Added: 2 years ago
From: jirdimaster
Views: 75,888
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (153)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Although I love both versions, I think the studio one is an absolute masterpiece.

  • wouldn't agree. both version are different. one is much more acoustic and one has more layers then an onion

  • Not a big radiohead fan anymore, but this song is alot better than his official version.

  • Supercollider

    been hearing it for quite awhile,

    through out various live shows,

    way before the 'official recorded studio version'...

    Don't dis that, its as good as well, might even appeals to the masses...

    ....well, enlightenment has to start somewhere! ; }

  • superb song, studio version not as good though..

  • As good as this is, it'll be a monster with the finishing touches a la give up the ghost and mousebirddog/separator studio versions. Here's hoping they do it!

  • studio version suck diggy dong balls

    

  • Anywhere I can download this exact version?

  • Could have added this to the 37 minute Limbs, no? Okay nitpickers it doesn't fit in with the theme, right?

  • Thom's voice is so exquisite and sweet.

  • I can't decide which version I love more.

  • this version is MILLIONS WAYS BETTER than the studio one. We have been waiting for the new album and these other studio stuff, but for nothing. I hate all that elect, there is no guitar, no real piano. Please Thom, give us a better work..

  • @axecold That's a very close minded view, the only songs on TKOL that don't use either guitar or piano are Bloom and Feral and Bloom has bass which isn't a six string but it's still a guitar.

  • @jirdimaster excuse me, but how is that a close minded view?? i mean, i'm a fan of radiohead and i actually have traveled to see them live, but God help me if i ever loose my right to dislike something. I mean even the beatles had crappy songs (nobody likes "don't pass me by"). Not that it's not good music but Radiohead could've done so much better and you know it. By the way, did you remember this Jhonny Greenwood guy? he was like a guitar hero and i can't hear him in this fuckin album.

  • @seiter13 Uh ya closed minded, you have closed your mind to music that doesn't involve guitar and piano like you said in your previous comment, that is the definition of closed mindedness lol anyway Jonny Greenwood did play in TKOL, you were just to busy pining for Ok Computer and The Bends to hear it, guitar is dead, it's been used to hell and i'm sick of it, Radiohead is sick of it, and plenty of other people are sick of it.

  • @jirdimaster So you don't listen to rock music anymore, 'cause you are sick of guitars right? well maybe you are right after all, radiohead has grown old and their fanatics are decided to follow them to death and you are sick of your past and are trying to evolve. as for me...fuck the future. i'm recording guitar music now! i mean, if nobody wants to do it for me anymore. you should not check my channel. it has a song i made...with guitars in it

  • @seiter13 I started listening to Radiohead 2 or 3 years ago, so i already had this huge spectrum of music to chose from and i loved every different sound they managed to come up with, i wasn't listening to them during the Ok Computer era so i never got hung up on it, ya it was a really good album but it had huge flaws, their albums have gotten progressively better since.

  • @jirdimaster I would agree with you mostly, but one thing I think "you might be wrong" on: the guitars. Have you noticed that just only a handful of songs didn't feature guitar recently from them? Those would be Sit Down Stand Up, Backdrifts, The Gloaming, Myxomatosis, Videotape, Bloom, and Feral. I believe I've heard guitar in just about every song from them recently. But that's just me, and I can respect your opposing opinion. :P

  • @StaticBunnyStudios You're absolutely right, i must have forgotten to point that out that even though most of their songs are layered with electronics almost all of them still have guitar and piano, but for the most part i'm sick of the "rock" sound itself.

  • @jirdimaster I enjoy both classic and modern Radiohead myself. If you don't like the rock sound, that's all fine. But I have to say their music doesn't get progressively better, to me it stays progressively great. I mean here and "there there" are some songs I really enjoy and some songs I just can't listen to on the get go. Like, for example, I really like Dollars and Cents, and then I always skip Hunting Bears afterwards. Supercollider is great both live and in the studio, but that's just me.

  • @StaticBunnyStudios Don't mean to nitpick, but Myxomatosis and Bloom use guitar. I think Sit Down, Stand Up does too.

  • @seiter13 your just not freaky enough, you gotta get freaky with the album. 

  • This sounds gorgeous. What a melody.

