Added: 3 years ago
From: john00713
Views: 89,504
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (276)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • steve is steve no doubt.,but lets just be happy that journey is back producing good songs again.,if arnel wasn't there,would you hear journey again?

  • Just accept that the two of them are really good. Who is better? You decide, but just know one thing arnel isn't trying to or copying Steve because Steve's voice is unique for those who argue in emptiness.... "unique". Arnel just happened to be the lucky Guy whose voice wasn't too far from Steve's, and who could sing well when journey needed a new lead vocalist.

  • peke

    

  • Steve Perry has a unique voice and singing style. I believe it is as recognizable a Sting or Freddy Mercury. You know who it is the minute you hear it. Arnel has a voice no doubt, but he's just copying Perry. Better he should do his own music.

  • Steve is the King.....

  • Arnel Pineda couldn't carry Steve Perry's mic siand. & thats the fuckin' truth

  • @beeteep60 steve perry is a legend now take a resting peace means leave him alone his retired don't bring him back nobody cares

  • @escariolahug POOR POOR MONGOLOID ERNIE

  • Blasphemy

    

  • Pathetic! Not an actual duet and how can you put the two singers on the same playing field? Bring back Rollie or Perry, ditch the cheap knock off Perry!

  • This is NOT a duet. This is called an awful edit.

  • Steve Perry.......No replacement for his signature voice. Enough Said.

  • Steve Perry sing it way better. he has more bass in his voice. No matter how u try but the original is always the best.I heard in with Steve as a Teen and it will be his voice that I hear with all the song.. Steve Perry ur a Legend. They can replace you but never ever duplicate you.. NEVER!!

  • AND THE WINNER IS ?

  • @HEARTHEANGELSVOICES LMAO! Like ANYONE doesn't know!?

  • Comment removed

  • @HEARTHEANGELSVOICES Don't assume everyone knows what HGSW, YSFH or KMNYF means. ME being one of them

  • Comment removed

  • @HEARTHEANGELSVOICES any MORON knows what that means!

  • @NoSteveNoPoint - KMNYF = KISS MY NUTSACK YOU FUCKHEAD. THE REST ANY MORON KNOWS. YOU BELOW THAT LEVEL STEVE ? LOL WABA WABA !

  • @HEARTHEANGELSVOICES = MONGOLOID

  • Why all the negative comments about Arnel? Have some freakin respect! Journey fans were blessed with Steve, and now their music can live on, courtesy of Arnel. I think Arnel does a fantastic job. It's an awesome tribute to Steve Perry!

  • @Dragonflyy826 ARNEL SUCKS You must be tone deaf

  • Arnel the imposter.

  • O.M.G Arnel is better than this old man ..maybe now he is 70 years old no way to sing again...Bravo Arnel,,,,,,,,

  • Below= Ernie the PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint momo u want ur attention

  • @escariolahug MOMO is not an English word, you illiterate Monkey!

  • @NoSteveNoPoint If you Enlish is right Why ur so MOMO because your dumbass in you tube did you ask yourself why? I have a nice answer for you UR KINGKONG of STEVE MOMO EXTENSION PERRY did you hear your voice to OLD sound like a woman

  • @escariolahug POOR POOR MONGOLOID ERNIE

  • @NoSteveNoPoint momo sound to old just like woman voice Arnel is better than that did you notice MOMO

  • Whats wrong with our society these days? People are very judgmental. Why cant you all just respect music and listen to its beauty than boasting on a new lead singer. Yes Steve Perry was an amazing singer, but so is Arnel. People need to learn to be thankful that Journey still exist. @NoSteveNoPoint Take that d*ck out your @ss and stop hating!

