if he didn't beat Darin on the charts).
@fullflop actually yes it was. If you actually did some research before you posted a comment, you wouldn't be making yourself look like a retard on the internet. Peter and Gordon released this song before Bobby, and it was a Lennon/McCartney composition.
Noticing that Bobby was trying to sound British in this song, that he seemed to have contempt for the material but had to try to stay up to date. Peter And Gordon had the original song, it was made for them. Bobby Rydell had a great voice, had great delivery but this song belonged to Peter And Gordon from Lennon-McCartney.
@BobbyDelRiv : Bobby actually recorded it first; Peter and Gordon liked the song and had the inside connection to Lennon-McCartney and rushed their version out taking it to #1 in June 1964. Peter and Gordon did a great job for sure, but Bobby's
actual recording of this song was equally extraordinary, but not given the support
it deserved due to the emphasis on British imports. Bobby can still sing well, but
has yet to produce contempory recordings to prove his capabiliities.
@paminddoc How did bobby get this first when mcartney was going out with ashers sister he seems to be doing a frank sinatra /joe piscapo parody arrangement of peterand gordons record with the ending as the intro ?
This is the first time I'm hearing this, and frankly, I'm not that impressed. It's hard for me to believe that this is the original--the Beatles were friends of Peter Asher, since Paul was involved with his sister, and had a connection with Peter and Gordon. Plus the Beatles and Peter and Gortdon both recorded for Capitol. I would tend to believe that they wrote it especially for Peter and Gordon.
@njva17420 No, it was Peter and Gordon, written by Paul McCartney for the group featuring his fiancée Jane Asher's brother, Peter Asher. Peter and Gordon got dibs on most of Paul's castoffs.
1964 was the year after Bobby Rydell was in Bye Bye Birdie with Ann-Margret, he was pretty big then. However, I believe it was also in 1964 when the Beatles first appeared on Ed Sullivan and brought the British Invasion to the US. I just checked and the Beatles first appeared on the Ed Sullivan Show on February 9th, 1964, which would explain why singers like Rydell had a hard time making hits.
Bobby has a good voice, but by the time he sang this that kind of delivery was considered old-fashioned. A more hearfelt arangement, like Peter & Gordon's was the way to go. Although the adults of the day probably loved it.
Bobby was without peer! I grew up with him, and he could sing the angels ot the Trees! I could play the guitar, but without doubt. Bobby could sing sing angels out of the trees.
I'm a huge fan of Beatles and Paul (despite my newer obsession of Adam Lambert lately). Used to follow stories about all of them and their wives and woulda/coulda been wives. Knew about Paul, Jane, Peter connections. (Gordon, RIP) When Linda died, I googled Jane and woulda loved for Paul & Jane to get back together! But she's been and still is happily married. There's a youtube interview video "Jane Asher - Paul O'Grady Show 10.05.2007". Gawd! She's gorgeous there!
I definitely remember BR's version preceding P&G's version. Bobby's song title's phrase notes go higher throughout, vs. P&G's notes go downward. Bobby does give the song a Vegas treatment; however, imho, his emphatic projection of "I WON'T STAY IN A WORLD WITHOUT LOVE" provides the appropriate feeling of defiance. I haven't seen Bobby on TV in years, but sure remember his voice still going strong when he'd appear on oldies revues.
The problem is that when you did the Sullivan show, they only gave you a couple of minutes to sing your song...usually that meant that you had to cut a verse...as he did here..., or speed up the song...many songs got butchered in the process...I saw Bobby in 1972, and he was fantastic...I don't say that about many artists, and I've seen many of the "greats".
Actually Bobby cut a kick ass version of The Kink's "When I See That Girl Of Mine" on Capitol which beat The Kinks version here to a U.S. release, it's VERY rockin'.
John wouldn't release it because of the phrase "Please lock me away" as that anyone would be daft to want to be locked up. Peter Asher is the brother to Jane Asher. Paul gave the song to Peter. This is simply an American release of the song.
I really don't remember this. I was a Rydell fan as a kid, and then when the Beatles came to America, I became a Beatles fan.
I remember that everyone wanted to record Lennon-McCartney songs, but I have to say, I don't think this really suits Bobby's style. It's much better sung in harmony by Peter and Gordon. You can see that Bobby is trying to give it that Rydell swing, but it just doesn't go with the song -- no disrespect intended.