  • The new album is pure beauty. . .and finally this song was released in all of it's glory just yesterday. :D

  • What a beatiful song ! :') it gives me the shivers !!

  • What a great song :') it gives me he shivers !!

  • @jir, thank you, i find software you tell me, and quality is also good!

  • Hi, Today Supercollider studio version is now avaliable in shop, but i think that this version is better than studio rec, that we wait for a long time. Could you put this file on P2P please? It would be really important for me. If you prefer i give you my personal mail.Thank you.

  • @jhonrobertc Unfortunately i don't have this on my comp anymore but there are plenty of youtube downloaders online, just cut the URL and paste into one and it'll let you chose the format you want to download it in.

  • @jhonrobertc just type Youtube to Mp3 on google mate

  • How is this a B-side? It should've been on the King of Limbs...

  • Somebody please post the two sides of the Record Store Day single! I would love to pay folding currency, but as there are only 2,000 copies ...

  • @missiondirect I just bought one for £8

  • hey

    

  • Parts of this sound like Analyze.

  • @failureboy3  true :)

  • i have to think on separator

  • The studio version is coming tomorrow!

  • The studio version is their longest song in the studio ever :O

    Not gonna listen to it until I get the vinyl tomorrow, though.

  • every time i think i'm going to super-pissed when they take heartbreaking thom yorke piano ballads and turn them into futuristic robot laments but somehow they pull it off every god damn time

  • @aburtonmatt The new album is very poor though...

  • Just heard the studio version of this. Wow. It's amazing. Truly amazing.

  • The actual recording of the song sounds like yoko ono joined the fray-of course im joking.

  • this sucks

  • @fittera917 Congratualtions, you know how to punch 9 keys into a keyboard and form two words.

  • @WickedLiquid hah i couldnt help but express my disappointment, im just not feeling radioheads new style

  • Perfection

    

  • this is like watching the growth a fetus in its purest form, When we here the final adult version of this song in their next album it will be explosive! It still blows my mind that they record their songs and let them evolve over time. Nude was made during OK computer, On a side not King of Limbs is only 4 minutes shorter than their shortest album Pablo Honey. This is a complete album there is no TKOL2. And I love it! I love how they weed out the people that just dont get it.

  • This song will be acoustic played on piano, if not, I think it will have a similar rhythm to thom yorke's song analyse. It's just an idea.

  • SUPERSOUND

  • if there ever was going to be a TKOL 2, surely this would be the first track, its title just makes sense, although i dont think there will be

  • Would anyone be turned off by happier Radiohead lyrics but darker music? Radiohead songs in a deeper lower register. Could that even work? This song actually annoys me. I like Airbag.

  • anyone got the butcher?

  • @MrReverendgreen no, I wish, I wann hear it.

  • @MrReverendgreen The butcher has never been mentioned yet, it may well turn out to be another mouse dog bird => seperator scenario, but fyi the name the butcher has never been used before, if it exists it has a different working title.

  • great song and everything but i have to point out that the section after 4:09 is really shit :/

  • @cillianc09 That comment was really quite boggling until I scrolled up and looked at how long the song was...

  • @cillianc09 i see what you did there ;D

  • reminds me of lull

  • 3 thumbs up to the 3 dislexic individuals. With god's will, we shall find a cure for this hideous disease.

  • Thom = 789% genius

  • I'm looking forward to hearing the studio version of this, though i've got a strong feeling The Butcher will just be a renamed version of The Daily Mail or Judge Jury and Executioner (Both of which I love) Though i'd love it to be The Present Tense...

  • to be honest i find this song pretty similar to Airbag

  • @gorgolyt lolwut

    

  • @MrReverendgreen the vibe, riff, and general structure are all pretty similar.

  • @MrReverendgreen also lyrics. in a blue light, in the neon light, in a supercollider, in an interstellar burst. seems pretty samey to me.

  • sounds like filter

  • hmmm the piano part reminds me of sigur ros.

    it sounds much more "happy" than radiohead's previous songs. i mean, just listen to pyramid song.

    i gotta say, if i heard this for the first time not knowing who wrote this, i would never have guessed radiohead. doesn't sound like them at all.

    i'm not sure if that's a bad thing or good thing....not sure whether the direction they're going in, is good or bad.