  • arnel isnt even close, hes got a decent voice but NOBODYS beating steve perry!! think im wrong stroll up and look at the no steve=no journey and the no arnel=no journey...i think the majority of people agree with me

  • @Camaro042006 is not beating a woman voice just like steve he quit journey will continue with out his ass

  • @escariolahug = ernie the JEALOUS PINOY BASTARD

  • @NoSteveNoPoint I don't thinks so MOMO your jealous of the NEW Journey singer because ur insecured bastard now he make better than you sitting your chair MOMO putang ina mo cabron

  • @escariolahug = PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint momo tell yourself your stupid

  • their both good Arnie sound kinda like Steve but nothing can beat Steve Perry

  • Honestly i think Steve And Arnel Are Both Really talented people and ya Arnel isn't steve but its better than no Journey Right?? :))

  • steve perry too old and SUCKS just like nosteve momo

  • steve perry is just a carnival karaoke king. i love the way arnel sings coz he is a very talented filipino.

  • @mariahshakira1 yes it's true nosteve is karaoke kingkong

  • @escariolahug THANK YOU NOSTEVE IS KARAOKE MOMO KINGKONG

  • @escariolahug  SEEK HELP!! MONGOLOID

  • @NoSteveNoPoint so you want instrumental journey or what? maybe Steve Augeri will make you happy....

  • @changutodx = DUMB ASS

  • Funny thing is, if this ever happens we'll only hear an echoed singing

  • @changutodx Arnel SUCKS

  • BELOW= ERNIE THE PEDO

  • Wow, after reading some of the comments below, it seems that there is a wide divided between Steve and Arnel. I said it below, but it's worth repeating for all of you judgemental types: if you love Steve, more power to you and listen to original Journey; but if you also like Arnel, then listen to Journey with both as lead singers. And, I never knew that hating someone was ever productive or positive, so let's all agree: to each his own. Or, live and let live. Rock & Roll will never die...

  • @DISCOBABY1956 NO STEVE= NO JOURNEY

  • Arnel is Journey! OkSiPak? Who the f**k's he?

  • NO, NO, NO! Are you kidding me? Steve Perry IS Journey! Arnel? Who's he?

  • pfffffft he sucks!journey is journey with steve perry,i dont care how may guys they get to replace him.they will never match up to steve.im a long time fan of journey,with steve perry.i wouldnt pay no money to go see the new guy he fucking sucks.the other guy sucked too! bring steve back asswholes.he made the band.

  • Sorry-there is no one better than Steve Perry-his voice is amazing! Open Arms is my fav Journey song. I love them all-but I miss Steve!

  • Wow! Arnel Pineda sings really good. His voice souns closer to Steve Perry than voice of Steve Augieri. Still Arnel has got his own power and style. This is still Journey with their own style and band members and it sounds great. If I didn't know that Arnel is singing I'd say this is Steve Perry. And don't forget: No man is irreplaceble! I would like Steve to join the band again but if there ain't no chemistry to do that, what can we do? Accept new member, that's all. Peace and love guys. :)

  • @petersamiutenki You must be TONE DEAF! Arnel sounds NOTHING like Perry! LMAO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint Without Steve or No Steve There's Journey and still ALIVE! No Point of saying Arnel is sucks! If you can't appreciate his talent and their music, Just shut your mouth! MORON! Leave Arnel Alone! FUCKER!

  • Well, if name calling is all you know, then you are more immature than I thought. Calling someone moron repeatedly is a sign that your vocabulary is limited. In your case, very limited.

    Buzz off and leave us morons alone...we don't want and we don't need you...LOL

  • @DISCOBABY1956 = MORON

  • Okay, Mr. Know it all aka no steve no point: I just looked up the definition of MORON and you are right: I have 2 learning disorders...I am dyslexic and have ADHD. Now, you are entitled to your own opinion, so if you do not like Arnel, God bless you. For the record, I love Steve and I like Arnel. Am I clear now? Apparently you do not know that once you get a hip replacement, you MUST be careful afterwards, or ANOTHER one might be needed.I know as my own aunt has already had two knee ones.

  • @DISCOBABY1956 = MORON

  • correct ka dyan.