Pamiddoc: I can't believe that! First of all, Paul McCartney wrote it, he's English and P&G are, too! Paul wrote some other singles for the duo and it was the hit. I really think you are wrong on this.
He looks good and sings well. His last big hit was "Forget Him" at the very start of 1964. Then came the Beatles topping the charts in February 64. That was the end for many American artists. Even the Ed Sullivan Show couldn't help him with this song. Unknowns Peter and Gordon (from the UK) made it a hit.
I'm old enough to remember this. By 1964, the white teen music scene was firmly dominated by the "British Invasion" and it was hard for previous hit makers like Bobby Rydell to chart. Nothing shows this like this song. The Peter and Gordon version (hell, I think Paul McCartney wrote it, didn't he?) was a hit. Radio stations at first played both, but quickly dropped the Bobby Rydell version when it failed to sell. I don't remember ever hearing a new song from him after that on the radio.
In the 60s it was not at all unusual for artists to have competing versions of the same song on the charts at the same time. This version gave the P&G version a real run for its money in the east, especially in the influential WKBW signal area, although due to the Beatles' relationship to Pete Asher, the P&G charted higher.
that maybe so but this version has no feel to it at all. thePG version has a beautiful tune sang with better feeling as well. and sang from the heart this version is more of a swing version. PG.S version will sit there in the book of love songs
Bobby even tried to put a little bit of a British flavor to his recorded version, but the British Invasion allowed little room for American recording artists at the time - he sings it with a far superior voice than the hit record by Peter & Gordon (no offense to them, I like them) but Bobby was under rated as a performer!
Bobby Rydell does an amazing cover of this song, he is truly one of the most amazing singers next to ricky nelson. Bobby has such a talent and is a great singer.
This song is made by the Great "Del Shannon" and nobody else , he gave it to Peter & Gordon on a tour in Australia, he regretted later that he did´nt record it him self, but he did alright anyway !
I go to pieces was the del shannon song that peter and gordon did [ del sang a cover version of the beatle song a world with out love also rag doll by the 4 seasons].
In 1964 U.S. fans embraced the Beatles & so many British beat groups. Motown was in its formative years, & the only successful American bands who wrote & played their own music were the Beach Boys & Four Seasons. Solo acts like Bobby Rydell scrambled to keep pace with the foreseeable trend. Peter & Gordon's version went straight to Billboards' covetted #1, but Bobby's recording didn't even dent the Top-40; His b-side, "Our Faded Love", is a much better song.
Jane asher was dating Paul McCartney. So John and Paul wrote a few songs for Jane's brother's group Peter and Gordon. After Peter and Gordon recorded it. Bobby Rydell did a cover version. Ed Sullivan featured Bobby Rydell in 64' even though his hits were virtually over at the time because he was in "Bye Bye Birdie" with him that year.
This has been flagged as spam show
may 9th 1964..both "peter and gordon" and "bobby rydell" released this song on the same date..it is a tie game people!
ERIMATT 3 weeks ago
this is my ultimate favourite Bobby Rydell song!!! yessss xxx
SthrnCrossLady 1 month ago
Thanks for YT, cause it come out the truth, which is which and who is who
Adoraa1 4 months ago
Brings back memories of many years ago..Love Lynne xxxxx
MegaNelson1111 6 months ago
Bobby Rydell hit the charts in 1959, same time as the "pretty boys" who had great looks, great hair (with "talent" being optional). So he got lumped in that catagory. Not fair. Bobby had talent. Bobby rocked and had he come out a year earlier, he would've been right there with Bobby Darin (if he didn't beat Darin on the charts).
littlemikey1954 6 months ago
He is amazing
diane189444 8 months ago 2
he reminds me of jim carry in the mask lol
marycockburn1 9 months ago
@fullflop actually yes it was. If you actually did some research before you posted a comment, you wouldn't be making yourself look like a retard on the internet. Peter and Gordon released this song before Bobby, and it was a Lennon/McCartney composition.