  • @ri394 then again, it is just a b-side, and their b-sides have been very variable. i should listen to the butcher before i make any judgements ;)

  • Haha I was right! This song is being released as a B-Side =)

  • @BSHFTW Haha i know, i contemplated rubbing that in the face of the dork who thought this song became Codex but i'm to lazy.

  • @jirdimaster Too lazy to spell correctly, apparently.

  • @BSHFTW Actually, a double A-side...

  • @BSHFTW 

  • Double A-side, actually.

  • vocal is so similar to separator in parts. why did they choose to release this and not the present tense.. let's hope 'the butcher' is the present tense

  • soon soon we'll get the studio version. has anyone heard a version of the butcher?

  • @stperea

    been all over looking for it. Just have to wait for the 12" I guess. Poor us :)

  • Now, we just have to wait for the studio version xD

  • @OneOfTheSmurfs Now, we have it ^^

  • @SoufMeng Yeah, and it's awesome! I wrote that comment when they announced the release of the song ;)

  • CHILL OUT SONG.

  • VERY NICE SONG.

  • (i smell a troll)

    nice one, I didn't know it

  • fuck! how did i not know this existed?

  • i could see this song as the last track to an album. TKOL part 2 maybe... :)

  • This turned into Codex.

  • @ThomYorkesHead i really doubt it

  • @ThomYorkesHead No similar lyrics or melodies or chords at all. Oh wait, its played on a piano. Yeah definitely Codex.

  • @sicnh4274 The lyrics have the same meaning if you are any good at comprehension. The chord progressions are similar. So same meaning with similar chords on the piano, that' s good enough for me to say that Super Collider turned into Codex.

  • @ThomYorkesHead I can guarantee u that's not what happened, this is a separate song.

  • @jirdimaster Is that a money back guarantee? Unless you are Thom Yorke you can't guarantee anything.

  • @ThomYorkesHead I can guarantee you're an idiot and no one here will dispute it lol

  • @jirdimaster Yes, shame on me for presenting an idea. Obviously you can't process an idea that is foreign to you. You're aren't clever either. That's a shame. But thanks for the upload.

  • @ThomYorkesHead This and Codex are two completely different songs, that was a sad attempt at condescension because if you actually knew anything about music and music theory you'd know there's no way this turned into Codex, i'll bet you anything this will be released as Super Collider in the future.

  • @jirdimaster well done sir

  • @ThomYorkesHead Btw you used "you're" improperly lol

  • @jirdimaster A typo? Wow that's petty. You are not interested in discussion, rather interested in pointing out basic typos. Looks good on ya.

  • @ThomYorkesHead Alright, let's use basic logic, different lyrics, different time signature, different chord progression, now explain to me how you think this became Codex.

  • @ThomYorkesHead I guess i should have bet money on it, this is being released April 16th...

  • @jirdimaster haha you're right I was off my rocker. It was just a guess based on a vaguely similar chord progression and the lyrics both being about redemption/finding peace. They have been known to change songs vastly in the past. But you certainly knew better on this one.

  • @jirdimaster Well said mate that thomyorkshead is a tool.

  • I love Radiohead fans and their conspiracy theories...

    'Kid A predicts 9/11!'

    'OK Computer and In Rainbows form a playlist!'

    'The King Of Limbs is a double album!'

    Honestly, I think we should just be pleased with what we got, instead of wanting more straight away; The King Of Limbs is a great album in my opinion, even if it their shortest.

    That said, this is a beautiful song, as is 'The Daily Mail,' and I'm not going to pretend a second album containing those wouldn't make me very happy...

  • @jackwearing well no one can predict the future, but to be fair a radiohead rep did confirm the theory that IR and OKC could be played alternately to form one cohesive work

  • @pspcrazy205 Really? Wow... Radiohead clearly put a lot of work into that, then. Respect to them.

  • of course it's already been recorded

  • Listened to King Of Limbs 3 times already. Unfortunately this song is not on it but it's stunning nonetheless. Taking into consideration that quite a few Radiohead songs in the past have not found their way onto a studio album until years after they were first played live, it could be several albums away before we can hear a studio version of this song. Or they could have already recorded it in studio and are planning to release it as a B-Side or something.