  • TO SAY: NO STEVE, NO JOURNEY IS LIKE SAYING: NO LANE STALEY, NO ALICE IN CHAINS...WHICH IS PURE BUNK, IF YOU ASK ME. THIS IS A GREAT VIDEO ONCE AGAIN SHOWING THAT ARNEL IS A SUPERB REPLACEMENT FOR PERRY. FOR A YOUNGER GUY OF 45, ARNEL CAN HOLD DOWN THE WEIGHTY JOB OF HEADING UP JOURNEY. STEVE HAD A HEALTH PROBLEM YEARS AGO, AND I'M AFRAID IF HE WENT BACK TO JOURNEY FULLTIME, HIS HEALTH PROBLEM WOULD ONLY PULL HIM DOWN AGAIN. AMERICA IS A MELTING POT, ASIAN OR NOT, THIS GUY ARNEL DOES WELL.

  • @DISCOBABY1956 = MORON. His HEALTH problem was a hip replacement ( repaired 11 years ago) WISE UP MORON! Arnel SUCKS!

  • If steve perry singing right now would be like a woman voice

  • arnell got a free ride to fame

  • arnel is great but steve is better.

  • Arnel has really amazing voice as well as Steve

  • steve perry all the way. more bass in the voice.

  • Aunque pineda demuestra mas fuerza es de recalcar q en el tiempo de Perry no habia tanta tecnologia musical ambos con mucha potencia...exelente Banda

  • I'm just not into the singing contestant kind of singer..No Steve no Journey..

  • Awww...Arnel does a wonderful, wonderful job!  However, he's not Steve Perry....

  • Arnel mumbles

  • guys, guys, guys..... it's time you guys take Steve Perry's dick outta y alls' mouth already! He's gone... Arnel is in the band now.. There's nothing none of you can do about it.. Stop advertising how big of a looser in life you are. Go watch some Britney Spears videos.. some dickhead even dedicate a freakin youtube account to troll on this. PATHETIC! Sell out every show all over the world is "No Point" ? WTF!!

  • @NoSteveNoPoint and NO ARNEL = NO JOURNEY

  • @hardstylemanga16 Fuck arnel. he sucks dick.

  • @YankeeBlue2K6 steve perry is good but his voice has woman voice hahahaa

  • @escariolahug = ERNIE THE PINOY MONGOLOID PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint who's pedo is you momo fagget voice sound like a woman steve is gone your voice is gone sound like grandpa with no teeth

  • @escariolahug = PEDO PINOY PARROT PUPPETEER

  • @NoSteveNoPoint who give fuck momo

  • @escariolahug  momo isnt a WORD you MONGOLOID

  • @NoSteveNoPoint u know momo is don't act like ignomoron u so stupid in you tube love urself steve perry himself haha idiot why not shut up don't say anything ECLIPSE ROCKS'

  • @escariolahug = DUMBASS MONGOLOID

  • @escariolahug = PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint estupido loco cabron

  • @escariolahug = PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint grandpa no teeth

  • @YankeeBlue2K6 SUCK STEVE PERRY  MAYBE U HAHAHA

  • @hardstylemanga16 No question, Arnel is good. Steve is sooo much better. Period! How do you best the original?  You don't!

  • @hardstylemanga16 hehehehe your right!!!

  • NO STEVE= NO JOURNEY

  • @NoSteveNoPoint yea nosteve =nomore journey his in nursing home just like you looking in you tube what a momo you are

  • @escariolahug = PEDO

  • @escariolahug momo still here why not just fuck yourself

  • @NoSteveNoPoint haha really?

  • @deaTh8322  REALLY!!!

  • @NoSteveNoPoint with arnel no more steve eclipse rocks u still momo gorilla

  • @escariolahug = PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint That's like saying "we lost our guitarist, we have no band" ...or you could just say "replace the guitarist for a better one.." :D

  • @squirrelmaster22 Steve's voice is IRREPLACEABLE!

  • @NoSteveNoPoint Let's see... Journey is kinda still around aren't they... shut it

  • @StatingPanic Journey is a PUPPET SHOW now.  Wise Up! MORON!

  • @NoSteveNoPoint in your smelly ass NO POINT USELESS LIKE YOU

  • @escariolahug = PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint  what ever momo you want ur attention hahaa poor poopo head steve who? momo

  • @escariolahug SEEK HELP MONGOLOID PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint who's mongoloid is u momo steve perry cock sucker

  • @escariolahug SEEK HELP MONGOLOID

  • @NoSteveNoPoint arnel love steve perry nosteve love himself shemale momo tang ina mo cabron

  • NoSteveNoPoint LOVES ARNEL!