JohnPaulGeorgeNose 10 months ago
@spacepatrolman: Let's just say that my information comes pretty much from the
horse's mouth. Also, there were other British connections, here, including the
song FORGET HIM written by Tony Hatch (aka Mark Anthony). But, it sounds like
you are griding your own axes, anyway. I put the info out for the fans who enjoy
this music.
pamindoc 10 months ago
The Beatles-Words Of Love this where your mixed up
fullflop 10 months ago
@fullflop Words of Love was originally done by Buddy Holly and the Crickets in 1958 and copied by the Beatles in 1965.
littlemikey1954 6 months ago
He was the only person who could actually sing in Bye Bye Birdie
Shadow8Star 1 year ago
@Shadow8Star is WRONG, wrong, and DEAD wrong - Anne Margaret was an awesome singer ... and a beautiful redhead!
boydsongs 1 year ago 4
@boydsongs Nah... she was super annoying in my opinion. Haha.
Shadow8Star 1 year ago
@boydsongs : Anne Margaret was certainly a beautiful redhead , a great actress, dancer, and a huge
star. Not a bad singer, but that was not her strongest suit. Classy lady
pamindoc 1 year ago
Thank you Beatles! See what you saved us from? whew!!!
Slotracer7 1 year ago
@Slotracer7 Thank you Micchael Jackson for saving us from "The Beatles". Did you get the message @Slotracer7?
tutmungblu 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Paul McCartney wrote this :]
NatandDavidLover 1 year ago
Gee, no wonder the Brits invaded and took over during this era!
nauort23 1 year ago
Noticing that Bobby was trying to sound British in this song, that he seemed to have contempt for the material but had to try to stay up to date. Peter And Gordon had the original song, it was made for them. Bobby Rydell had a great voice, had great delivery but this song belonged to Peter And Gordon from Lennon-McCartney.
BobbyDelRiv 1 year ago
@BobbyDelRiv : Bobby actually recorded it first; Peter and Gordon liked the song and had the inside connection to Lennon-McCartney and rushed their version out taking it to #1 in June 1964. Peter and Gordon did a great job for sure, but Bobby's
actual recording of this song was equally extraordinary, but not given the support
it deserved due to the emphasis on British imports. Bobby can still sing well, but
has yet to produce contempory recordings to prove his capabiliities.
paminddoc 1 year ago 7
@paminddoc How did bobby get this first when mcartney was going out with ashers sister he seems to be doing a frank sinatra /joe piscapo parody arrangement of peterand gordons record with the ending as the intro ?
spacepatrolman 10 months ago
@spacepatrolman dopey git this is an old song way berfore mcartney song it
fullflop 10 months ago
@fullflop your not makeing sense its not an old song [ at least it wasnt in the early 1960s ] mcartney wrote it
spacepatrolman 10 months ago
@paminddoc Thanks for this interesting info.
rickysbestgirl 3 months ago
This is the first time I'm hearing this, and frankly, I'm not that impressed. It's hard for me to believe that this is the original--the Beatles were friends of Peter Asher, since Paul was involved with his sister, and had a connection with Peter and Gordon. Plus the Beatles and Peter and Gortdon both recorded for Capitol. I would tend to believe that they wrote it especially for Peter and Gordon.
RaananVolesPianist 1 year ago
Bobby did the original and lost out to the British Invasion. It was as if he had never been there.
njva17420 1 year ago
@njva17420 No, it was Peter and Gordon, written by Paul McCartney for the group featuring his fiancée Jane Asher's brother, Peter Asher. Peter and Gordon got dibs on most of Paul's castoffs.
atimnie 1 year ago
@atimnie Perhaps, but Bobby's rendition was on the top 40 early summer 1964, before P&G's.
njva17420 1 year ago
1964 was the year after Bobby Rydell was in Bye Bye Birdie with Ann-Margret, he was pretty big then. However, I believe it was also in 1964 when the Beatles first appeared on Ed Sullivan and brought the British Invasion to the US. I just checked and the Beatles first appeared on the Ed Sullivan Show on February 9th, 1964, which would explain why singers like Rydell had a hard time making hits.