  • @BSHFTW Well considering the newspaper album comes with two disks and King of Limbs only has 8 tracks averaging at four minutes and fifty seconds (yes i did the math) then the second disk is likely material we haven't heard yet, and the album ends with "if you think this is over then you're wrong" so maybe King of Limbs is the first part of a two part album, we'll just have to wait and see.

  • @jirdimaster Not to mention the last track is called Separator

  • @jirdimaster The Newspaper Album does not come with two compact discs. It comes with two 10" vinyl records and just one compact disc.

  • @jirdimaster @jirdimaster The Newspaper Album does not come with two compact discs. It comes with two 10" vinyl records and just one compact disc.

  • @M83J01P97 Ya that's what i meant Mr. Split Hairs

  • The first four minutes and 9 seconds of this are amazing

    The rest, take it or leave it!

  • Super Collider? I just met her.

  • am who the cuk is posting with my account???? please disregard anything previously posted or at least knonw it wasnt really me

  • @legion0 Haha liar, nice way to try and spare urself

  • New Album on Saturday, Feb 19th!!

  • Just preordered the new album. Thumbs up if you did too!

  • I don't really care if it's a matter of weeks, months or another year when the next Radiohead album is coming out, I just hope it's as brilliant as the last 6.

  • oh my god!! the piano sounds like light shining on heavens chimes!!!

  • legion0 your a twat

  • radiohead have an average 3-year gap between each CD, but the gap's been growing since Ok Computer (4 years between HTTT and In Rainbows)

    If the next album comes out in 2011, it'd be a 4-year gap, although i wouldn't be suprised to see it out early 2012, since thom's got Atoms for Peace and Phil's got personnal projects.

    Will there be another album? Of course!

    Will it be out very soon?........well......

  • Looks like TWO people.. didn't... like this video.

  • well Radiohead laying songs not from albums is nothing new and has never meant that they will be in the new album. They sometimes do buyt most of the times they end up being just beautiful b-sides. also with Thom's Atoms for peace (AKA Eraser band) and Phil's new project it is unlikely that radiohead will be releasing a new album soon.

  • @legion0 Idk how much longer i can stand the anticipation, i've been waiting for almost a year now.

  • @legion0 yes they are. look it up.

  • @mistasliz It's debatable, it could be tomorrow, a month, or next year, there's alot they have to do after the music is finished which isn't even finished yet.

  • @jirdimaster Ah my friend... how wrong you were. 4 months is pretty soon.

  • @jirdimaster LOL it's coming out this Saturday ;)

  • @legion0 You must feel silly now considering the news today

  • @legion0 new album out saturday! how wrong you were!

  • @legion0 just 4 months later... RADIOHEAD is releasing a new album.

    Cheers.

  • @legion0 oops!

  • @legion0 lol dude, u right. but look at ur comment now :P lol WHOS SIKED FOR KING OF LIMBS?????!!!!

  • @legion0

    bet you feel silly now ;)

  • magic melody

  • i like the part where thom sings & plays piano. :)

  • @cobainbullet182 easily the best part of the whole song

  • the first time i heard this song, i nearly cried.

    it's that beautiful.

    this BETTER be on the new album.

  • Great song and vocal performance as well. Tom had a bad time during the HTTT era IMO but after In Rainbows the guy is fully recovered. I saw their 2 gigs in Brazil last year. Just amazing.

  • @colorbarsat4am

    what do u mean by a bad time?

  • @colorbarsat4am Ya Hail to the Thief is my favorite album

  • @jirdimaster Mine too

  • kik ass... this is only in live version?

  • @Juanjolead Nah, i'm sure there's several but this is the one i got ahold of.

  • Radiohead IS the best thing to every happen to music! Best band ever!!

  • @swayskeeet i totally agree!

  • Is this off the new album?? I like . Please tell me it's off the new album.

  • @mazzycat725 Don't know yet dude, he's been playing it live, we'll have to wait and see if it's going to be on the new album or another Follow Me Around.

  • love the piano riff

  • very hail to the theif like crossed with bends

  • Brilliant, radiohead are one of the best things that ever happend to music !

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more