    THAT'S WHY HE KEEPS CHECKING OUT ALL THE VIDEOS INVOLVING ARNEL! DON'T WORRY, WE WON'T TELL ANYONE!

    HAHAHAHA

  • @NoSteveNoPoint

    In my wind as well. Pineda is a super guy though and has given props to Perry. I can respect that.

  • Lo hace bien Amel ,pero a mi me gusta steve peerry.

  • No, Steve Perry it is, even at 62 he can out do Arnel!!

  • This was a really cool vid. Thanks:)

  • *Steve is

  • @wintercat2, I'm not gonna be one of those people that is a jerk but seriously. Steve feels the song. Watch how he moves with it. His voice is smooth and has range. Arnel doesn't have a bad voice at all. But people that know journey know that he's the only singer for the band. He's more experienced and amazing!

  • @guitarbaby27 - Feels the song? That's stupid talk, you can't feel a song moron, that's like feeling nothing. There has to be an object there to feel. You you weren't watching the video you wouldn't even know who was singing, they sound the same. When a Journey member was watching a youtube video of Arnel singing their songs he thought this guy Arnel was lip syncing. So if the Journey member couldn't even tell the difference, funny that you can. Bull, Arnel is just as good as Steve if not better

  • @wintercat2 Dude, your WRONG!!! OMFG you CAN, you MUST feel a song to really sing it. Been there, done that. But two things here - Arnel is DEFINITELY 'feeling' it (having been inspired by Steve p) and the most def deminish the sound on Steve's version. But come on, both of them 'felt' it - that's what music is about, and the ONLY reason we listen - cuz we really believe somehow they can 'feel' what we do..

    wolf

  • Comment removed

  • @08scamp - You feel some girls boobs not a song moron. Man are you ever stupid. Only thing that you've been and done is drugs By saying something dumb like that. Feel a song, LOL

    Shows how stupid you are, you don't even know how to spell, it's you're wrong, not your.

  • 3:25 I can hear stage 1 bgm of Top Gear

  • why compare each vocalist? are you kinda moron or something?

    99.99% you cant replace the original everyone knows that..

    but insulting a vocalist coz cant replace the orginal one? are you dumb fuck or something?

  • @paulorosas18 - You're the moron, Arnel sounds much better than Steve.

  • @wintercat2 = TONE DEAF

  • absolutely NOONE can take Steve Perry's place, i'm sorry...but, it's so true...sexy steve...whoo hoo

  • Arnel is to macho!!!!

  • hey bodizone u can suck a dick he sings better then you

  • NO STEVE= NO JOURNEY

  • The sound goes down when Steve sings and then is much clearer when Arnel sings. That part isnt really a fair comparison. They each have good qualities and the song choice for Arnel isnt his doing it is arranged for him. He sings some of the new songs very well. He cant get as high of a note as Perry did, so Deen has to do it. But you have to admit the songs are very grueling on the vocal chords. Of course I LOVE Perry but Arnel is no slouch.

  • fuck arnel, ther eis only one steve and one journey, Write your own songs you knock off asian copycat

  • ARNEL= COAT TAIL RIDER

  • This is a blessing. We get to hear this song live until now.

  • ARNEL SOUND VERY STRONG VOICE INTERNATIONAL ROCK SINGER WOW WHAT A VOICE

  • I don't understand this hating. It sucks. Pineda is a great talent. Were Schon, Cain and Valory supposed to retire because Perry wasn't interested or available and Augieri had lost interest ? BS. You keep going, and they found a great singer in Pineda. Grow up, people. Journey lives and they're great !

  • This is not duet...

  • Ya dejaron solo a Shon...lastima...la mejor banda de principios de los chochentas.