BigBearPaul 1 year ago
Bobby has a good voice, but by the time he sang this that kind of delivery was considered old-fashioned. A more hearfelt arangement, like Peter & Gordon's was the way to go. Although the adults of the day probably loved it.
ruberto53 1 year ago
Cringe-worthy! Sounds like someone in love with his own voice!
edvadosvba 1 year ago
this was well song before peter an gordon made a hit of it
fullflop 1 year ago
Bobby was without peer! I grew up with him, and he could sing the angels ot the Trees! I could play the guitar, but without doubt. Bobby could sing sing angels out of the trees.
Joseph F.
B52sguy 1 year ago
@B52sguy as far away from james brown as u can get......the stones couldn't arrive quick enough 4 me
baliscotsurf 1 year ago
@baliscotsurf Brown and the stones SUCK in comparison with Rydell, Peter and Gordon, and the Beatles.
sharx35 1 year ago
Written Lennon/McCartney (mostly McCartney)
Originally Released by Peter and Gordon
JohnPaulGeorgeNose 1 year ago
@JohnPaulGeorgeNose you need to get your facts right was not Written Lennon/McCartney
fullflop 10 months ago
Ohhhhhhhhhh what a beautiful version of this one.
I love it, I love it, I love it.
Thank you for posting. I love Oldies !!!!! Yes, Yes, Yes !
Banderuola66 1 year ago
enjoyed it back then as I do today. Gene Pitney had the better version.
starr522 1 year ago
He was good!
zaaritha 1 year ago
Not a bad version of the song.
RAMGEN2000 1 year ago
The boy could sing...end of story.
whatsupee 1 year ago
I'm a huge fan of Beatles and Paul (despite my newer obsession of Adam Lambert lately). Used to follow stories about all of them and their wives and woulda/coulda been wives. Knew about Paul, Jane, Peter connections. (Gordon, RIP) When Linda died, I googled Jane and woulda loved for Paul & Jane to get back together! But she's been and still is happily married. There's a youtube interview video "Jane Asher - Paul O'Grady Show 10.05.2007". Gawd! She's gorgeous there!
FanE4AdamL 2 years ago
I definitely remember BR's version preceding P&G's version. Bobby's song title's phrase notes go higher throughout, vs. P&G's notes go downward. Bobby does give the song a Vegas treatment; however, imho, his emphatic projection of "I WON'T STAY IN A WORLD WITHOUT LOVE" provides the appropriate feeling of defiance. I haven't seen Bobby on TV in years, but sure remember his voice still going strong when he'd appear on oldies revues.
FanE4AdamL 2 years ago
I do like Bobby Rydell but he has really murdered this one!
jokergame 2 years ago
I agree with you. But I really like his voice but this song wasn't for him.
timotastic 1 year ago
The problem is that when you did the Sullivan show, they only gave you a couple of minutes to sing your song...usually that meant that you had to cut a verse...as he did here..., or speed up the song...many songs got butchered in the process...I saw Bobby in 1972, and he was fantastic...I don't say that about many artists, and I've seen many of the "greats".
PutOnASweater 1 year ago
Bobby could sing anything !! What a great talent !! I have many of his records in my jukeboxes. They all sound great !!!
desoto1961 2 years ago
The guy headlined and got rave reviews
and the Copa Cabana in NYC at age 19;
starred with Anne Margaret in Bye Bye
Birdie around 1963-4, and performed
for the Royal Family. Still going strong.
pamindoc 2 years ago
Actually Bobby cut a kick ass version of The Kink's "When I See That Girl Of Mine" on Capitol which beat The Kinks version here to a U.S. release, it's VERY rockin'.
Wilthomer66 2 years ago
P&G released it on February 28, 1964.
John wouldn't release it because of the phrase "Please lock me away" as that anyone would be daft to want to be locked up. Peter Asher is the brother to Jane Asher. Paul gave the song to Peter. This is simply an American release of the song.
Starrman69 2 years ago
Click on You Tube, Bobby Rydell, Volare.
People who have seen him perform re-
cently compare him to Sinatra. The guy
truly still has it and I would encourage him
to get back to recording great songs,
have personally indicated the same to
him, and the more support he receives
in this area, the better. 45 years is too
long for a talent like his to stay away from
the limelight. Truly sensational talent
pamindoc 2 years ago
I really don't remember this. I was a Rydell fan as a kid, and then when the Beatles came to America, I became a Beatles fan.
I remember that everyone wanted to record Lennon-McCartney songs, but I have to say, I don't think this really suits Bobby's style. It's much better sung in harmony by Peter and Gordon. You can see that Bobby is trying to give it that Rydell swing, but it just doesn't go with the song -- no disrespect intended.
MissMiscellanea 2 years ago
MissMiscellanea: I totally agree; it's pretty funny this way...It's supposed to be a melancholy song, not a polka!
dearyogini 2 years ago
The song was written by Lennon-McCartney.
ajdale 2 years ago
Adjale: Nope, just Paul (although in those days they attributed to both of them). You can see his style all over it.
dearyogini 2 years ago
Old stuff but still makes me feel good when I hear it or see it as in this clip
afhyatt 2 years ago
People are finally catching on!!!! This was
Bobby's song!!!! I'm a huge P&G fan, but
Bobby did it first! The promoters backed
the Brits. Later the record company was
sold and his music not released on CD
until 2005!!!!!!!
paminddoc 2 years ago
Pamiddoc: I can't believe that! First of all, Paul McCartney wrote it, he's English and P&G are, too! Paul wrote some other singles for the duo and it was the hit. I really think you are wrong on this.
dearyogini 2 years ago
Dearyogini: Believe what you will. But,
Bobby did have British connections,
performed in the U.K., and Petulla Clark's
primary songwriter, Tony Hatch, also
wrote FORGET HIM, a huge Bobby
Rydell hit in 1963-1964 era. Actually,
have seen Bobby comment on YouTube
under Bobby Rydell. I myself am not a
singer; sorry to disappoint you.
pamindoc 2 years ago
Pamindoc: Peter Asher was the brother of Paul's girlfriend at the time, JANE ASTER. Check, please!
dearyogini 2 years ago
i didnt even knew he did this. i only knew of peter and gordon, thhose damm uk people took our music and fame LOL
mrbob424 2 years ago
He looks good and sings well. His last big hit was "Forget Him" at the very start of 1964. Then came the Beatles topping the charts in February 64. That was the end for many American artists. Even the Ed Sullivan Show couldn't help him with this song. Unknowns Peter and Gordon (from the UK) made it a hit.
ZarahLean 2 years ago
I'm old enough to remember this. By 1964, the white teen music scene was firmly dominated by the "British Invasion" and it was hard for previous hit makers like Bobby Rydell to chart. Nothing shows this like this song. The Peter and Gordon version (hell, I think Paul McCartney wrote it, didn't he?) was a hit. Radio stations at first played both, but quickly dropped the Bobby Rydell version when it failed to sell. I don't remember ever hearing a new song from him after that on the radio.
ZarahLean 2 years ago
This is not your typical song of the day;
really quite a nice sound and an example
of the extraordinary vocal skills of B.R.
Of relevance now is that the man has
further developed his vocal skills and
could blow the music world apart if he
chose to get serious and record new
material. We'll see......who knows what
may come next.
paminddoc 2 years ago
My fave Bobby song! Thank you for uploading!
sfratpack 2 years ago
Two big sold out shows for Bobby this
weekend at MT. Airy LOdge in The
Poconos. Standing ovations, as usual.
The legend continues.......
paminddoc 2 years ago
Pamiddoc: Hi, Bobby! Didn't know you Youtube, LOL
dearyogini 2 years ago
loads of respect for bobby hes a true great but this is shite.
1969jmd 2 years ago
A "star dusted opening" for the show? Good Old Ed Sullivan...
Tuggle 2 years ago
Bobby Rydell was the best singer out of Philly.
huey1965 2 years ago
This great song, sung by the great Bobby
Rydell is one of many he has performed.
More importantly, he's still performing
in concert, voice actually improving with
age. Unspoiled by fame he is both humble and charitible. One of the all time
greats.
paminddoc 2 years ago
In the 60s it was not at all unusual for artists to have competing versions of the same song on the charts at the same time. This version gave the P&G version a real run for its money in the east, especially in the influential WKBW signal area, although due to the Beatles' relationship to Pete Asher, the P&G charted higher.
pupman2 2 years ago
that maybe so but this version has no feel to it at all. thePG version has a beautiful tune sang with better feeling as well. and sang from the heart this version is more of a swing version. PG.S version will sit there in the book of love songs
will this version i doubt i dont think so
redfenderguy 2 years ago
I was a big fan of Peter and Gordon, but
Bobby's version is at least as good if not
better. Their song hit #1 in June 1964.