  • SOUND LIKE A WOMAN HERE

  • @escariolahug POOR POOR JEALOUS PINOY MONGOLOID ERNIE

  • @NoSteveNoPoint u sound like woman here agree with me NO GOOD listen TONE DEAF

  • @escariolahug =PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint STEVE LIKE U SOUND LIKE SHIT HERE WOMAN VOICE

  • @escariolahug = PEDO

  • @NoSteveNoPoint . Ok steve shit

  • What the f'ck . If u hate Arnel . Ok make a sing cover and youtube and post here . And see .

  • @ScoutTYPE LEARN ENGLISH! MORON

  • Steve Perry was and still is the best......no comparison.....

  • more swagg in voice is all you need and more soft voice in melody and less foriegn singing u know wat i mean too

  • arnel and steve were both have a good voice,every one of them have their own style so dont compare.

  • @vicmaala There IS no comparison.. ARNEL SUCKS

  • arnel has a unique voice that fits the band that is why he was chosen.. assholes!

  • Why would you even try and compare! Steves recording was what year and what year for Arnel's? The quality of sound has improved ALOT between those times.

  • @sarmali SO? The OLD one with Perry still sounds better than the New Arnel one by a MILE! And actually, the original quality of the old one was GREAT. I have the DVD concert of it. Ever who put these two recordings together just had Arnel's twice as loud!! LMAO

  • dude...arnel blows and perry is one of, if not the greatest ever...

  • I prefer Steve Perry’s voice! Period..

  • OMFG!!! MY FUCKING CAPS LOCK WAS ON AND I WAS TYPING SO FAST I DIDN'T NOTICE I JUST HAVE TO CLICK POST LIKE RIGHT AWAY!!

  • Arnel wasn't chosen by Journey because he has the same voice as Steve, he was chosen because they knew he fits the song pretty well and will bring it back with a new vocal variation.

  • @NoSteveNoJourney no doubt your still an ass hole!!!..

  • what with all this silly comparisons - you can't compare between two individuals because they will always be different.... yayyyyy . just enjoy the variety of voices - a song can be sung a hundred different ways and its alright.

  • Que gran descubrimiento para Journey fue Arnel....... es como escuchar a Steve, pero en el escenario Arnel es más carismático.....

  • both have fantastic 24k voices arnel's quality of voice is thicker and fuller...it's more powerful, crispier, fresher, huskier and rockier, more fitting of a rock song as compared to sp's finer and girly sound thus making the song sound more of a pop than a rock song...and arnel's voice is more versatile and has a wider vocal range than sp's, imho!!!

  • Man I thought I'd never say this in a million yrs, but Arnel is better than Steve, I still think Steve is an amazing performer, but Arnel just shows so much more emmotion while singing!!!

  • @annie4ever75 and, youre an idiot

  • @DrMugggles Go F youraelf, I'm entitled to my opinion, don't like it too bad, SUCKS T BE YOU!!!!

  • @annie4ever75 I agree. Especially on the "Live in Manila" DVD. Arnel sounds like a studio recorded Steve Perry - LIVE. I agree that the audio recording technology is totally different from the early 80's, but I really don't think it would make that much of a difference today. Arnel's voice IS more powerful than Steve Perry's, and I've been a huge fan of Steve Perry's since I was a kid, so it takes a lot to say that - but it's true. Still love Steve Perry, but Arnel was born for this new role.

  • @BillyHo1977 Arnel SUCKS live. I've heard him. The STUDIO release of REVELATION was digital magic! LMAO! They edited all the ACCENT sounds out ( or most) there is only so much you can do. And to say his voice is more POWERFUL?? GET REAL. You can drop the " I'm a Steve Perry fan"" LMAO! It's obvious by looking at your channel, you are an Arnel fan. SHAME ON YOU

  • @BillyHo1977 tHANKYOU! i'M GLAD SOMEONE AGREES! i WILL ALWAYS LOVE sTEVE pERRY, BUT, AS YOU SAID, aRNEL WAS BORN FOR THIS NEW ROLE. tHATS THE BEST WAY TO SAY IT.

  • @BillyHo1977 Arnel SUCKS dude. You must be ASIAN or Pinoy! LMAO And don't FRONT. You were never a fan of Steve Perry. FAIL!