Had Bobby's version come out first and
been given similar airtime it likely would
have been a huge hit .
paminddoc 2 years ago
paminddoc, for me, they were both equally
good!
fntime 2 years ago
fntime: Agree both versions are great.
Informed sources advise Bobby's was
recorded first, but P&G had closer
connections and rushed theirs out. So
Bobby's is not a cover as many believe; it
is an original.
paminddoc 2 years ago
paminddoc, I looked up my Billboard 100
and both songs actually first charted
on the week ending May 9 1964, Peter Gordon's version #76, and Bobby Rydell's
version #100.
The following week ending May 16,
Peter Gordon's version was #30 and Bobby Rydell's #92!
So you are probably right. This is the
nationwide top 100.
Alot depended on how many markets
the song was released into.
fntime 2 years ago
fntime: Very interesting. Everything I recall
and have since heard says P&G version
got way more airtime. It went to #1 by
June 1964. I loved their version as I did
Bobby's which was way better than Bill-
board would suggest. British invasion
left little room for great U.S. singers.
paminddoc 2 years ago
Bobby even tried to put a little bit of a British flavor to his recorded version, but the British Invasion allowed little room for American recording artists at the time - he sings it with a far superior voice than the hit record by Peter & Gordon (no offense to them, I like them) but Bobby was under rated as a performer!
JohnnyGNV 2 years ago
Bobby Rydell does an amazing cover of this song, he is truly one of the most amazing singers next to ricky nelson. Bobby has such a talent and is a great singer.
sarebear634 2 years ago
The amazing thing is that this performance is 45 years old, yet Bobby
Rydell continues to thrill audiences today
and actually seems to be getting better.
paminddoc 2 years ago
he's such a hottie
Blossom90sKid4ever 2 years ago
I really like Bobby Rydell and his voice, but in my opinion, this version pales next to Peter and Gordon's.
P&G gave their song a sense of longing. Bobby gives it a Vegas treatment and to me it loses its power.
But Bobby is/was cool.
bigman1239 2 years ago
I thought Bobby Rydell's version was sung with more feeling and intensity than Peter and Gordon's.
bgdisbrow 2 years ago
he looks like a young val Kilmer
tyson55 2 years ago
in val's better dreams.
Sweetpaddington 2 years ago
Note how great Bobby sounds with minimal musical background support on
the Ed Sullivan show and his powerful
ending unmatched by Peter and Gordon's
version. The PR people catering to the
British craze rushed the British version out
first and gave it massive playtime. Bobby
sang this a year ago on stage with no musical accompanyment and was sensa-
tional. A great talent then and now. Thanks for posting.
paminddoc 2 years ago
This song is made by the Great "Del Shannon" and nobody else , he gave it to Peter & Gordon on a tour in Australia, he regretted later that he did´nt record it him self, but he did alright anyway !
caro
baratittafilmer 2 years ago
I go to pieces was the del shannon song that peter and gordon did [ del sang a cover version of the beatle song a world with out love also rag doll by the 4 seasons].
spacepatrolman 2 years ago
In 1964 U.S. fans embraced the Beatles & so many British beat groups. Motown was in its formative years, & the only successful American bands who wrote & played their own music were the Beach Boys & Four Seasons. Solo acts like Bobby Rydell scrambled to keep pace with the foreseeable trend. Peter & Gordon's version went straight to Billboards' covetted #1, but Bobby's recording didn't even dent the Top-40; His b-side, "Our Faded Love", is a much better song.
pgh45rpms 2 years ago
Peter and Gordon were great; Bobby
Rydell still is great.
paminddoc 2 years ago
He looks like a puppet. lol
lilbabygurl120 3 years ago
he did, i'm glad he grew into his mouth after all these years lol
Skimsoco76 2 years ago
Jane asher was dating Paul McCartney. So John and Paul wrote a few songs for Jane's brother's group Peter and Gordon. After Peter and Gordon recorded it. Bobby Rydell did a cover version. Ed Sullivan featured Bobby Rydell in 64' even though his hits were virtually over at the time because he was in "Bye Bye Birdie" with him that year.
jnizny 3 years ago